Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Kevin Cheng
Professor Colombo
UWRT 1104-007
29 January 2017
Technology has allowed the spread of information to reach the masses quickly and more
efficiently. However, along with the spread of information, a new epidemic has risen: fake news.
From my personal experience and research, I have observed that fake news has become a
worldwide issue, with many countries wishing to take steps to eliminate this problem. Fake
news create confusion, political discourse, and can even cause bodily harm; as it is dangerous
when individuals act on what they believe to be the real news. Although it is protected by the
First Amendment of the Constitution, I believe it should be outlawed or regulated in the United
To achieve my goal, I have expressed my beliefs on why fake news should be outlawed.
In addition to that, I have also included real-life events that involved fake news, and a proposal
of a few solutions with explanations on how it does not violate the Constitution. The essay will
be divided into three sections: Problem, Solution, and Conclusion. The first section consists of
information about fake news, and contains recent real-life events. This section also explains why
people deliberately put out fake news. The second section consists of potential solutions that
could be employed to curb fake news, along with an analysis of potential problems. I feel these
solutions will come into minimal to no conflict with the Constitution, because they will not fully
ban fake news, thus not violating the Constitution. Lastly, the third section will discuss the
Problem
Before 2016, fake news had been a minor problem; causing little to no trouble. However,
during the 2016 Presidential Race, fake news exploded all over the web with the inadvertent help
of Facebook and Google. Most of the fake news centered around candidates Hillary Clinton and
Donald Trump. Articles had both positive and negative news about the two candidates, which
supporters and detractors used for or against a specific candidate. In the end, fake news had
caused more uncertainty and confusion towards both candidates. Fake news has also caused the
There was even an article about how Hillary Clinton ran a sex ring at a certain pizzeria,
to which a man took action based on the fake news. The man bought an assault rifle to the
pizzeria, cleared out the restaurant, all in attempt to break up a fake sex ring. The owner and
employees had also received many threats prior to the incident. Hillary Clinton had also been
said to have sold weapons to ISIS, or had helped fund ISIS. It was even said that Pope Francis
endorsed Donald Trump in the Presidential Race. In another event, Pakistans Defense Minister
threatened nuclear war with Israel, due to fake news stating that Israels Defense Minister would
destroy Pakistan if it sent troops to Syria. Imagine that; all it takes is a few misinformed
leaders of nuclear countries, and then it is all-out nuclear war. Although no one was hurt in these
situations, but these events prove how confusing and deadly fake news can be.
So why do people post fake news? The people who post fake news are doing it for the
money. An interesting story gathers a lot of attention, leading to many people visiting the
webpage. Whenever people generate heavy traffic to a webpage, the writer receives money
from automated advertisements, which rewards for internet traffic. One man in Los Angeles
claims he made between $10,000 to $30,000 per month, by running a string of fake news. A
Cheng 3
computer science student from the former Soviet republic of Georgia stated that posting fake
news on Trump was a gold mine, as it generates a large amount of web traffic.
As mentioned before, Facebook and Google have inadvertently helped the spread of fake
news. With 1.79 billion users each month, Facebook completely dwarfs other social media. As a
result, Facebook introduced their News section a few years ago, in the hopes of helping to keep
users informed of world events. However, their good intentions backfired when fake news
exploded in 2016. As more and more fake news was shared, people started to use Google to find
the articles. This led to Facebook deleting many fake news content, and Google banning over
200-and-counting publishers.
Solution
There are a few solutions that could be applied to stop or limit the spread of fake news.
One solution is for news to be published, the publisher should be approved by the United States
government. This way, fake news will not be able to spread, thus preventing unwarranted harm.
Only the real news would be spread via government-approved publishers. Opinion articles
would still be legal, as long it is from an approved publisher. This method does not violate the
Constitution, in the sense that it still allows the freedom of the press without government
interference. However, this method does restrict the freedom of press, as it only allows approved
publishers to spread the news. It also does not stop the fake news originating from foreign
If fake news in the United States cannot be banned, then the real news should be marked
with a nationally recognized seal. The seal would only be allowed on articles meant to inform
the public on current or future events, otherwise there will be a fine for misusing the seal. The
Cheng 4
seal would help the real news be distinguished from the fake news, and avoid the confusion and
panic fake news can generate, all while not violating the Constitution. Anything can be written
or published without any restrictions, as this policy is just marking the real news. This method
would be more effective in the United States, as it also distinguishes the real news from any fake
If we did not want the government to step in, the next best solution would be to have
search engines and social media networks monitor their systems. Facebook and Google, two of
the biggest firms, have already taken steps towards limiting the flow of fake news. Despite them
taking steps, it is still possible that there is simply too much data to process. After all, most of
the world uses a search engine and/or social media site, with Facebook and Google being the
These three solutions are the best ways to limit fake news, without fully violating the
freedom of press and speech. Although the first solution calls for only government-approved
publishers, it also restricts the freedom of press, thus making it a controversial solution. The
second solution would be a more reasonable, logical, and stronger method to limit fake news. It
is controversial-free and does not restrict the freedom of press. The last solution calls for the
search engines and social media firms to be responsible for their own systems. It involves no
government interference, and is controversial-free as well. Since they are companies, the First
Amendment does not apply to the businesses the same way as it does to citizens.
Conclusion
Fake news has become a worldwide epidemic; it is causing harm to people, as believers
of the fake news have taken reckless action on it. Despite causing harm and confusion, people
Cheng 5
will still post fake news, because of the money generated by the web traffic and advertisements.
The most recent fad of fake news revolved around the 2016 Presidential Candidates, causing
widespread confusion and uncertainty. The 2016 Presidential Race also had a hand in causing
the explosion of fake news, due to two (one very) controversial candidates. It also nearly pushed
Pakistan and Israel a step closer to nuclear war with each other.
To stop or limit fake news, I believe the best method is to have the government step in
and establish a set of laws forbidding or restricting the flow of fake news. Depending on how it
is handled, the First Amendment could be under questioning. The best way to ensure that the
First Amendment is not violated, there should be a labeling system for real news. This way,
everyone still has the freedom to publish what they wish, and the fake news will not be confused
with the real news. If fake news is not contained, it has proven it has the potential to start
Works Cited
Bohn, Kevin, Daniel Allman, and Greg Clark. "Gun-brandishing man sought to investigate fake
news story site, police say." CNN. Cable News Network, 5 Dec. 2016. Web. 29 Jan. 2017.
Holan, Angie Drobnic. "PolitiFact's 2016 Lie of the Year: Fake news." PolitiFact. N.p., 13 Dec.
Wakabayashi, Daisuke, and Mike Issac. "In Race Against Fake News, Google and Facebook
Stroll to the Starting Line." Nytimes. New York Times, 25 Jan. 2017. Web. 29 Jan. 2017.
Westcott, Ben. "Duped by fake news story, Pakistani minister threatens nuclear war with
Israel." CNN. Cable News Network, 26 Dec. 2016. Web. 29 Jan. 2017.