Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Jonathan Williams
May 13, 2015
jwillia1@linfield.edu
Final Paper
PROPOSED TOPIC: The new SAT and literacy in rural American schools
ORIGINAL QUESTION: Should the SAT be changed to bridge the literacy and
PREVIOUS QUESTION: Should the SAT be changed to bridge the literacy and
educational inequality gap for rural American students and should rural schools receive
CURRENT QUESTION: Should rural schools receive additional funding from the
federal government to bridge the literacy and educational inequality gap for rural
American students?
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 2
Table of Contents
Preface 3
Abstract . 7
Introduction 8
Teaching Strategies .. 12
High-Stakes Testing . 14
Conclusion ... 19
References 20
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 3
Preface
I have learned a lot about myself from this class. Ive learned what it takes to
classes. Through this class I have gained an increased appreciation and awareness of the
importance of being pragmatic and seeking assistance when needed. Allocating enough
time so that I feel like Ive given any assignment in this class the attention it needs has
been something Ive worked on all semester. Helping others as well as receiving help has
been a cornerstone to success for me in this class. This class has also helped me gain
experience using APA and AP style, which are two things that will greatly help me in
future academic endeavors. Ive also gain more depth in my experience writing in
different styles, as the way a paper is written for an English and social sciences class are
not the same, though they both remain committed to revealing intellectual truths.
There are many people Id like to thank who supported me in this class all
semester. First, Id like to thank my roommate who got me through quite a few rough
patches. My brothers in the Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity also provided immense support
throughout the whole semester as the assignments and projects became increasingly time
consuming and my overall schedule become even more chaotic. Id also like to thank
professors Barbara Seidman, Lisa Weidman and Lex Runciman who were all
understanding and willing to work with my schedule. My parents would also always
listen to all that I had to say about the class, what Id learned, my research and writing.
Id also like to thank you two, Susan and Professor Thompson, for reading all of our
papers and keeping the ball rolling throughout the long, laboring semester.
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 4
I think the most notable improvement Ive made in my writing this semester is
what Ive been able to edit out in the spirit of omitting needless words. I have a firmer
understanding of which verbs and phrases I should choose that are short but full of
interviewer and synthesizer of information this semester. I learned to ask questions that
are not obvious and in turn expose the truths and answers I need to help make sense of
my public policy topic. This class has taught me the importance of having a diverse group
of sources, since each adds levels of understanding and ways to look at my topic that
I learned that no matter what, you cant do it all. Finding some sort of balance is
essential to not spending the whole semester constantly bogged down by work. I learned
what it takes to make things work, which in some cases means consuming copious
amounts of coffee. I did learn a lot of research techniques and methods this semester that
will greatly help me as I continue on with the rest of my undergraduate career and on into
crucial subject interview with a teacher from Santiam High School proved to be all and
I think one of the best things I do that makes my hard work by pay off is my work
ethic. I am someone who is not going to give up or not give my full attention and
dedication to a project. I have enjoyed learning about myself and growing as a researcher
and writer this semester as my topic has evolved and as my subject matter has grown
more interesting. Some of the things I know I could improve on include possessives,
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 5
sleeping and being less critical of my work and myself. Having high expectations for
myself is great but I know that often I am my biggest critic. This class, as well as many
others that I have taken, has taught me the continued power of revision and seeking out
peers to edit my work. Reading my work out loud is something that I always do and has
Some of the trials of this class for me would be the workload and scheduling time
to work on my other classes. I have dedicated a lot of my time to this class, which has
other classes the time they also deserve has remained a challenge, but with the help and
understanding from my professors it has worked itself out. The hardest times for me this
semester were when we did the first and last set of complete annotations. That took up a
lot of time and I had to be quite adaptive with my overall schedule in order to complete
everything.
To future students I would recommend being honest with yourself of what you are
capable of. Choose a topic that interests you and makes you remain committed to
learning more about it through the entire semester. I would also recommend making a list
of all the writing improvements you can make to better yourself even after the class is
over. It never hurts to have more than 20 sources even if you dont use all of them in your
final paper. Dont be afraid to seek out interviews from people who seem like theyd be
difficult to talk to. The moments of this class that make you work the hardest are the ones
that you will learn from the most even if you cant see it right at that moment. Id also
like to add that we are all readers who become better writers because of the writing that
we read. It never hurts to read as much as you can about your topic or anything else to
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 6
become a better writer. Finally, Id also add to not be overly critical of yourself or
compare yourself to other classmates and people who have already taken the class.
To Susan and Professor Thompson, I firstly want to thank you again for teaching
this class. I know it takes a lot of energy and time from everyone, including you two! I
appreciate the level of commitment you worked to instill in students minds, I can say
without a doubt I dedicated a lot of my time to researching and writing about my topic
this semester. I would suggest that you dont spend as much time praising past students
when current ones are struggling and looking for help. I understand why you might want
to show students what they could be like if they work hard, but I think for some it can be
finding a balance so students who are struggling dont feel like they wont ever be as
good as previous students. I would also suggest to give students more time to work on
their final paper. A week may seem like a substantial amount of time, and it is, but I think
giving students one class to edit each other papers would be beneficial for all involved.
The final paper should have more importance placed on it since it has the potential to be a
great work sample for students to show as the synthetic conclusion to their extensive
research. I deeply appreciate both of your comments all semester on my papers and as
two professors who I know have impacted and made a difference in my life as well as my
classmates.
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 7
Abstract
This paper confronts the contributing factors that create and cause inequality in rural
education with a focus on literacy and reading. It examines research done that shows how
to improve rural schools and literacy and it also shows what federal funding and policies
are available for rural areas. This paper makes clear how poverty, economics, class and
quality of education all effect rural students overall life outlook and outcomes. It
provides many anecdotal examples from observations and interviews at rural schools in
understood as unique and should receive more funding from the state or federal
government that is unconstrained and strategic to bridge the literacy and overall
Introduction
The quality of education students in rural areas receive is affected by many factors
inequality. Jean Stockard (2015) asserts that poverty is a large factor that contributes to
inequality in rural education. Additionally, Bill Brown (2015) notes that in Mill City,
Oregon, where he teaches at Santiam High School, the city cant afford to pass a bond
measure to give the school more funding because there is not enough economic stability
or people to fund the bond. Geographic isolation is also a contributing factor to the
challenges of rural education, as people who live there are not usually college educated
(Graves, 2011). The middle class has also abandoned some rural areas, which has caused
there to be mainly low paying jobs that dont attract people to go there (Stockard, 2015).
Defining what rural, rurality, literacy and quality of education are all subjective to
each rural area. Donehower, Hogg and Schell (2015), make clear that rural schools
should not have the same standards that urban schools have, since they often lack the
amount of resources and funding that urban schools have access to. Building on
Donehower, Hogg and Schells notion Eppley and Corbett (2012) assert that literacy and
rurality have many meanings since they are both subjective to their own geographic area.
Additionally, most federal policies are aimed at urban school districts instead or rural
ones. An example of rurality differences is illustrated in how Gaston High School, (2015)
and Santiam High School, where Bill Brown (2015) teaches, are both rural schools in
Oregon, but face different challenges and dont have the same resources as the other.
Rural America can also be seen as a place outside of time because of its economic
The achievement gap is larger and harder to close in rural areas because of the
effect poverty has on rural youths education. Using research-based ways to confront and
improve literacy and rural education is essential, as the literacy gap is already present
before children start kindergarten since some may not have gone to preschool (Kennedy,
2014). Students in rural areas tend to not go to college because their parents didnt go and
they would have to pay for it on their own (Graves, 2011). Many rural schools dont offer
Advanced Placement courses, causing students to be not as prepared for college if they
decide to go (Mader, 2015). Students in rural areas and poverty fall even more behind in
the summer because they dont have access to or cannot afford summer enrichment
This paper will examine all of the contributing factors that create and cause
inequality in rural education. It will look at research done that shows how to improve
rural schools and literacy and it will also show what federal funding and policies are
available for rural areas. This paper will conclude with recommendations of what should
be done and adopted to bridge the educational and socioeconomic inequality gap in rural
America. Rural schools and communities should be understood as unique and should
receive more funding from the state or federal government to bridge the literacy and
overall inequality gap that rural Americans face in their daily lives.
students education. Some schools can receive additional funding from their state if they
offer AP courses for their students (Mader, 2015). Rural schools could all benefit from
receiving additional funds from the state or federal government, but are often forced to
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 10
use the money for certain things if they get it (Wilkins, 2015). Larger school districts
Rural America is affected by a poor economy that provides few jobs for people
who are college educated. These areas have a harder time drawing good teachers to come
there because they are often in poor areas and have few economic advantages that urban
areas dont have (Hill, 2015). Most people who leave rural areas tend to not come back if
they go to college because there arent many jobs that draw recent college graduates back
(Graves, 2011). In an effort to draw more people to Kansas, the governor decided to offer
recent college graduates $15,000 over a five-year period if they move to his state,
showing how rural areas are getting creative with ways to address possible opportunities
Rural America needs strategic funding and policy initiatives to bridge the
inequality gap in education and overall quality of life. Federal policy can change how
rural schools are designed and funded. Subtle efforts at the presidential level have been
made to improve rural life, as President Barack Obama created the White House Rural
Council to improve the economic prosperity and overall quality of life for people in rural
America (White House Rural Council, 2011). An additional effort of the White House
Rural Council is to ensure that rural America can be competitive in a global economy
(White House Rural Council, 2011). Oregons department of Education has outlined its
goals for the state to have 40 percent of Oregonians graduate from a four year college, 40
percent to graduate from a two year college and 20 percent to graduate from high school,
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 11
which the state wants to achieve by 2025 (State of Oregon, 2012). The U.S. as a whole
needs to develop a better educational system that ensures students will graduate high
school with proficient reading and writing skills (Haynes, 2012). In the state of Oregons
40-40-20 document, it mentions that people who are ages 25-34 are less educated than
their parents generation, which signals a large shift in education, learning and society
(State of Oregon, 2012). For some this means turning to tests like the Common Core
Standards that force teachers to all teach students the same curriculum. Hill (2015) asserts
that rural schools do need extra funding from either the state or federal government but it
needs to come with no restraints on how the school chooses to use it.
increase literacy and the overall education for students. Kennedy (2014) asserts that
schools that adopt research-based strategies will have success closing the achievement
gap in high-poverty schools. Some schools have adopted more radical teaching strategies
to improve student literacy. Nancie Atwells students in rural Maine read more than 40
books per year and are allowed to write about any topic that interests that them about the
book (Gambino, 2015). Offering harder or AP classes to students will help create more
opportunities for students to increase their own knowledge (Mader, 2015). One of the
overarching points is that it takes systemic change and sustained support to help close the
literacy and educational gap in rural education (Kennedy, 2014). The United States could
be 3 million workers short of people who have the necessary analytical and technological
skills, signaling that rural areas are not the only areas in the U.S. to suffer from a lack of
resources that would help students get a better education (Haynes, 2012).
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 12
Teaching Strategies
Having teachers in rural schools who are able to work with students and the
resources they have can greatly help the overall outcomes of their students success.
Teachers that adopt place-based education and virtual field trip methods of teaching can
help students in rural areas have a more conceptual view of the world and of different
cultures (Lester, 2012). Place-based education helps students learn about the area they
live in, its culture and community. Virtual field trips provides students exposure to
experiences they may never have had through activities that help them better comprehend
what they are reading, increases their understanding of the world and also helps them
books and creating a culture of reading and literacy will help students become more
drawn to reading early on (Wilkins, 2015). Making sure that students have access to
suitable books for their reading level is important because they will gain confidence in
themselves and will be more likely to build on what they know since they have had
previous successes with reading (Stockard, 2015). Additionally, creating a culture that
emphasizes the importance of reading and education will help create a better and more
just democratic society (Eppley & Corbett, 2012). Unfortunately, many students leave
high school without adequate reading and writing skills, causing students to be unable to
For teachers in in Oregon and across the U.S., teaching to the Common Core
Standards and Oregons Smarter Balance can be limiting and challenging for teachers.
Atwell, who teaches in rural Maine and was named the worlds best teacher by winning
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 13
the Global Teaching Prize, argues that the Common Core focuses too much on test scores,
takes away from student individuality and does not take into account that students learn at
different rates (Gambino, 2015). For students who are already suffering academically in
rural areas, testing can cause them to become invisible if they start falling behind and
do not get the help they need (Elish-Piper, Matthews, & Risko, 2013). Teachers at Gaston
High School say that all of their teaching is aligned with the Common Core and Oregons
Smarter Balance tests. They also said that they spend a lot of time getting students ready
to take the tests (Gaston High School, 2015). Brown (2015), who teaches at Santiam
High School, argues that the Smarter Balance forces teachers to teach to the test, instead
High-Stakes Testing
what students are learning and can be used to compare rural students to urban ones.
Atwell, who teaches in rural Maine, asserts that tests are limiting and take time away
from learning (Gambino, 2015). She also argues that testing is a business model and
technicians because of the standards and mandates placed on schools (Gambino, 2015).
As mentioned earlier, high-stakes testing can cause students who are already struggling to
do even worse and not get the help they need because they have fallen behind (Elish-
Piper, Matthews, & Risko, 2013). Additionally, the authors make clear that testing results
in students and teachers needs being pushed behind and testing goals taking the
forefront (Elish-Piper, Matthew, & Risko, 2013). Wilkins (2015) and Stockard (2015)
both argue that although high-stakes testing is controversial, they agree that it gives
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 14
educators a gauge of what students have learned and can also be used to compare and
show how rural students are doing in comparison to urban ones. Hill (2015) asserts that
schools need to have multiple ways to measure student success and learning. Student
success comes from motivation from teachers, which helps create the confidence cycle in
students if they have good initial experiences in their education (Stockard, 2015).
the academic year if they are going to successfully help their students learn and grow.
Eppley and Corbett (2012) assert that teachers need to have development days throughout
their teaching experience so they can continue to find ways to better help their students.
Additionally, teachers need more time out of the classroom and away from their students
so they can prepare and find better ways to be more effective in their teaching (Wilkins,
2015). Teachers in rural and urban areas are under more pressure now from schools and
the state and federal government to produce students who can score well on tests
(Stockard, 2015). At Gaston High School there is no paid librarian, so if students have a
research project or need extra help, it all comes from the teacher (Gaston High School,
2015). Notably, there isnt any specific training for teaching in a rural school for teachers,
as many have noted that the teaching methods are the same, its just the students and the
area that are different (Hill, 2015). Teacher collaboration and leadership in school
administration are also two things that can help create a successful school that can work
to close the achievement gap (Kennedy, 2014). Additionally, Brown (2015) said that he
likes working at Santiam High School because it has a high faculty retention rate, which
Many students dont have a stable home life if their parents are involved in
drugs or live in poverty. Brown (2015) notes that students who do not have a good home
life often struggle more in school and are at more of a disadvantage because they dont
have the family support students from the middle class or wealthy families have. Badger
(2014) also mentions that students who grow up in a family where drugs, violence or
poverty are prevalent struggle more throughout life and have a shadow of their
upbringing that follows them as they grow up. Students who live in areas of high-poverty
are more likely to talk to their teachers about their future, making it clear how important
good teachers are for students in geographically isolated areas (National Research
Rural areas are full of strengths, weaknesses and opportunities that all effect the
quality of education rural students receive. Students in rural areas often have good
relationships with their teachers and counselors because they can answer students
questions and help them figure out what they want to do after high school (National
Research Center on Rural Education Support, 2011). A weakness of rural areas is that for
some students, the baseline expectation is lower causing the achievement gap to widen
(Wilkins, 2015). Rural schools have also become creative with how they use their
funding, as Gaston High School received funds to purchase new textbooks and the faculty
and administration chose instead to adopt iPads and Kindles for students to use (Gaston
High School, 2015). Additionally, rural areas and schools are usually smaller than urban
ones, causing students to receive a more individualized education (Hill, 2015). Smaller
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 16
class sizes also creates a safety net for students who are struggling since there are fewer
students, and teacher are able to identify those who need additional help (Brown, 2015).
Rural students lack exposure to the rest of the world because of their geographic location
and possible isolation, forcing teachers to find creative ways to open students eyes and to
shape their view of the world and of other cultures (Lester, 2012). At Santiam High
School, students only go to school four days a week in order for the school to save
money. Students have the option to take classes on Friday if they want to get ahead or
Understanding that all rural schools are unique to their own geographic area will
help people and policy makers realize that they are all different and may need different
levels of support and funding. Gaston High School (2015) is a school that is
representative of a rural school that could be seen as an outlier since it offers AP classes
while others may not be able to due to that areas economic stability. Santiam High School
suffers greatly from its towns poverty and economic inequality. Mill City, Oregon, where
Santiam High School is located, used to have seven mills and now has two, creating a
shift in the economic stability of the area (Brown, 2015). For students who stay in the
area, there are now fewer jobs to come by and they often do not pay well, making
students likelihood of upward mobility (moving from one class to another) unlikely
unless they were to go to college or find work elsewhere. Graves (2011) notes that many
parents from rural areas in Oregon know their children may never come back because of
the few jobs those areas have for people who are college educated. Santiam High School
is only able to apply for grants from the state since it is difficult to ask and pass a bond
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 17
measure in that area because there are few residents to pay for it and not enough money
(Brown, 2015). It is worth mentioning that Mill City is just 40 miles away from Salem,
Oregon, where the states capital and governmental offices are. Even in that short of a
in both race and class. Some students of color and minority groups have a harder time
adjusting to college if they come from the South, since the schools they choose to attend
people were able to get blue collar managerial jobs while black people had a harder time
acquiring those kinds of jobs (Badger, 2014). Students who lack in literacy understanding
and development have a higher chance of having less income, social mobility and overall
quality of life (Kennedy, 2014). Some students who come from low-income families and
are smart choose not to apply to elite, Ivy League schools because of the cost and also
because admission counselors only visit select rural areas, which contributes to the
opportunities rural students miss out on because of the educational inequality they
experience (Meraji, 2015). In contrast to these assertions, other researchers say that
students who live in high poverty areas still have high educational aspirations such as
going to college (Irvin, Meece, Byun, Farmer, & Hutchins, 2011). In some rural areas
there is not a lot of diversity, causing literature to be the only way that students are
exposed to different cultures and beliefs (Nelson, 2004). Additionally, students are more
likely to understand the challenges of those who are from different cultures if they have
read and learned about them (Nelson, 2004). Only 4 percent of the 790 children in the
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 18
study from Baltimore went on to college and got a degree, illustrating that it is not only
In an effort to make the test fairer for all students, The College Board is using the
SAT as a source to bridge the economic and educational inequality gap rural and minority
students face. David Coleman, who is the president of The College Board is planning to
have a revised test of the SAT come out in 2016 (Balf, 2014). Notable changes to the test
include making the essay section optional and getting rid of obscure vocabulary words
that student wont likely use in a college classroom or a job. Some educators are worried
about the effect changes to the SAT will have on students overall and they are also
concerned because Coleman is only one person and is not an educator by training (Balf,
2014). Critics argue that he should not be the only one deciding the design of the SAT
and what is and is not changed or taken off of it. Wilkins (2015) said that if the SAT is
going to be changed, educators should have some input into what should stay or be taken
of the test. Other critics of the test understand that Coleman and the College Board are
trying to make the test more accessible to minority students, but argue that the vocabulary
section should not be changed to easier, more practical words and they also say that
changing it sends a message that possibly devalues language (Murphy, 2013). Murphy
also asserts that critics argue that learning difficult vocabulary contributes to students
lexical richness and helps them learn how to be critical thinkers. Some colleges and
universities no longer require students to provide an SAT score to apply to their school.
Balf (2014) cites Wake Forest University as one of the many colleges that doesnt require
students to provide an SAT score. Some colleges and universities are now offering free
LITERACY AND RURAL AMERICAN EDUCATION 19
AP courses for students to take who live in rural areas, as an effort to help students who
Conclusion
Rural American life and education is complex and should be understood and
treated as unique by the government. As it is illustrated in this paper: no two rural areas
or schools are alike. They all have different strengths and weaknesses and require
different resources relevant to their geographic location and economy. Rural schools
should not have the same standards placed on them that urban areas have. The state and
federal government need to work together to create a budget that is more balanced and
sustainable for the whole state or county, not just certain areas that take precedence over
others. Rural America is also a larger part of the U.S. than people think and is often
forgotten since some people dont live near areas that are considered rural. Education in
rural America can be improved if teachers, schools, communities, states and the U.S. as a
whole work together to create policy solutions that will ensure a more equal educational
system for rural schools. Rural economics, jobs and the overall quality of rural life can be
improved if time and money that is unconstrained for schools, is strategically invested in
them from the state and federal government. Creating job opportunities for people who
come from a variety of educational backgrounds will also help increase the population
and level of economic stability for rural areas, which will in turn help create better
References
Badger, E. (2014, August 29). What your first-grade life says about the rest of it. The
Balf, T. (2014, March 6). The story behind the SAT overhaul. The New York Times.
Donehower, K., Hogg, C., & Schell, E. (2007). Rural literacies. Carbondale, IL:
Eppley, K., & Corbett, M. (2012). Ill see that when I believe it: A dialogue of
Gambino, L. (2015, March 23). The worlds best teacher lives in rural Maine and doesnt
Gaston High School. (2015, April 6). Observation by Jonathan Williams. From notes.
Graves, B. (2011, March 29). Rural Oregon sending more high school graduates to
http://tinyurl.com/4nyxf7a
Haynes, M. (2012, March 31). Confronting the crisis: Federal investments in state birth-
http://tinyurl.com/k6hpuwk
Irvin, M., Meece, J., Byun, S., Farmer, T., & Hutchins, B. (2011, January 28).
Ebscohost
Iskander, M. (2014, March 23). Kansas offers incentives to bring people back to the
Lester, L. (2012). Putting Rural Readers On The Map. Reading Teacher, 65(6) 407-415.
Mader, J. (2015, February 12). Rural students lack access to advanced placement
Meraji, S. (2015, March 16). Why many smart, low-income students dont apply to elite
Murphy, J. (2013, December 11). The case for SAT words. The Atlantic. Retrieved from
http://tinyurl.com/lvvfsrr
National Research Center on Rural Education Support. (2011). How rural youth prepare
Nelson, C. (2004). Speaking My Mind: The Diversity Challenge in Rural Education. The
State of Oregon. (2012, April). 10 Year Plan for Oregon Project: Education Policy
The White House. (2011, June 9). Establishment of the White House Rural Council.
Wilkins, J. (2015, March 9). Interview by Jonathan Williams. From notes and audio
recording.