7/24/2017 The Politics of Numbers | Newsline

APRIL ISSUE
2017

(http://newslinemagazine.com/)

The Politics of Numbers

(/#facebook) (/#twitter)

(https://www.addtoany.com/share#url=http%3A%2F%2Fnewslinemagazine.com%2Fmagazine%2Fthe-politics-of-
numbers%2F&title=The%20Politics%20of%20Numbers)

By Ali Arqam (http://newslinemagazine.com/contributor/ali-arqam/) | Newsbeat National (http://newslinemagazine.com/cats/newsbeat-

national/) | Published 3 months ago

Like One person likes this. Sign Up to see what your friends like.

http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-politics-of-numbers/ 1/6
7/24/2017 The Politics of Numbers | Newsline

IN THIS ISSUE

Pakistani soldiers and ocials from the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics collect information from transgender residents

After a great deal of dithering by two successive governments, the sixth Population and Housing Census finally saw its
onset in March, under a cloud of scepticism: political parties continued to accuse each other of manipulating statistics to
gain political leverage.

In a Supreme Court hearing of the suo moto notice regarding the delay in holding a census, the federal government
forewarned that the provinces could manipulate the process if the armed forces did not get involved. Sindh and
Balochistan-based parties also expressed their concern regarding various aspects of the headcount and house-listing
process. While none of the political players in Sindh are opposed to the census, they have been desperately trying to
highlight their concerns, in an attempt to improve the process. Sindhi nationalist groups, community-based organisations
and other social platforms have conducted a mass-awareness campaign across rural and urban districts in Sindh. Owing
to the demographic changes and internal migrations, there are concerns that Sindhs indigenous population could become
a minority on its own turf. According to experts, such apprehensions carry weight because critical evaluations have
revealed that more than five million people in Sindh were left out of the 1998 census.

The ruling Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), and major stakeholders in the urban districts of Sindh, such as the Muttahida
Qaumi Movement Pakistan (MQM-P) have knocked on the judiciarys door. From the PPP, Senator Farhatullah Babar
filed a petition in the Sindh High Court, while the MQM-P has approached the Supreme Court of Pakistan through a joint
petition signed by 11 members.

It was former Chief Minister Qaim Ali Shah who championed the cause, and he was the most vocal in the demand for a
census in the meetings of the Council of Common Interests (CCI). He termed it a matter of life and death for Sindh. The
leadership of the Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz (PML-N) has still not developed the ability to reach a decision through
institutional processes, despite it being a constitutional requirement. Whereas the federal government is expected to call
meetings of the CCI on a quarterly basis, these have not been held as required in the PML-Ns current tenure. The chief

http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-politics-of-numbers/ 2/6
7/24/2017 The Politics of Numbers | Newsline

minister of any province has the authority to call a meeting of the CCI, but Qaim Ali Shah complained that despite several
requests from him, the meeting had not been held. In the CCI meeting last year in March, the census was put on the
agenda after much hesitation, but only under the condition that it would not be held without the help of the armed forces.
They meanwhile, happened to be busy with Operation Zarb-e-Azb, and could not provide the necessary support. Thus, it
was concluded that the census should be delayed even further. Then came the suo moto notice of the delay from the
Supreme Court last year, and the federal government was forced to give exact dates, and make arrangements for holding
the census in March 2017.

Pakistani soldiers escort ocials from the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics

The Sindh cabinet came to know, through a briefing by NADRA officials in January 2017, that 30 per cent of the adults in
Sindh do not possess computerised identity cards. The chief minister instructed NADRA officials to accelerate the process
of issuing CNICs, and to send more mobile teams for this purpose, to the remote areas, but the paucity of time made it
impossible to complete this process. Thereafter, the federal government agreed to the chief ministers demand that in the
case of those who did not possess CNICs, any document of identity should be accepted. Murad Ali Shah has also
established a census complaint cell, so people can directly lodge their complaints regarding the census operations. He has
also asked the federal government to release some of the census data, such as the number of people and houses in
particular blocks, as withholding this information would rouse peoples suspicions. Another aspect of the census debate in
Sindh was the demand from all those living in the province, that they be allowed to list Sindhi as their mother tongue. The
demand came from Sindhi nationalist groups, and was later echoed by others. Sindh United Party leader, Jalal Mehmood
Shah said that all those living in Sindh were Sindhis; therefore, every one of them, whatever language they spoke, should
mention Sindhi as their mother tongue to prove that their loyalty was with this province. In a video message on social
networking sites, Baseer Naveed, a prominent journalist and member of the Asian Human Rights Commission, echoed his
support for this demand and asked all members of civil society to list Sindhi as their mother language, regardless of their
ethnicity. While one can empathise with such demands on account of the fears induced by demographic shifts, the whole
idea of a census is to gather facts, to obtain an accurate picture. Asking people to fill in the wrong details to support a
political standpoint defeats the whole purpose of the census.

http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-politics-of-numbers/ 3/6
7/24/2017 The Politics of Numbers | Newsline

In a speech in January, Maula Bux Chandio had also asked the Urdu-speaking inhabitants of Sindh to express their
association with the province by listing Sindhi as their mother tongue in the census form. This demand was vociferously
opposed by MQM supporters whose political premise is built on ethnic lines. PPP members gave another twist to this
mother language debate when provincial minister Manzoor Wassan, in a cabinet meeting, said that only six religions and
10 languages were reflected in the census form, while Zoroastrians and their languages, such as Gujrati and Kathiawari,
were not mentioned. The chief minister said that Gujarati was the mother tongue of the father of the nation, Muhammad
Ali Jinnah, and should have been included in the census form. He said that he would take up this issue with the federal
government.

As might have been expected, the debate then went down the familiar path of the rural-urban divide in Sindh, and
resuscitated the age-old narrative which serves the purpose of two major political players the PPP and the MQM. Each
party invokes fear of the intentions of the other among their support base. The MQM has been promising its supporters
that the census, if conducted in a proper manner, will increase their representation in the assemblies, as the existing
composition is allegedly an inaccurate reflection of reality. Certainly, constituencies in Karachi, in terms of the number of
registered votes and section of the population they represent, are too big and unwieldy, as compared to other parts of
Sindh, or any other city in Pakistan. The MQM vows it will get an Urdu-speaking chief minister elected, while spewing
prejudice through the mantra-like assertion, Now you wont be ruled by a feudal coming from interior Sindh.

This rhetoric serves the MQM, old and rechristened, while reinvigorating the PPP, which poses as the guardian of rural
Sindh despite its lacklustre performance and poor track record.

http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-politics-of-numbers/ 4/6
7/24/2017 The Politics of Numbers | Newsline

The PBS Imbroglio

The Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (PBS) was established in 2011 under the General Statistics (Reorganisation) Act
2011, through the merger of the Federal Bureau of Statistics, the Population Census Organisation, the Agriculture
Census Organisation and the Technical Wing of Statistics Division. Its mandate comprises conducting population,
housing, and agriculture censuses.

The PBS has been at the centre of controversy since its inception. Its legal status is questionable, and it has been
run for years without any fixed rules or procedures. It violates the criteria set by the General Statistics
(Reorganisation) Act 2011 when making appointments for different positions. The composition of its governing
council is not proportionate to the weight held by each province. To top it all off, its track record in the last six
years has been dismal. In 2011, when the PPP government decided to conduct a census, the newly-established PBS
was tasked with conducting a house count across the country. The manner in which this was conducted led to
objections, and the statistics were deemed controversial due to reports of anomalies in Sindh, Punjab, and
Balochistan. The Chief Census Commissioner, Habibullah Khattak, acknowledged these discrepancies, and the
questions that were raised over the veracity of the entire exercise lead to a delay of the process. Khattak criticised
the lower staff, while political parties blamed the provincial government. Interestingly, none of the higher officials
of the PBS were held accountable for this negligence and waste of funds.

In September 2016, Assistant Attorney, General Waqar Rana, submitted a fresh report on behalf of the PBS during
a suo moto hearing by the Supreme Court on the delay of the census. The report stipulated that the house-listing
operation held in 2011 was manipulated to exaggerate the census results in favour of particular ethnic groups, and
to benefit political parties that relied on ethnic divides for political support. The Population and Housing Census
data forms the basis for political representation at the centre and in the provinces, and determines the share in
national resources. These factors point to the interests of the provinces and ethnic groups in the census and how
they would like to influence the process to their advantage, stated the report, suggesting that only the army could
ensure transparency.

In the end, PBS, an institution that was established for the sole purpose of conducting the census had to concede
that it was not capable of working independently. It had to shift the burden onto the shoulders of another
institution the armed forces.

(/#facebook) (/#twitter)

(https://www.addtoany.com/share#url=http%3A%2F%2Fnewslinemagazine.com%2Fmagazine%2Fthe-politics-of-
numbers%2F&title=The%20Politics%20of%20Numbers)

Ali Arqam main domain is Karachi: Its politics, security and law and order

Next (http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-revenge-of-the-poor/)

WEB (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/WEB/) MAGAZINE (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/MAGAZINES/)

FILMS (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/NEWSLINE-FILMS/)

SUBSCRIBE (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/REGISTER/)

http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-politics-of-numbers/ 5/6
7/24/2017 The Politics of Numbers | Newsline

(https://www.facebook.com/NewslineMagazine) (https://twitter.com/newslinemag) (https://www.instagram.com/)

Powered by Grocode (http://grocode.co)

ABOUT (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/ABOUT/) PRIVACY (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/PRIVACY-POLICY/)

ADVERTISE (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/ADVERTISE/) CONTACT (HTTP://NEWSLINEMAGAZINE.COM/CONTACT/)

http://newslinemagazine.com/magazine/the-politics-of-numbers/ 6/6