Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Thursday 9:00am
16 February 2017
Spring 2017
The heat affected zone (HAZ) is one of the most critical areas of a weld
how welding creates and morphs an HAZ is critical to ensuring the integrity of an
engineered product involving the welding process. There are a wide variety of
cooling rate, and alloying elements involved. The HAZ is not necessarily defined in
any textbook sense, and can vary from engineer to engineer. However, one
commonly accepted definition of the HAZ defines it as the area of base material
due to heating from the weld. This is often visually manifested through the growth
discontinuities and defects can form within the HAZ, often times found along the
ductility dip cracking, however there is a significantly larger list of defects that may
occur. The microstructures found within the HAZ can be better understood with the
use of phase diagrams, but only for steady-state solidification. Phase diagrams can
help predict what phases will be present in the HAZ, which formed from the base
material, and possibly the location of these phases. While welding is not steady-
state due to the fast cooling rates encountered, the diagrams remain useful in
structures such as FCC, BCC, BCT, and HCP will form in this region and provide a
samples of metals were evaluated. The materials tested include medium carbon
steel welded with E7018, type 304L stainless steel, a dissimilar weld between alloy
2205 duplex stainless steel 2205 and type 304L, a Ni-base alloy 718 with a spot
varestraint test, aluminum alloy 6022 autogenously welded, and a dissimilar friction
stir weld between alloy 2507 and type 316L. The varestraint, or variable restraint
test works to induce cracks into a weldment by applying a strain upon solidification.
and spot (no motion). Once a weld is formed rollers then descend to force the
weldment around a die block to introduce a strain and thus form cracks.
healing. Analyzing these microstructures across all different welding processes will
formed and the mechanical changes they brought with them that affect both the
carbon steel welded with E7018. Figure 1 is a phase diagram of the element system
Figure 1 Iron Iron Carbide Phase Diagram. While the phase diagram assumes equilibrium cooling,
this diagram can aid in the prediction of final phases present upon solidification.
HAZ Fusion
Zone
Base
Material
Figure 2 Macroscopic image of the fusion zone, heat affected zone, and base metal, taken at 25x
magnification.
Martensit
e
Ferrite
Figure 3 Coarse Grain Heat Affected Zone. Martensite can be optically detected in the upper right
corner due to the nature of the grains forming at approximately 60. Ferrite can also be seen
beginning to form between the grian boundaries. Image taken at 200x magnification.
Figure 4 Intercritical Heat Affected Zone. In the intercritical heat affected zone grains are reduced in
size and ferrite growth is increased. Image taken at 200x magnification.
Large
Grains
Small
Grains
Ferrite
Figure 5 Microscope image taken at 200x magnification showing the coarse and fine grain heat
affected zones. In the fine grain heat affected zone grains are smaller and ferrite is more prevalent.
Large grains are found closer to the fusion boundary.
In figure 1 the phase diagram for carbon steel can be seen, from which we
can predict equilibrium phases. In this sample ferrite growth along the grain
boundaries was expected due to it being the first phase formed when leaving the
pure austenite region. The ferrite would form along the grain boundaries due to the
lower amount of energy required to form within this region in comparison to the
center of the grains. The composition of the regions within the grain boundaries
could not be predicted entirely by the phase diagram due to the high cooling rates
encountered during welding, and thus, required further inspection to determine the
expected. In figure 2 an overview of the weld can be seen from the fusion zone to
the base material. The grains nearest the fusion zone are coarser than those further
away. This phenomenon is due to the heat affected zone near to the fusion zone
(also known as the coarse grain heat affected zone or CGHAZ) spending more time
at elevated temperatures, which in turn provides more time for grain growth. The
regions further away from the fusion zone (also known as the fine grain HAZ or
FGHAZ) spent less time at these elevated temperatures, resulting in less grain
growth and smaller grain sizes. By the time the FGHAZ boarders the base metal, the
grain size becomes essentially the same, as the base metal possessed "refined"
grains before the weld was made, and was thereby unaffected (in relation to
As can be seen in the image the zone consists mostly of martensite, with ferrite
lining the grain boundaries in white. Martensite presence is known due to the angles
created by the grains being around 60 degrees. Another way to confirm this would
have been to collect hardness data and compare the values to those expected of a
variety of microstructural constituents (such as martensite) to determine the
composition of the grains. The martensitic microstructure occurs due to the faster
cooling rates occurring in the CGHAZ. These fast cooling rates don't provide enough
time for the carbon alloyed in the steel to diffuse out of the BCC microstructure
below the A1 temperature (727 degrees Celsius). These carbon atoms become
trapped and deform the crystallographic BCC structure, resulting in the formation of
contains a greater amount of ferrite, as well as finer grains. The presence of ferrite
can be largely contributed to the fact that the HAZ closer to the base metal
experiences a slower cooling rate than areas closer to the fusion zone. Slower
cooling rates are more favorable for the formation of ferrite. Once again martensite
can be identified within the grains due to the shear angles seen within the grains,
while the white boundaries are ferrite. Bainite could also potentially be found
throughout the HAZ, however, this cannot be determined through use of etching the
sample and viewing it through an optical microscope. In figure 4 the transition from
fine grain HAZ to the inter-critical zone. This zone is a narrower region where the
base metals temperature rises between the critical temperature A1 and A3. There
phases are predicted to form under equilibrium cooling. The micrographs highlight
Figure 6 Nickel-chrome phase diagram at a constant 70% iron. Under equilibrium cooling rates final
phase constituents can be predicted in the given material.
Fusion
Fusion Zone
Bounda
Base HA
Metal Z
Figure 7 Macroscopic image taken at 25x magnification of the fusion zone, heat affected zones, and
base metal.
Fusion
Boundary
Fusion
Zone
HA
Z
Base
Metal
Figure 8 Macroscopic overview of the fusion boundary taken at 100x magnification. Grain growth is
present towards the base metal increasing towards the HAZ.
HA
Z
Liquation
Crack
Base
Metal
Fusion
Zone
Figure 9 Overview of a liquation present between the fusion zone and base metal. This liquation
crack can be found on the rightmost edge of the sample. Image taken at 100x magnification.
Liquation
Crack
Figure 10 Microscopic image taken at 400x of the liquation crack occuring on the right side of the
sample between the fusion zone and base metal. Liquation crack is evident between grain boundaries.
Figure 6 presents the phase diagram for 304 stainless steel. From this
diagram, it is predicted that the microstructure will form to be fully austenitic, but
with slightly varying alloy compositions in the austenite. In Figure 7 a macro image
of the fusion zone and HAZ can be seen. In this figure grain growth also occurs
within the microstructure, with large, coarse grains being found close to the fusion
zone and small, finer grains being found further away from the fusion zone. The
large grain sizes found near the fusion zone are due to the extended time spent in
the ferritic solidification phase, resulting in more time available for grain growth. As
the HAZ begins to border the unaffected base metal, the grain size of the HAZ
becomes practically the same as the grain sizes found in the base metal, which did
not experience any grain growth due to welding. In Figure 8 a closer view of the
microstructure can be seen, allowing for a better view of the grain growth.
Figure 9 shows the liquation crack between the HAZ to the Fusion Zone. This
mechanism occurs when melting point depressant elements (both alloying elements
and contaminants) found within the alloy or on the alloy's surface begin to
segregate to the grain boundaries, and in turn lower the melting temperature of the
alloy. This results in localized liquid being trapped by surrounding solidification along
the grain boundaries. As the liquid cools, it begins to solidify and subsequently
shrink, creating stress along the grain boundary. These grain boundaries will have
lower ductility and strength due to both liquation and grain growth, and when the
stress along the grain boundaries exceeds a certain threshold for the given volume
of solidified material, cracking occurs. Figure 10 takes a closer view of the liquation
crack in Figure 9. The white line seen in Figure 10 running vertically is the fusion
however both alloy 2205 and type 304L are stainless steels, with 2205 being a
duplex stainless steel. The following figures are micrographs that analyze the heat
Figure 11 - Phase Diagram for both alloy 2205 and type 304L. Type 304L solidifies in the large
austenite region on the left of the diagram and alloy 2205 solidifies in the three-phase region on the
lower right hand corner at approximately 23 wt% Cr and 7 wt% Ni.
Fusion
Zone
Base
Metal
Fusion
Boundary HA
Figure 12 Overview of the fusion zone and heat affected zone for the rolled alloy 2205 stainless steel
base metal taken at 25x magnification. Grains are oriented longitudinally in the base metal due to the
rolled nature of the steel.
Fusion
Boundary Fusion
Zone
HAZ
Base
Metal
Figure 13 Overview of the fusion boundary regions on the side of the alloy 2205 taken at 25x
magnification. The etchant used does not bring about the grain structure in the alloy 2205. The black
lines are the ferrite, the remaining area is the austenite.
Fusion
Fusion
Zone
Boundary
Austenite
Non- Base
Directional Metal
HA
Figure 14 The heat affected zone on the rolled steel side shows the directional grains in the rolled
steel and the non-directional growth in the heat affected zones. Image taken at 100x magnification.
Precipitat
es
Figure 15 In the stainless steel, the precipitates are detected in the darker brown clouds that form
throughout the heat affected zone. These precipitates are chromium nitrides, and the image was
taken at 400x magnification.
HAZ
Fusion
Zone
Fusion
Boundary
Base
Metal
Figure 16 This is a microscopic image taken at 200x magnification of the fusion boundary on the
2205 side. Non-directional grain growth is observable in the HAZ leading up to the fusion zone.
Figure 11 presents a phase diagram for the alloy 2205 stainless steel. This
figure is the same phase diagram utilized for the type 304L stainless steel
previously. The duplex stainless steel would occupy the regions with a composition
of around 23 weight percent chromium and 7 weight percent nickel. However, unlike
the type 304L, alloy 2205 stainless steel is expected to contain both ferrite and
a multi-phase region on the phase diagram during the final stages of cooling. This
Figure 12 provides an overview of one side for the weld between alloy 2205
and type 304L stainless steel. The base material seen in this image is alloy 2205
stainless steel, which had been rolled prior to welding. This rolling is evidenced by
the long, narrow, horizontal grains found in the image. In Figure 12, the overview of
the other base material, type 304L, can be seen. Figure 13 takes a closer view of
the alloy 2205 side of the weld. Here the grains can be seen to have non-directional
growth. Due to phase change and recrystallization during the welding process, the
directionality of the rolled base material was lost. The white portions of the grains
are austenite, while the brown portions are ferrite. In Figure 14 the nitrides can be
seen in the dark cloudy regions within the ferrite. These nitrides form due to fast
cooling rates, which do not allow the chromium to diffuse to the edges fast enough.
In Figure 15 the close-up image of the type 304L can be seen. The dark areas
forming are ferrite. This is due to 304L running through the eutectic point of the
phase diagram seen in figure 6. Upon entering this region liquid, austenite, and
ferrite are present. As solidification continues, the liquid phase transforms to both
austenite and ferrite. Finally, austenite will be formed from any remaining liquid.
varestraint test results in liquation cracking occurring radially outside the fusion
zone around the weld in the partially melted zone. Figure 17 is a phase diagram that
allows for the prediction of final constituent phases upon cooling, the remaining
Figure 17 Phase diagram for the nickel base alloy 718. The phase diagram aids in the prediction of
microstructural constituents and amounts in the final cooled phase.
Base
Metal
HA
Z
Fusion
Zone
Figure 18 Macro overview of the fusion zone across the HAZ to the base metal. Top of the sample is
oriented to the bottom of the image, taken at 25x magnification.
PMZ HAZ
Liquation
Crack
Back
Healing
Figure 19 Liquation crack present in the spot varestraint test (observed at 100x magnification).
Eutectic back healing is present on the left hand side where the eutectic liquid falls back in the crack
and solidifies. Cracking along the grain boundary is evident as well as back healing beginning in the
PMZ.
HAZ
Precipitat
es
PMZ
Fusion
Zone
Figure 20 Precipitates visible at 100x outside the fusion zone in the sample. Two different
precipitates are present in the sample (Titanium Nitrides and Niobium Carbides) however they are
almost optically indiscernable at this magnification.
HAZ
Liquation
Crack
Fusion
Zone
Back Healing
PMZ
Figure 21 Image of the fusion zone crossing into the wide partially melted zone (PMZ) taken at 100x
magnification. A liquation crack is visible and back healing also occurs on the edge of the partially
melted zone.
Figure 17 displays the phase diagram for a Nickel-Chromium alloy system.
This diagram helps to predict the presence of FCC Nickel in the HAZ. Figure 18
been welded and a spot varestraint test was conducted on it. The fusion zone, PMZ,
HAZ, and base metal being distinguishable from each other. As can be seen in both
Figures 18 and 21, this alloy possessed a large PMZ region. The large PMZ can likely
be contributed to the welding process (which is unknown for this sample). If the
process had a very high heat input, a large region of this alloy could have been in
the temperature range in which partial solidification of the weld could occur. This
region can be seen in Figure 17 on the phase diagram, with the alloy composition
In Figures 19 and 21, a liquation crack can be seen within the PMZ and HAZ of
the alloy. This crack occurred due to the segregation mechanism, which was
discussed earlier in the Type 304L Stainless Steel sample. This form of cracking will
occur exclusively along former grain boundaries of the microstructure, which can be
seen within Figures 19 and 20, with it being particularly evident in Figure 19. Back
healing of the crack can be seen on the side of the crack extending into the PMZ.
This back healing occurred due to the eutectic liquid in the PMZ extending into the
solidified crack that was formed and filling the cracked region. Upon further cooling,
this eutectic liquid would then solidify, and thereby heal the remainder of the crack.
The amount of healing that occurred can be contributed to the large PMZ found in
this sample, as there was liquid available to initiate healing in nearby cracks.
However, there was still not enough liquid that filled the cracked region to heal the
entirety of the visible crack, which resulted in portions of the crack remaining.
In Figure 20, precipitates can be seen throughout the HAZ. However, as one
extends into the PMZ and then the fusion zone, little to no precipitates can be seen.
The precipitates, when exposed to the elevated temperatures found in the PMZ and
fusion zone, begin to dissolve and therefore disappear. This can result in reduced
alloy's strength. This may be a problem depending upon the service application of
which is aluminum alloyed with magnesium and silicon. Figure 22 is the Al Mg 2Si
phase diagram and the remaining are micrographs that highlight cracking and
Figure 22 Phase diagram for 6XXX series aluminum. The phase diagram serves to predict final
phases and constituents.
Fusion Base
Boundary Metal
Hardness
Indents
Liquation
Crack
Fusion
Figure 23 Image taken at 25x magnification of fusion boundary overview with a liquation crack. The
partially melted zone falls between the fusion boundary and the liquation crack.
HAZ
Largest
Indentation
Fusion PM
Zone
Liquation
Crack
Figure 24 Detailed image (100x) of PMZ and the PMZ hardness indentation. That indentation is the
largest throughout the traverse indicating the region has the lowest hardness.
Precipitates
Fusion
Bounda
ry
Liquation
Fusion HA
Z
Figure 25 Image taken at 100x magnification displaying the liquation crack running parallel with the
fusion zone as well as precipitate dissolution in the HAZ.
Fusion Zone
Liquation
Crack
HAZ
Eutecti
c
Figure 26 Microscopic image taken at 200x magnification of phases present in the HAZ and fusion
zone of the weld. Eutectic phase is the dark region on the left-hand side that trails into the HAZ.
Fusion HA
Zone
Base
Metal
Fusion
Bounda
ry
Figure 27 This image taken at 100x magnification is of the cross section of the weld, whereas the
previous images were of the top of the weld.
fusion zone, HAZ, and base metal being clearly visible. The cross section of this
weld can be seen in Figure 27. As can be seen in Figures 23, 24, 25, and 26, this
sample features a significant amount of cracking within the PMZ and HAZ. The
mechanism. The cracking that occurred is likely so severe due to the small
quantities of eutectic phase throughout the sample. Portions of the eutectic phase
can be seen in Figure 26. This small amount of eutectic phase was enough to cause
liquation and lower the melting temperature of the grain boundaries, but it was not
in large enough quantities to provide sufficient healing to the cracks that formed.
In Figures 24 and 25, precipitates can be seen occupying parts of the HAZ.
However, as the HAZ approached the PMZ (which can be seen in Figure 24) and
exposed to the elevated temperatures found in the PMZ and fusion zone,
Figure 24, the hardness indentation made in the PMZ is the largest indentation
throughout the entire traverse. This means that the PMZ within this sample is the
softest region, which is expected due to the reactions that occur inside the PMZ
during welding and solidification. One specific reaction that softens the PMZ is the
dissolution of precipitates in the PMZ back into the matrix of the solid solution.
Dissimilar Friction Stir Weld Between Alloy 2507 and Type 316L
The phase diagram for the base metals alloy 2507 and type 316L is the same
as the previous dissimilar weld (Figure 11). The following images are micrographs
taken of a dissimilar friction stir weld (FSW), displaying the noticeable features and
affected regions.
TMAZ
Stir Zone
Figure 28 Overview of the advancing side of the weld taken at 25x magnification. The sweeping
motion is seen throughout the type 316L.
Stir Zone
HAZ
Figure 29 Image of the retreating side taken at 25x magnification containing alloy 2507.
Stir Zone
HAZ
Figure 30 Microscopic image taken at 200x magnification of the grain refinement present in the
retreating side.
Elongated
Sweeping
Grains
Figure 31 Macroscopic overview at 25x magnification in the TMAZ where long sweeping grains are
seen. The distinguished region separating the HAZ and TMAZ cannot be determined.
TMAZ
Stir
Zone
Stir
Zone
Figure 32 Microscopic image at 200x magnification of the advancing side. More refined grains are
seen in the stir zone.
The last sample analyzed was a Friction Stir Weld between type 316L and
alloy 2507 stainless steels. The phase diagram for these can be seen in Figure 11.
The type 316L was predicted to be fully austenitic, while the alloy 2507 would
the advancing (Type 316L alloy) and retreating (Alloy 2507) sides of the weld
respectively. The retreating side has a notably steeper slope than the advancing
side due to the differences in tool speed, and therefore heat input, on the two sides.
The advancing side experiences a higher heat input due to the rotation of the tool is
experienced speed). The retreating side is also more defined; however, this is likely
Figure 30 shows a closer view of the region between the stir zone and
often observed in fusion welding processes, with the grains in the stir zone being
Figure 31 provides a close image of the region between the HAZ and the
TMAZ on the advancing side of the weld. The TMAZ is marked by when the grains
start to sweep in an upward motion towards the stir zone. The HAZ resembles the
TMAZ, however it does not feature the sweeping motion found in the TMAZ. The
TMAZ and HAZ on the retreating side can be seen in Figure 30. However, in
comparison to the advancing side, the TMAZ on the retreating side is significantly
smaller and doesn't feature nearly as pronounced sweeping motions. Once again,
this is due to both the differences in heat input and the different mechanical
properties/compositions of the alloys. The retreating side saw slightly less heat and
may have a higher yield strength than the advancing side, both of which could
Grain growth found within the HAZ due to time varying times in which regions
within the HAZ were forming at a temperature ideal for grain growth. Larger
grains found near the fusion zone, with smaller grains found closer to the
base metal.
Microstructure consisting largely of ferrite, martensite, and possibly bainite.
Larger concentrations of martensite found near the fusion zone, while larger
concentrations of ferrite found near the base metal. Both phases can be seen
throughout all the HAZ. This distribution can largely be contributed to the
slower cooling rates experienced near the base metal.
Grain growth found within the HAZ. Grains were seen growing as they neared
the fusion zone. This was due to increased time for grain growth near the
fusion zone.
Liquation crack formed through grain boundary segregation in the HAZ.
Lack of directionality in the Alloy 2205 HAZ grains due to phase change and
recrystallization.
Formation of nitrides in the HAZ of Alloy 2205 near the fusion zone caused by
fast cooling rates in that region.
Ferrite forms within the grain boundaries of the Type 304L stainless steel.
Dissimilar Friction Stir Weld between Alloy 2507 and Type 316L
Hsieh, Chih-Chun, Jia-Siang Wang, Peng-Shuen Wang, and Weite Wu. Figure 12 of
15. Digital image.
ResearchGate. The Scientific World Journal, Jan. 2014. Web. 11 Feb. 2017.
<https://www.researchgate.net/figure/260612262_fig12_The-Fe-Cr-Ni-phase-
diagram>.
Lippold, John C. Welding Metallurgy and Weldability. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2015. Print.