Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Teaneck, NJ 07666
1086 Teaneck Road
Jewish Standard
I am proud to announce the
opening of my new offices.
CALL DR. LISS FOR EXPERIENCE AND EXPERTISE
IN CONSERVATIVE (NONOPERATIVE) CARE
No-go zone
l This sign found in a Jaffa park-
ing garage pretty much speaks for
itself. The Hebrew caption reads:
The restrooms are at Rabbi Pin-
chas Street #13-15.
CONTENTS
NOSHES4
BRIEFLY LOCAL16
COVER STORY 18
JEWISH WORLD 23
OPINION 26
JEWISH
JEWISHSTANDARD
STANDARDMARCH 3, 2017 3
JUNE 30,
Noshes
My credo is if it doesnt make you
laugh it wont make them laugh.
Comedy is real.
Mel Brooks, as quoted in Tablet.
PIG IN A POKE:
Okja plays
unevenly with
mood swings
The title ogist who enters into
character of dangerous relationships
Okja, a film with her patients, was a
that began streaming on good sign. But advance
Netflix on June 28, is a reviews have panned
pig genetically engi- Gypsy as plodding and
neered by a big nasty too full of filler. Begins
company to grow as big streaming June 30.
Darren Aronofsky Benjamin Millipied
as a hippo. The baby So far, we
Okja is sent out to be havent heard
fostered on an organic Goldies last
Korean farm. A young name. Goldie, a comedy
Korean girl bonds with club owner, is featured in
Okja, and shes devastat- the new Showtime series
ed when Dr. Wilcox Im Dying Up Here (see
(JAKE GYLLENHAAL, June 9 column), but no Dave Franco and Alison Brie
36) takes Okja to ones even mentioned
America. So she sets off her last name. The
to get Okja back. credits, however, reveal it
Variety criticized the
films jarring change in
is Herschlag. Obviously,
the writers didnt pick The Hours fly by
tones: from the sweetly
familiar (child in love with
that at random: It is well
known that Herschlag is Ohad Naharain Billy Joel
with Alison and Dave
animal in danger) to NATALIE PORTMANs The Little Hours, co-starring the busy ALISON
weird, adult scenes of original last name. by Israeli choreogra- tion ceremony at BRIE, 34, and DAVE FRANCO, 32, opens in limited
Okja mating roughly and (Portman is her paternal pher OHAD NAHARAIN, Hicksville High School on
theater release on June 30. This comic romp is set in a
in a grim slaughterhouse. grandmas maiden 65, was well received. Long Island. It was the
name.) Dont think its a medieval nunnery. Brie plays a nun who is very bored
The films co-writer, JON Hes the director of the 50th anniversary of his
RONSON, 50, is a dig its more an inside famous Batsheva Dance almost-graduation from and looking for irreligious fun. Franco plays a hot new
journalist and documen- joke to amuse the writers Company of Israel. Hicksville. (He left high groundskeeper who pretends to be deaf. Hours got
tary filmmaker. He was and well-informed Sadly, the New York school one credit short.) good reviews at Sundance. Brie and Franco, both the
born and raised in Wales viewers. Times savaged the Also last week, a children of Jewish mothers, wed last March.
and hes the second Portman, 36, was there dances Millipied cre- Manhattan By the way, the reviews are in for Glow, Bries
Welsh Jew to appear in when her husbands ated: If it wasnt for his federal judge new Netflix series, and they are great. Entertainment
this column. The first was company, the L.A. Dance own creations, Id call Mr. approved the request of
Project, performed in a Weekly called it a silly, smart masterpiece. N.B.
prolific actor ROGER Millepied enterpris- Cameron Douglas, 38, to
REES (1944-2015), who New York City theater ing, chic, unpredictable, leave the New York area
was a devout convert to from June 14 to 25. So modern a very consid- to go to California to visit
Judaism. was DARREN ARONOF- erable force for good in his grandfather, KIRK son on the phone and mary, died on June 15 at
I was excited SKY, 48, who directed the dance world. But hes DOUGLAS, 100. Camer- asks when he will come 92. He was best known
when I read that Portman in the ballet been making consistent- ons long history of drug out to see him. Outside for playing the comic
LISA RUBIN, film Black Swan (2010). ly unimportant dances abuse led to a six-year the court, Cameron Mexican bellhop Jose
only about 25, got her (She won the best ac- for many years now. stay in prison that ended thanked the judge Jimnez on TV, and for
big break and sold tress Oscar for Black Theyre what stop the last August when he was profusely and said that his comedy records. He
Gypsy, a 10-episode Swan.) The program L.A. Dance Project from paroled. He almost was the trip had nothing to do was also a WWII combat
thriller series, to Netflix. featured works choreo- becoming an important sent back to jail in April with Kirks health. He is veteran and the writer of
Word that the usually graphed by BENJAMIN company. Ouch! when he tested positive healthy, Cameron said. the famous All in the
solid Nicole Kidman MILLIPIED, 40, Port- BILLY JOEL, 68, for marijuana. The N.Y. Comedian BILL Family episode featur-
signed on to play the mans husband, and by spoke last week Post reports that Kirk DANA, born ing SAMMY DAVIS Jr.
lead character, a psychol- others. The dance Yag, at the gradua- often talks to his grand- William Szath- N.B.
Want to read more noshes? Visit facebook.com/jewishstandard California-based Nate Bloom can be reached at
Middleoftheroad1@aol.com
SPECIAL LEASE
OFFERS*
On select Models.
Hurry, offers end soon.
benzelbusch.com
*See your Benzel-Busch Account
Representative for complete details.
4 32185
JEWISHMBSE STANDARD
Strip Ad_2017.inddJUNE
1 30, 2017 6/5/17 5:24 PM
R.
A&S D
S
JO-ANN FABRIC
.
RD
AND CRAFTS
G
RIN
50 A&S Dr
Paramus, NJ 07652
201-477-6044
17 North near Paramus Park Mall at Ring Rd
7 AM-9 PM M-F | 8 AM-9 PM SAT | DEDICATED PRO TEAM
CLOSED SUN
flooranddecor.com
NOW OPEN
IN PARAMUS LARGEST IN-STOCK
SELECTION
29 SQ.FT
69 SQ. FT.
99 SQ. FT.
89
YOUR CHOICE
SQ.FT
LAMINATE SHENANDOAH PURE
SPRING MAPLE BROWN WOOD PLANK DIMENSIONS
6MM CERAMIC TILE LIQUID WOOL GLASS
6 X 24 LAMINATE LIGHT GRAY TILE
TIGERWOOD PORCELAIN TILE
12MM 4 X 8
24 X 24
1
$ 39
1
$ 99
2
$ 49
4
$ 79
13
$ 19
SQ. FT. SQ. FT. EACH EACH
YOUR CHOICE
Limited NO INTEREST! *
Time!
IF PAID IN FULL WITHIN 18 MONTHS WITH REGULAR PAYMENTS
ON IN-STORE PURCHASES OF $499 OR MORE WITH YOUR
FLOOR & DECOR CREDIT CARD MADE 6/29/17 THROUGH 7/30/17.
*OFFER APPLIES ONLY TO SINGLE-RECEIPT QUALIFYING PURCHASES. NO INTEREST WILL BE CHARGED ON THE PROMO PURCHASE IF YOU PAY THE PROMO PURCHASE AMOUNT IN FULL WITHIN 18 MONTHS. IF YOU DO NOT, INTEREST
WILL BE CHARGED ON THE PROMO PURCHASE FROM THE PURCHASE DATE. DEPENDING ON PURCHASE AMOUNT, PROMOTION LENGTH AND PAYMENT ALLOCATION, THE REQUIRED MINIMUM MONTHLY PAYMENTS MAY OR MAY NOT
PAY OFF PURCHASE BY END OF PROMOTIONAL PERIOD. REGULAR ACCOUNT TERMS APPLY TO NON-PROMOTIONAL PURCHASES AND, AFTER PROMOTION ENDS, TO PROMOTIONAL BALANCE. FOR NEW ACCOUNTS: PURCHASE APR IS
29.99%; MINIMUM INTEREST CHARGE IS $2. EXISTING CARDHOLDERS SHOULD SEE THEIR CREDIT CARD AGREEMENT FOR THEIR APPLICABLE TERMS. SUBJECT TO CREDIT APPROVAL.
**NO PURCHASE NECESSARY TO ENTER OR WIN. PURCHASE DOES NOT INCREASE CHANCES OF WINNING. MUST BE LEGAL U.S. RESIDENT LIVING WITHIN 250 MILES OF PARAMUS, 18+ AT TIME OF ENTRY. SEE COMPLETE OFFICIAL
RULES AT WWW.FLOORANDDECORRULES.COM/PARAMUSDICEROLL FOR DETAILS INCLUDING ELIGIBILITY RESTRICTIONS, PRIZE DESCRIPTIONS AND ARV. REGISTRATION AND GRAND PRIZE EVENT LOCATION: FLOOR & DECOR, 50 A&S
DR, PARAMUS, NJ 07652. REGISTRATION PERIOD: 7/1/2017, 12:00PM 2:00PM PT. OPEN ONLY TO FIRST (200) ELIGIBLE CONTESTANTS. IN THE EVENT THAT NO FINALIST COMPLETES GRAND PRIZE WINNING REQUIREMENTS, THE
GRAND PRIZE WILL NOT BE AWARDED. ODDS OF WINNING THE GRAND PRIZE ARE 1:46,656. SPONSOR: FLOOR & DECOR, 2233 LAKE PARK DR., SUITE 400, SMYRNA, GA 30080.
I
f a community can commission
music, then certainly music can help
create community, contends singer/
songwriter Michelle Citrin. Raised
in Fair Lawn, the musician, composer,
and producer is working on a new album
dedicated to taking the old and making
it new.
But its not just those liturgical texts,
and most specifically the psalms, that Ms.
Citrin will render in a more modern and
accessible form. Her fundraising approach
seeking community support online
through Kickstarter is taking the old
form of supporting the arts and making it
new via the internet.
Weve come full circle, said Ms. Citrin,
who now lives in Brooklyn. Before there
was recorded music, communities that
supported the arts sponsored musicians
to write, and then perform, their new
compositions. Just think of Mozart and his
many patrons.
Drawing on that approach, Ms. Citrin has
created a video explaining the importance
of bringing ancient Jewish wisdom into
everyday life and is asking those in the com-
munity who endorse that goal to help her
do it by contributing money. She believes
the music industry is in flux. Today, with Michelle Citrin, who grew up in Fair Lawn, is using Kickstarter to make a new album of old-turned-new Jewish music.
fewer people buying CDs and more people
streaming their music, the model is chang- internet and home recording technology, Modeh Ani. It helps people start off the fans of her music and interested in hearing
ing. To help defray the costs of producing more artists have the ability to share their day with gratitude, Ms. Citrin said. We her new pieces.
her new album, she has turned to Kick- works and be supported by an audience need hints and reminders of what prayers Ms. Citrin is no stranger to the internet.
starter, which calls itself the worlds larg- who enjoys it. are about. Everyone can appreciate that Her YouTube videos (20 Things to do
est funding platform for creative projects Ms. Citrin, who co-leads services at Tem- message even if theyre not observant. with Matzah, Rosh Hashanah Girl, and
a home for film, music, art, theater, games, ple Micah in Washington, D.C., during the Asking for money and watching peo- Hanukkah Lovin) have received millions
comics, design, photography, and more. High Holy Days and spends a good deal of ple step up to help is so humbling, of hits, and she has sold thousands of her
Citrins upcoming album, her second, time performing at synagogues and other she continued, and working to create the albums without the help of a record label.
due out in January her first, called Left venues around the world, said, I have a rewards also has been an amazing learn- Its a testament to modern technology,
Brained Right Hearted, explored the strug- lot of people coming up to me and saying, ing experience. She said that her entre- she said.
gle of heart versus head will be solely Jew- I didnt know what this prayer was about. preneurial spirit was invaluable when Its a very intimidating thing to ask
ish music. Ill be looking at ancient texts Ive just been going through the motions. she had to learn about producing mugs. the universe for money, Ms. Citrin said.
and finding modern connections, finding a The album will contain pieces Ms. Citrin Rewards vary with the size of the donation. You have to have time and a community
way to make them new, she said. has been doing over the past couple of Some people will get the digital version of to reach out to. Ive spent many years on
Jews have always reinterpreted texts, years, which she describes as mixing the CD, while others will get the product the road connecting with people. Its been
making them relevant so people can Hebrew with the English translation and itself. Still others will be sent videos of the incredible to invite my community to join
connect to them, she continued. They offering an interpretation. recording process, a phenomenal thing to me in the creation of this album. So much
contain beautifully rich pieces of wisdom, Her Kickstarter campaign has been watch, Ms. Citrin said. of the inspiration for the songs and proj-
and as my grandfather instilled in us, ein extremely successful. We have a 30-day The singer also will offer her expertise, ects I create come from my travels and
kol chadash tachat hashamesh, There is campaign to raise $25,000, and in just one and rewards include Skype counseling ses- interaction with people around the world,
nothing new under the sun. (Her grand- day, we fulfilled 30 percent of the albums sions on songwriting and singing. Those so it feels very natural and exciting to be
father, of course, was quoting Kohelet, the funding, which led to topping the charts synagogues that have contributed will able to engage this beloved community to
book of Ecclesiastes.) Now I appreciate of most popularly funded music projects receive a visit from Ms. Citrin. Theres help make new art possible.
what it means. My hope is to find ways on Kickstarter on Day 1, she said. Now its been a wide range of responses, ranging Its very rewarding to be a part of creat-
for people to embrace and celebrate Jew- up to about $17,000, and she is more than from $10 to $3,500, she said. ing something together, making this proj-
ish identity. halfway toward her goal of $25,000. Why do people contribute? I think that ect that much more meaningful.
Some things have changed, however, To make contributors feel even more a if people like what you do and believe in There is more information about
such as the platform through which music part of the effort, donations are acknowl- investing in the Jewish future and finding Ms. Citrin and a link to her Kickstarter
is funded, eliminating geography as an edged with rewards. One, the sip of grati- ways to make it relevant, this is an attrac- campaign on her homepage, www.
obstacle to reaching fans. Thanks to the tude mug, is printed with the prayer tive idea. Some contributors, she said, are michellecitrin.com
Sign up at www.seasonskosher.com/register
for a chance to win a
$500 Seasons Gift Card!
Use code: NJSTANDARD
Winner will be contacted the week of July 10
J
Edmund G. Love, the historian for Salomons division, and
ust before Memorial Day, I wrote a Noshes column never would have ended happily without him. Love was
item about Capt. Ben Salomon, a Jewish dentist who among the first on the scene of Salomons heroism. He
was posthumously awarded the Congressional Medal carefully documented what he saw, and that, along with
of Honor in 2002 for his heroism in World War II. the witness statements he gathered, allowed him to rec-
I noted that in November 2016, the American Friends ommend Salomon for the Medal of Honor.
of Dental Volunteers of Israel presented a special lecture A major general turned down the recommendation on
honoring Salomon. The AVI, as the organization is known, the grounds that the Geneva Convention did not allow a
is the sister organization of Dental Volunteers for Israel medical officer to take arms against the enemy.
(DVI). Founded by the late Trudi Birger, DVI runs a free In 1946, Love wrote a magazine article that mentioned
clinic for children in Israel. Salomon. Salomons father heard the article discussed
My column item prompted Dr. Scott Dubowsky of on the radio. He wrote the Pentagon. The Secretary of
Tenafly, a longtime Jewish Standard subscriber, to email War asked Love to visit Salomons father in Los Angeles
the Standard. He thanked me for the item and told me and also to re-submit the recommendation for the Medal
he is a dentist and the president of AVI. We exchanged of Honor.
further letters and I came to realize that several personal Capt. Love was the first person to tell Bens father how
stories, including Dr. Dubowskys, intertwined in what I his son had died. Until then, all his father had been told
came to think of as a remarkable chain of goodness. was by telegram and all it said was that his son had died.
Dr. Salomon, an only child, was born in 1914 and raised It took until 1951 before Capt. Love could submit a new
in Milwaukee. In 1937, he graduated from the University recommendation. The original recommendation papers
of Southern Californias dental school. In 1940, he was had been lost and several witnesses had died or couldnt
drafted into the peacetime army. An official Army article be found again. Loves new recommendation was rejected
says about his first year: when the Army ruled that the statute of limitations had
After basic training Ben joined the 102d Infantry Regi- run out for submitting papers for World War II awards.
ment and quickly proved to be a natural soldier and Capt. Ben Salomon In 1969, Dr. John Ingle, the dean of the USC School of
leader. He won awards as an expert rifle and pistol marks- Dentistry, who learned from his friend, Bens father, about
man, and his commanding officer stated that he was the Germany. Her family was prosperous and Orthodox. She Bens heroics, took over the fight. Again, it took a long
best all-around soldier in the regiment. Within a year he had one older brother. In 1934, a year after the Nazi take- time to put together more paperwork. Again, Capt. Love
had risen to the rank of sergeant and was in charge of a over, the family moved to Trudis parents birthplace: submitted an extensive account of the events on Saipan.
machine-gun section. Memel, Lithuania, a city that had been German before However, in 1972, the Department of Defense refused to
In 1942, with America at war, the Army realized it World War I. The Simons were living in Kovno (now act on the Secretary of the Armys recommendation that
needed more dentists, so Salomon was transferred to the Kaunas), Lithuanias capital, when the Germans invaded Salomon be awarded the Medal of Honor. This despite
Dental Corps. In July 1944, he went ashore on the island in June 1941. Many Kovno Jews soon were killed on the the fact that the statute-of-limitations bar had been elimi-
of Saipan, where a fierce battle raged. He quickly volun- streets. Those who survived, including the Simon family, nated by subsequent legislation and that legal counsel had
teered to replace his battalions wounded surgeon. were forced into the Kovno ghetto by August 1941. confirmed that under the Geneva Convention a medical
The final push to defeat the Japanese began on July 4. In March 1944, the Nazis swept the ghetto and rounded officer can take up arms in self-defense or to defend the
On July 5, Capt. Salomon set up an aid station 50 feet from up the children they planned to kill immediately. Trudis wounded and sick.
the front line. The next day, the Japanese, who were run- father tried to hide some children. He and the children In the mid-1990s, Col. John E. King, who had been work-
ning out of ammunition, were ordered to wage a suicide were discovered and murdered. Shortly thereafter, the ing on something else, came across Salomons story. At
attack against the Americans. ghetto was emptied. But Trudi and her mother survived. the same time, a USC dental school grad, Dr. Robert West,
Capt. Salomon defended the aid stations patients. They were sent to a labor camp where, through a series became interested in Salomons story. (In the mid-1960s, a
Inside the aid station tent, he killed several enemy soldiers of miracles, they were able to hang on to life, although major clinic at the school was named after Capt. Salomon.)
in hand-to-hand combat. When he went outside, he saw barely. Her brother was sent to different camp, and he, King and West joined forces and Dr. West put together the
that the enemys numbers were overwhelming, and he too, survived. paperwork for the medal. This time the cause had a great
ordered the healthy men to evacuate the wounded while ally: Maj. Gen. Patrick D. Sculley, the deputy surgeon gen-
he stayed behind and provided cover. The heroes who got a hero his medal eral, and head of the Dental Corps. Sculley made sure that
When his body was discovered a few days later, it was The official Army article on Dr. Salomon devotes several everything stayed on track as each approval in the long
clear his machine-gun fire had killed 98 enemy soldiers. thousand words to the long, difficult process that finally chain of command was secured.
Salomons body had 24 wounds on it. ended with Ben Salomon getting his Medal of Honor in Finally, on May 1, 2002, President George W. Bush pre-
Trudi Birger (ne Simon) was born in 1924 in Frankfort, 2002. sented Salomons medal to Dr. West, who represented
Dr. Scott Dubowsky of Tenafly at work in the Trudi Trudi Birger with Jerusalems iconic mayor,
Birger Clinic in Jerusalem. Teddy Kollek, who died in 2007. Dr. Scott Dubowsky, right, with his sons and grandchild.
USCs dental school. Bens parents were long dead, and dentists usually spend a month in the army each year, so animation hes the creator and producer and he has
he had no close relative to accept the medal on his behalf. asking them to volunteer in their off-time is difficult. She five funny videos on the popular Funny or Die site.
decided that foreign volunteer dentists might be the solu- On September 11, 2001, Dr. Dubowsky saw the North
Trudi Birger and her clinic tion to that problem. She recruited six volunteer dentists Tower of the World Trade Center collapse from Bayonne,
Trudi Simon and her mother lived in a displaced per- from France, set up a nonprofit company in Israel, and where he works. Later, he heard that some of the bod-
sons camp in Germany until Trudi discovered that her got an Israeli shipping line to bring in tons of equipment ies might be transferred to a morgue in Bayonne. Having
brother was alive and living in Frankfort, and they joined donated by a French company. some experience in identifying bodies through teeth and
him there. In Frankfort, she met and eventually married In 1980, what is now called the DVI Trudi Birger Clinic dental records, he called someone he knew in the New
Zev Birger (1927-2011), a strong Zionist who struggled to opened in Jerusalem. Thousands of children have been York medical examiners office and asked if the office
maintain Hebrew culture in the Kovno ghetto. After the treated there in the last 37 years. The clinic treats all chil- needed help. He was told that yes, they did, but at the
ghetto was emptied, Birger was sent to a labor camp and dren, regardless of ethnicity or religion. It emphasizes New York morgue. Could he volunteer there?
then to Dachau. He was liberated by American troops, bringing oral hygiene education to the the entire fam- From then until end of May 2002, Dr. Dubowsky
and became a translator for them, and they urged him to ily, so that problems are stopped before they start or get worked, without pay, examining the dental remains and
immigrate to America. much worse. About half the volunteers are from America; records of 9/11 victims. During that time, he maintained
But Zev wanted to build a Jewish state. After much the others are from around the world. (The international his own practice. At first, he worked from eight to 16 hours
thought, Trudi and her mother made the difficult deci- nature of the clinics volunteers is reflected in the fact that a week on 9/11 victims, although later he slowed down a
sion to not go to America, as Trudis brother and his wife the DVI website is in 14 languages.) little bit.
had done. Instead, they would go with Zev to Eretz Israel. It is the largest free dental clinic in Israel, and recently Dr. Dubowsky had met Trudi Birgir before 9/11, and
Trudi and Zev were married in 1946, and in November it began providing free dentures to Holocaust survivors he knew about DVI. But it took some time, he said, to
1947 they made aliyah. After serving in the army in the and the elderly. recover from 9/11, and he had three relatively young
War of Independence, Zev went into government service, After Trudi Birger died in 2002, age 75, the clinic was sons to look after. But by 2007, his sons were grown. Dr.
rising to be a deputy minister overseeing various eco- named after her. Dubowsky wanted to do something else outside him-
nomic matters in 1967. After retiring in 1977, he and Trudi self as he had in the aftermath of 9/11. He chose to
went to Paris, where he headed up the local office of ICM, Enter Dr. Dubowsky volunteer at DVI.
a worldwide arts management company. Dr. Scott Dubowsky, 67, is the linchpin that ties all these Volunteer dentists do pay for their own transportation,
Trudi became a microbiologist in Israel. Her thoughts stories together. Hes a second-generation dentist with a but they are provided a free if spare apartment in a nice
frequently turned to helping others and easing their suf- practice in Bayonne and the proud father of three really area of Jerusalem, he said. They typically spend a week at
fering. She long had been aware that poor children in cool sons: Eric, 41, is a former rock band musician who the clinic, working Sundays through Thursdays.
Israel had a pressing need for dental services. The govern- is now a mixer, songwriter, and producer, and he won a During his stays in Israel, Dr. Dubowsky has visited the
ment does pay for a sort-of HMO to treat children under Grammy for mixing the best dance music album (Flume). Holocaust shrine Yad Vashem several times. When I said
13, but the co-pay, while small, often is too much for a Jonathan, 39, has his own band ( Jonny Lives) and once I wasnt sure if I could stand to go a second time, he said,
poor family with many children. (Many ultra-Orthodox played with his band on the old Conan OBrien Show. He When I go to Yad Vashem, its not so much to remem-
and Palestinian families tend to have large families.) now is working with people at NYU on IT projects that ber the victims of the Holocaust, its to make sure that I
When she lived in Paris, she determined to set up a free deal with sustainability and the environment. Adam, 33, dont forget.
clinic in Jerusalem, staffed by volunteer dentists. Israeli is a comic wit who has sold one animated project to Fox SEE SALOMON PAGE 39
A reunion of the medical professionals who worked on identifying victims of the 9/11 attacks.
W
he would put together a group of had in common more than what divided
hat is a boundary? scholars. The rabbis, Rabbi Mata- them, he said. Of course, that effort to
When is it protec- lon continued, are from across build bridges did not extend to those Jews
tive and when is it the country, younger and older, who had married outside the community.
constrictive? When men and women. And Donniel put Those bridges were an attempt not to
should it have windows and when together a group of scholars. The give up, not to read out, Rabbi Matalon
should those window sashes be scholars who included Dr. Yehuda said. Even though those peoples behav-
thrown up? When should it raise the Kurtzer and other Hartman scholars ior was not acceptable or accepted. So it
portcullis to keep out invaders, when and Dr. Christine Hayes from Yale established that there is a tradition.
should boiling oil be poured from its got together for about four or five Jewish life became far more constrained,
slits, and when should that bridge months on a weekly basis to discuss narrow, and dangerous during the Middle
be let down? What passports should the Jewish lenses through which to Ages and even through the more gener-
visitors need? What documentation look at this theological, historical, ally expansive times that followed. Still,
should residents need? When should sociological, textual. Then we had a it never has been as stark or as binary as
it be remodeled? two-day retreat where the rabbis and we have been led to believe, Rabbi Mata-
There have been boundaries pro- scholars studied together, and the lon said. It was those things that rose to
tecting the Jewish people from outsid- Hartman scholars presented. That the surface in terms of shaping our under-
ers from the beginning, from before was in February 2016, he added. standing of our present situation. The
we were Jews, back to when we still Out of this emerged the curricu- present is not identical to anything that
were Israelites. Much of that protec- lum for BJ, Rabbi Matalon continued. happened in the past, but it gave us a way
tion was aimed at the most intimate From last years High Holy Days to think about the present.
of all kinds of protection or invasion until last month, the shul had a series The present is quite unprecedented,
intermarriage and the children that of talks from scholars, parlor meet- but we can use Jewish texts and a Jewish
might result from that union. Rabbi Roly Matalon ings, and other meetings and discus- lens to figure out solutions for the chal-
Right now, the Conservative sions about intermarriage. lenges we face today.
movement, with its carefully drawn bal- beginning in 2018, Bnai Jeshuruns rabbis I think that maybe the most salient As Rabbi Matalon began to talk about his
ance between tradition and modernity, will perform intermarriages, under certain takeaways from the scholars talks is that plans, he said that there are some points
between hewing to its interpretation of specific conditions, as a still-unwritten civil Jewish identity historically has lived within that must be made as a preface. First, he
halacha and its understanding of the truths ceremony with Jewish elements, as part of a spectrum, Rabbi Matalon said. It was said, the situation we deal with today is
and realities of the outside world, is con- a long-term project to strengthen the Jew- not always binary, in or out, Jew or non- bediavad ex post facto. We are trying
fronting the huge question of what to do ish homes and home lives of all the syna- Jew. There were citizens, there were for- to address something that already has hap-
about the increasing number of Jews who gogues members. He made that decision pened, a posteriori.
want to marry non-Jews but still retain as part of a yearlong project with the com- We are not out to promote marriages
their connection to the Jewish community. munity, and as an outgrowth of a partner- between Jews and non-Jews. We are not
Can its rabbis possibly perform inter-
marriages? What will happen if they do?
ship with Rabbi Donniel Hartman of Isra-
els David Hartman Center and a group of
Couples do not saying to Jews, go out and marry any-
one you want! We are addressing a situ-
What will happen if they dont? And is Conservative rabbis and Jewish scholars. change their ation that already exists, and is increas-
the decision necessarily binary and stark?
What is the best path forward?
(Donniel Hartman taught at the Kaplen
JCC on the Palisades in Tenafly for many
minds about who ing in number. Couples do not change
their minds about who to marry when we
Rabbi J. Rolando Matalon of Congrega- years and has many close relationships in to marry when express our disapproval. They are going
tion Bnai Jeshurun on Manhattans Upper
West Side has brought the question forward
this community.)
Rabbi Matalon began to think about
we express our ahead despite our disapproval.
Number two, we have to realize that
in a way that has affected the discussion intermarriage when the congregation disapproval. these people who are marrying non-Jews
around the country, and certainly in this
area, right across the Hudson.
undertook its strategic plan in 2014. One
of the people I interviewed for it was Don-
They are going do not intend to leave the Jewish commu-
nity. At other times, marrying a non-Jew
To begin, it is necessary to situate niel Hartman, he said. I wanted his per- ahead despite was a passport out of the Jewish commu-
Rabbi Matalon and his shul in the Con-
servative movement. Although the syn-
spective on some of the big issues he was
seeing from where he sits. Thats in Jerusa-
our disapproval. nity. That is no longer the case.
Number three, a Jewish person who is
agogue left the United Synagogue of lem, where he lives, but also in the United marrying a non-Jew is not doing it as an
Conservative Judaism, the movements States, where he was born, and where he eigners, there were resident aliens the indication of a weakness of Jewish identity.
synagogue association, decades ago, it still spends a great deal of time. Rabbi Hart- ger toshav and within that spectrum We live in an open society, and people look
still remains a Conservative institution man is an Orthodox rabbi, which adds yet people had different rights and responsi- for people just like themselves. And since
it uses the movements siddur and chu- another perspective to the mix. bilities but lived within the Jewish commu- Jewish values are the larger communitys
mash, takes guidance from the move- Intermarriage came up as a major nity. That was early on, through the rab- values, since the larger community has to
ments Joint Committee on Jewish Laws issue, and he said to me that if the Con- binic and even post-rabbinic period. And a large extent accepted Jewish values jus-
and Standards, and Rabbi Matalon is a servative movement doesnt deal with it in then things became more complicated tice, compassion, decency, responsibility,
member of the movements Rabbinical a serious way, it is going to be in trouble, and more binary. But throughout Jew- hard work so people say, Look, we share
Assembly. Although the movements to Rabbi Matalon said. It will be further and ish history, he said, there frequently was values. We dont share Shabbat or chaggim
the Conservatives left and right already further diminished. So I asked him if he an effort to keep apostates or heretics, or or a Jewish identity, but we share values.
have or someday will have to deal with would work with me in looking into this Karaites, or people who otherwise were One thing that used to keep Jews safe
the question of Jews marrying non-Jews, issue. Would he partner with us? And he somehow deviant, somehow outside from marrying non-Jews is that the non-
right now it is the centrist movements said he would be happy to. of the norm, connected to the commu- Jewish world rejected Jews. Who would
turn in this unwelcome spotlight. So we agreed that the two of us would nity. There was an attempt by Rambam want to marry an outcast? A big-nosed,
Rabbi Matalon has decided that put together a group. I would get about and other authorities to create bridges, See boundaries page 12
a beneficiary agency of
THANK YOU!
Your generosity will make it possible for JFCS to provide
over 79,000 meals on wheels this year, and to continue to
support the over 2,900 people fed through our food pantry.
Bronze Diamond Chemical Co., Inc. Ellkay Multipet International Oritani Bank
Paterson Papers PKF OConnor Davies Risk Strategies
Shoprite of Englewood Tapestrie Jewish Link Jewish Standard
Small Business Abeles & Heyman Amster & Rosensweig PC Kudo Society Caf
LoFaro & Reiser LLP River Palm Terrace Sal Lauretta for Men
Shapiro Croland SUEZ Summit Oaks Hospital Whole Foods Market
Friends Aerial Flyte Club Butterflake Bake Shop Julios Fruit Boutique
Maadan Massage/Spa Inc.
Jewish Family and Childrens Services of Bergen and North Hudson 1485 Teaneck Rd, Teaneck, NJ 07666 201.837.9090 jfcsnnj.org
boundaries are not Jewish. he will ask the non-Jewish partner if he question of Jewish status and identity, and
FrOM page 10 In order to do so, we will put a pro- or she is interested. On the other, we changing it is not something we could or
tribal, smelly, cheap creep? Thats no lon- gram in place that asks all couples to dis- want people to do it as a real thing, not would do independently.
ger the stereotype of Jews. To put it more cuss all these issues. What does it mean to for administrative reasons. Not to make That is a question of klal Israel.
sedately, as Rabbi Matalon did, The bar- have a Jewish home? To be Jewish? We will other people happy. This is a remarkably important issue,
riers are going down in both directions. work with mixed couples Conversion, he contin- Rabbi Matalon concluded. I dont know
So he ends up seeing Jews who want to and Jewish couples on a ued, is such a transformative if this solution would work for everyone,
marry non-Jews but also want their rabbi document of tenaim of spiritual experience that it has but it is our solution. Not trying to figure it
to perform the ceremony. He never used conditions for the mar- to be taken on with thought out is not an option.
to hear such requests, he said; until not riage which include the and meaning. It is a deep spir- This is the issue of our time. It is an
very many years ago, his assistants would commitments to a Jewish itual shift and has to be taken issue not of pikuach nefesh but of pikuach
turn them away before they reached him home, and if necessary, to with a deep desire to change. neshama not of saving a life, but of sav-
and his rabbinic colleagues at BJ. convert the children. It might not happen before ing a soul. A Jewish soul. This is not a
If we push them away, if they come to And at BJ we are going the marriage, but maybe five, physical life but a spiritual life.
seek our blessing and we push them away, to create a hopefully very 10, 20 years down the line. It Some people are afraid of moving the
they basically wander out, he said. They interesting core project can take time for the non-Jew- boundaries, of opening a door in their
carry a great deal of shame already, thats called the Jewish Home ish person to be able to come boundaries. We are not removing bound-
built into the situation, and we augment it, Project, with resources, Rabbi Adina Lewittes to that place. Sometimes aries. We are opening a door.
and theyre out. As rabbis, we have a sense guidance, and classes for they have parents or grandpar- Rabbi Adina Lewittes of Closter is the
of responsibility to them and to future gen- all members of BJ. We are going to invite ents they dont want to hurt; sometimes founder of Shaar Communities, a new look
erations to bring these people in, to give everyone to strengthen the Jewish content they just dont feel it. But we hope that at Jewish life in community. Like Rabbi
them the tools they need to build Jewish and meaning of their homes. after a number of years of living within the Matalon, she was ordained at the Jew-
homes and raise Jewish children, for their We often see Jewish/Jewish couples Jewish community, they will come to see ish Theological Seminary, but she left the
sake and for the sake of the Jewish com- who have very little idea of how to create the depth and beauty of the Jewish com- Rabbinical Assembly when she decided to
munity and the Jewish future. a Jewish home. Often their commitment munity, and say that they want to be fully perform some intermarriages a few years
So he and his colleagues will come up to the Jewish community is not strong or part of it. ago. (The RA does not permit its members
with an alternative ceremony, that will meaningful. BJ will not sanction marriages between to perform intermarriages, and Rabbi Mat-
not be kiddushin, that will unite these What about conversion? It will now Jews and people who hold other faiths, alon is fairly sure that he too will have to
couples as long as they commit themselves be held to a much higher and more vis- and of course that means they will never leave it.)
to having a Jewish home and if they have ible level, Rabbi Matalon said. We will co-officiate with clery members of other Rabbi Lewittes was part of the group
children to raising Jewish children, and to give much more prominence to the con- faiths. And we uphold maternality, that Rabbi Matalon convened. This is
converting the children if their mothers version program at BJ. On the one hand, Rabbi Matalon said. That is because it is a an urgent issue because it is a reality
dininG
Est. since 1991
WIFI
of contemporary Jewish life, she said. tools of sanctification that are reserved Lab/Shuls who was ordained by the Jew- David-Seth Kirshner of Temple Emanu-El
Drawing the lines where we have drawn for when two Jews are marrying. But a ish Theological Seminary just the year in Closter said. I respect Roly immensely,
them is not understanding the profound rabbi can offer a blessing to people who before, wrote a widely read piece discuss- but I dont think this decision is in the best
impact that we could have by somehow have found love, and offer teachings, and ing their doubts about just saying no to interests of Judaism. Saying no at times
being present to couples on this journey. extend a very passionate welcome, and intermarriage. She said that under certain defines our boundaries, and it is in our
And as she pointed out, an expectation that they will circumstances shed perform best interest to say no
saying no has not yielded live their lives within the Jew- them, and he said that until sometimes.
us the results that we ish community. he decided what he would In this case, it is not
imagined that they would There might not be a hala- do about intermarriage, he just saying no, but say-
have yielded us. chic paradigm, but it might would perform no weddings ing no with empathy,
GRAND OPEN
It worked very com- not need a halachic paradigm at all. A few weeks ago, he with understanding, and
fortably when society was because it is not a halachic made public his decision to with compassion. We let
organized around very moment. perform intermarriages. people know that this will
segmented communities, It is even less wise to turn The stakes here are really be their journey, and this
she said. It doesnt work away couples who ask a rabbi high, Rabbi Lewittes con- is just one stop on their
so well anymore. to officiate at their wedding cluded. No one should dis- journey. We are here for
The work we are doing because if you read the pages miss or naively assume that that journey.
now is focusing on a deep Rabbi David-Seth of the New York Times wed- those who are studying and Rabbi Dr. David J. Fine It is important to note
mining of the tradition to Kirshner ding section, youll notice that struggling to come up with a that we are the victims of
understand if there are fewer and fewer of wedding re-framework of this reality are in any way our own success, Rabbi Kirshner contin-
any halachic paradigms into which negoti- officiants are clery, she said. ignorant or dismissive of those stakes. I ued. We no longer live in the shtetl. No
ating this issue may make sense, she con- Rabbi Lewittes will work at BJ this year; cannot stress enough how the group of matter who had won the election, they
tinued. What inspiration, if any, may we as a part-time rabbi, she will teach and do rabbis with whom we are working are would have had a Jewish son-in-law. We
find in our own tradition to frame these pastoral work. Also, I hope it will afford people who are approaching it with a great do not want to go back to the shtetl. This is
efforts in a way that is continuous? To not me the opportunity to help them think sense of humility and of understanding of new for us, and we have to figure out how
rupture it in the way that most people through the model and evolve some pro- the great responsibility we carry with us. to deal with it.
anticipate that it will be ruptured? grams about how to implement it in ways Local Conservative rabbis understand Nonetheless, inherently, when you
Like Rabbi Matalon, Rabbi Lewittes that will allow them to embrace these cou- the problems they too face them but say no to one thing, you are saying yes to
said that she has not and will not per- ples and these families, she said. they do not embrace the solution Rabbis something else, he concluded. When
form a traditional Jewish wedding for Last November, Rabbi Lewittes and her Matalon and Lewittes are exploring. you say no to intermarriage, you are say-
an interfaith couple. It will be a civil cer- colleague Rabbi Amichai Lau-Lavie, the The difference in this situation is ing yes to a commitment to our people and
emony that cannot use the traditional influential founder of Storahtelling and between a butcher and a surgeon, Rabbi see boundaries page 39
dininG
RISTORANTE
I
h
n Orthodox synagogues throughout Teaneck and p
Bergenfield, July 1 will be observed as TVAC/BVAC w
Shabbos, raising awareness of the work of a selfless h
group who are there every day of the week to help m
those in need of medical assistance.
The synagogues will present information about the
lifesaving services provided by the Teaneck Volunteer
Ambulance Corps TVAC and the Bergenfield Volun-
teer Ambulance Corps BVAC.
These two squads assist with medical emergencies 24/7, i
with a medically trained and equipped first responder
arriving on scene in under two minutes. How do they do a
this? The highly trained emergency medical technicians
are an extraordinary force of volunteers from the com- a
munity friends and neighbors who give their time, skills, a
and knowledge to help people in need. When medical T
emergencies strike, quick response time is of the essence A
and may mean the difference between life and death, so a a
speedy response from the EMTs is paramount for saving i
lives and ensuring the best outcome possible. i
The goal of this weekend is to raise awareness and The leaders of the two ambulance corps, from left, include Rabbi Daniel Senter, Dr. Eliyahu Cooper, and Izzy s
support of our work, both in recruiting volunteers, fund- Infield, respectively president, medical director, and captain of the TVAC; and Mordechai Farkas and Ryan
raising, and general community support, the two corps Shell, respectively lieutenant and captain of the BVAC.
medical director, Dr. Eliyahu Cooper, said. The TVAC and
BVAC respond to more than 7,000 calls every year, and No matter who you are, everybody eventually winds nurses, and physician assistants, working in many medical
their average response time is significantly faster than the up on a stretcher, Mr. Shell continued. In the IT world, fields. Its a good springboard for people who are inter-
nationally recommended average response time. whats my contribution to society? Its not that fulfilling. ested in medical careers, he said.
The organizations are well-equipped TVAC has five BVAC is fulfilling. I definitely would not be a complete per- Dr. Cooper noted that while we have a lot of people
ambulances and BVAC has four so when there are simul- son without it. who have gone on to advanced medical careers, we also
taneous or overlapping calls or major emergencies, the Sam Levi, 71, has been serving TVAC for 23 years. He is have people who are in other professions. Members work
groups have the ability to cover multiple sites. They also its acting treasurer, managing its annual budget of about in business and law; they are teachers, contractors, and
have large numbers of highly trained volunteers. Accord- $300,000. He also rides in the ambulance on Tuesday bus drivers, to name a few. Many of my friends are people
ing to Ryan Shell, captain of BVAC, his squad has 55 mem- nights from 7 to 11 p.m. Its a voice telling you that this is who I met at TVAC, Dr. Cooper said. Many people form
bers, including 34 men and 21 women. TVAC has about lifelong friendships and bonds. Dr. Cooper met his wife
150 volunteers about 90 of them are on active duty each this writers daughter Dr. Abigail Cooper at TVAC. Like
month. About 40 percent of those volunteers are women, all emergency services we are very much a community and
Dr. Cooper reported. Many volunteers are Orthodox Jews support each other through good and bad times, he said.
who work side by side with fellow EMTs from a cross-sec- In the IT world, whats We are local residents helping local people, Rabbi
tion of the community. The squads are diverse with regard my contribution to Senter said. An added benefit in having response from
to religion and race as well as gender. The two corps serve a local volunteer is that it is your neighbors who will be
everyone, of all backgrounds, in Teaneck and Bergenfield. society? Its not that responding in an emergency. If you are relying on hospi-
In addition to their own extensive capabilities, TVAC fulfilling. BVAC is tal-based ambulance, they would probably be able to get
and BVAC work together cooperatively in what they call an ambulance in a reasonable amount of time, but when
a mutual-aid agreement, so that if either town has more fulfilling. I definitely emergency services are overtaxed in an emergency like
emergency calls than its group can handle at one time, the would not be a complete [Superstorm] Sandy or snowstorms, we have lots and lots
other towns ambulance corps will respond. of volunteers so we can respond quickly even in a major
Its a place where people from all different segments person without it. emergency. We are strongest when the community most
of the community get together for a common goal, Dr. needs us.
Cooper, a 15 year TVAC veteran and former TVAC pres- the thing you should be doing, he said. It has to come Volunteers commit a minimum of four hours per
ident, said. Dr. Cooper, an anesthesiologist and a mar- from inside the person. You get a lot of inner satisfaction week, he added. Many ride more than that. We try to
ried father of four, lives in Bergenfield. He grew up in from doing something thats a service to people. staff the building 24/7. Often there are four, five, or six
Teaneck and joined TVAC when he was a teen. It show- I get a lot of personal satisfaction from having done it. people in the building overnight. Rabbi Senter mentally
cases how all the different elements of the community Rabbi Daniel Senter, the president of TVAC, lives and calculated how many volunteer hours are completed
work together, he said. works in Teaneck. As chief operations officer of the Kof K each year. We take thousands of calls per year, and two
Mr. Shell, who joined BVAC when he moved to Bergen- kosher certification agency, his time is at a premium. But to five people go out on each call, he said. The aver-
field 10 years ago, has been an EMT since he was 16. Shell his volunteer work is a passion and a top priority for him. age call takes one hour. Summing it up, he concluded,
lives in Bergenfield with his wife and three children and Rabbi Senter joined TVAC about 12 years ago. I always We donate in excess of 10,000 ambulance hours free to
works in information technology. I do a few hundred wanted to be an EMT, he said. My daughter Dina was our community.
calls per year, he said. He reflected on the challenging anxious to start riding, and I said Ill do it with her. Shes a Rabbi Senter also reported that TVAC is a model for other
situations he has encountered in his service. Its hard, nurse practitioner now. ambulance corps. Were visited by neighboring ambu-
especially when you start young, when you start at 16, One of the successes of TVAC is that weve had many, lance corps so they can figure out how we do it, he said.
he continued. You see everything. You see people at the many members who joined as younger kids interested in We have more than 100 active members, he con-
most difficult and most vulnerable times in their lives. I medical fields, Rabbi Senter added. And many members tinued. The demographics are quite diverse. One
saw a teacher of mine as a patient. and former members have gone on to become doctors, aspect of diversity of both TVAC and BVAC lies in the
high percentage of women on the squads, with females TVAC and BVAC volunteers is the importance of spouses includes equipment, building and facilities, ambulances,
comprising about 40 percent of their members. We and families in encouraging and enabling their work. supplies, uniforms, and insurance. There are no person-
have women on the corps who have been members for My wife is very supportive, Mr. Shell said. People are nel costs volunteers contribute all the work.
many years, who are married with children, and younger very quick to thank the EMT for giving of their time, but I TVAC and BVAC are private not-for-profit organizations.
women just starting out. Women bring a lot to the table, believe our spouses sacrifice more than we do. We go out Both ambulance corps are supported mainly by dona-
Rabbi Senter said. There are times when a patient may and get the recognition. If my spouse was not supportive tions from people and businesses in the community, with
be more comfortable being treated by a woman, and it would be impossible. a limited annual donation from the local government. All
having a high proportion of female EMTs makes that My kids like what I do, he added. They understand services are provided free of charge. All donations are
possible. Women are serving on all crews daytime, that sometimes daddy has to run, but they understand it. tax deductible.
weekend, overnight, he continued. Women serve and Mr. Levi said that his wife, Leah, who teaches first grade The public should know that our volunteers are just
have served in every role, from president to captain, and at the Moriah School, always has been supportive of his like them, Mr. Shell said. We dont get paid. We are
many are crew chiefs. TVAC work. You have to have a spouse willing for you extremely appreciative of community support.
There is also linguistic diversity. We have Spanish- to be out of the house going on calls, he said. They are If you dont have the time or wherewithal to take on
speaking members, Rabbi Senter said. Just today there the unsung heroes. They let the volunteers do their thing. the commitment [to be an EMT], the best way to help is
was a call with a stroke victim, and its very important to Spousal support would be a very, very important factor in to donate your funds to the extent that you can, Mr. Levi
find out when symptoms started with regard to proper being able to volunteer. added. They are definitely worthwhile organizations that
treatment. In that case, a crew member who speaks Span- Rabbi Senter also noted that spouses and family members provide services to the towns that they serve.
ish helped to obtain the necessary information quickly. make a tremendous sacrifice. My wife knows that I can dis- For more information or to donate to TVAC, go to www.
Being that were diverse, were often presented with the appear, he said. And during disasters were not home. We teaneckambulance.org or email info@teaneckambulance.
ability to better serve people, Rabbi Senter said. all leave the house. We need to acknowledge all these men org. For more information or to donate to BVAC go to
The work at TVAC goes beyond ambulance calls, he and women who have wonderful spouses who make sac- www.bergenfieldambulance.org or email bvacinfo@ber-
added. He rides on the ambulance about six hours a week rifices. The volunteers give up time with their spouse and genfieldambulance.org.
and also contributes more time for administrative tasks. family members so they can serve the community.
There are some volunteers who help out with fundraising. People are surprised that we are funded solely by Dr. Miryam Z. Wahrman of Teaneck is the Jewish
And members are called upon to do routine tasks, such donations and staffed by volunteers, he continued. We Standards science correspondent. She is professor of
as working on vehicle maintenance, cleaning the build- are supported by the community. In the community, peo- biology at William Paterson University of New Jersey. Her
ing, ordering materials, equipment, and supplies, stock- ple never get a bill. Weve always been reluctant to bill for recent book, The Hand Book: Surviving in a Germ-Filled
ing ambulances, and washing them. All this is done and our services, because if we were to bill there may be peo- World, has tips on how to reduce the risk of infection in
staffed by volunteers, he said. ple who would hesitate to call us during an emergency. health care settings, the workplace, at home, school, camp,
One theme that consistently arises when talking to The operating budget of about $300,000 for each squad summer activities, and while traveling.
Amerike
THE G LDEN LAND
For tickets visit NYTF.org or call 866-811-4111
JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 30, 2017 15
Briefly Local
PHOTOS COURTESY OU
NCJW volunteers at the dedication of the new National Council of
Jewish Women Bergen County Section/Renee Guller Infant/Toddler Representative Josh Gottheimer (D-5th Dist.), third from left, with the New Jersey
Center at the Bergen Family Center in Englewood. Delegation of the OU Advocacy Leadership Mission after a private meeting.
Dr. Peter Cardiello, Youth Consultation Service pediatrician, meets with OU Advocacy Mission delegation at briefing with Secretary of
NCJW BS volunteers at the opening of the renovated infirmary. Education Betsy DeVos in the White Houses Indian Treaty Room.
Blood drive
will honor
Adam Gussen
Community Blood Services is hold-
ing a blood drive for former Teaneck
Deputy Mayor Adam Gussen, who
required blood transfusions after
recent surgery. The drive will be at
Teaneck Volunteer Ambulance Corps,
PHOTOS COURTESY OU
RCBC
Let Them In
The Folksbiene presents Amerike, Although there were Jews in the 13 colonies that
became the first United States, none were represented
Yiddish music about the immigrant among the entirely white male Christian founders. We
extrapolate the promises those men made to themselves
experience, starting on the Fourth of July to cover all of us as well.
Overwhelmingly, most of us are immigrants or the
I
descendants of immigrants. It is no accident that the Stat-
Joanne Palmer we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our For- ute of Liberty, one of the great symbols of the freedom
tunes, and our Sacred Honor, they said, the exuberance that this country offers, holds her torch up to immigrants.
ts extraordinary, when you think about it, this of their capitalization underscoring the depth of their This country grew from immigrants, was built by immi-
country of ours. resolve to create a new kind of state in the New World. grants, welcomes immigrants, enriches and is enriched
Thats always a loaded statement to make these It was, of course, not an untarnished state the found- by immigrants.
days; tempers are so high, political divisions are ers created human beings were enslaved but it was Like this country itself, though, immigration was not
so deep, mistrust is so pervasive. the start of a brave new experiment. It remains very far all glorious. It was hard, painful, dark, impoverishing, at
But still. from perfect, but on the Fourth of July we still explode times fatal. It could divide families, maim hope, kill love.
We are celebrating the Fourth of July this week, the fireworks of hope and joy. The only way truly to acknowledge the great gifts immi-
time when the founders of this country, along with the Some of those fireworks soar and crest and rain colored grants have given us is to honor their sacrifices and their
less powerful people they represented, risked everything fire on the Statue of Liberty. despair as well as their joy and success.
1 month
studios & over 90 speCialty Classes inCluding
CyCling, barre, pilates, yoga, Zumba & more!
free!
aquatiCs Center with sprinKler play parK
Kaplen JCC on the Palisades taub Campus | 411 east Clinton avenue, tenafly, nj 07670 | jccotp.org
20 Jewish standard JUne 30, 2017
Superstorm Sandy knocked out most of
lower Manhattan, including Baruch Col-
lege, where it was playing. And then
when we came here to the museum, to
our new home, last year, we were wres-
tling between Amerike and The Golden
Bride as the first piece to present here.
The Golden Bride won. Its represen-
tative of Second Avenue material, and
we opted for that, to give people a taste
of actual Yiddish theater, Mr. Mlotek
said. The musical had a brief but critically
acclaimed run at the museum.
Now, though, we decided that because
immigration has become such an impor-
tant issue today, and because we are con-
stantly inspired by our location it doesnt
escape us that the Statue of Liberty is right
outside our windows we felt that it was
time to bring the show back.
Theyve made a change, though. Theyve
stripped the English they added. There is This crumbling handwritten page has music and transliteration for Lost Arayn, which means let them in. Its a heart-
English throughout, Mr. Mlotek said. Its wrenching plea to immigration officials.
the story of immigration, so as the immi-
grants assimilated their Yiddish became members will know whats going on. We auditioned more than 300 people from Berlin.
peppered with English. But now much of Now, he said, a challenge they face is in New York, and we came up with a ter- Daniel Kahn is the young Detroit native
the material is back to the original authen- how to pick a cast that can sing Yiddish rific ensemble of 12 people, he said. Some who has lived in Berlin for the last decade;
tic Yiddish sources that we picked. Also, honestly, authentically, and dramatically have experience in Yiddish, and some he broke into Americas consciousness last
the production includes supertitles so even and also look good and of course also learned it. And then there is one major fall, soon after the singer/songwriter/poet
the most Yiddish-challenged of audience sound good. standout. Daniel Kahn, who we brought Leonard Cohen died, by translating Mr.
Cohens brilliant, popular, and hauntingly have been. from immigrants. We are celebrating it in a recording by Aaron Lebedev. My
and undeniably Jewish song Halleluyah That Daniel Kahn. that tie. mother transcribed it. We used the first
into Yiddish, and singing it on YouTube right We are not making a political point with To that end, the Folksbiene also is verse but not the second one. It was in
into the camera, looking right at the viewer this show, Mr. Mlotek said. This is a nation hosting the first immigration arts sum- one of Ms. Mloteks books about Yiddish
as he sang in a language that the song hadnt of immigrants. The Yiddish theater in Amer- mit, set for Monday and Tuesday, July 17 music; for the purposes of her argu-
been written in but seemed as if it should ica became American theater, and it came and 18. The summit, which will include ment, one verse was enough.
a keynote address by John Leguizamo, My mother passed away three years
will bring together the Pan Asian Rep- ago, and I found this in her papers, Mr.
ertory, the Repertorio Espaol, the Mlotek said. She never published this
Irish Repertory Theatre, the Kairo Italy verse, and it is the killer verse.
Theater, the Irish Arts Center, and the Its the story of a young family:
Turkish American Repertory Theatre, as
well as Israels Office of Cultural Affairs A young father with bent shoulders is
in the USA, the Romanian Cultural Insti- on Ellis Island.
tute, and the Cumbe Center for African He raised two small children by himself.
and diaspora Dance. The point is to talk They lost their mother, and came here
about shared experiences, brainstorm with great difficulty.
shared ideas for paths forward, and The gates are locked before them.
share performances and audiences with Their father is kept away from them.
each other. (See box for more details.) Hearts are broken here at the door.
To go back to the American Jew- It ends, in a universal plea that is as
ish experience, there are many light- relevant today as it was then
hearted lyrics in the show. Its not at all then to Jews, today to others:
a depressing experience it is in fact Dont have hearts of stone.
the opposite, and Vatch Your Step Open the gates to the Golden Land.
is in it but there still are moments of You see people falling, reach out
deep sadness. It is hard to leave behind your hand.
all that you know, and it is hard to learn Let them in, let them in.
to adapt to something new. And it is also Dont break any more hearts.
hard, very hard, more than hard, it is The whole world will bless you for it.
Here and below, the cast rehearses for the Folksbienes new production of Amerike. soul-rending, to come to a new country, Open the gates and let them in.
stand hopefully at its gates, and then be
turned away. Zalmen Mlotek hopes that everyone will
Lost Arayn Let Them In is a come to see the story of Amerike, down
song written at the turn of the century, in southern Manhattan, facing the Statue
TEANECK
ITS
ITS
ITSGOING
GOING
GOINGTO
TOFARMERS
TOBE
BE
BEANOTHER
ANOTHER MARKET
ANOTHERGREAT
GREAT
GREATSEASON
SEASON
SEASONAT
AT
AT Mr. Mlotek said; of course, that turn is of Liberty and the torch that lit the way
not the most recent one but from the for so many of our families, and to keep
19th to the 20th centuries. We found Yiddish theater alive as they do so.
Farm
Farm
FarmFresh
Fresh
FreshFruits
Fruits
Fruits&&&Vegetables
Vegetables
VegetablesPlants
Plants
PlantsFlowers
Flowers
Flowers&&&
Herbs
Herbs
HerbsPickles
Pickles
PicklesOlives
Olives
OlivesFreshly
Freshly
FreshlyBaked
Baked
BakedGoodsGoods
Goods
International
International
Farm FreshInternational Gourmet
Gourmet
GourmetPrepared
Fruits & Vegetables Prepared
Prepared
FlowersFoods
Foods
Foods Honey
Pickles Honey
Honey
Olives
Who: The National Yiddish Theater Folksbiene, under the artistic direction of Zal-
Baked Goods
men Mlotek and Jams
Jams
Jams
the Honey
Cheese
Cheese
Cheese
leadership Jams
Meats
of CEO Meats Gourmet
MeatsPoultry
Poultry
Christopher Poultry Prepared
Seafood
Massimine,Seafood
Seafood
presents Foods
Empanadas
What: Amerike
Gourmet
Gourmet
TheCheese
GourmetNuts Nuts
Golden Nuts
Nuts&&&Dried
Land,
Dried Dried
DriedFruits
directedFruitsFruits
FruitsSenior
by BrynaSeniorSenior
SeniorCoupons
Wasserman Coupons
Coupons
Coupons
Wonderful
Wonderful
Wonderful
When: July 4 to August 6 Cedar
WonderfulCedar Cedar Lane
CedarLaneLaneMerchants
LaneMerchants
Merchants & More!
Merchants&&&more!more!
more!
Where: At the Museum of Jewish
Open
Open
Open Thursdays
Heritage,
Every
Every36 Battery
Every ThursdayPlace in Manhattan
Thursday
Thursday
June
June
June
For tickets and more information:4th
4th
4th
Go toto
to
toOctober
October
October
nytf.org 29th
29th
29th
or call (212) 213-2120
JuneFrom
through
From
FromNoon
Noon October
Noon6:00
6:00
6:00
PM
PM
PM
AND ALSO
Noon -6
Weather
Weather
Weather p.m.
Permitting
Permitting
Permitting
Who: The National Yiddish Theater Folksbiene,
Located
Located
Located
Located ininthe
inin
the Cedar
the
the Lane
Cedar
Cedar
Cedar municipal
Lane
Lane
Lane parking
Municipal
Municipal
Municipal lotlot
Parking
Parking
Parking at
lotGarrison
lot
at
atat Avenue/Beverly
Garrison
Garrison
Garrison Road.
Avenue/Beverly
Avenue/Beverly
Avenue/Beverly
Road.
Road.
Road.
What: Hosts the Immigration Arts Summit,
Plenty
Plenty
Plenty
Plenty ofwhich
of
of
free
of FREEfree
free includes
parking. a free concert outside in
parking.
parking.
parking.
Robert Wagner
Tune
Tune
Tune
inin
and
in
and
and
State Park on Tuesday at 7 p.m.
listen
listen
listen
Follow
Follow
Follow
usus
on
uson
Facebook
onFacebook
Facebook
and
and
and
toto
WFDUs
to
WFDUs
WFDUs
When: Monday,
89.1FM,
89.1FM,
89.1FM,July
for
for
for 17, to Tuesday, July 18 Like
Like
Like
us!
us!
us!
www.teaneckfarmersmarket.com
www.teaneckfarmersmarket.com
www.teaneckfarmersmarket.com
announcements
announcements
announcements
Where: At the Museum of Jewish Heritage, 36 Battery Place in Manhattan, and Robert
about
about
about
our
our
our
market!
market!
market!
Closter Furs
& Fashions
570 Piermont Rd.
Closter Commons
(near Annie Sez next to
Whole Foods Mall)
201-767-0448
www.closterfursandfashions.com
DANCE WITH US
ON TEANECKS CEDAR LANE
FREE DANCE LESSONS
This overview of the Kotel shows the plaza in the back, the mens section to the left, and the smaller
womens section to the right. WIKIMEDIA COMMONS
Jewry.
The Jewish United Fund/Jew- compromise to pass last year but since have railed
ish Federation of Metropolitan Chicagos president, against it, blocking its implementation. American Jewish
Steven Nasatir, also responded quickly and passion- leaders had hailed the agreement last year as a step for-
ately. The Federation in Chicago will not be hosting ward for Jewish pluralism and, at the time, Netanyahu
any member of Knesset that votes for this bill, he said. called it a fair and creative solution.
None. They will not be welcome in our community. Now the American Jewish leaders who pushed for the
Were past the time when were standing and agreement say they feel betrayed by Netanyahu. To
applauding and being nice because theyre members of see the agreement go into dormancy for 18 months, and
Knesset or because they hold this position or that posi- then in one day to have it frozen for political reasons,
tion, he said. People who dont have the understand- is feeling like you were sucker-punched and completely
ing of what this bill means to the Jewish people God devalued, Jerry Silverman, CEO of the Jewish Federa-
bless em, but theyre not welcome in our community, tions of North America, said. It is a direct insult.
period. Silverman said that he and other diaspora leaders are
Another part of the original agreement, expanding determined to fight back to have the Western Wall deal
the small egalitarian section at Robinsons Arch, which is implemented as originally agreed, and to challenge the
not visible from the main part of the wall, will continue governments new conversion bill.
during the suspension, Netanyahus office said. But any We are developing a strategy for a campaign to con-
new agreement would have to be negotiated by Israels vince the Knesset and all Israelis as to the reasons why
Cabinet and come to a new vote before moving forward. the Kotel [Western Wall] plan is so important, he said.
The suspension is a result of pressure from Netan- On Tuesday, the Jewish Agency for Israel took out
yahus charedi Orthodox partners, who allowed the large advertisements in major Israeli newspapers say-
ing that the govern-
ments decisions to halt
the creation of a plural-
istic prayer pavilion at
the Western Wall and to
restore the ultra-Ortho-
dox monopoly on Israeli
conversion endangers
the unity of the Jewish
people.
In a interview with
Israel Radio, Jewi sh
Agency chairman Natan
Sharansky, who was inti-
mately involved in mak-
ing the Western Wall deal,
said that the problem was
Israels refusal to recog-
nize Reform Judaism.
It all exploded because
A 500-yard platform opened south of the familiar Western Wall plaza in Au- the State of Israel did not
gust 2013 was intended as an interim solution to calls by diaspora groups and recognize the Reform,
feminists for a space where Jewish men and women could pray as they wish. he said. This is a very
I
n November 2015, in front of a roaring, care bill by leaning on politicians from his party; and Torah law
T
massive roomful of Jewish profession- he has a Republican majority in the Senate, and Judaism, on the other hand,
als and professional volunteers at the for complicated reasons needs only 50 votes to he Environmental Pro- insists we must keep protect the
general assembly of the Jewish Federa- get the legislation through. tection Agency probably world around us. The earth is not
tions of North America, Israels Prime Minister In the U.K., Theresa May, less than a year after needs to change its name ours, after all; it belongs to God.
Benjamin Netanyahu said that he was making taking office as the result of the Brexit vote and to the Environmental Sad to say, that humankind has
progress on a compromise between all streams a huge kerfuffle in the Conservative Party, mis- Lack of Protection Agency. such an ambivalence toward its
of Judaism, from the most liberal to the most calculated by calling for a unnecessary election. In Administrator Scott Pruitts relationship to the environment is
charedi, about access to the Kotel. It was of top She hoped to strengthen her party but instead first few months in office, the EPA indicative of the ambivalence we
importance to him, he said; he was working on weakened it, and herself. For us here, though, it has made a number have toward God and
it because he knew how much it mattered. He is so very interesting to watch how those elec- of moves designed to His role as Creator. As
promised that if diaspora Jews were patient, he tions work. Only her own constituency had the dismantle the depart- much as many people
would make it all work out. chance to vote for or against Ms. May directly. ments effectiveness. pay lip service to that,
He has said similar things often; I note that All the rest of it, like the machinations that It has proposed a they do not really
one in particular because I was there. He was brought her to the premiership in the first place, budget that will make buy the package. The
throwing red meat to that crowd, who ate it up was indirect. That, of course, is the way the par- it unworkable in many texts, however, do
and waited for more, but it was clear even then liamentary system works. vital areas. It has elim- not allow for such
that he was pandering. Similarly in Israel which takes Britains par- inated a number of ambivalence.
Now, Mr. Netanyahu has pulled back from liamentary system and adds another layer of sites on its web pages Thus, while it is
the agreement he was advocating then, which crazy by removing any mooring to any particu- that offered detailed Shammai t r u e t h at P s a l m s
would have given non-Orthodox Jews more lar place Mr. Netanyahus politicking leaves his climate data and sci- Engelmayer 115:16 says, The heav-
space close to (although not at) the Western actual constituency far behind. Eventually he entific information ens are the heavens of
Wall. The liberal movement had given up far has to answer to his voters, but well before that about greenhouse the Lord; but He has
more than it was going to get already in agree- he has to bargain with his own coalition part- gases and other dangers. given the earth to the children of
ment, which seemed unlikely to work anyway, ners, who keep him in power but could topple Last week, the EPA moved to men, that does not mean the chil-
given the opposition from both the Waqf and him should they chose. purge nearly all the members of its dren of men can do with it as they
the Antiquities Commission. American Jews have no power in Israel. There current Board of Scientific Coun- please. As Psalm 24:1 states: The
Still, this decision is upsetting, and should be is a strong argument that we have no right to any selors by mid-August. It also shut earth is the Lords and all that fills
upsetting to everyone who cares about the con- power there. We live here. There is also a strong down any meetings planned for the it; the world and those who dwell
tinuing relationship between diaspora Jews and argument that we give Israel enormous amounts summer by BOSC subcommittees. in it.
Israel. As we all know, younger Jews are disen- of money. Beyond that, if we are all one people This is not a total surprise. Aside The earth belongs to God. The
gaging from Israel at a shocking rate its hard and we always are told that we are, huge dif- from the fact that Pruitt, while job of humankind is to care for the
to support a country that the rest of the world, ferences in theology, life choices, and worldview serving as attorney general of Okla- earth on behalf of the Landlord. It
for motives ranging from perhaps disinterested notwithstanding we all must be recognized. homa, sued the EPA 14 times, the is that simple.
concern for the downtrodden to a quite clear We are all Jews; Israel has a powerful meaning man who appointed him appar- Say that, however, and you
loathing of Jews, hatred of Zionists because they for each one of us. ently believes that climate change is get many who will quote Genesis
are Jews, and a willingness to demonize both Liberal Jews are not asking for equality. a hoax. Since 2011, President Don- 1:28, And God blessed them, and
Israel and Jews, has turned into a pariah state. Theyve given up on that long ago. They are not ald Trump has tweeted as much God said to them, Be fruitful, and
Its wrong, but its easy to understand. trying to change the nature of the worship at the as 115 times, according to a survey multiply, and replenish the earth,
Its fascinating if unnerving to watch whats main part of the Kotel. They are more like Oliver by Vox contributor Dylan Mat- and subdue it; and have domin-
going on around the world as leaders in liberal Twist, asking for scraps. Those scraps are being thews. Trump and his spokespeo- ion over the fish of the sea, and
democracies try to make the kind of compro- denied. Still, they we are asked for money, ple, meanwhile, steadfastly refuse over the birds of the air, and over
mises that allow them to stay in power. In the and beyond that, for unswerving allegiance. to say whether he still believes that. every living thing that moves upon
United States, Mitch McConnell has tried and That wont work forever. The question was raised again late the earth. Having dominion, they
for now failed, but hes a remarkably shrewd We join much of the rest of the American Jewish last month, when Trump withdrew insist, means being in control and
politician, so stay tuned to push through a world including the CEO of the Jewish Federa- the United States from the Paris cli- making all the decisions.
remarkably and deservedly unpopular health tion of Northern New Jersey, Jason Shames, who mate accord. Not so. According to the com-
we quote on page 23 in hoping that Mr. Netan- Sadly, the American public mentator Abraham Ibn Ezra, The
The opinions expressed in this section are those yahu changes his mind and lives up to the prom- seems to be as unconcerned as is ignorant have compared mans rule
of the authors, not necessarily those of the ises he has been quoted many times as making. the administration. over the earth with Gods rule over
newspapers editors, publishers, or other staffers. Truth matters. Promise-keeping matters.
We welcome letters to the editor. Send them to JP Shammai Engelmayer is rabbi of Temple Israel Community Center/
jstandardletters@gmail.com. Congregation Heichal Yisrael in Cliffside Park and Temple Beth El
of North Bergen.
Jewish Editor
Joanne Palmer
Correspondents
Warren Boroson
Advertising Coordinator
Jane Carr
Production Manager
Jerry Szubin
Founder
Morris J. Janoff (19111987)
Standard Associate Editor
Larry Yudelson
Lois Goldrich
Abigail K. Leichman Account Executives
Graphic Artists
Deborah Herman
Editor Emeritus
Meyer Pesin (19011989)
1086 Teaneck Road Miriam Rinn Peggy Elias Bob O'Brien
Community Editor Dr. Miryam Z. Wahrman Brenda Sutcliffe City Editor
Teaneck, NJ 07666
Beth Janoff Chananie Mort Cornin (19151984)
(201) 837-8818 Advertising Director International Media Placement
Fax 201-833-4959 About Our Children Editor Natalie D. Jay Editorial Consultant
P.O. Box 7195 Jerusalem 91077
Heidi Mae Bratt Max Milians (1908-2005)
Publisher Classified Director Tel: 02-6252933, 02-6247919
James L. Janoff Janice Rosen Fax: 02-6249240 Secretary
Israeli Representative Ceil Wolf (1914-2008)
Associate Publisher Emerita
Marcia Garfinkle Editor Emerita
Rebecca Kaplan Boroson
thejewishstandard.com
the heavens. This is not right, for God rules over every-
A great Judeo-Christian nation?
O
thing. The meaning of he has given the earth to the chil-
dren of men is that man is Gods pakeed over the earth rthodox Jews and orthodox Christians may layers upon layers of interpretation and practice, fails
and must do everything according to Gods word [because view each other as natural allies. the test of commonality.
pakeed, meaning steward, is a specific term, referring to Large segments of both groups tend to The idea of a Judeo-Christian tradition is uniquely
a commission for a specific task. That task is found in Gen be social conservatives who share a belief American, and it has a long history. In postwar Amer-
2:15]: And the Lord God took the man, and put him into in a divinely sanctioned model of marriage and family. ica, it was intended to foster cultural inclusiveness, in
the Garden of Eden to till it and tend it. Both are unwavering in their support for Israel. And the much the same way that a transdenominational Ameri-
In fact, the Torah makes clear in several ways that staunchest religious conservatives, Christian and Jewish, can civil religion with its own mythology, holidays,
humankind does not have absolute power over the envi- also are united in opposing liberalism often carica- martyrs, villains, and saints lowered cultural barriers
ronment. Nowhere is this more evident than in the notion tured as moral relativism or anti-religious secularism for the children of European immigrants.
that even the land is entitled to a Shabbat of rest. Thus, which they consider an existential threat. On a range of Judeo-Christian has evolved since then. The expres-
the Torah tells us in Leviticus 25:1-19: And the Lord spoke issues, many within these two faith communities stand sion simply may reflect a traditional orientation toward
to Moses in Mount Sinai, saying, Speak to the people of on common ground. American culture. But it also might be
Israel, and say to them, When you come into the land But given the unique relationship between taken as an exclusionary label for a soci-
Christianity and Judaism, common ground ety that tolerates all religions while being
is not a simple thing. In fact, it is a minefield, dominated by two (more precisely, a
especially for Orthodox Jews. The American blend of two, not necessarily in equal
In fact, the Torah Orthodox rabbinate sets strict guidelines for
interfaith dialogue and forbids official dis-
measure). And it may be used as a euphe-
mism a veiled claim that the United
makes clear in several cussion on matters of belief. States is, or should be, a great Christian
ways that humankind Yet on the battlefields of the culture wars,
Orthodox Jews have found common cause
nation. (The Judeo part of Judeo-
Christian sometimes feels like an after-
does not have absolute with Christian conservatives. Behind the David S. thought; a fig leaf designed to conceal a
power over the burgeoning partnership is the idea, some-
times stated explicitly, that Jews and Chris-
Zinberg socially unacceptable description of our
national character.)
environment. tians, despite their religious incompatibility, Taking the idea a few steps further,
can agree on the content of a divinely revealed morality. 21st-century nativists have weaponized Judeo-Chris-
which I give you, then shall the land keep a Shabbat to the The first principle of this ideology is the Judeo-Chris- tian in a bid to purge American culture of any influence
Lord. Six years you shall sow your field, and six years you tian tradition. other than its European or Western heritage. It is
shall prune your vineyard, and gather in its fruit; but in Politics aside, the idea is flawed. While Christianitys not hard to guess which ethnic and religious minorities
the seventh year shall be a Shabbat of rest to the land; deepest roots are in Judaism, the Judeo-Christian tradi- are excluded from that vision of America.
you shall not sow your field, nor prune your vineyard.... tion is historical fiction. As religious communities, Jews Religion is a primary source of personal and social
Therefore you shall do my statutes, and keep my judg- and Christians effectively parted ways by the middle of identity, but it need not be the sole basis of moral fellow-
ments, and do them; and you shall dwell in the land in the first century. Since then, in theology, religious prac- ship, especially in the United States. A much wider moral
safety. And the land shall yield its fruit, and you shall eat tice, and historical experience, they have been defined circle encompasses Americans of all religious stripes.
your fill, and dwell in it in safety. more by their differences than their commonalities.
Then there is Deuteronomy 20:19. You shall not destroy (Arthur H. Cohen, in a 1969 essay in Commentary titled
the fruit-bearing trees of the enemy, for is the tree of the The Myth of the Judeo-Christian Tradition, called it
field a man, that it should be besieged by you? a myth which buries under the fine silt of rhetoric the
This simple statement led to a halachic principle often authentic, meaningful, and irrevocable distinction which The Judeo part of
cited here, the principle known as bal tashchit, or pro-
hibition against wanton destruction. Thus, the Babylonian
exists between Jewish belief and Christian belief.)
Related to the Judeo-Christian tradition is the notion
Judeo-Christian
Talmud Shabbat 67b teaches us, He who covers an oil of a common moral code called Judeo-Christian ethics sometimes feels like
lamp or uncovers a naphtha [lamp] infringes the prohibi-
tion of wanton destruction, because such actions would
or biblical values, as though it were the product of an
essential Judeo-Christianity reduced to its bare bones.
an afterthought.
speed up the burning of those fuels in the lamp. Because And this too is a myth. Such an ethic never existed in
it is forbidden to burn fossil fuels with abandon, for exam- practice and cannot arise naturally from the history of We are a nation of traditional American values that are
ple, it is a violation of Jewish law to drive above maximum religion. To manufacture one would violate the integrity a legacy of the secular (but not godless) Enlightenment
speed limits, because the faster we go, the faster we burn of both faiths. as much as revealed religion. Like America itself, those
the cars fuel. To begin with, from which Bible and from whose common civic values transcend religious divisions. Chris-
Maimonides, the Rambam, addresses the question of extra-biblical tradition should Judeo-Christian ethics tians and Jews along with members of all faiths and
removing trees for esthetic purposes. Says he, based on be taken the Hebrew Scriptures and the Talmud? those who profess none can find unity in the values,
this simple verse, The Torah forbids ... uprooting with- The Gospels and the Church Fathers? All of the above? norms, laws, and institutions of our great Republic.
out any purpose, for that is wanton destruction. (See his The Tanach and the Old Testament may contain the To that, let every patriotic American say Amen.
Responsa, No. 54.) same words but each is wrapped in a distinct prophetic
A 14th century rabbi, Aharon Halevy of Barcelona, wrote and moral tradition that often is unrecognizable to the David S. Zinberg lives in Teaneck with his wife and three
of the way of the pious and those of good deeds in his other. Even the Ten Commandments, viewed through sons. He works in inancial services.
Sefer Ha-Chinuch. They love peace, rejoice in that which
is of benefit to people and brings them to Torah; not even
a grain of mustard do they destroy, and are grieved by any
destruction they may see.
More than 411,000 likes.
Like us on
The Jerusalem Talmud (Kiddushin 4:12, 66d) offers
another interesting take on Torah law: It is forbidden to
live in a town in which there is no garden or greenery. facebook.com/
Facebook
Neither Trump nor his EPA administrator need to take
Torah law seriously. We do, however. We are, after all, jewishstandard
Gods kingdom of priests, and the earth is the Lords and
all that fills it.
I
t was the summer of 1974, I had just
graduated high school and was look-
ing forward to starting my first year
of college in the fall, and I had been
accepted into a special summer program
called Torah Corps, sponsored by what
was then known as the Union of American
Hebrew Congregations, now the Union for
Reform Judaism.
It was an intensive learning experience
for a small group of students, all of whom
had just completed 10th, 11th, or 12th
grade. Most of us were from the United
States, but the group also included several
students from Canada.
The program was held at a lodge in Lit-
tleton, New Hampshire, and I well recall
how we all gathered around the lone tele-
vision set available to us on the night of
August 8 to watch President Richard Nixon
deliver a speech to the nation. We knew
that he was in trouble over the Watergate
scandal, but it still came as a tremendous
shock when he uttered the words, I shall
resign the presidency effective at noon
tomorrow. We vocalized our sense of dis-
may at this unprecedented development
collectively, through gasps and cries and
the like. At least those of us who were President Nixon sits in front of edited transcripts of his taped conversations as he broadcasts an address to the nation on
Americans did so, in response to what we April 29, 1974. National Archives & Records Administration
T
h e p ro p o s e d c h a n ge s t o them each an estimated $7 million a year is Paula White, the senior pastor of New make it impossible for a consumer to exer-
Americas health care sys- in savings. Destiny Christian Center in Apopka, Flor- cise such a risky but idealistic choice, he
tem advanced by the Republi- How exactly to cut government ser- ida, who gave the invocation at the Trump wrote. (The full details are in my rejoinder
can Congress have been con- vices to pay for this financial windfall var- inauguration. Followers of the Prosperity volume, How Would God REALLY Vote: A
demned by patient advocates like AARP, ies between the Senate and the House Gospel believe that a persons wealth and Jewish Rebuttal to David Klinghoffers Con-
doctor advocates like the AMA, and hospi- plans, but not significantly. The Senate health reflects his or her righteousness. servative Polemic.)
tal advocates like the American Hospitals plan would manage by reducing Medicaid You can hear this theology in the recent Klinghoffer further argued that any gov-
Association. payments by an ever-increasing amounts, remarks of Republican Congressman Mo ernment effort to provide health care is an
But theres a religious case that has leaving the states and future legislators to Brooks of Alabama. He declared that obstacle to religious growth. He approv-
been made in its defense that decide whether to cut ser- people who lead good lives shouldnt ingly cites a Catholic theologian who, ignor-
is worth examining, even vices for the working poor, have to pay for the health care costs of ing the role of Jesus as a healer, argued for
though its not a case the disabled children, or senior people who have higher health care the value of human suffering as a neces-
authors of either the House citizens in nursing homes. It costs. If youre sick, in other words, you sary condition in spiritual formation.
or the Senate bill have been would also reduce support deserve it. He summarizes this religious view in a
forthright in making per- for insurance premiums for Or as Vice President Mike Pence recently sentence that I believe explains not only
haps fearing to bring reli- the lower middle class, and tweeted, the new Republican-designed the specifics of the Republican health-
gious ideas into the public encourage plans that would health care system will be based on per- defunding tax cuts, but also many pro-
discourse. be cheaper for healthy peo- sonal responsibility. So indeed, why visions of the proposed Trump budget,
The basics of the bill the ple while being less likely to should people with pre-existing medical which would slash funding for medical
Senate has been consider- Larry keep sick people from being conditions have to be paid for by healthier, research: If materialism is the premise,
ing and might consider Yudelson bankrupted. and presumably more godly, citizens? then by all means, let us deploy the gov-
again are simple. The bill For those of us raised It is not a new idea this is one of the ernment to rid ourselves of illness of all
would retroactively repeal the with a mandate of vahavta theological arguments that the biblical illness, why not?
taxes that financed the ACA. Most impor- lreiacha kamocha loving our neigh- Book of Job was written to rebut thou- But the point of view that Klinghoffer
tantly, this is a 3.9 percent tax on invest- bor as ourselves (Leviticus 19:18) and sands of years ago. represents is anti-materialist. From this
ment income above a certain threshold. lo taamod al dam reicha do not stand You dont have to be a full-fledged Pros- religious view, a government designed to
Someone who makes $200,000 a year in idly by the blood of your neighbor (Leviti- perity Gospel advocate to think God would help citizens with their material problems
salary and earns $50,000 in capital gains cus 19:16) it would seem that redirecting rather you get a tax cut than that money is a bad thing. If salvation comes from the
will not benefit from the tax cut, since such money to rich peoples pockets from sick go to heal people. One Jewish advocate for church, who needs government? And by
a person now doesnt pay any Net Invest- peoples health care would be religiously valuing wealth over health is the writer that logic, any secular government is the
ment Income Tax. A family with $500,000 indefensible. Indeed, Yeshiva Universitys David Klinghoffer, who spelled out his enemy of religion.
of earned income and $50,000 of interest Rabbi Moshe Tendler has used these two argument in his 2008 book, How Would Yes, Klinghoffer has followed his Chris-
and dividends, however, will save $1,800 biblical verses to argue that providing God Vote: Why the Bible Commands You tian brothers in ideology into the realm of
with this tax cut. And for the 400 richest health care is a societal obligation. So why to Be a Conservative. anti-Zionist ultra-Orthodox Jews. But note
families, this and related tax cuts will net arent all religious groups following the Basing himself on an extremely innova- that while he doesnt want the government
lead of the Union for Reform Judaism and tive reading of Talmud Chulin 91a, Kling- to help other people, he confesses to per-
Larry Yudelson is the associate editor condemning the Republican health plans? hoffer writes that the Bible would have us sonally lacking enough faith to renounce
of the Jewish Standard and the author One answer is that an increasing number choose wealth over health. the medical services his wealth can buy
of Ben Yehuda Presss How Would God of Americans particularly those who iden- It would be a shame if government him: The Talmud explains that in an ideal
REALLY Vote: A Jewish Rebuttal to David tify as Republican follow what is called policies, namely the imposition of uni- world, we would never consult doctors at
Klinghoffers Conservative Polemic. the Prosperity Gospel. A classic exemplar versal health care, were implemented to See Care Act page 30
Letter
Regime of the extreme not less important than defending ourselves against Irans move its embassy to Jerusalem, let us start by making Jeru-
Is Israel a religious Zionist state or a charedi ayatollah ayatollah state. As matter fact, if were not careful, we salem a democratic city first.
state? might actually become one. This is a travesty. We cannot just let Israel devolve into
Weve heard this news before: I am not alone in this and, as matter of fact, the Jew- a totalitarian regime of the extreme.
Israels Chief Rabbinate rejects conversions authorized ish Agency has just issued a severe and unprecedented We need to stop the passive acceptance of such dicta-
by top U.S. Orthodox rabbis. criticism of the governments approval of a bill to grant the torship. The government yields to the demands of the
Israels government has rejected the Supreme Courts Chief Rabbinate a total monopoly over conversion in Israel extreme members in its midst, but we, the diaspora, that
ruling in favor of women being allowed to read from the and the prayer space at the Western Wall. supports Israel with over a billion dollars a year of Israel
Torah in the womens section at the Western Wall. Rabbi Donniel Hartman suggested that Suspending the Bonds, should have our say as well.
The coalition government strikes down a law mandating Kotel agreement is an affront to Zionism, its dreams and We tried negotiations but everything failed. We need
ultra-Orthodox conscription into the IDF. aspirations. It is an affront to Israels commitment to being to stop capitulating in the face of rabbinic excuses and jus-
And now, in its latest affront, Israel indefinitely freezes a Jewish democracy. It threatens Israels core identity and tifications. We must invigorate our Jewish media and the
the agreement for a state-recognized egalitarian prayer future. public to pressure the government, in a rebellion of the
space at the Western Wall. Journalist and author Yossi Klein Halevi wrote: In the moderate Jewish world.
Reading this troubling news year after year, I keep fiftieth year of the liberation of the Wall, the government Charedi politics is taking over Israel, trampling public
wondering if and when Israel will start balancing its civil of Israel has told a majority of diaspora Jewry that it has rights, while the charedim keep condemning the very
rights laws with its coalition needs? Quite honestly, as an no organized place in our most resonant public space. If state whose rules they are dictating.
Israeli and an American Jew, the charedi parties hijack- unity helped us return to Jerusalem, what does our squab- This has to stop immediately.
ing of Israels democratic institutions make me feel that bling over the Wall portend? Soli Israel Foger
this is an affront to us all. I believe that this struggle is In a time when we demand that the U.S. administration Englewood
I
f you havent encountered the term Shia corridor
yet, chances are that you will in the coming weeks,
particularly if the ongoing confrontation between
the United States and Iran in Syria intensifies.
What initially was a sideshow to the main battle against
Islamic State in Syria is fast becoming the main focus of
attention. In recent weeks, the United States has shot
down at least two Iranian armed drones over Syria. A Syr- Iranian anti-tank
ian regime bomber jet supposedly attacking Islamic State rockets that IDF
positions near Raqqa also was downed, after it ventured forces in southern
too close to positions held by U.S.-allied forces. Armed Lebanon captured
skirmishes have been reported between U.S.-allied forces from Hezbollah
and Iranian-backed Shia Islamist militias. The Russians in 2006.
allied with Iran in supporting the tyrant Bashar al-Assad idF
Yemen. It requires that Iran has easy, uninterrupted those who see the Muslim Brotherhood or Iran as their
access to all those parts of the region where it exercises main enemy, and those who accord that distinction to Ben Cohen writes a weekly column on Jewish affairs and
political control. Israel and the United States, Iran is presenting a unified Middle Eastern politics. His work has been published in
On one level, the idea of a Shia corridor seems a little Shia revolutionary stance toward the outside world. Iran Commentary, the New York Post, Haaretz, the Wall Street
fantastical. Almost 2,000 miles separate Tehran from the has allies all the way from Lebanon to Bahrain, and Iran Journal, and many other publications.
Mediterranean coast to its far west. The road between
the two points is distinguished by rough terrain and the
presence of numerous militias along the route, many of
them belonging to Sunni Islamist factions hostile to Iran.
In addition to heavy defenses on the ground, the corridor Care act mainstream of Jewish tradition roundly rejects. Those
FrOM page 29
would need effective aerial warning systems, given Israels lending their support to these plans to change Ameri-
demonstrated willingness to bomb weapons shipments all. A person with an illness would seek out spiritual can health care should keep in mind how Rabbi Israel
between Iran and its allies in Syria and Lebanon. Can a guidance, not unlike the model of Christian Science. Salanter distinguished between a tzaddik, a righteous
country with an ailing economy like Irans, that is now fac- That we are allowed to use medicine is a lenience, a con- man, and a rasha, a wicked one.
ing an increasingly hostile administration in Washington, cession taking into account that few of us are up to the A righteous tzaddik, Rabbi Salanter, worries about
really carve out such a corridor unopposed? exalted spiritual level it would require to effect healing his own soul and his neighbors body. A wicked rasha,
The point, for now at least, is Iran is doing precisely that through repentance. by contrast, worries, about his own body and his neigh-
assisted by the lack of a defined U.S. policy toward not We all understand that Christian Science is a religious bors soul.
just the Iranian nuclear program, but its entire regional view and most of us are grateful that our own reli- If Congress succeeds in passing its proposed undoing
role; the absence of any appetite among the Europeans gious teachers dont preach it. We take pride in Juda- of the Affordable Care Act, it will have made some reli-
for a confrontation with Tehran; and the unprecedented isms this-worldly nature. I believe that the Republican gious people happy. Rabbi Salanter, however, would not
support coming from Irans traditional foe, Russia, thanks plan likewise reflects a religious view and one that the be among them.
jfnnj.org
Its not just a fresh look.
Its the gateway to the
northern New Jersey
Jewish community.
W
hen I was little, the only up, but back in the stone age, blind meant
reason why I enjoyed just that. You had no idea what you were
playing with Barbie dolls getting. So this particular narcissist that I
was because I liked cut- went on one date with was disappointed
ting their hair. with my physique did it matter that he
I even remember the giant Barbie head looked like a monkey? No, because he
that I got for Chanukah one year I could was a narcissist. He thought he was a Ken
cut her hair and put permanent marker on because he was a doctor, but he was not.
her face instead of the washable makeup In any event, the other day, on the radio,
that came with her. Yes, I was a troubled I was pleased to hear that now Ken comes
child. But I had an older sister who took in different shapes! If I am not mistaken,
such good care of everything Ken now comes in three or
my parents ever bought for four different builds, one of
her. How could I ever live up which is sturdy.
to that? Dolls in their origi- Ahh, sturdy Ken he
nal boxes! Crayons kept in an likes drinking five or six
orderly fashion! Her grades beers when he comes home
always perfect! Her room from the office and eating a
always spotless! Who can fol- couple of steaks that zaftig
low in such immaculate foot- Barbie grilled for him when
steps? I would usually dump he was at work. His doctor Across 7. Some Omnicom or Joseph Jacobs work-
everything from my closet Banji keeps warning him about 1. They might be held when drinking some
Galil Ela
ers
8. Pose a shaylah again
onto the floor, thinking that I Ganchrow his cholesterol and his mid- 6. Gan Sacher, e.g. 9. Dennings who played a Broke Girl
was going to organize every- section, but zaftig Barbie 10. Sacrifice stock 10. Something taken at 47-Across
thing. My dad would come in loves him just the way he 16. ___ Be (Lu Yehi) 11. Will on Hurwitzs Arrested Development
a few hours later to check on my progress, is. Truth be told, original size Barbie also 17. Many people think turning cell phones 12. Chan. that might air Billy Wilder films
off one day a week is a good one 13. Words between Am in Exodus 3:14
to find me sleeping on the very comfort- loves him because he comes from family 18. Hachnasat ___ 14. Say Joseph is comparable to Daniel
able pile of stuff. Yes, that was me. But money that has afforded her a five carat 19. Day of celebration in Eretz Yisrael 15. Its the truth
back to the Barbies. diamond ring, the dream house, and the 21. Get into an Inbal bed 20. She won gold four years before Sarah
Over the years, many feminists have dream pool. 22. Fig. for those at 47-Across (Hughes)
23. Dismays 24. Leading the Jews for forty years, for
criticized the Barbie doll. They have said If we put sturdy Ken with zaftig Bar- 24. Shoresh center? Moses (at times)
that her measurements, if they were bie, we are just promoting the stereo- 25. Hebrew letter with a value of 9 27. Its good in Yiddish, but can be
unhealthy in English?
translated into a real live woman, were type that big belongs with big. I think that 26. Mel Brooks classic
28. Job of Michael Kahn on virtually every
impossible to maintain. No one has mea- the makers of Ken and Barbie should go 30. Country in Jerusalem? Spielberg film
surements like that, unless, of course, 31. 2002 Streisand album 29. Jacobs twin, and others
32. Actor Broderick, for short
they have been surgically altered. How 35. Claremont or Martin
32. Film mogul Louis B.
33. Hapoel Jerusalem Basketball Club, for
is this doll supposed to be a role model 38. You ___ heard nothin yet (Al Jolsen) one
for little girls and boys all over the world?
Measurements aside, Barbie had a dream
If we put sturdy 42. An Emanuel brother
43. Remove, as pages from this publication
34. N.Y.U.s ___ School of the Arts
35. Stereotyped Jewish job: Abbr.
house, a dream pool (of which, I was the Ken with zaftig 45. Faith, in Judaism
47. Jewish Institution established in 1886...
36. Historic name in magic
37. Confrontation, like on Bochcos Hill
proud owner), a dream car. There were
doctor Barbies and scientist Barbies and
Barbie, we are or a hint to whats missing in 19, 26, 61,
& 75- Across
Street Blues
39. Iconic role for Mandy (Patinkin)
businesswoman Barbies. These were just promoting 50. Confine, like the lion in Ezekiel 19
51. Those eating in a 1982 Barry Levinson
40. Refusenik Sharansky
the stereotype
role models. 41. Herb in a Simon & Garfunkel title
film
43. Make like Rothstein to the World Series,
Barbie taught us that you can have it all. 52. When doubled, a kosher restaurant in
that big belongs
supposedly
Venice
A few years ago, Barbie started coming 44. ___ Lost You (Elvis)
53. An Emanuel brother
out in different shapes. This, of course,
made me happy because there was a zaf-
with big. 54. Shmutzy
55. Sof haderech
45. Puppet ending (e.g. Shari Lewis)
46. Zeresh, ___ 48-Across
48. Husband of 46-Across
tig Barbie. Barbie with a little meat on her 56. Ones in charge at 47-Across, for short
49. Oy follower
bones. Of course, true to form, if zaftig one step further with the Ken line. How 59. Like Laban
54. Adjusts electric lights for Havdalah,
61. Israels Ambassador to the United
Barbies measurements were translated about receding hair Ken? Combover Ken? Nations from 1984-88
perhaps
into real life ones, she still would only Buzzed-haircut-because-I-am-really-bald 55. She wrote about Dagny (Taggart)
68. Hair product from Natural
57. ___ Unchained (film with a humorous
probably be a size 12, but it still is progress. Ken? Maybe we could mix and match the 69. Ramat Hadar borders? Jonah Hill cameo)
Barbie would have to shop in the plus size different heads with the different builds? 70. Kama and Basra 58. 75-Across, e.g.
71. El ___ (1961 Anthony Mann classic)
department, while all of her skinny Barbie Fat and bald Ken would go over great with 59. Legendary Lee
73. Symbolic liquid of one who might need 60. Ammo for Han Solo
friends were lunching on lettuce and wear- the ladies, because I have always said that tzedakah
61. Southern Kibbutz
ing a size 2 but it was still a shout-out to a woman, like zaftig Barbie, could be suc- 75. Jerusalem locale that gets very crowded
62. Rental name at Ben Gurion
on Friday
big gals everywhere. But it got me think- cessful but still single in her 40s, whereas 63. Casspi or Curry, briefly
77. Color of Jenji Kohans Netflix show
ing what about Ken? Would Ken, the ulti- fat and bald Ken could be unemployed 78. Astin of Lord of the Rings 64. A brigade in the IDF
mate man, date zaftig Barbie? and living in his car and still manage to 79. Jordan e.g. 65. Famous Abba and his family
I still remember the blind date I went on get married. 80. Tisha BAv readings 66. Bin name in Halva
81. Addresses used by one medium of this 67. Miep Gies to Anne Frank
many, many years ago, when the voice on Yup, it is still a mans world, but at least publication 68. ___ Nation (Mayim Bialik website)
the other end of the phone asked me if I Barbie has started eating, and that, my 82. Part of Tommy Ramones kit 72. Double ___ (Marc Summers game
was zaftig. I was taken aback by the ques- friends, is progress! Down show)
tion because the joy of the blind date (to 1. Make like the Jews through the desert 74. Establishment for Rahab
2. Pace or a chalav yisrael brand in Australia 75. Big Ten sch. of Sam Raimi and Magic
be read sarcastically) is not having any Banji Ganchrow has never been a fan of Johnson
3. A Coen brother
idea what the other person looks like. dolls, but has always been a fan of peanut 4. Hamm or Kirshner
76. Karem or Gedi
With social media, you can look people chews. 5. Props for Jacob and Moses
The solution to last weeks puzzle
6. Big Apple offering is on page 39.
T
pora groups that have come together in
here is something ironic Israel Moroccan, Iraqi, Ethiopian and
maybe post-ironic about other smaller Mizrachi groups each hold
having a Yiddish program in onto their own traditions even as they are
Weimar. woven into the larger ribbon of Jewish life.
Until 1933, when the Nazis took over This year, the Summer Weimar Festival
the city, art flourished there music, lit- will look at how that works, and will pro-
erature, visual art, architecture. It was mote conversations among those groups
vibrant, freethinking, exciting every- and between those groups and the larger
thing the Nazis hated, and tried and failed Jewish world.
to destroy. It gave its name to the Weimar Hope for the future, hope for our chil-
Republic, that between-the-wars flowering dren, will be embodied in performances
of cutting-edge culture. by Kadya, is a collaboration between the
Then the Nazis came, and there was Arab-Jewish Voices of Peace girls choir
darkness. from Jaffa and the Weimar Schola Can-
Now, the city has come alive again; for torum. When they perform, Arab-Israeli
the last 18 years its been home to the festi- and Jewish-Israeli children will sing with
val of Yiddish culture called Yiddish Sum- German children; theyll be joined by an
mer Weimar. It has introduced and rein- Arab-Jewish orchestra from Haifa.
troduced thousands of participants and As full of events as the entire festival is,
visitors to the artistic and anthropological everything is ramped up on Festival Week,
scientific and social dimensions of Yiddish August 2 through 6, when workshops, mini-
culture through imaginative exploration of workshops, all-night concerts, lectures, a
the past, and a trenchant engagement with brand-new Israeli documentary film series,
the present, in order to further the develop- and other emotionally and intellectual
ment and celebrate Yiddish as a language, engaging experiences come together.
life-style, and art form, in the 21st century Keep Yiddish alive in Germany, the orga-
and beyond, its press release reads. nizers urge. Its more than ironic. Its more
The festival, from July 12 to August 15, than post-ironic. Its a tribute to the past
offers workshops, lecture series, and con- and an invitation to the future.
certs in, on, and about Yiddish; its long Theres lots more information about
history has seen some of the biggest names Yiddish Summer Weimar online in Eng-
in Jewish music perform there. lish! at yiddishsummer.eu.
100 minutes of
POTENT THEATRICAL MAGIC.
NY1
inside the mall in the Whole Foods wing collection, decrease when schools close ELECTRIC & SURPRISING!
across from Marshalls. for the summer. A masterful exploration of the
In appreciation, each donor will To donate blood or for information, go theatrical past and present!
receive a voucher for a pair of 2017 New to www.nybloodcenter.org or call (800)
TABLET MAGAZINE
York Mets tickets, a Whole Foods Market 933-2566.
coupon, and refreshments.
PHOTOS BY CAROL ROSEGG
Art at bergenPAC
The Bergen Performing Arts
Center in Englewood displays
paintings by Vincent Priblo in
the Sandy Bennett Art Gallery
through July 19. The gallery is
open during performances, on
Mondays through Fridays, 11
a.m. to 4 p.m., and on Saturday
afternoons. Priblo has exhib-
ited his work at local libraries
and galleries. The center is at 30
North Van Brunt St. For informa-
tion, call (201) 227-1030 or go to IndecentBroadway.com Telecharge.com 212-239-6200
www.bergenpac.org.
CORT THEATRE 138 W 48th St, New York @IndecentBway
JEWISH STANDARD JUNE 30, 2017 35
Jewish World
and one of two Cabinet members to vote chairman, Natan Sharansky, was one of
against the decision to freeze the agree-
ment, said in a statement that it consti-
the architects of the 2016 agreement.
After four years of intense negotia-
Netanyahu defends suspending
tutes a severe blow to the unity of the
Jewish people, Jewish communities, and
tions, we reached a solution that was
accepted by all major denominations the Western Wall agreement.
the fabric of relations between the State
of Israel and the Jews of the diaspora.
and was then adopted by the govern-
ment and embraced by the worlds Jew- Heres his spin on events
Yair Lapid, head of the opposition ish communities, Sharansky said in a
Yesh Atid party, spoke in English at the statement. Todays decision signifies BEN SALES will be expedited.
beginning of his partys faction meeting a retreat from that agreement and will The symbolic piece was holding the
in order to reach the Jewish diaspora, make our work to bring Israel and the American Jewish leaders are calling it a practical piece hostage, the official said.
particularly U.S. Jews, he said. Jewish world closer together increas- betrayal. What was frozen yesterday was the sym-
I want to tell you that the vast major- ingly more difficult. They say that 17 months after achiev- bolic part. The practical part of advanc-
ity of the citizens of Israel oppose the Yizhar Hess, head of the Conservative ing a historic agreement to provide a ing the prayer arrangements, that can
two decisions taken yesterday by the movement in Israel, wrote an op ed in a non-Orthodox space at Judaisms holiest
government, he said, referring to the daily newspaper, Yediot Ahronot, saying prayer site, Israeli Prime Minister Benja-
Western Wall decision and a separate that he regretted reaching a compromise min Netanyahu reneged in a Cabinet vote
conversion bill that would solidify con-
versions in Israel under the authority of
with the government.
We made a mistake, he wrote. We
Sunday, effectively canceling the deal and
caving to the interests of his charedi Ortho-
The symbolic
the charedi-dominated Chief Rabbinate. believed the government, we believed dox coalition partners. piece was
Do not give up on us. We have no
intention of giving up on you. We are one
the prime minister, we believed that
we needed at last to end this squab-
Netanyahu disagrees. Far from killing
the compromise, he believes the vote has
holding the
people. It might take time. It might take bling among ourselves over the Western given it new life. And far from betraying practical piece
elections. But in a democracy the major-
ity decides and the majority in Israel
Wall, and we agreed to a compromise
arrangement.
diaspora Jewry, he says the vote shows his
concern for Jews around the world.
hostage. What
want us to be one nation. But the Cabinets decision last night In a lengthy conversation, an unnamed was frozen
Sephardi Orthodox Shas Party leader
Arye Deri, who opposes the Western
a cynical, even wicked decision took
this historic agreement and threw it in
senior Israeli official gave some insight into
Netanyahus defense of the vote freezing
yesterday was
Wall compromise, said during his partys the faces of millions of Jews around the the 2016 Western Wall agreement: why he the symbolic
meeting that the canceled plan destroys
Jewish unity.
world.
Non-Orthodox leaders also decried
did it, what the vote leaves in place, and
what it means moving forward.
part.
Every Jew in the world, and non- the Israeli governments advancing a bill The agreement, which was passed by
Jews, can come pray there. We have to centralize authority for Jewish conver- the Cabinet in January 2016, has three now move forward. Regrettably, there are
nothing against Jews, in any place they sions under the Israeli Chief Rabbinate, components. First is a physical expansion those on both sides who are spinning this
may be. They are all our brothers. Our a charedi-dominated body. Silverman and upgrade of the non-Orthodox prayer as cancellation.
fight is against the approach, this ideol- compared the bill to a 2010 bill on con- section south of the familiar Western Wall However, several aspects of the proj-
ogy which is attempting to bring a new versions in Israel, which American Jew- plaza. Second is the construction of a ect as it stands are murky. It isnt clear
Judaism here, is trying to destroy every- ish groups also opposed because they shared entrance to the Orthodox and non- whether the expansion of the site will
thing that we built here over the years. argued it would delegitimize non-Ortho- Orthodox sections. Third is the creation of proceed according to the dimensions
Health Minister Yaakov Litzman of the dox conversions. a government-appointed, interdenomina- outlined in the 2016 agreement. Nor is it
charedi United Torah Judaism party also The conversion bill that was approved tional Jewish committee to govern the non- clear whether construction will begin on
welcomed the Cabinet decision as a vic- by the ministerial committee and Knesset Orthodox section. the shared entrance to the site or whether
tory over liberal Jews. is one that definitively changes the status Sundays decision, the senior official the non-Orthodox space will have a staff,
This decision sends a clear message quo in conversions, Silverman said. This said, leaves in place the physical expan- accessible prayer books, and Torah scrolls,
to the entire world that Reform Judaism is something that almost every 10 years sion of the prayer site while suspending as promised in the agreement.
has no access to or recognition at the comes up, and would have a dramatic the creation of the interdenominational The official said that the suspension of
Western Wall, he said Sunday in a state- effect on who is a Jew, which obviously committee. Netanyahus charedi partners, the deal is itself a compromise: the charedi
ment. I thank the rabbi of the Western has a significant impact. the official said, objected to the idea that parties wanted to cancel the deal altogether,
Wall, Shmuel Rabinowitz, and the chief JTA WIRE SERVICE/TIMES OF ISRAEL the committee amounted to state recogni- a step he said that Netanyahu was unwilling
rabbis of Israel. To their merit we were tion of non-Orthodox Judaism. to take. Freezing the agreement, the official
able to sanctify Gods name. Amanda Borschel-Dan, Larry Yudelson, With the controversy over the commit- said, allows for continued negotiations to
A range of other groups criticized Sun- and Joanne Palmer contributed to this tee frozen, the official said, actual build- rework it. It also may provide an acceptable
days decision, including the American report. ing at the site can start unhindered and SEE WESTERN WALL PAGE 40
children, Arthur of Wash- 89, of Franklin Lakes died tor. The family moved to Hackensack. Gary Schoem Manager - NJ Lic. 3811
ington, D.C., and Susan June 20. Paramus in 1956, where Conveniently Located
of New York City, and a A World War II Coast Dr. Mitchel established a David Perskie W-150 Route 4 East Paramus, NJ 07652
sister, Adeline Some of Guard veteran, he was a pediatrics practice where David B. Perskie, 82, of 201.843.9090 1.800.426.5869
Livingston. Arrangements partner of DMM Enter- she worked for the next Teaneck died on Sunday.
were by Louis Suburban prises and a member of 42 years. She was on staff Raised in Forest Hills,
Chapel, Fair Lawn. the North Hudson Yacht at Hackensack Hospital, N.Y., Perskie attended
We continue to be Jewish family managed,
Club. He was known as director of the infectious Cornell University, where knowing that caring people provide caring service.
Herbert Dorfman Mr. Harmonica. diseases department at he received his B.A. and
Herbert Dorfman, 88, of Predeceased by his wife, Bergen Pines Hospital in M.B.A. Upon graduation,
GUTTERMAN AND MUSICANT
Leonia died June 22. Phyllis, ne Markowitz, he Paramus, school doctor in he joined his father in JEWISH FUNERAL DIRECTORS
Born Brooklyn, he was is survived by children, Hackensack, and donated the graphic arts industry 800-522-0588
a retired television news Richard (Linda), Lenny free medical services at where he used his techno-
producer. Predeceased (Alexis), and Linda Lucas the Well Baby Clinic in logical acumen and entre-
WIEN & WIEN, INC. MEMORIAL CHAPELS
by a son, Andrew in 1968, (Chris); grandchildren, Paramus. preneurial skills to build
800-322-0533
he is survived by his wife, Cassie, Maleyma, Shan- Predeceased by her hus- many thriving businesses. 402 Park Street, Hackensack, New Jersey 07601
Esther, ne Gold, a daugh- non, Michael, Rebecca, band of 67 years, Stanley, He was also a painter, a ALAN L. MUSICANT, Mgr., N.J. Lic. No. 2890
ter, Robin Dorfman of Los Derek, and Tina; great- and sister, Bela Chechik in patron of the arts and a
MARTIN D. KASDAN, N.J. Lic. No. 4482
Angeles; a brother, Walter grandchildren, Amanda, Israel, she is survived by golf enthusiast.
Anderson of White Plains, Matthew, and Lily, and his her daughters Francine Perskie is survived by Advance Planning Conferences Conveniently Arranged
N.Y., and a grandson, partner, Pat. Winters (Richard) and his wife and partner of 60 at the Funeral Home or in Your Own Home
Andrew Farrow. Contributions can be Tamara Mitchel (Daniel years, Flora, three daugh- GuttermanMusicantWien.com
Arrangements were by made to the music depart- Ross); grandchildren, ters Debra Schwartz, Rox-
Eden Memorial Chapels, ment or cantors fund Leslie Silver (Michael), anne Harband and Phyllis
Fort Lee. at Temple Beth Rishon, Steven Winters, and Owen Kesslen; sons-in-law Dr.
Wyckoff. Arrangements and Hugh Ross, and great- Robert Schwartz and Mark
Miriam Friede were by Gutterman Musi- grandchildren, Jayme and Kesslen; grandchildren
Miriam Friede, 93, of Fair cant Funeral Directors, Jack Silver. Emilia, Kayla, Matthew,
Lawn, died June 25. Hackensack. Services were at the JCC Benjamin and Daniel, and
A Holocaust survi- of Paramus/Congregation sister Lenore Holland.
vor, she was a former Dr. Selma Mitchel Beth Tikvah, where dona- In lieu of flowers, please
member of Temple Beth Dr. Selma Mitchel, 97, of tions can be sent. Arrange- donate to The David B.
Sholom in Fair Lawn and Paramus, died June 23. ments were by Robert Perskie Memorial Fund
a member of the Jacob Born in Russia, she Schoems Menorah Chapel for the Arts at the Kaplen
Dineson Lodge #422 Brith earned a medical degree in Paramus. JCC on the Palisades at
Abraham in Paterson and after of World War II, jccorg.org. Arrangements
Hadassah. enrolling in medical Albert Pekelney were by Gutterman Musi-
Predeceased by her school in Leningrad at Albert Al Pekelney died cant Funeral Directors,
husband, Jacob, and a age 18 and completing June 20, his 93rd birthday, Hackensack.
granddaughter, Keren, her studies in Moscow. in Haworth.
she is survived by sons, Her parents died in the Predeceased by a
www.thejewishstandard.com
Bronzes Silver Bronzes Porcelain Serving the Tri-State Area, New York and Bergen County
EWR $39 LGA $42 JFK $59
Chinese Porcelain & Art Oriental Rugs Furniture Tolls, parking, wlt, stops & tps are not included Extra $7 Airport Pickup
Prices subject to change without prior notice. Price varies by locations.
Mens & Womens Watches Marble Sculpture Jewelry Fuel surcharge may add up to 10% Additional charge may be applied to credit card payment
201-641-5500 888-990-TAXI (8294)
Top Dollar for any kind of Tiffany Items Chandeliers Visit us online at: www.apluslimo1.com E-mail: apluslimo@earthlink.net
Salomon three speakers who told Dr. Salomons story. The speak-
FROM PAGE 9 ers include Dr. Dubowsky and another Medal of Honor
vendors Want to buy During a return visit to Yad Vashem in 2009 with a winner, Jack Jacobs, who also is Jewish. The main
group of other DVI dentists, Dr. Dubowsky came across speaker was retired Maj. Gen. Patrick Sculley. Hes the
VENDORS .
JOIN US AT OUR ALWAYS PAYING CASH an exhibit he had not seen before, about someone hed mensch who finally pushed Ben Salomons Medal of
GOODS & SERVICE FOR SPORTS CARDS never heard of. While touring the exhibits, I came to Honor over the finish line.
BOUTIQUE AND AUTHOGRAPHS.
an exhibit which was dedicated to American Jews who Dr. Dubowsky tells me that this year, Ben Salomons
to be held Sunday,
Nov.12, 2017 WE BUY IT ALL! had been awarded the Medal of Honor, he said. I yarhzeit falls on July 10, and because Dr. Salomon has
CALL 732-547-4381
Congr. Beth Sholom, read all of the material diligently, but when I came to no family alive, he will light a candle for Dr. Salomon.
Teaneck,N.J
For more particulars call
the last awardee Capt. Salomon I was totally blown Perhaps you will too. If you do, as you do, think of all the
Cindy 201-907-0305 away. As an American, a Jew, and the son of an Ameri- menschen named in this article.
can Jewish dentist who had served in the Pacific the- One final note: Dr. Sadowsky tells me that the funds
ater in World War II, I just stood there and the tears available to DVI were diminished a great deal by the
rooFing flowed down my cheeks. Madoff scandal. So think about joining this chain of
In November 2016, Dr. Dubowsky helped to arrange goodness and donating to AVI or DVI. All funds go to
ROOFING SIDING
HACKENSACK GUTTERS LEADERS a benefit for AVI at New York University that featured support the clinics work.
Free ROOFING
OOFING Roof they have to affiliate with Reform synagogues. That is
Estimates CO. Repairs Boundaries
FROM PAGE 13 fine if that is what they want, but I am bothered that
INC.
201-487-5050 83 FIRST STREET
HACKENSACK, NJ 07601
to our tradition.
Rabbi Dr. David J. Fine of Temple Israel and Jewish
they do not feel that they have a place in a Conservative
synagogue.
Community Center in Ridgewood is more blunt. And there is always the possibility that they will raise
First, he said, any intermarriage that is officiated by Jewish children, he added. I do think that we need
PARTY
a rabbi is going to be nonhalachic. Its a civil marriage, some way of getting the message across to intermarried
and he does not perform civil marriages. If I am asked Jews that they are welcome in our community.
to do a wedding, I say, Im sorry, but I can only do a Jew- Rabbi Fine acknowledges that the status of non-Jewish
PLANNER
ish wedding. Thats a wedding between two people who partners in the Conservative world is both fraught and
accept the same covenant. I am working in a covenantal changing, and he is a bit puzzled by how the movement
system, and I am working with two partners and God is handling it. Last February, the United Synagogue
and the tradition, and both partners have to accept the voted to eliminate the standard that you had to be Jew-
system. I can still say mazal tov, but I represent the cov- ish to be a member of a synagogue, he said. That was
enant system of only one of the partners. a big change, and I dont think it was taken as seriously
To advertise call I think that the Conservative movement has chosen as it should have been.
the wrong path in turning their back on intermarried I think that it will take some time for the results to be
201-837-8818 couples and trying to limit acknowledging them in the
synagogue, Rabbi Fine continued. I think that the
felt. I feel that the movement needs to recenter itself. I
think that there is a healthy discussion to come, and we
result of that is that often intermarried couples feel that will see where it goes.
10850 Wilshire Blvd. Suite 400, Los Angeles CA 90024 | (800) 813-0557 | mazon.org
Yonatan Sindel/Flash90
Israeli parliament member Nachman Shai, left, and Jewish Agency Chairman A Lotties Kitchen Meals on Wheels volunteer stays at the bedside of a family
Natan Sharansky confer at a meeting in the Knesset on June 27. member dealing with a serious illness. Courtesy LK
Western Wall
from page 36
government minister and Netanyahu ally,
on Tuesday. And now youre going to
Supporting Lotties Kitchen
answer to the Supreme Court, which is con- compromise over the compromise? The annual Lotties Kitchen event is It benefits Ezer Mizions Lotties
sidering a petition to force the government On Tuesday, at the conclusion of its planned for Thursday, July 6, in Oakhurst, Kitchen in Israel, which provides meals
to provide an appropriate space for non- board of governors meetings in Jerusalem, near Deal. for families dealing with serious illness.
Orthodox prayer at the Wall. Jewish Agency for Israel Chairman Natan More than 2,000 people are expected The organization provides 1,200 hot
The official added that The prime min- Sharansky urged 200 employees who rep- attend this all-day event. The program meals and 1,500 sandwiches every week.
ister takes Israels relations with diaspora resent the agency abroad to prepare for features professional food demos, gour- For information, go to www.ezermi-
Jewry very seriously. criticism of the governments suspension met bakery, portrait sittings, a tricky-tray zion.org or call (718) 853-8400.
But non-Orthodox leaders were not pla- in the diaspora. The night before, the Jew- auction, and lunch by Juice Theory.
cated by these assurances. ish Agency canceled its scheduled gala din-
Rabbi Steven Wernick, CEO of the ner with Netanyahu over the Cabinet vote.
United Synagogue of Conservative Juda- According to a statement, Sharansky
Briefs
ism, called Sundays vote sleight of hand. urged the emissaries to listen to expres-
He is treating it as a cancellation of the Mossad establishes tech investment fund
agreement, given that the agreement had Mossad, Israels security and intelligence harvesting, web intelligence, encryp-
not been implemented nearly a year and a agency, will converge with the Jewish tion, and more.
half after being passed. states start-up nation through the We are looking for companies that
Its not really a freeze, its a kill, he
said. Its already been frozen. It hasnt
Its not really a establishment of a technological innova- are dealing in areas we are interested
been moving for 18 months. We were wait- freeze, its a kill. tion fund.
The fund, Libertad, will serve as
in, that are at the beginning stages, with
a good idea and a good staff, said a
ing, and assured by the prime minister
that entire time that negotiations were
Its already been an additional branch of the intelligence Mossad employee identified as Aleph
happening and they would get back to us. frozen. It hasnt services technological force build-
up, Mossad said. Libertad will connect
on a conference call with reporters. We
want a relationship with them and to
That hasnt happened.
Jewish leaders also called the expansion
been moving for Mossad to Israels various technology invest in their idea, so that they can ful-
of the prayer space insufficient. They noted 18 months. start-ups by enabling the intelligence
agency to invest in homegrown research
fill their dreams and we can get the tech-
nology that we can use.
re Service that the shared entrance would have granted and development programs directly. Libertad is offering up to NIS 2 mil-
the non-Orthodox space equal standing with sions of anger and criticism that are being As part of the Libertad initiative, lion ($570,000) in equity-free capital
the Orthodox section, but now the plan for heard in many Jewish communities and Mossad has called on entrepreneurs to invest in cutting-edge projects, and
expanding that space is unknown. bring them to the attention of public fig- and companies to submit innovative pro- larger sums may be approved in unique
The physical portion of this agreement ures and politicians in Israel. posals in the fields of robotics, energy cases. JNS.org
was far more extensive, including opening After meeting with the prime minister
the site to the main plaza, making it visible on Monday, Jerry Silverman, CEO of the
and accessible, Rabbi Rick Jacobs, presi- Jewish Federations of North America, told
U.S., Israel sign new cybersecurity pact
dent of the Union for Reform Judaism, The Times of Israel that American Jewish The United States and Israel announced to develop [international] cyber pol-
said. What the government is currently groups plan to lobby Israelis to support a pact to establish a cybersecurity work- icy, protecting crucial infrastructure,
planning to do in no way meets the prom- their concerns about religious pluralism. ing group. research and development, and more.
ises and the details of this agreement. American Jewish leaders, he said, will also The new working group will be led by Speaking at the Cyber Week 2017 con-
Anat Hoffman, chairwoman of the invest more in lobbying Israeli lawmakers. Rob Joyce, special assistant to President ference in Tel Aviv, Bossert said the new
Women of the Wall, whose activism led to But the Israeli official said that trying to Donald Trump and cybersecurity coor- working group will focus on identifying
negotiations over the Wall, also said that force change in Israeli religious policy is dinator, and Dr. Eviatar Matania, direc- and stopping attacks before they reach
any physical expansion of one of the most what leads to acrimony over these issues. tor of the National Cyber Bureau at the critical infrastructure and networks,
sensitive sites in the world would take years. Better, he said, to let the laws change grad- Israeli Prime Ministers Office. while also seeking to punish offenders.
Given the delays that have already plagued ually and quietly. Prime Minister Benjamin Netan- The agility Israel has in developing
the process, Hoffman said she is hesitant to So what you have is, you have the sta- yahu met with Joyce and Tom Bossert, solutions will innovate cyber defenses
trust assurances from Netanyahu. tus quo: a set of slowly evolving, informal the Trump administrations homeland that we can test here and bring back to
We sat for three years in good faith, rules, the official said. Often you get into security and cyberterrorism adviser, to America, he said. Perfect security may
our group split over this, we paid such a trouble when one of the sides tries to for- outline the new partnership. Accord- not be achievable, but we have within
price, how could I possibly believe you? malize something by going to court or by ing to the U.S. Embassy in Israel, They our reach a safer and more secure
she recalls telling Tzachi Hanegbi, a legislation. discussed creating joint cyber teams internet. JNS.org
201-585-8080 Office
Realtorallan@yahoo.com
201-661-4940
We do not transport solid or hazardous waste
We d
$2,850,000 $3,800,000
V&N Realty 1401 Palisade Avenue Teaneck, New Jersey 07666 vera-nechama.com 201.692.3700
Jewish Standard JUNE 30, 2017 43
A P P Y F O U R T H O F J ULY
H
FIREWORK
POP PING
EALS D
at Cedar Market