PAGE No.

:
L&T-VALDEL ENGINEERING HAND CHECK FOR
CONTRACT No.: COWGD725
LTD SACS OVERSTRESSED MEMBERS
SHEET 1 OF 3 REV.: 1
DOC.No. : COWGD725-73-RS15-302 ITEM NO :
PROJECT: MHS REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT PHASE - II
PREPD. : KR CHKD.: RP APPD.: BSR
DATE : 8/11/2008 DATE : 8/11/2008 DATE : 8/11/2008

Overstressed Member is 3186-3214

1 Original Section UB610X101

2 Yield Stress of beam 345 Mpa
3 Critical Loadcase 1350
4 `AMOD` factor 1.00

5 Calculated Stress (obtained from SACS):

a) Axial Stress fa or ft = 50.00 Mpa

b) Major axis bending Stress fby = 28.38 Mpa
c) Minor axis bending Stress fbz = 178.07 Mpa
. (Refer `SACS` member
6 Allowable stress (obtained from SACS): Report enclosed in
next Page)
a) Axial Stress Fa or Ft = 207.00 Mpa
b) Major axis bending Stress Fby = 207.00 Mpa
c) Minor axis bending Stress Fbz = 258.75 Mpa

7 Original UC Ratio:
a) Axial Fa or Ft = 0.24
b) Major axis bending Fby = 0.14
c) Minor axis bending Fbz = 0.69
Original `SACS` UC 1.07

8 SECTIONAL PROPERTIES OF BEAM UB 610X101

a) Depth D = 602.21 mm
b) Width B = 227.60 mm
c) Flange thickness tf = 14.80 mm
d) Web thickness tw = 10.60 mm
e) Area A = 12807 mm2
f) Moment of Inertia-Major axis I-maj = 747115466 mm4
g) Moment of Inertia-Minor axis I-min = 29139031 mm4

9 PROPERTIES OF BEAM UB 610X101 with 300X16 Star Plates

a) Revised Depth R.D = 602.21 mm
b) Star Plate Width Bs = 300.00 mm
c) Star Plate thickness ts = 16.00 mm
d) Web thickness tw = 10.60 mm
c) Revised Area R.A = 15644 mm2
d) Revised Major axis Moment of Inertia RI-maj = 9.887E+08 mm4
e) Revised Minor axis Moment of Inertia RI-min = 7.206E+07 mm4

10 Ratio of section modulus of original section to modified section

a) Section Modulus of Orginal Section in Major-Axis (Zorg ) = 2481246 mm3

b) Location of COG for Revised Section (from the top of star plat = 272 mm
c) Section Modulus of Revised Section in Major-Axis (Zrev) = 2994262 mm3

11 Revised UC Ratio
a) Axial Fa or Ft = 0.24
b) Major axis bending Fby = 0.11
c) Minor axis bending Fbz = 0.28

Revised SACS UC 0.63 <1

Hence the Section is safe with Star Plates

LTV5040-1/0
 PAGE No.:
L&T-VALDEL ENGINEERING HAND CHECK FOR
CONTRACT No.:
LTD SACS OVERSTRESSED MEMBERS
SHEET 3 OF 3
DOC.No. : COWGD725-73-RS15-302 ITEM NO :
PROJECT: MHS REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT PHASE - II
PREPD. : KR CHKD.: RP APPD.: BSR
DATE : 8/11/2008 DATE : 8/11/2008 DATE : 8/11/2008

Overstressed Member is 1465-617G

1 Original Section UB203X30

2 Yield Stress of beam 250 Mpa
3 Critical Loadcase 1750
4 `AMOD` factor 1.00

5 Calculated Stress (obtained from SACS):

a) Axial Stress fa or ft = 20.48 Mpa

b) Major axis bending Stress fby = 105.77 Mpa
c) Minor axis bending Stress fbz = 89.57 Mpa
(Refer `SACS` member
6 Allowable stress (obtained from SACS): Report enclosed in
next Page)
a) Axial Stress Fa or Ft = 150.00 Mpa
b) Major axis bending Stress Fby = 165.00 Mpa
c) Minor axis bending Stress Fbz = 187.5 Mpa

7 Original UC Ratio:
a) Axial Fa or Ft = 0.14
b) Major axis bending Fby = 0.64
c) Minor axis bending Fbz = 0.48
Original `SACS` UC 1.26

8 SECTIONAL PROPERTIES OF BEAM UB 203X30

a) Depth D = 206.80 mm
b) Width B = 133.80 mm
c) Flange thickness tf = 9.60 mm
d) Web thickness tw = 6.30 mm
e) Area A = 3751 mm2
f) Moment of Inertia-Major axis I-maj = 28461289 mm4
g) Moment of Inertia-Minor axis I-min = 3836463 mm4

9 PROPERTIES OF BEAM UB203X30with 150X20 Star Plates

a) Revised Depth R.D = 206.80 mm
b) Star Plate Width Bs = 150.00 mm
c) Star Plate thickness ts = 20.00 mm
d) Web thickness A tw = 6.30 mm
c) Revised Area R.A = 7051 mm2
d) Revised Major axis Moment of Inertia RI-maj = 5.498E+07 mm4
e) Revised Minor axis Moment of Inertia RI-min = 1.125E+07 mm4

10 Ratio of section modulus of original section to modified section

a) Section Modulus of Orginal Section in Major-Axis (Zorg ) = 275254 mm3

b) Location of COG for Revised Section (from the top of star plate) = 76 mm
c) Section Modulus of Revised Section in Major-Axis (Zrev) = 420461 mm3

11 Revised UC Ratio
a) Axial Fa or Ft = 0.14
b) Major axis bending Fby = 0.42
c) Minor axis bending Fbz = 0.16

Revised SACS UC 0.72 <1

Hence the Section is safe with Star Plates

LTV5040-1/0
 COWGD725
REV.: 1

BSR
8/11/2008

(Refer `SACS` member

Report enclosed in
next Page)
 PAGE No.:
L&T-VALDEL ENGINEERING HAND CHECK FOR
CONTRACT No.: COWGD725
LTD SACS OVERSTRESSED MEMBERS
SHEET 2OF 3 REV.: 1
DOC.No. : COWGD725-73-RS15-302 ITEM NO :
PROJECT: MHS REDEVELOPMENT PROJECT PHASE - II
PREPD. : KR CHKD.: RP APPD.: BSR
DATE : 8/11/2008 DATE : 8/11/2008 DATE : 8/11/2008

Overstressed Members are 1454-1465,1439-1440,1446-1447,1484-1485

Conservatively member1484-1485 with highest UC among UB356x45 has been checked

1 Original Section UB356X45

2 Yield Stress of beam 345 Mpa
3 Critical Loadcase 1350
4 `AMOD` factor 1.00

5 Calculated Stress (obtained from SACS):

a) Axial Stress fa or ft = 54.13 Mpa

b) Major axis bending Stress fby = 212.32 Mpa
c) Minor axis bending Stress fbz = 423.43 Mpa
(Refer `SACS` member
6 Allowable stress (obtained from SACS): Report enclosed in
next Page)
a) Axial Stress Fa or Ft = 207.00 Mpa
b) Major axis bending Stress Fby = 227.70 Mpa
c) Minor axis bending Stress Fbz = 258.75 Mpa

7 Original UC Ratio:
a) Axial Fa or Ft = 0.26
b) Major axis bending Fby = 0.93
c) Minor axis bending Fbz = 1.64
Original `SACS` UC 2.83

8 SECTIONAL PROPERTIES OF BEAM UB 356X45

a) Depth D = 351.99 mm
b) Width B = 171.00 mm
c) Flange thickness tf = 9.70 mm
d) Web thickness tw = 6.90 mm
e) Area A = 5612 mm2
f) Moment of Inertia-Major axis I-maj = 118348826 mm4
g) Moment of Inertia-Minor axis I-min = 8092779 mm4

9 PROPERTIES OF BEAM UB 356X45 with 300X16 Star Plates

a) Revised Depth R.D = 351.99 mm
b) Star Plate Width Bs = 300.00 mm
c) Star Plate thickness ts = 16.00 mm
d) Web thickness tw = 6.90 mm
c) Revised Area R.A = 11808 mm2
d) Revised Major axis Moment of Inertia RI-maj = 289978906 mm4
e) Revised Minor axis Moment of Inertia RI-min = 72008760 mm4

10 Ratio of section modulus of original section to modified section

a) Section Modulus of Orginal Section in Major-Axis (Zorg ) = 672456 mm3

b) Location of COG for Revised Section (from the top of star plate) = 117 mm
c) Section Modulus of Revised Section in Major-Axis (Zrev) = 1233069 mm3

11 Revised UC Ratio
a) Axial Fa or Ft = 0.26
b) Major axis bending Fby = 0.51
c) Minor axis bending Fbz = 0.18

Revised SACS UC 0.95 <1

Hence the Section is safe with Star Plates

LTV5040-1/0