Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Uncertainty returns
UK Equity Market : FTSE All-Share last 6 months
Source: Bloomberg
The UK market: Uncertainty returns
Following a recent pattern, the FTSE100 index started the month strongly, reflecting the continuing upward momentum from investors’
greater risk appetite as economic data remained broadly positive rekindling hopes that the worst of the global economic downturn was
over. This mood persisted, taking the index briefly above the upper level of the established 4300 to 4500 range, despite the General
Motors bankruptcy. The UK Purchasing Managers Index confirmed that the UK economy seemed to be recovering much quicker than
expected with all sectors of the economy showing positive signs. However, having reached a five-month high, UK investors appeared
to take fright as the sharp recovery raised concerns over high commodity prices (especially crude oil, which has pushed petrol prices
back up above 100p per litre), persistent inflation levels and the spectre of higher interest rates. Thus in the middle of the month the
equity market had difficulty making any further progress. In the second half of June, equity markets weakened sharply as uncertainty
returned, triggered by downgrades to growth forecasts and generally cautious comments over global economic prospects from the
World Bank, central bankers and the IMF. In essence, the prevailing feeling was that markets had run ahead of themselves. With risk
aversion resurfacing as investors worried over the sustainability of the green shoots, and recent economic data offering no directional
help, markets will be quite releaved to retain current levels as we approach the end of the second quarter.
With average house prices moving up from the low point in February this year, the peak to trough figures from the Halifax – from peak
in August 2007 - was 22.5%, and the Nationwide – from peak in November 2007 – was 18.4%. Both organisations were predicting
further falls this year of around 6% from the trough levels. In view of the latest data these peak-to-trough forecasts are looking
increasingly pessimistic, although there will undoubtedly be further declines in values in individual future months. Nevertheless, the
media has been full of optimistic commentary following the rises in the monthly indices, predicting that the UK residential market could
be at, or approaching, a turning point. While short term data are generally unreliable, and liable to volatility, particularly at a time when
numbers of transactions are far below normal levels – the Land Registry commented that turnover was some 60% below long-term
averages – leading to unreliable statistics, there are, nonetheless, strong signals that the rate of decline is slowing, and maybe
approaching stability.
The main reasons behind the more optimistic outlook for residential property include an increase in buyer enquiries, a gradual easing
in the credit situation, and the limited supply of new property onto the market. The lack of supply of property is a result of potential
vendors, who are able to, holding back until prices improve, together with fewer forced sellers as a result of low interest rates,
government intervention and lenders’ improved forbearance on outstanding payments. Despite the continuing poor outlook for the
UK economy, and in particular, the expectation of a continuing rise in the unemployment figures – from currently around 2.26m (7.2%)
to perhaps three million by the end of 2009/early 2010 – both the Bank of England and the Council for Mortgage Lenders (CML)
confirm that the level of mortgage approvals is continuing to rise, albeit erratically and from historically low levels. The Bank of England
said that the number of mortgages approved in the first quarter of 2009 had risen by 19% over the previous quarter, while the CML
Amongst other encouraging data, the Purchasing Managers Index (PMI), which measures business-to-business activity in
manufacturing, construction and services, revealed an improving picture over the past few months, and is now at a level indicating
economic expansion. While the relationship between PMI and economic growth is less precise than usual, the commentary believes
that a return to growth could now be happening a year after the economy went into recession. Many economists agree that the
indications are that the worst of the UK recession is now over. The respected National Institute for Economic and Social Research
thinks that economic growth returned in April and that the second quarter GDP could be flat, after a 1.9% contraction in the first
quarter. Analysis of the first quarter GDP showed that the contraction was largely due to the run down in inventories (with little
restocking), while business investment and exports were not as weak as first thought. These factors point to the UK economy being
further through the economic cycle than previously thought, and underlines the possibility of growth in the third and fourth quarters
as the positive effects of the huge fiscal and monetary stimulus, low interest rates, reduced VAT and a sharp fall in commodity prices
combine to boost household and business spending. The major concern is that all these factors, and the necessary restocking, will
provide only a short-term boost to the economy, and that the recovery will not be sustained through 2010, potentially leading to a
second downturn in growth – thus a ‘W’ shaped recovery rather than the hoped for ‘V’. It may be that the current improvement in
the housing market is mirroring the economic recovery pattern, driven by a rise in demand, a shortage of new housing stock and
relatively cheap credit. Certainly the decline in residential values, and interest rates at historic lows, has improved affordability, with
the percentage of earnings used by new borrowers to pay an average mortgage over disposable income declining sharply from a
peak of 48% in Q3 2007 to around 31% in Q1 2009. The long-term (25 year) average is estimated to be around 37% of earnings.
However, the combination of rising prices encouraging reluctant vendors to put properties onto the market, increasing supply, the
prospect of higher interest rates in the medium term (as economic growth returns and inflation rises) making credit more expensive
(lenders are already increasing the cost of longer term fixed rate mortgage deals), at the same time as unemployment is at its peak,
are likely to adversely affect affordability. Thus the outlook for residential values remains highly uncertain. While we expect values to
rise in the short term, by early 2010 the adverse factors mentioned above are likely to result in values finding it much harder to make
progress, and may result in some declines particularly as uncertainty over job security and earnings growth undermines confidence.
Longer term the lack of supply of new property, particularly in London and the South East, should result in stability and then the
resumption of average long-term growth rates, provided that availability of credit returns to more ‘normal’ levels.
The information in the newsletter is taken from publicly available sources and the newsletter is distributed for information purposes
only. Whilst reasonable steps have been taken to ensure the fairness of any views expressed, First Equity Limited does not offer any
guarantee as to the accuracy or completeness of the information. The newsletter is not intended as a solicitation to buy or sell any
securities or investments which may be mentioned. First Equity Limited is regulated and authorised by the Financial Services Authority
and is a member of the London Stock Exchange and the PLUS Market.