Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Updated 4/28/2007
Introduction
“Do you think you can take the risks involved? Are you willing to experience all kinds of
feelings with me? Could you imagine yourself getting angry with me and us working it
out? Could you imagine yourself tolerating my frustration with your behavior and us
working it out?”
Clients need to experience a strong healthy relationship with me in order to
develop their own healthy functioning. They need to learn how to get close to me and
how to take risks with me while concurrently experiencing the absence of punishment or
abuse for those vulnerabilities. They need to see that I am not godlike, but human just
like them, and that they are worthy of my, and therefore others’, love. If they can tolerate
their anxiety and move in these directions, then they have a chance of replacing their
unhealthy internal working models with a healthier set of rules, beliefs and paradigms.
Clients can then experience a corrective emotional experience.
I believe that people are born good and by virtue of possessing life energy are
worthwhile and sacred. Unfortunately, the world not only holds millions of people upon
its surface but also holds upon it the human condition (Keating, 1992; 1992; 1999). The
human condition comprises all the action states of being and environmental conditions
that human beings find themselves in the world. Sometimes the human condition takes on
characteristics which move people toward a destructive direction. Famine, war, poverty,
discrimination, drug abuse, sexual abuse, and oppression are all part of our human
condition and when these things happen to an individual, that person is cut off from the
knowledge of him or herself as good, worthy, and sacred. Much of the therapeutic work I
do with individuals and families tries to get the person back in touch with the sacredness
and worthwhile nature of his or her being.
Clients enter therapy with me for various reasons. The addicted client decides
that his or her program for happiness, using drugs, (Keating, 1992) is no longer working
and is in fact causing more pain then relief and thus enters treatment. Other clients may
find that their perfectionism or control issues are out of control, or their symptoms of
depression are no longer minimal. Persons who have experienced trauma such as sexual
abuse or disasters come in because those feelings and memories have exhausted their
coping resources and they need resolution. I work with traumatized adopted children
because their parents are searching for a professional helper who will not sabotage their
parental power. These parents want to reach and influence their wounded children in a
positive way. They want my assistance to intervene upon their children’s negative
internal working models. Parents hope through therapy that their children will risk a
relationship with them despite the abuse of previous caretakers. They hope their children
will allow themselves to be children who have the right to have their vulnerabilities
protected by non-abusive parents. Generally speaking when the misery of not
resolving interpersonal problems becomes larger then the anxiety of facing them,
individuals wind up walking into my office.
The definition of the problem is unique in every client situation. I take time to
listen to the person’s life story and to discover what makes sense to the client and what
does not. Due to different cultural experiences and internalized culturally based belief
systems, something that might be a problem for one person and family is not a problem
4
for another. For example, I have counseled families where a child’s enuresis has caused
major difficulties, some of which is due to societal injunctions and norms. Other families
have had children who also engage in bed-wetting, but see it as a very understandable
behavior given the child’s level of trauma. Thus, the bed-wetting becomes a non-issue. I
work in team fashion so everyone involved in the therapy has important input into
problem identification.
In work with traumatized individuals and their families, I focus on both nature
and nurture issues. We explore and often celebrate the positive aspects of the individual
that came with birth. I stress the importance of one’s culture of origin in the healthy
development of personal identity and in finding the solutions to internally and externally
based conflicts. In adoptive families, I look toward the environments (nurturance) that are
in the individual’s present experience as the bridge for the person to integrate and/or
transform his or her nature (what one is born with) in order to bring about optimal health
and functioning. With adults, much of the focus is on building the nurturing environment
that was not experienced as a child but which can be safely constructed as an adult.
Assessment
Assessment also has a part in relationship building and therefore I do not ever rush this
process. Even though assessment is important, it never takes a priority over the
personhood of the client. I rarely do assessments for assessments’ sake and I always take
into consideration the cultural background of clients and how these factors can affect the
process and results of assessment (Rothbaum, Weisz, Pott, Miyake, & Morelli, 2000).
When requested by a Court, Children and Youth Services or the Department of Juvenile
Probation to do just assessment, I mandate the assessment take place over at least five
sessions as usual. I do this because I see it as my responsibility to assist the client in using
the assessment information for his or her benefit in order to get the services that have the
best chance of helping the individual. Occasionally, the assessment phase of therapy
helps me to discover that I cannot help a particular client or his or her family. I use the
assessment information then to make an appropriate referral.
Additional relationship building results from assessment in the form of debriefing
sessions for clients and then problem identification and prioritizing occur. I then work
with the client and or family to develop an operationalized treatment plan with clearly
stated goals, objectives, strategy steps, and dates for reevaluation. The treatment plan is a
contract I have with my clients and I work hard for them to see that improvements are
because of the effort they expend and not because of anything magical about me. I often
say that I am a guide that will hold the flashlight and if they wish their hand while we
explore different directions but their legs have to do the walking.
In my opinion the essential conditions for effective therapy are the following:
I work best with individuals and families who are acutely aware of their own pain
and despair. I have the gift of being able to be in close contact with another person and
his or her pain in a supportive manner. By staying present to the client, I help to facilitate
their resolution of that trauma and despair. I enjoy the challenge of helping children and
adolescents who are both survivors of severe abuse and who are offending and acting out.
A typical client profile for me is the 13 year old male or female who was abused in all
ways in the birth home, lived through five to six foster homes and is now in a foster to
adopt family situation but has begun to sexually offend on the younger siblings in the
home. Additionally, often substance abuse, fire setting, or self-mutilation is present.
I also treat severely traumatized adults who may be addicted but I have a difficult
time treating adults who are perpetrators. I find that I cannot give these adult clients a
fair chance in therapy because I tend to get impatient and frustrated with them. Many of
the clients that I work with are resistant and in truth they should be. They have
experienced oppression from multiple societal systems as well as abuse. They have been
6
Change for the good in a client’s life happens because I have been able to develop
a healthy honest relationship with the client where a number of interpersonal relationship
events take place. They are:
1. The client feels he or she can share most anything with me and not face rejection,
although unhealthy behaviors will be challenged.
2. The client feels he or she can confront me about the ways I relate to him or her
that are frustrating.
3. The client can accept from me appropriate comments and gestures of affirmation,
appreciation, and care including in some cases appropriate ethical touch (Hunter
& Struve, 1998).
4. The client has an appreciation for me and thus becomes attached and begins to
care about what I think about him or her and the behaviors of concern.
5. In experiencing from me healthy caring, support, understanding, and affirmation,
the client begins to challenge his or her own irrational beliefs. Eventually the
client begins to internalize healthier ways of viewing the self and others and
engages in healthy self- nurturance.
7
I do not know if change for the bad ever happens because I am very careful about not
intentionally hurting or abusing my clients. Certainly, the state of ‘no change’ has
occurred and the reasons for this has been:
1. I have not been able to adequately communicate to the client that a relationship
with me, although painful in the developing stages, would be well worth the
client’s time and energy and would promote the client’s healing as a person.
2. The client has been so abused and shattered by previous caretakers early in life
that there is brain damage and severe immobilizing anxiety that has produced
extraordinary guardedness.
Some behavioral changes with certain techniques can happen relatively quickly,
especially if there is an external reward to influence the client. For example the client
who is told, “Stop using drugs or else you will be incarcerated for two years,” is more
likely to change those behaviors relatively quickly. The reward is continued freedom. The
question is whether the change in the client is for the right reasons. If drug use is a
problem, the client should desire to quit using because doing so would increase the
individual’s overall level of healthy functioning and improve interpersonal relationships.
These reasons are considered internalized motivations to work in therapy as opposed to
the externalized reason of avoidance of jail. In the latter situation, the client’s external
behavior is abstinence from drugs, but the internal motivations for doing so are not there.
Treatment is part of the game to try to outsmart the judicial and other systems that are
impinging on the client’s life because of his or her irresponsible behavior. The danger in
accepting change due to external motivations is that when the carrot or external reward is
gone, the original problematic behaviors may return. Facilitating a client to change his or
her behavior so that internally his or her thoughts and feelings match up with behavioral
outcomes takes a great deal of time. Changes in self and other concept, internal working
model and issues of self-esteem, self-worth and personality changes require long-term
therapy. Although the treatment I do with most of my clients is long- term therapy, those
who put forth the effort to internalize needed changes find that a new healthier style of
living in the world emerges and endures.
1. Be the healthiest I can be in order to role model this for the client and to have the
energy needed to support the client in his or her transformation.
2. Use whatever knowledge and techniques I know to (a) facilitate a healthy
relationship with the client and (b) help the client to make healthy life changes.
Techniques
1. What is the status of the client’s attachment to me (or to the parents if a child)?
2. How am I promoting or pushing for the attachment or this relationship? What
strategies can I implement to promote a stronger relationship (i.e. non-directive
sessions so the client can have more control over session contact, increased
physical touch or proximity, interactive games that build or promote teamwork
etc.)? What am I personally doing within the therapeutic relationship that could
be hampering the client’s growth?
3. When I think about different strategies, what cultural issues for this particular
client do I need to consider? Are there cultural differences between this client and
me about the use of touch or affection, the expression of feelings etc? How
should I adjust or adapt to these cultural issues and differences?
4. What are the client’s affective, cognitive, behavioral stuck points that are
interfering within our relationship, within his or her relationships with others?
Are these stuck points due to reactions on the part of the client to external
oppressive forces such as discrimination and oppression? What appropriate
interventions can I implement to assist this client to get unstuck (i.e. journaling,
disputing of irrational beliefs, empty chair work, parts work, EMDR coaching
etc.)?
5. How is this client generalizing session learning to his or her greater community
and life outside of therapy? If generalization is happening to a high degree is the
client ready to approach termination? If generalization is happening to a low
degree, what still needs to be worked through?
My personal and professional journeys have resulted in a place and space where I
find that I am an expert on the treatment of trauma and attachment difficulties in the lives
of individuals whose ages travel across the life span. Being an expert though does not
mean that I have ‘arrived’. No one ever fully arrives in his or her lifetime because growth
and development never stops. Our lives just take on new pathways and we move in new
directions possibly just a tad bit bolder then before. I find of course, that I am still
growing. My plan is to keep doing what I have been in the way of providing services as a
clinician to clients and families who for whatever reason walk into my office. I also want
to do more research and outcome study trials so that I can provide some clarity as to what
is really helpful to children who have been so terrorized and battered in their young lives
that their spirits seem crushed and they have no effective energy to struggle once more to
build relationship. Finally I see myself someday training and supervising other
professional helpers who have the same goal as me of facilitating the attachments
between traumatized children and their adoptive families.
11
References
Bandura, A. (1974). Behavior theory and the models of man. American Psychologist, 29,
859-869.
Bean, B., & Bennett, S. (1993). A guide for teen survivors: The me nobody knows. New
York: Lexington Books.
Courtois, C. (1988). Healing the incest wound: Adult survivors in therapy. New York:
W. W. Norton.
Dinkmeyer, D., & McKay, G. (1990). Systematic training for effective parenting:
Parenting teenagers. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
Einon, D. (1985). Play with a purpose: Learning games for children six weeks to ten
years. New York: Pantheon Books.
Federici, R. (1998). Help for the hopeless child: A guide for families. Alexandria,
VA: Federaci and Associates.
Framo, J. (1992). Family of origin therapy: An intergenerational approach. New York:
Brunner/Mazel.
Freeman-Longo, R., Bays, L., & Bear, E. (1996). Empathy and compassionate action,
issues and exercises: A guided workbook for clients in treatment. Brandon, VT:
Safer Society Press.
Garbarino, J. (1993). Let’s talk about living in a world with violence. Chicago, IL:
Erikson Institute.
Glasser, W. (1975). Reality therapy: A new approach to psychiatry. New York: Harper
and Row.
Glaser, W. (1981). Stations of the mind: New directions for reality therapy. New York:
Harper and Row.
Hage, D. (1997). Therapeutic parenting: It’s a matter of attitude. Silverthorne, CO:
Parenting with Pizazz Publications.
Hage, D. (1999). Me and my volcano. Silverthorne, CO: Parenting with Pizazz
Publications.
Hughes, D. (1997). Facilitating developmental attachment. Northvale, NJ: Jason
Aronson.
Hunter, M., & Sturve, J. (1998). The ethical use of touch in psychotherapy. Thousands
Oaks, CA: Sage.
James, B. (1994). Handbook for treatment of attachment-trauma problems in children.
New York: Lexington Books.
Jernberg, A., & Booth, P. (1999). Theraplay: Helping parents and children build better
relationships through attachment- based play. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Johnson, S. (1996). The practice of emotionally focused couple therapy: Creating
connections. New York: Guilford Press.
Johnson, S. (2005). Emotionally focused couple therapy with trauma survivors:
Strengthening attachment bonds. New York: Guilford Press.
Johnson, S. & Whiffen, V. (Eds.) (2003). Attachment processes in couple and family
therapy. New York: Guilford Press.
Keating, T. (1992). Open mind, open heart: the contemplative dimension of the gospel.
Rockport, MA: Element Press.
Keating, T. (1992) Invitation to love: The way of Christian contemplation. Rockport,
12