A Theory for Evaluating Ideas

16 May 2017 | Nolan Manteufel | nolan.manteufel@gmail.com

Abstract Introduction

This paper introduces a five-point framework for evaluating Evaluating ideas involves negative thinking, objection and
ideas: (1) novelty (creativity), (2) validity and truth discussion. This theory (1) enables more efficient negative
(correctness), (3) utility and value (contribution), (4) thinking, (2) helps clarify objections, and (3) reduces the risk
presentation and interest (circulation and collaboration) of misunderstandings.
and (5) considerations.
Framework for Evaluating Ideas
Preface to a Theory for Evaluating Ideas
1. Novelty
(1) A theory for evaluating ideas should be holistic. It 2. Validity and Truth
should be able to account for every possible evaluation 3. Utility and Value
thought, objection and discussion. 4. Presentation and Interest
(2) A theory for evaluating ideas must balance versatility 5. Considerations
and specificity.
Cute Version
(3) An idea evaluation framework should not address
evaluation priority, process or phases. If such a It may be cute, clarifying and insightful to remember this
framework appears as a numbered list, the numbers framework as a list of c words.
should act as a reference designator and memory aid.
1. Creativity
(4) An idea evaluation framework should integrate items
2. Correctness
that are more closely related to each other than other
3. Contribution
points on the list.
4. Circulation and Collaboration
5. Consideration