Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
D O N A T O N I I SE T W A SR U H I G E NI M A U S D R U C K
by
M i c h a e l B a r k 1 , B . M u s . ( N . S . W .S t a t e C o n s e r v a t o r i u m
of Music), F,T.C.L.
January,1985
PREFACE
I first was introduced to the music of Franco Donatoni in 1979 when a felfoir composltion student at
t h e N . S . W . S t , a t e C o n s e r v a t o r i u m o f l , l u s i c , I l i c c r r d u F o r m o s a , v i s . i l c d h i c I t o m cc i t . y , R o m c ' d u r i n g L h e t e r m
holldays and returned enthusiastic with news about Ital-ian compos-ition and, in particular, Franco Donatoni.
The musicology lccturer, Richard Toop, lalcr srowed me a s(jore of [twrs Ruhiitcl'jn A r l s L l r l r c ka n d I w a s
immediately struck by its external characteristics: itc cpced, the exlrsordj-narrr trltmher of notes and the
I found out that the piece was conpletefy derived from the Schoettl'erg fragnent found in the last bar
and, from then on, Etwas Ruhiger took on an afmost mystical signi.ficance for me. l{ow did all ihose notes
cone from that smal1 fragment? I thought that, if I could flnd that oul, tire r:yslerics of musical de-
velopnent within a New llusi.c context woul"d becomc instantly apparent to me.
After working on the piccc for s o m e L - L m ea s a s t u r l u n t a l bhc Univcr:ity of llew rt:glarrd, I .1.i11 had
only a vague idea of how it was constructed. T wrol;e lo Fr:rnco Donatonj brtt he roplie,l, 'riJnfortunalcly,
I c a n r t h c l p y o u i n t h e a n a l y s i s o f l i l , w a sf o r L l r e s l m p l n r c l : t - u i l r r ' . J I o s L L i ; ^ m ? 1 . {' 1r :i r L 1 . d L } , e
1
'appuntir.rr' Without Donatonirs sketches to guidr- me, undcrtrking bhe analy.-is took il,c I'orn of rnusicaf
These past four years of ever so gradual- enlightenment (which have laughl ne nuch about fife and art)
have slow1y revealed the apparent complexity of Lhe music to bc, in i'acl, irrcrcclible sinplicily. ithat I
the other, I am left with a residue of analytic technique and insight into the creative ideas of this
composer which can only benefit my own r.rork. This proccss lrrs alio produceC a documcnt that may be of
I would like to thank, firstly, Associate Professor Cecil liilf for hi:i faith tlat. I could comnlete
this progranme of study and, secbndly, Mrs Ann Chandar for her supervision. I woulcl afso fike to thank
larIy, Sharyn Lee, without whosc patience I would have qiven up long ago, S p e c i a l t h a n k s t o m . yn o t h e r ,
Mrs Nola Barkl-, for typing lhe dissertaLion so carefully and without compfaint.
@!p!9: 1. Franco Donatoni in a letier to bhe author dated 17th March, 1981.
ll
TABLE OI' CONTEI'ITS
PREFACE ii
Chapter
I. INTRODUCTION 1
III. E T W A SR U H I G N RI M A U S D R U C K 21
Fornal Outli-nes
Tr r h! vc Snhnonhorc
v v r r v v r r p v 4 6 fgll 22
rv. B A R S1 - 2 0 2/+
Pitch Structure o f t h e P i a n o B a r s 1- 2 0 2\
?<
Schoenberg Text - Primary relationship
f ) w n a m i e so f B a r s 1 - 2 0 5lr
V. B A R S2 1 . 1 0 0 57
Rhyihmic structure 57
Pitch structure
la].
TABLEOF CONTEIITS
I aa-+ i .',-, i l
Chapter
r n e c e - L - t ot r o m o a r o 132
1V
TAELI OF rn\rTFirTq /^^-+i -,,-d )
Chapter Page
T h e c e 1 1 o f r o m b a r 17 139
Dynamics
General princlples
B a r s 2 1- 4 0
1 l l
B a r s 6 1- 8 0
1AI
vr. B A R S1 0 1 - 1 4 5
1Al
General Construction
Dynamics to4
iAo
The Clarinet from Bar 100
VII. B A R S1 4 6 - 1 6 6 186
'186
General Construction
q+
fDt lLr y, ,u+nLn-t ic ^ o u l -' ur 'u^C+U f e too
Dynamics 203
T A B L n 0 l C 0 N T E N l ' : '( c o n t , i n L r e d )
Chapt er
BIBLIOGRAPiIT 2A6
DISCOGRAPHY 249
APPENDIXES 210
Appendix A: The Fifth Pi,ece from l'ive Piano Pieces (Op. 23) by Alnold Schoenberg 210
Table Page
1. Biographical Notes l,
.
1 .. lr ,r l- sr L o
^4
l du^o- m
-^^l+.'
posrLtons 6
Figure
7. S c h o e n b e r gT e x t - P r i m a r y R c l a t i o n : h i p 26-2,q
8. P r i m a r y 1 a n d C o m m e n L e r y( 1 ) 3A
11 1 / o r 1 - . i n r 'Ol n i o i n 4 l a n d H o r i z o n t a l Invercion
2l+. C o m m e n b a r yD y n a m i c I r r e g u l a r i L y (i) 55
)E
)). vuiruarruruJr
^-'
errq
'r rn t e r v a l Diminution of the FLute from Bar 1 o)
38. Continuity and Interval Dininution of the Ffute from Bars 4-6 66
v:l-]-1
L I S T 0 F F I G U R E S( c o n t i n u e d )
Figure
t.1
+ , .
l'lnntinui*.rr and lnlsly4l
v v r . v - r r q r v J * r . g . Diminution of the Flute fron Bars 7-8 68
AO
42. The Two Doubled Sequences Bar 68
,n
+t.
^u u^r hr u+r r ir ru .r u, J, i + , , 4- r-i iu rntervaf
I Diminution of the Flute from Bars 1O-11
"t3
48. The Doubled Sequcnce Bar 72
l+9. Continuity and Interva] Diminuti.on of the Ffute fron Bar 12 7/+
50. Continuity and Interval Dimj.nution of the Flute from llars 13-1l' 75
52. Continuity and Interval Dininution of the Fl-ute from Bars 14-15 77
?R
53. The Expected Figures in Bars 8/+-85
qt /v lv n rlirrrii.rr
rruarrufqJ
nnrl T
qrrq r 1l61y4l Dininution of the Plute from Bar 16 (a) 79
)+.
55. Conti.nuity antl Interval Diminution of the Flute from Bar 1(> (b) 80
57. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Flute from Bar 18 (a) 83
58. Continuity and Interval Dinrinution of the Flute from Bar 18 (b) 84
59. Continuity and fnterval Diminution of the Flute from Bars 18-19 85
68. Continuity and Interval- Dininution of the Clarinet fron Bars 9-10 95
oy. I n e t n r e e L j o u o l e q b e q u e n c e sl J a r s o y - l u
73. Continuity and Interval- Diminution of the Clarinet from Bats 12-13 99
71,. Continuity and Interval Diminutio:t of the Clarinet from Bars 1.1-15 100
Figure Page
'1
7?. The Two Doublcd Sequences Bars 75-76 01
78. Continuity and Intervaf Dinrinution of the Clarinei from Bar 15 102
80. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Clarinet frotn Bar 1(r 1AL
R? Cnntinrrifv anr'l Tnterval Diminubion of the Clarinet fron Bars 19-20 107
86. Continuity and Intervaf Dirninution of the Violin from Pars J-lr 110
87. Continuity and Inlervaf Diminution of the Violin from Bar 5 111
1 1 1
90. Continuity and Interval Diminuti-on of the VioLin from Bars 7-8
1 1 5
92. The Doubled SequcnceBars 50-51
'1
93. Continui-ty and Interval Diminubi-on of the Violin flom ll:rr 9 1b
9lr, Continuity and Interval Dj-minulion of the Violin from Bars 10-11 117
96. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Violin fron Bars 12-13 119
4aa
98. Continuiiy and Interval Dininution of the Vlolin fronr Rars 14-15
'1O3. '18-19
Coniinuity and Interval DininuLion of the Violin from Bars tlo
1t1
1O5. The Doubled Sequence Bar 50
106. Continuity and Interval Dirninution of the Violin from Bar 20 128
1O7. Continuity and Interval Dininution of the Cello from Bars 1-2 129
109. T h e D o u b l e d S e q u e n , r eB a r 6 5 130
110. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Cel1o from Bals 4-5 131
111. Continuity and Interval Dlminution of the Cell,o from Bars 8-9 133
112. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Cello from Rars 10-11 1 3t ,
.11 135
113. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Cello from Ilar
Figure Page
115. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Cell-o frour Bars 13-14 137
116. Continuity and Interval Dininution of the Ceflo from Bars 15-16 138
119. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Cello from Bar i6 1lro
12O. Continuity and Interval Dlminution of the Cel1o from Bar'17 1lr1
122. Continuity and Interval- Diminution of the Cello from Bars 19-20 1l'3
123. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Piano from Bals 1-2 1 1,8
121,. Continuity and Interval Dinrinuti.on of the Piano from Bars 3-l+ t4t
125. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Piano frorn Bars 5-6 tlu
126. Continuity and Interval Dj.minution of the Piano from Bars 7-t 151
127. Continuity and Interval Dininution of the Piano fronr Bars 9-.10 t)J
128. Continuity and Interval- Dininution of thc Piano from Bar.11 t)4
110. Continuily and Interval Dinrinution of the Piano from Bars 14-15 156
1?1
| ) | .
enntinrriiv enrl lnlslyal
w v r r v f , ^ q r u J e r r Y I Diminubion of the P|ano fl'orn lllrls 1"-1i' l rti
132. Continulty and fnterval Dininution of the Piano from llars 16-17 159
133- Continuity and Interval Dininution of the Piano fron Bars 17-18 160
1t ) ?
4.
) ru vl rar ur: rtr iqnr v rJ r i t r r rq rnr ud T
r nlslysl D i m . i n u t i o n o f t h e P i a n o J l r o mB a r s 1 8 - 1 9 to I
135. Continuity and Interval Diminution of the Piano from Bar 20 toJ
'100 165-167
1aA CnnLinrrilrr and Interval
v v r . e 4 r . s 4 v J q r r q * Di-nj-nution of the I'lubc fronr llar
1t+O. Continuity and Interval Dininution of the Clarj,net from Bar 10t-) 170-12
7
11 4t 4. . .u ^u r- r+u jr -t l!ui ri u+J, , e^ rnr q^ !r n t e r v a l Dininution of the Cello from Bar 100
'1OO 179-1e)
11t3. Continuity and Interval Dirninution of the Piano fron tsar
151. Page 1O of Doubles (1961) and the Corresponding Page of Babai (1961*) 21lr
152. D l - v e r t i . n e n t o 1 7 ( 1 9 6 5 ) B a r s 1 / , / * - 1/ , 9 215
L I S T 0 F F I G U R E S( c o n t i n u e d )
Figure Page
xi1
C H A P T E RI
INTRODUCTION
The project which I have set for myself is an analysis of a mrjor post-sefial work: Franco Donatonirs
.1
. llhy analysis?
Analysis has direct relevance to lhe sLudcnt-composer in tlrlt it provides inst,ruction in composiLion
technique.
2. Why post-serial?
ilClassicrr seriaLism provides a vaLuable grounding in modern chromatic techniques l't:t i:r afready amply
covered. Much information is available on th(] works of the Secontl Viennesc Schoo.l and increasirlg-Iy on
On the other hand, rrfree l2-note compositionrr (post-serialism) has becn hailed as lhe difficult and
Itunchartedrruay of the future and it is precisely this area which would bc of interest lo explore:
But there is no short cut to the technique of free \2-noLe composition. It, can only be attempled after
Lhe discipline of serialism has been completely absorbed, when thc mind instj'ctivefy thinks in terns
of total-thromaticism a n < 1w h e n n e w s e l f - i m p o s e d d i s c i p l l n e s can bc evolved. [Free 12-note composition
is]...a vast unchartecl territorT, the confines of which are st,iff unknown and llre ltays and byeways [s:tg]
rr -1 -- -^-ceived.4
s UIII urraJ uf rrrJ PEr
This quotation from Reginald Snith Brindle is particr:larly relevant in that it is contai.ned in a book which
a) Donatonirs style of composition is fast, light and, to me personally' has an elegance which appeals.
L\
ul n^-^+^-: l^
- -^ -+ a. t u r e as a composer cannot be denied. His works are wiclely performed at internationaf
nusic festivals and he constantly receives connissions from virluoso performing grcul)s. Over 70 of his
c) Donatonj-rs stature as a-teacher is equally uefl atteste,l. Ile teacht;s tho advanced composition
finishing course at Italy's najor conserva'uory and g-ives seminars at summerscltc.cls alf over: Ertop".3
d) Donatonits music is tranalysabler'. ?he works are systcmatic in their construction using processes
which can be traced rather than being the product of intuition only.
e) Despite items a) to d) above, almost no uork ]ras becn Jonc on Donrloni in the Er:g1ish Language.
a) The piece stands at a turning point in Donatonits eirlislic devclopment. His'nook Questo (Zt6 pages)'
Footnotes: 2. R. Smith BrindLe, Serial Composili"n, Cxfcrd University Press, 1966, c. 194'
? Two of Australiars leading composers of the younger generation, Gerard Brophy and Riccardo
Formosa, spent 1982-1983 studying with Donatoni in Rome.
F d ^ ^ F r i h - . r . , . .
c) Thele is a commercial ^ . , i r v e i f a b l e ,
As slated above in J. e), little informaLion is available on l)orraloni in t,)re rirrglistr lan!Iuage. There
are onl;,'three arLicles (orre of which is irr translaLion from Italj-an) plus a I'ew lislinr:s in rc,cent nuslc
,lictioriaries and passing comments in text-books. 0f the three articles, tr,'o r,,ere oLrtlisheci in 195o anC
195? and the other in 1965--lhat is, virtually al lhe beglnning ol Donalonirs career, lio+. one oi then is
in Ine 1950rs and who was a good lrlend o1'lror,aioni at thr i.irre:
i;e uere ver;r good friends ?.j-)O years aBo, in lacl iie began his intct'e:it. 1r, -r,rfiir,i
and re had long di-scussions then, /
As a result, the arlicfes give a good insignt, irrto Dorratonirs earliesl cor:posil,irlli
The third arti.c1e8 is bv Mario Bortolotlo, a music criNic whom Donat,or.ri nrt irl
far more concerned with the philosoplrical ano mvsLic:-L aspects of tlrc mu: ic ',n:, rs tf
As far as dictiontrry references are concclrred, t,he nosL coltgrrehcrrsive ari iL'l,:r, i)lr
'lwentiel,ir 'l'irr o
rr, iirt, !ictionar.,. of Centur.,' Mur;ic and iicir rlrovr:s.'
Lhree books by the composer himsel-f10 und a 110-page monograpil by iierrzo Cr.st.i.11 f-rf Donaionirs literar.t
His om extensive theories (lqn itis book 0uesto), ruritien in a singularf.y coriprrlent r.ut irr;r,'r.t.r':b1e
language, make tough reading. ''
''1..-"1,,,
ii. .lrj.llL i'r'itr,ll--, rli,,,: Lurrrrl.i:j i,'ril,jer, fi,': i'1tt:;ir::rli'irr,.:r, l;1,. )'., i:.
R. Snitf, llinrile, r I i . a 1 l a n C , r r ) i l n i - ' L ) r ' r r :i 1i u:icr, irL ii. ilrrt-o,' (.I i. '.r,t,ri ir 1l
E. l'1. Bortolotto, rThe llew i,iusic 1n li-afi.r, Llans. l.lillialr i. ilolr: ...
Lf Janunry 1965, pp. t,1-67.
1:) D o n a i o n i , . l u e r r i , , l.
i i . J o t r a t o n i , A n t e c e d ' : n + , e- ' . , i i i l r l , , , \ i i e 1 p h i , ' 1 9 i 3 U .
i. Donatoni, fl Sigaro di iir;nlrdo, Ililrin, lipirlli Eriizioni, 1 )r-.
only a rudinentary knowledge of Italian. Donatonits journal articles are only a liltfe less rrimpenetrablerr.
The nost important of these are conveniently collected in Il Siearo rli Arnando. 0f the material written by
music criti-cs, by far the most accessible is Crestits Franco Donatoni. This book traces Donatonirs artistic
developrnent in cl-ear and relatively straightforward ILalian. ILs use, however, is limited to being an
introduction or overvi-ew of the sub.ject as Cres'"j" declines to become involved with the more technical
The following Tabfcc 1 and 2 list DonaLonirs biographicrrl dotr.ifs anJ con,po.ritlnns re:irccliveJ):-
TABLE 1
Biographical I'lotes
Education
19116 Enters the Conservatorio rrVerdi.x di Mifano at the encouragenent of his first nusj-c
teacher Piero Bottagisio. Studies cdunterpoint and fugue under nttore Desderi.
19/rB Enters the Conservatorio lrMartini'r di Bologna and studies under Adone Zecchi and Lino
Liviabella.
1950 Takes a Diploma in Musica Coral e Direzione di Coro (Choral l.lusic and Choral Conducting).
Pj.zzett'i.
1g5f+, 1958, 1961 Atiends the Ferienkurse f,l.lr Neue Musik (summ"r courscs) j.tr Darmstadl,.
1952 International Radio Luxembourg Prize awarded to @g"t!lng for strings, brass and
1953 International Radio Luxembourg Prize awarded to Sinfonia for strings (1953).
1966 Marzotto Prize awarded to Puppenspiel JI for flute, piccolo and orchestra (1965).
Teaching Appointrnents
Switzerland.
1969 Professor of Cornp6sition, donservatorio rrVerdirr di Mifano (teaching at Turin and Milan
concurrently).
1971 Begins teaching courses in nusic and the arts for the Department of Literature,
University of Bologna.
T A B L E1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
1972 Holds seninar in Granada (Spain). Spends a year in Berl-in at the i.nvj-tation of the
List of Compositions
PubLisher: Zanibon
f1 Libro dei Sette Sisilli biblical cantata for soloists, choir and orchestra (',rithdram)
Publisher: Zanibon
Duration: 161
Publisher: Schott
Publisher: Zanibon
Publisher: Zanibon
Publisher: Zanibon
1954 Divertinento for viofi.n and chanber orchestra (2.2.2.2. 2.2.2.A. timpani strings)
Duration: 21 |
Publisher: Schott
Publisher: Drago
1955 M u s i c a f o r c h a n n b eor r c h e s t r a ( 2 . 1 . 1 . 1 . 2 . 1 . 1 . 0 . c e f e s t e p e r c u s s i o n 1 0 , 0 . e . 6 . 3 . )
Duration: 1lrl
Publisher: Schott
Publisher: Schott
L A D L LI (Conttnued.'
Publ-isher: Ricordi
Fi-rst performance: 2nd and Jrd improvisations Naples 1958 - Piano: A. Itrrau]
Publisher: Schott
1959 Serenata for 16 instruments and soprano (3.o,3.O.0.1.1.0. mandolin, guiLar, harp, celeste,
first performance: Milan 11th April- 1959 - Conductor: Bruno l4aderna; Sol-oist: Cathy
Berberian
Duration: 131
M o v i m e n t of o r h a r p s i c h o r d , p i a n o a n d n l n e i n s t r u m e n t s ( 3 . 0 . 2 . 1 . 2.1.0.0.)
First perfornance: Mil-an J0th September 1959 - Conductor: P, Santi; Soloists: The Duo
Canino-BalLista
Duration: 5t15r
S t r o p h e s f o r o r c h e s t r a ( 0 . / , . 0 . 4 . / - . / , . 3 . 1, 1 5 , 1 5 , 1 A . 8 . 6 . )
Duration: 1 1I
Duration: 5t 30\
Fi.rst performance: Hamburg 1{th May 1962 - Norddeutscher liundfunk Orchestra; Conductor:
M. Gielen
Duration: 11"
Duration: 6l
Duration: l n tl + 5 r
P u p p e n s p i e lf o r o r c h e s t r a ( 2 . 2 . 2 . 2 . 2 . 2 . 2 . 0 . 3 p e r c u s s i o n 6 . 6 , 6 . 1 . 2 . )
Duration: 9t3Or
1962 P e r O r c h e s t r a f o r o r c h e s t r a ( 4 . 0 . 4 . 0 . / , . 1 , . 1 r . O3. p e r c u s s i o n 1 5 . 1 5 . 1 2 . 8 . 8 . )
Duration: c.201
First performance: Festival of Palermo 5th Oclober 19bl -.jocieLa Catlelist,ica Italiana
Duration: Aleatory
Duration: 3l
Duration: Aleatory
Duration: Aleatory
Footnote: 13. This date is laken from the Suvini Zerboni catalogue but according lo Cresli, op. cil,,
p. 10J the first performance was in Merlinge 1967 - llarpsi-chord: R, Pagano.
IABLE2 (continued)
DuraLion: l 1l
Publisher: S u v i n i Z e r b o ni ( 6 3 9 1 )
1 2 , O . 6 , 1 , . 2) .
First performance: Valdagno 1?th September 1966 - Conductor: E. Gracis; Flute and
Piccolo: S. Gazzelloni.
Duration: 1lrl
196'l i ep u s 1 8 ) f o r 1 5 i n s t r u n e n l s ( 1 . 1 . 2 . 1 . 1 . 1 . 1 . 0 ,
S o u v e n i . r ( K a n m e r s y m p h o nO harp, piano,
First performance: Festiva] of Venice 12th Septenber 1967 - Musica Viva Pragensis Ensemble;
Conductor: Z. Vostrak
Duration: 1l , l
Etwas Ruhiger im Ausdnrck for fluLe, clarinei, viol.in, cello t'nd p.itrnrr
Conductor: W. Heider
Duration: 1?l
First performance: Sesta Settimana Inlernazionale Palermo 27th December 1968 - The Duo
Canino-Ba1lista
fl,rnetian. Ilaotnr',,
First p e r f o r m a n c e : P a r i s 2 1 s L l 4 a r c l . 1 9 6 9 - I ' l u s i q u eV i v a n L c f n s e n L l . ; C o r i , r c L o r : 1 1 . P a n n i ;
Narrator: S. Bussott,i
Duration: 1 0|
Conductor: C. Scimone
Duration: 13t
First perfornance: Arte Viva Trieste 19th February 1970 - Piano: A. BaLlista
Duration: 5oil
1 8 . o. 9 , 6 , 3 . )
Duration: 251
tr'irst performance: Brescia 9th June 1970 - Harp: M. Selml; Piano: R. 'i'r'ythall;
Harpsichord: M. de Robertis
Duration: 121
T o E a r l e f o r c h a m b e ro r c h e s t r a ( 2 . 2 , 2 . 2 . 2 , 2 . 0 , 0 , 18.0.5,lr.3.)
First performance: Bolzano 2nd l'ebruary 1971 - Haydn Orcheslra; Conductors: I'. Donatoni
and E. Cracis
Duration: AJ-eatory
1 9 7 1- 1 9 7 2 T o E a r l e T w o f o r t w o o r c h e s t r a s( ) . ) , 3 . 3 . ) . 3 . 3 , A . 2 A . A . 6 . 5 . 5 . ) a n d ( 1 . 1 . 1 . 1 . 2 . 1 . 1 . 0 .
First performance: Stadttheater Kiel 2nd September1972 - Conducrors: il. Zender and
F. Donatoni-
Duration: 30t
1972 - 1973 V o c i ( O r c h e s t e r i . j b u n s )f o r o r c h e s t r a ( / , . / , . / , . 1 . 1 , . / , , ) , 1 , p i - a n o , 2 r a r p s , i i a r p s i c h o r d ,
Duration: 1 3 11 3 t r
19'l) Lied for 1l instruments (2.0.2.0,0.0.0.0. celeste, vibraphone, harp, harpslchord, piano
2.0.2.0.0.)
First perfornance: Accadernia Chigiana Siena 3rd September 1913 - Die Reihe Ensenble;
Conductor: F. Cerha
Duration: 161
Organ: X. Darasse
Duration: ltt3)'
1973- 197t, Espressivo for oboe (doubling cor anglais) and orchestra (/,.2,1r,1'.3,3.3.0.2 xylophones,
First performance: Festival of Royan 24th March 1975 - Orchestre National,e de France;
Duralion: 1b t
Publisher: S u v i n - i Z o r L J ni ( ' 7 7 i : )
197,'. Duo pour Bruno for orchestra (t,Z.t-.A.3.lr./',A. celeste, 2 pianos, 2 harps, viirraphone,
Conduetor: P. EBtvBs
' l $t
Duration: c. JQtt
!.irsL performance: Sr,escla 5lh Jurre l975 - ]{ar.psicirorri: Il. lt, lobcl Li:;
DuraLion: c.2l
First performance: Settimana Musicale Siena 2Tth August 1975 - Conduclor: M. de Bernart
Duration: / + t) A r
Piano: A. Ballista
Duration: 8l
1976 A s h f o r e i g h t i n s t r u m e n t s ( 1 . 1 . 1 . 0 . 0 . 0 . 0 . 0 . p i a n o , h a r p s i c h o r d1 . 0 . 1 . 1 . 0 . )
Duration; c, 121
First performance: Settimana Musicale Siena 2?th Augusl 1976 - Soloist: Loihar Faber
Duration: c.5l
First perforroance: Paris 6th October 1977 - Radio Orchestra; Conductor: L Malec;
Harpsichord: E, Chojnacka
Duration: g. 18'
Duration: c.11r
Firsl performance: T e a t r o R e g i o T u r i n 2 3 r d J u n e 1 9 7 7 - T r i o d i C o r n o ;H a r p s j c l r o r d :
l.l. de Robertis
Duration: 9,15t
First oerfornance: San Maurizio Mifan 2nd Nor.ember 1977 - luitar: P. Cherici
Duration: c,9l
Duration: 8I
First performance: Accademia Filarmonica Romana Rome 1811, .Januar\' -197E - 1,1'rsicu;
Duration: 10'
Publisher: Ri c o r d i \ 1 ) 2 6 1 , 7)
13
T A B L E2 ( c o n t i n u e d )
Text: Robertet
First p e r f o r r n a n c e : R a d i o F r a n c e P a r i s 9 t h F e b r u a r y l ? 8 0 - 2 L 2 ME n s e n b l e ; S o p r a n o : Sigune
Duration 3r33rl
Text: Kabir
Duration: lrt38'
Arie for feroaLe voice and orchestra (L.1r./..lt. 5.3.2.1. glockenspiel, celeste,
Texts: Tiziana Fumagal-Ii Hufiz, Omar Khayyam, Fray Luis de Leon and Renato Maestri
Duralion: 231
First perfornance: Settimana Musicale Siena 25th August 1979 - Viofin: S. Accardo;
Duration: 4t 31r
DuraLion: 5|
Duration: 6l
Duration: 9l
Footnote: 1l'. This date is taken fron the Ricordi cataLogue but according to Cres-ui, on. cit., p, lC?
the first perfornance lras in Naples 1978 - Soprano: Dorolhl' Dorrow.
T A B L E2 ( c o n L i n u e d )
Duration: 8l
tr'irst. nprlnrmance: V e n j - c eB i e n n a l e 7 t h O c t o b e r 1 9 8 1 - A n a l i Q u a r i e i
Duration: 171
Duration: 13'
LrUl-tima Sera for female voice and five instruments (flute, cfarlneL, violin, cello, piano)
i'ircf. ncrfnrmsnce: R a d i o F r a n c e P a r i s 1 8 t h J u n e 1 9 8 1 - E n s e m h l e0 o n t r a s t e s ; F e m a l e V o i c e :
Anna Ringart
Duration: 19'
T e m af o r 1 2 i n s t r u m e n t s( 1 . 1 , 1 . 1 , 2 . 0 ' 0 . 0 . 3 , 0 ' 2 . 1 . 0 , )
Duration: 151
First performance: Settimana Musicale Siena 25th Augusl 1!81 - Piccolo: Roberto Fabbriciani;
Duration: 7l
r l r l r ^ r ' r l ) i a , n ^ n r . 1 J
F inel- norfnrmanee:
! f r v w y v r
Vonice Biennale ?th October 1981 - Flute: Robcrto !'abbrlciani;
Duratlon: 11 |
Pirst perfornance: Accademia Chj,giana Siena 26th August 1!82 - Ceflo; Alain Meunier
Duration: 10t
Publi sher: R i c o r d i ( 1 3 3 / , 6 1)
Duration: 121
She for three sopranos and six instruments (guitar, violin, vioJ-a, pl,ccolo, clarineL, harp)
First perforroance: S t r a s b o u r g 2 7 t h S e p t e m b e r 1 9 8 3 - 2 E 2 ME n s e m b l e
Durati-on: 121
Publisher: R i c o r d i ( 1J J 5 ? 9 )
Duration: 9l
Duration: 10t25n
1983 Abyss for female voice and 1O instruments (cor anglais, uass clarj,nel, contrabassoon, horn,
'1 !
Duration: 8
Sinfonia Oous 5-?rtAnton i'Jebernrtfor chamber orchestra (clarinet, lrass clarinet, 2 horns,
harp 8.8.6.{.0.)
Duralion: Ll
First performance: A c c a d e m i aM u s i c a l e C h i g i a n a S i e n a 2 9 l h A u g u s t 1 9 8 3
Duration: 131
STYLISTIC DEVELOPMENT
G o f f r e d o P e t r a s s i ( u n t i I 1 9 5 1 ) , B e l a B a r t o k ( u n t i l 1 9 5 4 ) , S c h o e n b e r ga n d W e b e r n ( u n t i l 1 9 5 6 ) , P i e r r e
Boulez.Juntil 1957), Karlheinz Stockhausen (unti1 1961), John Cage (until 196/.), Custav Mahler (unti,1
1970). | )
It is perhaps typical thal DonaLonirs entry in Lhe Dictionary should be so neally organised and formalised.
He interprets his entire compositional development in terms of seven year peri-ods: 1955-1962' 1962-1969,
1969-1976 and,1976-1983. The first was a period of rrapprenticeshiprr and learning to compose through the
study of models. The second and third were concerned with the search for ldentity as a composer (seemingly
regarded by Donatoni as a kind of'rPilgrimrs Progress'r). The fourLh period is Lhe rediscovery of compositlon'
Donatoni writes:
What I called the period of the great Contritions occupies the doubl-e septennium starting in 1962 and
ending in 1976, having been preceded by a first septenniun 1955-1962, dedicated mainLy to artisan-1ike
selfteaching sesslons, suggested by those composJ.tlve experiences which were ca1led - with hurried
investigatlon arousing dogmatic theology and theological intolerance - as Neaue Musik (remember Darmstadt
of the second postwar period). Those sessions owed their existence, almost excluslvely, to lhe in-
ventions of the second avantgarde, which had, in Pj-erre Boufez and Karlheinz Slockhausen, its nosl
o u t s t a n d i n g c o m p o s e r sa n d t h e o r i s t s . At the conclusion of this triplc'septerlniuill, 1t:is a rtecessary
obligation to consider the period of artisan-like apprenticeship as I'irrished and equall;'' necessary to
assune as begun that,yrhich is born of composing, literalJ-y: this will be nothing but lhe mirror image
of the fi-rst period.ro
T:6e pre-1955 works are certainly inffuenced by Bartok, especially ConcerLino for strings, brass and
solo timpani ( 1 9 5 2 ) a n d ,S i n f o n i a for strings (1953). This is to be expecled as the influcnce of both Bartok
Donatoni asslmj-lates the 12-tone method. It is a transitional work which is jmrnedialely followed by
f=-r
I
b. d. . . . .
T h e s e a r e n o t u s e d i n a u g m e n t e do r d i m i n i s h e d f o r m s - - o n l y t h c - i r o r d e r i s p e r m u t a L e d . T c ' d e l e r m i n e t h e
pernutation order he forns squares that may be read in any one of four direclions.lT
a b c d d c b a
b c d a c b a d
c-
c o a o b a d c
d a b c a c i c b
T m p r o v v i s a z i o n i f o r p i a n o ( 1 9 5 7 ) r + h j , c ht a k e s m o v e m e n t so n e a n d t h r e e o f B o u . l e z r s S e c o n d P i a n c S o n a t a a s
Footnotes:
E. ResLagno, 'Il Settennio dj, Franco Donatonir, Catalosue of the Venice iliennal-e,
Quarto
1981, p.12). (A quotation of Donatonirs words without the source acknowledged.
1 a AnextractofComposizi-oneusingpermutalionsdcbaandcbaclisre'producedin
Appendlx B.
16
t i
its rnodel. Innediately following is Quartetto IT for string quartet (1958)' wlrir'ir is mo,lelled on
instrunents (1959) continue to be under the inffuence of Stockhausen and, by the ti.me i'ie has mltten
For Grillv improvisaiion for seven (1960), Donatoni is applying serial techni-ques to all parameters of the
1' /a qaoinni invonl.in4 for orchesLra (19u0) ttrd ilnrthlercxercises for i.3j-psichord
^^-^^.i*i^- Fn- nrill.'
j-iL.l----:-:-=jjr ::::.::::g
(1961) display a irighly developed compositional lechniquc and cjcnrf Lhe end noi only of Donatoui's serial
Quartetto lll for 1r-track magnetic Nape (1961) is the resuft of Donatonirs brief flirtation vith
electronic music.
At this tinre, the influence of Cage was confronting quiLe a number of the European composers:
But the sixLies were particularLy intense, drarnatic years for many composers of my generation. When'
', in those very years, the America of John Cage invaded Europe, the reactions of young composers ?f tl"!n
tine were varied and very different: they went from the rnost unthinking enthusiasm to totaf refusal.'"
l ^ -
Donatonirs own reaction was one of thoughtful enthusiasm. The foreword of his book Questo- deals with his
lesponse to these confrontations at length in a typically decp and obscurc manner'. Ilowever, a more straight-
It seemsto mc hhat the musical hirtory of the t.wenLjeth cenLury was a i,isLory of prorrecsive splits,
separations, dissociations induced wlthin the musical materiaf. h'e can suppose that the first separation
was that by which Arnold Schoenberg determined a new logic by the pitch of his sounds completely ne-
glecting the other s)mtactic and formal aspects of music. l'trith Anton Webern first, arid structuralisn
next, the dissociation of sound was accomplished who1ly anrl, in my opinion, irr r t,otr'rlly lrrevcrsibl.e way.
With John Cage, it seems to me, the nost dangerous and deflnitivc r;plit occurrc-d: tlte process,.reveiils
i t s a u t o n o m o u sf u n c t , i o n , a n d p l a c e s i t s e - l f a s a c o m p l c m e n t , r t ' -nt e' c L ' : s j t , : , i' n L o L h p u o r k j t . s o l f . < '
Prrppelqpigl for orchestra (1961) begins to show the influence of John Cage in j.ts alea'uor1'passages.
This pioce esLabfished Donatoni as a lesdcr of new music ir: ILa15'. I'onatonirs se:ond seplcnniun bcgins with
Per orchesira (1952) wtricir is one of his most adventurous "otk".2J Tlic ner:l picces Quartetto lV (Zrcacllo)
for string quartet (1963), Asar for 10 string instruments (196/') and Black and l'lhite for 37 rrtring inslru-
ments (1954) conbine the mobile forms of Stockhausen witli the cirancc operations of Ca53e. In each case
Donaboni devises automatisns capi'ble of generaLing music. In Qrarteito TV, cvenl,r Je;unJ ott tlio pcrformersr
reading of four newspapers. There arc no separatc parls for thc pcrfo.rmcrs, jJsL the one "score". in
Blaek and llhite the score indicates no notes or durations, only directing which fingers are to be used at a
given time.
!g@!forharpsichord(196/+)a1thoughwrittenbeforeAsarand!]a'@ismore1ncontextwith
Divertimento fI for strings (1965) and Puppenspiel n. 2 for flute, piccolo and orchestra (1965). Babi is
a reworking of pages 1,, 8, 10 and 14 of Doubles (1961) where the original nota.iion ]r:rl been converted into
a serles of slgns or symbols for reinterpretation.24 Divertimento II and Puppenspie.l n. 2 are reworkings
)<
of Quarlutto I! and Puppenspief respectively.-'
Rrr f.hie t.ima fl.natonils concern is not for the indeterminale outcon;e o-f sound everits but for the de-
valuation of the creative process that leads to these sound events, llis alt,itude is one of objective
^ r- + { ^ - - d L i ^ .
q urJqrrrrrrP.
The exploration of these ideas forms the main cotttent of his book Qucsrto.
Ruhiqer irn Ausdruck for f1ute, clarinet, violin, cello and piano. The material to be transformed is taken
tracted fron Stockhausenrs Qggpg and distributed between the 15 instruments. This section is then
trre-readrrby applylng different autonatic codes to Llic maLclial. l ' l l l ) r i c c o r l ( lr o - r ' c r L d i t t i lo 1 ' l . l r o m r r t , o l i a l
(tirat is, naterial thab was not extracted) is then taken t,o form a figurc of' homageto Schoenberg lhat
Black and white n' 2 exercises for 1o fingers on the keyboard (t9os) i= a development of the trans-
formation techniques present in the previous aleatory pieccs:n,l in particular lhc firsl R l r c k a . n dl r , l h i t e
(1961,). The piece consisps of a succession of 120 10-finger exercises to be performed o:r any one or
conbinati-on of keyboard instrurnents. The use of a rnute keyboard is afso permissable. The five lines of
the stave stand for one finger each; the bfack or white notation stands for any black (sharp or flat) or
:.P
white (natural) note on the keyboard respectively; and the notes are of free duration.-"
Donatonirs third septenniun begins with Solo for 1O string instruments (1969). Solo is nore pre-
cisely notated than Black and White n. 2 but is based on similar matelial and translormation lechniques.
In Solo the dynanics are not marked but are determined by the string articulation and mode of attack. The
14 29
time signature is f. DonaLonits interest in Gruppen rct,:rns in Orts (Sotrv.nir n. 2) for'14 instruments
Footnotes: 2l'. Page 10 of @!fq and the corresponding page of Babai are reproduccd in Appendix B.
and narrator (1958) and Secontlo Estratto for harp, piano and harpsichord (1969-197A). The flrst Estratto
for piano was written in 1969 and is a tiny piece of 50 seconds duration based on a brief sequence from
To Earle for chanber orchestra (1970) and To llarle T r . r of o r two orchestras \1971-1912) are cledlcated to
the Anerican composer Earle Brown. During the course of composing To Earle Two a transposition of the notes
(Orchesterilbune) for orchestrc (1972-19'/3) which is consLructed exclusively on lhe notes 5 A O ii.
Sinopoli (one of Donatonils ex-students). The borrowed materiaf is transposed ttp an oclave and is heard as
the first two bars of the flute in Lied. Material is derived fron thc flute by a strict harmonic formula
which is then arranged polyphonicaLty through the ittstruments. This makes ttio sectioris of 16 + 15 bars. A
sections naking another two sections of 15 + 15 bars. This cutting of bars is done for each re-reading of
tlre naterial giving section lengths ot 32, 30, 28, 26, 24... down to 2 bars. This makes the piece 272 bars
1ong. Each of the 16 sections ilj composedaccording to the applicaLtlon of constant automalic codes. The
piece has an absence of dynamic co:ltrasb which finds formal justificatiorr in Lhe pp dynanic of the original
The next piece J-eux pour DeuI for harpsichord and positive organ (1973) is baseC on a series of nine
notes. The choice of the number nj-ne is a dedication to Donatonir5 logular hltrpsiclrordisl' ljlisalteLh
Chojnacka, whose surnane contains nine letters. Chojnackats surname again provides source material for
DuoDourBrunofororchestra(1974.1975)isbasedOntheVenetiansong@.In
addition to being in homageto Bluno Maderna, the title refers to the rrantasonistic dualltyrr of the source
31
rre t,o form 1,hcworl:. Doralonits
Donatoni ushers in 1976 and his fourth septennium with l'fusett,e pour Lofhar, [[ for eighl, inslruments
and !or!g!! for harpsichord and orchestra. Portralt is a large work enlirely constructed iron pitches
derived from the harpsichordistrs surnane: Cholnacka.33 Houever, Lhe fourth septennium proper really
starts with reX for string trio and harpsichord (1917), written in nine hrief episodcs'J4
The new conquest of Lhe subjective invention takes placc...with Tov... ,I"ty c a r e - L ' u l 1 5 ' o, f c o u r s e ,
Donatoni talks about this piece as arrplayful exerc-ise of invent-Lonlr..'/'
32. B a r s 3 3 - 3 6 o f L u r n e na r e r e p r o d u c e d i n A p p e n d i x B .
The fourth septenniun is dominated by solo and chamber music. A nunber 01'pieces.from this period can be
grouped together as having a similar formal structure: LhaL is, constructed of two parts differing in
In fac!-!,Jre composition technique was that tested an infinit,e nunber of times: more or less regular
panels poJ followigg one another, and whose symmetrical play is however continuously broken by breaks
and sudden turns.J/
The pieces that fa1l into this category are Also for colo guitar (1977), ALi for solo viol a (19'/7), Arr:ot
for solo violin (1979), Nidi for solo piccolo (1979) (based on D, F and G-flat taken from bar 59 of Lunen),
Marches for harp (1979) and Ql35!r for solo clarinet (t9eo).'"
Donatonj.ts nost recent work seems to be concerned with the possibili.ties of recombining previous works,
She for piecolo, clarinel, harp, guitar, violin, viola and three soprano voiccs (1982) ccmbines the piccolo,
clarinet and harp nusic of Smal1 (1981) with the duitar, viofin and viola music of About (1979) and adds
three female voices. At the monent (1984), Donatoni is working on an opera, Atem, due for 1985 to be
Donatonj.rs fifth septennium began in'1983. With his rigorous attention to structural detail, he is
?o
alnost compelled to take a change in nusical direction.-'
36. ttPanelsrrin this context means sections resulting from the re-reading of previous rnateriaf.
&g@!eg:
38. Extracts of A1go, Ali' Argot and Clair are rcproduced in Appcndj-x B.
39. A very helpful transfation of an interview given by DonaLoni t.o Angelo Valorl is included
in Aopendix C.
CHAPTNR
lII
ETWASRUHIGERIM AUSDRUCK
Etwas Ruhiger im Ausdruck (1967) is scored for flute, clarinet, violin, ce1]-o and piano. The per-
formance insLructions direct the strings to be muted and the piano 1id closed throughouL thr performance.
The flute, cfarinet and piano are also required to irnplement any pruden-' means of reduci.ng lhe intensity
of their sound lrithout making perfornance difficult. Strirrgs are to play without vibrato at;d the sneed of
I
the performance is to be not slower than 60 mlnims to the minttte ( d = 6C). Therefore, ihe duration of ihe
piece is to be at the nost 11 minutes, d seconds. The actual dura'bion of the recordinglo i" a virluosic
NI\ i
@ t-l ,o
. DIRE'IT..
T'IGURE1
In the case of Etwas Ruhiger im Ausdruck, the materlal Lo be subjected to the r'l:chnique of the
artisan'r is the first three beats of the eighth bar of the second of Scho..nbelg's Five Piano Pieces (0p. 23).
rrEtwasRuhiger irn Ausdruckrr is the perfornance direction for this bar: it could be translated as tra 1itt1e
,{-:
FIGURE 2
One always finds it difficult, perhaps because of the dynamics pp, ppp and pppp, to understand exactly
what is going on at that point. There is something elusive i"n thgsc ferv notes, something which evades
what ry! happen and invites one to think about wh;t can happen.4l
gne has taken here an almost neutral naterial, historically determined, bu! foreign to modern practice
and therefore resistant if not antagonistic to the habits of the artisan.aa
Quite possibly, though, Schoenbergrs Five Piano Pieces mean nore lo Donatoni than just lhis.
Schoenbergrs rlatonal-expressionistrrperiod encled wi-th !'ortr Son*: for voicc and orr:hes't,r', (0p' ??,
Piano Pieces is Schoenbergls first conpleted work to move decisivel), beyond'rft'ee alonalityt'torlards a
style in which most or all notes of a piece are derived from a basic motivlctrcellr. 0f these the lifth
t a
p i e c e ( c o m p o s e di n 1923q) is Schoenbergrs first consistently 12-tonc com[,o.ilion. During 1907 and as he
was conposing Etwas Ruhiger im Ausdruck, Donatoni was undertaklng a similarly large personal and artistic
Formal Outlines
a) Bars 1-60, further subdivided into three sections each of 20 bars duration.
d) Bars 1/+6-166.
The first 20 bars of section a) contain the initial operaLions whieh govern the diruction of tl.le resl,
of the piece. Fundamental interval-s and rhythrnic patterns arc extracteil from the ScLoenberg Texl vhich are
bars 1-20 using a systern of automatic codes to transform the material. Thc re-readings mcke a series of
In section b) the nusical material gradually accumulales into evenly t-lowing patterns of staccato
Section d) ttren attempts to reconstruct the initiaf material.. Fragmentary materiaf returns and the
At this point we should nake an examination of the Schoenberg ?ext itse1f45, in an attempt to isolate
T
r r rh
e o af n
v r rl vlwn
l i Bu i n a
r r . a l l < r rf r n n f . t r oS n h n e n \ n r - --:r^-'-'l intervrilic structure of a minor 2nd
l'3. J . M a e g a a r d ' S t u d i e n z u r [ n t w i c k l u n s d e s D o d e k a p h o n e nS a t z e s b e i A r n o l d S c h o e n b e r g ,
Copenhagen, Musik-Forlag, 1972, p. 97.
lr/r. Stoianova, Donatoni, Szernovicz, 9p. cit., p. ?.3. A prcr.ious example of an ltalian
composer using this ensenbLe in homageto Schoenberg is Castiglioni'" flg! (959).
l+6. ArtNote on Terminologyrrwith regard to the specification of pitch regis',er and interval
qualily is included in Appendix D.
?)
<:> sl
FIOURE 3
In the following example, other ce11s from the Schoenberg Text have been transposed to be the same letter
notat ion:
< > S f
f
\
II
I
1GURE4
While each ceLl is notated in /,ths, a reading of the examples in the order of i., ii, ii1, iv, would give a
Generaf Construction
The piano holds all the prirnary materiaf for bars 1-20. Quotatiorrs or transpositions of tlie
),1
S c h o e n b e r gT e x t i n t h e p i a n o p a r t f o r m t h e b a s i s o f t h e c o n s t r u c t i o n . Thes.'rrl.rimery ma+"erialsrr*'
are always played within triplets, duplets, quintuplets or septrrpl,:Ls. In addition' they are always
LR
followed by arrconnentaryrr'- s['6tr takes the form of c gracc-lrole froup.
Grace-notes in this piece are to be played as fcst as possible and arc to bc cligned willrin ihe beeL
TICURE5
In this case, the third beat of the bar has been divided int- Lriplets. T h c L r . i p l e t p u l s e s a r e s h o u mb y
the position of the crotchel rests. The chord is tu be played just before the bhird triplet pulse and the
LQ
d-sharp jusb before the fourth beat.-'
The material in the wind and strings is a retrograde i.nversion of all the material in i,lte piano. Any
vertical chords in the piano are converted to horizontal- mefodies when inverled ln the winC o-zr '*-i--c
Bars 1-20 are subdj.vlded into three secLions: Section 1 (bars 1-6); Section 2 (bars 7-11); and
Section 3 (bars 1/r-20). Sections 1, 2 and 3 are further divided int,o a scquence of triplets, duplets,
qulntuplets and septuplets. Where lripleLs = 3, duplets = {, quintuple*"s = 5 and septuplcts = 7' the
which is followed by its own retrograde 7 5 /, 3 using 7 as 4 pivot. The doubfed sequence, therefore, is
3 1 , 5 7 5 / ,1 ) ) 1 , 5 7 5 t ,l ) ) L 5 7 5 1 , )
/,9. T h e f i - g u r e j u s t
before the second beat is also a grace-note group but, because of a
misprint in the score, is.rnissing the grace-note slash.
2ll
25
The three statements of the doubfed sequence correspond to the abovementioned lllrce slcctions:
Bars: u,
l , 1| 2 | ) 1 1 , 1 5
l'^ l" i'ul" l , r l l ' ' et i r o ll
Ir lt I s ,:,:,:,,
l';l':l)':, t
I, I ,,,,, 313 1,L/. 515 717 5l t 4l L 3 t 3 l
Divislons:
f - I
I
I
1 f
v
- ,_-_)
Sections: 1 2 i(a.) l(b)
justificatior, for this schemc is the irnposition ol- lriplrts ott l tj.ne jn tlli.':lclroPxbcri'Tcxt.
The formal
S c h o e n h e r qT e x L - P r i m a r v P e l a t i o n s h i p
The Primaries are quotations or transpositions of segments taken from t,he Schoenbvrg Text. Figure 7
inrRhythmic Structure of Bars 1-20t) is imposed on the rhythm of the Primaries. In gcnelal the Prinaries
keep their original- rhythmic profile when fitted within a duplet, quintuplel or ceptuplet. The only two
exceptlons are in the 3rd beat of ba.r 2 and the 3rd beat of bar 4 whcre in each case the Primary is a
grace-note group.
The amount of materjaf taken from the Schoenberg'lcxt Lo form eecl, Frimary increases ciight,y as the
music continues. I n g e n e r a l , S e c t i o n 1 ( b a r s 1 - 6 ) t a k e s a o n e - c r o t c h e t s e g n e n t o f t l i e S c l , o e n b e r gT e x t a t
crotch(t segnent and Section 3(b) (bars 17-20) takes a four-crotchet scgment. The abovc subdivisions are
not strictly adhered to. There are considerabLe overlaps and exceptions. For examplc, the flrst two-
crotchet segmentis found in bar 5, a five-crotchet segmentic found in bar.14 and a two-crotchet segment
in bar -t9,
'l
S e g m e n L so f t h e 3 c h o e n b e r g T e x L a r e L a k e n i n o r d e r , irc fjrct : r c f : r n ( , nLL: k e n i , : 1 ' r o r n L h ^ l r e g i n n i n g o f
t h e S c h o e n b e r gT e x t . From there, the segmentscontinue in reverse order (from righi to lefl) lhrough Lhe
Schoenberg Text. Occasionally a segrnent is missed out for no apparent reason. An exanple of this is
between bars 3 and /+ where the segment containing C, B f1at, d and b is omitted. At times, large segments
The transpositions of the Prinaries are deri.ved from the seri-es of notes in the left hand of the
Schoenberg Text:
-!r41=,5-j,tf,_
FIGURE 6
F I G I I R E? ( c o n t i n u e d )
alwos ru u3druck
_?_ '-J._
:
> p w
> s f
.twos ruhig.r im Au
I I r=:
d=d -3- /-
F I O U R E7 ( c o n t i n u e d )
elwos ruhiccr im Ausdruck
J-l
e'o 1 r--3-z
-7;<\
-J-
pp l= l F?l
+J
G l w o s r u h i g e r i m) l { t s d r u c k
I I ./r--r
/ -J-
d.d -3-1- !-,
+ J -t :
!' ? t:
F I G U R E? ( c o n t i n u e d )
\ TtFr
.PP-.-s-+ z.
P P -
. t=l
pp\7 W c:l-r
gJJ
3:
"/''#
rlwos ruhigrrim
FIGURE7
c: -^+ -r ^r v+u ^s ..
vl aJ urrs !rlru
the second note (C-flatr) is a diminished i+th (maior 3rd) from D1i
t h e s e v e n t h n o t e ( G - s h a r p l ) i s a n a u g m e n t e d 4 t h f r o m D 1'
Related to the sequenceof triplets (3), duplets (4), quintuplets (5) and septuplets (7) the transpositions
are therefore:
3 /, 5 7 5 lt )
no transposition dininished 1'th minor ?th minor lOth -- i ^-, cr+ L augmented dth
/-. in- ?rrl )
Prinarv - C o m m e n t a r yR e l a t i o n s h i p
of one of the Primaries. In FJ.gure 9, the Primaries have been numbered 1 - 28 with the corresponding Com-
Once again, the structure is based on the three subdlvisions of bars 1-20: Section 1 (bars 1-6);
Section 2 (bars 6-11); ana Section 3 (bars 11'-20). Primaries 1 - 9 are in Secticn'1. The posiLion of each
using the beginning of bar 1 and the end of bar 6 as boundaries. The intervals o f t h e C o m m e n t a r ya r e i n -
verted internallys that is, the lowest and highest pitches stay the same while the intervals within thent
invert:
Pnnau I Grnenton 1
/1
t--.e9-7r -fr =
'<- ;
FICURE8
Secti.ons 2 and 3 operate in an identical" way. Section 2 conbains Primaries 10 - 18 and Section 3 contains
Primaries 19 - 28.
Because a large amount of material has been directly generated from the ncre three beats of the
Schoenberg Text (which in itseLf is quite unified in its intervallic material), there are many other in-
teresting inter-relationships in the nraterial just presented. These add to a certain unity in the aural-
result lthilst at the same tine adding io the complexity of the inter-relationships within the music. For
example, Figure 10 sholrs the subtle relationship between Prinary 1 and Comnentary (9) in bar 1. The
Pitch-Class Set of the Primary 1s intervallically identical to the Pitch-C1ass Set of the left-harid chord
riuutt|, y (contlnued,,
--j3 t?/
F I C U R E9 ( c o n t i n u e d )
)/r
---G7-,
I, lUUt(n y lconr.r-nueo,/
--:-.. -----
? -
, " ? 7 ,
I ' - t u u t 1 t ry I c o n L r n u e o /
)o
FTGIIRE9
P r i m a r y - C o m m e n t a r yR e l a L i o n s h i p
F I G U R E1 O
P r i n a r y 1 - C o m m e n L a r y( 9 ) R e l a t i o n s h i p
37
The wind and strings bars 1-20 are a retrograde inversion of the piano bars 1-20. When a verticaf
chorcl j-n the piano is to be inverted in one of the wind or string instruments, the invclsion is converted
F I G U R E1 1
An exception to this is s o m e t i m e sf o u n d i n t h e s l r i - n g s w h e n a d o u b l e - s t o p i c c o n v c n i e n t :
F I G U R ] I1 2
"
llarlinal Oniainr'l *a .n.. J' V e r t r c a l (uollole-slopreo./ Inversron
lJhen r piano figure is inverted in the wind or sLringl, bhe rl';'tl'mic placemorrL of llre inverted figure
within the beat of the bar is a retrogradc of the original. This *rn be seon nrost clearly il F i g u r e 1l
which has the dulations which show the retrograde rclationship marked:
F I G U R E1 3
Retrograde Relationship
l8
F'IGURI i /,
The transposition leve1 of the inverted material is refated io the p,itcL range c1'the Scficenberg Text.
It has been previously noted that the range of the Schoenberg Text is D1 to gr. The piano range used in
the range used of these instruments colfectively is two octaves smafl-er: that is, fron D to gilr. This
results in symmetry: the top and bottom bounCary notes of each range used are an equaL distance from their
iv) The collective range of Lhe wind and stringi in Etwns Ruhinor.
hjso- - -
,1
}.IGURE 5
Ranges
inversi.on (wind or string) are equidistant from their own respecLive ran-a hnilnAor.' nar- Fi dt,r6 1A
F I G U R E1 6
f r rr*o.
The first and most obvi.ous ownnnlo nf fhiq i< in 11s1 1 bet.wccn Lhe ni onn rnrl f hn
FIGURI 17
' -
Trrnc^nei+inn T a r r o, l. a- f. trnotnversron (ll
In the above figure, the piano (original) begins on its fower boundary note and the flute (retrograde
inversion) ends on its higher boundary note. Another example of tlris type of transposition of the
inversion is in bar 16 between the piano and the viofin and ceflo:
I'IGURE18
fn the above figure, the piano is a (conpound) major Jrd above its lower boundary note while the violin ncte
itoLMo
PTAlrOPORTE
I'IGURE 1 9
At opposite poles of the original - inversion couplet in thc ebove figure there is a diminished ?th from
CLARIIiETTO
VIOLONCELLO
F I G U R E2 0
Figure 21 shows the relationship firstly between the wind and strings and the Primaries (at the top of
the page) and, secondlyr between the wind and strings and the Conmentaries (at the bottom of the page). 1'se
irregularities occur in this system. The firsb is in bar 14 where, for no apparent reason, the piano chord
marked with a (?) does not have a retrograde inversion in the wind ancl strings. The other is in bar'15 where
the cl-arinet d-flatr marked with a (?) would bu u*p""t"d to be a d-naturalr, This may welf be a copyistts
1t1
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n L i n u e d )
t.)
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
t a
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
FIGURE21 (continued)
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
---i-J:l
PPPP'a._..-_1 -t
P2./'
F I C U R E: 1 (continued)
?//./ 9\rl. rtco
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n t i n u e c l )
/r9
P2// p"llo*.
F I G U R E2 1 ( c c n t i n u e d )
/"r? yofio*.
'- l t r a t
,.'r;\i pnfr n"ul-:-l-E-ll-
'tttt
- -' - nor4. pppP
Iucta tont
----i---J 177 A I
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
PPPPgo. oota. 2fpp
F I G U R E2 1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
r=-:t-
--ffi--1,
FICURB21 (continued)
53
I'IGURE 21
to their sources in the Schoenberg Text. The only excepiion is in bar 1, the second Primar.y. This parti-
cular Prirnary is already irregular in Lhab it i:; e qracc-noLe rat.lr-r th:n b t ' i t t , 1I h r r l r i ' t h n o f L h e S c h o c n b c r g
Text. Because it is a gracc-note, the whole chord is givcn the dynnmic of fppp il-rste:cl of the three upper
F I G U R E2 2
The Conmentaries take their dynamlcs not from their own related Primary but from thc Primcr-;' immedietely
preceding it. The dynanic chosen is the softesL contained in lhe Plirnary. Thur lhe softest dynanic of
Primary 1 is ppp which in turn becomes the dynamic of llommcntury (o); tlre dyrtamic of frinarv 2 1s pppp which
FIGURE23
Dynamicsof Comrnentaries
The onJ.y iregularity is in bar 16. Commentary (26) is split into two parts with Prinary 22 between them.
The second psrt o f C o m r n e n t a r y( 2 6 ) t a t e s the softest dynamic of Primary 21 (nnn) rnther thnn that of
rrlmary
^z z^ \|p p p p /\:
55
I
(
,P7- , '
FTNIIDq ] /
In the same fashion, Primarj-es 22 and 2) nay be grouped togelher since tlrere is only the second part of
Therefore, Comnientary (25) takes the softest dynamic of Primaries 22 and 23 cornbined (i.e. ppnp) rather than
T I G U R E2 5
C o m m e n t a r yD y n a m i c I r r e g u l a r i t y (ii)
The dynanics of the wind and strings correspond cxact,ly to tire Primaries and Commentaries ^ f rrhi^ h +h61'
w'r!J qa rF A v
retrograde inversions. Where a Prirnary lias two dynamics, its retrograde inverslon has a c r e s c e n d o or de-
crescendo between the two dynamics to make performance at spee,l mol'e pFrtical:
!'rcuR!26
Dynamics of Wind and Sl;rirrgs
56
The only exception is i n b a r 2 0 b e ' u w e e nt h e r i g h t hand of the Primary and the cello and lhis case may well be
a misprint:
TIGURE2?
q -i ' .'
t:a] 1n u, )J ' ! n
, , q, 'mr ui n I r r oI ncr Br ul r o r tuJ
uurau rr
CHAPTERV
B A R S2 1 . 1 0 0
Generaf Conslruction
Bars 21-1OO are a serj-es of re-readings or verses based on bars 1-20. T h e w l n d e L n Cs t r i n g s on one hand
and the piano on the other pursue quite independent paths as the naterial is transformed'
The raind and strings introduce a system of interval rliminr.rt,ionand drtrati.onal (rhytlrmic) diminution
from bar 21. Each new verse is the resuLt of a re-reading of the previcus verse. Because of the rhythmic
transformations, the verses stray from the 20-bar pattern established in bars -1-20.
The piano, on the other hand, adheres to the 20-bat verse pattern rigidly. Bars 21-l,O are an inversion
of bars l-20 (using the same rhythrn). B a r s 1 n 1 - 6 0a r e a n i n t e r v a l l i c diminution (as in the wind and strings)
and a verticalisation (i.e. tte transformation of everything into chords) of bars'1-20. Bars 6'l-80 are an
inversion of bars 41-60 (using the sane rhythm). Bars 81-100 are a furthcr intervalfic dimlnution and
Rhythnic Struct,tire
There are two sections in the rhythmic cuperstructure of bars 21-100 in the uj-nd and strings. The
clarinet frcm bar 41. The second is a written accelerendo rpplic'd Jucce:sivc.ly bhrough Lhc sLrings and
wind from bar 61. It is applied firstly to the violin from bar 61, then the cello from bar 68, the flute
fron bar ?/* and the clarinet fron bar 81. The rhythmic durations impo;ed on tlie matcrial in the first
section are: ninims, dotted crotchets, crotchets, dotted quavcrs' quavers and grsce-notL--. Table J lists
the instrunents, the durations and the bars from where the process begins. It also notes where the second
section starts.
TABLE 3
Crotchts from: bar 31, bar 1,1 bar i,8 bat 51+
T a b l e 3 s h o r " r sc l e a r organising principles. Seven bars aft,er the violin, the ce11o begins rltyihmic
dimlnutlon. Six bars later, the flute follows, as does the clarinet after seven rnore bars, naking a total
of 20 bars (7 + 6 + 7 = 2O). Each inslrunent continues with the diminution for exactly 40 bars. The
57
58
violin, ceLlo and clarinet all have minims for six bars, dotted crolchets for seven bars, r:rotchets for
seven bars, dotted quavers for six bars, quavers for seven bars and grace-notes for se'ren bars
The second sectlon is a lrritten accelerando (i,e. a gradual accumulation of materiaf F.er bar). Each
instrument begins the section with one note per bar. The number ol notes pcr bar inereases bv two for
every new bar until a peak is reached which is mainbained until bar 100. Tlro violitr rcachcs a pr:ak of
37 notes (and rests) in bar 79; the celfo, 33 notes ln bar' 84; the flutc, 39 notes in bar 9J; and the
rnrinql. ?o t'f]rrt.o) nn'.os (innludino ros',s) ner bar. Table filr.r;:.hn rc,"rmrrlaLjcn.f noto- 6n- r'rr {-^r ^a.r'
4
instrument.
Pi.tch Structure
General principles.
r,rith a diminution in the size of the intelvafs. Thc principlc of intervaf dimirrution may have been derived
FIGURE 28
TABLE I,
Bar
61 1
3
o) 5
6/+ 7
o) 9
66 11
67 t )
bu 15 1
oy 17 3
70 19 5
71 21 l
,1)
9
73 11
7/+ 1) 1
75 15 3
/o 31 11 5
77 19 1
'/8 21 9
79 37 13 11
80 l ) 13
81 )'l 15 1
82 2A 11 3
83 31 19 5
81, 33 21 1
Rq 23 9
tJt) 25 11
87 27 13
88 )a 15
89 31 i7
90 33 19
a1
91 )5
o) 31 )2.
93 39
o/ 27
95 2a
96 31
97 73
35
99
100
DU
Figure 28 also shows the coursc of action wiren the axis isr reacheC. Tn the case of a unison, there may or
may not be a residual rest. In the case of a ninor 2nd, one of the notes is tranrposed one octave (to make
In practice, of course, the process is not quite so well defined. Thet'e are a number of irregularities
The flute figure in bar 1 becomes the flute figure in bar 2'1:
,: ooDm?to di 80
-----7::-
1 flitl,. l.
ILTUTO
FIGURE29
The augnented 5th between b-flatrt and f-sharpttr (bar 1) contracts to a diminished 5th between brrand
frrr (bar 21) according Lo the normal conditi-ons outlincd above. Iiowever, Lhe minor 2nd between f-sharprrr
and gttt (bar 1) and f rrt and g-flatr I I ( b a r 2 1 ) i s a c o n n - t : " r r r t .l { e m a y t h e r e f o r e say that both the
employed in a 3-note (or other odcl numbered) figure which has a mj.nor 2nd and is hcreafter called a
FIGURU30
UngroupedPitch
Here, the central- gr is left ungroupedwhilst the dr and ctt ( b a r 1 1 + )c o n t r a c t t o e - f f a t r and br. Hereafter
& note which is left at its original. pitch on repetition of the figure is referred to asrrungroupedrr.
An exanple of the third conmon variant is in the {'lute between bars 4 and 2/u:
F I G U R E3 1
Double Grouping
The central a-flatrt (bar /r) is groupedwith both the errrand Lhc ftrr ( b a r 4 ) a n d c o n t r a c l s a c c o r d . i n gt o
the above grouping varlants apply mainl-y to early material (roughly bars 1-60). As the rhythmic figures
become less defined (after bar 60)' the grouping becones more regular:.
An extra pitch development takes place whilst the material procccdc thlorrgh t,lte quaver phase of iLs
rhythmic diminution (outlined ln Table 3). Each piLch sequenceis cxtended or"rdouhLedrrhy having its or,m
inversion or retrograde inversion added on to the end of it. This caso is hcreafter called a rrDoubled
Sequencetr. For exanple, in Figure l2 the pitch series (i) may be exLcnded b;vj.rrvorsion (ii) or retrograde
inversion (iii):
FIGURE32
S t r u c L u r eo f t h e D o u b l e di e q u e n c e
b2
In each case, the last note of the I'pilotrrsequcrrcc acts ac tirc pivot, not,e (marked P) for thc Doubled
In practice, a few slight changes are made to these t'asic prirrciplcs. For cxrmple, e pcrtieular note
may be required to be Lransporcd by one octrve to fiL Lhe rar6c,)r:L ('elLlilr instrunerL. I;t oLher pl-aces,
c ^dtr,}/r c
ryr '' bhn f1ul,e:
T'TGURE
33
+.he nerfenl. lt.h in t.lre nilnt qonrrennp ir irvortcd irr tho nelrn-"p,1^ :nrrrr.inn
fTr nr lFai go qr rr w
re 33- P,trreuu lo fOfm a
is only undertaken in the second hal-f of the sequence. The pilci sequence is always left unaltered. It
should be pointed out that for figures containing only one note (such as i,he sofit.ary quaver in bar 54 of
the ce1lo) no extensj.on into a Doubled Sequence is possihle. The Doubled ;lcouence acts on each instrument
independently during its particular quaver phase and is terminated at the onset of ils new grace-note phase.
I'igure 35 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the flute from bar 1. Thc irorpin; of the
intervals to be diminished is s h c i w nl y " \ , / between the two notes concerned. Notice that the interval
dinrinution is really the diminution of every second interval (especially in t s , h el a t e r stages after bar 60)
except in the rare event of a Double Grouping. Obser,rations on thcse procl5sses rre outfined beloru.
Grouping variants.
Ilatthl ad Soatar^a<
FIGURI34
The DoubledSequenceBar 6l
aE fla!l
PPl - lP
PPP
E9
' ' i
/ / ? - t
T.IGURE
35
Bar 92: The dllrto clrrgrouping in bar 89 formc c-sharprrr plus the quaverrestr.
Grouping variants.
Bar 232 The b-fkLtrr and arr form a l,finor 2nd UriiL.
Doubled Sequences.
IIGURE ?6
S o u r c e s o f t h e n e r , rr e s t s .
Bar 85: The brr to c-sharprrt grouping in bar 81 forms crrrplus the quavc: t'esl.
Trnaarrlrri*ioa
Bars 65-66: The result of the diminulion of the interval between cttr and 1,rr uoulcl be expected to be
crrr to br, a ninor !th. The acttral result in bar 81 is brr to crr, a major ?th but using
Figure 38 shows the continuity and interval di.minution of the flute from bars 4-6. Observations on
Groupi.nq variants.
Bar 2Lz The brrin the first figuro is ungrouped. Tho art in 1 . 1 , i 'f h i r d fir"rrp ir tlre cenlre of
a Double Grouping.
rl'!.r- l-t Ur'r
, . 97
u . =
F]CURE37
Doubled Sequences.
Bars 66-67: The intervaflic structures of the two Doubfed St:quonccs arc sirown be1ow.
:-o{{}-b!-@-\:-9i'-
F I G U R E] 9
T h c T w o D o u b l e d S c c l u e n c e sB a r s 6 6 - o T
fneeularities.
Bars 66-67': These two figures are i.gnored in bar 81, The expected figures would probably be the
following.
F I G U R E4 0
Figure 1*1shows the continuity and interval diminution of the flute from bars 7-8. Observations on
Tho r-chrr-r y e
I o-i
r r q
Lr I
v J lorm a l,linor 2nd unit.
Rar la. The crrr and d-flatrrr form a lvlinor 2nd Unit.
Doubled Sequences.
bar oaJ: The intervallic structures of the two Doubled Sequences are shown in Figure 42.
l,;nd l^r tJ!,t
E6
ir,-1
F^PP
1
89
9? r-
&
-P
3,
4 p'.,
:--:_
IIGURI 41
T h e T w o D o u b l e d S e c l u e n c e sB a r 6 8
Trregularities.
'li
Bar The figure marked with a (?) is a Double Crouping bul tLc cenl,ral nole (1,") does not
brr is ungrouped. Thc notes either;idc of brrprocecd ac if tltc; wcre 6roupedwith brr
but brr itself remains uninffr.ctod. Thc only oti:cr examplcs of this l;.'pe ol irregularily
Figure 44 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the flute from bar 9. Observations on
Bar 292 The errr and d-sharnrrr folm a l4inor 2nd Unlt.
The c-sharprt i s t h e c e n t r e o f a D o u b l - eG r o u p i n g .
Doubled Seouences.
bar oy3 The intervalfic structure of lhe Doubled Sequence is shol"n befow.
- ? - t - -
FIGUHE4,3
Tha Dnr:hrod c-^1,6-^- D11
69
This Doubled Sequence i s irregular in that the dimlnished 5th in tha ni' ln* caarrona- ia
-?/
91
09
22
FIGURE44
3-6F
F T d U ? J r4 '
Bar 92: ?he hll t.n nll ororrnino in hrr 80 forms h-fln+ll r-ll. J.hn e ',rvn- n
' o :' 1 , .
Y"*'"'
Irresularities,
cxpectedto producea drrand gr in har !2. Inslead, lhc cr-lt omittcd from bar 92,
Figure 47 shows the continuity and intervaf diminut,ion of the flute from t'ars 10-11. Observations on
Groupins varlants.
lJar I l: The f-sharprris ungrouped. The flute br is grouped wilh thc:Jnclrlonous b-flat in the
clarinet,
Doubled Sequences.
Bars 70-71: The intervallic strucburec of Lhe l;wo Dorrbfcd ilcquenccs urc shom below.
!.Ii}URE ,16
T h e T w o l - a o u b l e dS e q u e n c c s B a r s 7 0 - 7 1
96
,/2
97
99
FIGURE /,7
Sources o f t h e r y rests.
Bar 90: There are two new quaver rests in tlris bar. The brt t,o c-citarprrr g r o u p i n g i n b a r 8?
forms clrrplus the first rest. The b-fla'urr to a-flatrr groupini; in bar 87 forms
Bar 92: The dlr to ctr grottping in bar 90 forms c-shat'prr plus t,hc (lllaver l'\-'s+!.
'Ihe I/,
tlute lrom o3r
!'igure 49 shows the contlnr:ity ancl interval dinlnution of t,hc flut,e from bar 1!. Observaticns on
Grouping variants.
T
r rLr u
- - r r 4ru r -r,,4r ! r l " o r m
Bar 122 ts a Minor 2nd UniL.
Bar 52: Tho qrl nnd --sharnrt form a Mirror 2n1 UniL.
Doubled Sequenees.
irICirRIl 48
Bar 9O: The b-flatrLo crrgrouping in bar 87 forms hrl-lus thc quavor rect.
Bar 93: The arto brgrouping in bar 90 form: h-flarr plrrs Lhe quavcr rest.
Figure 50 shows the contlnuity and inlerval di.minution of the ffute from bars 13-11+. Observaiions on
Crorrping variants.
'lh- -r i< rrn-nn,r-oA
4 i , v
6
Doubled Seouences.
Bar 73t The intervallic structure of the Doubled Sequence is sirom in Figure 51.
93
2/
FIGURE49
9 3 t
I'IGURE 50
I . ' I G U R E5 1
Bar 87: There are four new quaver rests'in this b'rr. A rcpeLilion of hrr is negaled to form the
firsl rest. The brto argrouping in bar 83 fonms h-flaLrplus Lhc reccnd rest. The
. l l + ^ h l l - - a r r - i - - ; - h ^ r n z f n n m < h - f t r r l l r , t r r : ivt , r, a
E t h i r . , l , r r r r v , , r r , , : t . T h , , f - c h r r n l
liLuJ
Bar 901 Thp hrrt.n:rr ororrnino in bar 8? form: b_fla+rr h1.,^ rhA ^,,a-16-,^-t.
Irregularities.
plus quaver rest. The acLual- resulL 1n bar 97 is Lhe c-sharprr only, the quaver rest
beins onitted.
Figure J2 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the flute from bars 14-'15. Observations on
Grouping varlants.
D-- ar. Tho ol ic rrnornrrnod Tha P-<hrrnrI i< tho ann*ro nf r llanhlo -'--r-nC.
a.ra,,r.i
Bar 84: The at to gr grouping in bar 75 forms a-flatrp-tus the qutver resL.
Bar 93; The g-sharprto b-flatrgrouping in bars !0-!1 forms arplus the quaver rest.
Bar 95: The frtto grrgrouping in bar 93 forrns f-sharp'r plus the quaver rest.
frregularities.
conttal f-sharprr of the Double Grouping (bar 84) splits to form grr and frt in bar 88.
5 5 . -
t ! 7
-
?t4 PP ' PPl PPP
2u4
>--J
. ,L) i:
l;
H++ri*-;+-4i,!--153
FICURtr52
Figure J{ shows the continuity anrl interval diminution of the f}ute from bar 16 (a). Observations on
Groupinq variants.
'tjnit,,
bar Io : The d-sharnrrr and errr form a Minor 2nd
Figure J! shows the continuity and interval dininution of the flute from bar 16 (b). Observations on
variants.
Trnaarr'larilioe
Bar 78: The f-sharptt and grr marked with a (?) would be expected lo be grouped nnd yct the
Figure 56 shows the continuity and interval diminrrtion of the ffute from bar 17. Observations on
Groupinq variants.
Bar 1?: The drr is grouped with the synchronou: a in Lhe clarlnet.
Irresul-arities.
Bat 75t These two figurec are ignored in berc cil,-rJ5. Thc cxpccied I'i1;uros uould probably be
the following.
FIGURE53
TICURB5,i
Continuity and fnterval Dirninution of tho Flute f r o m I l a r ' 1 6 ( a )
- P?
67
c.;--;-----
PPz '??P PP
6t
?2P
FICURE55
Fi -rrra (? cLa'.'a
- .L r e c o n t i n u i t y
*
and interval diminution of the flute from bar 1E (a). Observations on
Grouping variants.
Bar /r0: The c-sharpr and dl form a Minor 2nd Unit. The l;-flatr is unglouped. The g-sharprrand
Trraa,rlori*ioc
Bar 18: The c', d-flattand arnarked wlth a (?) are all g r o u p e da s a U n i t t o t h e b r . The a'
combines wilh brto forn b-flatr (lar 1,0) and the }iinor 2nd Unit rises one serrltone
Figure 58 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the flute from har 1B (t). Observations on
Grouping variants.
Figure 59 shows the continuity and interval dimi.nution of the flute flom Lars 18-'19. Observations on
Bar 88: The crrrto b-flatrr grouping in bar 85 forms'ut'plus the quavei. rest,.
T r r aar , l qr i * i ac
Figure 50 shows the continuity and interval diurinution of the ffute from bar 19. Observations on
Grouping variants.
Bar 88: The frr to glr grouping in bar 85 forms f-sharprr plus the quaver rc'st.
sl
FIGURE57
93
l/
96
F I G U R E5 8
F I G U R E5 9
t6
Ptz
?b tL
-= ' '
91 |g ,. tJ
-l-,!_--{;
r:=
-
?//
F I G U N ! ]6 O
Figure 61 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the flule from bar 10. Obs"-rvations on
Grouping variants.
Orouping va:iants.
Bar 9l't The glrto alr grouping in bar 90 form trre quaver rcst pltts a-flttrr.
Trregularities.
take part in the di-minution proces:, However, in this case it,loes not, meantliat, the
brr but brr itsel-f remains uninffected. ?ire only Lrthcl eronpl!.: oi 'uhi-: iype of ir-
Bat 9l+z The rest referred to above is placed bcfolc 1.1r.'a-flatrrinsleud o1'afL.er, which ls
Figure 6l shows the continuity and interval diminution of the cfarj,net, from bar 2. Observations on
Grounins variants.
Bar 2: The clarinet f-sharprr is grouped with lhe synchronous bil in thc flute.
Figure 6/, shows the continuity and intervaf diminution of the clarinet from bars /*-5. Observations on
I']GI]RE 62
TIGURE 6i*
Bar 4: The clarinet atl is grouped witir the synchronous crrr 1n tLIe f1utc.
Figure 66 shows the continuity and intervaf dininution of the c.larinet lron bllr 6. Observations on
There are two new quaver rests in this bar' A rlpr'liLion of er j: neqaled to form the
Bar:95:
first rest. The a-flatrt to b-flattr grouping ir he- Q1 fo'.ns rl I n'rrs the second rest,
Bar 100: The fr to gr grouping in bar 97 forms f-sharpr plus the quai'er resi.
Figure 5'l sho$rsthe continuity and interval diminution of the clarinet from bar 7. Observations on
Groupins variants.
- ! r r ^ . . - _ _ - . . _ 1 d .
Bar 1o7: fIIE U-IIEU TO U!ItsIUUPC
Doubled Sequences.
Bar 67: The intervallic structure of the Doubled Sequence is shotvn bcloi+'
F ] G U R E6 5
-ha finrhled Sonrrpneo Pnr 67
Irreqularii, ies .
EAT I: The resuft of the bt to al grouping marked rsith a (?) is a repeated b-ffatr i-nbar 27.
ljar b /: The dr to a-flatr grouping markedwith a (?) would be expected to form c-sharpil to al
Figure 68 sirows the contj.nuity and interval dininuti"on of the clarinet from bars 9-10. Observations
Grouping variants.
F ] G U R E6 6
l r
l"1t--i',
fT- =
| ""2
lrr T;-
ffi
f 2P,
|l l 8 u. -.
v#
I'IGURE 67
Doubled Scquences.
Bars 69-70: The intervallic structures of Lhe three Doubled Sequences are shown befow.
P I C U R E6 9
Bars 91-92: There are two neruquaver rests in this figure. The b-flal to a-ffal grouping in bar 86
forms a (r"rhich is immediately negated forming the firsl rest) plus the second qttaver rest'
Trrac,r'lrri*iac
g'
Bar 85: This rest marked with a (?) appcars sometirne earlicr th{rn resLs woufd be expected. It
is also the only rest in the piece to be encfosed in brackets. It woufd appear that the
bar was found to be one note short (eight notes instcad of nine) and the rest inserted
Iigure 71 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the clarinet from bar 11. Observations
Orouoing variants.
IJAT II3 The frr ungrouped. The viol,in e'r is grouped with the synchronous arr in the ce11o.
Doubled Sequences.
Bar 71: The intervaLlic structure of the Doubled Sequence is shown below.
FIGURE 70
'v,,l,^
F](]URE71
first rest. The err to f-sl,arprl grouping in bar 87 forms fr' (uhich is irnmediately
Irresularities.
ljar I l: The violin ell is taken as source material for the clarlnet (ratlier than the clarinetrs
own b-f1ab).
Bar 31: IL seemsobvious that there is a misprinL in thc score. Tlterc should be a quintuplet
Figure 73 shows the continuity and intervaf diminutlon of ihe clarinet fron bars 12-1J. Observations
0rouping varj-ants.
Bars 72-73: The intervallic structure of the Doubled Sequence is shown below.
tz- 13
F I G U R B? 2
Bar 92:. There are two new quaver rests in this bar. A - ^ - ^ + : + i
r sPvuaurw,,
n i ^ + i ^ na-atai * a fa+-
' the first rest. The a to g grouping in bar 87 forms a-f1ai (wl.rich is immediately negated,
Figure 7{ shows the continuity and interval diminution of the cfarinet from bars 11*-15. Observations
Bar'14: The clari,net c-sharpr is grouped wi1!h the synchronous g-sharp in the cef.lo.
Tho nl ic rrrara,rnan
F I G U R N7 ]
--------<t
I A - -
//P7J ?/
FICURE74
Continuily a n d T n t c r v s l D i m i n u t i o no f t h e C l a r i n e t f r o n B a r s 1 / , - 1 5
l)oubLeo Sequences.
F I C U H E7 5
T h e D o u b f e d S r : , 1 u c r t L :l cr a r
This Doubled Sequence is quibe i-rregrtlar. 1'he inl,ervals of 1.h^ n:lnf. q-n'ron-e rln not
re.l-ate to the intervals in the seoond half of the sequence. Tl.- -.--.an{oA ln',ll ai
Sequence is s h o r n mb e l o w .
I'IGUR!] 7b
Bar 96: The ell to f-sharnl | -rnr:nino in xnn Q? fnnn lrl nlrr- t.ho .r)1'ror r!\s- .
'15.
The clarinet fron bar
Figure ?8 shows the continuity and interval diminution of t,he clarinet from bar i5. Observations on
Oroupine variants.
B a r 15 : The a-fLat is ungrouped (first figurc). The f'r 1S ungrouped (senond fisure).
The a-flat is ungrouped (first figure). The ftl ungrouped (5-cond fi--ure).
Tha ft t ia rrnarnlnaA
ljar )o 3
Doubfed Secluences.
Bats 75-76t The intervaLlic structures of the tuo Doublcd Sequences are shom below,
F I G U R D7 7
IIGUR]'J 78
Bar 92: Thr:re are two new quaver r e s t s i n t h i s bar. ?hc g r^ 4 .rrrrninc in h.r" 87-88 forms the
first rest plus a-flal. A -enet.ition e'''-llrt. is negsted to form Ll.te soccnd rest.
Irregularit ies.
-^h6r. l I rr * ha aq ca
Figure 80 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the clariret from bar 16. Obscrvations on
t-^,r^i-- 'rarionic
Bar 362 The f-sharp and f forn a Minor 2nd Unit (first figure). The b is un,;rouped (second
figure).
'rh-
Bar 572 The g is the centre of a Double Grouping (firsL figur"'), I, i1,th,,n^rlra/t lr^q9nd
figure ) .
Doubled Sequences.
ljar /o: The intervallic structure of the Doubled Seqrtr:nco is sliown l,t 1ow.
FICURE?9
Bar 99:' Tho al *.n f-charnl ornrrnino !n hrr Qlr fnnme frnlrr<
P 4 q P
iv -1 h
r !
a nrravor neet
Irregularities.
Bar 57t The a-flaL to g to f-sharp Doublc Grouping woufd be expccted to form a-fl:Lrr f, and
F-sharp in bar ?6. However, F-sharp is below thc rangc of the clarinet so -iL is placed
Figure 81 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the clarj-nel from bars 17-18- Cbservations
Croupine varlants.
Bar 17: The clarinet a is grouped with the synchronous dtr in the ffute (first figure). The
f tritf is ungroupcd (third figure). The f and e form a Minor 2nd ijnii (fourth figure).
F I G U R E8 0
-- -h '_----.
.......,.,""\
tt rz
\----l
A1
t?r2
2
i':-=
F I G U R E8 1
Bar 57t The b-flat i s u n g r o u p e d( f i r s L figure). The a-ffaLrtand g'r form a l'linor 2nd UniL
/ a-^nr,-] f i -,,-^ )
Bar 58: The g is ungrouped (second figure). The grand a-f1atr form a l4inor 2nd Unit (thirC
figure ) .
Doubled Sequences.
Bars 77-78: The intervallic structure of the three Doubled Sequences are shom below.
f;-@-;
F I G U R E8 2
Trregufaritie s,
Bar 77: The F-sharprtto g'r grouping narked witlr a (?) would bo cxpcclcd Lo lcrnr eilher f-sharprr
to gttt or f-sharpr to grr in ber 89. The forner poss-ibility:eems Lo be preferred buL
therefore placed dovm an octave resulting in f-sharprt (uhich is immediately negated with
Flgure 83 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the clarinet from bars 19-20. Observations
Groupinq variants.
Bar '19:
E ] G U R E8 ]
'19-20
Continuity and Interval Dininution of tire Clarinet frorn Bars
108
Doubled Sequences.
Bar 792 The intervallic structure of the Doubled Sequence is shown below.
l'IGURii 8/,
Ber 99: The ftr to e-fl-atrrgrouping in bar 9? forms ctrplus the qu:ver resL.
Bar 100: The b-flatrto cil grouping in bar 9? forms br pluc the quaver rest'
Figure 8J shows the conti-nuity and interval diminution of the violin from bars 1-2. Observations on
Grouping variants.
EAT Z' The e-sharprr is grouped with the synchronous c in the ceffo.
Bar 82: There are two new quaver rests in this bar. The e-flatrrrto d-flatrrrgrouping in bar ?9
f o r n s d r r r a n d the first rest. The b-fIat' t.o nrr -rn)ni-u in ha- ?9 forns bt and the
second rest,
Figure 86 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the vrolin from bars 3-1'. Observations on
GrorrpingvaricnLs.
Tha nr l ie rrn+rnlnoA
Bar 88: Tha nrrtn rlrr ornilninu in hqr R5 fnrmc n-ehernrl arrA *ha nrrrrror noet
Figure 87 shows the continuity and interval dinrinution of t h e v i o l i n from bar 5. Observati-ons on
/')"i c*'l
\,"*
l ?
aL ,, ,- |
|i,,l*
--.ll
tj't rtco gocl
:37 \=
FICURT8i
C o n t l n u l t y a n d I n t s r v s . l D j . m l n u t l o no f t h e V 1 o 1 1 nf r o n r B a r s 1 - 2
110
Dqotr \s
i>ont.22
l'unt+ Ponr
i)?t : l;
tq +t_
FIGURE 86
FIGURE 87
Figure 8! shows the continuity and intervaL diminution of the violin from bar 6. Observations on
Crouping variants.
Irrepularities.
Bar 6: The ce1lo is taken as source material for Lhe vlolin in bars 26-27.
the violin.
Bar d6: It seems obvious that there is a misprint ln the score. The quaver d-flatrrt should be
dotted.
Figure 90 shons the continuity and inLerval dininutlon of the violin from bars 7-E. Observations on
Gror.tping variants.
'fho
Bar 28: qll i< r,nanarraan
Doubled Sequences.
Bars L7-l+8: The i-ntervallic structures of the two Doub]ed Sequences are shoum below.
F T O U R E8 8
T h e T w o D o u b f e d S e q u e r r c e sB a r s / + ? - 1 , 8
EAt tl, The cr | | to b-flatr I grouplng ln bar 65 forms bil and the quaver rest.
Bar 88: Tho fll f" n " 6 o l l arnrrnin- in lrar R5 frnmc f-ehannll nnd tho nlnrron ro<i
tffrPlr Posioorm
2P gvti gor.t
PPP rys6fi1.1.
c ! z ;
PP jxolt.tco p!t;l
rrouRE69
Continuity and Interval- Diminution of the Violin from Bar 6
lP gect, po..l
-,,.
:
i.fr o t ooi
?f juotr ttco trll
. ' 9
FIGURE 90
figure 93 shows the continuity and interval diminrrtion of the violit.r from l.::r 9. Observations
Grouping variants.
Doubled Seqrtences.
Bar /+9: The intervallic structures of the two Doul,led Serluences a]'e shown belolv.
I'IGURII 91
T h c T w o D o u b l . e dS ^ q u ,n c c s P r r t / , 4
Figure 94 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the violin fronr bars 10-11. Observations on
Grouping varia.nts.
Bar 11: The cel1o at I harmonic is grouped with the synchronous err in the viofin'
Doubled .Seouences.
Bars 50-51: The intervallic structure of the Doubled Sequence is shom below.
FIGIJRB 92
ti !,4
FIGURE93
(o^,tiU) |;
-*_=
---
,-.+- -/
// --+-/
;:+=4i.{
F::ffir
zt2 ligoo gdrt)
PT rtrL. rt.o
il tr 4r,.
3:
??P crii pont,
FIGURE94
Bar 95: The ar to btgrouping in bar 92 forms b-flatrand the quaver resl.
Irrequl arities.
Bar 11: The ce1lo arrharmonic is takcn as source malu-riaf for ihc violin in ber ?1 ill preference
Bar 80: The rcst narked with e (:) is tltere for no apparonl reasor'I. The d-sharptr Lo er5rouping
j-n bars 76-77 forns dtt plus quaver rest plus ft.
Figurc 96 shows the continuity and interval dirninution of the vlolin from bars 12-13. Observations on
Grouping variants.
Bar 33: The b-flatrr and attform a Minor 2nd Unit (second figure).
Bar 92t The c-sharprt (second figure) is lhe centre of a Double Crouping'
Doubled Sequences.
Bars 52-53t The intervallic structures of the two Doubled Scquences are shown befow.
I'IGURE 95
Bar 732 There are two new quaver rests in this bar. The arr to brr grouping in bar 67 forms
b-flatrrand the first rest. The crrr to b-f1at'r grouping in bar 68 forms brrand the
second rest.
EAr ttz A repetition of b-flattr is negatccl to form tlre quaver rest (second figure). This case
Bar 80: A repetition of b-ffatrris negated to form the quaver rest (second flgure).
,, c?):
,, t t
li !^-.
! rco poDr.
1 r * l i
. .,.li.l .,.i
FIGURE96
NARTF q
b-f1atr I b-f1atr
a l Al
r- Pr^r | |
b-flatr
Trraarr'loriliae
Thll is, two noLes from scparale figur.: fottn otrc nolc, Thi.'notc, b-ftrlrr, mttst Lhcre-
Figure 98 shows the continuity and interval diminution of tile viofin from bars 14-15. Observations on
Grouoing varlants.
"lho ritlt f roannrl f icrrrp) ir rrnprorrnnd-
s v v v ' ' v t L L s L e t
\
Bar 3/,: The frr and eil form a Minor 2nd Unit.
Doubled Seouences.
Bar 5l+: The intervallic structures of the two Doubled jequences are shomr befovr.
r-{}- hr *-1:)/;\-
2
=
}.ICURE 97
Bar 73: The alrto brr grouping in bar 67 forms b-flatlr and tlre quaver rest.
Bar 83: There are two new quaver rests in thi.s bar. The brr to c-sharprrr grouping in bar 80
(bctween the first and second fi.gures) forms crrr, which would be a repetition and thus
is irnnediately negated by the first rest, plus the regular residual rest.
\:>r+-J
PPPP ligao Dos. lorb
lc!:Dg pog.Doro
,r li
--:
-Er
:
tool
==4
r='iriE=-=tE=:E
i:--<--:-==--=:==:-
F I G U R E9 8
Bar o . ) . The e-flatrtto d-flatrtgrouping in bar 89 forms drrplus the quaver rest.
Bar o ? . The b-flatrr bo a-flattrgrouping in bars 89-90 forms:rr (bar 92) plus lhe quaver.rest
(bar 93).
IrreAularities.
Bat 1/+t The grouping of e-flatrrand ert (firsb figure) marked with a (?) would be erpected to
The second and third flgures of bars 14-15 combine to form one figure with b-flattras
the pivot.
-uar ob 3 The b-flatrt enclosed by the dotted line is the overlap with the preceding figure, as
Figure 100 shows the continuity and interval- diminution of the violin from bars.15-16. Observations
Grouping variant,s.
IJar to: The b-flatr (first figure) is ungrouped. The ar (second figure) is'uhe centre of a
uuuurY u1uuylrts.
Doubled Sequences.
Bars 55. 56:. The inlervaflic structure of the Doubled Sequcnce is shoum befow.
IIIGURI' 99
T h e D o u b l - e c lS e q u e n c e l l a r s 5 5 - 5 t r
Sources of t h e n e w r e s t s .
'l l+: There are two new quaver rests in this bar. The ftr to e-ffairr grouping in bar 69 forms
Ba.r
err and the first rest. The arr to gtr grouping in b3r 69 forms g-sharprr plus the
second rest.
Bar 87: There are two new quaver rests in this bar. The b-flatrr to a-ffatrr grouping in bar 84
Bar 90: There are two new quaver rests in tlris bar. r\ repetition ol fr is nega'.ed to form the
fir<f. rast A n
n r o
s Pnc o
u ttuif tv ir ro n of e-flaf,ll ic ned.iart tn fnrn +.1)^ .Fn^nd ]'est.
Bar 93: The f-sharpr to g-sharpr grouping in bar 9O forms gr plus the quaver rest.
bar yo: The gtr to lr I grouping in bar 93 forms f-:harpt I plus the quaver rest.
, ir-----:T-
----
-*- .-.
'i---'
t:\.
rii, pont.I+-'
,2?l? tcaoo
//P tio
F I C U R E1 O O
Irregularities,
Bar 552 The three figures from bars 35-36 conbine t,o forn rine scquence which is tl:en doubled. The
Figure 102 shows the continuity and interval diminution o f + - h ev i o l i n from bars 16-'17. Observations
Grouping variants.
IJar 6t: The b-flatr (sccond figure) is the centre of a Double Crouping.
Doubled Seclttences,
Bay 57: The intervallic structure of the Doubled Sequence is shom below.
P I G U R E1 0 1
Bar 81: fhere are truo new quaver rests in this bar. The b-flatrr to crrt grouping in bar 78 form
brrplus the first rest. The btto ar grouping in bcr 78 forms b-flatrplus Lhe sccond
rest.
bar yo: The g-sharpt'to f-sharplr grouping belween bhe -iirsL and second figures in bar 93 forrns
frresularities.
Bar 57: The second and thj.rd figurec from hars J7-38 combine to form one sequencewhich is then
doubled. The dotted lines show the two parts of the pilot sequence.
Figure 103 sholrs the continui.ty and interval dininution of the violin from L,ars 18-19. Observations
Doubled Sequences.
Bar 58: The intervallic structures of the two Doubl-edSequences are shom in Figure 104.
h'c!l'lrovn''q
vir.^.!rro
tur.l. tool
r , , ' . , . . b 4 . ,. - . / s ; t , ,
.x L:
} - I C I I R E1 0 2
F I C U R E1 O ]
'1
Fii;URE O/;
Bar 91: A nnnol ition nf ol is negated to form tlre cluaver rest (secotrdfirlure).
Trreeul-arities.
'lho
Bar 79: The quaver rest marked with a (?) ic +haro anr no rnnr-Fnt fceson. ovnani orl rnerrl t
a rest.
'l aU.
he vao11n iTOm DaT
Iigure 106 shows the continuitY and irrterval dimin,ttion of tlre vio.i in from bar 10. Cl.serv:Ltions on
Croupine variants.
Doubled Sequences.
bar ou: The intervalLic structure of the Doubled Sequencc is shown below.
trTNI]Rtr 1N(
^r ,^^rrAnna r.rtr ou
t t r ^ ^ t l t _ _ ^ . . * : - _ : - l ^ - o c 4 ^ - - ^ r 1 . 6 . , r . - , 6 - , 6 s t .
Bar 88: dr wuPrrrS rrr rtrr e/
L t t - t r r -
Figure 107 shoirs the continuity and interval diminution of the cello fron bars 1-2. Observations on
2/l'l.Zro
t7 gnnl| [co,o!t.
I'ICURE106
-__--
ri ti r: o'; t
//2P lcaio
r------:-
ti
FIGURI 107
Grorrpinq variants.
Bar 2z The cel-lo c is grouped *ith the sltrchronous c-sharpl I in the violin.
Doubled Seouences.
Bar 61: The intervalLic structure of tho lnrrhl pri Sne ,nnnr i s sl.orm bc1ow,
IIGURE 108
Bar 8J: The a to g grouping in bar 80 forms a-fl-at plu: tl.e quaver rest,
Bar 992 TL: B-fl-at to c grouping in bcr 97 forms B plt,.r tbe quaver rest.
Figure 110 shows thc continuity and interval dininution , f i,lrc ccllo froni bars 1u-J. tlbscrvulions ort
Groupine variants.
The cello f-sharpr is grouped wiLh th. synchronous ' ;rtarprr in thc vi.:in.
dL^ -t i^,,---^.,-^n
Bat 2l'z rrrs ts ro urr6ruuysu.
Doubled Sequences.
F I G U R E1 0 9
frresularities.
Bat 752 The e-f1atr to d-fLatr grouping in bar 65 woufd be expected to form dr plus a quaver rest
in bar 75. Instead, only the dl is form.d. T h e ( ? ) n a r k s t h e place where the r-st would
be expected.
l?/ lqai
.li
11 +-12
r l ; . f i
l. r t--
I .- \:-
l--=s-=-
I /2 ica}o tlst.
I
2/2 lc(no t.
F I G U R E1 1 0
The whole of the ce11o bar 6 has been taken as source material for the violin as shom in Fig;re 8!.
Figure 111 shoirs the continuity and interval diminution of the ce1lo from bars 8-9. 0bservations on
Grouping variants.
Bar 88: The drto crgrouping in bar 87 forms d-ffatrplus the qua:er resl'
*r." rtt "t"- tr" tinuity and i-nterval- diminution of the cello from bars 10-11. Observations on
Grouping variants.
frresularities.
Bar 69: The two figures of bars 50-51 combine to form (through the conmonnoLe f-sharp) one
figure.
"l
The cel1o fron bar 1.
Figure 113 shows the continuity and interval di.ninutlon of the cello fron bar.11. 0bservations on
Grouping variants.
Bar 11: The f is ungrouped. The clarinet b-flat is grouped with the synchronous br in the fl-ute.
Bar 79: The f to e-f1at grouping in bar 76 forms e plus the quaver rest.
Bar 90: The b-flat to a-flat grouping in bar 88 forms a plus the quaver rest.
Irreeularities.
Bar 11: The clarinet b-flat is taken as source material for the celfo j-n preference to the
rl;---l--T;
l.too Dclt
FIGURE 1 1 1
li E -r:ll-
2P/P lcaro
F I C L T R E1 1 2
I'
* ,,,.,,,.,,,."
i li -r:
t3..
F I G U R E1 1 3
Figure 115 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the cello from bars 13-14. Observations
Crouoing variants.'
Bar 14: The ce1lo g-sharp is grouped with the slmchronous c-sharpr in the clarinet.
Bar 89: The b to a groupi-ng in bar 87 forms b-f1at plus the quaver rest.
Figure 115 shows the continuity and interval dininution of the ce11o froll bars 15-16. Observations
Grouping variants.
'15: The e is ungrouped.
Bar
Doubled Sequences.
Bars 55-56: The lntervallic structures of the two Doubled Sequences are shom bel.ow.
F I C I J R E1 1 4
Bar 712 There are two new quaver rests in this bar. The a to b grouping in bars 5lr-55 forns
b-flat plus the first rest. The e to d grouping in bar 55 forms e-flat plus the second
rest.
Bar 83: The g to f grouping in bar 81 forms f-sharp plus the quaver rest'
Bar 99: This rest is iregular and is discussed under rrlrregularitiesrr below.
frresularities.
sequent verses. fnstead, l"ey are omitted and do not appear again. I ne rnLro t i.i marKs
+^ L --^,,-i-- i-
the position where one would expect a quaver rest--formed by the a
FIGURI 115
2P7? grll^
arco PoDl.
0 Pont
(2)
!t
.gno t.5t,
?P? ysli
TICURE116
Figure 11p shows the continuity and interval diminution of the cello from bar 16' Observationson
Grouping variants.
DoubLed Sequences.
Bars 56-572 The intervallic structure of the Doubled Sequence is shom below.
F I G U R E1 1 i ' .
Bar 82: The a to g grouping in bar 79 forms a-flat plus the quaver rest.
Figure 120 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the cell-o from bar 17. Observations on
Grouplng variants.
Doubled Sequences.
Bats 57-58: The intervall-ic structures of the three Doubled Sequences are shom below.
F I G U R E1 1 8
, f
i' 7 .4
dr.:
E":7r
?Urf l.ano
IQ
?2? 12g1s
I ' I G U R D 1 . 19
2P l.ano lisl.
?22 1r7r.elj1.
FICURN 120
Bar 77: There are three ncw quaver rests in this bar. Tirc c-sharf to 3-flat grouping in bar 73
forms d plus the firsL new resL,. The cr uo dt grouping in har ?3 forns c-sharpr plus
the second new rest. The c-sharp to d-sharp grouping in bar 7J forms d plus the third
new rest,
Bar 80: A repetition of f i.s negated to form the quaver rest (',hird figure).
Bar 93t The g to a grouping in bar 91 (third figure) forns g-sharp plus the quaver rest.
Bar 9l': The G to A grouping in bar 9: forms A-flat plus the quaver rest'
Bar 96: There are two new quaver rcsts in this bar. The c' to b-flal grouping in bar 95 forms
b plus the first new rest (second figure). A repetiti.on of b is negated to forn the
Figure 122 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the ce11o from bars'19-20. Observations
Grouping variants'
Bar /,0: The g-flattrto frt forn a Minor 2nd Unit. The cr is ungrouped (fast figure).
Doubled Sequences,
Bars 59-50: The intervallic structures of the three Doubfed Sequences are shom below.
F I G U R E1 2 1
Bar 78: The d-sharpr to c-sharprgroupi-ng in bar 7/r forms drplus the quaver rest.
Bar 80: There are two new quaver rests in this bar. The g-sharp to b-flat grouping in bar ?8
forms a plus the first new rest. The crto dr grouping in bar 78 forms c-sharprplus
Bar 86: The b to a grouping in bar 8/+ forrns b-flat plus the quaver rest.
Bar 98: The f to g grouping in bar 97 forms f-sharp plus the quaver rest.
t'l)
?r,er 4n u'r,r
It_---.-.---'-----
|' I t - ! : --l - : l - rr----+\
L - i
FIGURE122
Irregularities.
Bar 19: The figure narked with a (?) is a Doubfe Grouping buL the cenlral note (f-sharprr) does
not take part in the dininution process. However, in this case it does no'u nean that the
f-sharprr is ungrouped. The notes either side of the f-sharprr proceed as if they uere
grouped with the f-sharprt but the f-sharprr itself remains uninflected, The only other
cLarinet.
Bar 20: The grouping narked with a (?) acts like a Minor 2nd Unit but is in fact a perfect /*th'
naking it arrPerfect dth Unitrr. There are no other Perfect 4th Units in the piece.
Bar 7l+z The d to a-fl-attgrouping in bars 58-59 woufd be expected to form e-flat and gt. The
narked rrith the first (?). The b-flatr to a-flatr grouping in bar 59 would be expected
to forn ar plus a quaver rest. The ar is presenL but the rest is omitted. The place
where j-t would be expected is marked with the second (?). The first figure of bar 60
is transposed down one octave when transformed in bar 71+. Presumably this is done to
Dynanics
The dynamic structure of the wind and strings in bars 21-100 is related to the rhythnj"c structure of
bars 21-100 which has been presented previously in this chapter und.cr trRhythmic Structurett. (Thc two
rhythnic structures are: i) the dininution of rhythrnic durations; and ii) a written accel-erando.)
During the first of these sections, the dynanics for each figure are retained from verse to verse.
During the second section, the dynarnics for each figure are only retained for the first four bars; that is'
fron one note per bar to seven notes per bar. At nine or more notes per bar separate dynami,cswould becore
inpractical. From this stage, therefore, only one dynamic per bar is used. The dynamic for each of these
subsequent bars is arrived at by_deternining the expected dynamic of the very first note in the bar. This
note then acts as a rrpilotrr note and its dynamic is applied to the whole of the bar.
Table 6 sets out each instrunent and its dynamic per bar. It will be noticed that, despite the system
used to determine dynamics, the results are surprisingly structured. These structures (formed by chance)
are bracketed.
alanarol Drirain'la<
ry
Bars 21-40.
thls inversion is deternined by the boundary notes D1 and grrrr and executed in the sane manner as described
previously in Chapter 4, rrPitch Structure of the Wind and Strings Bars 1-20rr. In this case, however, it is
sinply an j.nversion (not a retrograde inversion) and the rhythn stays the same.
TABLE6
W i n d a n d S t r i n g D y n a m i c sB a r s 6 1 - 1 0 0
6 1 Ppp
oz ppp
oj pppp
o4 ppp'
65 vvv
oo pppp
67 vPv
od pp ppp
pppp ppp
70 PYP
ppp
pPpp ppp
72 !v pppp
n2 pppp pppp
pp D
" "D P P I
I
pppp
I
75 vvv
pDp j pppp, PPPP' PPP
4A ppp ppp ppp' P P P ' P P P ' P P P ' P P P ' P P P
pppP pppp ppp' P P P ' P P P , P P ' P P P ' P P P ' P P P
78 vv -pppp
" ' Il vvv
ao ppp l
Ppp DDD I
I
80 ppp pppp " - l
ppp I
ol pPpp ""1
ppDp'l p p J pppp
82 pp ppp
" ' I pp PPFP' PPPP, PPPP
J
ppp "p p p"p 'tl ppp PPPP' PPPP' PPI PPP' PPPP
AJ
vvv
ppp I "'t
pppI PP' PP, PPP' PPP' PPP' PP' PPP
pppP "-l
ppDp I ^ " 1
DDD I ppp
do pp DDD I D D I
I
pp
J
9,n ppp "p D p"p ' l1 pp ppp
66 ppp ppD I ppp
- - 1l ppp
pppp " " 1
pDpD l DDD I
I
pppp
ao pp ppp J n n l ppp
pPp ' - ^ 'I l
DDDD - " 1
ppD I ppp
ta ppp ppp l 'DDD
^ ^I l pp
93 pppp eeee'l n n l ppp
91, pp ppp J DDD
" ^ Il pppp
.I
ppp ^"'t
DDDD DDD I ppp
')o pppp ppD I Y Y JI lpp
t "
o., .I
pppp " " 1I "DDD' l
PDDD I ppp
tI DpD
"'
98 pp ppp I "DDD' tI t"'
oo ppp pppp p p l lpp
I Ippp
100 pppp ppp I ppp I
t40
bars 4l-ou.
Pitch structure.
manner as described provlously in this chapter undcrrrwind end Striltgc Ilars 21-1OO--PiLch Structurerr.
Isolatetl pitches which are not part of any other figure remain the same (i'e. ungrouped) and Minor 2nd
Units also occur. When a figure is comprised of two pitches a semitone apart and no diminulion is possible'
one of the pitches is displaced by an octave. Examples of this are between bars 3 and 1r3; and bars 4 and
Rhvthnic structure.
Another variation in this section is that a!1 the horizontal nelodic material- i.n bars l-20 is now
expressed as vertical chords. The chord is placed vrhere the first attack of the horizontal nelody would
have been. In addition, a1l- durations are now either of " qri.ve. or a grace-note in length. The grace-
notes of bars 1-20 have stayed as grace-notes, while a1f the larger durations in bars 1-2O are reduced to
Dynarnics.
When two dynanics have to be conbinect (for instance, when a horizontal- meJ-ody becornes a vertical
chortl), the dynamic used is the louder of the two. In all other circumstances, the dynamics are those of
bars 1-20.
llars o t-6u.
,* rr"* t bars 61-80 is an exact inversion of the piano in bars /*1-60. The transposition leve1 of
Bars 81-100.
Pitch structure.
Bars 8'1-100 repeat bars 61-80 and further diminish the size of the inierval-s within each figure, This
is ilone in the sane nanner as the interval diminution of bars 1-20 during bars 41-60,
Rhvthnic structure.
A11 of the material is now converted into horizontal melodies with the durations reduced to staccato
grace-notes. Grace-note nelodies derived from the grace-note chords of bars 61-80 are plaeed so that the
first grace-note of the nelody is exactly in the previous position of the chord. Similarly, grace-note
nelodies derived fron the chords of a quaverrs duration in bars 61-80 are placed so that the first grace-
note cf the nelody is just before the previous position of the chord. The grace-notes that foll-ow in the
Dvnarnics.
I.igure 123 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the piano from bars l-2. Observations on
Grouping variants.
Bar 1: The D1 ancl D-sharpl (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The d-sharp (fourth figure)
is ungrouPed.
The frtr and g-flatttt (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The f-sharprr (fourth
Bar 6.1:
figure) is ungrouPed.
Figure'12ii shows the continuity and interval-idirninution of the piano from bars J-4. observations on
Grouping variants,
Bar 3: The cl-f1at and c (second figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit.
Bar 63: The artand b-flatrr (second figure) forrn a Minor 2nd Unit.
Bar 6lr: The d-sharprrrand ertt (thj-rd figure) form a trlinor 2nd Unit.
Figure 12! shows the continuj-ty and intcrval clinj-nution of thc plano from bal's 5-6. Obselvalions on
Grouping varj-ants.
Bar 6: The d-sharp (first figure) is ungrouped. The 81 and B-flatl (fourth figure) forn a
Bar 66: The f-sharprt. (fj.rst fi.gure) is ungrouped. The brr and ctr' (fourth figure) form a
Figure 125 shows the continuity and interval dininution of the piano from bars 7-8. Observations on
Grouping varj.ants.
Bar 8: The F-sharpl and G1 (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The f (second figure) is
ungrouped.
Bar 67: The arr and b-flattr (second figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit.
Bar 68: The c-sharprrrr to drrtr (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The err (second figure)
is ungrouped.
FICURE123
rlcuRE 121,
FIGURI 126
Grouping variants.
(bar 9) forn a Minor 2nd Unit' The f (bar 9) to e-flat (bar 10)
Bars 9-10: The dr and c-sharpt
Bar ?O: The at to br grouping (first figure) forms b-flatrin bar 90. The drto ergrouping
Figure 128 sholrs the continuity and interval diminuti.on of the piano from bar 11. observations on
Grouping variants.
Bar 11: The E and F (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The d-flat to e-f1at grouping (first
Grouping variants.
Bar 13: The E-flat and D (first discrete flgure) forn a Minor 2nd Unit'
Bar |jz The gtrr and a-flattrr (first figure) forn a l'linor 2nd Unit. The a-sharprr and brl
Figure 130 shows the continui.ty and interval dininution of the piano from bars 1/+-15. Observations
Grouping variants.
Bar 1d: The F ancl E (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The a (firsl figure) is ungrouped.
Bar 15: Tho G to A grouping (flrst dlscrete flgure) forns C-sharp in bar 55. The f-sharp and
Bar 7t+: The etrt and fttr (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The ctr (second figure) is
F I G U R E 12 7
_PP
I'IGURE 1'O
'1l+-15
Continuity and fnterval Diminution of the Piano from Bars
151
Bat 75: In the first figure, the a-flatrr to c-sharptr grouping forms arr and crrr in bar 95 whj.1e
the inLervening b-flattr is ungrouped. The remaining drrr and crrrgroup to form e-fLatrrt
in bar 95.
*".-rt "-n" the continuity and interval di-minution of the piano from bars 15-16. Observations on
Grouping variants.
The C and C-sharp forn a Minor 2nd Unit. The A to B grouping forros B-flat j.n Ltar 55.
Bars 15-15:
Bar 16: The f-sharp and g (first discrete figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The b to c-sharpr
grouping (third discrete figure) forms cr in b.ir 56. The !'and F-sharp (fourth discrete
Bar 762 The d-sharprt and etr (second figure) form a l4inor 2nd Unit. The ar (fcurth figure) is
ungrouped. The dttrand e-ffaLttt (fifth figure) forn a llinor 2nd Unit.
Irregularities.
Bar 762 In the second figure, the f-sharprr is presurnably grouped with the Minor 2nd Unj-t
d-sharprrand ert (listed above), However, the irregular result in bar 96 is ftt (a
Figure 132 shows the continuity and interval- diminution of the piano from bars 15-16. Observations on
Grouping variants.
Bars'16-17: The d-sharptrand ert (bar 17) forn a Minor 2nd Unit.
Bar 77'. The f-sharp and g (first figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit which is ungrouped,
Figure 133 shovs the continuity and interval dininution of the piano from bars'17-18. Observations on
Grouping variants.
Bar 18: The errand ftr (first discrete figure) forn a Minor 2nd Unit.
Bar 77t The b-flatrto e-flatrrgrouping forms brand dil in bar 97 whil,e the intervening crl
renains ungrouped. The etr to f-sharprr grouping forns frt in bar 97.
Bar 78: The f and g-flat (second figure) forn a Minor 2nd Unit.
F I G U R E1 ] 1
'15-16
Continuity and Interval Dirninution of the Piano from Bars
- f - . - . ? -
-
, P S '
FICURE i ]2
FICURE133
-.-7-
134
FICURE
Grouping variants.
Bars 18-19: The C-sharp and D (third beat, bar 18) forn a Minor 2nd Unit.
Bar 19: The g-sharprand at (first disctete figure) forn a Minor 2nd Unit. The b-flat to ct
grouping (first discrete figure) forns b in bar 59. The G-sharpl and At (second discrete
figure) form a Minor 2nd Unit. The F to G gror-rping (second discrete figure) forms
F-sharp in bar 59. The f to d-sharp grouping (third discrete figure) forns e in bar 59.
Figure 135 shows the continuity and interval diminuLion of the piano from bar 20. Observations on
Grouping variants.
FIGURE135
B A R S1 0 1 - 1 4 5
General Construction
A sudden change to a legato articulation occurs in bars 101-145 which presents this section in sharp
contrast to bars 21-10O. The music proceeds to 'rthin outrr and reduce in quantity, lnstrunents dropping out
of the texture, until all that is l-eft is a flute solo accornpanied by a piano trill' This entire section
is based on bar 100. Bar 101 is a re-reading of bar 1OO, bar 102 is a re-reading of bar'101' bar 10J is a
Pitch and rhythn are interlocked and nutually dependent upon each other in the automatic codes that
govern the re-reading of the materiaL in this section. The process used is very similar to that described
Qnce again, the notes forming the intervals contract semitone by semitone towards a central axis, the
axis being either a unison or a roinor 2nd. In the case of a mj-nor 2nd axis' one of the notes is transposed
one octave (to nake a minor 9th) and the diminution process starts again. In the case of a unison axis,
there is always a residual rest. Upon the re-reading of the material the rest is omitted' thus reducing
the anount of naterial- per bar. Rests are also created by negating bhe repetition of a note by inserting
a rest.
Again in connon lrith the previous section is the presence of irregularities in lhe grouping of the
notes forning the intervals to be dininished. There are notes which are ungrouped and others which forn
Double Groupings.
In re-reading bar 100 to form bar 101, the grace-notes of bar'l0O are transformed into the equal
rhybhmic subdivisions of bar 101 the previous rests are omitted. The rhythm then continues to be en-
-and
tirely the result of how nany notes and rests are avaj.lable after any given re-reading to be fitted into
Dynamics
The piano holds the dynanic of pppp (estabJ-ished by the dynamic for the pianors second phrase of
The other instruments each rotate through the dynamics of pp, ppp, pppp in that order. The signal for
a change in dynanic is the presence of a resti after each rest the dynarnic is changeci. The commencing
-100
The F]ute from Bar
Figure 136 shows the continuity and interval dininution of the rnaterial fron bars 101-145 together
vith the source Datrlal for thls section, bar 100. The grouplng of the intervals to be diminighed ls
oholrn by a! between the tuo notse conoernd. Observatlons on these processes aro outlined bel"ow.
)6t,
tol
F I G U R E1 3 5 ( c o n t i n u e d )
r .!uunI t ro ( co:]t1nueo./
F I G U R E1 3 6
Continuity and llterval Dininution o.i the Flute frorn Bar' 100
ta-
Although one nay think that the particu'1r code or system used i n t h i s section is raLher arbitrary,
there are sone surprising structural considerations which come about c o m p l e t e l y b y " h a r , c e . 5 0 First of all,
E1
( pp sempre)
:.-.:----::\
F'ICURE137
This is perhaps the inevitable result of Donatonirs process of eliminating all the intervals with an even
nunber of senitones and recycling all the intervals with an odd number of semitones: if there is arr even
nunber of notes per bar (in this case 1l+), tlne same intervals will be re-read each time leaving only odd-
nunbered intervals which will continue recycling. The sequence begins in the ffute at bar 125, starts
repeating itself at bar 139 and is interrupted at the end of bar 145 wlth the conclusion of the pianors
naterial-
i,
In 9g!9, Donatoni makes a point of exploring the structural ramifications of the frreducible Periodic
Sequence even though these ranificatlons are completely ignored and left undeveloped as the piece progresses.
Indeed, they nay have only been discovered in retrospect. The lrreducible Periodic Sequcnce is 1d bars 1ong,
each bar having 1{ notes. Its range is from f-sharpr to fr I I and the number of times each note occurs in
the sequence is given on the following scaIe. The brackets show the symmetry which is already present.
t:
- 7 c t , , t ! , 2 p e 7 ' , 6 t t I
t , + 6 7 I 1 3 t + t + t + t t
, t t t t r * ' l l l l I
FICURE138
F I G U R E1 3 9
'1
The Clarinet fron Bar 00
Figure 1{O shows the continuity and intervaf diminution of the cfarinet from bar 100. Observations on
Bar 1l+)z Inbar 1t+2the naterial is reduced to a trill between g-sharpr and a' According to the
trrules'r, this interval of a minor 2nd should expand to a minot 9th and conti-nue diminishing.
However, Donatoni chooses to end the process in bar 143 with the minor 9th in grace-notes.
Figure 1dl shows the continuity and interval dininution of the vlolin from bar 100. Observations on
0rouping Variants
Irregularities
Bar 1232 lnbat 122 the naterial is reduced to a tril1 between brand crr. lnstead of the interval
expanding to a rninor 9th and continuing to diminish, the process ends in bar 123 with the
Figure 1{2 shows the continuity and interval diminution of the ce1lo from bar 100. Observations on
Grouping Variants
IrregularLtLes
Bar 1 0/+: The expected result of the d to e-flat grouping in bar 103 would be either D to e-flat
or al to o-flott but not tho glvon rosult of d to E-flat (rnarkedwith a (?)). Perhaps
the octave change was madeto makeperfornance of the line more practical.
1to
.tiluuK.r, r 4u ( con!J.nueq,,
(t) i4) (6, (r) t.t /t, ' /t) /,2t n' ,c t'') /'.,
b' 1t) 6t /1,
F I G U R E1 4 0 ( c o n t i n u e d )
FIGURE 140
FIGURE141
F I C U R E1 4 2 ( c o n t i n u e d )
r /o
T h e P i a n o f r o m B a r 1O O
Figure 143 shows the continuity and interval dj"minution of the piano from bar 100. Observations on
Grouping Vari.pnts
Decorati-on
notes always occur synnetrically within the bar. For exanple, in bar 101 the second and fourth notes of the
bar have grace-notes as do the second-last and fourth-last notes. This is because the pitch content of each
grace-note is taken fron the note in the corresponding synmetrical position. Therefore, in bar 101, the
pitch of the second note becomes tire grace-note for the second-last note and the pitch of the second-last
Figure 144 shohrsall the bars which are decorated with grace-notes, together with arrows showing their
derivation.
The decorated notes are chosen systematically: each symroetrical pair of notes which are a ninor 9th
or naJor 7th apart (or their compoundequivalents) are the ones chosen for decoration. (Minor 2nds' however,
are not decorated.) The only exception (which nay have been an oversight whilst composing) is in bar 103
where the fifth note c and its symmetrical partner c-sharprt are feft undecorated.
179
f ttjUltll | 4J (conafnued l
13) 4' tr) t.) /r) 6, tr)
FIGITRE1/'3 ( continued )
t (r, at)
I ' I G U R E1 4 3 ( c o n t i n u e d )
F I G U R E1 4 1 ( c o n t i n u e d )
183
rrcuRE 11+3
B A R S1 4 6 - 1 6 5
General Construction
Bars 146-166 take bars 1lrt-1/r5 of the flute and, using this material, try to reconstruct the original
Schoenberg Text:
...an attenpt, without success, at reconstructing the original material with the precise scope of re-
integrating Sg[oenbergts text: the end must be regarded as an arbitrary interruption of an experiment
which failed.)z
Rhvthmic Structure
1t.6-155 are also subdivided into 14 crotchets eaeh (notated in thi.s case as 7 + 7). Bars 156-165 continue
this process but ln rhythnic dininution naking 28 quaver subdivisions per bar (7 + 7 + 7 + 7). Bar 155 is
the trarbitrary interruptiontr of the process and conbines the triplets of the Schoenberg Text in the piano
Pitch Structure
Bars 1t+l+-1t+5of the flute (which hereafter sha1l be calLed the Pil-ot Sequence) are used without any
change in their note order. Notes which are used in each attenpt to reconstruct the Schoenberg Text are
generally sustained untif the last note used is sounded. The notes of the Pilot Sequence which are left
over are distributed aoongst the other instruments. The piano contains all the Schoenberg Text fragnrents
which are ori.ginal; that is, without transposition or inversion. The wind and strings contain afl the
inversions.Aswitha11theinversionsin@'theirconstanttransposition1eve1is
Figure 1{! shous how the Pilot Sequence relates to each bar and also how each bar rel-ates to the
Schoenberg Text.
Upon exanination of these exanples it can be seen that, despite Donatonirs admission of failure quoted
previously, the impossible task of re-integrating the Schoenberg Text fron the given naterial is handfed
very elegantly. Even within the restrictions of the Pilot Sequence, Donatoni presents the Schoenberg Text
In bar 1/,6 the Criginal and Inversion are both present in the same bar.53 An attenpt is nade to do
the sane in bar 1/i7 rith the G-flat1, C-sharp, A and c figure but, because the pitch-class A is absent fron
the Pllot Sequence, both the Original and Inversion rernain inconplete.
The 0riginal of the next figure, C, B-flat, d and b, is found in bars 1/+9-150, The Inversion is in
bar 1/+8but again is incomplete because the pitch-chss A is absent from the Pilot Sequence. (Tne C ot
186
clwos r im Ausdruck
P I C U R E1 / - 5 ( c o n t i n u e d )
alwos ruhigcr Ausdruck
d.d -i-
< >
=
J w
I
L.--:3-'
{vt .
F I C U R E1 4 5 ( c o n t i n u e d )
190
il"'3;"'',
F I G U R E1 4 5 ( c o n i : i n u e d )
\
i.
d
d
o
t:
a
E l l t
Bl ' l
< L
c f
I p
L I
J I
Cl cl
5 l
]-\
- --l
rt
r
tl
lqr^
!< Ll t '
E I I
L I
3 l
ct ir
= l
5 l
! [
3
ll-\
E-t
(
r l
9 t l,l I
l"r r^
ll
E lt'
I
< L ll' J
E I I
L
o
ot
I
l
.rr
I
I
l el
o
i-\
:_i
5
o
c
rl o
o
Tr {
3l.l
< L
E f kl
:f ll ()
H
tl Fr
i t &
o --1
'
E-i
\
S
I
.1wos ruhigcr im Ausdruck
d'a 'ffi
-l._J^--:' ,i-,.
,^.,6r,
s ruhigcr
;-J..-_J._
-J-'------r --> ffi
3
flr,-,
t tu utt!, | 4) [ contlnueo,f
195
-r--l
= z - T,
.lwqs ruhigcr im
--J-r
)-) rJ- Ppw
st
Pp \?
"= -t=,JriY
,
JJ L-:J--'
l6E .-'----
?PPPlexoo lP2P14r,
!ut. poDt.
-?-;-------1
E
F I G U R E1 4 5 ( c o n t i n u e d )
alwos ruhiglr im Ausdr-uck
f t - J -
d'd -3- a-->
wl
stJ
F I C U R E1 4 5 ( c o n t i n u e d )
.lwo3 ruhig.r im Ausdr_uck -
l i - ' _ ,r-;---J-
c'd ---J-',: -J-
.it :-> ffi
<> sl
pp .:-_zJl
q
g a J
L_:3_J
F I G U R E1 4 , 5 ( c o n t i n u e d )
pp\= '='
+?J
-t,luur(!, | 4) \ conf,lnueo,t
clwos ruhigcr im Aurdruck
).J -J--.:?,-ffiJ-
pp\? 7='
-Jr
FIGURE 145
The Original of the next figure" F, F-sharp and E, is found in txls 151-153, The fnversion is in
bar 1l+9.
The 0riginal of the next figure, C-shlrp, a, dr and gr, is found jn bars 153-151,. Once again, the
pitch-c1ass A is absent fron the Pilot Sequence and consequently the Original is incomplete. The Inversion,
The Original of the last figure of the Schoenberg Text is found in bar 155. This parLicular figure
afso narks the interruption of the process up to date to be followed by a further attempt at re-i-ntegration
of the Schoenberg Text by continuing in rhythmic dininution (that is, using 28 quavers per bar). The figure
itself is only made possi.ble by bringing back the drrand grrfrom b a r 1 5 / +a n d p r e s e n t i n g then as grace-notes.
The inplication of the grace-notes is perhaps that one can bend the rrrulesrr and project them to where they
are needed, because they are theoretically of no rhythuric vatue. Even with the addition of the grace-notes,
The Inverslon ls found in bar 15J and likewise is only made possible by the grace-notes d, g and cl
brought back fron bar 152. With the addition of the grace-notes the Inversion conpletes the required figure.
Bar 156 begins the cycle agaln and contains the Original and Inversion of the first two figures of the
Schoenberg Text. The Inversion of the third figure is in bar 157 followed by its Original in bars 157-158.
The Original and Inversion of the second figure and the Inversion of the third figure each contaj-n an
added grace-note group a, arand alr. These notes (at each of the octave registers) are those which are
required to conplete the given figures but are absent from thc Pilot Sequencc: tllL- second figrrre Original
requires a, its Inversion requires al and the third figure fnversion requires att. In each case, the three
Ars are added in their cornplete forn as a rrsupplementary grouprr even though only one A is required at a time.
The Inversion of the fourth figure appears in bar 157 fofLowed by the Original in bars 158-159. The
fnversion of the fifth (second last) figure appears in bars 158-159 follor,red by the Original in bars 159-160.
The 0riginal- of the fifth figure also contains the rrsupplementary grouprr of a, ar and arr to fil1 in for
The fnversion of the last figure appears in bar 159 and brings back a grace-note grouping of d, g and
cr in otder to conplete the figure, just as it did in bats 152-153.54 The Original '160
is in bar and brings
back both the dr and gt (as it did previously in bars 15/'-155) and thetrsupplementary grouprtof a, arand art
With the presentation of this last figure, the process is again interrupted to be followed by the next
phase which starts at bar 161.55 This final phase uses the Pilot Sequence to trigger the presentation of
the naterial fron the Schoenberg Text but does not distribute the leftover material among the other instru-
nents. It seems that one note in the Pilot Sequence useful for reconstruction is now sufficient to trigger
any nunber of required notes (whether or not they appear in the Pilot Sequence) provided they are presented
vertically in a chord.
The flrst two flgures and their Inversions are in bar 151. The Inversions display extra decorating
naterlal obtained by synnetry. The third,,fourth and fifth figures and their fnversions are in bars 162-j65,
55. Another nisprint: the clefs for the violin and the ce1lo are confused.
?03
The Inversion of the last figure is in bar164 (supplementedby the d, g and ctbrought back from the
previous figure) followed by the Original in bar 165. This brings to an end Lhe final phase of the re-
construction atteupt.
Bar 166' the final bar in the piece, presents the courplete Schoenberg Text in the piano (transposed
an octave higher) accompanied by inverted (but not retrograde) figures. The exception is tl.re trilled ft
to er figure in the clarinet which' because of its synmctrical posiLion between Lhe boundary notcs Dl and
Dynanics
The naterial used in the reconstruction of the Schoenberg Text is assigned the appropriate dlaramic
fron the Schoenberg Text. The leftover material from the Pilot Sequence is assigned the dynamic of pppp.
CONCLUSION
Although the main thrust of this study is to present the finer delails of the composition technique
usetl in Etwas Ruhiger im Ausdruck, some comnents must be made concerning the aural- effects of the music.
Fron the aural viewpoint, as opposed to the structural viewpolnt, the pi.ece may be divided into only three
sections: bars 1-20, bars 21-1/+5 and bars 1/+6-166. The first section (1-20) and the fast section (bars
The first section is composed entirely of real (as opposed to tonal- or otherwise altered) retrograde
inversions and transpositions of the Schoenberg Text. This results in a consistency of intervallic quality
for the first 20 bars giving a unifled and satisfying resul-t. Likewise the third seclion, being almost
who1Ly derivod fron bars 1l'/+-1/'5 of the flute (with no pitch-c1ass alterations), Jisplays a similar uni-ty.
The reconstruction of the Schoenberg Teri also provides a satisfying intervallic relationship to the first
section.
In conparison, the niddle section is by far the most aurally inconsistent area of the piece. The
systen of interval diminution enployed ensures that intervallic quality always remains in a state of f1ux.
Thls aspect, conbined with the fact that each instrunent pursues its course independently, results in a
certaln lack of control vhich is perceived. aurally. These results, of course, may be quite within the
composelts intentions. The whole niddle section seems as if it could almost be a written-out version of
an aleatoric passage taken fron a previous aleatoric piece. The processes are essentially the sar:oe: a
set of autonatises act on a body of naterial to form a result which is not pre-specified.
Out of a nunber of possible exanples of aural inconsistencies, bar 42 is ren:arkpble for its conr-
pletely exposed octave between the flute and the clarinet within an atonal and dissonant context:
F I C U R E1 4 6
Elsewhere, tonal chords energe from a sinilarl-y dissonant context. An exanple of this is in bar 80 of
20t,
the flute lrhere the first six notes of the bar form an arpeggio of E major:
F I G U R E1 1 7
Notwithstan.Ilngtheabovecomnents,ana1ysisof@sho"s it to be a superb
exauple of nusLc constructed systenatically but without recourse to the 12-tone row.
BIBLIOCRAPHY
Writings by Donatoni
Books
I 1 S i g a r o d i A r r n a r r d o ,M i 1 a n , S p i r a l i Edizloni, 1982.
Articles
1Su||FaseSeconila|'diMarioBorto1ottot,@,Rome,1959.
| 52 Interventit , W, n . 8 - 9 , S e p t e n b e r 1 9 ? 1.
lSuF11i,TheHeartlsEye'LtU1tinaSera,LeRuisseausur].|Esca]ier',@'1981.
Wrltings on Donatoni
Books
Aitleles
206
)41
Bortolotto, M. t N o w aM u z y k aw e W l o s z e c h r , R u c h . M u z y c z n v ,
n, 1a, 1962.
Rnrinla*+^ M f T h e N e v rM u s i c i n I t a l y r , T h e M u s i c a l -Q u a r t e r l v , 1 9 6 5 .
Cresti, R. rLe Parole Piu caloer, Bollettino der centro Musicale Fiorentino, Florence,
1979.
Cresti., R. rPer una Storia Filosofica deL segno Musicaler, R1yista del-la civica ScuoLa
di Milano, Mi1an, 19 8 2 .
Degrada, I'. r C j - n q u eD o m a n d ea F r a n c o D o n a t o n i t , D i s c o t e c a ,
n. ZZ, Milan, 196g.
Jarocinski, S. r O P a r u F e s l i w a l o w y c hh ' y d a t z e n i a c h r ,
R u c h M u z v c z n v ,n . 21, 196j.
Marco, T. l r f P e r O r c h e s t r a r r d eF r a n c o D o n a t o n i r , S o n d a ,
n, 1,,196g.
Markiewicz, L. f S p r a w aD o n a t o n i e g o r , R u c h M u z y c z n v ,
n. 22, 1963.
Selni, A. t C f e F o r m a e F o r m a , l r l m p o r t a n t e e S a p e r J - o r ,M u s i c a V i v a ,
anno II, n. I+,
A p r 1 1 19 7 8 .
Sinigaglia, A. rDonatoni: If Contenuto dell-a Musica e l-a sua Formar, Tuttolibri, n, 26g,
T u r j . n , 1! 8 1 .
s o u v e n i r ( K a r n m e r s v n p h o n i eo p u s ' 1 8 ) ( 1 9 6 7 ) f o r 1 5 i n s t r u m e n t s
Teatronusica di Rooat Conductor: Marcello panni
cBs 61t55
Etwas Ruhiger im Ausdruck (1967) tor^ f1ute, clarinet, violin, cel1o and piano
Contlnuum Dortnund Ensenblei Conductor: Werner Sej.ss
cBs-Esz61/,5/.
AIi (1977) two pieces for solo viola
Vi.ola: Aldo Bennici
Disco Italia ITL 70038
209
A P P E N D I XA
T H E F I P T H P I E C E F R O MF I V E P I A N O P I ] I C E S ( O P . 2 3 ) B Y A R N O L NS C I I O E N B E R C
Sehr rasch(J)
poco p.:ruo'3- | . h
I
3 5 J
| n; u 'qtf u-:;
.fI fi+
f,+ => J ,q
't= q:
hJ t . ? ,
ppq:
, J '
langsamer beginnsa4
n ))=)G"rcrundnroo)
--[
A P P E N D I XA ( c o n t i n u e d )
- et$as langsamer
allmdhlich
u)
l ' 7
sf dim.
r---- 20J
J3----__r r-J,--- j
---------.1
. J (a., tor.rcnT*tor)
, ,o'qq'{E{ jo=To-ff
22).J dolce
APPENDTX
B
SELECTEDEXCERPTSFROMDONATONI'SI,IORKS
F I G U R E 14 8
t'
ITIGURE 1 4,9
212
Ar|-LNUII\ U tCOnLlnueo/
- ' - " f
i ot
.(t -- "1.
I
I
.ir'
,
l
t ?
/ i r:
i: ,- ) t
llllill
t . (
:r -
l t
l
r .
'
tl
..:
:i
':l:
i.
:
.,)
li$
i ! 'i (i f
-';
} T
i(
" 1 l i
-) t fb,
:,t
' l
'r1.,|':
i
f,i
","n
', ,l;: -ai
'i,"'
lilll{l
o.
r I
o.
I
-i I N
O \ O
,'; \ r I q o
( f x
',
1r +ri p !
\-l l
ll
t ) H A
t r o
l)
O
rf '
r{
1., l
) o
'1t:
.'1., ;i.:
i : i "
rll
'Tr'
,i'i' r
c t l
/i
llilill
.t' t ' (
: f ,
',Ilt
'.1
r
:ilr;
^lr" {[ I F
?i
uu ...i. ( , t .
.t r l -
( ' r
'it "lli
l'' ri '$
r i t I t
l . , l t 1 '
i lr: li' {
1lr ,1, x.
.tlll,l ' l
it{ill{
'J ' Il
',
il
.. ,i'
"i'"]'
t
s
i
-rir,:';.
li{li1{
1' .'i-
-1t., x )
t
)t
: ' 1
il, r'tr
i r . l
11. ,'
'ri'l.ii
' ^:,1. ^, ri
-t?-'t- + . 1 "" . e . r l LS.
)1 |
A P P E N D I XB ( c o n t i n u e d )
;F,
I
B' oi|, :J
..lntoin.rt. r'i..h..
BABAI
PEP Ci AVICEMAAL.)
FRANCO DONATONI
F7:"4
E tsr{ r06.
lr
I Gr'l
9 - qr o.o.", ".o\ :.o..
trre.
Oa o
'+7
t-
: " e . o o . E c z o
'o
o o. o
o o
o o
i-
r
I
J
O E E ' o . - ;
L.J
o + o . o
o o @ o
; / 1
lllltrnnmtrl-!oooo6.0 oo\y'.tot
XIm @6ro
i;;.".i*;ltq
FICURE151
P a g e 1 0 o f D o u b l e s ( 1 9 6 1 ) a n d t h e C o r r e s p o n c l S - n gP a g e o f B a b a i ( 1 9 6 4 )
A P P E N D I XB ( c o n t i n u e d )
FIGURE 1 52
Divertimento II ( 1 9 6 5 ) B a r s 1 l + / * - 1/ , 9
ATT}JNU.L,( IJ (COntlnued,l
0t
cl.
fg
'-r.-....-.............-- 8*r-
lVn
trYn.
llr
FICURE153
l l
fl I
l f
I
r l t n
FIGURE154
F I G U R E1 5 5
I ' ] G U R E1 5 6
C.lb
PfP
C.t iE:ilff=_,lsr:-,=
I'ICIJN]] 153
Toy
per 2 violini, viola c clavicenrbalcr
FRANCO DONATONI
l:tsz I
5) AI:i'e'2 4
I
Vni
,. ':
Vla
*li.:, :,c
Clav.(
t
I
\
1 -
.' ,lb'
'|
o
i i-
I r +';
4
5r:
1
Vni
2
.v
Vni
I ' ] G U R E 15 9
a Oscar Ghiglia
)- t't il
T'I)
rs
l'P .
t - r ' -
J J
FICURE160
Al,eo(1977) p. 7
223
Arrurul^ lJ tconf,lnued/
F I G U R E1 6 1
{,l"J,.pn =-----=-rD
ttS-n
f f i - ' i
F I G U R E1 6 2
"f
h ,fri {" '8.:t .f ,t;
"t-r-,.
^o2 r?
"/
i)
.D.
-rir
& r;'I-
FICURE16'
226
))1
A P P E N D I XC ( c o n t i n u e d )
[..0.] Ash.
NOTE ON TERMINOLOCY
F I G U R E1 6 I ,
pitch-register
Terninology
<26