United States Patent 1%
Avitzur
tn 3,934,446
(45) Jan. 27, 1976
[54] METHODS OF AND APPARATUS FOR
PRODUCTION OF WIRE
[76] Inventor: Betzalel Avitzur, 817 N. 31st St
Allentown, Pa. 18104
[22] Filed: Apr. 16, 1974
[21] Appl. No. 461,307
[52] US. Ch. 72/206; 72/262
(51) Int. cL B21B 21/00
[38] Field of Search . 72/206, 256, 262, 263,
72/92, 93, 64, 65, 233, 231
186] References Cited
UNITED STATES PATENTS
3,143,786 8/1964 Jones 72/206
3.186.943 5/1965 Ware 72/206
3,525,096 8/1970 Klenz. 72/206
765,216 10/1973 Green 727262
Primary Examiner—C. W. Lanham
Assistant Examiner—Robert M. Rogers
Atorney, Agent, or Firm—Seidel, Gonda &
Goldhammer
[57] ABSTRACT
Methods of and apparatus for the production of wire
are presented. Previously, the most economic and
popular process was drawing. In each pass, a small re-
duction was obtained and normally several dies in tan-
dem were mounted on a single wire drawing machine
The process was continuous ahd precision wire was
made. Also in the prior art, traditional rolling was a
continuous process, but was limited to heavy and me-
dium gauge, to small reductions per pass, and to poor
dimensional and surface control. In comparison, tradi-
tional extrusion and hydrostatic extrusion are capable
of large reductions, good dimensional control and sur-
face finish, but are limited to finite wire or rod length.
The more’ recent concepts of: continuous extrusion
with viscous drag, continuous chamber extrusion, con-
tinuous extrusion forming, combined hydrostatic ex-
trusion and drawing for fine wire and helical extrusion
are compared and their advantages and shortcomings
are discussed,
A family of new processes of and apparatus for
combining extrusion and rolling, utilizing the friction
drag provided by rolling with open chamber extrusion
is described. A continuous process, with large
reductions and good dimensional control, can be
achieved.
22 Claims, 17 Drawing Figures
0 |.
5 fe
“f3,934,446
U.S. Patent Jan. 27, 1976 Sheet 1 of 10U.S. Patent Jan. 27,1976 Sheet 20f 10 3,934,446
FIG. 2U.S. Patent Jan. 27,1976 Sheet 3010 3,934,446
FIG. 3
FIG. 5
FIG. 4 FIG. 6U.S. Patent
Jan. 27, 1976
Sheet 4 of 10
NG
FIG. 7
3,934,446U.S. Patent Jan. 27,1976 Sheet 5 of 10 3,934,446
I |
| |
x 3 fl
i li 59
Oe
FIG. 8U.S. Patent Jan. 27,1976 Sheet 6 of 10 33,934,446U.S. Patent Jan. 27,1976 Sheet 70f 10 3,934,446U.S. Patent Jan. 27,1976 Sheet 80f 10 3,934,446
an
1 MN
! |
| | |
HAW ANAT |
Z-|
4 5, Hi
( ¢ ]
\
|
1 iii
N Z :
LAMM MI
idl,
Til,
FIG. 1U.S. Patent Jan. 27,1976 Sheet 90f 10: 3,934,446U.S. Patent Jan. 27, 1976 Sheet 10 of 10
FIG. /4a
FIG. 146
3,934,4463,934,446
1
METHODS OF AND APPARATUS FOR
PRODUCTION OF WIRE
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates methods of and apparatus for
the production of wire. Accordingly, it is a general
“object of this invention to provide new and improved
‘methods and apparatus of such character.
2. Description of the Prior Art
a. Forward
In the production of wire and rod of all shapes and
cross sections, the processes of wire drawing, rod roll:
ing and extrusion are the conventional production
methods. One or the other of the following two limiting.
factors plagues each of these processes. By the pro-
cesses of wire or rod drawing or rolling one can accom-
plish only small reductions per pass. For larger redue-
tions, successive passes must be followed. The process,
however, can then be done as a steady state continuous
process with little interruptions. In the process of extru-
sion, larger reductions can be made in a single pass, but
only finite lengths can be extruded and the process is
intermittent,
In the search for a truly continuous process, with
large reductions per pass, the following four recent
processes were proposed and developed:
I. Continuous Extrusion with Viscous Drag by Fuchs
— See: Fuchs, F. J., Wire Jr, 105 October, (1970)
2. Continuous Chamber Extrusion by Fuchs — See:
Fuchs, F. J., and Schmebl, G. L., “Continuous
Hydrostatic Extrusion”, presented and published,
NEL/AIRAPT International Conference on Hydro:
static Extrusion, University of Sterling, Scotland,
June 13-15, 1973.
3. Continuous Extrusion Forming by Green — See:
Green, D., “Continuous Extrusion - Forming of
Wire Sections”, Jr. of the Inst. of Metals, Vol. 100,
1972
4. Combined Extrusion Drawing for Fine Wire.
Eash process is described briefly, its concept ex-
plained and its shortcomings pointed out.
. Continuous Extrusion with Viscous Drag
The development by Dr. Fuchs of Western Electric,
as reported in Wire Jr., 105 (1970), utilizes viscous
drag as the motivating force for the extrusion of contin-
‘uous rod of aluminum or copper. In principle, the liq-
uid passing through a narrow gap between a chamber
and a rod drags the rod forward by viscous drag. To
maintain flow, a pressure drop prevails between the
pressure at an'entrance on the back side of the cham-
ber and an exit at the front. Only a small differential
pressure can be maintained in each chamber. The dif-
Terence in pressure between entrance and exit must be
below the flow strength of the workpiece material to
prevent pinch off. Thus, only low drag and small reduc-
tions can be made by the use of a single chamber. In
fone embodiment, the chambers are piggybacked in
tandem to effect large reductions. The highest-pressure
chamber is in front, discharging through a passage into
a lower-pressure chamber behind it. The discharge
from chamber to chamber proceeds, until at the last
chamber, the exit pressure is atmospheric. Thus, if the
entrance pressure to the first chamber is (say) 200,000
psi, a gradual drop prevails toward the entrance to the
chamber at the back. Because of the forward motion of
the rod, a small gap around the rod at the walls between
5
1s
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
55
60
65
chambers does not leak. A rolled or extruded rod could,
be reduced to final telephone wire size in a single die by
a single pass,
This process was apparently abandoned due to poor
efficiency. The applicant has calculated the expected
power consumed by shear in the liquid itself and has
determined that maximum efficiency expected theoret-
ically is in the vicinity of 30%. This 30% efficiency
could only be achieved when pressure approaches in-
finity and the gap between the rod and the chamber
approaches zero. Such conditions can not exist in prac-
tice. Furthermore, approaching such conditions, the
process becomes very unstable and any change in pres
sure oF size of the rod throws the process out of bal-
‘Thus, due to inefficiency, such process becomes un-
acceptable for economical production application.
¢. Continuous Chamber Extrusion
To avert the shortcomings of the continuous viscous
drag extrusion, a continuous segmented chamber ex-
truder, has been developed, as reported by Fuchs, F.J.,
and Schmehl, G. L., “Continuous Hydrostatic Extru”
sion”, presented and published, NEL/AIRAPT Interna-
tional Conference on Hydrostatic Extrusion, University
of Sterling, Scotland, June 13-15, 1973. The continu-
‘ous chamber is made from matching segments moving
in a chainlike manner. Four circumferentially seg-
mented parts form together a short length of the cham-
ber. Longitudinally, many segments form the length of
the chamber which is open on both ends. The segments
move together parallel to the axis of symmetry of the
chamber. They separate at the exit in order to get away
from the chamber they formed and then return to the
entrance side where they meet again to form the cham-
ber with their matching counter-parts. A die is set at
the exit and a rod is fed at the entrance. The rod is
squeezed and dragged by the segmented chamber,
moving with it towards the die. To enhance the drag,
the rod is coated with plastic material before entering
the machine. The rod is machined to close tolerances
before coating to fit snugly in the chamber. As the rod
reaches the die, the drag produces enough pressure to
force extrusion through the die, Very little relative
motion is expected between the moving chamber and
the rod, so that friction losses are minimized
‘The motivation mechanism to mobilize the chamber
components and the matching of the components re-
quires a high degree of precision. Cleanliness must be
maintained to avoid gaps between the matching seg-
ments, through which fins from the deforming work-
piece might squeeze. Besides being precision made, the
mechanism must be highly rigid to produce and with-
stand the high operating pressures and forces,
Preparation of the raw material to enter the machine
(dimensioning and coating) and the watchmakers’ pre
cision, combined with massivity demands from the
production machine parts and assembly, are the major
shortcomings of such machines.
d. Continuous Extrusion Forming
‘A development by D. Green of the British Atomic
Energy Agency, reported at “Continuous Extrusion-
Forming of Wire Sections”, Jr. of the Inst. of Metals,
Vol 100, 1972, employs friction between a workpiece
and a tool as the motivating force for continuous extru-
sion. There, in an explanatory model which describes
the principles, a die with a hole is attached to a station
ary platen. A top platen with a square groove is
mounted over the bottom stationary platen. Together,3,934,
3
they form a square chamber with a block closing the
left end; the hole in the block is the die opening. The
right end of the chamber is open. A round rod is placed
in the chamber, touching at the four surfaces. Then, the
top platen is made to slide towards the die, Friction 5
from the three sides of the moving platen drags the rod
toward the die, where the rod is blocked, Please note
that friction from the top platen exceeds and over-
comes resistance by friction from the bottom platen.
The friction effect on the rod is to upset the rod. The
more the rod is upset, the more effective the friction
drag becomes. As it comes closer and closer to the die,
more contact prevails between the workpiece and the
four walls. At the die, the round original rod has al-
ready deformed into a square rod. Pressure is high
enough to effect an extrusion through the die. As a
bonus, the design is made so as to leave a small gap
between the die block and the moving platen, Through
this gap, a thin chip is discarded, removing the unde
sired surface of the rod. Standard extruded or rolled
stock serves as the workpiece
When the stationary platen is replaced by a station-
ary semi-circular member, and the moving platen by a
rotating cylindrical tool, a continuous process is estab-
lished.
The two major factors restricting the efficiency of
such process are the redundant work of upsetting the
incoming wire and friction losses. The redundant work
is due to an upsetting of the original round wire to a
square (and then starting from a square rather than a
round — through the die). This work is independent of
the attempted reduction. The friction losses in the
square channel depend both on friction values and on
reduction
e. Combined Extrusion Drawing for Fine Wire
‘One of the shortcomings of the process of hydrostatic
extrusion is the finite length of an extruded billet. Since
the process of wire drawing has the advantage of being
a continuous process, the problem of overcoming the
batch-interrupted nature of hydrostatic extrusion has
long been with us.
When a spool of wire is inserted into a cylindrical
chamber, longer runs can be made. Simple spools can
20
2s
30
35
40
446
4
be used, and spinning reels and standing reels have
been explored at Battelle, as set forth in U.S. Pat. No.
3,328,998, “High Reduction Drawing”, By Sabroff, A.
M., and Fiorentino, R. J. — July, 1967, and by Pugh of
the National Engineering Laboratories in Scotland, in
“The Mechanical Behavior of Materials Under Pres-
sure”, FIG. 41 of Chapter 9, “Hydrostatic Extrusion”,
Elsevier Materials Science Series, 1970, Pugh, H. Ll.
D., (Editor). When the extrusion pressure is aug-
mented by a pull, a Robertson process is provided, as
described by J. Robertson at “Method of and Appara.
tus for Forming Metal Articles”, British Pat. No.
19,356, October 14, 1893; U.S. Pat. No. 524,504, Au:
gust 14, 1894, Hundreds of thousands of feet of fine
wire, (<0,001 inch), used in the solid state industries,
can be spooled and inserted into a % inch bore cham:
ber to provide very long runs between loadings. Deli-
instrumentation to relate chamber pressure to
augmenting tension controls is essential for such equip-
ment. Development work along these lines is followed
internationally. With present day limited chamber size,
only very fine wire production is expected to be eco-
nomically competitive for this process.
It should be noted that very long wire can be made,
but the process is not a truly continuous process.
£. Helical Extrusion
Another process by Green is called Helical Extru.
sion. There, hydrostatic extrusion is combined with a
chip forming process to produce a small gauge wire (of
all shapes) directly from an ingot. Reductions of thou-
sands to one are obtained. Because of the involved
concept, this prior-art process is not described herein.
Very long wire can be made, but the process is not truly
continuous. Each ingot is loaded separately.
g. Comparisons of Alternate Processes
In Table I, the alternate possible processes for the
production of wire and rod are tabulated vertically,
Criteria for the comparison of major characteristics of
those processes are listed horizontally, thus obviating
the necessity for deliberation. The process of “extroll-
ing” the newly proposed process of this invention, in
included,
TABL
‘COMPARISONS OF ALTERNATE PROCESSES
Power” Design Dimensional,
Property Product Reduction oth charac surtuce ia Other
Process engi possible” Speed _clency _terisics femal damage comments
Roig Un Small High High Simpl, fow mov Poor
limited ing pars. rugged
Conventional ‘Short Large Moderate Moderate Simple, few tow aie
‘extrusion ing pars rugged
Wire Ue Sell gh oigh Sa Goo
Graing Vimitod
Contintous Un Large Very Excess: Complicated, but Good “Limite only by ability
fxtrsion with Dito Right ely few moving ports to collect product
Sissons drag oor
Continuovt Un. Larger” Moderate Esimed Complicated, many —