Sie sind auf Seite 1von 23

Villagrana 1

Did the American government have any involvement with the events

that occurred on 9/11?

Guillermo Villagrana

Francisco Bravo Medical Magnet H.S

We keep moving forward, opening new doors, and doing new things,

because we're curious and curiosity keeps leading us down new

paths.

-Walt Disney
Villagrana 2

Abstract

Has anyone ever wondered if 9/11 was real? Well of course it

happened and tragically took hundreds of lives, but was the

Government involved, or was this an actual terrorist attack? That

is a big question that many American citizens, teachers, and even

students have thought about since the horrifying event of 9/11 .

The purpose of this in depth research paper is to visit different

viewpoints and ideas, knowledgeably, to seek if 9/11 was a

Government made up phenomenon or if the case stays as rested

where terrorist had full responsibility of 9/11.

Students and teachers of all ages have always seen 9/11 as

an act of terrorism caused by Al-Qaeda, but are they one-hundred

percent responsible of the horrifying act? Time after time huge

attacks have been occurring all over the world. Hate and fear

surrounds the world by terrorist groups like Isis, But who is

responsible for Isis? Can it be the American government? They

secretly did create Isis when trying to help the rebels in Syria,

so is the blood put on America? Are the perished lives of

millions blamed fully on terrorist groups or did the American

government have to do with it.

There is need for further and more extensive research to

fully determine if the Government was responsible for 9/11.

Having a clear winner is prominent to explore many other


Villagrana 3

situations that have been contradicted secretly by the Government

such as the bombing in Syria or the Apollo moon landing. When

going deeper and looking further into the provided research,

should anyone trust the Government? Who are the good guys? Is war

just a way to boost a country's economy? Are they made up

distractions by the Government to keep the American people from

real world problems like climate change? We must actively be

aware and always be open minded to everything...


Villagrana 4

History Context

Years before 9/11, there were many conflicts tensing up

horrifically in The Middle East. According to PBS organization, A

Terrorist group by the name of Al-Qaeda were first formed in

1988. On December 29, 1992, the first attack conducted by Al-

Qaeda was carried out in Aden, Yemen known as the 1992 Yemen

Hotel Bombings. That evening, a bomb went off surprisingly and

unexpectedly at the Gold Mohur hotel, where U.S. troops had been

staying safely while in route to Somalia, though the troops

already left, before the bomb went off, This made the United

States get tremendously involved with countering Terrorism

especially Al-Qaeda.

On February 26, 1993, the World Trade Center was sadly

bombed for the first time.

A bomb built in Jersey City was driven into an underground garage

of the World Trade Center; the blast killed six people and

injured 1,500 others.This created a clear message to the American

Government and American citizens that Al-Qaeda strongly opposed


Villagrana 5

them. Throughout many struggles the bush administration showed

their faces after the attacks and promised to bring justice to

America and the grieving families. The United States was angry

and demanded revenge which cause them to fight and waste billions

of dollars on the military to counter the terrorist group. This

also caused a lot of debt in the American budget, but of course

it is not the only main thing that caused the United States to

get into a lot of debt.

On September 11, 2001 the main event that made Al-Qaeda

infamous occurred. The questionable 9/11 attacks caused a huge

panic in the United States. Everyone that was alive during that

time was looking at the news and eyewitnessing the terrible and

horrific event. From the World trade Center to the Pentagon, many

predict that United 93, the plane that crashed before hitting its

destination, was aim for the white house. It is kinda weird how

easy the planes were taken after the terrorists had pass though

many security procedures. It was if like a man could have of just

walked in with a gun. It is also kinda weird how easy the

terrorist got into the pilot's room in order to control the plane

to finish their mission.

On April 11, 2002 the Ghriba synagogue bombing occurred when

a natural gas truck full with deadly explosives drove past


Villagrana 6

security barriers at the ancient Ghriba Synagogue on the Tunisian

island of Djerba. The truck detonated in front of the synagogue,

killing 14 German tourists, three Tunisians, and two French

nationals. More than 30 others were wounded. Al Qaeda later

claimed responsibility for the attack. This in an example of how

crazy and terrifying the attacks were. This is also another

example of why other countries started to help in Syria and

basicly the United States.

On December 30, 2009 an Al-Qaeda agent posing as a double

agent killed 7 CIA officers in the Camp of Chapman. The

Jordanian man, thought to be an American asset penetrating Al-

Qaeda, was brought in the camp and in which detonated an

explosive belt. The explosion killed 7 CIA, 1 Jordanian

intelligence officer, and seriously wounding six other people.

Most of these stories were not really put on a spotlight in the

United States.

In this nonfiction book, The War on Terrorism:Opposing

Viewpoints(2005), experienced writer F. Balkin, Karen purports

that the war on terrorism is really a struggle for oil in the

Middle East. Balkin has many quotes by many known Government

officials that have made Balkin claim that oil and money had to
Villagrana 7

do with the recent terrorist attacks, especially the one that

occurred September 11, 2001. Balkin has quotes and cited work

from both side of this argument. Not only does Balkin include his

side of the argument that terrorism is made up to make an excuse

to fight for oil, but gives a chance to talk about the other side

of the story which includes the government's viewpoint in order

to support his thought out claim. Balkins intended audience was

for the public which is always lied to or feel like they are

being kept away from some kind of secret.

The war on oil had brought lots of attention after the

9/11 attacks. What did Balkin mean when talking about the war on

terrorism being a cover up to gain control of oil fields in the

Middle East? Taking a look back in what even started the war in

Iraq and all over the Middle Eastern does not make sense. For

many years the United States have contributed a lot of money and

resources to the Middle East to help fight against dictation and

other people trying to be communist among those regions.

Americans hate communism and would only go to war to spread

democracy and freedom to the world, the worlds police, the

strongest nation in the world! What has made the U.S be so rich

and successful? One simple and powerful word; Capitalism. The

strongest form of Capitalism are, of course, Oil corporations

which have uncontrollable power against anyone wanting to take

them down. Oil corporations are running out of oil in the United
Villagrana 8

States and are forced to look all over the world for it. Oil

corps. Have so much money that everything is possible and

especially in a world where 80 percent of the current population

uses fossil fuel as an energy source.

The demand is extremely huge since the world population

keeps getting higher and cars are being produced at a faster

rate. Oil companies then wanted to expand to the Middle Eastern

where the lands are rich of fossil fuel; Oil fields. Companies

did in fact end up going, but this cause a lot of chaos when

people living in these areas rejected the idea of huge oil corps.

Trespassing to the Middle Eastern. The weird thing is that is was

the same time terrorist group started to form. Such as the

infamously known group Al- Qaeda which was formed in 1988. These

kind of groups hated America because of the governments way of

thinking. Why does America care about a small terrorist group?

The American government actually did not care until big lobbyist

started to see the billions that can be made by having oil corps.

Dig in those areas. How can the American government take control

of the Middle Eastern without leading to the suspension towards

the oil companies being guilty of wanting more more money. The

government knew exactly how they can taking control a whole

region and it is simple, this is done by setting a puppet

government around Middle Eastern countries and convincing the


Villagrana 9

American citizens that they are doing this for Democracy and

freedom.

President Wilson first started saying the quote, We must

fight for democracy and freedom all over the world. or many

similar things to that, but what the American people do not

notice is that citizens are being tricked and lied, but are they

really? Could the American government be wanting to have a puppet

government to allow corporations to build their billion dollar

monopolies or was this a way to protect the people living in

those parts who were stuck and enslaved by the dictation of

someone. Could war on terrorism be caused due to those puppet

governments in which people from the Middle Eastern dislike?

Maybe in reality this a fake cycle which goes around where the

American government brings the famous words, Democracy for

all! and explain why there must be troops to protect the

puppeteered countries which in reality it is to protect the oil

corps. How can someone really know if this is true though?

In this nonfiction book, The War on Terrorism:Opposing

Viewpoints(2005), experienced writer Ferrara Peter purports the

war on terrorism is not a struggle for oil. Ferrara has many

quotes from Government officials at Washington D.C which claim

that the war in Iraq is not about the control for oil. He cites

both sides of the argument with company names and specialist of

the subject. Ferrara fights for his side of the argument in order
Villagrana 10

prove that oil is not the reason why America fought the war in

Iraq.The informative, yet decided tone, points to the audience

of those who are looking for answers to the war in Iraq.

Oil might not be a reason the United States is at war. Maybe

we need do need to protect democracy and prevent us another cold

war. Ferrara talks about the need for war in the Middle Eastern

to protect the people in our homeland. If the United States does

not put the flag over the world, someone else would and would

people rather be the U.S or the old U.S.S.R? The United States

has help aid countries and individual people from money to food,

the nation has done it all. President Calvin Coolidge stated,

The business of America is business. The Only reason the United

States was able to grow to its economic strengths were because of

the big red world and no of course it is not communism, but

Capitalism. The only way the United states can become the officer

of the world is if it has lots of money and by keeping the

business happy, the United states will definitely prosper and one

big key, especially in the 20st century and even in present time,

is fossil fuels which are controlled big oil corporations. If the

United States are doing good financially then the world will have

a prosperous economy. Besides, the corporations bring local jobs

all around the Middle Eastern which boosts their economic

structure. The United States has always fought with terrorism and

it has not been as strong until now. This is caused because the
Villagrana 11

the United States is being forced out of the Middle Eastern. The

United States have show weakness and therefore groups like Isis

now control most of the Middle Eastern areas. Isis is getting

larger and stronger everyday and the United States should set up

more and stricter democratic governments to prevent things like

Isis to happen.

What does oil have to do with the 9/11 attacks? Well the

United States needed an excuse to go to war in the Middle Eastern

without really going to war to have control and power in those

lands. The objective is to set military bases all over the Middle

Eastern fields to get its hand on the oil. Many Americans were

not buying it so this might of caused the government to take

extreme measures. If not they would lose a chance of winning

billions of dollars. How did the American government pull off

horrifying event? Or did the government even want this to happen?

Did this event happen mysteriously or was it a plan to have a

cause to have military bases and gain power in the Middle Eastern

land and economy. How did the U.S pull of this terrible event?

In this nonfiction article, Peer Review Melts Steel Beams

(2016), journalist Alex Kasprak brilliantly states that 9/11 was

brought down by a controlled demolition. Kasprak used quotes and

citations from books to support his claim of 9/11 being brought

down by controlled demolition. The author provides good quotable

evidence with strong references in order to help support his


Villagrana 12

thesis of 9/11 not being what it is said to be. The targeted

audience for this argument would be conspiracist, adults affected

by 9/11 and anyone looking for a different point of view other

than just listening to Fox news.

To fully understand and grasp the intellectual part of why a

demolition is possible is due to the why the building falls.

Professor Malo from the University of Arizona architect, Malo

firmly states, A building can not be collapsed that fast

especially a skyscraper that size impossible for the twin towers

to collapse with its every own weight it just a little funny

because everyone states that the jet fuel melted the steel beams

which is impossible when jet fuel can burn only, a maximum, of

2,230 C ad for steel to melt, it needs 2,500 C . Professor

Malo bring up a very interesting point that many other scientist

and architects have proved but have been denied by the American

government. There have been multiple groups that have been formed

to help bring cause to this subject. Although only about 15

percent of the world think the United States were to blame for

9/11, based on 2008 polls, this is slowly changing though the

years and is still yet one to be made for 2017.

After collecting data from many students from an educated

and highly respected school named Bravo Medical Magnet High

School where they have been asked to anonymously answer five

controversial questions. One-hundred Students from grade levels 9


Villagrana 13

to 12 and ages 14 to 18 answered a the questions. For example,

Do you believe all Middle Easterners are terrorist?(figure 1)

a whopping 100% disagree with that statement which surprised me

and shows how a younger generation is less affected from 9/11

than someone who is much older. Research has been done before

about this question, Do you trust the American government? 78%

percent state that they do not believe nor trust the American

government (Figure 2).


Villagrana 14

. These are huge number which also tell the world about the

incoming generation willing to be more peaceful and pointed more

to a socialist point of view. Looking into America's recent past

the U.S have seen attempts of people trying to run for office

who are different parties like the Green party and there has also

been people who believe in a different. For example, Bernie

Sanders who was a democrat, yet believed in socialism. Anyone can

see the way people are reacting to the current government.

American citizens what to be able to trust their very own

government and currently it's not quite happening. Though many


Villagrana 15

people feel like the government is very dishonest, there is

probably more people right now that still very much trust their

government.

This nonfiction book, The 9/11 Commission Report (2004),

Knowledgeable American commissioners, state that there is a

connection between the hijackers from 9/11 and Al Qaeda. The

commission members cite a variety of eyewitnesses, Airport

security reports, and security cameras that help claim the

connection of the hijackers and Al Qaeda, thereby explaining why

all the horrifying events that occurred that day were due to Al

Qaeda. The authors provide highly descriptive evidence in order

to persuade readers that the hijackers were connected to Al

Qaeda. The informative, yet decided tone, points to the audience

of those who are looking for the truth of 9/11, or someone who

likes history and wants to find out more on what happen over this

topic, which they put dates and point out specific areas.

The American government has been struggling to be the good

guy lately , but there are many conspiracies and unneeded protest

that have caused unwanted rage towards the government. The U.S

government, after 9/11, issued a full on book report on what

happen in 9/11. Hour by hour and minute by minute the United

States commissioners set out a brightly made explanation of what

happen. This included how the hijackers got in and also included

the pentagons explanation of the plane crash there. The


Villagrana 16

commissioners are professionals and have evidence that back up

their claims. Before 9/11, there had been many reports and

already constate little battles with the group named Al- Qaeda.

Many Al-Qaeda group member already tried to terrorize the United

States army. Even before 9/11 there had been a bombings in the

parking lot of the twin towers or world trades center. The Al-

Qaeda members simply drove a white van into the building parking

lot and soon there was chaos everywhere. This should of been one

of the warings the United States should of taken more seriously.

The American people got the hateful message from the Al- Qaeda

good and clear. They were willing to go to the homeland just just

show the group's strong and mighty power. The events that

accord had to be one-hundred percent Al-qaeda. They spent many

year planning these attacks and even killed innocent people that

did not deserve to die in this particular way no should die in a

plane crash where the plane purposely was crashed to make a point

to a tower where more people worked. If the United States were

already capable of what the Al-Qaeda group were willing to do

then why not be more prepared? Did the U.S let their guard down

or was it planned. Maybe the United States knew about this

horrific event and just let happen to show how we must fight a

war. Maybe this isnt an inside job but the U.S might still be

strongly responsible. They just sat back a let the show begin.

Would the U.S actually let this happen to their citizens?


Villagrana 17

This non fiction podcast, Visibility 9-11 Welcomes Dr. Frank

Legge, PhD(2009), Knowledgeable radio host and writer states that

the government would make false accusations of someone when

proving the truth of 9/11. He uses Dr. Frank legge, which guest

on his show, and many example to support his ideas. He has many

more podcast about 9/11 in general and cites people or

eyewitnesses who believe in his theories. He gathers

professional Drs and PHD professors in order to prove that

Government is trying to hide someone from telling the truth of

9/11. The audience would be conspiracist and people who enjoy

listen to radio talk shows or podcast maybe anyone interested in

what other peoples thoughts are.

Not only are these conspiracy theories in books or articles

around the internet, but they are also is podcast. There has been

numberless stories of people knowing the truth of not

specifically 9/11 but anything where there are argument and

theories based on the government and then all of a sudden

disappearing. Is it fake or is it real? Well during the podcast

the host invites Dr. Frank Legge who is a historian and a

political researcher. Dr. Legge talks about his own research in

depth detail which is very convincing. Dr. Legge states, If the

U.S government had nothing to do with 9/11, why do they not

release all the classified files after all Osama bin laden is

dead. Dr. Legge bring up an interesting topic about all these


Villagrana 18

situations, If Bin laden is dead then what are we still doing in

Syria and the Middle Eastern. Dr. Legge also brings up very

simple, yet never thought before of scenarios, which keep you

thinking and saying why? One good example is when Dr. Legge

urgently said, Didnt Obama take out the soldiers stationed in

Iraq and Iran? What are we still doing there? Is it money or

something deeper? What other secrets can our government (U.S

government) keep from us? We need to open our eyes! Obama also

created Isis!. Isis was made made by the government and it all

happened when the United States tried helping out the rebels.

The pentagon secretly authorized training of the rebel army

going against the Syrian dictator Bashar Hafez al-Assad. Then

after a few conflicts, the nes trained by the C.I.A made there

own group and added more people. Islamic State of Iraq and Syria

is what Isis stand for and is currently the most effective and

successful terrorist group ever made. This can another reason not

to trust the government, but at the end of the day the United

States want to help out the people fighting for democracy

which totally backfired and caused more men and women to go back

and fight once again with a terrorist group, but this time Isis

is just as skilled as the U.S Army due to Obama's incident. It

was not Obama's fault necessarily, but it did end up falling on

him just like the attack on 9/11 and the war on Iraq. This does

seem like deja vu does it not? Kinda suspicious right?


Villagrana 19

In this informative yet horrific documentary, The Story Of

Flight 93 by Real stories (2013) , Real stories claim that there

is always a chance if you fight. The authors use family member

which actually talked to there loved ones before the plane

crashed. They also use quotes from plane operators and radio

operators who talked to some passengers in order to prove there

is a chance, but only if you fight. The intended audience would

be for students who are intrested on a visual view of what happen

to one of the plane that actually fought back against the

terrorist.

People ask why the U.S is still in The Middle EAST and that

is simple to answer is that there is a new threat that must be

eliminated. It is a danger to not only the American people, but

the world and the U.S can not let that happen since we are the

cops here. To show how bad things have gotten, this year, 2017,

president Trump dropped The Mother of All Bombs and that is

literally the name of them bomb; It is the strongest bomb ever

made that has no radiation. This was needed to keep Isis on its

toes and show that we can win. The United States is willing to

risk war to protect its people and people all over the world. The

U.S had tried talking to them since the U.S is super reasonable,

but they kept being disobedient to the U.S and that called of

desperate measures. There are recording from the United 93 where

there is evidence that people were actually in the planes and not
Villagrana 20

just some kind of simulation. Eyewitnesses have not only seen but

heard the final good byes of the onboard passengers. Everyone is

still devastated on what happened during 9/11 and should be taken

more seriously than making fake suggestions and conspiracies.

Epilogue

Conducting this hard and exclusive research has opened many

points of view. From the formation of Isis to scientific proof

there are many ways to find out information about 9/11. From

podcast to official government reports there are all kind of

conclusions that can be on the both side of the argument. This is

important to many families and to the American citizens who need

help in trusting their government and learning knowledge to vote

for future government election;to be independent. Knowing the

truth of the involvement of the United States is crucial because

it make us wonder what other thing have the American government

been keeping a secret.

Secrets can impact the world especially when it can cause a

war. Can 9/11 be connected with the U.S government? Although

there is a lot of evidence which can prove the United States

guilty from its involvement in 9/11, this could just be over


Villagrana 21

thought and maybe people think of the situation too much. Humans

have an amazing imagination which can come up with all kinds of

theories that are just simply outrageous. Government officials

have constantly researched and examined all the evidence which

then the U.S government property blamed the Al-Qaeda. Al-Qaeda

did ended up taking responsibility, but can Al-Qaeda be a

secretly formed group trained by the U.S government to from

distractions of something? Can it just be a group of people who

just want to spread horror and disturbance in the world for

attention? Maybe there is something bigger going on...


Villagrana 22

Cited work

911truth.org

https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/w/waltdisney1

32637.html?src=t_curious

https://news.brown.edu/articles/2016/09/costsofwar2

http://edition.cnn.com/2001/US/09/11/chronology.attack/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_al-

Qaeda_attacks

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/network/a

lqaeda/indictment.html

Peer Review Melts Steel Beams (2016),

The 9/11 Commission Report (2004)

The War on Terrorism:Opposing Viewpoints(2005)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zbsZjW-m0x8

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cw8_YPQLH5I
Villagrana 23

https://www.youtube.com/watch?

annotation_id=annotation_2895751793&feature=iv&src_vid=

zbsZjW-m0x8&v=70Ce_mbY5cc

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen