Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
INTRODUCTION
1
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil
2
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil
3
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil
4
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil
5
Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais, Brazil
1-4 December 2015
conception of land and resources use, which may pose a real threat to the populations food
security and to the protection and maintenance of adequate and good quality water sources.
Those competing land uses are a permanent challenge to planning and public policies.
The paper is organized as follows: the next section contains a brief discussion of the
main concepts related to urban agriculture and its practitionners. The following section
discusses the metropolitan planning experience of the Metropolitan Region of Belo Horizonte, in
which the protection of catchments and water sources, associated to the productive (mainly
agricultural) uses of land are seen as important elements for achieving social and environmental
sustainability. The next evaluates the extent to which conventional agricultural practices can
pose a real threat to the availability of good quality water sources and for food security. After
that the paper highlights some of research results related to the identification and
characterization of non-conventional agricultural practices in the metropolitan region. Finally
some final remarks constitute an attempt to sum up the discussion and point out new research
possibilities.
legislation. The establishment of the AIMs and of the Metropolitan Interest Zones (ZIM) were
motivated by some specific feature of the areas, whenever they were recognized as a
metropolitan asset, that is, whenever their metropolitan value or function encompassed a larger
area or population, which meant that the metropolitan interest surpassed the strictly local value
or interest. The Macrozonig established several ZIMs related to important metropolitan water
sources, clearly an asset of metropolitan importance, and their catchment areas. The map in the
following pages illustrates the location of the AIMs related to the development and incentive of
rural/agricultural activities, and the ZIMs associated to water sources.
The identification of areas of rural/agricultural interest through the MZ process was
complemented by a second important source: a work-in-process project carried out by AU
Urban Agriculture Studies Group, formed in UFMG, and to which the authors also belong: the
mapping and characterization of agricultural practices and experiences in the municipalities of
the RMBH, also shown in the above mentioned map. Two distinct and complementary
perspectives could be highlighted from those studies.
The first one refers to food security. Sectoral studies carried out for the PDDI-RMBH
emphasized the conditions of food insecurity present in RMBH, expressed by the huge budget
commitment of low-income families with food; overweight and obesity; and the lack of policies to
support family farming food production. Therefore the maintenance and encouragement of agri-
food production spaces performed on a sustainable basis were acknowledged by the
metropolitan plan as a public function of common interest aiming at ensuring food security for
the population (UFMG, 2011).
The second perspective refers to the containment of urban sprawl and sustainable use
of the land. In general, public discussion at the workshops reinforced a need for maintenance of
rural areas and of vacant landed property for food production. Extensive mining and urban
expansion through new land developments were perceived as a real threat to the maintenance
of water protection areas and of rural activities therefore should be contained in the
Macrozoning proposal. Another related threat is the tendency of some municipalities to extend
their urban boundaries (urban perimeter) thus allowing larger areas for urban expansion. On the
other hand agricultural land use in the region was often associated with the preservation of
green areas and unbuilt spaces, both in rural and in urban areas.
From the viewpoint of environmental protection and development, ecological agriculture
was defined as one of the activities or land uses considered of great importance for the gradual
construction of a Trama Verde e Azul (TVA - Green-Blue Network), a new element in the
territorial restructuring of the MRBH, which proposes to connect a network of green areas, water
courses, road system, cultural and leisure activities in different scales. Agricultural land use
improves soil permeability, protects water sources and river banks through the cultivation and
management of local flora species; reduces runoff volumes through infiltration of rainwater. In
that sense agriculture helps to maintain and produce water.
The final results of the Metropolitan Macrozoning point to advances in the
understanding of the multiple ways in which agroecology and urban agriculture are related to
the metropolitan territorial restructuring. The ecological proposal principles indicated that the
common view that agricultural activities necessarily cause negative environmental impacts,
does not take into account the contrast between different paradigms of agriculture production
currently in dispute in Brazil. Agroecological practices present in the MRBH and the research
trajectory and social organization of the ecological field in Brazil offers the possibility of
incorporating ecological and socio-cultural perspective on food production, such as the
integration with nature cycles and environmental protection; achieving decent and fair work
conditions in the production process; adopting cooperative relationships with consumers; and
1-4 December 2015
making the local/regional economy more dynamic. On the other hand, the preliminary results of
the mapping of agricultural practices and experiences carried out by AU showed that there is
huge heterogeneity of old and new agricultural practices in the metropolitan municipalities.
Despite the richness of the debates during the planning process, the agricultural land
use and the protection of rural areas was not the main justification for any of the 19 ZIMs
proposed in the MZ. However, the maintenance of rurality was an important concern to guide
the delimitation of perimeters and zoning of most ZIMs. These results reaffirm that agricultural
activity in metropolitan areas occurs in different scales; extrapolates the administrative
definitions of both rural and urban areas; and can coexist with land uses often seen as
antagonic.
From those brief examples, it seems clear that the current pattern of food production in
the Metropolitan Region of Belo Horizonte in several areas has many potential impacts on the
sustainability of water production to the whole region. Since the major part of this agricultural
production is conventional with intensive use of pesticides its relationships with the most
important water sources require careful thought.
Based on an ongoing research by AU, the urban agriculture study group of UFMG,
several non-conventional experiences and practices are being registered and analysed as far
as some variables are concerned, such as number of participants, location, size of property,
land ownership relation, type of work, type of space used, technology, level of organization of
producers, destination of production among other. The map that follows presents the location of
the experiences and practices, pointing so far to areas of concentration of them.
In the northern region, for example, there are several communities of agroecological
family farmers commercializing their products in local markets, as the Feira Razes do Campo in
Jaboticatuba. In other municipalities, as mentioned previously, farmers produce the
conventional way using chemicals and commercializing through distribution centres, such as in
Baldim. In the Northwest the municipality of Capim Branco is reference in the production on
organic food, now known as "the organic city". In the South the municipalities of Rio Acima,
Nova Lima and Raposos became important for honey production, small-scale fruit production,
and family and agroecological backgardens.
The municipalities of Ibirit, Betim, Sarzedo, Mario Campos, So Joaquim de Bicas,
Igarap and Brumadinho integrate a southwestern metropolitan greenbelt, producing fruits and
vegetables distributed by supply centers. Those are conventional agricultural production and the
consequences for the contamination of the water sources and reservoirs require huge
investments in terms an ecological transition.
1-4 December 2015
Matozinhos; 22- Nova Lima; 23- Pedro Leopoldo; 24- Raposos; 25- Ribeiro das Neves; 26- Rio Acima;
27- Rio Manso; 28- Sabar; 29- Santa Luzia; 30- So Joaquim de Bicas; 31- So Jos da Lapa; 32-
Sarzedo; 33- Taquarau de Minas; 34- Vespasiano.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
The paper attempted to establish some links between planning and the dispute over
metropolitan land for different uses, particularly emphasizing the protection of water sources as
a common environmental asset and for metropolitan supply. It reinforces the role of planning
tools at metropolitan level to encourage solidarity among local interests instead of competition.
The arguments highlighted the importance of economic, social, and cultural use of
urban land for the improvement of the environmental quality of cities and the maintenance of
urban biodiversity related to urban agriculture and the production and maintenance of water.
Such approach contributes to surpass the dichotomist views that oppose the natural
environment and the metropolis, aiming towards new convergent approaches of sustainability
and urbanity. Metropolitan planning proposals developed by the group, tend to reinforce
alternative uses of land and water, as an attempt to bring nature to urbanization, and people
and social, economic and cultural activities to high environmental quality areas.
REFERENCES
ALMEIDA, D.A.O. Agricultura urbana: isto e aquilo. In: COSTA, G.M.; COSTA, H.S.M.;
MONTE-MR, R.L.M. (orgs.). Teorias e prticas urbanas: condies para a sociedade urbana.
Belo Horizonte: C/Arte, 2015.
ALMEIDA, D.A.O.; MELGAO, L. Agroecologia, agricultura urbana e planejamento
metropolitano: conexes possveis para uma reestruturao territorial da RMBH. Cadernos de
Agroecologia, v. 10, n. 3, Out 2015.
LEFEBVRE, H. A revoluo urbana. Belo Horizonte: Ed. UFMG, 2008.
MOUGEOT, L.J.A. Urban agriculture: Definition, presence, potential and risks. In:
BAKKER, N. et al (eds). Growing cities, growing food: Urban agriculture on the policy agenda. A
reader on urban agriculture. Feldafing: German Foundation for International Development,
2000.
SANTANDREU, A.; LOVO, I. Panorama da agricultura urbana e periurbana no Brasil e
diretrizes polticas para sua promoo: identificao e caracterizao de iniciativas de
agricultura urbana e periurbana em regies metropolitanas brasileiras. 2007.
SMIT, J.; RATTA, A.; NASR, J. Urban agriculture: food, jobs and sustainable cities.
Publication Series for Habitat II, Vol. I. Nova York: PNUD, 1996.
TUPY, I. S.; ALMEIDA, D.A.O.; MELGAO, L. Notas sobre a produo agrcola na
Regio Metropolitana de Belo Horizonte: para alm da irrelevncia, inviabilidade e
incompatibilidade Cadernos de Agroecologia, v. 10, n. 3, Out 2015.
UFMG. Plano Metropolitano. Macrozoneamento RMBH. Belo Horizonte: UFMG, 2015.
UFMG/Pucminas/UEMG. Plano Diretor de Desenvolvimento Integrado da Regio
Metropolitana de Belo Horizonte. Belo Horizonte: UFMG, 2011.