Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
This paper was prepared for presentation at the Offshore Technology Conference held in Houston, Texas, USA, 30 April3 May 2012.
This paper was selected for presentation by an OTC program committee following review of information contained in an abstract submitted by the author(s). Contents of the paper have not been
reviewed by the Offshore Technology Conference and are subject to correction by the author(s). The material does not necessarily reflect any position of the Offshore Technology Conference, its
officers, or members. Electronic reproduction, distribution, or storage of any part of this paper without the written consent of the Offshore Technology Conference is prohibited. Permission to
reproduce in print is restricted to an abstract of not more than 300 words; illustrations may not be copied. The abstract must contain conspicuous acknowledgment of OTC copyright.
Abstract
This paper provides insights and interpretations regarding the use of API RP 2A-WSD 22nd Edition. In 2010, OTC
paper #20837 discussed modifications being made to and reasons behind the changes to API 2A-WSD in conjunction with
other new API standards, 2MET, 2EQ, 2SIM and 2GEO and the elimination of API Bulletins 2INT-MET, 2INT-DG and
2INT-EX. In this paper, emphasis is placed on use of the 22nd Edition in combination with the other new standards.
General
API RP 2A-WSD 22nd Edition was balloted in 2011 and approved by 96% of the votes cast. There were over 339
individual comments (the vast majority editorial) with some 21 still in final resolution by API TG13 at the time this paper was
written. This has resulted in the API RP 2A-WSD 22nd Edition final table of contents to include the following (with reference
to the 21st Edition Section in parentheses):
Section 1: Scope
Section 2: Normative References
Section 3: Terms, Definitions and Acronyms
Section 4: Planning (21st Edition Section 1)
Section 5: Design Criteria and Procedures (21st Edition Section 2)
Section 6: Structural Steel Design (21st Edition Section 3)
Section 7: Strength of Tubular Joints (21st Edition Section 4)
Section 8: Fatigue (21st Edition Section 5)
Section 9: Foundation Design (21st Edition Section 6)
Section 10: Other Structural Components and Systems (21st Edition Section 7)
Section 11: Material (21st Edition Section 8)
Section 12: Drawings and Specifications (21st Edition Section 9)
Section 13: Welding (21st Edition Section 10)
Section 14: Fabrication (21st Edition Section 11)
Section 15: Installation (21st Edition Section 12)
Section 16: Inspection (21st Edition Section 13)
Section 17: Accidental Loading (21st Edition Section 18)
Section 18: Reuse (21st Edition Section 15)
Section 19: Minimum and Special Structures (21st Edition Section 16)
Annex A (Informative): API 2A-WSD 21st Edition vs. 22nd Edition Cross-reference
Annex B (Informative): Commentary
Bibliography
Changes from OTC paper #20837 and specific topics of importance in using the new API Standards are discussed below.
2 OTC 23558
Normative References
API 2As Section 2 contains all Normative References, i.e. standards that shall be followed as they apply. They are
called out in name only, e.g. API 2MET, in the text without a specific reference number. All API normative references are
undated, so the latest edition of the referenced document including any addenda/errata shall apply. Special attention is drawn
to the following with regard to two of the non-API normative references:
The 1989 edition of the AISC Specification for Structural Steel Buildings is included as a normative reference. ASD
(Allowable Strength Design) was still supported by AISC in this edition and is applicable. Load and resistance
factors (LRFD) in later editions of this AISC specification are based on calibration with building design practices and
may not be applicable to offshore platforms. Research work is now in progress to incorporate strength provisions of
the new AISC specification into offshore design practices.
In API 2A, reference is made to AWS D1.1/D.1.M:2006 Structural Welding Code Steel. While use of this edition
of D1.1 is endorsed; the primary intent is that the AWS code be followed for welding and fabrication of fixed
offshore platforms. However, where specific guidance is given in the 22nd edition of API 2A, the 2A guidance should
take precedence. Past editions of the AWS D1.1 have contained some significant modifications in conflict with those
in API 2A. Reference to a specific D1.1 edition where exceptions are already included in 2A protects against
possible future conflicting modification.
Planning
Section 4.7 of API 2A contains updated and new guidance for determining the Exposure Category that will be used
in selecting the required level of design criteria for fixed offshore platforms. Life safety exposure categories are now labeled
S-1 (manned-nonevacuated), S-2 (manned-evacuated) and S-3 (unmanned). Similarly, consequence of failure exposure
categories are now labeled C-1 (high), C-2 (medium) and C-3 (low). New and different symbols for each type of exposure
are used in the 22nd Edition to address user feedback and help avoid the many reported incidents of confusion in and conflicts
with the final selected platform exposure category label of L-#.
Table 1 attached presents the complete Exposure Category Matrix from Table 4.1 in API 2A-WSD 22nd Edition. For
clarity and to help explain to users applying API 2A on platforms in parts of the U.S. other than the GoM and other parts of the
world, note a at the bottom of the table has been expanded to describe when the design criteria for the GoM contained in
Section 5 is applicable to a manned-nonevacuated platform (winter storms, sudden hurricanes and earthquakes).
Earthquake
Design loading conditions for earthquakes are outlined in Section 5.3.6 of API 2A 22nd Edition. Strength
requirements are checked at the extreme level earthquake (ELE) and ductility requirements at the abnormal level earthquake
(ALE) as defined in API 2EQ. The (ELE) was the strength level earthquake (SLE) and the ALE was the ductility level
earthquake (DLE) in the API 2A-WSD, 21st Edition and earlier.
Fatigue
Twenty-second Edition users are reminded that Simplified Fatigue has been removed from the commentary (Annex
B), with references removed from Section 18 Reuse and Section 19 Minimum and Special Structures. This decision was
necessary because API 2MET has now defined the GoM to have three separate regions. To maintain Simplified Fatigue API
would have to maintain the 21st Edition extreme wave criteria in API 2MET or include it in the 22nd Edition commentary. This
was felt to be too confusing and could possibly increase user error. All new and reused structures are now required to have a
detailed fatigue analysis.
Installation
API 2MOP Recommended Practice for Marine Operations, ISO 19901-6:2009 (Identical) was issued in July, 2010.
It is now a normative reference in the 22nd Edition. It provides alternate dynamic load factors for marine lifting operations,
plus additional details for planning, designing, performing and documenting loadout, transport, launching and marine lifting
operations.
Surveys
As noted in OTC paper #20675, the entire section on inplace surveys and its commentary from the 21st Edition have
been moved to and expanded on in the new API 2SIM. Because API 2A-WSD 22nd Edition is for new offshore platforms, the
move of the information on surveys of existing platforms goes well in hand with the creation of the new structural integrity
management standard. Further information regarding the use of API 2SIM can be found in OTC paper #23559.
Assessment
As noted in OTC paper #20675, the entire section on existing platform assessment and its commentary from the 21st
Edition has been moved to, updated and expanded on in the new API 2SIM. Because API 2A-WSD 22nd Edition is for new
offshore platforms, the move of the information on assessment of existing platforms goes well in hand with the creation of the
4 OTC 23558
new structural integrity management standard. However, as noted above, API 2SIM is referenced directly in the 22nd Edition
for procedures regarding ultimate strength robustness checks and wave in deck loading. Further information regarding the use
of API 2SIM can be found in OTC paper #23559.
Reuse
The 22nd Edition continues to maintain that any reused platform must meet the requirements of a new platform with
special considerations provided to account for allowances for fatigue damage experienced at the original platform location. It
has been reported that some regulatory agencies have applied the reuse section for platform requalification and/or change in
loading/use on existing platforms. This was and still is an incorrect application of the reuse section. Any platform
requalification and/or change in loading/use on existing platforms should refer to API 2SIM.
Annex A (informative) API 2A-WSD 21st Edition vs. 22nd Edition Cross-reference
As noted in OTC paper # 20837, to assist in the use of the API 2A-WSD 22nd Edition, Annex A has been included to
provide a detailed cross reference between API 2A 21st Editions Figure, Table and Equation numbers and their new numbers
in the 22nd Edition or their new location in either API 2MET, API 2EQ, API 2GEO, API 2SIM or API 2FB.
B4 - Commentary on Planning
B5 - Commentary on Design Criteria and Procedures
B6 - Commentary on Structural Steel Design
B7 - Commentary on Strength of Tubular Joints
B8 - Commentary on Fatigue
B10 - Commentary on Other Structural Components and Systems
B11 - Commentary on Material
B13 - Commentary on Welding
B17 - Commentary on Accidental Loading
B19 - Commentary on Minimum and Special Structures
Bibliography
In past editions of API 2A-WSD, references were provided either in the text or at the end of the subsection in which
they were referenced. In the 22nd Edition, all non-normative references (including the numerous references from the
commentary) are located in the bibliography. They are directly referred to as Reference [#] in the text or indirectly as a
superscript [#] following referenced text.
Summary
This paper provides insights and interpretations regarding the use of API RP 2A-WSD 22nd Edition with the other new API
standards, 2MET, 2EQ, 2SIM, 2GEO and API 2MOP. Highlighted is how to use the new standards together with every
reasonable effort having been made to smooth the transition from the 21st to the 22nd edition.
The present schedule is for API to complete incorporating ballot comments into all new RP2s by mid 2012. The API RP 2A-
WSD 22nd Edition will likely be published by 3Q 2012.
The 22nd Edition is still planned to be the last edition of RP 2A-WSD. Subsequent editions of RP 2A will take the form of
modified adoptions of corresponding ISO documents and as such will conform to the load and resistance factor design (LRFD)
philosophy.
Acknowledgments
The authors wish to thank the entire API TG 13 for their diligence and care in conducting the many necessary reviews,
addressing the ballot comments and performing the modifications to complete the 22nd Edition. TG 13 members include:
Mike Abbas, Atlas Engineering; Frank Buescher, Casbarian Engineering; Kris Digre (Vice Chair/Secretary), API Consultant;
Abdel Ghoneim, DNV; Rudy Hall, Ralph Shaw, and Gwen Accardo, Keystone Engineering; Jay Hooper, Upstream
Engineering/Audubon Engineering; Hyungwoo Kim, Shell; David Stockard, Fluor; Boon Sze Tan, J. Ray McDermott
Eng/ConocoPhillips; Ben Chang, J. Ray McDermott Eng; Farrel Zwerneman (Chair), Mustang Engineering.
References
American Petroleum Institute, Recommended Practice for Structural Integrity Management of Fixed Offshore Structures, API RP 2SIM,
First Edition.
OTC 23558 5
American Petroleum Institute, Recommended Practice for Planning, Designing and Constructing Fixed Offshore Platforms Working
Stress Design, API RP 2A-WSD, Twenty-First Edition, Errata and Supplement 3, October 2007.
American Petroleum Institute, Recommended Practice for Derivation of Metocean Design and Operating Conditions, API RP 2MET, First
Edition.
American Petroleum Institute, Recommended Practice for Earthquake Loading in US Offshore Areas, API RP 2EQ, First Edition.
American Petroleum Institute, Recommended Practice for Soil and Foundation Considerations in Offshore Areas, API RP 2GEO, First
Edition.
American Petroleum Institute, Specification for Offshore Pedestal Mounted Cranes, API Spec 2C.
American Petroleum Institute, Recommended Practice for Design of Offshore Facilities Against Fire and Blast Loading API RP 2FB,
Latest Edition.
American Petroleum Institute, Recommended Practice for Marine Operations, API RP 2MOP, First Edition, ISO 19901-6:2009 (Identical).
American Institute of Steel Construction, Specification for Structural Steel Buildings Allowable Stress Design and Plastic Design, June 1,
1989 Included in AISC Manual of Steel Construction, Allowable Stress Design, 9th Edition, 1989.
American Welding Society, Structural Welding Code Steel, AWS D1.1/D1.1M 2006.
Zwerneman, F. J. and Digre, K. A. 22nd Edition of API RP 2A Recommended Practice for Planning, Designing and Constructing Fixed
Offshore Platforms Working Stress Design, OTC 20837, Proceedings of Offshore Technology Conference, Houston, Texas, May
2010.
Stear, James D., "RP 2MET: An API Standard for Metocean", OTC 20693, Proceedings of Offshore Technology Conference, Houston,
Texas, May 2010.
Stear, James D., "Use of RP 2MET Annex Gulf Metocean Conditions with 2A and 2SIM", OTC 23459, Proceedings of Offshore
Technology Conference, Houston, Texas, May 2012.
S. DeFranco, P. OConnor, F. Puskar, J. Bucknell, and K. Digre "API RP 2SIM: Recommended Practice for Structural Integrity
Management", OTC 20675, Proceedings of Offshore Technology Conference, Houston, Texas, May 2010.
DeFranco, S. J., "API RP 2SIM: Offshore Structures Integrity Management", OTC 23559, Proceedings of Offshore Technology Conference,
Houston, Texas, May 2012.
Table 1
nd
API 2A 22 Edition Exposure Category Matrix
ConsequenceCategory
*M
Table 2 from API 2MET Draft t
OTC 23558 7
Table 3
nd
API 2A 22 Edition Design Level Criteria and Robustness Analysis
Exposure
DesignLevelCriteria RobustnessLevelAnalysis
Category
Fig