Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
BatteryUniversity
WhatstheBestBattery?
Weoftengetpuzzledbyannouncementsofnewbatteriesthataresaidtoofferveryhighenergydensities,deliver1000charge/dischargecycleandare
paperthin.Aretheyreal?Perhapsbutnotinoneandthesamebattery.Whileonebatterytypemaybedesignedforsmallsizeandlongruntime,this
packwillnotlastandwearoutprematurely.Anotherbatterymaybebuiltforlonglife,butthesizeisbigandbulky.Athirdbatterymayprovideallthe
desirableattributes,butthepricewouldbetoohighforcommercialuse.
Batterymanufacturersarewellawareofcustomerneedsandhaverespondedbyofferingpacksthatbestsuitthespecificapplications.Themobilephone
industryisanexampleofcleveradaptation.Emphasisisplacedonsmallsize,highenergydensityandlowprice.Longevitycomesinsecond.
TheinscriptionofNiMHonabatterypackdoesnotautomaticallyguaranteehighenergydensity.AprismaticNickelMetalHydridebatteryforamobile
phone,forexample,ismadeforslimgeometry.Suchapackprovidesanenergydensityofabout60Wh/kgandthecyclecountisaround300.In
comparison,acylindricalNiMHoffersenergydensitiesof80Wh/kgandhigher.Still,thecyclecountofthisbatteryismoderatetolow.HighdurabilityNiMH
batteries,whichendure1000discharges,arecommonlypackagedinbulkycylindricalcells.Theenergydensityofthesecellsisamodest70Wh/kg.
Compromisesalsoexistonlithiumbasedbatteries.Liionpacksarebeingproducedfordefenseapplicationsthatfarexceedtheenergydensityofthe
commercialequivalent.Unfortunately,thesesuperhighcapacityLiionbatteriesaredeemedunsafeinthehandsofthepublicandthehighpriceputsthem
outofreachofthecommercialmarket.
Inthisarticlewelookattheadvantagesandlimitationsofthecommercialbattery.Thesocalledmiraclebatterythatmerelyliveincontrolledenvironments
isexcluded.Wescrutinizethebatteriesnotonlyintermsofenergydensitybutalsolongevity,loadcharacteristics,maintenancerequirements,self
dischargeandoperationalcosts.SinceNiCdremainsastandardagainstwhichotherbatteriesarecompared,weevaluatealternativechemistriesagainst
thisclassicbatterytype.
NickelCadmium(NiCd)matureandwellunderstoodbutrelativelylowinenergydensity.TheNiCdisusedwherelonglife,highdischargerateandeconomical
priceareimportant.Mainapplicationsaretwowayradios,biomedicalequipment,professionalvideocamerasandpowertools.TheNiCdcontainstoxicmetalsandis
environmentallyunfriendly.
NickelMetalHydride(NiMH)hasahigherenergydensitycomparedtotheNiCdattheexpenseofreducedcyclelife.NiMHcontainsnotoxicmetals.Applications
includemobilephonesandlaptopcomputers.
LeadAcidmosteconomicalforlargerpowerapplicationswhereweightisoflittleconcern.Theleadacidbatteryisthepreferredchoiceforhospital
equipment,wheelchairs,emergencylightingandUPSsystems.
LithiumIon(Liion)fastestgrowingbatterysystem.Liionisusedwherehighenergydensityandlightweightisofprimeimportance.Thetechnologyis
fragileandaprotectioncircuitisrequiredtoassuresafety.Applicationsincludenotebookcomputersandcellularphones.
LithiumIonPolymer(Liionpolymer)offerstheattributesoftheLiioninultraslimgeometryandsimplifiedpackaging.Mainapplicationsaremobile
phones.
Figure1comparesthecharacteristicsofthesixmostcommonlyusedrechargeablebatterysystemsintermsofenergydensity,cyclelife,exercise
requirementsandcost.Thefiguresarebasedonaverageratingsofcommerciallyavailablebatteriesatthetimeofpublication.
NiCd NiMH LeadAcid Liion Liionpolymer Reusable
Alkaline
LoadCurrent
peak 20C 5C 5C7 >2C >2C 0.5C
bestresult 1C 0.5Corlower 0.2C 1Corlower 1Corlower 0.2Corlower
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 1/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
NiCd NiMH LeadAcid Liion Liionpolymer Reusable
Alkaline
Figure1:Characteristicsofcommonlyusedrechargeablebatteries
1.Internalresistanceofabatterypackvarieswithcellrating,typeofprotectioncircuitandnumberofcells.ProtectioncircuitofLiionandLipolymer
addsabout100m.
2.Cyclelifeisbasedonbatteryreceivingregularmaintenance.Failingtoapplyperiodicfulldischargecyclesmayreducethecyclelifebyafactorof
three.
3.Cyclelifeisbasedonthedepthofdischarge.Shallowdischargesprovidemorecyclesthandeepdischarges.
4.Thedischargeishighestimmediatelyaftercharge,thentapersoff.TheNiCdcapacitydecreases10%inthefirst24h,thendeclinestoabout10%
every30daysthereafter.Selfdischargeincreaseswithhighertemperature.
5.Internalprotectioncircuitstypicallyconsume3%ofthestoredenergypermonth.
6.1.25Vistheopencellvoltage.1.2Visthecommonlyusedvalue.Thereisnodifferencebetweenthecellsitissimplyamethodofrating.
7.Capableofhighcurrentpulses.
8.Appliestodischargeonlychargetemperaturerangeismoreconfined.
9.Maintenancemaybeintheformofequalizingortoppingcharge.
10.Costofbatteryforcommerciallyavailableportabledevices.
11.Derivedfromthebatterypricedividedbycyclelife.Doesnotincludethecostofelectricityandchargers.
Observation:ItisinterestingtonotethatNiCdhastheshortestchargetime,deliversthehighestloadcurrentandoffersthelowestoverallcostpercycle,
buthasthemostdemandingmaintenancerequirements.
TheNickelCadmium(NiCd)battery
TheNiCdprefersfastchargetoslowchargeandpulsechargetoDCcharge.Allotherchemistriespreferashallowdischargeandmoderateloadcurrents.
TheNiCdisastrongandsilentworkerhardlaborposesnoproblem.Infact,theNiCdistheonlybatterytypethatperformswellunderrigorousworking
conditions.Itdoesnotliketobepamperedbysittinginchargersfordaysandbeingusedonlyoccasionallyforbriefperiods.Aperiodicfulldischargeisso
importantthat,ifomitted,largecrystalswillformonthecellplates(alsoreferredtoasmemory)andtheNiCdwillgraduallyloseitsperformance.
Amongrechargeablebatteries,NiCdremainsapopularchoiceforapplicationssuchastwowayradios,emergencymedicalequipmentandpowertools.
BatterieswithhigherenergydensitiesandlesstoxicmetalsarecausingadiversionfromNiCdtonewertechnologies.
AdvantagesandLimitationsofNiCdBatteries
Advantages Fastandsimplechargeevenafterprolongedstorage.
Highnumberofcharge/dischargecyclesifproperlymaintained,the
NiCdprovidesover1000charge/dischargecycles.
GoodloadperformancetheNiCdallowsrechargingatlow
temperatures.
Longshelflifeinanystateofcharge.
Simplestorageandtransportationmostairfreightcompaniesaccept
theNiCdwithoutspecialconditions.
Goodlowtemperatureperformance.
ForgivingifabusedtheNiCdisoneofthemostruggedrechargeable
batteries.
EconomicallypricedtheNiCdisthelowestcostbatteryintermsof
costpercycle.
Availableinawiderangeofsizesandperformanceoptionsmost
NiCdcellsarecylindrical.
Limitations Relativelylowenergydensitycomparedwithnewersystems.
MemoryeffecttheNiCdmustperiodicallybeexercisedtoprevent
memory.
EnvironmentallyunfriendlytheNiCdcontainstoxicmetals.Some
countriesarelimitingtheuseoftheNiCdbattery.
Hasrelativelyhighselfdischargeneedsrechargingafterstorage.
Figure2:AdvantagesandlimitationsofNiCdbatteries.
TheNickelMetalHydride(NiMH)battery
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 2/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
ResearchoftheNiMHsystemstartedinthe1970sasameansofdiscoveringhowtostorehydrogenforthenickelhydrogenbattery.Today,nickel
hydrogenbatteriesaremainlyusedforsatelliteapplications.Theyarebulky,containhighpressuresteelcanistersandcostthousandsofdollarspercell.
IntheearlyexperimentaldaysoftheNiMHbattery,themetalhydridealloyswereunstableinthecellenvironmentandthedesiredperformance
characteristicscouldnotbeachieved.Asaresult,thedevelopmentoftheNiMHsloweddown.Newhydridealloysweredevelopedinthe1980sthatwere
stableenoughforuseinacell.Sincethelate1980s,NiMHhassteadilyimproved.
ThesuccessoftheNiMHhasbeendrivenbyitshighenergydensityandtheuseofenvironmentallyfriendlymetals.ThemodernNiMHoffersupto40
percenthigherenergydensitycomparedtoNiCd.Thereispotentialforyethighercapacities,butnotwithoutsomenegativesideeffects.
TheNiMHislessdurablethantheNiCd.Cyclingunderheavyloadandstorageathightemperaturereducestheservicelife.TheNiMHsuffersfromhigh
selfdischarge,whichisconsiderablygreaterthanthatoftheNiCd.
TheNiMHhasbeenreplacingtheNiCdinmarketssuchaswirelesscommunicationsandmobilecomputing.Inmanypartsoftheworld,thebuyeris
encouragedtouseNiMHratherthanNiCdbatteries.Thisisduetoenvironmentalconcernsaboutcarelessdisposalofthespentbattery.
ExpertsagreethattheNiMHhasgreatlyimprovedovertheyears,butlimitationsremain.Mostoftheshortcomingsarenativetothenickelbased
technologyandaresharedwiththeNiCdbattery.ItiswidelyacceptedthatNiMHisaninterimsteptolithiumbatterytechnology.
AdvantagesandLimitationsofNiMHBatteries
Advantages 3040percenthighercapacityoverastandardNiCd.TheNiMHhas
potentialforyethigherenergydensities.
LesspronetomemorythantheNiCd.Periodicexercisecyclesare
requiredlessoften.
Simplestorageandtransportationtransportationconditionsarenot
subjecttoregulatorycontrol.
Environmentallyfriendlycontainsonlymildtoxinsprofitablefor
recycling.
Limitations Limitedservicelifeifrepeatedlydeepcycled,especiallyathighload
currents,theperformancestartstodeteriorateafter200to300cycles.
Shallowratherthandeepdischargecyclesarepreferred.
LimiteddischargecurrentalthoughaNiMHbatteryiscapableof
deliveringhighdischargecurrents,repeateddischargeswithhighload
currentsreducesthebatteryscyclelife.Bestresultsareachievedwith
loadcurrentsof0.2Cto0.5C(onefifthtoonehalfoftherated
capacity).
MorecomplexchargealgorithmneededtheNiMHgeneratesmore
heatduringchargeandrequiresalongerchargetimethantheNiCd.The
tricklechargeiscriticalandmustbecontrolledcarefully.
HighselfdischargetheNiMHhasabout50percenthigherself
dischargecomparedtotheNiCd.Newchemicaladditivesimprovethe
selfdischargebutattheexpenseoflowerenergydensity.
PerformancedegradesifstoredatelevatedtemperaturestheNiMH
shouldbestoredinacoolplaceandatastateofchargeofabout
40percent.
Highmaintenancebatteryrequiresregularfulldischargetoprevent
crystallineformation.
About20percentmoreexpensivethanNiCdNiMHbatteries
designedforhighcurrentdrawaremoreexpensivethantheregular
version.
Figure3:AdvantagesandlimitationsofNiMHbatteries
TheLeadAcidbattery
InventedbytheFrenchphysicianGastonPlantin1859,leadacidwasthefirstrechargeablebatteryforcommercialuse.Today,thefloodedleadacid
batteryisusedinautomobiles,forkliftsandlargeuninterruptiblepowersupply(UPS)systems.
Duringthemid1970s,researchersdevelopedamaintenancefreeleadacidbatterythatcouldoperateinanyposition.Theliquidelectrolytewas
transformedintomoistenedseparatorsandtheenclosurewassealed.Safetyvalveswereaddedtoallowventingofgasduringchargeanddischarge.
Drivenbydifferentapplications,twobatterydesignationsemerged.Theyarethesmallsealedleadacid(SLA),alsoknownunderthebrandnameofGelcell,
andthelargevalveregulatedleadacid(VRLA).Technically,bothbatteriesarethesame.(Engineersmayarguethatthewordsealedleadacidisa
misnomerbecausenoleadacidbatterycanbetotallysealed.)Becauseofouremphasisonportablebatteries,wefocusontheSLA.
Unlikethefloodedleadacidbattery,boththeSLAandVRLAaredesignedwithalowovervoltagepotentialtoprohibitthebatteryfromreachingitsgas
generatingpotentialduringcharge.Excesschargingwouldcausegassingandwaterdepletion.Consequently,thesebatteriescanneverbechargedtotheir
fullpotential.
Theleadacidisnotsubjecttomemory.Leavingthebatteryonfloatchargeforaprolongedtimedoesnotcausedamage.Thebatteryschargeretentionis
bestamongrechargeablebatteries.WhereastheNiCdselfdischargesapproximately40percentofitsstoredenergyinthreemonths,theSLAself
dischargesthesameamountinoneyear.TheSLAisrelativelyinexpensivetopurchasebuttheoperationalcostscanbemoreexpensivethantheNiCdif
fullcyclesarerequiredonarepetitivebasis.
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 3/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
TheSLAdoesnotlenditselftofastchargingtypicalchargetimesare8to16hours.TheSLAmustalwaysbestoredinachargedstate.Leavingthe
batteryinadischargedconditioncausessulfation,aconditionthatmakesthebatterydifficult,ifnotimpossible,torecharge.
UnliketheNiCd,theSLAdoesnotlikedeepcycling.Afulldischargecausesextrastrainandeachcyclerobsthebatteryofasmallamountofcapacity.
Thisweardowncharacteristicalsoappliestootherbatterychemistriesinvaryingdegrees.Topreventthebatteryfrombeingstressedthroughrepetitive
deepdischarge,alargerSLAbatteryisrecommended.
Dependingonthedepthofdischargeandoperatingtemperature,theSLAprovides200to300discharge/chargecycles.Theprimaryreasonforits
relativelyshortcyclelifeisgridcorrosionofthepositiveelectrode,depletionoftheactivematerialandexpansionofthepositiveplates.Thesechangesare
mostprevalentathigheroperatingtemperatures.Cyclingdoesnotpreventorreversethetrend.
TheoptimumoperatingtemperaturefortheSLAandVRLAbatteryis25C(77F).Asaruleofthumb,every8C(15F)riseintemperaturewillcutthe
batterylifeinhalf.VRLAthatwouldlastfor10yearsat25Cwillonlybegoodfor5yearsifoperatedat33C(95F).Thesamebatterywouldendurealittle
morethanoneyearatatemperatureof42C(107F).
Amongmodernrechargeablebatteries,theleadacidbatteryfamilyhasthelowestenergydensity,makingitunsuitableforhandhelddevicesthatdemand
compactsize.Inaddition,performanceatlowtemperaturesispoor.
TheSLAisratedata5hourdischargeor0.2C.Somebatteriesareevenratedataslow20hourdischarge.Longerdischargetimesproducehigher
capacityreadings.TheSLAperformswellonhighpulsecurrents.Duringthesepulses,dischargerateswellinexcessof1Ccanbedrawn.
Intermsofdisposal,theSLAislessharmfulthantheNiCdbatterybutthehighleadcontentmakestheSLAenvironmentallyunfriendly.
AdvantagesandLimitationsofLeadAcidBatteries
Advantages Inexpensiveandsimpletomanufactureintermsofcostperwatt
hours,theSLAistheleastexpensive.
Mature,reliableandwellunderstoodtechnologywhenusedcorrectly,
theSLAisdurableandprovidesdependableservice.
Lowselfdischargetheselfdischargerateisamongthelowestin
rechargeablebatterysystems.
Lowmaintenancerequirementsnomemorynoelectrolytetofill.
Capableofhighdischargerates.
Limitations Cannotbestoredinadischargedcondition.
Lowenergydensitypoorweighttoenergydensitylimitsuseto
stationaryandwheeledapplications.
Allowsonlyalimitednumberoffulldischargecycleswellsuitedfor
standbyapplicationsthatrequireonlyoccasionaldeepdischarges.
Environmentallyunfriendlytheelectrolyteandtheleadcontentcan
causeenvironmentaldamage.
Transportationrestrictionsonfloodedleadacidthereare
environmentalconcernsregardingspillageincaseofanaccident.
Thermalrunawaycanoccurwithimpropercharging.
Figure4:Advantagesandlimitationsofleadacidbatteries.
TheLithiumIonbattery
Pioneerworkwiththelithiumbatterybeganin1912underG.N.Lewisbutitwasnotuntiltheearly1970sthatthefirstnonrechargeablelithiumbatteries
becamecommerciallyavailable.Lithiumisthelightestofallmetals,hasthegreatestelectrochemicalpotentialandprovidesthelargestenergydensityper
weight.
Attemptstodeveloprechargeablelithiumbatteriesfollowedinthe1980s,butfailedduetosafetyproblems.Becauseoftheinherentinstabilityoflithium
metal,especiallyduringcharging,researchshiftedtoanonmetalliclithiumbatteryusinglithiumions.Althoughslightlylowerinenergydensitythanlithium
metal,theLiionissafe,providedcertainprecautionsaremetwhencharginganddischarging.In1991,theSonyCorporationcommercializedthefirstLiion
battery.Othermanufacturersfollowedsuit.Today,theLiionisthefastestgrowingandmostpromisingbatterychemistry.
TheenergydensityoftheLiionistypicallytwicethatofthestandardNiCd.Improvementsinelectrodeactivematerialshavethepotentialofincreasingthe
energydensityclosetothreetimesthatoftheNiCd.Inadditiontohighcapacity,theloadcharacteristicsarereasonablygoodandbehavesimilarlytothe
NiCdintermsofdischargecharacteristics(similarshapeofdischargeprofile,butdifferentvoltage).Theflatdischargecurveofferseffectiveutilizationof
thestoredpowerinadesirablevoltagespectrum.
Thehighcellvoltageallowsbatterypackswithonlyonecell.Mostoftodaysmobilephonesrunonasinglecell,anadvantagethatsimplifiesbattery
design.Tomaintainthesamepower,highercurrentsaredrawn.Lowcellresistanceisimportanttoallowunrestrictedcurrentflowduringloadpulses.
TheLiionisalowmaintenancebattery,anadvantagethatmostotherchemistriescannotclaim.Thereisnomemoryandnoscheduledcyclingisrequired
toprolongthebatteryslife.Inaddition,theselfdischargeislessthanhalfcomparedtoNiCd,makingtheLiionwellsuitedformodernfuelgauge
applications.Liioncellscauselittleharmwhendisposed.
Despiteitsoveralladvantages,Liionalsohasitsdrawbacks.Itisfragileandrequiresaprotectioncircuittomaintainsafeoperation.Builtintoeachpack,
theprotectioncircuitlimitsthepeakvoltageofeachcellduringchargeandpreventsthecellvoltagefromdroppingtoolowondischarge.Inaddition,the
celltemperatureismonitoredtopreventtemperatureextremes.Themaximumchargeanddischargecurrentislimitedtobetween1Cand2C.Withthese
precautionsinplace,thepossibilityofmetalliclithiumplatingoccurringduetooverchargeisvirtuallyeliminated.
AgingisaconcernwithmostLiionbatteriesandmanymanufacturersremainsilentaboutthisissue.Somecapacitydeteriorationisnoticeableafterone
year,whetherthebatteryisinuseornot.Overtwoorperhapsthreeyears,thebatteryfrequentlyfails.Itshouldbenotedthatotherchemistriesalsohave
agerelateddegenerativeeffects.ThisisespeciallytruefortheNiMHifexposedtohighambienttemperatures.
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 4/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
StoringthebatteryinacoolplaceslowsdowntheagingprocessoftheLiion(andotherchemistries).Manufacturersrecommendstoragetemperaturesof
15C(59F).Inaddition,thebatteryshouldbepartiallychargedduringstorage.
ManufacturersareconstantlyimprovingthechemistryoftheLiionbattery.Newandenhancedchemicalcombinationsareintroducedeverysixmonthsor
so.Withsuchrapidprogress,itisdifficulttoassesshowwelltherevisedbatterywillage.
ThemosteconomicalLiionbatteryintermsofcosttoenergyratioisthecylindrical18650cell.Thiscellisusedformobilecomputingandother
applicationsthatdonotdemandultrathingeometry.Ifaslimmerpackisrequired(thinnerthan18mm),theprismaticLiioncellisthebestchoice.There
arenogainsinenergydensityoverthe18650,however,thecostofobtainingthesameenergymaydouble.
Forultraslimgeometry(lessthan4mm),theonlychoiceisLiionpolymer.Thisisthemostexpensivesystemintermsofcosttoenergyratio.Thereare
nogainsinenergydensityandthedurabilityisinferiortotherugged18560cell.
AdvantagesandLimitationsofLiionBatteries
Advantages Highenergydensitypotentialforyethighercapacities.
Relativelylowselfdischargeselfdischargeislessthanhalfthatof
NiCdandNiMH.
LowMaintenancenoperiodicdischargeisneedednomemory.
Limitations Requiresprotectioncircuitprotectioncircuitlimitsvoltageand
current.Batteryissafeifnotprovoked.
Subjecttoaging,evenifnotinusestoringthebatteryinacoolplace
andat40percentstateofchargereducestheagingeffect.
Moderatedischargecurrent.
Subjecttotransportationregulationsshipmentoflargerquantitiesof
Liionbatteriesmaybesubjecttoregulatorycontrol.Thisrestriction
doesnotapplytopersonalcarryonbatteries.
Expensivetomanufactureabout40percenthigherincostthanNiCd.
Bettermanufacturingtechniquesandreplacementofraremetalswith
lowercostalternativeswilllikelyreducetheprice.
Notfullymaturechangesinmetalandchemicalcombinationsaffect
batterytestresults,especiallywithsomequicktestmethods.
Figure5:AdvantagesandlimitationsofLiionbatteries
TheLithiumPolymerbattery
TheLipolymerdifferentiatesitselffromotherbatterysystemsinthetypeofelectrolyteused.Theoriginaldesign,datingbacktothe1970s,usesadry
solidpolymerelectrolyte.Thiselectrolyteresemblesaplasticlikefilmthatdoesnotconductelectricitybutallowsanexchangeofions(electricallycharged
atomsorgroupsofatoms).Thepolymerelectrolytereplacesthetraditionalporousseparator,whichissoakedwithelectrolyte.
Thedrypolymerdesignofferssimplificationswithrespecttofabrication,ruggedness,safetyandthinprofilegeometry.Thereisnodangerofflammability
becausenoliquidorgelledelectrolyteisused.Withacellthicknessmeasuringaslittleasonemillimeter(0.039inches),equipmentdesignersareleftto
theirownimaginationintermsofform,shapeandsize.
Unfortunately,thedryLipolymersuffersfrompoorconductivity.Internalresistanceistoohighandcannotdeliverthecurrentburstsneededformodern
communicationdevicesandspinninguptheharddrivesofmobilecomputingequipment.Heatingthecellto60C(140F)andhigherincreasesthe
conductivitybutthisrequirementisunsuitableforportableapplications.
TomakeasmallLipolymerbatteryconductive,somegelledelectrolytehasbeenadded.MostofthecommercialLipolymerbatteriesusedtodayfor
mobilephonesareahybridandcontaingelledelectrolyte.ThecorrecttermforthissystemisLithiumIonPolymer.Forpromotionalreasons,mostbattery
manufacturersmarkthebatterysimplyasLipolymer.Sincethehybridlithiumpolymeristheonlyfunctioningpolymerbatteryforportableusetoday,we
willfocusonthischemistry.
Withgelledelectrolyteadded,whatthenisthedifferencebetweenclassicLiionandLiionpolymer?Althoughthecharacteristicsandperformanceofthe
twosystemsareverysimilar,theLiionpolymerisuniqueinthatsolidelectrolytereplacestheporousseparator.Thegelledelectrolyteissimplyaddedto
enhanceionconductivity.
TechnicaldifficultiesanddelaysinvolumemanufacturinghavedeferredtheintroductionoftheLiionpolymerbattery.Inaddition,thepromisedsuperiority
oftheLiionpolymerhasnotyetbeenrealized.Noimprovementsincapacitygainsareachievedinfact,thecapacityisslightlylessthanthatofthe
standardLiionbattery.Forthepresent,thereisnocostadvantage.ThemajorreasonforswitchingtotheLiionpolymerisformfactor.Itallowswaferthin
geometries,astylethatisdemandedbythehighlycompetitivemobilephoneindustry.
AdvantagesandLimitationsofLiionPolymerBatteries
Advantages Verylowprofilebatteriesthatresembletheprofileofacreditcardare
feasible.
Flexibleformfactormanufacturersarenotboundbystandardcell
formats.Withhighvolume,anyreasonablesizecanbeproduced
economically.
Lightweightgelledratherthanliquidelectrolytesenablesimplified
packaging,insomecaseseliminatingthemetalshell.
Improvedsafetymoreresistanttooverchargelesschancefor
electrolyteleakage.
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 5/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
Limitations LowerenergydensityanddecreasedcyclecountcomparedtoLiion
potentialforimprovementsexist.
Expensivetomanufactureoncemassproduced,theLiionpolymer
hasthepotentialforlowercost.Reducedcontrolcircuitoffsetshigher
manufacturingcosts.
Lastupdated20170321
***PleaseReadRegardingComments***
Commentsareintendedfor"commenting,"anopendiscussionamongstsitevisitors.BatteryUniversitymonitorsthecommentsandunderstandstheimportanceof
expressingperspectivesandopinionsinasharedforum.However,allcommunicationmustbedonewiththeuseofappropriatelanguageandtheavoidanceofspam
anddiscrimination.
Ifyouhaveasuggestionorwouldliketoreportanerror,pleaseusethe"contactus"formoremailusat:BatteryU@cadex.com.Weliketohearfromyoubutwecannot
answerallinquiries.WerecommendpostingyourquestioninthecommentsectionsfortheBatteryUniversityGroup(BUG)toshare.
OrJumpToAnotherArchive
DoestheBatteryFuelGaugeLie?
BatteryFuelGauge:FactualorFallacy?
WeirdandWonderfulBatteries
WhatstheBestBattery?
WillSecondaryBatteriesreplacePrimaries?
FourRenegadesofBatteryFailure
AdvancementsinLeadAcid
TheSecretsofBatteryRuntime
CantheLeadacidBatteryCompeteinModernTimes?
ModernLeadBatterySystems
UnderstandingLithiumion
IsLithiumiontheIdealBattery?
PouchCellSmallbutnotTroubleFree
TheHighpowerLithiumion
LithiumionSafetyConcerns
TheSmartBattery
WilltheReusableAlkalineBatteryhaveaFuture?
WilltheFuelCellhaveaSecondLife?
HowdoesInternalResistanceaffectPerformance?
TheBatteryandtheDigitalLoad
NoncorrectableBatteryProblems
WirelessCommunications
HowtoServiceTwowayRadioBatteries
Memory:MythorFact?
HowtoServiceCellPhoneBatteries
PortableComputing
IndustrialApplications
AdvancedBatteryAnalyzers
ComputerizedBatteryTesting
RapidTestingPortableBatteries
WhydoDifferentTestMethodsProvideDissimilarReadings?
ObservingBatteriesinEverydayLife
WheeledandStationary
WhatCausesCarBatteriestoFail?
StartingisEasy,butcanISteerandBrake?
RapidTestingAutomotiveandStarterBatteries
AreHybridCarsHeretoStay?
IstheElectricCarMature?
ComparingBatteryPower
BatteriesagainstFossilFuel
TheCostofPortablePower
IsLiiontheSolutionfortheElectricVehicle?
TheFutureBattery
BatteryStatistics
BatteryTestingEquipment
Comments
OnOctober22,2010at3:58am
EdIglehartwrote:
Verygoodoverview.Helpedmedecideonapowertoolpurchase.
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 6/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
Thanks
OnOctober29,2010at9:03am
Renegadewrote:
Howoldisthisarticle?LiPolyiswaybeyondthisnow.WhataboutLithiumIronPolymer?
OnNovember7,2010at12:29pm
LeszekJwrote:
Isuggesttocorrectsomeunits.
Namely,internalresistanceunit.
OnNovember19,2010at2:03am
Michaelwrote:
Reallyitsverygood.Itgavemeclearideasonwhatpartsdowe(nextgeneration)havetofocus.EspeciallyontheLiionbatteryonwhichIaminterestedin.
OnNovember19,2010at4:16am
PietHumanwrote:
WeareinvetigatingtheRegenerationofLeadAcidbatteriesprincipals,thefeasabilityofthisprocedureetc.andrequiremoreinformationregardingthisnewtechnology.Can
youassistorrefermetosomebodywhocanassistmeplease?
OnNovember22,2010at6:51am
Generalmanagerwrote:
Lookingforthelatestbestbatterychargerforrechargeblebestbatteriesforelectroniclocks,remoteandcommercialuse.andsafety.
OnNovember24,2010at1:45pm
holtb.harrisonwrote:
canyougivemethenamesofthepubliclytradedstocksmakingyourreccomendedelectriccarbatteries?thankyou,HoltHarrison
OnDecember23,2010at6:14am
Heburawrote:
Verygoodbasicsforanewpractitionerinthebatteryfield.
OnDecember25,2010at11:27pm
Errolwrote:
goodgeneralcover
OnDecember28,2010at12:08am
Mudwrote:
Interestingstuff.Ioriginallywantedtoreadthearticletoanswermyquestionbutitwasnotaddressed.Thequestionis,whenbuildingasolarchargingsystemwithSLAbatteries,isthere
adifferencebetweentypesofdeepcyclebatteries.Iveseensourcesusingdeepcyclebatteriesusedinanumberofapplicationssuchasgolfcarts.Iseemtorecallsomeoneonce
sayingacertaindeepcyclebatteryneedstobeusedinsteadofanother,butIcannotrecallthesource.Ivetriedtoresearchthisquestionbutamnotfindingastraightanswer.Canyou
clarifythisanswer?
OnDecember30,2010at1:48pm
WayneParsonswrote:
Veryinformative
OnJanuary4,2011at9:12pm
BWMichaelwrote:
Mud:Thereare2typesofSLAbatteriesdeepcycleandnondeepcycle.
Thedeepcycleoneswilllastlongerifbeingflattenedandrecharged,whereasthenondeepcyclepreferstobekeptchargedallthetimeandareusuallyusedforUPSsystemsand
housealarmsastheyarenotconstantlybeingused/cycled.
p.sGabrielifyouaregoingtocorrectme,dontbother.Iamright
OnJanuary14,2011at2:54am
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 7/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
K.SambasivaRaowrote:
Dearsir/madam,
IWantcombtypegriddesigndateilsforleadacidbatteries.Avoidthepastefallingfrompositve&negativeplates.
Regards
K.SambasivaRao
Asst.Designingengineer
HBlPowersystems,
HYD.AP,India.
OnJanuary14,2011at3:05am
K.SambasivaRaowrote:
Dearsir/madam,
IWantcombtypegriddesigndateilsforleadacidbatteries.
Avoidthepasteissheddingfrompositve&negativegrids.
Regards
K.SambasivaRao
Asst.Designingengineer
HBlPowersystems,
HYD.AP,India.
OnJanuary15,2011at10:38pm
awrote:
HowdoesNickelIronfare?FromwhatIvereadthethingsseemawesomeforsolarchargedsystems.
OnFebruary11,2011at11:48pm
Fralamwrote:
HowaboutsomeNiMhbatterycellsofCtypewith1.2v@9000mAmpandweigthofonly63grpercellisthisfake?....plzsomeonetellmebecausethethewattperkgrishigerthanthe
reported
OnFebruary26,2011at1:17pm
nealegrierwrote:
freezingofthesebatterieswillitdamagethem???
OnMarch8,2011at12:03pm
jesperlindskogwrote:
Notetopoethuman
wehavebeenworkingwithregeneretingleadacidbatteriesforover10years.
Wehavealsobeendoingreserchforprolongingthelifetimeofallkindofbatteries.
Contactmeformoreinfoonjesper.lindskog@reacc.se
OnMarch18,2011at6:43am
DeanScottwrote:
Canyoureplace66voltgolfcartbatterieawith312voltona36voltcart?
OnMarch19,2011at6:47pm
Dr.Haddadwrote:
Pleasesendmeuptodateinformation.
Thanyou.
Dr.Haddad
OnJune11,2011at3:45pm
CliveWilsonwrote:
Thisisareallyniceintrotobatteries,veryusefultothenovicelikemyself.
But(theresalwaysabut)pleasecouldyouaddadateelementtothistoindicatehowcurrent(sorry!)thisis.
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 8/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
OnAugust16,2011at3:05am
Eduardwrote:
Hi,youforgotthebatteriesnickeliron,theseareestimatedlifeof20yearsandmorethan10000chargedischargecycles,withouthavingtoChangetheElectrolite
Theywereruledbyobsolescenceplanned.
Createdmorethantwocenturies,andeven70sbatteriesrunning,Ithinkweshouldkeeptheminmind.
http://www.nickelironbattery.com/
OnAugust23,2011at1:27pm
Andrewwrote:
@Fralam
Thebatteryyouretalkingaboutislistedasa1.2V,9000mAhcell.Somebodyboughtandtestedit,itproduced4Ahnot9.Hoax
OnNovember24,2011at6:51am
NatashaMohanwrote:
Veryinformativearticle.IwantedtoknowwhatthebestbatteryforaUPSsysteminmidpowerrange(online)systemis?Thiswouldmostlybeusedforcommercialapplications.Iknow
leadacidbatteriesarecommonlyusedinUPSsystems,butcanLiionorSodiummetalhalidebatteriesbeused?
OnJanuary3,2012at2:38pm
AlanOppywrote:
Ihavedevelopedasmallportableapplianceforuseintheoutdoorrecreationmarketthatrequiresa12voltpowersourcetooperate.Thispowersourceneedstobeabletodelivera
startupcurrentof1.9ampandaruncurrentof1.5ampsandneedstobeabledeliverthisforapprox34minutesperoperation.Itwillthencease,rest,andrepeatthisfunctionapprox
30to40timesbeforeneedingtoberecharged.Iamseekingadviceastowhichbatterywouldbebestsuitedtomeetingmyneeds.Otherimportantfactorsthatneedtobeconsideredare
weight,size(portability),longevityandofcourseprice.Cananyoneadviseonthis
OnMarch3,2012at2:39am
Alanwrote:
ThankyouJack,Iwillfollowupyoursuggestion
OnMarch19,2012at9:34am
SareyahCookwrote:
Wow,thisreallyhelpedmewithasixgradescienceprojct.iminhighscholnowanyway.
VERYWELLDONE.
OnMarch19,2012at9:35am
Toddwrote:
...Melikeybateries:D
OnMarch30,2012at2:04am
jagmohanwrote:
Hi...
Imworkingasaseniorsolutionarchitect..ineedallbatteryrelatedupdates.
Thankyou
Jagmohan
OnJune1,2012at4:03pm
RafyAzmanwrote:
Thisisaverygoodarticle!THankssomuch!!
OnSeptember12,2012at6:20pm
jhkdhkwrote:
heythisiscoolas
OnSeptember17,2012at1:10am
markezwrote:
Thanksforthisarticle.NowImdoingmyfinalprojectfortheuniversityandthisinformationcanhelpmetounderstandbetterwhatihavetodo.
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 9/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
OnSeptember17,2012at7:31pm
RumbleBumbleBeewrote:
Thisisfantablious.Ireallylovespendingmyweekendreadingthissortofeducationalinforation.thanks,yourbiggestfanRumbleBumbleBee
OnNovember5,2012at2:51pm
killerwhalewrote:
Thearticleappearstohavebeenwrittenquitesometimeago.Itmakesnomentionofthe(notsonewnow)NiMHlowselfdischargebatteries(enelooptype).
OnNovember23,2012at10:42am
GaryM.FranklinSr.wrote:
Inlawnmowerspoweredbyrechargeablebatteries,whichbatteryareyoubesttohaveasfarasoverchargingandlonglifeareyoubesttohaveLEWADACIDORLITHIUMION?Please
sendmeanemailA.S.A.P.ThanksSincerley,GaryM.FranklinSr.
OnJanuary10,2013at5:10pm
nikwrote:
Informationhereisquiteaged(iwoudlsay5yearsatleast)...LSDNiMHandLIFePObatterieschangedlandscapequiteabit,andevenolderchemistriesbeentweakedquitesignificantly
(makesyourealisehowbatteryimprovementsrackedupinlastyears).
Example:youcangeteneloopcellsforfewyearsalready,parametersinrangeof2.4Wh,1000+cycles,27gweightand2,5$cost...
..andLiFePOnanophosphatecellscouldshameNiCadsinalmosteveryaspectbutprice(NiCadsarenolongerkingofthehillwhenyouneededbothcyclecountsandpowerdelivery)
Arcticleleavesoutsomeusefulcharacteristicsofsomechemistries,whilementioninglessrelevantinformation,ex.woudbenicetomentionthatNiMHarecloseto100%efficientinfirst
80%oftheircapacitycycle,orthatkeepingLiIionchemistriesunder80%SOCnotonlyincreasetheircyclecounts,butsignificanlydecreasesagerelatedcapacityloss(whichunder
manyusesismuchmoresignificantthancyclerelatedcapacityloss)....
...andsoon
OnJuly28,2013at9:17am
jerrycarrwrote:
enersyshastakenawaytheneedfordangerousliionbatteriesbymakingpureledhiprofilebateriesthatarenttoexpensive.onshipsthisisveryimportantbecauseoftheriskoffire,
whichpowerstarsolves.
OnOctober9,2013at10:59am
ariannawrote:
sobored.....
OnApril10,2014at10:14pm
harinathwrote:
reallyinformative
OnMay13,2014at10:20pm
nikhilwrote:
hi,
ihaveasmalldigitalclockcircuitwhichworkson12v1asmpsadapter.iwanttoconnectittoaninverterbattery12v50ah.
myquestioniswhetherineedanyspecialcircuitwithstandthishighcurrent(50ah)?.
andahmeansitjustincreasethebatterybackuptimeandthecircuitdrawsonlythecurrentitneedsregardlessofthebatteryAH.?
pleasereply,
thanks
Nikhil
OnMay31,2014at9:38pm
Tigranwrote:
Veryhelpfuloverview.Ithelpedmeinchoosingthebatterytypeforlongcyclelifesystem.
AlsomotivatedmetothinkaboutothertypesofenergystoragelikeCAES(CompressedAirEnergyStorage)forsolarhomeapplication
OnJune2,2014at2:12pm
RavindraGosaviwrote:
HowtoFastandfullbostcharginginlowconditionbatteriesbyrailwaystation
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 10/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
OnJuly7,2014at12:10pm
MKpandeywrote:
Pleaseprovideyourinputsforfollowing.
Inapowerdistributioncontrolcircuitsareratedat24Vor48Vdcvoltage.Pleasecommentaswhattypeofbatteriesbeused.Oneoptionisweuse12Vcarbatteriesinseriestoarrive
atrequiredvoltage.Otheroptionistogoforthebatterybankwith2Vcellsinseriestoachieverequiredvoltage.
Iwouldliketoknowwhataretheadvantageofbatterybankwith2Vcellsovera12voltbatterybank,especiallyforprotectionofcontrolcircuitsofapowerdistributioncompany.Please
elaborateyourreplywithconstructiondetails&lifeofthebatterycells.
Pleaseprovidetheinformationasearlyaspossible.
OnAugust4,2014at5:17am
Edwardwrote:
differentkindsofbatterycanmeetdifferentrequirement
OnSeptember16,2014at2:20pm
Alexwrote:
Haveaquestion,thenewKiaSoulEVhaveLithiumPolymerwithenergydensityof200Wh/kg,higherthanothercarmaker.Isthatsomuchimproved,andhowaboutcyclesofKiaSoul
EVbattery?
OnSeptember17,2014at12:39am
Edwardwrote:
DearAlexAsyouknow,theSouthKoreaisverygoodattheLithiumbattery.Sodonotdoubtthat.thecyclesofKiaSoulEvbatteryisnotveryclear.
OnNovember5,2014at7:32am
mr.smarterthanyouwrote:
...MESMARTERTHANYOULOL
OnDecember10,2014at2:21am
NAPASURESHwrote:
HiThere,
CananyoneclarifymethatwecanuseLipolbatteryinhighertemperatureslike>60degCoperatingtemperature?
Imeanchargingat60degCoperatingtemperature.
OnDecember10,2014at5:27am
Edwardwrote:
NAPA,NoitisdangeroustousetheLipolinsuchhightemperaturer,youcanchoosetheNiCdorNiMhhightemperaturerbattery,formoredetailspleasesendmyemail
zzrm316@163.comEdward
OnDecember20,2014at7:09pm
Robdogwoofwrote:
IninterestedintheearlyquestionregardingNickelIronchemistryinstationarysolarorwindpoweredinstallations.Whiletheyhavelowenergydensity,theirrobustnessandcyclelife
seemtomakethemappealing.Soisthereanyreasonnottoemploytheminthisapplication?Imthinkingofa1000AHrinstallation.
OnJanuary28,2015at2:51am
pwrote:
lol
OnFebruary1,2015at12:39pm
mokuyacankybiyatchwrote:
ithinkthisisaveryinnterestingarticle
verinteresting
thanku
fortheniceinformation
OnFebruary2,2015at6:43pm
Dacostawrote:
Thisisaveryinformativearticle.iamworkingonachargingcircuitforaLiionbatteriesanyhelpwillbewelcomed
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 11/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
OnFebruary4,2015at7:00am
Jeffwrote:
HiDacosta,Iamworkingontherechargeablebattery,keepintouchzzrm316@163.comEdward
OnFebruary5,2015at8:35pm
CamiR.wrote:
Oneofthegreatcontributorsofsoilandwatercontaminationarethebatteries,thehighleadcontentones.Weshouldalllearntodoresponsibledisposalsotoavoidtheriskofhumanand
environmentalhealth.|http://www.advancedchemical.net/
OnFebruary13,2015at2:57am
mehwrote:
doesanyoneknowwhatbatteriesthesilexchreosisgoingtoouseifitexists?
OnApril14,2015at7:04pm
zcccwrote:
Greatarticle.
OnApril26,2015at10:50pm
farhannezamiwrote:
cananyonesuggestmethatwhichisthebestbatteryoutofall
OnMay15,2015at2:49am
NathanMaxfieldwrote:
DeezNutz
Slpurge
OnAugust26,2015at6:19am
shadabarzoo(raja)wrote:
whichisbestLiIonorLiPo?
OnOctober15,2015at5:42am
150321wrote:
batteriescanexplode!
OnNovember6,2015at9:40am
AnzalnaSaifwrote:
Iwantthebriefinformation
OnNovember6,2015at9:43am
AnzalnaSaifwrote:
Iwantthebriefnotabouttheadvantagesanddisadvantagesofbattery
OnFebruary16,2016at10:51am
JaiprakashMorewrote:
whichtypeofbatterytobeusedforprivatesolarsystemwhereregularelectricityisnotpresentatallandneeddeepdischargeseverynight.Andwhereelectricitypresentbutirregular.
OnMarch10,2016at5:15am
Jackwrote:
Sometypesofrechargeablebatteriesandthechargingcircuit
OnMarch30,2016at2:14pm
rolandandersonwrote:
Howdoesthepureleadbatteriescomparetolithium?
Thepureleadisabigimprovementfromwetleadacidisitnot?
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 12/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
OnApril3,2016at11:09pm
shekharwrote:
isthereanydamagetoleadacidbatteryifweprovideconstantcurrenttoitthroughout?
OnMay11,2016at5:24pm
Robertwrote:
Fromthefirstparagraph
Quote:Wescrutinizethebatteriesnotonlyintermsofenergydensitybutalsolongevity
Andthenthereisnofurthermentionoflongevity,verydisappointingforasitethathasuniversityinitstitle.
IamlookingtofindwhatisbestforabackupbatterythatIexpectwillhardlyeverbeneeded/used/discharged.Socyclesnotequallongevity!
OnAugust22,2016at7:57pm
RenoMagrowrote:
Loveyourarticlesonbatterytechnolgy,thewayofthefuture.Whencoupledtosolarandwindtechnolgy,hopebatteryscankeepup
OnSeptember9,2016at5:43am
MichaelStephenwrote:
TheArticlewassoenrichingandigainalotfromit.IthasalsogivenmeanheadstartonmypresentresearchreviewpaperonpresentdayBatteryTechnologies
OnDecember19,2016at1:12am
zameerwrote:
batterytypeLithiumIon(LiIon)4Cell
batterytypeLithiumIon(LiIon)
whichbatteryisgoodformylaptop?
OnJanuary5,2017at2:32pm
RodolfoMartinezwrote:
IsthereanyinformationonthiswebsiteconcerningLithiumIonIronPhosphatebatteries?
OnJanuary15,2017at11:52pm
KenPagewrote:
WheresNiFe?NickelIronBatteries??:(...
OnFebruary18,2017at8:34am
Miklowrote:
Batterieshavecomealongwaysincecellphoneswerefirstused.Whilebatteriesarestilltheweakpointinmyopiniontheynowlastlongerchargefasterandarenotastoxicasbefore.
Ofcoursetherearestillafewthingsthatshouldbedonetogetthemostfromyourbattery,soitsimportanttofindoutwhatkindofbatteryyouhaveandtheproperwaytomaintain.By
doingthisyouwillextendthelifeofthebattery,andmakelifeeasier.
MIKLO
OnFebruary19,2017at8:18am
Johnwrote:
Iseelotsofunansweredquestionsandcommentshere,butIlltryanyway:WhydoesnttheFTC(FederalTradeCommission)orotherAHJ(AuthorityHavingJurisdiction)requirebattery
manufacturerstoplacetheenergydensityofthebatteryineasilyunderstoodunits,suchaswatthoursonthepackagingandintheadvertisingoftheseproductssothatconsumerscan
haveameaningfulwayofcomparingtheperformanceofbatteriesbyunitpricing($/WH)amongvariousmanufacturersandbrands?Thisshouldapplytorechargableandnon
rechargeablebatteriesalike.Theonlytechnicalinformationaboutbatteryperformancethatiseasilyobtained(fromWebsites)bytheaverageconsumer,arecharge/dischargecurves
undercontrolled,notnecessarilytypicalconditions.TheseareUSELESSinhelpingtheconsumermakeaninformedpurchasedecisionortoprovideanobjectivepricevs.performance
comparisonofavailableproducts.
OnMarch17,2017at6:41pm
davewrote:
Youlistleadacidascommercialusesince1970?Ithinkthatiswrong,theyvebeenaroundforover100years.Maybeyoumeant1870?
JoinusonFacebookFollowusonTwitter
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 13/14
5/4/2017 batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery
LearningthebasicsaboutbatteriessponsoredbyCadexElectronicsInc.
http://batteryuniversity.com/learn/archive/whats_the_best_battery 14/14