Sie sind auf Seite 1von 12

NEUROMUSCULAR TRAINING IMPROVES MOVEMENT

COMPETENCY AND PHYSICAL PERFORMANCE


MEASURES IN 1113-YEAR-OLD FEMALE NETBALL
ATHLETES
AMANDA HOPPER,1 ERIN E. HAFF,1 OLIVER R. BARLEY,1 CHRISTOPHER JOYCE,2 RHODRI S. LLOYD,3
1
AND G. GREGORY HAFF
1
Center for Exercise and Sport Science Research, Edith Cowan University, Joondalup, Western Australia, Australia; 2School of
Health Sciences, Notre Dame University, Fremantle, Western Australia, Australia; and 3Youth Physical Development Unit,
Cardiff School of Sport, Cardiff Metropolitan University, Cardiff, Wales, United Kingdom

ABSTRACT improve performance and movement competency in youth net-


Hopper, A, Haff, EE, Barley, OR, Joyce, C, Lloyd, RS, and Haff, ball players.
GG. Neuromuscular training improves movement competency KEY WORDS strength training, resistance training, sport, injury
and physical performance measures in 1113-year-old female prevention
netball athletes. J Strength Cond Res 31(5): 11651176,
2017The purpose of this study was to examine the effects INTRODUCTION

N
of a neuromuscular training (NMT) program on movement com-
euromuscular training (NMT) programs have
petency and measures of physical performance in youth female
been shown to improve physical performance
netball players. It was hypothesized that significant improve- measures and reduce injury risk in youth and
ments would be found in movement competency and physical adolescent athletes (27,28). Typically, NMT
performance measures after the intervention. Twenty-three combines fundamental movement skill training with
junior female netball players (age, 12.17 6 0.94 years; height, strength and conditioning activities, such as resistance train-
1.63 6 0.08 m; weight, 51.81 6 8.45 kg) completed a test ing and plyometric training (28) to improve dynamic joint
battery before and after a 6-week training intervention. Thirteen stability, enhance movement patterns and skills, improve
of these athletes underwent 6 weeks of NMT, which incorpo- neuromuscular control and increase strength (27). Research
rated plyometrics and resistance training. Trained athletes has shown that NMT may be particularly important for
showed significant improvements in 20-m sprint time, 505 agil- child and adolescent female athletes as they consistently
ity time, countermovement jump height, and peak power (p # show decreased levels of strength, power and performance
0.05, g . 0.8). In addition, trained athletes significantly indices, and increases in injury risk in comparison with males
improved their score in the Netball Movement Screening Tool (12,26,27). One sport that may benefit from the incorpora-
tion of NMT is netball. The sport requires athletes to possess
(NMST) (p , 0.05, g . 21.30); while the athletes also dem-
high levels of speed, agility, upper and lower-body strength
onstrated increased reach in the anterior and posteromedial
and power, movement competency, and anaerobic and aer-
directions for the right leg and left leg, and in the posterolateral
obic endurance (5,8). Netball is also commonly associated
direction for the left leg only in the Star Excursion Balance Test
with a high incidence of lower limb injuries (11), and is
(SEBT) (p , 0.05, g . 20.03). Control subjects did not exhibit one of the top 5 sports associated with sporting injuries in
any significant changes during the 6-week period. Significant Australian children (39).
negative correlations were found between improved score on Several studies have shown that NMT programs are
the NMST and decreased 5-, 10-, and 20-m sprint time, and effective in improving physical performance measures in
505 change of direction time (r . 0.4, p # 0.05). Results of the youth populations (10,27,29). Myer et al. (27) report that
study affirm the hypothesis that a 6-week NMT intervention can after a 6-week NMT program, 1416-year-old female ath-
letes across 3 different sports significantly improved sprint
Address correspondence to G. Gregory Haff, g.haff@ecu.edu.au. time, vertical jump performance, and squat and bench press
31(5)/11651176 1-repetition maximums. Similarly, another study reported
Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research that after the completion of an 8-week NMT program by
2017 National Strength and Conditioning Association grade 2 children, significant improvements were found in

VOLUME 31 | NUMBER 5 | MAY 2017 | 1165

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Neuromuscular Training Improves Movement Competency and Performance

push-ups, curl ups, long jump, single leg hop, and running capacity can occur simultaneously. Similarly, McLoad et al.
performance (10). In addition, Noyes et al. (29) report sig- (25) conducted a 6-week NMT program for high school
nificant improvements in vertical jumping performance after female basketball players, which resulted in a significant
6 weeks of NMT undertaken by 1417-year-old female bas- decrease in errors in the Balance Error Scoring System
ketball players (29). The well-documented improvements in (BESS) as well as significant improvements in the SEBT.
performance of basketball (29) and volleyball (27) athletes Improvements in balance and stability could potentially lead
suggest that similar results may be found with netball ath- to improved athletic performance and reduced injury risk
letes of a similar age owing to similarities in physical and (25). As in basketball, balance and stability are also particu-
movement demands inherent to both sports. larly important in netball because of the foot work rule of the
Careful inspection of the scientific literature reveals that game requiring athletes to decelerate, stabilize, and balance
female athletes are at a higher risk of sports-related injury in when receiving the ball to avoid a step violation (40).
comparison with males (14,27). One possible explanation for Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine whether
this discrepancy is the decreased neuromuscular control fe- NMT was effective in improving physical performance
males experience after maturation (15). Poor neuromuscular indices and movement competency in female youth netball
control can lead to poor movement patterns and predispose players. Based on previous research (10,18,25,27,29), it is
female athletes to an increased risk of injury (14,23). Move- hypothesized that the training intervention will increase
ment screening tools are commonly performed to assess sprinting speed and agility, improve vertical jumping height,
movement capabilities, identify musculoskeletal and strength and improve movement competency scores in junior netball
deficits, and predict potential injury risk in athletes (33). The players.
Netball Movement Screening Tool (NMST) was developed
specifically to replicate the movement patterns pertinent to METHODS
netball to identify injury risk (33). The screen incorporates 4
Experimental Approach to the Problem
components (a) the Movement Competency Screen (MCS),
This study used a 6-week NMT program comprising 3
(b) jump components, (c) the Star Excursion Balance Test
training sessions per week completed on nonconsecutive
(SEBT), and (d) the active straight leg raise (ASLR).
days, lasting approximately 60 minutes. All participants
Although various movement screens were developed to
partook in a 1-week familiarization program before under-
assess an athletes risk of injury (33,38), recent research sug-
taking baseline testing. After baseline testing, participants
gests that they may be largely ineffective in predicting injury
were randomly assigned into either an experimental or
(1). For example, a recent meta-analysis on movement
control group (CG). After the 6-week intervention, all
screens suggests that the Functional Movement Screen
subjects completed the after testing sessions. The CG only
(FMS) may not be predictive of injury risk in active adults
participated in the baseline and after intervention testing
(9). Although there may be limited utility of movement
sessions and undertook no NMT intervention during the
screens for prediction of injury, there is evidence to suggest
course of the study. All participants were instructed to
that movement screens such as the FMS may have a relation-
continue with their normal netball training and games
ship to performance measures in adolescent athletes. For
throughout the data collection period. All participants had
example, Lloyd et al. (23) revealed significant relationships
their sprinting and change of direction speed, CMJ, and
between FMS scores, reactive agility, and reactive strength
NMST performance assessed. A summary of the testing
index intraclass correlation coefficient alpha (ICCa = 0.4
schedule is presented in Figure 1.
0.7) in 1116-year-old male soccer athletes. Furthermore,
another study found that younger than 16-year-old rugby Subjects
union players who scored lower on a movement screen A total of 23 junior female netball players (age, 12.17 6 0.94
had slower sprint times, scored lower on the Yo-Yo test, years; height, 1.63 6 0.08 m; weight, 51.81 6 8.45 kg) with
and jumped lower in a vertical jumping task (31), thus indi- no NMT experience were recruited to participate in the
cating movement competency could be related to perfor- study. Age, height, and weight data across participants are
mance in youth populations. presented in Table 1, with no significant differences found
Research shows that movement competency can be between control and experimental groups (EGs) between
enhanced after exposure to NMT interventions; for example, the baseline or after testing sessions (p . 0.05). Participants
Klusemann et al. (18) conducted a 6-week fully supervised were selected on the following criteria; currently participat-
resistance training program to junior basketball athletes, ing in competitive netball, no previous history of lower limb
which resulted in improvements in FMS scores. In addition, injuries, and no history of resistance training. Written paren-
there were improvements in countermovement jump (CMJ) tal consent and participant assent were provided before ini-
and agility performance after the 6-week training period tiating the study in accordance with the Edith Cowan
(18). These findings suggest that when junior athletes engage University Human Research Ethics Committee guidelines.
in supervised training, significant improvements in move- All participants completed a modified Pubertal Matura-
ment competency and markers of sports performance tion Observational Scale (PMOS) that is used to classify
the TM

1166 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM

Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca.com

Countermovement Jump Test


The participants CMJ height
(centimeter) was measured
using a Vertec (Yardstick II;
SWIFT, Queensland, Australia).
Participants performed a CMJ
in accordance with the proce-
dures outlined by Nuzzo et al.
(30). Participants were in-
structed to take-off from
Figure 1. Data collection timeline. a self-selected jump stance
and jump for maximum height.
Participants were given 3
warm-up trials, followed by 3
participants into maturational categories: prepubertal, mid- maximal effort trials with a 60-second intertrial rest interval
pubertal, and postpubertal as previously used in the literature (32). The highest vertical jump obtained was used for
(15). All participants completed the Physical Activity Read- analysis.
iness Questionnaire (PAR-Q) before commencement of the The vertical displacements determined in this study were
study. Finally, participants were randomly divided into either used to estimate a peak power value with the use of the
the EG (n = 13) or CG (n = 10). Analysis of the PMOS Sayer et al. (36) equation:
revealed that there was no significant difference in matura-
tional categories between the EG and CG (p . 0.05). Peak powerW 60:73Jump Height; cm

Testing Procedures
45:33body mass; kg22; 055:
Height was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm with the use of
a stadiometer (ECOMED; New South Wales, Australia), This equation was selected because it has previously been
whereas weight was measured to the nearest 0.1 kg on an shown to be an accurate estimator of peak power output
electronic scale (Tanita Australia Inc., Kewdale, Western during vertical jumping (13,36).
Australia, Australia). Both sessions also included a battery of The validity of the Vertec as a tool for determining vertical
performance and movement competency tests. Counter- jump displacement has previously been reported to be a valid
movement jump, 20-m sprint, and 505 netball agility tests tool for the assessment of anaerobic power (4,16,20,30). The
were used to assess the athletes neuromuscular performance, reliability of the assessment of vertical jump displacement
and the NMST was used to assess the participants movement using the Vertec has previously been reported to be excellent
competency. The order of testing was constant for both test- (ICCa = 0.94) (30). Analysis of vertical jumping scores in
ing sessions with the movement competency testing occur- this study demonstrated a high degree of reliability as indi-
ring first, followed by the physical performance measures. cated by an ICCa = 0.89.

TABLE 1. Subject characteristics.*

Experimental (n = 13) Control (n = 10) Total subjects (n = 23)

Variable Mean 6 SD Mean 6 SD Mean 6 SD

Age (y)
Pre 12.08 6 0.95 12.30 6 0.95 12.17 6 0.94
Post 12.23 6 0.93 12.30 6 0.95 12.26 6 0.92
Height (m)
Pre 1.64 6 0.07 1.63 6 0.10 1.63 6 0.08
Post 1.64 6 0.08 1.64 6 0.11 1.64 6 0.08
Weight (kg)
Pre 50.66 6 8.81 53.31 6 8.19 51.81 6 8.45
Post 51.95 6 8.88 53.80 6 8.43 52.79 6 8.54

*Significant difference between groups (p , 0.05).

VOLUME 31 | NUMBER 5 | MAY 2017 | 1167

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Neuromuscular Training Improves Movement Competency and Performance

by Netball Australia (42). A distance of 15 m was measured


with distances of 0 and 15 m marked with masking tape and
TABLE 2. Dynamic warm-up program.*
cones as directed by the national netball protocols (42).
Exercise Sets Repetitions Wireless infrared timing gates (SWIFT) were used to quan-
tify the change of direction speed (seconds) of each athlete.
High knee march 2 10
Athletes were instructed to perform the change of direction
Sumo squat arms MB overhead 2 10
Arm swing and lunge 2 10 element of the test with the preferred foot (42). All partic-
Backward hip flexion walk 2 10 ipants completed 2 warm-up trials at 50 and 70% of maximal
Superman 2 10 effort. Participants then completed 3 maximal effort trials
Knee grab to lunge and twist 2 10 with the fastest time being recorded for analysis. All 5-0-5
Carioca 2 10
change of direction trials were separated by 2 minutes to
Rocket jump 2 10
ensure adequate recovery and maximize performance (42).
*MB = medicine ball. Previous authors have reported high reliability and good
within-subject variation of the 505 agility test with CV values
ranging from 1.95 to 2.40% (41). The reliability of the 505
agility test has also previously been examined in netball play-
Twenty-meter Sprint Test
ers; results revealing ICCa of 0.960.97 for the stationary
Sprinting speed (seconds) was assessed using the 20-m sprint
start (2). Analysis of 505 scores for this study showed simi-
test as outlined by Netball Australia guidelines for testing
larly high between-trial reliability (ICCa of 0.92).
netball athletes (42). Wireless infrared timing gates (Swift,
QLD) were set at distances of 5, 10, and 20 m and used to
Netball Movement Screening Tool
record the athletes velocity and ability to accelerate from
All participants were screened with the NMST (33). This
a static position. Participants performed 3 warm-up sprints at
screening tool consists of 4 components, (a) the MCS con-
50, 70, and 90% respectively. Participants then performed 2
sisting of 5 tests: bodyweight squat, lunge and twist, bend
maximal effort sprints. All sprint trials were separated by a 2-
and pull, single leg squat, and push-up; (b) Jump components
minute rest period to ensure that the participants had ade-
composed of 3 jump tests; CMJ, CMJ with a single leg land-
quate recovery between sprints, as recommended by the
ing, and a broad jump with a single leg landing; (c) the Star
national netball protocols (42). Only the fastest 20-m sprint
Excursion Balance Test (SEBT) assessed anteriorly, poster-
time was used for analysis. Five-meter, 10-, and 20-m sprint
omedially, and postereolaterally; and (d) the ASLR. These
time and sprint velocity were recorded for analysis. Previous
tests were chosen as they reflect movement patterns relevant
authors have shown high reliability of using infrared timing
to netball (33). All components of the NMST were video
gates to assess sprint speed (coefficient of variation [CV] =
recorded using a standard 2-dimensional camera (HDR-
1.001.13%) (44). Analysis of 20-m sprint scores in this study
XR260VE; Sony, North Sydney, Australia), with the partic-
demonstrated excellent reliability (ICCa = 0.97).
ipants observed from the frontal and sagittal planes.
505 Agility Test Each participant completed 6 repetitions of each of the
The 505 agility test was used to assess the participants abil- MCS, jump component tests, and SEBT in all directions; 3
ity to decelerate, change direction, and accelerate as outlined repetitions on each leg were completed for the ASLR as
previously used in the literature
(33). Screening was completed
by qualified strength and con-
TABLE 3. One-Week familiarization program. ditioning coaches with exten-
sive experience in movement
Sets Repetitions Rest interval (s) screening youth athletes. Scor-
Plyometric exercise ing occurred retrospectively
squat jump 2 5 60 and was conducted in the same
Box drop to stick 2 5 60 manner described by Reid et al.
Resistance training exercise (33). Specifically, the MCS,
Back squat 2 5 60
Push-ups* 2 5 60
jump components, and ASLR
Static lunge (arms in front) 2 5 60 were scored out of 33, and
Horizontal pull-up (knees bent) 2 5 60 the SEBT was scored sepa-
Glute bridge 2 5 60 rately (33). Two scorers were
used to assess the participants
*If athletes could not perform a traditional push-up, they were allowed to use a modified
technique with knees on ground. MCS and jump components to
ensure reliability in scoring and
avoid interobserver bias; with
the TM

1168 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM

Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca.com

TABLE 4. NMT training block 1 (weeks 13).*

Part A: Plyometric training

Exercise Sets Repetitions Rest interval

squat 3 5 60
Lateral bound with stick 3 5 60
Single leg push off (low box) 3 5 60
908 spin jump 3 5 60

Part B: Resistance training

Sessions A and C Session B Sets Repetitions Rest Interval

Back squat Front squat 3 5 60


Medicine ball static lunge (bent arms) Medicine ball static lunge (straight arms) 3 5 60
Military press Behind neck press 3 5 60
Horizontal pull-up (knees bent) Horizontal pull-up (leg straight) 3 5 60

*NMT = Neuromuscular training.


Plyometric training was done before each of the resistance training sessions.

the agreement between 2 scorers assessed using the (ICCa = 0.96) reliability (33). Analysis of SEBT scores for
weighted kappa statistic (19), whereby a score of above this study showed excellent between-trial reliability across all
0.81 was considered almost perfect, 0.610.80 substantial directions (ICCa $ 0.93).
agreement, 0.410.60 moderate agreement, and below 0.40
poor agreement (33), reliability of this movement-screening Neuromuscular Training Program
tool has previously been quantified in the literature demon- The EG trained 3 times per week on nonconsecutive days
strating excellent interrater (ICCa = 0.84) and intrarater for approximately 1 hour. All familiarization and training

TABLE 5. NMT training block 2 (weeks 46).*z

Part A: Plyometric training

Exercise Sets Repetitions Rest interval

medicine ball squat jump 3 5 60


Medicine ball lateral bound 3 5 60
Single leg push off (medium box) 3 5 60
1808 spin jump 3 5 60

Part B: Resistance training

Sessions A and C Session B Sets Repetitions Rest Interval

Back squat Front squat 3 8 60


Incline bench press Bench press 3 8 60
Split squatBFE Split squatFFE 3 8 60
Chin-up* Bent-over row 3 8 60
Forward alternating lunge Backward alternating lunge 3 8 60
Romanian deadlift Romanian deadlift 3 8 60

*BFE = back foot elevated; FFE = front foot elevated; NMT = Neuromuscular training.
Plyometric training was conducted before each of the resistance training sessions.
zIf athletes could not perform a chin-up resistance, bands were used to assist them. In this case, the resistance bands were
modified to reduce reliance on the band across the training period.

VOLUME 31 | NUMBER 5 | MAY 2017 | 1169

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Neuromuscular Training Improves Movement Competency and Performance

TABLE 6. RPE session goal based on OMNI


rating of perceived exhaustion (RPE) scale.

Training block Week RPE goal

Block 1 1 34
2 56
3 78
Block 2 4 34
5 56
6 78

Figure 3. Effect size comparison between the experimental and control


group raw difference scores (post and pre) for selected sprint variables.

sessions were initiated with the use of a standardized 10-


minute dynamic warm-up (Table 2), followed by plyometric
exercises, strength training, and finishing with static stretch- coach to insure technical competency. Participants were
ing. All participants went through a comprehensive 1-week explained how to use the scale to describe the level of
familiarization period to ensure familiarity with the types of difficulty the exercise exhibits as outlined by Robertson et al.
resistance training and plyometric exercises that were used (34). Before the session, participants were given an RPE goal
in the NMT (Table 3). The NMT program composed of 2, 3 for the session (Table 6), and load was adjusted in accor-
week blocks (Table 4 and 5), in which the movement pattern dance with the prescribed RPE. All training sessions were
remained the same but the volume and exercise complexity monitored by accredited strength and conditioning coaches
were increased in the second block. Exercises in the strength (Australian Strength and Conditioning Association) and
training sections used barbells, medicine balls, and resistance a certified strength and conditioning specialist (CSCS) to
bands. Warm-up sets of each exercise were completed start- ensure that all exercises were performed safely. If the tech-
ing with the lowest weight and incrementally increasing by nique was deemed to be unsafe, appropriate modifications to
1.25-, 2.5-, or 5-kg until working weight was reached, with the training load were made.
technical competency prioritized at all times. As the partic- Statistical Analyses
ipants increased weight over the 6-week period, more warm- Descriptive statistics were reported for all performance and
up sets were required. anthropometric tests. A 2 3 2 (group 3 time) repeated
The OMNI rating of perceived exhaustion (RPE) was measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to com-
used to measure RPE during the strength exercises to pare pretest and posttest values for the control and training
determine the training intensity for each session. Specifically, groups. If significant F values were determined, paired com-
the load lifted was modulated to achieve the prescribed RPE parisons combined with a Holms sequential Bonferroni post
as well as at the discretion of the strength and conditioning hoc adjustment were performed to account for type I errors
to determine differences. Raw difference scores (postbaseline)

Figure 2. Comparison of performance change scores in sprint Figure 4. Comparison of 505 agility change scores between the
performance between the experimental and control conditions. experimental and control conditions. *Significant difference between
*Significant difference between groups (p , 0.02). groups (p , 0.05).

the TM

1170 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM

Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca.com

TABLE 7. NMST individual movement scores


during pre- and post-intervention testing for
experimental and control conditions.*

Experimental Control
(n = 13) (n = 10)

Variables Mean 6 SD Mean 6 SD

Squat
Pre 1.54 6 0.66 1.50 6 0.85
Post 1.77 6 0.72 1.00 6 0.00
Diff 0.23 6 0.60 20.50 6 0.85
Figure 5. Comparison of performance change scores in vertical jump Lunge
performance between the experimental and control conditions. Pre 1.46 6 0.51 1.00 6 0.00
*Significant difference between groups (p , 0.05). Post 2.38 6 0.65 1.30 6 0.48
Diff 0.85 6 0.55 0.30 6 0.48
Twist
Pre 1.62 6 0.51 1.70 6 0.48
were compared with the use of a 1-way ANOVA. Pearsons Post 2.69 6 0.48 2.30 6 0.48
product moment correlation coefficient was used to deter- Diff 1.08 6 0.76 0.70 6 0.48
mine the relationship between selected variables. Statistical Push-up
significance was set at p , 0.05. Effect sizes were calculated Pre 1.25 6 0.45 1.00 6 0.00
Post 1.33 6 0.49 1.10 6 0.32
as Hedges g, because it corrects for small sample biases (7).
Diff 0.08 6 0.49 0.10 6 0.32
Effect sizes were considered as trivial, ,0.20; small, 0.200.50; Bend
medium, 0.500.8; large, 0.81.30; and very large, .1.30 (37). Pre 1.69 6 0.48 1.44 6 0.53
All effect sizes were calculated with 95% confidence intervals Post 2.08 6 0.64 1.89 6 0.33
(CIs). Intraclass correlation coefficient alpha was calculated to Diff 0.38 6 0.87 0.40 6 0.52
Pull
measure between-trial reliability across all measures (17) and
Pre 1.31 6 0.48 1.56 6 0.53
were interpreted as follows; ICCa # 0.20 poor, ICCa = 0.21 Post 1.92 6 0.28 1.89 6 0.33
0.40 fair, ICCa = 0.410.60 moderate, ICCa = 0.610.80 sub- Diff 0.62 6 0.51 0.30 6 0.48
stantial, and ICCa = 0.811.00 almost perfect. All statistical Single leg
analyses were conducted using SPSS (SPSS 23.0.0.0; SPSS squat
Pre 1.08 6 0.28 1.00 6 0.00
Inc., Chicago, IL, USA).
Post 1.31 6 0.48 1.00 6 0.00
Diff 0.23 6 0.60 0.00 6 0.00
RESULTS
Vertical jump A
Twenty-meter Sprint Test Pre 1.54 6 0.52 1.10 6 0.32
When comparing baseline versus postintervention data, there Post 1.69 6 0.48 1.00 6 0.00
Diff 0.15 6 0.56 20.10 6 0.32
were significant group 3 time interactions for 10- and 20-m
Vertical jump B
Pre 1.15 6 0.38 1.10 6 0.38
Post 1.23 6 0.44 1.00 6 0.00
Diff 0.08 6 0.37 20.10 6 0.28
Broad jump
Pre 1.31 6 0.48 1.00 6 0.00
Post 1.77 6 0.44 1.00 6 0.00
Diff 0.46 6 0.52 0.00 6 0.00
ASLR right
Pre 1.31 6 0.63 1.60 6 0.52
Post 2.23 6 0.60 1.30 6 0.48
Diff 0.92 6 0.64 20.30 6 0.48
ASLR left
Pre 1.54 6 0.66 1.10 6 0.32
Post 2.15 6 0.80 1.40 6 0.52
Diff 0.62 6 0.65 0.30 6 0.48

*ASLR = active straight leg raise; NMST = Netball


Figure 6. Comparison of performance change scores in NMST
Movement Screening Tool.
performance between the experimental and control conditions.
*Significant difference between groups (p , 0.05). NMST = Netball
Movement Screening Tool.

VOLUME 31 | NUMBER 5 | MAY 2017 | 1171

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Neuromuscular Training Improves Movement Competency and Performance

Countermovement
Jump Height
TABLE 8. SEBT results during pre- and post-intervention testing for experimental
and control conditions.*
When examining the impact of
the NMT program on vertical
Experimental (n = 13) Control (n = 10) jump performance, there was
a significant main effect for
Variables Mean 6 SD Mean 6 SD
time with both groups increas-
SEBT (anterior right) (m) ing jump height after the 6-
Pre 0.68 6 0.84 0.71 6 0.06 week intervention (p , 0.05).
Post 0.78 6 0.61 0.73 6 0.06 There were no significant
Diff 0.10 6 0.83 0.02 6 0.10 group 3 time effects (p .
SEBT (posteromedial right) (m)
Pre 0.84 6 0.07 0.88 6 0.07 0.05). However, when examin-
Post 0.94 6 0.07 0.83 6 0.08 ing raw difference scores, the
Diff 0.10 6 0.05 20.04 6 0.09 EG demonstrated a significant
SEBT (posterolateral right) (m) and large 0.04-m increase in
Pre 0.91 6 0.07 0.94 6 0.08 their vertical jumping height
Post 0.95 6 0.07 0.94 6 0.08
Diff 0.05 6 0.07 0.00 6 0.10 after the 6-week training inter-
SEBT (anterior left) (m) vention (p # 0.05, g = 0.84;
Pre 0.67 6 0.08 0.73 6 0.08 95% CI 20.01 to 1.70),
Post 0.77 6 0.06 0.72 6 0.05 whereas the CG only displayed
Diff 0.10 6 0.08 20.01 6 0.08 a 0.01 m increase (Figure 5).
SEBT (posteromedial left) (m)
Pre 0.86 6 0.07 0.90 6 1.00 Results of the peak power
Post 0.96 6 0.06 0.87 6 0.10 values obtained showed a sig-
Diff 0.10 6 0.06 20.03 6 8.91 nificant main effect for time
SEBT (posterolateral left) (m) (p , 0.001) with both groups
Pre 0.91 6 0.07 0.96 6 0.08 increasing peak power after
Post 0.98 6 0.06 0.94 6 0.08
Diff 0.07 6 0.09 20.02 6 0.08 the intervention. Data also re-
vealed a significant group 3
*SEBT = Star Excursion Balance Test. time interaction, with the
EG significantly and largely
improving their peak power
values after the intervention
sprint (p # 0.05) performances. Conversely, there were no in comparison with the CG (p , 0.05; g = 1.68; 95%
significant group 3 time interactions for 5-m sprint perfor- CI = 0.722.64).
mance (p . 0.05). Based on post hoc analyses, the EG dem-
onstrated large and significant decreases in 10- and 20-m The Netball Movement Screening Tool
sprint times (p # 0.05, g . 21.2) (Figure 2) in response to Kappa scores for each individual test demonstrated sub-
the 6-week NMT program. stantial to almost perfect agreement between the 2 scorers
Similarly, there were no significant group 3 time inter- (K = 0.610.99). When comparing the effect of the NMT,
actions for the 5-m sprint velocity (p . 0.05); however intervention on the NMST inclusive of the MCS, jump com-
there were significant group 3 time interactions for ponents, and ASLR, there was a significant group 3 time
the 10- and 20-m sprint velocities (p . 0.05). When interaction (p , 0.001). When examining raw difference
raw difference scores were examined, the EG demon- scores, the EG displayed a significant and very large
strated a significant and large increase in sprint velocity improvement in their total NMST score (p , 0.001, g =
over 10- and 20-m sprint times (p . 0.05, g . 1.20) 22.70; 95% CI = 23.84 to 21.57) (Figure 6 and Table 7).
(Figure 3). Raw difference scores on the NMST correlated with the
change scores for the 5 m (r = 20.41, p # 0.05), 10 m (r =
505 Agility 20.49, p # 0.05), 20-m sprint times (r = 20.57, p # 0.01),
There was a significant group 3 time interaction when and 505 change of direction time (r = 0.428, p # 0.05). No
examining the impact of the experimental and CGs on the significant correlations were found between the NMST and
505 change of direction results (p , 0.001). Post hoc analysis vertical jumping height (p # 0.05).
revealed that the EG largely and significantly reduced their Results of the SEBT showed a significant group 3 time
505 sprint time (p . 0.05, g = 20.98; 95% CI 21.85 to interaction for the anterior reach and posteromedial reach
20.10), whereas the CG displayed an increase in their times position for both the right and left legs (p # 0.05). Follow-up
(Figure 4). tests revealed that the EG anterior and posteromedial reach
the TM

1172 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM

Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca.com

was significantly further than the CG for both the right and NMT program that is designed to improve performance in
left legs (p # 0.05). Conversely, no significant group 3 time untrained female athletes.
interaction was found for the posterolateral reach direction After the NMT program, both the experimental (+0.04 m)
for the right leg (p . 0.05). However, a significant group 3 and CGs (+0.01 m) improved their vertical jump; however,
time interaction was found for the left leg (p # 0.05). Follow- the EG made a much larger and significantly greater
up tests revealed that the EG significantly improved their improvement. This finding is in agreement with the work
reach in the posterolateral direction for their left leg only by Myer et al. (27) who reported that adolescent female
(p # 0.05), whereas the CG decreased their reach (Table 8). athletes were able to improve their vertical jump by
0.03 m in response to a 6-week NMT program. Similarly,
DISCUSSION Chappell et al. (6) found a 0.04 m improvement in vertical
The main findings of this study were that the 6-week NMT jump after an NMT program in college-aged female athletes.
intervention significantly improved sprint and change of Both of these studies incorporated a combination of balance,
direction speed, CMJ height and peak, and movement resistance and plyometric exercises. A key component of the
competency in 1114-year-old netball players. The CG did NMT program outlined by Myer et al. (27) is that the resis-
not show any significant improvements in any of the phys- tance training exercises used were all executed under load.
ical performance measures or movement competency assess- Similarly, this study also used a combination of plyometric
ments during the course of the 6-week intervention. and resistance training exercises which were performed
After the completion of the 6-week NMT program, data under load. Based on the work by Myer et al. (27) and the
revealed that the EG performed significantly better than the data from this study, it seems that NMT programs which use
CG in all physical performance tests. Although the EG progressive overload are more effective at improving perfor-
decreased their sprint time in response to the training, the mance and movement competency as a result of systemati-
CG became significantly slower across the 5, 10, and 20 m cally increasing strength levels. It is important to note that
distances as noted by the increase in sprint time and Lesinski et al. (21) recently reported that youth athletes
decrease in sprint velocity. Although there was no statistical exhibit the greatest strength improvements in response to
difference in 5-m sprint time, it should be acknowledged that higher training intensities when movement quality and tech-
the EG maintained their 5 m sprinting speed after the nical competency is upheld. Therefore, the inclusion of a pro-
intervention. These findings are consistent with the work by gressive resistance training program to an NMT program
Myer et al. (27) who reported that adolescent female athletes may be imperative to improve jumping performance in
improved their sprint times in the 9.1 m sprint by 0.07 sec- youth athletes. The data collected in this study reveal that
onds after a 6-week NMT intervention. A meta-analysis by the CG also displayed a small improvement in vertical jump
Rumpf et al. (35) found that plyometric training was the performance (+0.01 m), although this was not statistically
superior training method in improving sprint time in pre- significant. One possible explanation for this finding is that
and mid-pubertal male youth, whereas postpubertal males all participants were participating in regular netball training
benefited from a combined training method. However, after throughout the study. As playing netball would require some
puberty, sex-differences in muscular strength begin to jumping performance during games and practice, it is likely
emerge, with males experiencing natural increases in muscu- that this may have contributed to the improvement in ver-
lar power, strength, and coordination that are not commonly tical jump of 0.01 m over the 6 weeks in the CG. However,
seen in females (24). Furthermore, the loss of neuromuscular results of this study indicate that the inclusion of the NMT
control females experience after puberty (15) may indicate program resulted in superior vertical jump improvements
the need for an integrative NMT program inclusive of when compared with netball training alone, thus suggesting
strength training and plyometric training to improve perfor- that youth netball players should incorporate NMT as part
mance. Results of this study shows that the inclusion of of their performance programs.
strength training exercises to improve lower-body strength When examining the 5-0-5 change of direction test, the
and power may be an important component of improving EG was able to largely and significantly decrease their
sprinting performance in youth female athletes. The NMT change of direction time after the 6-week NMT intervention,
program used in the study by Myer et al. (27) incorporated whereas the CG increased their change of direction time.
strength training exercises as part of the integrated NMT These findings agree with previous research that found
program (i.e., plyometrics, balance, and strength training). youth male soccer athletes were able to significantly
The strength training program incorporated back squats, decrease their change of direction time after completing
bench presses, lateral pull-downs, shoulder presses, Russian a plyometric training program (43). The NMT program used
hamstring curls, and various isolation exercises, which were in this study incorporated a small plyometric component
similar to the strength training exercises used in this study. with a larger emphasis on resistance training, indicating that
Taken collectively, the work by Myer et al. (1) and the data the improvements in change of direction speed may have
from this study seem to suggest that strength training, which been a combination of both the plyometric and resistance
targets the lower body is an important component of an training. Change of direction speed is largely affected by

VOLUME 31 | NUMBER 5 | MAY 2017 | 1173

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Neuromuscular Training Improves Movement Competency and Performance

sprinting speed, movement efficiency, and muscular strength cises, while also incorporating plyometric, agility, and bal-
(21). The NMT program in this study included resistance ance training. This study did not incorporate any specific
training exercises to improve lower-body strength and balance training as part of the NMT program, indicating that
power with a focus on movement quality and technical effi- the strength components and plyometric training alone were
ciency. This may indicate that resistance training may play enough to improve dynamic balance without inclusion of
a bigger role in improving speed than plyometric training in specific balance exercises. Thereby, the inclusion of resis-
youth female netball athletes. tance training exercises to improve full body strength seems
After completion of the NMT program, the EG signifi- to be a very important component of NMT programs. Prop-
cantly improved their score on the NMST and had erly designed and implemented NMT programs that focus
a significant increase on their dynamic balance reach on improving movement efficiency, motor coordination and
distance in the 2 SEBT directions. These results are in neuromuscular control, and thus performance measures are
accordance with the findings of Klusemann et al. (18) who paramount to successful performance netball practice and
found that after a resistance training program, junior basket- competition.
ball athletes were able to improve their FMS scores. Based
on the work by Klusemann et al. (18) and the data from this PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS
study, it seems that when youth athletes exhibit movement Netball is a game reliant on rapid acceleration, deceleration,
deficiencies, the incorporation of an NMT program that in- and change of direction in combination with short bouts of
cludes resistance training seems to be a valuable tool for sprinting, lateral movements, jumping, landing, lunging, and
improving movement competency, which may directly leaping movements. The game is high intensity in nature and
impact performance. Lloyd et al. (23) investigated if a rela- requires athletes to possess among other physical qualities,
tionship exists between FMS scores and physical perfor- lower-body power, sprinting, change of direction speed, and
mance in youth male soccer athletes. Their findings strength and technical competency. Completion of an
showed moderate-to-strong (r = 0.40.7) correlations integrative NMT program is important for their athletic
between the individual components of the FMS and meas- development to prepare them for the high-intensity nature
ures of physical performance inclusive of jumping height, of the game and to improve performance in netball practice
agility, and reactive strength index. Results of this study and competition. This study suggests that acute beneficial
affirm that a strong correlation exists between movement adaptations (6 weeks) in CMJ height and peak power output
competency, sprinting, and change of direction speed in during jumping, sprinting performance, change of direction
youth female netball athletes. Strong negative correlations speed, and movement efficiency in youth female netball
were found between improved scores on the NMST and athletes were elicited through an NMT program that used
decreased times in the 5-, 10-, and 20-m sprint, and 5-0-5 progressive resistance training in combination with plyo-
change of direction task. Based on these findings, it seems metric training 3 times per week. Because of the decrease in
that an NMT program that focuses on improving movement neuromuscular control in female athletes after puberty and
competency may be associated with improved performance heightened injury risk, this training study may also decrease
capacity in youth netball athletes. Furthermore, the NMST the potential for injury risk in netball by improving
may be a useful test to predict physical performance capa- neuromuscular control, motor coordination, and dynamic
bilities in youth female netball athletes. joint stability as indicated by the improvements in the
The NMST was created specifically to replicate the movement screen performed in this study. Given the
movement patterns evident in netball and as such included short-term nature of this study, practitioners are advised
a specific jump component. When examining the jump that to facilitate long-term adaptation, systematic changes in
scores independently, the EG improved their score, whereas training prescription are required ideally as part of a long-
the CG decreased their score. These results indicate the term athletic development plan (22).
NMT program was effective in improving jumping and
landing efficiency in youth netball athletes. This improve- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ment in jumping and landing quality may be due to The authors wish to thank the coaches, players, and parents
improved motor performance because of neural adaptations from the clubs involved in the data collection and Carl
from the NMT program. A meta-analysis by Behringer et al. Woods for his assistance with the movement screen
(3) showed that resistance training is a very effective tool for methodology. The results of this study do not constitute
improving motor performance in youth athletes. Specifically, and endorsement by the authors or the National Strength
children made greater gains in motor skill performance in and Conditioning Association.
comparison with adolescents. Similarly, McLoad et al. (25)
also found that after a 6-week NMT program, high school
REFERENCES
female athletes were able to significantly improve their reach
1. Bahr, R. Why screening tests to predict injury do not workand
distance on the SEBT. The NMT program used by McLoad probably never will.: A critical review. Br J Sports Med 50: 776
et al. (25) placed a large emphasis on strengthening exer- 780, 2016.
the TM

1174 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
the TM

Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research | www.nsca.com

2. Barber, OR, Thomas, C, Jones, PA, McMahon, JJ, and Comfort, P. 21. Lesinski, M, Prieske, O, and Granacher, U. Effects and dose-
Reliability of the 505 change of direction test in netball players. Int J response relationships of resistance training on physical
Sports Physiol Perform 11: 377380, 2015. performance in youth athletes: A systematic review and meta-
3. Behringer, M, Vom Heede, A, Matthews, M, and Mester, J. analysis. Br J Sports Med 50: 781795, 2016.
Effects of strength training on motor performance skills in 22. Lloyd, R, Oliver, JL, Meyers, RW, Moody, J, and Stone, M. Long-
children and adolescents: A meta-analysis. Pediatr Exerc Sci 23: term athletic development and its application to youth weightlifting.
186206, 2011. J Strength Cond Res 34: 5566, 2012.
4. Caruso, JF, Daily, JS, McLagan, JR, Shepherd, CM, Olson, NM, 23. Lloyd, RS, Oliver, JL, Radnor, JM, Rhodes, BC, Faigenbaum, AD,
Marshall, MR, and Taylor, ST. Data reliability from an and Myer, GD. Relationships between functional movement screen
instrumented vertical jump platform. J Strength Cond Res 24: scores, maturation and physical performance in young soccer
27992808, 2010. players. J Sports Sci 33: 1119, 2015.
5. Chandler, PT, Pinder, SJ, Curran, JD, and Gabbett, TJ. Physical 24. Llyod, R, Faigenbaum, A, Stone, M, Oliver, J, Jefferys, I, Moody, J,
demands of training and competition in collegiate netball players. J Brewer, C, Pierce, K, McCambridge, T, Howard, R, Herrington, L,
Strength Cond Res 28: 27322737, 2014. Hainline, B, Micheli, LJ, Jaques, R, Kraemer, WJ, McBride, M, Best,
6. Chappell, JD and Limpisvasti, O. Effect of a neuromuscular training TM, Chu, DA, Alvar, B, and Myer, GD. Position statement on youth
program on the kinetics and kinematics of jumping tasks. Am J resistance training: The 2014 international consensus. Br J Sports
Sports Med 36: 10811086, 2008. Med 48: 498505, 2013.
7. Cumming, G. Understanding the New Statistics: Effect Sizes, 25. McLeod, T, Armstrong, T, Miller, M, and Sauers, JL. Balance
Confidence Intervals, and Meta-analysis. New York, NY: improvements in female high school basketball players after
Routledge, 2013. a 6-week neuromuscular-training program. J Sport Rehabil 18:
465481, 2009.
8. Davidson, A and Trewartha, G. Understanding the physiological
demands of netball: A time-motion investigation. Int J Perform Anal 26. Myer, GD, Chu, DA, Brent, JL, and Hewett, TE. Trunk and hip
Sport 8: 117, 2008. control neuromuscular training for the prevention of knee joint
injury. Clin Sports Med 27: 425448, 2008.
9. Dorrel, BS, Long, T, Shaffer, S, and Myer, GD. Evaluation of the
functional movement screen as an injury prediction tool among 27. Myer, GD, Ford, KR, Palumbo, J, and Hewett, TE. Neuromuscular
active adult populations a systematic review and meta-analysis. training improves performance and lower extremity biomechanics in
Sports Health 7: 532537, 2015. female athletes. J Strength Cond Res 19: 5160, 2005.
10. Faigenbaum, AD, Farrell, A, Fabiano, M, Radler, T, Naclerio, F, 28. Naclerio, F and Faigenbaum, A. Integrative neuromuscular training
Ratamess, NA, Kang, J, and Myer, GD. Effects of integrative for youth. Kronos 10: 4956, 2011.
neuromuscular training on fitness performance in children. Pediatr 29. Noyes, FR, Barber-Westin, SD, Smith, ST, Campbell, T, and
Exerc Sci 23: 573584, 2011. Garrison, TT. A training program to improve neuromuscular and
11. Flood, L and Harrison, JE. Epidemiology of basketball and netball performance indices in female high school basketball players. J
injuries that resulted in hospital admission in Australia, 20002004. Strength Cond Res 26: 709719, 2012.
Med J Aust 190: 8790, 2009. 30. Nuzzo, JL, Anning, JH, and Scharfenberg, JM. The reliability of
12. Hagglund, M, Atroshi, I, Wagner, P, and Walden, M. Superior three devices used for measuring vertical jump height. J Strength
compliance with a neuromuscular training programme Cond Res 25: 25802590, 2011.
is associated with fewer ACL injuries and fewer acute 31. Parsonage, JR, Williams, RS, Rainer, P, McKeown, I, and
knee injuries in female adolescent football players: Williams, MD. Assessment of conditioning-specific movement
Secondary analysis of an RCT. Br J Sports Med 47: 974949, tasks and physical fitness measures in talent identified under 16-
2013. year-old rugby union players. J Strength Cond Res 28: 14971506,
13. Hertogh, C and Hue, O. Jump evaluation of elite volleyball players 2014.
using two methods: Jump power equations and force platform. J 32. Quagliarella, L, Sasanelli, N, Belgiovine, G, Moretti, L, and
Sports Med Phys Fitness 42: 300303, 2002. Moretti, B. Power output estimation in vertical jump performed by
14. Hewett, TE. Biomechanical measures of neuromuscular control and young male soccer players. J Strength Cond Res 25: 16381646,
valgus loading of the knee predict anterior cruciate ligament injury 2011.
risk in female athletes: A prospective study. Am J Sports Med 33: 33. Reid, D, Vanweerd, R, and Kingstone, R. The inter and intra
492501, 2005. reliability of the netball movement screening tool. J Sci Med Sport
15. Hewett, TE, Myer, GD, and Ford, KR. Decrease in neuromuscular 18: 353357, 2014.
control about the knee with maturation in female athletes. J Bone 34. Robertson, RJ, Goss, FL, Aaron, DJ, Gairola, A, Kowallis, RA,
Joint Surg Am 86-A: 16011608, 2004. Liu, Y, Randall, CR, Tessmer, KA, Schnorr, TL, and Schroeder,
16. Hoffman, JR and Kang, J. Evaluation of a new anaerobic AE. One repetition maximum prediction models for children
power testing system. J Strength Cond Res 16: 142148, 2002. using the OMNI RPE scale. J Strength Cond Res 22: 196201,
17. Hopkins, WG. Reliability from construct pairs of trials (Excel 2008.
spreadsheet). In: A new view of statistics sportsciorg: Internet Society for 35. Rumpf, MC, Cronin, JB, Oliver, J, and Hughes, M. Effect of different
Sport Science. sportsci.org/resources/stats/xrely.xls, 2000. training methods on running sprint times in male youth. Pediatr
18. Klusemann, MJ, Pyne, DB, Fay, TS, and Drinkwater, EJ. Online Exerc Sci 24: 170186, 2012.
videobased resistance training improves the physical capacity 36. Sayers, SP, Harackiewicz, DV, Harman, EA, Frykman, PN, and
of junior basketball athletes. J Strength Cond Res 26: 26772684, Rosenstein, MT. Cross-validation of three jump power equations.
2012. Med Sci Sports Exerc 31: 572577, 1999.
19. Landis, JR and Koch, GG. The measurement of observer agreement 37. Seitz, LB, Trajano, GS, and Haff, GG. The back squat and the power
for categorical data. Biometrics 31: 159174, 1977. clean: Elicitation of different degrees of potentiation. Int J Sports
20. Leard, JS, Cirillo, MA, Katsnelson, E, Kimiatek, DA, Miller, TW, Physiol Perform 9: 643649, 2014.
Trebincevic, K, and Garbalosa, JC. Validity of two alternative 38. Shultz, R, Anderson, SC, Matheson, GO, Marcello, B, and Besier, T.
systems for measuring vertical jump height. J Strength Cond Res 21: Test-Retest and interrater reliability of the functional movement
12961299, 2007. screen. J Athletic Train 48: 331336, 2013.

VOLUME 31 | NUMBER 5 | MAY 2017 | 1175

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Neuromuscular Training Improves Movement Competency and Performance

39. Smith, R, Damodaran, AK, Swaminathan, S, Campbell, R, and 42. Taylor, KL, Bonetti, DL, and Tanner, RK. Netball Payers. In:
Barnsley, L. Hypermobility and sports injuries in junior netball Physiological tests for elite athletes. Tanner, R and Gore, C, eds.
players. Br J Sports Med 39: 628631, 2005. Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics, 2013. pp. 341352.
40. Steele, JR. Biomechanical factors affecting performance in netball. 43. Thomas, K, French, D, and Hayes, PR. The effect of two plyometric
Implications for improving performance and injury reduction. J training techniques on muscular power and agility in youth soccer
Sports Med 10: 88102, 1990. players. J Strength Cond Res 23: 332335, 2009.
41. Stewart, PF, Turner, AN, and Miller, SC. Reliability, factorial 44. Waldron, M, Worsfold, P, Twist, C, and Lamb, K. Concurrent
validity, and interrelationships of five commonly used change validity and test-retest reliability of a global positioning system
of direction speed tests. Scand J Med Sci Sports 24: 500506, (GPS) and timing gates to assess sprint performance variables. J
2012. Sports Sci 29: 16131619, 2011.

the TM

1176 Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen