Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted
digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about
JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Midwest Modern Language Association is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to The Journal of the Midwest Modern Language Association
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Reflections of Ophelia (and of Hamlet)
James M. Vest
The Pleasure Garden, The Manxman, Rich and Famous, Jamaica Inn, Foreign Corres-
pondent, Lifeboat, To Catch a Thief, and Psycho, among others, insist on that con-
nection, as do the made-for-television A Dip in the Pool and Hitchcock's last, un-
finished feature The Short Night.2 In the publicity short for Frenzy, it is the direc-
tor himself who floats buoyantly down the Thames. More typical, and certainly
more archetypally convincing, are those films in which Hitchcock shows a beauti-
ful woman finding watery death in a manner that recalls floating heroines of lit-
erature and legend. The image of a drowning beauty underlies the mystery of
Young and Innocent, Rebecca, and Frenzy as well as the dramatic denouement of The
Skin Game. In Vertigo in particular, water couples with the idea of the suicide of a
Alfred Hitchcock grew up on Shakespeare, and throughout his career was fond
Recumbent in San Francisco Bay, Kim Novak strikes a patently Ophelian pose.
Citing the lines quoted above from Hamlet IV.vii, Donald Spoto noted this paral-
lel but did not pursue the connection (Art 316). The deeper implications of
Spoto's observation for this film and for Hitchcock's aeuvre have not been sys-
James M. Vest 1
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
is shown to be Ophelian in both posture and purpose.5 The insistence on flowers
brated painting of Ophelia in the stream. Novak's wafting scarf resembles the di-
Valmont and others.6 Yet rather than showing her horizontal as in the Millais
graph Kim Novak on the bias, her body slashing the screen diagonally. That pose
depict the fine line between reality and imagination, between life and death, from
the treacherous slope of slanted roof in the first scene to the splayed, falling bodies
that punctuate the picture to the end. It also recalls the Hamlet lithographs by
Eugene Delacroix, which accent slanted, diagonal lines of Ophelia's body. Each
time the actress strikes a similar pose thereafter -in John Ferguson's arms as he
brings her back to shore, in his apartment, leaning out of her car, as they touch
and kiss - the pathos of this scene is recalled and the Ophelian motif reinforced.7
In Vertigo Kim Novak plays Judy Barton, who, at the insistence of shipping
magnate Gavin Elster, agrees to impersonate his wife Madeleine. Her role is a dual
cated not only by the flowers that she carries and then thoughtfully tosses onto
the water (cf. Ham. IV.v.173-184 and IV.vii.165-182) but also by the graveyard
scene, when she visits the tomb of Madeleine's ancestor, "the beautiful Carlotta,
the sad Carlotta ... the mad Carlotta," whose fate she seems doomed to share. A
connection with Ophelia's funereal stream is suggested when she mentions earlier
falls into water: "I've fallen into lakes out of rowboats ... I even fell into the river
once trying to leap from one stone to another." The flowers, the madness, the
graveyard reflections, the affinity for death by water all recall Ophelia's peculiar
Other parallels with scenes in Hamlet involving Ophelia develop in the context
ofJudy's relationship with John Ferguson (played by James Stewart). In this film,
where both space and time are out of joint, the Hamlet-like hero is a vertigo-
stricken detective hired by Elster, ostensibly to protect his wife from her suicidal
tendencies. The fact that this is in reality an elaborate plan to kill the real Mrs. El-
ster is eventually revealed to John Ferguson and to the audience. Thereafter Judy's
role-playing and her involvement with John become the chief subject of the film.
ently, then emerges from his bedroom, hair down, distant, and somnambulistic,
much as Ophelia is often played in her mad scenes. She presents "a document in
sense in the mind of her listener (Ham. IV.v.176, cf. IV.v.5-13). Later, when the
couple are approaching San Juan Bautista, the trees overhead are shown to pass by
2 Reflections of Ophelia
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
the tree-lined stream. In John's dream his face is shown to be careworn and wind-
the reappearing buggies and carriages associated with the mission settlement. The
nature of Ophelia's death is the cause of much debate in the churchyard scene that
opens Hamlet's final act, and similar concerns inform scenes in Vertigo, notably
those at the inquest (held near the churchyard) and outside the Elster residence
where the new owner of Madeleine's car asks, "Is it true that she really ... ?"
At the bidding of the male authority figures in her life Judy, like Ophelia, plays
multiple roles. First seen as Laertes's playful sister and then as Polonius's dutiful
daughter, (Ham. I.iii), Ophelia agrees to play the disenchanted lover and to bait
Hamlet before a concealed audience (II.i-ii and III.i). In her on-stage contacts
with Hamlet, she plays "straight-man" to the prince, setting up his one-liners in
the "nunnery" and playlet scenes (III.i-ii).8 In her rantings (IV.v, vii), the pre-
viously proper Ophelia assumes something of the fickle, ribald character attrib-
uted to her by Hamlet. Her scenes with Hamlet and her mad scenes are played be-
fore a courtly audience, and her entry into the water is presented as a dramatic ta-
water but is rescued by her spectator, John Ferguson. The idea of falling, so cen-
tral to Hitchcock, pervades the bay-side sequence of the film. Both actors must
jump and fall, she on a floral cue, then he. Her leap, supposedly toward death, is
later acknowledges, she is "a wonderful swimmer." John's dive (shown as a diag-
onal) is also re-creating in that it represents his first positive step toward over-
coming his acrophobia: he survives a drop from a height and thinks he has saved
Hamlet traditional notions of love introduced in the opening acts give way to
which time the theme of love is reintroduced: "I lov'd Ophelia. Forty-thousand
brothers could not with all their quantity of love make up my sum" (V.i.264-66).
In Vertigo death is posited first: Carlotta has died a century ago. We are taken to
the cemetery before we visit the bay. Thus Carlotta's death is followed by
"mad scenes" in John's apartment and on the coast, which eventually give way to
love scenes. In the end, like Hamlet, John Ferguson finally makes up his mind and
asserts his own needs, with tragic results. Both stories conclude with an expres-
past who is used by the murderous king to try to trick the hero into revealing the
James M. Vest 3
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
the king while remaining absolutely devoted to Prince Amleth, she performs her
traditional role (indeed her only role in the prose tales on which Hamlet is based),
that of faithful decoy. Some of that subterfuge persists, in an inverted way, in Ver-
tigo. Under directions from Gavin Elster, Judy-Madeleine plays upon a weakness
of John Ferguson's to set in motion Elster's plan for murdering his wife. She ful-
fills the quintessentially Ophelian role of decoy, apparently diverting the hero
from the truth while actually remaining devoted to him. This peculiar role is re-
called when John says to Judy, in a curt rehashing of Hamlet's tirades about hon-
esty and painted women in the "nunnery" scene (Ham. III.i.103-51), "You were
the copy. You were the counterfeit . . . I loved you so, Madeleine."
When Kim Novak plays Judy rather than Madeleine, her gait appears more bal-
anced, more down to earth, and her demeanor is more assertive, even caustic.
Eventually, however, Judy's posture and attitude change. She accepts John's
flowers, and they stroll past lovers reclining together, diagonally, by a lake,
couples whom she alone sees. In John's apartment she allows herself to go diag-
onal as she succumbs to his desire to resurrect Madeleine. She asks, "If I do what
you tell me, will you love me?" Her situation is reminiscent of Ophelia's when
she confronts the monomaniacal Hamlet, from whom the most she can expect is
slanted non-sequiturs: "I loved you once ... I loved you not" (III.i.115-19).
Finding themselves in equally hopeless positions, both Ophelia and Judy try to
please. Polonius's daughter suppresses her selfhood as she attempts to fulfill the
tyrannical demands of her father and her beloved. Judy allows herself to become
Madeleine once more, for John. Dressing herself like Madeleine, dying her hair
the color of Madeleine's, Judy walks down the dark corridor of Madeleine-Car-
lotta's suicidal vision. John awaits her in her room, which is now bathed in an
eerie light, recalling the blue-green light seen at the beginning of his vertiginous
dream. When Judy re-enters the room in her final apparition as Madeleine she is
enveloped in an aureole of green-blue mist.10 In their long embrace, the pair turn
fluidly as the room rotates slowly about them. The atmosphere is aqueous, with
furniture and then a carriage languidly floating past. The scene recalls not only
events at the mission but the surrealistic wandering and meandering, the pursuit
and evasion, that have characterized their relationship.11 It is as if they are under
water again, as if, like creatures "native and indued unto that element," they have
IV.vii. 174-78).
Ophelian echoes also resound in the situation ofJohn's girlfriend Midge Wood
(Barbara Bel Geddes). She is portrayed as the faithful, neglected childhood sweet-
heart, devoted to a man who has trouble talking straight to her. While the James
a-down-a. O how the wheel becomes it" (Ham. IV.v.169-70). Like Ophelia's
"snatches of old tunes" (IV.vii.176, Folio var.; cf. "old lauds" in the Second
Quarto), Midge's classical musical selections are always cut short. A gifted artist,
4 Reflections of Ophelia
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
she paints a portrait of herself as Carlotta Valdes, thus demonstrating her identifi-
appearance in the film Midge is shown in the psychiatric hospital, walking down
Vertigo, like Hamlet, is a story about a man under severe mental stress who ap-
pears to see ghosts and to have difficulty acting in time: John "Scottie" Ferguson.12
Between the two major episodes of his story Ferguson is exiled, like Hamlet the
Dane, among the "mad" (Ham. V.i.144-50). Returning to live among ostensibly
normal folks, he contemplates his beloved's open grave and visualizes himself,
dark clothes, and in his dream-vision appears with unkempt hair and cavernous
eyes, as Hamlet is traditionally portrayed (cf. Ham. II.i.77- 100, as well as picto-
rial representations by Delacroix, Lehmann, Manet, et al.). Like the dark prince,
his exaggerated determination to regain what he has lost and to manipulate others
The role of Hamlet, like other roles in Vertigo, is diffused, fragmented, and set
spinning. Observing Madeleine-Carlotta's leap into the Bay, John is forced into
the role of Gertrude-like witness and then does the queen one better by prevent-
ing the drowning. Nor is he the only Hamlet-figure in Vertigo. Judy, who plays so
many roles in this story, also resembles Hamlet in one important way. Her origins
with my mother and that's my father. He's dead. My mother married again, but I
didn't like the guy." By making Judy over into Madeleine, Ferguson is forcing a
tragic resolution to her life,just as Hamlet's attempts to make over Ophelia, Rose
of May, in light of his own image of a weed-filled garden lead to her derangement
and death.
For Alfred Hitchcock, Hamlet remained a source of profound dramatic and per-
sonal inspiration. Although the Hamlet first announced in 1946 never material-
work and in his personal life. The director's preoccupation with willful manipula-
tion, both as theme and as technique, so clearly visible in Elster's and Ferguson's
and Hamlet involving compliant Ophelia. The same attractive, tractable figure
may lie behind Hitchcock's lifelong obsession with the "Nordic" blond (his
phrase, quoted in Spoto Dark Side 431), an acquiescing beauty who could be made
over in his own image, who could be convinced to dress and move as he wished,
to play a variety of roles according to his whim before being set adrift. It also may
have suggested the director's own metamorphosis into moribund floater for
Frenzy, where the scene of Hitch gliding down the Thames - perhaps the direc-
James M. Vest 5
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
tor's most complete and self-conscious identification with Ophelia-was orig-
inally intended as his ritual cameo appearance in that film (Haley 118).
unifying metaphor. It undergirds the action from the opening sequence on the
Carlotta collapsing into his, to the falling sequence in John's dreams, through the
three leaps that define Kim Novak's role in the film. Falling symbolizes instability
and powerlessness, loss of control and balance in both a physiological and an exis-
tential sense. In Vertigo it serves as a correlative to the collapse of reason and of so-
ciety. "If I'm mad, that would explain it, wouldn't it?" asksJudy-Madeleine-Car-
lotta, tottering on the precipice by the sea. In John's dream, his room dissolves
into a floral arrangement that rearranges itself into a spiraling descent through
tion. Something is fatefully rotten in a social order that allows a Carlotta, a Made-
leine, a Judy to suffer so. In Vertigo, society itself is shown de-composing like the
and letting live are systematically jolted by the multiple falls which characterize
this film.
of his favorite visual themes - the struggle for life depicted as a bias shot, , la Dela-
croix. In three oil paintings of Ophelia in the stream and in his lithographic en-
graving of the same scene, Delacroix showed his subject with hand extended, as-
suming a dramatic diagonal.14 Delacroix's Ophelia is not dead but still grasping
the willow branch that bonds her to life. Even as she lets go, she is reaching out in
a primordial gesture of vitality. That gesture of the hand and body which is char-
acteristic of the struggle for life in films from Blackmail, Young and Innocent, and
Saboteur to Dial Mfor Murder, North By Northwest, and Psycho, is conspicuously ab-
Emerging from the water holding her diagonally in his arms, John Ferguson
resembles a modem John the Baptist. At San Juan Bautista, searching for Judy-
Madeleine, John's eye turns quickly from the baptismal font to the belltower
steps. This movement is indicative of the fact that the identity-changing immer-
sions in Vertigo are not performed with traditional revivifying holy waters, as the
final lethal appearance of the nun makes clear. They are not associated with
church but rather with Judy's memories of childhood falls into lakes and streams,
with Elster's docks, with the pond where lovers embrace, with the tears in Judy's
eyes. Most of all, they are connected with the murky bay scene where Kim Novak
(who actually feared water) was directed to play a drowning girl.15 The result of
IV.vii.182). Traditional baptismal rites are "maimed" in Vertigo, as are the burial
Of the six main characters who are killed in Hamlet, only Ophelia is allowed to
6 Reflections ofOphelia
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
die out of sight, offstage. When Judy takes her final plunge from the church
tower, her fall and landing are not shown. The lingering image of the real Made-
leine's fall, like that of the detective who plunges to his death in the opening scene
and the representation of John spiraling downward in his dream, has no visual
correlative here. Judy simply disappears as she has previously disappeared to be-
tion with her. Like Ophelia and like Midge, she vanishes from the scene.
A final sequence showingJohn with Midge was cut from the released version of
the film (Spoto Art 335). Vertigo as we know it ends with an "impossibly high-
angled looming view" ofJohn Ferguson alone on the tower platform (Zirnite 2).
that of Hamlet confronting the dead in the churchyard. Seeing the broken re-
self. Will hejump? Will he again take up life? The audience is left to reflect on his
Rhodes College
Notes
1. The text of Hamlet cited throughout this essay is the Arden Shakespeare edition, Harold Jenkins,
editor. All line and scene references are to that edition. Page references to the First Quarto Hamlet are
2. For the screenplay of Alfred Hitchcock's The Short Night and commentary on it, see Freeman
71-250.
3. Spoto Dark Side 310-11; on the role of Shakespeare in Hitchcock's education see Spoto Dark Side
28-29; for the director's views on Shakespeare, see Truffaut 74 and 263 as well as Samuels 241.
4. Villien, who follows Spoto's Art closely, insists on the importance of flowers and the outspread
skirt in this film (293-96; cf. his remarks on Topaz: 331); Wood, whose influence on Spoto was
great, speaks of Vertigo as generally Shakespearian in structure (Hitchcock's Films 77-78); Radcliff-
Umstead summarily compares male-female relationships in Hamlet with those in Vertigo (24).
5. On the social and pathological symbolism of Ophelia, see Showalter Female Malady, 10-13 and
91 and "Representing Ophelia"passim; cf. also Lyons (67-74) on the iconography of Ophelia. Some
of the paintings and engravings discussed in this essay may be seen in Showalter, Lyons, and Raby,
three particularly valuable sources for modern interpretations of Ophelia to which the present study
is indebted. Stage directions indicating that Ophelia's hair is disheveled appear in the First Quarto
only (Variorum ed. 2:74); but she is traditionally played that way.
6. Cf. portraits by Ducarme, Dev6ria and Boulanger, et al. inspired by Harriet Smithson in the role
of mad Ophelia; see Raby 72, 179-82; on the Millais Ophelia see Merol 79-80; on those of Valmont
7. Diagonals as they relate to spirals and the concept of laterality in Vertigo are discussed by
Durgnat 292-93.
8. Novy has written convincingly about the specifically histrionic inferences of these exchanges.
James M. Vest 7
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
9. See Gollancz for both the Saxonian and the Belleforestian versions.
10. On the care Hitchcock took with the coloration and filtering of light and with movement in this
scene, see Truffaut 245, Spoto Art 330-31, and Samuels 246.
11. Spoto develops the idea of circularity and wandering as unifying metaphors for Vertigo in Art
300-27.
12. The name Ferguson is based on a Norse model (cf. *Ferg6's son, reminiscent ofJutish Fengi's
son, i.e., a descendent of Feng6, Amleth's murderous uncle/step-father in the prose tales on which
Hamlet is based).
13. In the Amleth tales, it is the hero's own grave which he discovers on returning from exile; on
Ophelia's grave as analogous to Hamlet's own death-in-life experience in Shakespeare's play, see
14. See Delacroix Opera, figs. 332 (1838), 415 (1844), 764 (1859), and color plate no. il (1844). The
lithograph (1843) is reproduced in Raby 171. Some of these pictures may also be seen in Raby, Sho-
16. This essay is indebted to a Faculty Development Grant from Rhodes College, which facilitated
research; to my wife Nancy and daughter Cecelia, without whose patience and perceptiveness it
could not have grown; to Patricia Ferrara, Mikle Ledgerwood, Valerie Nollan, Catherine McGee,
Chris Caldwell, Torbj6rn Sall, and Joe Rees, as well as the staffs of the university libraries at
Duke U., UNC-Chapel Hill, UNC-Asheville, and of the Buncombe and Madison Counties, NC,
public libraries, whose assistance and encouragement were invaluable; and especially to my former
students in Paris who said, "Allons voir Sueurs froides - let's go see Vertigo."
Works Cited
Coursen, Herbert R. Christian Ritual and the World of Shakespeare's Tragedies. Lewisburg: Bucknell
UP, 1976.
Delacroix, Eugene. L'Opera Pittorica Completa de Delacroix. Ed. L. R. Bortolatto. Milan: Rizzoli,
1972.
Durgnat, Raymond. The Strange Case ofAlfred Hitchcock: Or, The Plain Man's Hitchcock. Cambridge,
Freeman, David. The Last Days ofAlfred Hitchcock: A Memoir Featuring the Screenplay of"A lfred Hitch-
Gollancz, Israel. The Sources of Hamlet. 1926. New York: Octagon, 1967.
Haley, Michael. The Alfred Hitchcock Album. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice, 1981.
Harris, Robert A. and Michael S. Lasky. The Films ofAlfred Hitchcock. Secaucus, NJ: Citadel, 1976.
Merol, Carolyn. "John Everett Millais and the Shakespearean Scene." Gazette des Beaux-Arts 1388
8 Reflections of Ophelia
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
Neely, Carol T. Broken Nuptuals in Shakespeare's Plays. New Haven: Yale UP, 1985.
Novy, Marianne. "Shakespeare's Female Characters as Actors and Audience." The Woman's Part:
Feminist Criticism ofShakespeare. Ed. Carolyn Lenz, et al. Urbana: U of Illinois P, 1980. 256-70.
Raby, Peter. Fair Ophelia: A Life of Harriet Smithson Berlioz. Cambridge, England: Cambridge UP,
1982.
Motion Pictures. Proceedings of the Third Annual Film Conference of Kent State U. Kent: Kent State
U, 1985. 19-25.
--. Hamlet. Ed. H. H. Furness. The Variorum Shakespeare. 2 vols. New York: American
Scholar, 1965.
Showalter, Elaine. The Female Malady: Women, Madness, and English Culture 1830-1980. New York:
Pantheon, 1985.
--. "Representing Ophelia: Women, Madness, and the Responsibilities of Feminist Criti-
cism." Shakespeare and the Question of Theory. Ed. Patricia Parker and Geoffrey Hartman. New
Spoto, Donald. The Art ofAlfred Hitchcock: Fifty Years ofHis Motion Pictures. New York: Hopkinson
Taylor, John R. Hitch: The Life and Times of Alfred Hitchcock. New York: Pantheon, 1978.
Truffaut, Frangois. Hitchcock. Rev. ed. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1984.
- . "Male Desire, Male Anxiety: The Essential Hitchcock." A Hitchcock Reader. Ed. Marshall
Deutelbaum and Leland Poague. Ames: Iowa State UP, 1986. 219-30.
Zirnite, Dennis. "Hitchcock, on the Level: The Height of Spatial Tension." Film Criticism 10
James M. Vest 9
This content downloaded from 130.113.111.210 on Tue, 29 Mar 2016 17:00:48 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms