Sie sind auf Seite 1von 9

Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Social Science & Medicine


journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/socscimed

The specter of post-communism: Women and alcohol in eight post-Soviet states


Brian Philip Hinote a, *, William C. Cockerham b, Pamela Abbott c
a
Department of Sociology & Anthropology, Middle Tennessee State University, 1301 East Main Street, MTSU Box 10, TODD 325, Murfreesboro, TN 37132-0001, USA
b
University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA
c
Glasgow Caledonian University, UK

a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t

Article history: Because men have borne the heaviest burden of premature mortality in the former Soviet Union, women
Available online 21 February 2009 have for the most part been overlooked in studies of the health crisis in this part of the world. A
considerable body of research points to alcohol consumption among males as a primary lifestyle cause of
Keywords: premature mortality. However, the extent to which alcohol use has penetrated the female population
Russia following the collapse of communism and how this consumption is associated with other social factors is
Former Soviet Union
less well-understood. Accordingly, this paper investigates alcohol consumption in eight republics of the
Health lifestyles
Alcohol consumption
former USSR Armenia, Belarus, Georgia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Russia, and Ukraine using
Women data collected in 2001. More specically, discussion of gender role transformations and the historical
Gender experiences of women during the Soviet era emphasize two potentially important social inuences
examined in this analysis: psychological distress and Soviet political ideology. Findings suggest that
distress is only weakly statistically associated with frequent drinking behavior among women, but results
for political ideology show that this factor is statistically and signicantly associated with drinking
behaviors. Alcohol consumption was not particularly common among women under communism, but
trends have been changing. Our discussion suggests that, after the collapse of the Soviet state, women are
more able to embrace behavioral practices related to alcohol, and many may do so as an overt rejection of
traditional Soviet norms and values. Findings are also discussed within the context of current epide-
miological trends and future research directions in these eight republics.
2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Introduction continued under post-communism (Nemtsov, 2005; Shkolnikov,


Field, & Andreev, 2001; Transchel, 2006; Van Gundy, Schieman,
Women have been overlooked in the majority of studies of the Kelley, & Rebellonn, 2005). This drinking practice, in turn, is iden-
health crisis in the former Soviet Union. This is because Russian tied as the primary lifestyle cause of premature male mortality via
men have borne the heaviest burden of premature mortality, losing heart disease, accidents, poisonings, homicide, and suicide (Cock-
on average some 5.8 years of life expectancy between 1965 and erham, 2000, 2007; Pridemore, 2002, 2006; Shkolnikov et al.,
2005. In contrast, life expectancy for Russian women stagnated, 2004; Van Gundy et al., 2005). However, the specic extent to
advancing only 0.2 years for the average woman over the same 40- which alcohol use has penetrated the female population following
year period (Goskomstat, 2007). Most studies, however, primarily the collapse of communism, and how this consumption is corre-
use females as a comparison group to demonstrate the more severe lated with other important social factors identied in previous
health outcomes for males the obviously greater casualties of the research like psychological distress and political ideology (Cock-
health crisis. While they have not been impacted to the same erham, Hinote, & Abbott, 2006a; Cockerham, Snead, & DeWaal,
degree as men, the health of females has clearly suffered in that 2002), has not been thoroughly studied. It is the purpose of this
they have not experienced the rise in longevity common to women paper, accordingly, to investigate female alcohol consumption in
in other developed countries around the world. eight republics of the former USSR, a geographic area correspond-
A considerable body of research shows that alcohol use, ing to about 80% of the population of the former Soviet state.
particularly the excessive consumption of vodka, is a major feature The discussion that follows will consider the negative health
of male health lifestyles in the former Soviet Union that has situations in these parts of the world and provide an abbreviated
history of female experiences with alcohol in order to emphasize
the signicant concepts of psychological distress and political
* Corresponding author. Tel.: 1 615 494 7914; fax: 1 615 898 5427. ideology concepts integral to this analysis. As a response to
E-mail address: bhinote@mtsu.edu (B.P. Hinote). stressful social conditions, distress is essentially a negative

0277-9536/$ see front matter 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.01.019
B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262 1255

physiological and psychological state characterized by feelings of 2006). Some sources identify sharp increases in female drinking
depression and anxiety, which generally exert a negative impact on and related behaviors as late as the 1980s (e.g., White, 1996), but
health (Mirowsky & Ross, 2003). On the other hand, ideology may historically, alcohol consumption, the male workers only avail-
be dened as shared frameworks of normative political ideas and able source of entertainment and oblivion from the conditions of
values maintained by a social group that advocates particular his life, was not part of the female world. Women workers
behaviors, social arrangements, and ways of looking at the social consumed no tobacco and little alcohol (Glickman, 1984:131).
world (Cockerham, Hinote, Abbott, & Cockerham, 2006b). Yet this Drinking alcohol and smoking tobacco were typically male
paper is more precisely interested in the ideology of Soviet activities, especially outside of the factory gates. Herlihy (2002:93)
communism, with its emphasis on the collective and consequent writes that by the twentieth century, alcohol was perceived as
devaluation of the individual. The structures of the Soviet social a symbol of masculinity and sobriety a symbol of femininity. Society
system created conditions of considerable distress for many expected women to conform to its ideal of accepted behavior, with
members of society, and these conditions exhibit observable womens drinking becoming unfeminine and mens sobriety
statistical associations with health lifestyle patterns and choices becoming unmasculine. So, while the female worker may have
regarding alcohol use. These effects on males have been investi- been better off not drinking, she was also deprived of an important
gated in earlier research (Abbott, Turmov, & Wallace, 2006; Cock- social arena for the alleviation of stress and escape from the toils of
erham et al., 2006b; Shkolnikov et al., 2004), but potential effects everyday life (Glickman, 1984). So distress-related factors likely
on females arguably deserve further attention. We therefore focus affected both males and females alike under communism, but
our analysis on the phenomenon of female alcohol consumption as societal proscriptions prevented many females from engaging in
an increasingly important health lifestyle practice in these repub- this traditionally male behavior, for a number of reasons.
lics. Some sources point to notable increases in drinking among However, to say that women rarely imbibed is not to say that
women in the former USSR, and this paper seeks to identify specic they were unaffected by drunkenness, as alcohol clearly touched
correlations involving these important social factors and the womens lives through interactions with many male counterparts.
frequency of alcohol consumption within this particular demo- From early on, the Bolshevik blueprints for revolutionizing
graphic group. Unlike previous analyses, this paper also considers communist gender relations aimed to undermine the institution of
the concepts of distress and ideology in the same statistical model the family by transforming the traditional roles of men and women
in order to control for the potentially confounding inuence of in the home (Issoupova, 2000; Kukhterin, 2000). Yet, because
each, although we specically investigate the independent effects existing patterns of malefemale interaction were not challenged,
of these important predictors, as outlined below. traditional power relationships persisted between them (Ashwin,
2000). These dynamics are notable for two reasons. First, while
Mortality, women, and alcohol men were intentionally stripped of many of their social roles of
power and authority, they were able to re-establish these positions
From historical, sociological, demographic, and epidemiological in the public sphere by serving the state as party functionaries,
perspectives, the health crisis that developed in this part of the soldiers, or workers (Kukhterin, 2000). Second, despite increasing
world from the mid-twentieth century onward is well-documented levels of labor participation, females were still tasked with main-
(e.g., Blum & Monnier, 1989; Cockerham, 1999). However, when the taining the home and managing domestic life (Kiblitskaya, 2000a).
Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, the health situation further dete- As a result, mens estrangement from domestic and caring work
riorated and negative health dynamics continue to affect large meant that they were only weakly integrated into the Soviet
segments of many post-socialist republics (Abbott, Turmov, & family (Ashwin & Lytkina, 2004:193), and many women were
Wallace, 2006; Cockerham, Hinote, Abbott, & Haerpfer, 2004, more and more facing distressful situations of managing the
2006b; Shkolnikov et al., 2004). Recent 2005 gures published by domestic sphere and the nancial affairs of the family, as well as the
the WHO (2007) indicate a life expectancy of only 59 years for often pervasive negative effects of alcohol consumption among
Russian males and 72 years for females, while the State Committee men.
of the Russian Federation on Statistics (Goskomstat, 2007) lists Kiblitskaya (2000a) traces the evolution of female roles over the
Russian male longevity at 58.9 years and female longevity at 72.4 course of Soviet history and also emphasizes the female domestic
years for 2005. To illustrate some differences across these regions, role and responsibility to the family throughout the twentieth
life expectancy statistics from 2005 show that Russia exhibits the century. Men typically assumed the role of breadwinner in Soviet
greatest disadvantages in longevity among both males and females, times, but in many families, mens wages were, for one reason or
with the Central Asian states, Belarus, and Ukraine faring only another, unreliable to the extent that their wives became the
marginally better. Data from the Caucasus region, on the other nancial heads of the household and effectively assumed all of the
hand, indicate that residents of Armenia and Georgia may antici- central roles of the family. One often cited problem in this research
pate the greatest longevity among the republics in this analysis. is the alcohol issue among men a problem often considered
However, even the greatest life expectancy statistics for both sexes a major contributor to nancial shortcomings within the Soviet
in these eight republics are nearly a full decade behind Western family. These problems worsened during the transition years, as
nations like the U.S., Canada, and the UK (WHO, 2007). As males consistently lost status in the realm of employment, creating
a particularly harmful lifestyle practice, alcohol consumption conditions contributing to the negative health situations for many
patterns have played a large role in the negative health trajectories men, often through the escapist dimensions of vodka consumption
of men, but what is known about alcohols impact on females (Kiblitskaya, 2000b).
during and after communism? Indeed, this is an important ques- Traditionally, then, males were considered the weak link in
tion worth exploring. many Soviet families, in that there was always a question mark
Despite the legacy of alcohol use in Russian history and culture, over their behavior, particularly in relation to drink (Kukhterin,
statistics on drinking behavior among women during Soviet times 2000:83). There can be little doubt that the social conditions
are often hard to come by or do not exist. This is probably not surrounding alcohol consumption also affected women, and while
because females did not drink; rather, it is more likely that drinking evidence does not implicate direct female consumption as a major
among women did not constitute a particularly signicant or determinant of the stagnation in life expectancy, some sources
noteworthy social problem (Shkolnikov et al., 2001; Transchel, show considerable increases in female alcohol consumption in the
1256 B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262

1980s (White, 1996). Abbott et al. (2006) report that drinking Surely, the plight of females under Soviet communism and its
among women has become increasingly common, further high- aftermath may be characterized as situations of particular stress
lighting shifting patterns of female consumption. But what social and/or distress, as reected in the research and social circum-
factors have potentially played a role in drinking among women in stances described above. Existing research ndings motivate the
the republics of the former Soviet Union? In briey describing following hypothesis:
gender role transformations and the broader historical experiences
of women during the Soviet era, the trends and accounts cited H1: Higher levels of psychological distress are positively asso-
above help emphasize two potentially important social inuences ciated with frequent alcohol consumption.
further examined in the analysis that follows: (1) psychological
distress among females as a result of these social conditions and (2) Although alcohol consumption clearly has not affected female
the legacy of Soviet political ideology in helping to construct these longevity to the extent that it has male life expectancy, levels of
realities. distress among women may feasibly be related to more recent
increases in drinking behavior as reported by other researchers
Distress and health (e.g., Abbott et al., 2006; White, 1996). Perhaps women in the
aftermath of communism have more recently begun to manifest
The concept of psychological distress may be dened as an their elevated levels of distress in the form of more frequent alcohol
adverse mental state involving marked depression and anxiety that consumption, yet ideological dynamics arguably play a role in these
falls short of clinical mental illness and is characterized by negative processes as well.
mood and malaise. It is described as a state of misery that is
a common response to a stressful situation, rather than simply Ideology and health
a symptom of disease (Mirowsky & Ross, 2003). Existing research
emphasizes the importance of such factors with regard to health Previous studies have also investigated the ways that commu-
matters (e.g., Brunner & Marmot, 2001; Marmot, Siegrist, Theorell, nist political ideology has shaped the ways that post-Soviet citizens
& Feeney, 2001; Stansfeld, 2001), as many ndings suggest that view, interpret, and act upon the social world in the form of health
distress and stress-related symptoms play important roles in lifestyles (Cockerham et al., 2002, 2006b). Yet perhaps surprisingly,
health-related outcomes (e.g., Mechanic & Hansell, 1987; Ross & considerations of ideology are relatively recent in sociological
Bird, 1994) and lifestyle choices (e.g., Boardman, Finch, Ellison, studies of health, even though this concept has been discussed
Williams, & Jackson, 2001; Umberson, Williams, & Anderson, since the nineteenth century in the broader discipline of sociology.
2002). Psychological distress not only threatens an individuals Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels (1976) considered ideology
sense of well-being, but may promote negative health behaviors a weapon of the ruling class used to perpetuate their interests and
like drinking and smoking or help bring about negative physio- power, an approach that inuenced later thinkers in considering
logical responses to stressful conditions over time (Mirowsky & the role that ideology plays in molding many forms of social
Ross, 2003). behavior. As a concept, ideology may be dened as shared sets of
Several existing studies examine the effects of stress and normative ideas and values held in common by individuals, groups,
distress within the broader development of negative trends in parties, classes, and nations that advocate particular forms of
health and longevity in the former Soviet Union (Cockerham conduct, social relationships, and solutions to problems (Cocker-
et al., 2006a; Leon & Shkolnikov, 1998; Pietila & Rytkonen, 2008). ham et al., 2006b:17991800).
Yet, with the available empirical studies that have been con- In illustrating the power of ideological forces, Malia (1994)
ducted, evidence supporting the role of stress and distress as points out that the Soviet experiment was rst and foremost an
direct causal factors in the current mortality crisis is limited and ideocratic regime. For example, the primary social unit under
unconvincing at present (Shkolnikov et al., 2004). Findings do, Soviet-style communism was the collective, which served to ensure
however, suggest that stress and related processes need to be conformity while discouraging any sense of individualism. The
considered when analyzing the experiences of many people after implementation and provision of state services in economic sectors
the post-communist transition. Leon and Shkolnikov (1998) like housing and health care also reinforced the paternalistic
identify high levels of stress during the transition but do not link character of Soviet leadership and social life. As Shkolnikov et al.
that pattern to morbidity or mortality. Other studies examine (2004:65) write, Soviet ideology placed the interests of the state
stress-related inuences and their effects on self-rated health in above those of the individual.. People were taught to sacrice
Russia (Bobak, Pikhart, Hertzman, Rose, & Marmot, 1998) and their lives to build communism. [while] the value of individual life
Ukraine (Gilmore, McKee, & Rose, 2002). Other research has and health was low. Existing research also suggests that such
identied higher levels of alienation among Muscovites than ideological inuences exert a negative impact on health, as Soviet
residents of Helsinki, Finland, where alienation was associated communism appears to have hindered the implementation of
with more physical symptoms and poorer health (Palosuo, 2000, health practices geared toward promoting individual health and
2003; Palosuo, Uutele, Zhuravleva, & Lakomova, 1998). Further, well-being (Abbott et al., 2006; Cockerham et al., 2002, 2006b).
residents of Moscow exhibited less healthy lifestyles, while That is, research examining males shows that identifying with
researchers noted the possibility that lifestyles mediated the Soviet political ideology is associated with negative health lifestyles
association between stress and health. (i.e., the political ideology hypothesis), but similar relationships
Cockerham (1999:107108) also notes this possibility for males, between ideology and female alcohol consumption have not been
claiming that the greatest effect of stress and distress was in sufciently studied (Cockerham et al., 2006b). Indeed, the tenets of
promoting unhealthy male lifestyles through excessive drinking Soviet-style communism, especially considering the roles and
and smoking, rather than in causing a direct physiological shock. positions of women within such a system, created unique social
After all, if stress-related factors were direct causal variables, we conditions that potentially impact individual health lifestyles.
would expect females to represent the demographic group most Along with the effects of psychological distress, the precise role of
adversely affected in this health crisis, as existing evidence shows ideological dynamics is of particular interest when it comes to
that women experience and report signicantly higher stress and female lifestyle choices regarding frequent alcohol use in this study.
distress levels than men (Abbott, 2002; Cockerham et al., 2006a). Existing research supporting the political ideology hypothesis in
B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262 1257

post-Soviet populations motivates the following hypothesis for 18 years or over for each republic and was developed in consulta-
females in this study: tion with country representatives. Surveys were translated into
Russian and other national languages, back-translated to ensure
H2: Soviet communist political ideology is positively associated consistency, and pilot-tested in each republic. See Pomerleau, Gil-
with frequent alcohol consumption. more, McKee, Rose, and Haerpfer (2004) for additional discussion
of methodology and Abbott (2002) for more focused data on each
It is clear that lifestyle choices like whether or not to drink alcohol country.
are not simply isolated, uncoordinated behaviors among discon- Samples were selected using a multi-stage random sampling
nected individuals. Rather, they are patterned routines that are design, with no over- or under-sampling of subpopulations.
arguably associated with specic, observable, and measurable social However, certain potential respondents were excluded like pris-
factors (Cockerham, 2005) like psychological distress and ideolog- oners, military personnel, institutionalized or hospitalized persons,
ical dynamics factors that can be traced back to the historical and the homeless. Persons residing in the scarcely inhabited and
experiences of females beneath the banner of Soviet communism inaccessible regions of the Russian Far North and areas subject to
and the structural constraints of the former Soviet Union. Important military action like the Chechen and Ingush Republics of the
research undertaken by Abbott et al. (2006:236) further emphasizes Russian Federation were also excluded. Primary sampling units
the applicability of this conceptualization within the post-Soviet were established for each country and within each sampling unit,
context. They specically note that even when structural changes households were selected using standardized random route
led people to question aspects of life formerly taken for granted in procedures to avoid bias in the selection of respondents when
the case of post-Soviet citizens, that they do not need to look after random selection from household lists is not feasible or available,
their health because the state will provide for them their ability to with the exception of Armenia, where household lists were used to
exercise agency and look after their own health is limited by both ensure a random sample. Sample sizes were determined for each
structural factors over which they have no control and unques- republic according to population size. Response rates range from
tioned, taken-for-granted daily practices. 71% in Kyrgyzstan to 88% in Armenia and Georgia.
Analysis of qualitative data reveals that while post-Soviet citi- Dependent variables measured drinking behaviors among
zens were aware of the health consequences of negative lifestyle females, including the frequency of alcohol consumption (all types),
choices like smoking and drug use, most male informants drank as well as the frequency of beer consumption and the frequency of
alcohol and smoked cigarettes, with some reporting vodka wine consumption. All three outcome measures are operationalized
consumption as a way to deal with stress. The authors go on to as follows: once per week or more frequently (i.e., multiple times
write that smoking and drinking have become habitual, part of the per week or daily) 1, or less frequently than once per week 0.
taken-for-granted everyday life, and are seen as both pleasurable, Vodka is the leading alcoholic beverage in most parts of the former
in a life that offers few pleasures, and as a way of coping with Soviet Union and is closely identied with male drinking (Herlihy,
stress (2006:236). The connection between alcohol (particularly 2002; Transchel, 2006). However, we examined the frequency of
vodka) and poor health outcomes (across a wide range of indica- vodka consumption among females in these data and found its use
tors) among men in this part of the world has been well-estab- to be low. Results were not statistically signicant and, unlike beer
lished. However, Abbott et al. (2006) note that drinking was also and wine, are therefore not reported as a separate outcome. The
commonly reported among females in their qualitative study lack of signicant numbers of women vodka drinkers and statistical
samples, yet these behaviors are less well-understood. Alcohol use outcomes is interesting in itself and identies an important
has not affected female longevity to the same extent as it has mens, difference between men and women with respect to alcohol use.
but Shkolnikov et al. (2004:40) point out that mortality from liver Feelings of psychological distress were measured using a 12-item
cirrhosis and homicide has become increasingly common among distress scale, and this scale was arranged into a series of dummy
females types of mortality closely associated with heavy alcohol variables indicating the presence of (1) 02 symptoms, (2) 36
consumption (Pridemore, 2002). Accordingly, the analysis of female symptoms, (3) 79 symptoms, and (4) 1012 symptoms. Distress-
consumption patterns may yield some useful insights into the related symptoms are not simply discrete outcomes among indi-
nature of female lifestyle choices in the years following the collapse viduals; they are not something that are entirely present or
of the Soviet state. completely absent. Problems related to psychological distress range
on a continuum from quite minor to very severe, so it is important
Data and methods to use measures that are capable of measuring such a continuum of
distress, in contrast with the traditional diagnostic approach to
The data for this project come from the Living Conditions, mental health (Mirowsky & Ross, 2003). The measurement
Lifestyles, and Health (LLH) project, funded by the Copernicus instrument used in the current study is consistent with recent
Program of the European Union. This comprehensive survey recommendations for studying this phenomenon and exhibits
provides a snapshot of social life, health, and well-being in eight a high degree of reliability (Cronbachs alpha (a) 0.841). The scale
republics of the former Soviet Union. Data for this project are cross- used here is also supported in the literature by recent research in
sectional and were collected in November 2001. Interviews were Belarus, Russia, Kazakhstan, and Ukraine (Cockerham et al., 2006a)
conducted by respected survey research organizations in Armenia and offers a quite useful measure of psychological distress.
(State Engineering University of Armenia, Yerevan), Belarus (Center Communist political ideology was measured by asking respon-
for Sociological and Political Research, Belarusian State University, dents if they believed they would be better off under communism
Minsk), Georgia (Center for Social Studies, Tbilisi), Kazakhstan and wanted it restored. Responses included (1) agree, (2) partially
(Center for the Study of Public Opinion, Almaty), Kyrgyzstan agree, (3) dont know/neutral, (4) partially disagree, and (5)
(International Center of Sociological, Political, and Social-Psycho- disagree. We do not intend this variable to capture the structural
logical Research, Bishkek), Moldova (Independent Sociological and effects of political ideology; rather, this item indicates individual-
Information Service, Chisina u), Russia (Center for Sociological level afnity or support for communism and its underlying ideol-
Studies, Moscow State University), and Ukraine (East Ukrainian ogy, for any reason. It resembles similar measures employed in past
Foundation for Social Research, Kharkov). The survey consists of studies (Cockerham et al., 2002, 2006b). As one might suspect, the
representative national samples of the adult female population age distress and ideology predictors employed in this analysis are not
1258 B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262

completely unrelated. These variables are correlated in a way the association between these two variables, which is noted above.
suggesting that those female respondents agreeing with a return to The block of demographic covariates, including nationality, marital
Soviet communism tend to also report higher levels of psycholog- status, and social class variables, was entered into the regression
ical distress. This would seem to make sense in that respondents model initially, followed stepwise by the distress and ideology
favoring a restoration of previous structural arrangements report predictors at steps two and three, respectively. We utilize such
greater feelings of distress in their current situations. After all, a design in order to observe statistical correlations while control-
those favoring a return to Soviet-style communism may not be ling for other potentially confounding variables and also to examine
doing as well as other females in the post-communist period, thus any shifts or uctuations in adjusted odds ratios at each step of
manifesting higher distress levels, while the opposite is likely true analysis, if they exist. However, no signicant changes in these
among females that do not wish to return to communism. These coefcients emerged when distress and ideology predictors were
considerations are important in developing an appropriate entered, suggesting that distress and ideology effects are indeed
modeling strategy to test derived hypotheses, which are further independent, as hypothesized. As a result, only the completed
specied below. logistic regression model and coefcients are presented in Table 2.
Six demographic covariates derived from the relevant literature Table 1 reports descriptive statistics for the females included in this
were also employed in this analysis, measuring nationality, age, study, while adjusted odds ratios and 95% condence intervals are
marital status, income, education, and occupation. Age was measured reported and interpreted below.
by asking respondents their age at their last birthday and coded
into three categories: (1) ages 1834 years, (2) ages 3559 years, Results
and (3) ages 60 years and above. Nationality was measured by
asking what nationality respondents considered themselves. Descriptive statistics, reported in Table 1, show that the majority
Nationality responses were coded into a series of dummy variables, of females in this sample are of Russian, Ukrainian, or Armenian
including (1) Russian, (2) Armenian, (3) Belarusian, (4) Georgian, national background, with other national groups also represented
(5) Kazakh, (6) Kyrgyz, (7), Moldovan/Romanian, (8) Ukrainian, or in various proportions. The largest represented age group is the 35
(9) other nationality. Previous work by Cockerham (2005) suggests 59-year-old demographic, followed by younger women and then
the need to investigate the relationship between health lifestyles women over age 60 years, and the majority of these females report
and different ethnic groups and nationalities, as previous studies being married. Descriptive income data indicate that most females
have tended to focus on overall health proles and nations rather report having just enough money for food and clothes, with the
than specic health lifestyle patterns common to particular second most frequently reported category reecting not even
national groups. having enough money for nutritional needs. Indeed, nancial
Marital status is measured in a dichotomous format, whether resources in the form of income appear to be low among this
respondents are (1) married, or (2) single, divorced, or widowed. sample of women. Most of this sample possesses a secondary
Income is measured as the level of material living conditions of the education or higher, and occupying a relatively wide range of
respondents family, as reported by the respondent, whether their occupational categories, but very few of these females report
income (1) is not enough for nutrition, (2) is just enough for food/ employment as senior ofcials or top managers. Symptoms of
clothes, (3) is enough to purchase major consumer goods (televi- psychological distress appear skewed toward the lower end of this
sion, refrigerator) but not enough to buy a car or a at, or they (4) distribution of scores, with most females self-reporting between
can purchase expensive goods (car, at). zero and six distress symptoms, while females reporting either
Education is measured using the following coding scheme: (1) agreeing or disagreeing with a restoration of the communist system
primary or without education, (2) unnished secondary education, appear about equally represented in this sample. Finally, between
(3) secondary vocational education (medical, technical, pedagog- 9% and 12% of females responding to items regarding alcohol report
ical, etc.), (4) unnished higher education, or (5) higher education. consumption of at least once per week or more frequently,
Finally, occupation is categorized as: (1) agricultural/unskilled depending on the type of beverage.
worker, (2) skilled worker, (3) ofce clerk without higher educa- The completed analysis shows that Russian females consume
tion, (4) public service employee, (5) manager/professional, (6) alcohol more frequently than non-Russians in these eight
senior ofcial/top manager, or (7) other/none. republics, with the exception of Moldovans (Table 2). Younger
To assess the relationships between psychological distress, females consume alcohol more frequently than older women, and
political ideology, and alcohol consumption, we employ a series of the married imbibe less frequently than unmarried, divorced, or
multivariate logistic regression analyses to test the following widowed respondents. Results for income indicate a positive
hypotheses, which have been developed above but are rened socioeconomic gradient in general alcohol consumption, with
here: women in the highest two income categories drinking most
frequently. The association between psychological distress and
H1: Controlling for the effects of political ideology, higher levels general alcohol consumption is modest, with females that report
of psychological distress are positively associated with frequent moderate levels of psychological distress (36 symptoms) drinking
alcohol consumption. more often than females reporting fewer symptoms. Women
reporting distress at the highest levels of measurement do not
H2: Controlling for the effects of psychological distress, favoring appear to drink more frequently than women reporting very few or
a return to Soviet communism is positively associated with no symptoms, indicating very little support for our rst hypothesis
frequent alcohol consumption. when controlling for demographic covariates and political ideology.
In other words, psychological distress does not appear strongly
We hypothesize independent and measurable effects for associated with the frequent drinking outcomes analyzed here. Yet,
distress and ideology on frequent drinking behavior, and we women who do not favor returning to Soviet communism are more
employ a stepwise logistic regression design in order to ensure that likely to report frequently consuming alcohol in general than those
independent effects are indeed being tested. Distress and ideology females that are neutral on this item, seemingly contradicting our
predictors are included in the same statistical model in order to second hypothesis. This is a surprising and interesting nding. In
control for any potentially confounding inuence stemming from the years following the collapse of the communist system, younger
B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262 1259

Table 1 working class appear to consume beer more frequently than agri-
Sample descriptives for health lifestyles, political ideology, psychological distress, cultural or unskilled workers and managers or professionals. As for
and sociodemographic covariates females (n 10,454)
political ideology, Table 2 shows that female respondents opposing
Variable n Valid % a return to Soviet-style communism are signicantly more likely to
Nationality report frequent consumption of beer. In addition, those reporting
Russian 3072 29.6 a partial agreement to returning to communism prior to the collapse
Armenian 1234 11.9
appear signicantly less likely to consume beer frequently. Conse-
Belarusian 930 9.0
Georgian 978 9.4 quently, it appears that older women are less likely to frequently
Kazakh 385 3.7 consume this beverage, while younger women opposed to commu-
Kyrgyz 705 6.8 nism returning are signicantly more likely to do so.
Moldovan/Romanian 855 8.2 Results for frequent wine consumption are also reported in
Ukrainian 1424 13.7
Other 799 7.7
Table 2. Contrasting with other results reported here, Belarusian,
Georgian, Moldovan, and Ukrainian females are signicantly more
Age (years)
likely than Russian women to report consuming wine once per
1834 3025 28.9
3559 4635 44.3 week or more frequently. Frequent wine consumption also appears
60 2794 26.7 to be more evenly distributed across age groups than general
alcohol or beer consumption, with no statistically discernible
Marital status
Single, divorced, widowed 4353 41.9 differences among age categories. Marital status effects also
Married 6033 58.1 disappear, while the positive gradient association with income
Income
persists. Frequent wine consumption also appears more probable
Not even enough for nutrition 2639 25.2 among females of the unskilled or agricultural working class with
Just enough for food/clothes 6213 59.4 lower levels of education. Finally, the consistent ideology effects
Enough to but TV/fridge but not car/at 1224 11.7 emerge once again for frequent wine consumption, with respon-
Can purchase expensive goods 177 1.7
dents opposing a return to Soviet communism increasingly likely to
Education imbibe more often. In summary, we nd very modest support for
None/primary/unnished secondary 1775 17.0 the hypothesized positive association between psychological
Secondary education 2724 26.1
Secondary vocational 3203 30.6
distress and frequent drinking, while ndings surprisingly contra-
Unnished higher 525 5.0 dict the hypothesized association between favoring a return to
Higher education 2172 20.8 Soviet communism and drinking behavior. Despite the relevant
Occupation studies to support the formulation of hypothesis two and statisti-
Armed force/public service 66 0.6 cally controlling for possible confounding variables, the statistical
Agricultural/unskilled worker 2160 20.7 results for political ideology are consistent across all dependent
Skilled worker 1760 16.8 measures. This latter nding is an unexpected one, but it none-
Ofce clerk w/o higher education 1443 13.8
theless uncovers a very interesting and important dynamic likely
Manager/professional 2457 23.5
Senior ofcial/top manager 177 1.7 operating among the females included in this study.
Other/none 2391 22.9

Psychological distress
Discussion
02 symptoms 2488 31.3
36 symptoms 2969 37.4 From the historical and sociological contexts discussed above,
79 symptoms 1537 19.3 we formulate and carry out this analysis in order to identify
1012 symptoms 952 12.0
statistically signicant correlations between psychological distress
Communist political ideology and ideology on one hand, and frequent drinking outcomes on the
Disagree 2670 25.5 other. Our ndings suggest that distress is only weakly associated
Partially disagree 1516 14.5
Dont know/neutral 2073 19.8
with frequent drinking behavior among females in these eight
Partially agree 1586 15.2 republics. However, ndings for ideology indicate that this factor is
Agree 2609 25.0 associated with frequent drinking behaviors among the females in
Drinking frequency general this study. Consistently throughout this analysis, females reporting
Less than once per week 9222 88.2 that they do not favor a return to Soviet-style communism exhibit
Once per week or more frequently 1228 11.8 an increased likelihood of frequently drinking alcohol, regardless of
Drinking frequency beer type. These data offer some interesting insights into the nature and
Less than once per week 5470 88.9 patterns of female consumption following the Soviet collapse.
Once per week or more frequently 683 11.1 Drinking was not a particularly common behavior for females
Drinking frequency wine under Soviet communism, as previously cited evidence indicates,
Less than once per week 5574 90.6 but existing research also suggests that consumption trends among
Once per week or more frequently 580 9.4 women have been changing over the past two decades or more.
In summarizing their own qualitative data from the former
women may feel there is a more permissive environment in which USSR, Abbott et al. (2006:236) note that the majority of our male
to consume alcohol. informants smoked and drank, and while few of the women
Results for beer consumption point to Russian females as more smoked, they did drink alcohol. While types of alcohol involved
frequent drinkers, compared with other nationalities in this study. are not mentioned, these ndings are noteworthy because they
Again, younger respondents appear to drink more frequently than suggest that women are drinking more alcohol in the republics of
those in middle and upper age groups, while married respondents the former Soviet Union. That is, while drinking did not constitute
report less frequent consumption when it comes to beer. Females in appropriately feminine behavior under the ideology of Soviet
the highest income groups report more frequent beer consumption communism, females are now apparently more able to embrace
than those in the lowest income category, while females of the skilled these behavioral practices, if they wish to do so. With the collapse,
1260 B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262

Table 2
Odds ratios (OR) and 95% condence intervals (CI) for alcohol consumption among females

Drinking frequency general Drinking frequency beer Drinking frequency wine

OR 95% CI OR 95% CI OR 95% CI


Nationality
Russian Ref. Ref. Ref.
Armenian 0.337 0.2410.472*** 0.275 0.1620.467*** 1.339 0.8332.150
Belarusian 1.093 0.8601.387 0.992 0.7381.334 2.070 1.4372.981***
Georgian 0.218 0.1380.345*** 0.831 0.4931.402 2.790 1.6284.782***
Kazakh 0.525 0.3520.784** 0.242 0.1200.485*** 0.954 0.4831.883
Kyrgyz 0.144 0.0840.246*** 0.243 0.1240.475*** 0.170 0.0410.700*
Moldovan/Romanian 1.638 1.2802.095*** 0.339 0.2060.557*** 7.692 5.57010.622***
Ukrainian 0.997 0.8021.240 0.938 0.7111.236 1.804 1.2752.552***
Other 0.561 0.4170.755*** 0.755 0.5141.107 1.570 0.9922.486

Age (years)
1834 Ref. Ref. Ref.
3559 0.612 0.5190.722*** 0.394 0.3180.487*** 1.081 0.8381.394
60 0.208 0.1560.278*** 0.099 0.0560.176*** 0.802 0.5441.183

Marital status
Unmarried, divorced, widowed Ref. Ref. Ref.
Married 0.836 0.7180.975* 0.805 0.6580.984* 0.905 0.7201.137

Income
Not enough for nutrition Ref. Ref. Ref.
Just enough for food/clothes 1.216 0.9841.502 1.154 0.8421.580 1.133 0.8381.532
Enough to buy TV/fridge but not car/at 2.347 1.8123.040*** 2.029 1.4222.897*** 2.159 1.4783.154***
Can purchase expensive goods 2.630 1.6694.145*** 1.871 1.0393.370* 2.589 1.3554.947**

Education
None/primary/unnished second. 1.116 0.8241.511 0.762 0.4401.320 1.597 1.0492.430*
Secondary education Ref. Ref. Ref.
Secondary vocational education 0.934 0.7621.146 1.109 0.8581.434 1.074 0.7871.466
Unnished higher education 1.330 0.9761.812 1.067 0.7321.454 1.353 0.8622.125
Higher education 1.164 0.9311.454 0.983 0.7321.319 0.940 0.6751.309

Occupation
Public service 1.004 0.4272.361 1.714 0.7174.097 0.478 0.0633.622
Agricultural/unskilled worker 1.045 0.8101.349 0.571 0.3910.834** 1.821 1.2442.666**
Skilled worker Ref. Ref. Ref.
Ofce clerk w/o higher education 1.115 0.8691.430 0.879 0.6491.191 1.360 0.9002.057
Manager/professional 0.926 0.7181.193 0.669 0.4820.930* 1.454 0.9852.147
Senior ofcial/top manager 1.197 0.7211.987 0.774 0.3901.535 1.680 0.7703.668
Other/none 0.768 0.5900.998* 0.781 0.5671.077 1.296 0.8541.967

Psychological distress
02 symptoms Ref. Ref. Ref.
36 symptoms 1.226 1.0321.456* 1.019 0.8181.270 1.049 0.8181.345
79 symptoms 1.186 0.9511.479 1.140 0.8541.522 0.907 0.6521.262
1012 symptoms 1.157 0.8661.547 0.700 0.4391.116 0.826 0.5341.276

Communism
Disagree 1.406 1.1381.738** 1.327 1.0091.744* 1.642 1.1922.262**
Partially disagree 0.947 0.7371.216 0.889 0.6431.230 1.094 0.7421.612
Neutral Ref. Ref. Ref.
Partially agree 0.783 0.5961.028 0.602 0.4080.888* 0.914 0.6101.371
Agree 0.913 0.7061.180 0.881 0.6121.270 1.352 0.9291.967

Pseudo-R2 0.160 0.182 0.139

*p  0.05; **p  0.01; ***p  0.001.

many, often younger, females may be adopting these behaviors modernity, where consumption patterns increasingly become
either as a personal statement against a formerly masculine- salient markers related to social identity. As one form of
dominated social system or against the traditionalist Soviet order, consumption, lifestyle choices, including whether or not to drink
or as a way of exercising agency or individual choice in an alcohol, are one way that females may participate in the ongoing
increasingly uncertain time. construction and maintenance of self-identity in these republics.
This interpretation is consistent with research conducted by Our ndings are perhaps further elucidated by other existing
Gilmore and McKee (2005), noting that smoking American ciga- research as well. Karen Van Gundy et al. (2005) examine gender
rettes has been viewed as a symbol of status, used to display a sense role orientations and alcohol use among Toronto and Moscow men
of individuality and personal freedom that directly contradicts the and women. They highlight sex differences in consumption
tenets of Soviet communism. This type of dynamic appears patterns and also discuss the various ways that masculine and
particularly relevant to females, where women may be engaging in feminine gender roles inuence drinking behaviors in these pop-
traditionally un-feminine behaviors like drinking and smoking as ulations. Van Gundy et al. (2005:2326) go on to note that increases
a way to assert a sense of individuality in the post-Soviet period. in alcohol use among women in the Moscow sample may be related
Contemporary social theorists like Bauman (2000), Beck (1992), to a tendency to reject Soviet ideals and/or embrace increasingly
and Giddens (1991) describe the emergence of new forms of individualist values. Discussion of their ndings also emphasizes
B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262 1261

the fact that such a distinct break from tradition is particularly Limitations
meaningful for women and very different from such a break among
men. Further, because behavioral proscriptions and forces related The current analysis is not without limitations, however.
to gender socialization have encouraged abstention from alcohol, First, alcohol consumption is one behavior that may often go
the adoption of these individualist values may free them to underreported among many survey respondents, so self-reported
consume alcohol in rejection of conventional drinking norms. data such as these may represent conservative estimates of
These interpretations support our ndings, despite the fact that we drinking patterns among women included in this sample. Heavy
are testing quite different ideas than the earlier study. alcohol use may sometimes serve to conceal levels of self-reported
More generally speaking, lifestyle choices are also ways that distress as well. In addition, factors relating to political ideology are
individuals can exercise some semblance of agency when many often difcult to accurately measure and interpret, but considering
events and forces seem beyond their control. This may be partic- that our instrument is supported in the existing research literature
ularly true in the years following the collapse of the Soviet Union. (Cockerham et al., 2002, 2006b), we are condent that our
Further supporting these conclusions are statistical results showing measures are valid, especially when controlling for potentially
that drinking practices are associated with increasing levels of confounding variables such as age and socioeconomic standing as
disposable income among females. Evidence appears to support the well as psychological distress. It should also be noted that these
connections between material consumption and lifestyle practices data are cross-sectional, so it is therefore impossible to make any
when it comes to drinking among women. In other words, drinking distinct attributions of causality, which we have been cautious to
itself may be conceptualized as one form of consumption that avoid. While more a methodological decision than a limitation, our
serves as a social marker signifying individuality or as an assertion choice to analyze pooled data from these eight republics may serve
of self-identity as part of a younger, post-communist cohort of to mask within-country correlations, but with our ndings we
citizens. It is also important to remember that consumption effects nonetheless highlight and discuss some important statistical
related to income persist even while accounting for the potential associations across these regions, thus making a contribution to the
inuence of other related or intervening variables. existing body of literature. Finally, this study involves only indi-
Still, it is somewhat misleading to claim that all elements of the vidual-level data, which effectively precludes any direct observa-
Soviet order have been either rejected outright or completely tion of the effects of any structural or contextual inuences on
eradicated when it comes to females and lifestyle choices, as drinking behavior. Predictors of this type are arguably important to
ndings for age and marital status seem to suggest that some consider, and future studies should strive to incorporate hierar-
vestiges of Soviet society likely remain intact. These data show that chical, nested data to examine associations at multiple levels of
married women of middle or older age groups are signicantly less analysis.
likely to report consuming alcohol (and specically, beer) on a more
or less regular basis. These data may be interpreted in a way that Conclusion
continues to reect the positions, identities, and roles of many
women in post-Soviet societies. As noted above, females have Our results indicate that political ideology is associated with
historically been the center of the domestic sphere, responsible for female drinking behaviors in the eight republics included in this
keeping the household running, while males have traditionally study. These conclusions are interesting contributions to the liter-
occupied the dominant breadwinner roles, despite the fact that ature on post-Soviet health lifestyles but also to the study of female
both males and females have historically represented important drinking behavior in these republics. Incidentally, our discussion
and equally sizable parts of the Soviet workforce (Ashwin, 2000; may have something to say about future trends as well. Recent data
Ashwin & Lytkina, 2004). Accordingly, it may be the case that older, (WHO, 2007) and the implications of our results point to the fact
married females are still somewhat bound to the operations of the that alcohol consumption among younger females may signal
household through their identities as wives and/or mothers coming increases in alcohol-related morbidity and mortality
(identities lauded by the Soviet state), so that less time is available among these demographic groups. However, women in this region
for extra-household activities time perhaps spent socializing or have escaped the high mortality levels of men thus far, so perhaps
having a drink with friends or relatives. Again, these processes may they will continue to do so. Female drinking is characterized
deprive females, both now and historically, of one socially accept- primarily by beer and wine consumption, rather than the harmful
able way to alleviate stress or to escape from the repetition of binge consumption of vodka that often characterizes male drinking.
everyday life, thus contributing to the higher distress levels that Yet, the overall stagnation in female life expectancy statistics may
may be discerned among post-Soviet females generally. indicate a delicate balance of factors that increasingly unhealthy
Finally, ndings for nationality show that this concept is an lifestyle patterns may disturb. Dynamics related to such factors
important way to differentiate lifestyle choices, supporting Cock- need to be investigated in future research.
erhams (2005) assertion that nationality and ethnicity are impor- There are also broader implications for this research as well. As
tant elements of lifestyle formulation and reproduction. This is an other authors (Van Gundy et al., 2005) have noted previously, the
integral element of this analysis and as far as we are aware, this is continued development of Western values and ideals in the former
the only lifestyle study conducted thus far to consider nationality so USSR may affect the health of both men and women in distinct
extensively. Russian females appear to favor beer and other sources ways. Practitioners and researchers alike must address these effects
of alcohol other than wine when they choose to drink more or less in the coming years and decades. Alcohol consumption is deeply
frequently. The frequent consumption of wine, on the other hand, is embedded in history and society across many parts of the former
most common among Belarusian and Ukrainian, and perhaps not Soviet Union, and lifestyle decisions involving alcohol are not likely
unexpectedly, Georgian and Moldovan women (Georgia is a wine- to disappear among populations in these regions, especially those
producing region). It is also important to remember that these groups and areas with traditionally high rates and harmful
differences refer to national and ethnic groups as a whole, consumption patterns. Although the quantities and patterns of
regardless of country of residence, although we acknowledge consumption are very different among males and females in many
signicant, yet far from perfect, overlap between these variables. republics, recent increases in drinking, along with the implications
So, this analysis attempts to grasp ethnic and cultural differences of the relationships identied here and elsewhere, may put some
independent of current country of residence. female populations at especially high risk of developing future
1262 B.P. Hinote et al. / Social Science & Medicine 68 (2009) 12541262

health problems. Potential interventions targeting harmful Herlihy, P. (2002). The alcoholic empire: Vodka and politics in late imperial Russia.
Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
drinking patterns and their deleterious effects should arguably
Issoupova. (2000). From duty to pleasure? Motherhood in Soviet and post-Soviet
consider the social inuences discussed in this study and others. Russia. In S. Ashwin (Ed.), Gender, state and society in Soviet and post-Soviet
Social, political, and ideological inuences are indeed important Russia (pp. 3054). New York: Routledge.
factors to consider in examining alcohol-related outcomes in these Kiblitskaya. (2000a). Russias female breadwinners: the changing subjective expe-
rience. In S. Ashwin (Ed.), Gender, state and society in soviet and post-Soviet
regions factors that help construct a more complete theoretical Russia (pp. 5570). New York: Routledge.
picture of lifestyles and the health crisis in the former Soviet Union. Kiblitskaya. (2000b). Once we were kings: male experiences of loss of status at
work in post-communist Russia. In S. Ashwin (Ed.), Gender, state and society in
Soviet and post-Soviet Russia (pp. 90104). New York: Routledge.
References Kukhterin. (2000). Fathers and patriarchs in communist and post-communist
Russia. In S. Ashwin (Ed.), Gender, state and society in Soviet and post-Soviet
Abbott, P. (2002). Living conditions, lifestyles, and health in Armenia, Belarus, Georgia, Russia (pp. 7189). New York: Routledge.
Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Russia & Ukraine: Social trends 19902002. Leon, D., & Shkolnikov, V. (1998). Social stress and the Russian mortality crisis.
Vienna, Austria: Institute for Social Research. Journal of the American Medical Association, 279, 790791.
Abbott, P., Turmov, S., & Wallace, C. (2006). Health world views of post-Soviet Malia, M. (1994). The Soviet tragedy: A history of socialism in Russia, 19171991. New
citizens. Social Science & Medicine, 62, 228238. York: Free Press.
Ashwin, S. (2000). Gender, state and society in Soviet and post-Soviet Russia. In Marmot, M., Siegrist, J., Theorell, T., & Feeney, A. (2001). Health and the psychosocial
S. Ashwin (Ed.), Gender, state and society in Soviet and post-Soviet Russia (pp. 1 environment at work. In M. Marmot, & R. Wilkinson (Eds.), Social determinants
29). New York: Routledge. of health (pp. 105131). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Ashwin, S., & Lytkina, T. (2004). Men in crisis in Russia: the role of domestic Marx, K., & Engels, F. (1976). The German ideology. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
marginalization. Gender & Society, 18, 189206. Mechanic, D., & Hansell, S. (1987). Adolescent competence, psychological well-
Bauman, Z. (2000). Liquid modernity. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press. being, and self-assessed physical health. Journal of Health and Social Behavior,
Beck, U. (1992). Risk society: Towards a new modernity. [Translated by Mark Ritter]. 28, 364374.
London: Sage. Mirowsky, J., & Ross, C. (2003). Social causes of psychological distress. Hawthorne,
Blum, A., & Monnier, A. (1989). Recent mortality trends in the USSR: new evidence. NY: Aldine de Gruyter.
Population Studies, 43, 211241. Nemtsov, A. (2005). Russia: alcohol yesterday and today. Addiction, 100, 146149.
Boardman, J., Finch, B., Ellison, C., Williams, D., & Jackson, J. (2001). Neighborhood Palosuo, H. (2000). Health-related lifestyles and alienation in Moscow and Helsinki.
disadvantage, stress, and drug use among adults. Journal of Health and Social Social Science & Medicine, 51, 13251341.
Behavior, 42, 151165. Palosuo, H. (2003). Health and well-being in Moscow and Helsinki. Helsinki, Finland:
Bobak, M., Pikhart, H., Hertzman, C., Rose, R., & Marmot, M. (1998). Socioeconomic STAKES.
factors, perceived control and self-rated health in Russia: a cross-sectional Palosuo, H., Uutele, A., Zhuravleva, I., & Lakomova, N. (1998). Social patterning of ill
survey. Social Science & Medicine, 47, 269279. health in Helsinki and Moscow: results from a comparative survey in 1991.
Brunner, E., & Marmot, M. (2001). Social organization, stress, and health. In Social Science & Medicine, 46, 11211136.
M. Marmot, & R. Wilkinson (Eds.), Social determinants of health (pp. 1743). Pietila, I., & Rytkonen, M. (2008). Coping with stress and by stress: Russian men and
Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. women talking about transition, stress and health. Social Science & Medicine, 66,
Cockerham, W. (1999). Health and social change in Russia and Eastern Europe. New 327338.
York: Routledge. Pomerleau, J., Gilmore, A., McKee, M., Rose, R., & Haerpfer, C. (2004). Determinants
Cockerham, W. (2000). Health lifestyles in Russia. Social Science & Medicine, 51, of smoking in eight countries of the former Soviet Union: results from the
13131324. Living Conditions, Lifestyles and Health study. Addiction, 99, 15771585.
Cockerham, W. (2005). Health lifestyle theory and the convergence of agency and Pridemore, W. (2002). Vodka and violence: alcohol consumption and homicide
structure. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 46, 5167. rates in Russia. American Journal of Public Health, 92, 19211930.
Cockerham, W. (2007). Health lifestyles and the absence of the Russian middle Pridemore, W. (2006). Heavy drinking and suicide in Russia. Social Forces, 85, 413430.
class. Sociology of Health & Illness, 29, 457473. Ross, C., & Bird, C. (1994). Sex stratication and health lifestyle: consequences for mens
Cockerham, W., Snead, M., & DeWaal, D. (2002). Health lifestyles in Russia and the and womens perceived health. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 35, 161178.
socialist heritage. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 43, 4255. Shkolnikov, V., Andreev, E., Leon, D., McKee, M., Mesle, F., & Vallin, J. (2004).
Cockerham, W., Hinote, B., & Abbott, P. (2006a). Psychological distress, gender, and Mortality reversal in Russia: the story so far. Hygiea Internationalis, 4, 2980.
health lifestyles in Belarus, Kazakhstan, Russia, and Ukraine. Social Science & Shkolnikov, V., Field, M., & Andreev, E. (2001). Russia: socio-economic dimensions
Medicine, 62, 23812394. of the gender gap in mortality. In T. Evans, M. Whitehead, F. Diderichsen, &
Cockerham, W., Hinote, B., Abbott, P., & Cockerham, G. (2006b). Health lifestyles and A. Bhuiya (Eds.), Challenging inequities in health: From ethics to action. Oxford,
political ideology in Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine. Social Science & Medicine, 62, UK: Oxford University Press.
17991809. Stansfeld, S. (2001). Social support and social cohesion. In M. Marmot, &
Cockerham, W., Hinote, B., Abbott, P., & Haerpfer, C. (2004). Health lifestyles in R. Wilkinson (Eds.), Social determinants of health (pp. 155178). Oxford, UK:
central Asia: the case of Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. Social Science & Medicine, Oxford University Press.
59, 14091421. Transchel, K. (2006). Under the inuence: Working-class drinking, temperance, and cultural
Giddens, A. (1991). Modernity and self-identity: Self and society in the late modern revolution in Russia, 18951932. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
age. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Umberson, D., Williams, K., & Anderson, K. (2002). Violent behavior: a measure of
Gilmore, A., & McKee, M. (2005). How the East was won: BAT and big tobaccos emotional upset? Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 43, 189206.
conquest of the former Soviet Union. Multinational Monitor, 26, 915. Van Gundy, K., Schieman, S., Kelley, M., & Rebellon, C. (2005). Gender role orien-
Gilmore, A., McKee, M., & Rose, R. (2002). Determinants of and inequalities in self- tations and alcohol use among Moscow and Toronto adults. Social Science &
perceived health in Ukraine. Social Science & Medicine, 55, 21772188. Medicine, 61, 23172330.
Glickman, R. (1984). Russian factory women: Workplace and society, 18801914. White, S. (1996). Russia goes dry: Alcohol, state and society. Cambridge, UK: Cam-
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. bridge University Press.
Goskomstat. (2007). The Demographic Yearbook of Russia. Moscow: State Committee World Health Organization. (2007). World health report 2007: Working together for
of the Russian Federation on Statistics. health. Geneva, Switzerland: WHO.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen