Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract—The advantages of adjustable speed hydroelectric dynamic response of the adjustable speed hydro plant was
generation have been highlighted by several authors. The characterized, it was detected the need of using intelligent
optimum speed for actual working conditions must be methods such as artificial neural networks to generate the
continuously adjusted by means of an appropriate control optimum speed that maximizes the turbine efficiency,
system. This process gives rise to dynamic changes in operation
variables. In this paper an Artificial Neural Network is used to
depending on the hydraulic operating point.
generate the reference speed that optimises the turbine The aim of this paper is to present an artificial neural
efficiency. The main results of measurements on a test loop network used to implement an optimum speed module used
with an axial-flow turbine are reported. in adjustable speed hydro plants. In the first section
conventional linear models, along with a proposed non-
I. INTRODUCTION linear approach, are presented. In the second section, the
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA. Downloaded on August 03,2010 at 15:47:02 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
the coefficients depend on each operating point. reduction, for a constant net head H. This can be avoided by
adjusting the turbine speed so that the operating point moves
B. Non-linear approach
from (A) to (C). This one is the key characteristic of variable
An empirical and non-linear model of a Francis turbine speed operation.
has been derived by applying both the kinetic momentum
theorem (2) and the principle of energy conservation (3).
Two equations – first of which is the so-called Euler
1.1
50.0º
47.5º
equation – are obtained as a result of its application to the 1
40.0º
42.5º
45.0º
Q I (m 3 /s )
17.5º
0.6
15.0º
90
12.5º 89 .0
H = H u + ∆H 1 + ∆H 2 , (3)
0.5
88
10.0º 87 .0 6 .0
8 8 5 84
where:
0.4
7.5º
∆H 1 = C1 ⋅ Q 2 , (4)
0.3
5.0º
(C) (B)
0.2
2.5º
∆H 2 = C 2 (Q − Qn1 )2 ,
0.1
(5) 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
nI (r.p.m.)
65 70 75 80 85
3
Francis
H • Fixing flow and gate angle, a curve is obtained, giving
Turbine
alpha the efficiency as a function of runner speed
nD1 Q
nI = QI = (7)
H D12 H
Fig. 3. Evaluating optimum speed for α=constant and Q=constant.
At fixed speed operation, an input flow variation involves
an important decrease in efficiency. The turbine operating
point follows a trajectory over the plane unit speed-unit flow • Finally, the value of the speed that allows a maximum
similar to that superimposed over the turbine hill charts in efficiency is evaluated.
Fig 2. As it can be seen there, the efficiency decreases
substantially with respect to its initial value. The operating
point moves from (A) to (B) in response to an input flow
4105
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA. Downloaded on August 03,2010 at 15:47:02 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
For a complete model simulation, conventional OSM has The proposed conventional OSM Module operates
been integrated in a SIMULINK® block as shown in Fig. 4. correctly during the simulation, but is inefficient due to the
Their inputs are gate angle and turbine flow and its output is inclusion of several FOR-END loops. These loops are
the optimum rotational speed. continuously evaluated for each step of the SIMULINK®
solver, so the simulation becomes slower. Table I presents
1
the execution times for a 50 seconds of simulation interval
Q, of the complete model. If the OSM module is implemented
turbine
flow
MATLAB
Function
1 in MATLAB®, it last 474 seconds. If an ANN is used, the
2 OSM Module
Optimum speed execution time is reduced about 20 times, lasting 21 seconds.
alpha,
gate angle
1 350
wm
pu->rpm
Terminator1 Current
v s_abc
Active
lwk
Q POWER
Measurements Reactive
POWER
pu >rpm
Reference
Fig. 5. Optimum Speed Module (OSM) MATLAB-SIMULINK® Head
A S Y N C H R O N O U S
R E G E N E R A T IV E 50 s. 474 s. 21 s.
F O R E B A Y C O N V E R T E R E L E C T R IC
M A C H IN E
E L E V A T IO N G R ID
S E N S O R
O W
F L
R
T E
W A
P E N S T O C K
generated speed changes abruptly. This optimum speed is
S H A F T
used as a reference speed for the turbine-induction generator,
controlled by a conventional PID that modifies the supply
R
F L
O W
W A
T E
R
F L
O W
frequency of the regenerative converter, needed to adapt the
T E
W A
W IC K E T turbine speed to its optimum value.
G A T E S
F R A N C IS
C O N T R O L These small steps introduced in the optimum speed
T U R B IN E
generated by the conventional OSM, affect to the rest of the
Fig. 6. Variable speed hydro plant.block. dynamic system variables. This effect can be observed in the
rotor speed of the induction generator and the active power
This model comprises the behaviour of both the electrical generated, as shown in Fig. 8.
system (Fig. 7a), including electromagnetic and An Artificial Neural Network (ANN) was suggested to
electromechanical inertial dynamics, and the hydraulic solve these disadvantages. This ANN will learn the
system (Fig. 7b), including fore bay, penstock and turbine relationship between inputs and output of the conventional
dynamics. OSM module, smoothing the generated optimum speed.
4106
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA. Downloaded on August 03,2010 at 15:47:02 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
[
x k +1 = x k − J T J + µI ]−1
JT e , (10)
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA. Downloaded on August 03,2010 at 15:47:02 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
In Fig. 10 a diagram of the test loop is shown. Due to
limitations in the test loop, the net head is modified through
a change in the pump speed. This pump is operated by a
variable speed drive. Thus, the net head applied to the
turbine varies accordingly. The turbine and the
asynchronous machine turn at the same speed, its value
being very close to the synchronous speed. Thus it may be
changed by the regenerative converter by adjusting the
frequency in the stator side. In that way, a variable-head,
variable-speed turbine results. Once the pump and turbine
speeds are kept fixed, the discharge through the turbine is
determined by the hydraulic characteristics of this machine
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA. Downloaded on August 03,2010 at 15:47:02 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Both Neural Networks are of the type multilayer- The used frequency converter must be able to operate
perceptron. The first one has 2 neurons in the input layer, 8 within the frequency limits imposed by the optimal turbine
neurons in the hidden layer and 1 output neuron determining speed variations. In this case, assuming that the synchronous
the estimated pump speed. The second ANN has a similar speed were 1000 rpm, the required range of frequency
structure with 1 neuron in the input layer, 5 neurons in the variation would be (+ 30% , - 10%).
hidden layer and 1 neuron in the output layer, giving the
optimal value of the turbine speed.
Fig. 12 shows the response of the first Neural Network
and its good agreement with experimental data.
Fig. 12. Response of the Neural Network “PUMP SPEED” x: VII. CONCLUSIONS
measured points; ¡ : ANN response (the turbine speed is fixed at
1200 r.p.m.) During the development of a dynamic model of a
variable-speed hydro plant, an original and novel optimum
speed module (OSM) has been developed. This module
The output of this ANN is considered as an estimation of
the system state, which is used by the second Neural generates an optimum speed value from the gate position
Network to determine the turbine speed giving the highest and the turbine flow.
The used algorithm generates a stepped reference
efficiency. Fig. 13 presents the results for the tested system.
optimum speed that introduces some oscillatory behaviour
on the rotor speed, active power and torque. In order to
smooth the response, an interpolating artificial neural
network has been designed.
In order to prove the feasibility of the complete system, a
modified of the proposed OSM-ANN has been implemented,
using MATLAB-SIMULINK® and a data acquisition board,
in a small laboratory facility, where ccommercial frequency
converters have been used. This OSM-ANN has been
developed to adjust automatically turbine speed to the
existing operating conditions. The experimental results
confirm the improvements obtained in the turbine efficiency
when the turbine speed is continuously adjusted depending
on the hydraulic conditions.
Fig. 13. Optimal turbine speed as a function of system state: + ANN
response;--: interpolated response. APPENDIX
It is clearly shown that for high values of the gross head The notation used throughout this paper is stated as
(represented here by the pump speed) the turbine speed follows:
should be adjusted in the range of 1300 rpm; while for low
heads the optimum efficiency of the turbine is reached when
its speed approximates the value of 900 rpm. Obviously, Turbine model parameters
there exists a smooth transition between both regions. ∆Pmech
Turbine mechanical power variation [p.u.]
The dependence of efficiency vs. turbine speed for each
∆α Gate angle variation [p.u.]
pump speed is shown in Fig. 14. The line detached on the
surface links the optimum efficiency points.
4109
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA. Downloaded on August 03,2010 at 15:47:02 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Tw granted a student to collaborate in this research.
Water starting time [s]
Hu REFERENCES
Useful head [m]
[1] Kundur, P., Power System Stability and Control. Mc Graw-Hill, 1994.
U1 [2] IEEE Working Group Report, “Hydraulic Turbine and Turbine
Peripheral speed of the runner blades at the
Control Models for System Dynamic Studies”, IEEE Transaction on
water inlet point [m/s] Power Systems, Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 167-179, February 1992.
U2 [3] Vournas, C. D., “Second Order Hydraulic Turbine Models for
Peripheral speed of the runner blades at the Multimachine Stability Studies”, IEEE Transactions on Energy
water outlet point [m/s] Conversion, Vol. 5, No. 2, pp. 239- 244, June 1990.
[4] Status report on variable speed operation in Small Hydropower,
Vu1 Available: (January 2006):
Peripheral speed of the water at the water inlet
http://europa.eu.int/comm/energy/res/sectors/small_hydro_disseminati
point [m/s] on_en.htm
Vu 2 [5] Wilhelmi, J.R., Fraile-Ardanuy, J., Fraile-Mora, J., Íñigo, L.
Peripheral speed of the water at the water outlet “Adjustable speed hydro generation” in Proc. of the International
point [m/s] Conference on Renewable Energy and Power Quality, ICREPQ’2003,
Vigo (Spain), paper nº 360, April 2003.
S1 Water inlet area [m2] [6] Fraile-Ardanuy, J., Wilhelmi, J.R, Fraile-Mora, Íñigo, L. “A neural
controller for an adjustable speed hydro generator” in Proc. 8
β1 Runner blades angle at the water inlet area [rad] Congresso Luso-Espanhol de Engenharia Electrotécnica. Vol. 3, pp.
6273-6278, Vilamoura (Portugal), July, 2003.
∆H 1
Friction energy losses [m] [7] Fraile-Ardanuy, J., J. R. Wilhelmi, J. Fraile-Mora, J. I. Pérez and I.
Sarasúa, “A dynamic model of adjustable speed hydro plants”, in Proc.
∆H 2 9 Congreso Hispano Luso de Ingeniería Eléctrica (9CHLIE), paper
Energy losses caused by the sudden diversion
number 321, Marbella (Spain), July 2005.
prompted by the impact with the runner blades [8] Fraile-Ardanuy, J., J. I. Pérez, I. Sarasúa, J. R. Wilhelmi and J. Fraile-
[m] Mora, “Speed control of run-of-river variable speed hydro plants”, in
Proc. of the International Conference on Renewable Energy and Power
Qn1
Water flow that makes the second losses term, Quality, ICREPQ’2006, Mallorca(Spain), to be published, April 2006.
[9] Fraile-Ardanuy, J., J. I. Pérez, I. Sarasúa, J. R. Wilhelmi and J. Fraile-
∆H 2
, equal to zero [m3/s] Mora, “Variable Speed Hydro Generation: Operational Aspects and
Control”, IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, to be published.
c1 , c 2 [10] Vallarino, E. and M. Delgado Fernández, Obras Hidráulicas. III
Losses coefficients empirically obtained Maquinaria. Madrid: Editorial Publicaciones de la ETSI de Caminos,
[adimensional] Canales y Puertos, 1974.
nI [11] Hagan, M. T., H. B. Demuth and M. Beale. Neural Network Design,
Unit speed [r.p.m.] Boston: PWS Publishing Company, 1996.
QI [12] Hagan, M. T. and M. Menhaj. “Training feedforward networks with
Unit flow [m3/s] the Marquardt algorithm”, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks,
n Turbine speed [r.p.m.] Vol. 5, No. 6, pp. 989-993, 1994.
[13] Scales, L. E. Introduction to Non-Linear Optimization, New York:
Springer-Verglag, 1985.
ANN parameters
J Jacobian matrix containing first derivatives of
network errors with respect to network
parameters [adimensional]
e Network errors vector [adimensional]
xk
Network parameters vector [adimensional]
µ Adjustable parameter to be updated after each
successful iteration step [adimensional]
Simulation parameters
a, b Adjustable parameters used to fix both the
initial position and the slope of the smooth
change applied to the fore bay elevation.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The Polytechnic University of Madrid has supported this
work within its Interdisciplinary Research Programme
number AM0104. Fundación Agustín de Betancourt has
4110
Authorized licensed use limited to: UNIVERSITY TEKNOLOGI MALAYSIA. Downloaded on August 03,2010 at 15:47:02 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.