Sie sind auf Seite 1von 8

C YBER P S YCH O LO G Y & B EH AV IOR

Volume 3, Number 2, 2000


Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.

Does Internet and Computer Addiction Exist?


Some Case Study Evidence

MARK GRIFFITHS, Ph.D.

ABSTRACT

It has been alleged that social pathologies are beginning to surface in cyberspace (i.e., tech-
nological addictions). To date, there is very little empirical evidence that computing activi-
ties (i.e., internet use, hacking, programming) are addictive. Anecdotal evidence indicates that
the typical addict is a teenager, usually male, with little or no social life, and little or no
self-confidence. This article concentrates on five case studies of excessive computer usage. It
is argued that of the five cases, only two of them describe addicted subjects. Addiction com-
ponents criteria were used in the assessment. The excessive usage in the majority of cases
was purely symptomatic and was highlighted how the subjects used the Internet/computer
to counteract other deficiencies.

INTRODUCTION sons life and dominates his or her thinking


(preoccupations and cognitive distortions),

I T H AS BEEN ALLEG EDthat social pathologies are


beginning to surface in cyberspace (i.e., tech-
nological addictions).1,2 Technological addic-
feelings (cravings), and behaviour (deteriora-
tion of socialized behaviour). For instance, even
if the person is not actually engaged in the be-
tions are operationally defined as nonchemical haviour, he or she will be thinking about the
(behavioural) addictions that involve human next opportunity to do so.
machine interaction. They can either be pas-
sive (e.g., television) or active (e.g., computer Mood modification
games) and usually contain inducing and rein-
forcing features that may contribute to the pro- This refers to the subjective experiences
motion of addictive tendencies. 35 This authors that people report as a consequence of en-
view is that technological addictions are a sub- gaging in the particular activity and can be
set of behaviourial addictions6 and that behav- seen as a coping strategy (i.e., they experience
iourial addictions feature the core components an arousing buzz or a high or paradoxi-
of addiction (i.e., salience, mood modification, cally tranquilizin g feel of escape or numb-
tolerance, withdrawal, conflict and relapse). 7 ing).
These core components are expanded upon.
Tolerance
Salience
This is the process whereby increasing
This occurs when the particular activity be- amounts of the particular activity are required
comes the most important activity in the per- to achieve the former effects. For instance, a

Psychology Division, Nottingham Trent University, Nottingham, United Kingdom.

211
212 GRIFFITHS

gambler may have to gradually have to in- thors research on a national radio programme;
crease the size of the bet to experience a eu- and origin of data: written correspondence.
phoric effect that was initially obtained by a Gary is an only child and spends many hours
much smaller bet. on his home computer, averaging at least 34
hours a day in school term, with up to 5 or 6
Withdrawal symptoms hours or more a day at weekends. During the
school holidays it increases even more, espe-
These are the unpleasant feeling states cially because he is on his own in the house
and/or physical effects that occur when the whilst his parents are at work. Garys mother de-
particular activity is discontinued or suddenly scribes him as extremely good technically, very
reduced (e.g., the shakes, moodiness, irritabil- bright and very good at computer program-
ity, etc.). ming. His mother claims he is computer mad,
but not for computer games, rather for serious
Conflict computingprogramming etc. His General
This refers to the conflicts between the ad- Certificate of Secondary Education homework
dict and those around them (interpersonal con- has been increasingly suffering because of the
flict) or from within the individuals themselves time he spends on his computer. When he is not
(intrapsychic conflict) that are concerned with working on his computer, he watches television.
the particular activity. Gary suffers from neurofibromotosis, a con-
dition that can produce severe behavioural
problems to varying degrees. According to his
Relapse mother, Gary has always had problems so-
This is the tendency for repeated reversions cially. He has had difficulty in making friends,
to earlier patterns of the particular activity to difficulty in coping with teasing and minor bul-
recur and for even the most extreme patterns lying (usually of a verbal nature). His parents
typical of the height of the addiction to be feel he views his computer as a friend and,
quickly restored after many years of abstinence therefore, tends to spend much of his time on
or control. the machine. Gary also suffers from an inferi-
To date, there is very little empirical evidence ority complex and lack of confidence when
that computing activities (i.e., internet use, dealing with his peers. As a consequence, he
hacking, programming) are addictive. Anecdo- gets very depressed. This condition worsened
tal evidence indicates that the typical addict when he got his own computer. At the same
is a teenager, usually male, with little or no so- time, his general behaviour worsened. He re-
cial life and little or no self-confidence. 8 How- fused to do his normal household chores when
ever, recent work suggests there are individu- requested, was generally awkward and diffi-
als who do not fit this stereotype. 9 This article cult, and provoked confrontational situations
concentrates on five case studies of excessive between himself and other members of the
computer usage collected by the author over a family.
period of 6 months. Each of the outlined cases He spends time with the computer to the ex-
has been given a pseudonym and a demo- clusion of family and friends. His parents had
graphic description (i.e., age, gender, national- his general practitioner refer him to a psychia-
ity, status). Information is also given about the trist for counselling and help. Whilst Gary
origin and source of the case study. Each case viewed this as a possible quick fix for his
is also followed by a brief commentary. problems, it was very slow progress. He is still
getting the help of the local psychological ser-
vices. His mother feels that much of his lack of
GARY confidence stems from the fact that he is con-
tent to spend his time in his room to the ex-
Demographic profile: 15-year-old British clusion of others in his own world. She sees the
male (at school); source of account: author con- problem as a self-induced Catch 22 situation
tacted by subjects mother who heard about au- in that he will never make friends whilst he
EXISTENCE OF INTERNET ADDICTION 213

spends time alone, but the action of spending morning. He describes him self as sci-fi mad
time alone reduces his ability to deal with other and spends hours and hours taking part in
people. Garys own view is that he does not Usenet discussion groups about the televis ion
have a problem with his computer use and that programme Star Trek (and its spin-offs). Al-
he does not spend too much time on the com- though he had played computer games when
puter. There is no doubt that this appears to be he was younger, Jamie first used a computer
an unusual case and that Garys excessive time properly when he was 14 years of age. He
spent on the computer appears to be sympto- used the Internet for about 10 months before
matic of other underlying problems. getting a modem. As a consequence of his ex-
cessive Internet use, the house telephone bills
Commentary are large.
Jamie claims the Internet is the most impor-
Gary appears to fit the stereotype of a com- tant things in his life, and that he thinks about
puter addict in that he is a male teenager who it even when he is not using it. He claims the
appears to have little or no social life and little Internet can change his moodeither calming
or no self-confidence. He appears to use the him or exciting him. He gets withdrawal symp-
machine as an electronic frienda behaviour toms if he cannot get Internet access. When try-
that has been reported with other technologi- ing to cut down or quit, he finds the lure of cy-
cal products such as video games 10 and slot berspace too strong to resist (I get very
machines.3 5 He appears to display all the core irritable and I start to shake). However, he
components of addiction and like many ad- does not view himself as an addict.
dicts, denies he has any kind of problem. His Jamie says he has difficulty limiting or con-
primary motivation for excessive use of his trolling the time both on and offline. Over a 2-
computer appears to be some sort of escapism year period he has upgraded his computer 11
into his own world where he can counteract his times. He says I log on literally until I am
depression and forget about his social isolation physically unplugged by someone else . . . I
and his medical condition (neurofibromotosis). cant work or live without itmy social and in-
tellectual life are linked directly to it. If hes
not connectedeven for a short length of time,
JAMIE he worries he no longer knows what is going
on. Jamies use of the Internet causes irregu-
Demographic profile: 16-year-old British lar sleeping patterns. It doesnt bother him that
male (at college); source of account: Subject ap- he has become nocturnal in order to use the In-
peared on television programme (about Inter- ternet when the telephone charges are low. Oc-
net addiction) with author and continued cor- casionally he oversleeps and misses college be-
respondence; origin of data: face-to-face cause of his computer usage. He has tried to
interview and written correspondence via the quit the internet once giving up for 3 days
Internet. but the pressure to log back on proved too
Jamie is an only child and lives alone with great.
his mother. There appears to be few problem s If Jamie was not online, he feels he would
in Jamies family life although his mother di- not use that time to meet people in real life (I
vorced his father when Jamie was 3 years old. tend not to socialise much). He has no friends
Jamie has no physical problems although he outside of those he meets on Internet Relay
is very overweight. Jamie spends approxi- Chat (IRC) and has no desire to make any.
mately 70 hours a week on his computer in- Jamie uses the Internet for a variety of differ-
cluding 40 hours on the Internet. This in- ent chat methods (e.g., IRC, Westwood Chat,
cludes two 12-hour sessions at the weeken d. as well as the Web and newgroups). Jamie
Only 3 hours a week is spent on work-related claims he uses these services to meet lots of
activities. Jamies usual pattern is to log on people. He feels that the Internet has im-
between 2 p.m. and 4 p.m. in the afternoon proved his level of knowledge and intends to
and log off between 1 a.m. and 5 a.m . in the enter an Internet-related field of employment.
214 GRIFFITHS

Commentary England to study chemistry and I soon I real-


ized that I couldnt do without computers. But
Jamielike the case of Gary aboveappears this time it was not playing games. Gradually,
to fit the stereotype of an internet addict in that I discovered the huge world of Internet and its
he is a male teenager who appears to have lit- many uses and applications. I used to go to the
tle or no social life, little or no self-confidence, computer only to word process and print but
displays all the core components of addiction, now I am spending many hours every day ex-
and denies he has any kind of problem. How- ploring Internet, in addition to sending nu-
ever, Jamie claims to have friends although merous E-mails and doing stuff that in fact (for
all of these are net friendships. His passion entertainm ent) and to my opinion can ruin
for science-fiction echoes research carried out somebodys life.
by Wolfson11 who found that obsessive fans of
the television programme Star Trek use the In- Panos feels his whole life revolves around
ternet extensively. Jamies primary motivation computers and that he feels comfortable being
for using the Internet excessively is to socialise in this country when he is on the Internet. He
with other Internet users. It may be the case claims that using the Internet excessively helps
that Jamie feels comfortable in the text-based him cope with every day life as a university
(nonface-to-face) world of the Internet be- student. He spends an average 4050 hours a
cause of his obesity. week on the Internet but has no financial prob-
lems because he accesses the Internet for free
from his university. His studies have suffered
PANOS considerably as he spends so much time on the
Internet, which leaves him little time to get on
Demographic profile: 20-year old Greek male with his degree work.
(at university); source of account: subject con-
tacted author via an Internet discussion group; Commentary
origin of data: Written correspondence via the
Panos, to some extent, appears to fit the
Internet.
Panos has played on computer games since stereotype of an internet addict in that he is a
he was a small child. As an only child he got young male who appears to have little or no
almost anything he wanted when he was social life and little or no self-confidence. How-
younger, including all forms of electronic tech- ever, he appears to display only some the core
components of addiction (salience, conflict,
nology. He recalls that as a child he had a small
mood modification, and possibly tolerance),
computer on which he used to play games but
used the computer for nothing else. Panos and, unlike the previous two cases, he does not
claims that at that particular time in his life, he deny he has a problem surrounding his Inter-
had become addicted to the games he used net usage. The primary motivation for exces-
to play. He played the games to the neglect of sive Internet usage is to cope with the fact that
he is in a foreign country in which he has very
everything else in his life. He now believes that
few friends. Panos very much uses the Internet
people can become addicted to computers as
well and that the escapism he felt as a young for escapism and socializing.
boy is now being recreated via his use of the It is interesting to note that Panos claim ed he
Internetparticularly through the playing of was once addicted to computer games. There
fantasy role-playing games (such as Dungeons have been a number of models putting forward
a developmental account of personmachine
and Dragons) and through the use of chat
relationships.12,13 It is perhaps unsurprising
rooms. As Panos says:
that a former computer game addict should
I was 100% sure that you could only become use the Internet most excessively for the fan-
addicted to a computer by playing games. I tasy role-playing games. A fairly recent study
thought that it was impossible to become ad- of fantasy game players found that that the
dicted to a computer by using it for profes- time spent on such games was considerable
sional purposes. Many years later I came to and that they were more introverted and more
EXISTENCE OF INTERNET ADDICTION 215

likely to play with computers and be com- Granted, our actual real life together time
puter game players than controls.14 hasnt been muchhowever, I feel our time
on the net (we speak for 34 hours every night)
has given us MORE of a chance to really get
JODIE to know each other . . . all we do is talk about
our feelings, wants and needs, future desires
Demographic profile: 35-year-old Canadian etc.
female (unemployed); source of account: sub-
ject contacted author via an Internet discussion Jodie feels her excessive Internet use is
group; origin of data: written correspondence purely a function of the relationships in which
via the Internet. she is involved and that it is no different from
Jodie spends at least 40 hours a week on the other peoples use of the telephone. The emo-
Internet. Her excessive usage is totally con- tional highs that she gains from using the In-
fined to IRC services. Jodie describes herself as ternet come from the social interaction rather
disabled, overweight and not at all attrac- than the Internet herself. She claims that she
tive. She says that this makes no difference gets depressed and moody when she is not on
on the Internet because she gets to know oth- IRC but again she says this is because it means
ers first in the Internet environment and that she is on her own without it.
then when she meets them in real life later
it does not matter. She says I have met well Commentary
over a dozen people in real life that I first met Although Jodie appears to display some of
on IRC or in some other way through the In- the components of addiction (salience, mood
ternet. She does not view her use of the In- modification, and withdrawal) she does not fit
ternet as an addiction although she does see it the young male stereotype. Similar to Jamie,
as a way of life. she is very overweight and is explicit in ex-
Almost all of Jodies relationships are Inter- plaining that she likes the Internet because no
net-based. The following extract is her account face-to-face communication takes place. Her
of the typical cycle of an Internet relationship. primary motivation for using the Internet ex-
cessively was to socialise (also exacerbated by
I meet men through IRC and we start out the the fact that she is disabled) although this has
same as anyone else just chatting where are
now changed into the most accessible (cheap-
you from? How old? Any kids? And then it
est) way to stay in touch with her partner. Jodie
evolves into exchanging pictures, phone calls
and then an overwhelming desire to meet in
does not feel she has a problem in any way and
real life. When I meet a guy, I usually decide feels that the excessiveness she displays on the
to meet as friends and if there is more then Internet is totally vindicated by the situation
that is fine. Even if there is nothing romantic she is in.
I usually have a good time.

Jodie is now married to someone she met on DAVE


the Internet but sees him very little because she
lives in Alberta (Canada) and he lives in North Demographic profile: 32-year-old British
Carolina (United States). They met on a camp- male (employed); source of account: author
ing holiday with other people she had met contacted by subjects wife after reading an ar-
through the Internet. Jodie only meets with her ticle about authors research on Internet addic-
husband at traditional vacation times (e.g., tion in a national newspaper; origin of data:
Christmas) and suffers verbal abuse from her written correspondence.
mother about her marriage. Her mother thinks Dave (a loveable happy man) had been
her daughter has lost her mind and is crazy for married to his wife for 3 years and had lived
wanting to marry someone she feels that her with her for 7 years. They had a beautiful
daughter does not really know. Jodie says of house, Dave had an excellent job, and they
her relationship: were both very happyuntil the Internet en-
216 GRIFFITHS

tered Daves life. The problem began when spread now that people need to escape from
Dave changed jobs and had to spend more time every day life and intimacy via Internet.
at homealone. As a result of this, Dave
quickly became depressed and slightly with- Commentary
drawn. As a result, he began spending time on
Although Dave is a male, he does not fit the
the IRC whilst his wife was at work.
Internet addict stereotype in that he is not a
Within a couple of months of being at home,
teenager or young. However, he does appear
he became worse, could not sleep, and used
to fulfill most of the addiction components (at
the Internet long into the early hours of the
least while he was having his virtual affair) al-
morning. His wife claimed that Dave got an
though the whole of his behaviour appears
incredible thrill from using (the Internet), as
symptomatic and was completely motivated by
though filling a need within. He became an-
his desire to interact constantly with a new
gry and anxious, with his whole body be-
partner. Although there is no direct evi-
coming twitchy when he was not on the In-
dence, it appears that his Internet usage has
ternet. He also suffered a loss of concentration
now declined significantly or stopped now that
and turned into someone that his wife did not
he has finally met up with the woman with
know. Within 3 months of being at home,
whom he was having a virtual affair.
Daves wife found out that he was using the
Internet to live in a fantasy worldmainly
with people in the United States. His wife GENERAL DISCUSSION
claim s he became totally obsessed by itnot
leaving his office for up to 5 days at a time, ex- It is quite obvious that of the five cases, pos-
cept to eat and sleep. The cost of Daves In- sibly only two of them (Gary and Jamie) were
ternet use was kept hidden from his wife but addicted according to the addiction compo-
she found out that the other woman lived in nents criteria. The excessive usage in the ma-
Boston and that Dave would call her five or six jority of cases was purely symptomatic and was
times a day and talk to her for 34 hours on where the Internet/computer was used to
IRC. counteract other deficiencies (e.g., relation-
Within 3 months of working from home, ships, lack of friends, physical appearance, dis-
Dave had left his wife and walked out without ability, coping, etc.). However, it is interesting
a word. His wife did not know where Dave had that all of the case studies used the computer
gone until she found out he had gone to the for social contact, with four of them using it for
United States to meet a woman who under- IRC services and the fifth one using the com-
stands his fantasy world through the Internet. puter as an electronic friend. As these cases
Dave proposed marriage to the American show, text-based relationships can obviously
woman before he left the United Kingdom be rewarding for some people and is an area
even though he had never met her. His wife for future research. It is perhaps also refresh-
says that the Internet caused the destruction of ing that in some circumstances, online rela-
their marriage, the loss of their house, and the tionships could be deemed to be psychologi-
loss of her husband. cally healthy because they break down
Dave briefly returned home for 10 days but prejudices and that intimate relationships are
has now gone back to America to live out his not based on peoples physical appearance.
fantasy. As far as his wife knows, he is not The three young males were all only children
now using the Internet. Dave now admits that who appeared socially isolated and had few so-
his fantasy was not quite what he wanted, and cial skills. These factors may or may not have
that he is depressed and has begun to realise had an influence in excessive computer use.
the damage of losing his job, his wife, and However, the psychotherapist Rawlins 15 has
walking out on his family. Daves wife specu- specifically reported some positive attributes
lates that men can emotionally communicate through intensive Internet use. Rawlins sees
better through a computer than verbal com- many children who fit the criteria for Pervasive
munication. She says, It seems to be so wide- Developmental Delay or Atypical Autism. She
EXISTENCE OF INTERNET ADDICTION 217

reports that these children often fit in hand reasons that appear to fit with the case studies
and glove with computer technology. They al- outlined in this article:
ready have poor social relatedness and are
rather isolated individuals. She argues that net It allows correspondence with people who
use may actually augment and help their social share mutual interests.
interactio n. It puts people in touch with other people
Another question to consider is whether the who they would otherwise never meet.
social pathologies in cyberspace are inevitable. The costs of communicating is low.
Ajayi16 has reported that, where the Internet is There is a substantial puzzle elem ent to
concerned, what we are seeing is merely the using the internet, and many people find
continuation of a decades-long trend of people puzzling tasks reinforcing.
spending increasingly more time with technol- People can download software toys, some
ogy than with humans. He argues that the shift of which are reinforcing.
away from family and peers to mass media People can keep in touch with friends with
technology as the primary socialization agents minimal time and financial costs.
can be traced to the advent of radio in the 1930s, It gives people feelings of status and
followed by television in the 1950s, and com- modernity, which may bolster self-esteem.
puter networks today. Ajayi further argues These are all commonplace reinforcers for
that, for many people, going online is a way of humans.
dealing with a society where people are be- It allows people to be taken seriously and
coming increasingly more isolated from one listened to.
another. It allows people to present a well-man-
One of the objectives of any future research aged persona, which may deviate in sig-
should be to determine the object of the ad- nificant ways from ones every-day, face-
diction. Is it the process of typing? The to-face persona.
medium of communication? Aspects of its spe- It allows people to be boring about ones
cific style (no face-to-face, etc.)? The informa- favourite hobby horse.
tion that can be obtained (e.g., pornography)?
Playing games? Talking to others (in chat Finally, it is perhaps worth nothing that Grif-
rooms or on Internet Relay Chat)? Could it be fiths 5 speculated that the structural character-
that the Internet provides a medium for the istics of the software might promote addictive
addiction to flow to its object of unhealthy tendencies. Structural characteristics (i.e., fea-
attachment (i.e., a secondary addiction to more tures that manufacturers design into their
pervasive primary problems)? The Internet products) promote interactivity and, to some
could easily be the focus of obsessive and/or extent, define alternative realities for the user
compulsive behaviours. One thing that may in- and allow them feelings of anonymity in fea-
tensify this focus are the vast resources avail- tures that may be very psychologically re-
able on the Internet to feed or fuel other ad- warding. For instance, determinants of the de-
dictions or compulsions. For example, to a sex cision to engage in a particular activity not only
addict, the Internet could be a very dangerous include the persons biological and psycholog-
medium. There is also the problem that the In- ical constitution and the situational variables,
ternet consists of many different types of ac- but also the structural characteristics of the ac-
tivity (e.g., E-mailing, information browsing, tivity itself. As Griffiths 18 points out, the struc-
file transferring, socialising, role-game playing, tural characteristics of particular activities are
etc.), and it could be the case (and probably is responsible for reinforcement and may satisfy
the case) that some of these activities (such as users needs and may actually facilitate exces-
IRC or role-playing games) are more addictive siveness. By identifying particular structural
than some other net activities. characteristics, it may be possible to see how
Future research should establish why the in- (a) needs are identified, (b) information about
ternet is highly reinforcing for some people. the Internet is presented (or perhaps misrepre-
Hammersly 17 has speculated on a number of sented), and (c) cognitions are influenced and
218 GRIFFITHS

distorted. (See Griffiths 18 for an overview on 11. Wolfson, S. (1995, Decem ber). Star trek fan behav-
iour: Its addiction Jim, but not as we know it. Pa-
structural characteristics.)
per presented at the British Psychological Society
There is no doubt that Internet usage among London Conference, Institute of Education, Lon-
the general population will start to increase don.
over the next few years. If social pathologies do 12. Brown, R.I.F. (1989). Gaming, gambling, risk taking,
exist, than psychologists may well be the peo- addictions and a developmental model of a pathol-
ple who have to deal with the aftermath. This ogy of man-machine relationships. In: Klabber, J.,
Croowall, D., de Jong, H., and Scheper, W. (eds.). Sim-
is certainly an area for development that
ulation gaming. Oxford: Pergamon Press.
should be of interest and concern to all those 13. Griffiths, M.D. (1991). Amusement machine playing
involved in clinical health issues. in childhood and adolescence: A comparative analy-
sis of video games and fruit machines. Journal of Ado-
lescence, 14:53 73.
14. Douse, N.A., and McManus, I.C. (1993). The person-
REFERENCES
ality of fantasy game players. British Journal of Psy-
chology, 84:505 509.
1. Griffiths, M.D. (1996). Internet addiction: An issue for
15. Rawlins, C. (1995). Cited in Terminal Addiction. In-
clinical psychology? Clinical Psychology Forum, 97:3236.
ternet and Comms Today, p. 35.
2. Griffiths, M.D. (1997). Psychology of computer use:
16. Ajayi, A. (1995). Cited in Terminal Addiction. Inter-
XLIII. Some comments on Addictive use of the in-
net and Comms Today, p. 36.
ternet by Young. Psychological Reports, 80:81 82.
17. Hammersley, R. (1995). Personal e-mail communica-
3. Griffiths, M.D. (1995). Technological addictions. Clin-
tion to ADDICT-L discussion group.
ical Psychology Forum, 76:14 19.
18. Griffiths, M.D. (1993). Fruit machine gambling: The
4. Griffiths, M.D. (1995). Adolescent gambling. London:
importance of structural characteristics. Journal of
Routledge.
Gambling Studies, 9:133 152.
5. Griffiths, M.D. (1995, April 7). Netties Anonymous.
Times Higher Educational Supplement, p. 18.
6. Marks, I. (1990). Non-chemical (behaviourial) addic-
tions. British Journal of Addiction, 85:1389 1394.
7. Griffiths, M.D. (1996). Nicotine, tobacco, and addic- Address reprint requests to:
tion. Nature, 384:18. Dr. Mark Griffiths
8. Hybels, S. (1995). Cited in Terminal Addiction. In- Psychology Division
ternet and Comms Today, p. 35. Nottingham Trent University
9. Young, K. (1996). Psychology of computer use: XL.
Burton Street
Addictive use of the internet: A case that breaks the
stereotype. Psychological Reports, 79:899902. Nottingham, NG1 4BU
10. Selnow, G.W . (1984). Playing video games: The elec-
tornic friend. Journal of Communication, 34:148156. E-mail: mark.griffiths@ntu.ac.uk

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen