Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
www.elsevier.com/locate/ceramint
Received 18 February 2002; received in revised form 3 March 2002; accepted 10 November 2002
Abstract
Reaction-bonded Al2O3 (RBAO) ceramics were fabricated from attrition-milled Al/Al2O3 powder mixtures. Two dierent Al
precursor powders and several contents of Al were used. The raw materials and the RBAO powder mixtures were studied in terms
of grain size, oxidation behaviour (TGA/DTA), morphology and microstructure. The inuence of the important parameters con-
trolling the RBAO process is rst discussed. Secondly, the microstructure of RBAO bodies uniaxially pressed and heat-treated in
air, up to 1100 and 1250 C, is reported and their mechanical strength is evaluated and compared to conventional Al2O3 ceramics.
# 2003 Elsevier Ltd and Techna S.r.l. All rights reserved.
Keywords: A. Milling; A. Sintering; C. Strength; D. Al2O3
Fig. 1. SEM of the powders used in the present work: (a) Al2O3 powder, (b) AlC akes powder and (c) AlE globular powder.
S. Bertrand et al. / Ceramics International 29 (2003) 735744 737
the content of the hard Al2O3 particles which assist the the oxidation of AlC aky powder into alumina takes
plastic deformation and the fragmentation of the Al place in the range 300600 C, in the solid state and
particles [9] (batches #4 and #2). In the batch #2, the then at T > 660 C, in the liquid phase, whereas AlE
long attrition-milling time (24 h) has been ecient to globular powder is primarily oxidised at T > 660 C, i.e
reduce strongly the size and the ake shape of the Alc in the liquid phase. As the theoretical relative weight
particles. gain for a full oxidation of the aluminium through the
reaction:
3.2. Heat treatment
4=3Al O2 2=3Al2 O3
The TGA curves, up to 1400 C, show that the two
aluminium raw powders present dierent oxidation is m/m0=0.89, it appears, from the previous results,
behaviours (Fig. 4a). The maximum relative weight that the AlC metal surfaces seem initially to be more
gains are 0.72 (0.78 when corrected by the initial weight oxidised than the AlE ones. The dierence in morpho-
loss) and 0.86 for AlC and AlE respectively. Moreover, logy between the AlC and AlE particles can explain this
S. Bertrand et al. / Ceramics International 29 (2003) 735744 739
phenomenon, but especially the specic area values of of the specic area values is also responsible for the
the Al powders. Indeed, it seems normal that the Al2O3 oxidation behaviour of the two aluminium raw materi-
oxide layer formed by surface contact with air is more als. Indeed, the high specic area of the AlC particles
important for the AlC particles, with the higher specic permits an increase of aluminium oxidation in the solid
area than for the AlE powder. So, the oxidation state. Finally, between room temperature and 300 C,
potential during reaction-bonding for AlC particles the weight loss reveals the evaporation of fugitive spe-
should be lower than for AlE powder. This dierence cies (such as H2O).
740 S. Bertrand et al. / Ceramics International 29 (2003) 735744
For all the TGA curves of the powder mixtures (Fig. 4a), the batches #4#6, exhibiting similar commi-
(Fig. 4b), the oxidation rate is rst very high, but at nution of the AlE particles, are now oxidised both in the
about 580 C it slows down and increases again above solid and liquid states. It is interesting to note that,
the melting temperature of Al, until at about 900 when milling time increases, for the same composition
1000 C oxidation is complete. According to these of RBAO mixture, the fraction of Al oxidised below the
curves the aluminium, in the milled powder mixtures, is melting temperature of Al increases strongly (compar-
oxidised through solid-gas and liquid-gas reactions. In ison of batches #5 and #6). The attrition milling of the
particular, whereas the raw AlE globular aluminium has AlE particles is responsible of this behaviour change. The
shown principally an oxidation step in the liquid state decrease of the AlE particle size and the modication of
S. Bertrand et al. / Ceramics International 29 (2003) 735744 741
3.3. Microstructure and mechanical properties lity of the Nextel bres is limited: for example, the use
temperature of the Nextel 720 bre is 1204 C [17].
The selected RBAO heat-treatment to prepare the Thats why, to process Nextel/RBAO composites, the
three-point bending samples consists of several heating sintering treatment of the RBAO matrix will not exceed
rates (0.251 C/min), with four holds for 1 h up to 12001250 C.
1100 C and a nal hold for 3 h at 1250 C. The holds The RBAO sample obtained from the batch #2 sin-
at 500 and 600 C promote Al to Al2O3 oxidation in tered at 1250 C shows an homogeneous microstructure,
the solid state whereas the ones at 700 and 1100 C with a ne alumina grain size (Fig. 6a). The large frag-
complete the oxidation in the liquid phase and the sin- mentation of the Alc particles and the de-agglomeration
tering of porous samples . The hold at 1250 C was to of the powder mixture (Al/Al2O3 volume ratio: 40/60)
sinter more dense samples. Cooling rate of the cycle permits to obtain a sample with a very small grain size.
was 1 C/min. The lower heating rate of the cycle The RBAO sample obtained from the batch #4 (Al/
(0.25 C/min) is used between 450 and 1100 C in order Al2O3 volume ratio: 60/40) sintered at 1100 C is also
to solve the problem of sample cracking, which is most characterised by rather equiaxed and ne alumina
often encountered at high aluminium contents (> 45 grains (Fig. 6b). Here again, this is the result of the
vol.%) [7]. Indeed, a recent work [16] has shown that, fragmentation of the AlE particles of the mixture during
to avoid sample cracking, the heating rate in the tem- the milling process. Finally, the microstructure of the
perature range of 450600 C should be reduced to RBAO sample obtained from the batch #6 (Al/Al2O3
41 C/min. The maximum sintering temperature dur- volume ratio: 80/20) sintered at 1250 C reects the
ing the last hold was deliberately chosen 41250 C. specic morphology produced by a large fragmentation
Indeed, one of the possible applications of the RBAO of the AlE particles of the powder mixture. Small
ceramics is the processing of oxide/oxide composites, as equiaxed alumina grains are observed as well as small
Nextel/Al2O3 composites. However, the thermal stabi- alumina grains with a rather ake shape (Fig. 6c).
The bending strength of porous RBAO samples (bat- strength observed cannot be justied by this aw size
ches #2, 4, 5, 6), together with that of conventional [18] argument because the grain size of the conventional
porous Al2O3 (batch #0) is presented in Fig. 7, as a alumina is not the largest. The factors controlling sur-
function of the porosity. The strength of RBAO mate- face energy, as the chemistry of grain boundary, can
rial is superior to that of conventional alumina one over thus be put forward to account for the improve of the
the whole porosity range. It has been already seen that strength in RBAO samples. Due to the use of Al metal
at a given porosity the strength of RBAO ceramics is in the RBAO process, the amount of impurity present
much higher than that of conventional Al2O3. The in the materials is more important in RBAO samples
mechanical strength measured in the present is in than in conventional alumina and the chemical nature
agreement with those reported by. Claussen et al. [14] of the grain boundaries will change from RBAO sam-
and by Luyten et al. [19] for a similar RBAO system. It ples to conventional alumina. The possibility of a
is generally supposed that this behaviour had something stronger atomic bonding which should increase the
to do with the special microstructure of RBAO cera- fracture resistance of alumina interfaces in doped alu-
mics [6,9,20]. Usually, we can consider the inuence of mina has already been discussed by Wang and Raj [23].
microstructure on the strength of ceramics in terms of Like in metals, where segregation reduces the grain
the key variables of the simple Grith approach of the boundary energy b [24], it can be expected that strong
fracture mechanics: i.e., the critical aw size c and the segregants change the surface energies in RBAO cera-
eective surface energy i for the initiation of fracture mics. If impurity atoms prefer to reside on a grain
under the fracture stress f=Y(2E i/c)1/2. Intuitively boundary rather than on a free surface, thus segregated
the aw size is related to the grain size or to the pore atoms do not aect solely the free surface energy. In
size. The main conclusion concerning the relation this situation the reduction of the grain boundary
between aw size and microstructure is that the aw energy implies an increase of the work of fracture of a
size approximates to the largest grain size or to the lar- grain boundary 2=2 s b, and this means a stronger
gest pore of the microstructure. Thus for some authors, cohesive strength.
the surprising improved mechanical strength observed
can be explained by the mechanism of neck forming
during the oxidation and sintering of the RBAO pro- 4. Conclusions
cess [4,21]. In these porous RBAO samples the
mechanism of neck forming should be controlled by the Reaction-bonded Al2O3 (RBAO) ceramics were fabri-
special and homogeneous microstructure observed: big cated from attrition-milled Al/Al2O3 powder mixtures.
original Al2O3 grains, surrounded by smaller grains, Two dierent Al precursor powders were employed and
coming from oxidised Al [22]. However, as shown several contents of Al were used. The nal powder mor-
above, it is the largest grain size of the microstructure phology which depends directly on the characteristics of
that is pertinent. In our case, the improved mechanical the raw materials and the attrition-milling conditions
744 S. Bertrand et al. / Ceramics International 29 (2003) 735744
determines the microstructural characteristics of the [7] D. Holz, S. Wu, S. Scheppokat, N. Claussen, Eect of processing
sintered RBAO ceramics. parameters on phase and microstructure evolution in RBAO
ceramics, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 77 (1994) 25092517.
Among the important processing parameters [16,25],
[8] D. Holz, N. Claussen, Reaction bonded Al2O3 (RBAO) and
the milling conditions, and the temperature holds in the related technology, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc. 16 (1995) 252258.
heating cycle have been studied. Generally, after a mil- [9] N. Claussen, N.A. Travitzky, S. Wu, Tailoring of reaction-bon-
ling time of about 814 h the two types of precursor ded Al2O3 (RBAO) ceramics, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc. 11 (1990)
powders tend to exhibit less dierent morphologies and 806820.
this time was sucient to reduce Al mean particle sizes [10] F.F. Lange, M.M. Hirlinger, Hindrance of grain growth in Al2O3
by ZrO2 inclusions, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 67 (1984) 164168.
to about 1 mm in order to have sintering with low [11] J. Wang, R. Stevens, Reviewzirconia toughened alumina
dimension variation. (ZTA) ceramics, J. Mater. Sci. 24 (1989) 34213440.
In the present work, it was demonstrated that RBAO [12] D. Holz, M. Roger, R. Janssen, N. Claussen, Mechanical prop-
ceramics can be processed, at low temperature (1100 erties of reaction bonded Al2O3/ZrO2 composites, Ceram. Eng.
1250 C) with good mechanical properties: 270 MPa Sci. Proc. 15 (1994) 651658.
[13] A.G. Gesing, G. Burger, E. Luce, N. Claussen, S. Wu,
at 80% TD for the RBAO ceramic, against 175 N.A. Travitzky, Preparation and characterization of reaction-
MPa at 80% TD for a conventional alumina. bonded aluminum oxide (RBAO) matrix SiC particulate ller
The improved mechanical strength observed cannot composites, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc. 11 (1990) 821841.
be justied alone by a aw size argument because the [14] N. Claussen, R. Janssen, D. Holz, Reaction-bonding of alumi-
grain size of the conventional alumina was not the lar- num oxide (RBAO) science and technology, J. Ceram. Soc.
Jpn 103 (1995) 738746.
gest. The factors controlling surface energy, as the [15] N. Claussen, S. Wu, D. Holz, Reaction bonding of aluminum
chemistry of grain boundary, can thus be put forward oxide (RBAO) composites: processing, reaction mechanisms and
to account for the improve of the strength in RBAO properties, J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 14 (1994) 97109.
samples. [16] S.P. Gaus, M.P. Harmer, H.M. Chan, H.S. Caram, Controlled
ring of reaction-bonded aluminum oxide (RBAO) ceramics:
Part I, continuum-model predictions, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 82
(1999) 897908.
Acknowledgements [17] 3M company, Nextel ceramic ber typical properties (private
communication).
The authors wish to thank J.F. Justin, A. Vallejo and [18] S. Bertrand, Internal report of ONERA-DMSC (private
communication).
M.H. Ritti, from ONERA-DMSC, for their help in
[19] J. Luyten, J. Cooymans, P. Diels, J. Sleurs, The eect of powder
mechanical tests, TGA/DTA measurements and SEM conditioning on the synthesis of RBAO, Silicates Industriels 78
observations, respectively. (1992) 9194.
[20] J. Luyten, J. Cooymans, R. Leysen. Shaping of a RBAO-membrane
support, in: Euro-Ceramics V, Key Engineering Materials, Vols.
132136, 16911694, Trans Tech Publications, Switzerland, 1997.
References [21] J. Luyten, J. Cooymans, P. Diels, J. Sleurs, RBAO-used as part
of a membrane conguration, in: P. Duran, J.F. Fernandez
[1] W.E. Washburn, W.S. Coblenz, Reaction-formed ceramics, Am. (Eds.), Third Euro-Ceramics V. 1, Faenza Ed Iberica SL,
Ceram. Soc. Bull. 67 (1988) 356360. Madrid, 1993.
[2] Y. Chiang, J.S. Haggerty, R.P. Messner, C. Demetry, Reaction- [22] J. Luyten, J. Cooymans, C. Smolder, S. Vercauteren,
based processing methods for ceramic-matrix composites, Am. E.F. Vansant, R. Leysen, Shaping of multilayer ceramic mem-
Ceram. Soc. Bull. 68 (1989) 420425. branesby dip coating, J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 17 (1997) 273279.
[3] A.J. Moulson, Reviewreaction-bonded silicon nitride: its for- [23] J. Wang, R. Raj, Estimate of the activation energies for boundary
mation and properties, J. Mater. Sci. 14 (1979) 10171051. diusion from rate-controlled sintering of pure alumina, and
[4] N. Claussen, T. Le, S. Wu, Low-shrinkage reaction-bonded alu- alumina doped with zirconia or titania, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 73
mina, J. Eur. Ceram. Soc. 5 (1989) 2935. (1990) 11721175.
[5] S. Wu, N. Claussen, Fabrication and properties of low-shrinkage [24] D. Gupta, Inuence of solute segregation on grain-boundary
reaction-bonded mullite, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 74 (1991) 2460 energy and self diusion, Metall. Trans. A 8A (1977) 14311438.
2463. [25] S.P. Gaus, P.M. Sheedy, H.S. Caram, H.M. Chan, M.P. Harmer,
[6] S. Wu, D. Holz, N. Claussen, Mechanisms and kinetics of reac- Controlled ring of reaction-bonded aluminum oxide (RBAO)
tion-bonded aluminum oxide ceramics, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 76 ceramics: Part II, experimental results, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 82
(1993) 970980. (1999) 909915.