Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Ruth Rettie
is an ex-Unilever brand manager and a senior lecturer in internet marketing at Kingston University, specialising in new media
and communications. She is also doing a PhD on mobile phone communication at Surrey University.
Ursula Grandcolas
lives in Paris and teaches at several French business schools. She is also an industrial fellow of Kingston University. Her
research interests include e-marketing, international marketing and sustainable development.
Bethan Deakins
completed her marketing MA at Kingston University. She is currently European Marketing Manager for BT Global Services.
304 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005)
Text message advertising: Response rates and branding effects
Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005) Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 305
Rettie, Grandcolas and Deakins
306 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005)
Text message advertising: Response rates and branding effects
*Averaged for those campaigns where this response was relevant. 5,401 respondents.
Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005) Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 307
Rettie, Grandcolas and Deakins
campaign make you feel more or less wide variation in purchase intention, by
positive about xxxxx (eg Expedia.co.uk.) campaign.
or did it not change your impression at Positive brand effect and purchase
all?. Unsurprisingly, for most respondents intention are significantly related to all
there was no change in brand image (78 actions, ie visiting the companys website,
per cent average over all the campaigns), visiting a shop, calling a number,
but there were also considerable replying to a number, supplying an
improvements, for example, 35 per cent e-mail address, watching television,
felt more positive about the brand in one buying the product, visiting a WAP site,
campaign. Table 3 indicates the wide buying a newspaper, requesting a
variation in brand attitude change, by brochure and visiting a restaurant
campaign. Positive change of brand (Chi-square, p 0.000). Figure 1
attitude was related to spontaneous recall illustrates the response pattern overall,
(Chi-square, p 0.01) and occurred for demonstrating that those who act on a
campaigns that did not necessarily text message are much more likely to
produce high response in terms of action. purchase.
Ordinal regression was used to model
the dependence of change in purchase
Purchase intention intention (an ordinal measure) on a
Respondents were asked about purchase number of predictors. Ordinal logistic
intentions: Did this campaign make you regression was used because the
more or less likely to consider buying dependent variable, purchase intention,
from xxxxx (eg Expedia.co.uk) in the was measured with a three-item scale.
future?. Increased likelihood to purchase The final model includes age (recoded
was significantly correlated with into four categories), positive brand
improved brand image; generally the attitude change and message relevance, as
positive effect on purchase intention was factors. The resulting goodness of fit was
approximately twice that of the positive significant at 99 per cent with an
effect on brand attitude. 85.7 per cent of appropriate predicting power (Cox and
those who felt more positively towards Snells pseudo-R squared 0.26), see Table
the brand claimed they were more likely 5. The estimated coefficients in an
to make a purchase. Table 4 indicates the ordinal regression cannot be directly
308 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005)
Text message advertising: Response rates and branding effects
10.6% 51.8%
Not read
Less likely to 2.5%
Action purchase
100%
26.4%
Read 89.4% More likely to
purchase
No action
48.2%
interpreted. Rather, the impact of a these three campaigns varied from one of
change in a particular variable can be the best to one of the worst campaigns,
determined by examining the change in reflecting the importance of the text
the predicted probability (holding other message creativity and contents. The
variables at their means). To do this campaign rated highest included a much
Long and Cheng45 xpost spreadsheet was better promotional offer. The other two
employed. This showed that increased were similar, and, in fact, had a similar
purchase intention was related to positive response in terms of action, ie visits to
brand attitude change and relevance. The the website, but they had very different
youngest age range, 1624, was also branding and purchase effects. These
significant. effects may be the results of the website
experience and unrelated to the text
content.
Creative execution
The campaigns diversity made analysis
difficult, but it was felt that promotions RESEARCH LIMITATIONS
that were more explicit, with greater This research is based on claimed
added value, or more involving, had a response and attitude change. It is likely
stronger effect. For example, the two that respondents are exaggerating their
campaigns beginning want to win receptiveness and response to this new
1,000 did well, as did an offer of 20 medium. In addition, as the campaigns
for opening a bank account, and riddles took place over three months, some
or jokes. The research included three respondents will have received several
campaigns for Expedia. Responses for advertising messages and responsiveness
Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005) Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 309
Rettie, Grandcolas and Deakins
Parameter estimates
Estimate Std. error Wald df Sig.
may decline over time. The authors were recipients may be looking for
unable to determine, from these data, entertainment. The mobile phone,
whether response declines with repeated however, is also perceived as extremely
exposure, or how creative content affects personal,49 so that SMS may be an
response. invasion of privacy. There is scope for
further qualitative research on this area,
which is pertinent to the timing and
DISCUSSION creative style of SMS advertising.
SMS advertising is an effective interactive These 26 campaigns demonstrate the
medium that combines the impact of effectiveness of text message advertising.
telemarketing, the digitalisation of e-mail, Response rates varied from 68 per cent
and the localisation of mcommerce. Its to 3 per cent, with an average of 31
precise targeting makes SMS advertising per cent. This compares very
particularly suitable for time and place favourably both with direct mail, with
sensitive advertising. reported response rates between 1 per
The overall acceptability of SMS cent and 5 per cent,50,51 and
advertising was 44 per cent, significantly permission-based e-mail marketing, with
higher than the acceptability of reported response rates from 1 per cent
telemarketing.46 This more positive to 8 per cent.5254 The average
attitude could either be the result of the response rate of 31 per cent compares
novelty of the medium or an intrinsic reasonably well with the 63 per cent
aspect of SMS advertising. The authors found by Barwise and Strong,55 for an
suggest that it is the latter; the medium incentivised scheme where respondents
is less intrusive than traditional were paid both to take part and per
telemarketing, because respondents can message received. The correlation found
choose when and if they read a message, between acceptability, relevance and
unlike the telephone which produces a interest supports Godins56 argument for
summons which evokes a conditioned permission marketing; moreover, these
response.47 Moreover, unlike traditional three dimensions are also related to
direct mail, text messages on mobile response.
phones are available in otherwise dead SMS advertising has three different
time,48 eg while travelling, when effects: response, branding effect and
310 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005)
Text message advertising: Response rates and branding effects
Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005) Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing 311
Rettie, Grandcolas and Deakins
312 Journal of Targeting, Measurement and Analysis for Marketing Vol. 13, 4, 304312 Henry Stewart Publications 1479-1862 (2005)