Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
2
ABSTRACT
The built environment at some hospitals in The purpose of this master thesis is to explore how Three scales in which I as an architect can approach
emerging contexts are inadequate for delivering on an architect can apply the concept of a sustainable the project in different roles was identified. In each
the human right to health which includes the access and healthy hospital design in the international scale a design proposal was developed through
to quality healthcare in an environment free from development sector by taking different roles in an immersive design process on site in Kolandoto
factors causing illness or poor health. This is the a concrete development project. The goal is to and in close collaboration with the hospital
case at Kolandoto Hospital in Tanzania, a district show feasible designs for peoples health, for a management. I was a planner, process leader and
hospital with a large outpatient department and 168 healthy environment and for a healthy approach hospital environment specialist when creating a
inpatient beds for medical and surgical treatments. to development. Kolandoto Hospital is the case masterplan for the development during the next
The hospital has scarce resources in terms of and a collaborative development project with non- 10 years. I was a designing architecture consultant
personnel, money, material, quality water, sufficient governmental organizations forms the framework. when creating a design proposal for a new eye clinic
electricity, and adequate spaces for healing free from building with sustainable building techniques. I
risks of errors, delays and infections. Possible help was a project manager when building an extension
to counteract this problem might come from within to the maternity operating theatre.
the international development sector. However,
there are issues regarding ownership and benefit
when people from a different part of the world bring
in resources to specific projects that often are based
on a limited understanding of the reality.
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. PROJECT BACKGROUND pg. 7 2. THE MASTERPLAN pg. 19
1.o. Thesis overview _________8 2.1. Diagnosing the current context _______________20 2.4. Defining a way forward __________38
1.1. Introduction ____________10 Starting point ____________20 A masterplan for peoples health _______38
Purpose and goal ________________10 Mapping of the site ______21 Site plan proposal _____________38
Collaborations _________10 State of buildings analysis _________22 Zoning plan proposal ____________40
Overarching issues _____11 Flows analysis _____________24 Flow plan proposal ___________________42
Case problems ________________11 Zoning analysis _______25
Research questions __________12 Analysis of water, sewage and electricity __26 Proposal for gradual development in
Methodology __________12 Weather and climate analysis ________27 10 steps and building projects ______________44
Delimitations _____12 2.2. Dreaming of the future _____28 Step 1: Eye clinic ________45
Thesis timeline ___________13 Vision ___28 Step 2: Casuality unit and emergency flows ___46
1.2. Tanzania, Shinyanga and Kolandoto ______14 Programming workshop ____________28 Step 3: Private ward and maternity ward _47
Location and quick facts __________14 A perfectly organized site __________29 Step 4: Pharmacy _____48
Climate ___________________15 The right to health principles ________30 Step 5: Reproductive child health clinic _______49
1.3. Kolandoto Hospital ______________16 Reference examples _____32 Step 6: Surgical ward and medical ward ____50
History of the hospital ___________16 2.3. Developing alternatives and consensus ____34 Step 7: Paediatric wards ____________51
The hospital today _________16 Site layout scenarios ______34 Step 8: Outpatient areas _______52
The hospital in the future ___17 Priorities within different types of projects _36 Step 9: Social hall and resource center ____53
Priorities withing different sizes of projects _37 Step 10: Intensive care unit ___________54
4
4. THE MATERNITY 5. DISCUSSION
3. THE EYE CLINIC BUILDING pg. 57 THEATRE EXTENSION pg. 85 AND REFLECTION pg. 99
3.1. Diagnosing the current context ______________58 4.1 Diagnosing the current context _____86 5.1. Healthy hospital design ... _______________100
Starting point ____________58 Starting point _____86 ... for peoples health __________100
Background information _____58 Finding a project ________________86 ... for a healthy environment ____101
The problems __________60 The problem ___________86 ... for a healthy approach to the
3.2. Dreaming of the future ______62 4.2. Dreaming of the future __________87 international development sector _____101
Vision ____62 Goal _____87 5.2. The architects role as ... ___________102
Building programme and connectivity __62 Building programme _______87 ... a hospital planner and process leader ___102
Sustainable building techniques ______63 4.3. Developing alternatives and consensus __88 ... a designing architecture consultant __102
Reference examples ___64 The site ____88 ... a project manager __________102
Key words _______65 Initial design proposal _____________89 5.3. A rich project with ... ___________________103
3.3. Developing alternatives and consensus ______66 4.4. Defining a way forward _______90 ... different scales ____________103
The first building proposal ____________66 Final design proposal _____________90 ... several focuses __________103
Finding a site ________________67 Budget _________91 ... many stakeholders __________________103
The chosen site __________68 Timeplan _______91
Sketching alternatives _______________70 4.5. Constructing the building ______92
3.4. Defining a way forward ________72 Buying material _______________92
6. REFERENCES pg. 104
Plans and perspectives ______73 Construction coordination ______92
Sections and perspectives _____________76 Construction supervision ____________93
Roof ___________79 Book keeping _____93
7. APPENDICES pg. 106
Elevations ___________80 Documenting the process ___________94
Materials ______82
Collaborations __________83
Budget ________________________83
5
6
1. PROJECT BACKGROUND
Giving the wider picture of the thesis, the context it is set in and the case Kolandoto Hospital.
7
1.0. THESIS OVERVIEW
INTRODUCTION
OVERARCHING CASE
SUB- QUESTIONS
PURPOSE AND GOAL ISSUE PROBLEM
COLLABORATIONS
How can a masterplan for Kolandoto
MASTERPLAN
lack of a Hospital support the access to
the right long-term appropriate healthcare in a healing
building plan environment free from factors
RESEARCH QUESTION to health
causing illness or poor health?
observations, research,
interviews, study visits,
discussions, workshop,
THEATRE EXTENSION
PHYSICAL CONTEXT
8
THREE SUB-PROJECTS DISCUSSIONS
large scale ... for peoples ... a hospital planner ... different
masterplan health scales
planning and process leader
... a designing
eye clinic middle-size ... for a healthy architecture ... several
design building design environment consultant focuses
9
1.1. INTRODUCTION
Purpose and goal Collaborations
The purpose of this master thesis is to explore how Healthy Hospital project:
I Aid Africa:
an architect can apply the concept of healthy hospital This thesis is part of the development project
IAA is an NGO working with mostly health issues
design within the international development sector Healthy Hospital. The project is a collaboration
in Tanzania. It has an established collaboration with
by taking different roles in a concrete development between Kolandoto Hospital in Tanzania, and the
Kolandoto Hospital since 2008.
project. The goal is to show designs for peoples three swedish NGOs I Aid Africa (IAA), Architects
health, for a healthy environment and for a healthy without borders (ASF), and Engineers without
Architects without borders Sweden:
approach to development. The designs should borders (EWB). The project aims at supporting a
ASF is an NGO that works for a sustainable, equal
be feasible and in three different scales - the large sustainable development of water, electricity and
and fair development of the built environment
scale of a masterplan for long term development, building infrastructure at Kolandoto Hospital. The
across the whole world.
the middle scale of a building design, and the small project is divided in three phases. The first phase
scale of a building intervention realizable during focus on in-depth understanding of problems and
Engineers without borders Sweden:
the master thesis period. Kolandoto Hospital in suggesting possible solutions, but also include
EWB is an NGO contributing to a better world by
Tanzania acts as a case study with scarce resources some quick interventions to improve the water and
applied engineering, science, entrepreneurship and
in terms of personnel, money, material, quality building infrastructure. The second phase is about
project management through volunteer projects in
water, sufficient electricity, and adequate spaces implementing recommended designs and solutions
primarily Africa as well as inspiring young people
for healing. The collaborative development project from the first phase. The third phase is about
to become engineers and broadening the minds of
that forms the framework is the project Healthy maintenance and further development. Two master
professional engineers in Sweden.
Hospital that aims at improving the building, theses are done within the first phase of the project.
electricity and water infrastructure at Kolandoto This architectural thesis called Healthy Hospital
Andreas Berg and Daniel Kallus:
Hospital in Tanzania in a sustainable way. Design, alongside an engineering thesis called
Andreas and Daniel are two engineering students
Healthy Hospital Water.
at Chalmers University of Technology. Their master
thesis is about the water situation at Kolandoto
Kolandoto Hospital:
Hospital. During the first phase of the Healthy
The hospital has 168 beds, was founded in 1913 and
Hospital project Daniel, Andreas and I made
is run by the African Inland Church Tanzania. It is
a comprehensive survey report of the current
an educational hospital located in a village close to
water, electricity and building situation and
Shinyanga town, a regional capital in the north west
needs at Kolandoto Hospital, which also included
of Tanzania.
recommendations for improvements.
10
Overaching issues and case problems
Issue 1: The right to health Issue 2: Sustainable building techniqes Issue 3: Relation to international development
The first issue is the topic of the right to health The second issue is that of sustainable development The third issue, that is apparent in many emerging
(WHO and OHCR 2008), which covers the access (WCED 1987), and to adapt the way we build to contexts, is that of its relation to the international
to and quality of healthcare in general, as well as ensure that we fulfill the needs of today without development sector. Questions of who benefits and
underlying factors of ill health such as access to jeopardizing our environment, the social fabric and has the ownership over development arise when
potable water, adequate sanitation and healthy the economy. This needs to be at the core for any people and organizations from a very different part
environmental conditions (WHO 2013). The building development, not the least one focusing on of the world brings in money and other resources
importance of this right is clearly manifested in health. In specific, the techniques for constructing to specific projects that often are based on a limited
some hospitals in the emerging world, where one environmentally sustainable buildings have to be understanding of the reality.
can observe the lesser quality of health care due adapted to the local climate. Aspects of building
to scarce resources in personnel, money, material, energy efficiency, incorporating water systems in the
quality water, sufficient electricity, and adequate building, using local material, and providing natural
spaces for healing free from risks of errors, delays ventilation and light should be climate adapted.
and infections.
Problem 1: Lack of a long term building plan Problem 2. Congestion in the eye department Problem 3. Unsafe conditions for c-sections
The current logistical flows of patients, staff, material Kolandoto Hospital has a specialized eye department Kolandoto Hospital has an operating theatre at the
and air throughout the hospital site are assumed to consisting of an inpatient ward, an outpatient clinic maternity department, which is closely connected
create room for errors and cause infections, and a and an operating theatre. Currently the eye clinic to the delivery room. The theatre is supposed to
long term plan could gradually change that. At the and eye ward is in the same building. The spaces be used for performing c-sections. However, the
moment the development of the built environment for the eye clinic are often overcrowded with many theatre is not in use due to that the hospital does
at the hospital is perceived to happen without a patients sitting uncomfortably waiting outside on not feel like it can guarantee the needed hygienic
comprehensive overview and goal, which might the paths or inside the actual examination rooms. conditions for performing safe c-sections. Today,
lead to that some decisions on specific building The lack of space compromises the patients privacy the pregnant mothers who are in delivery and need
development projects and their placement can during examinations and consultations. In addition, emergency c-sections have to be transported out of
prevent the hospital from reaching its goals for the congestion of inpatients and outpatients in the building, and along an outdoor path to go into
health care service provision in the years to come. small spaces in the same building also poses a risk the general operating theatre.
Lastly, looking at the access to health care services, for transmission of diseases and infections between
a council hospital in Shinyanga Urban district is patients.
missing, and Kolandoto Hospital is in the process of
becoming a Council Designated Hospital to fill that
void. But certain prerequisites regarding the built
environment apply before that is possible, and a
strategic plan for that development is needed.
11
Research questions Methodology Delimitations
The overall research question is: The whole master thesis has been done through The master thesis is done with the point of
an immersive design process happening mainly departure of considering sustainable development
- In what roles can an architects skills and knowledge on site in Kolandoto village in Tanzania. The three in its broadest sense all through. That means that
be applied in a project about healthy hospital design sub-projects have all been developed with the aspects such as local culture, economic feasibility,
in the international development sector? conceptual methodological steps of first diagnosing historic aspects have been thought of alongside of
the current context, then dreaming of the future, an environmentally friendly development.
In addition to that three sub-questions related to the then developing alternatives and consensus, and
sub-projects are formulated: lastly defining a way forward (French, M.A. 2011).
An overall method has been to work with the built
- How can a masterplan for Kolandoto Hospital environment in three different scales, and use the
support the access to appropriate healthcare in knowledge gained from working with one scale to
an healing environment free from factors causing the other scales. For example, the knowledge gained
illness or poor health? through supervising a construction process have
informed the building design.
- How can sustainable building techniques for a
tropical climate be applied to a building design at Some of the methods used include:
Kolandoto Hospital? observations
literature research
- How is it possible to implement a good quality interviews
architectural intervention at Kolandoto Hospital discussions
during a two months study visit? meetings
workshops
strategy analysis
flow analysis
zoning analysis
sketching
site analysis
full scale testing
study visits
12
sk
yp
w em
w30-3
rit e
e e
DESIGN
w the ting
rit s s
in is
g ov
w4
w4
w4
w4
tra fun erv
ve di ie
THE MATERNITY
re ap
pa pl
THE MASTERPLAN
ra ic
w5
w5
w5
w5
stu at
Thesis timeline
dy tio io
THEATRE EXTENSION
vi ns ns
sit
fin si ar
d n m riv
w6
w6
w6
w6
Na ap
in a bu iro pi m al t
ve il
bi ng ee o K
sti di ho tin o
ga ng gs lan
te t pr
flo sp w do
w7
w7
w7
w7
dy m an ls ho
lo ne ct ap d ite
ca ed pi zo sp
lb m n n ita
lit u ap g b ing lm
w8
w8
w8
w8
er
at
ild u an
ur in sk pin ild ana ag
gt et g s in ly
er ra ch p g si em
se
ar sit e s di stu ing atia con s en
ea t
ch tio d
w9
w9
w9
w9
ea rc al l n dit
fo na h ns ev y vi tern eed ion
rp ly al sit s
fo os sis ua s ativ s
un sib sk tin to es
le et pr o
dr d m c
w10
w10
w10
w10
w11
w11
w11
w11
aw ed l ea al on lte ild tb
re in ba tre ua in oo
ce g c pr te
a b rna
us tiv gn kl
ive rev k m oj pl ee et
bu b is
y u i e e ec pl an y c es ds du
t an lin m m
al m
w12
w12
w12
w12
co ma dg ons ting
e te ic id
ns te t di and r da -te y
co tru ria an gi
ta se
na
t y rm
ns ct ls d m l 3 ti c ives se
bu tru ion at de D o sk w m
y ct s er in
w13
w13
w13
w13
ia ta m ns et ra
co ma ion tart le ile od ke ch p ar
ns te su ed d el tch in up
tru ria pe sti
m sit sk e g m
bu c ls rv at m e m etc s fin ee
y m tio isi io at al tin
w14
w14
w14
w14
co a n s on ns er ap hes gs
ns te up ia pi pr pro w
tru ria er li ng oj gr ith
ec am
co l vi nv
e ti ho
n ctio s sio de sti nv me le s
n sk es p pi
w15
w15
w15
w15
ha stru n s sig ga et av ta
nd ct up n tio ch tig ri i ng lm
ov ion erv fe ns in at ori
ed io tiz Ko an
er su is b w
g fi
n
ns a la ag
bu pe ion sk ac
k al
tio
n n em
w16
w16
w16
w16
dg rv et m
rit do
et isi ch in pr to en
to on sit ee
tin
gp op t
ho ep ro os
sp ro la gs je al
of
c n ct
a
w17
w17
w17
w17
ita de
l pr on
od st
nd sc
uc ruc se rip
ct tio
e d tio io w
ill r n n pr
od ns rit
aw s e
w18
w18
w18
w18
us u
tra in ket pr ce wo in
tio gs ch od il rk tro
ns es uc lus on du
an e d tra bo ctio
d ra tio pr
w19
w19
w19
w19
pe w n od ok n a
rs in s uc le nd
t
pe gs e fi di
ct na sc
ive pr lm us
s
w20
w20
w20
w20
ep sio
ar a te n
ep ria
r es l bo
fin en
al ok
t
w21
w21
w21
w21
bo sem atio le
t
ok in n
le a
pr t re r
ep v
w22
w22
w22
w22
ar isio
ee n
xh s
pu ib
bl iti
w23
w23
w23
w23
on
ex ic p
hi re
bi se
tio nt
13
n ati
on
1.2. TANZANIA, SHINYANGA AND KOLANDOTO
The largest city Dar es Salaam located by the coast Shinyanga region is one of 26 administrative regions Kolandoto Village is located 15 km from Shinyanga
to the Indian Ocean, and the capital Dodoma is in Tanzania and is situated in the northeast part of town, and around 150 km from Mwanza. The village
located roughly in the middle of the country. The the country. It has a population around 1,5 million is located in Shinyanga Urban District and has a
second largest city is Mwanza, situated along the people. It takes about 2h to go to Shinyanga by car population of about 10000 people. The name comes
shoreline of Lake Victoria in the northwest. from Mwanza by Lake Victoria. from a tree that used to be green all year round.
14
FIGURE. 2.2-1 CLIMATE ZONES FOR EAC
Climate
East africa
There are six different climatic zones within the
tropical climate experienced in East Africa, seen
in the map to the right. Shinyanga region and
Kolandoto is located in the hot semi-arid / savannah
zone. In this zone the mean air temperature range is
20-22 C. In the warmest periods the temperatures
are about 29-31 C, but can rise to 33 C in semi-arid
areas. The mean relative humidity is about 65%,
but it can go down to 40% in the savannah plains.
The mean annual rainfall ranges from 500-750 mm
in semi-arid areas, and 1000-1500 mm in savannah
areas. (UN-Habitat 2015)
Shinyanga region
16
The hospital in the future
A council designated hospital
The system of health care facilities in Tanzania is
from smaller to larger: dispensary, health center,
district hospital, regional hospital, and national
referral hospital. Kolandoto Hospital is at the
moment not in that system, since it is a hospital run
by a faith based organization. However, a hospital
at the district level is missing in Shinyanga Urban
District, which Kolandoto Hospital is located within.
A story of a masterplan that defines the development at the hospital the next 10 years.
Annika Danielsson - June 2015
19
2.1. DIAGNOSING THE CURRENT CONTEXT
Starting point
The first point of departure for the collaborative
development project was that Kolandoto Hospital
needed to do something about its problems
concerning water shortage and quality, and its
unreliable power supply. But individuals involved
would also like to have a more comprehensive
overview and see more of the whole situation at
the hospital, to create really sustainable solutions.
The conclusion was to include an overview of the
buildings and flows at the hospital, through teaming
up with Architects without Borders as well. In June
2014 the three Swedish NGOs started looking for
engineering and architecture master thesis students
who could be part of the project. That is when I
got in contact with them. At the time I was living in
Nairobi, Kenya, and decided to go to visit Kolandoto
Hospital for a week. During that week I got an initial
overview of the hospital, the buildings, the water
system, the electricity situation, and problems that
the hospital faced. It was compiled into a Visit
Report (Danielsson 2014) that then became the
starting point for discussions around creating a
masterplan for the hospital.
20
Mapping of the site
SHOPS SHOPS
INCINERATOR
COLLEGE
KITCHEN
DISPENSARY
EYE WARD
PHARMACY
The hospital site is characterized by PHYSIO. STERIL. IMAGING
FAMILY LAUNDRY
- approximately 27 000 m2 PLANNING EYE
THEATRE
- only one storey buildings INFUSION
DENTAL
- buildings are spread out MATERNITY
- a lot of outdoor area WARD
ADMINISTRATION
- outdoors paths with roofs SUPPLY STORE
21
State of buildings analysis
SHOPS SHOPS
INCINERATOR
COLLEGE
KITCHEN
DISPENSARY
EYE WARD
PHARMACY
FAIR WORKSHOP
CANTEEN
PRIVATE
GOOD WARD
22
The outpatient building has a unique design. The reproductive child health clinic. The pharmacy building is one of the oldest.
The infusion unit is in the old administration. The administration used to be a paediatric ward. The social hall for the students at the college.
The general theatre building. The pathway leading to the general ward entrance. The maternity building.
23
OUTPATIENT
SPECIAL EMERGENCY PLANNING
PLANNING
EYE
MATERNIT
DELIVERY
WARD
PHARMACY
CTC WARD
INPATIENT CARE CARE
VISITORS
GENERAL STUDENTS DE
DE
PARKING EYE C
PAEDIATRIC EMERGENCY
TREATMENT THEATRE
FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL.C-SECTION
IMAGING
DELIVERY C-SECTION
DELIVERY
INFUSION
INFUSION
LAUNDRY
OUTPATIENT
WARD CLINIC
CARE DELIVERY
PLANNING
STUDENTS STAFF THEATRE
THEATRE SS
MATERNITSS
PRIVATE
PHARMACY DENTAL
Flows analysis INPATIENT EMERGENCY DELIVERY VISITORS
STAFF
DELIVERY C-SECTION
PHYSIO. STERIL.THEATRE
INFUSION
GOODS AND
WARD
WARD
GOODS AND
GOODS
GENERAL WARD LAB
REPRODUCTIVE MATERIALS
CHILD HEALTH
COLLEGE
KITCHEN
DISPENSARY
SPECIAL
EYE WARD
CTC
CARE GENERAL
Flows today 1.1000 PAEDIATRIC TREATMENT THEATRE PARKING EYE CLINIC
WARD CLINIC
patients DELIVERY
MATERNITY
- outpatient flow spread out over the whole WARD
VISITORS
hospital and crossing other more crucial flows WORKSHOP
STAFF
GENERAL AND
WARD OUTPATIENT LAB
ADMINISTRATION DEPARTMENT
REPRODUCTIVE
CHILD HEALTH PUBLIC COLLEGE
SQUARE KITCHEN
DISPENSARY
SPECIAL
EYE WARD
CTC
CARE GENERAL PARKING EYE CLINIC
TREATMENT OFFICE THEATRE
CLINIC
Zoning today 1.1000
PAEDIATRIC PHARMACY
INPATIENT WARD
Isses with the functional zoning include: FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDRY
- poor wayfinding for outpatients who are PLANNING EYE
THEATRE
OUTPATIENT
spread out over the whole hospital INFUSION DENTAL
25
Analysis of water, sewage
and electricity
Conclusions:
- avoid building on top of main water line
- consider that it will be more expensive to build if main water line electricity
the water, electricity or sewage systems have to be
moved water line septic tank
- avoid building on top of septic tanks in use
water tank
26
Weather and climate analysis
Kolandoto Hospital is in the semi-arid / savannah
climatic zone.
reproductive physiotherapy
VISITOR ENTRANCE EMERGENCY ENTRANCE dispensary eye clinic
child health
OUTPATIENT AREAS
and nosocomial infections. healing and safe environments.
illness or injuries. To incorporate the right to health
in the overall design of Kolandoto Hospital some Site circulation and flows of patients, staff, materials Functional zoning in masterplanning divides the
principles on this topic have been formulated here. and visitors across the hospital area plays an site so that public areas areas are easy to reach and
important part in making sure the hospital is an areas requiring privacy or clinical isolation are
environment that does not cause illnesses or poor restricted (MASS Design Group 2013) Zoning could
health. Appropriately designed flows will decrease be a tool to control the flows through a hospital and
the risk of medical errors and nosocomial infections control the feel and cleanliness of areas and spaces.
or diseases (WHO 2002), and it will also improve Different types of functions have different needs. In
the wayfinding for patients and visitors. Access to a masterplan layout one could strive to differentiate
the site for different types of flows also need to be between different types of functions in zones. The
considered. justification is to decrease the risk of transmission of
communicable diseases and nosocomial infections,
Flows to consider include: to safeguard the security and safety of patients, to
- emergency care differentiate between non-sterile spaces and sterile
- inpatients spaces, to ensure appropriate privacy to patients,
- outpatients to create an environment that minimizes room for
- delivery errors, to ensure a good healing environment for
- visitors patients, and to ensure a good working environment
- staff for the staff.
- students
- goods and material Six different types of functions within the hospital
have been identified and categorized into zones:
- Inpatient areas
- Outpatient areas
- Diagnostics and treatment
- Support, goods and materials
- Staff and administration
- Public and non-hospital functions
30
Future proofing Water and sanitation Healing design
and technologies change fast. illness if treated poorly. adapted to local culture.
The healthcare building facilities constructed in Some of the more obvious factors that can cause Hospitals are areas for healing. The design of the
a certain period will most probably be used under illnesses at a hospital are solid waste, water, physical environment of healthcare facilities can
circumstances that were unpredictable during the wastewater, and storm water. Solid waste and affect safety and satisfaction of patients and staff, as
time of planning and construction since the type wastewater that is not handled properly might well as quality and costs of the healthcare (Clancy
of health care needed, the philosophies around cause illnesses or infections. A lack of water 2008, Sadler et al 2011). Evidence based design (EBD)
health care provision, alongside with technological immediately reduces the possibility of keeping good explores what design features of a building that can
development in health care, constantly are changing. hygienic conditions for health care. Storm water or improve the healing process of patients as well as
Hence, it is important to plan for uncertainty and wastewater that become stagnant are good breeding prevent patients and staff from getting injured or ill
design for change when building a hospital (Francis grounds for mosquitoes and increases the risk of from being at hospitals.
2007). contracting malaria.
Some aspects to consider for the hospital as a
There are three core concepts connected to future Hence some of the topics to consider in a master healing environment include:
proofing that should be considered: plan are the location, flow and treatment of: Way-finding
- Flexibility: the possibility for space to change - water sources and distribution system Cultural sensitivity
- Generality: the possible use/functions of spaces to - stagnant water Patient privacy
be widespread, not only specific - waste water Positive distractions
- Elasticity: the ability of space to swell and contract - storm water Nature
according to need - solid waste Accessibility
- biological waste Natural lighting
- dirty equipment Acoustics
- dirty linen Natural ventilation
(Mkony 2009)
31
Reference examples Mpongwe Mission Hospital in Zambia
The project of developing a masterplan for the
Mpongwe Mission Hospital in Zambia is a good
Butaro District Hospital reference of a similar project to this one. With
The Butaro District Hospital on a hilltop in a rural the aim of creating a masterplan that can guide
district of Rwanda was finished in 2011. With its the development and also be of help in resource
140 beds and services in maternity health, internal mobilization and prioritization. The project was
medicine, surgery and pediatrics in now provides done in collaboration with White architects in
healthcare to the regions 340000 inhabitants. The A section. (c) MASS Design Group Sweden. (Caira 2011)
architect is MASS Design Group who through
an immersive work process in the field, and in
collaboration with the Rwandan Ministry of Health
and Partners in Health, designed a state of the art
facility as well as designed a construction process
in which only local workers were employed and
trained in the necessary skills to build the hospital.
The hospital is specifically designed to mitigate and
reduce transmission of airborne diseases such as
for example tuberculosis, through its overall layout,
patient and staff flows, and natural ventilation.
(MASS Design Group. Butaro Hospital / MASS
Design Group 2011. Cary, J. and Martin, C. E. 2012. The beds in the wards are turned towards the views. A nice booklet with the masterplan was produced.
Butaro Hospital 2011.) (c) Iwan Baan
The site is located on a hill with beautiful views. There are clear signs in the central courtyard. The masterplan defines flows and new building projects.
(c) Iwan Baan (c) MASS Design Group
32
Shinyanga Regional Hospital Mwadui Hospital
A study visit to Shinyanga Regional Hospital, the Mwadui Hospital is a hospital run by a local diamond
referral hospital for Kolandoto Hospital 15 km from mine company 10 km from Kolandoto. From looking
Kolandoto, was made to get a feeling for hospitals at its built environment, my conclusion is that it
in general in the local context of western Tanzania. has and probably have more financial resources
This helped the process for example through available than other public or faith-based hospitals.
gettting a better understanding of what staff meant It is however a good local reference of a hospital
when talking about new planned services such as a that has gone through an extensive renovation and
casuality unit and an intensive care unit. upgrading of facilities during the last years.
The waiting area at the outpatient department. The outdoor walkways at Shinyanga Regional Hospital. An inpatient ward.
The main room in the intensive care unit. An outdoor walkway at Mwadui Hospital. An examination room.
33
WAST
scenarios are roughly explained here. The scenarios the hospital instead of the college. In addition,
was presented to and discussed with the medical functions like the care treatment clinic, the lab and
DIAGNOSTICS
& TREATMENT
officer in charge. the canteen are kept in their current places. The only SUPPORT,
GOODS AND
large department that is moved is the reproductive MATERIALS
The following conclusions were made based on the child health clinic. Otherwise the large investments PUBLIC AND
discussion:
NON-HOSPITAL
are on new functions and buildings. FUNCTIONS
- avoid moving functions that are working well and STAFF AND
ADMINISTRATION
have been renovated recently
- try to collect the outpatient areas
- assess the need for a building project against the
level of investment INFECTION
WASTE ZONE
PUBLIC
INPATIENT
- very well justified larger investments are feasible if SOCIAL HALL WAITING
WARD SQUARE OUTPATIENT
MORTUARY
STAFF AND
PHYSIO
ADMINISTRATION
DENTAL
RCH CASUALITY EYE WARD
THEATRE
SHORT
CTC STAY WARD
PAEDIATRIC
WARD EYE OPD
FP STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDRY EYE
THEATRE
INFUSION
DELIVERY
PRIVATE STORAGE ADMINISTRATION
WARD
PHARMACY
LEPROSY
WARD
34
WASTE ZONE INCINERATOR
PUBLIC
SQUARE
COLLEGE
MORTUARY SOCIAL
HALL
LAB
SPECIAL
EYE WARD
CTC
Collect all outpatient areas Big investments
CARE
allowed GENERAL PARKING EYE CLINIC
OFFICE
TREATMENT THEATRE
In this alternative all the outpatient areas are moved INPATIENT In this alternative many of the functions have been
CLINIC
INPATIENT
PAEDIATRIC PHARMACY PAEDIATRIC
to the same area. The diagnostics and treatment allowed to move. There isPHYSIO.
WARD a large waiting
STERIL. IMAGING
area by WARD
OUTPATIENT FAMILY LAUNDRY OUTPATIENT
functions of lab and imaging are placed in between the public square. On one side of it is the new main
PLANNING EYE
THEATRE
the outpatient area and the rest of the diagnostics DIAGNOSTICS outpatient department, and onINFUSION
DELIVERY C-SECTION
the other
DENTAL
side is the DIAGNOSTICS
& TREATMENT & TREATMENT
and treatment. The logistical spaces for medical casuality unit which is closely connected STORE to the new
THEATRE SUPPLY
ADMINISTRATION
SUPPORT, SUPPORT,
supplies and drugs are also all collected in one area GOODS AND lab, the new imaging, and the general theatre. The GOODS AND
MATERIALS MATERNITY MATERIALS
in between the delivery point through the public PUBLIC AND
clinic functions
WARDmove in to the current outpatient WASHING PUBLIC WORKSHOP
AND
square, the large inpatient areas and the diagnostics department building instead.
LINES
NON-HOSPITAL NON-HOSPITAL
CANTEEN
FUNCTIONS FUNCTIONS
and treatment areas. STAFF AND
PRIVATE
WARD STAFF AND
ADMINISTRATION ADMINISTRATION
WORKSHOP
MATERNITY MATERNITY WORKSHOP
INFECTION CANTINE CANTINE
WARD
INFECTION WARD
35
Priorities within different
types of projects Diagnostics and treatment Wards
1. casuality unit: for emergency cases and night time 1. extend maternity ward
A meeting with some of the management staff at
2. extend maternity theatre 1. new private ward
the hospital was held to identify priorities among
3. labour room with 4-6 delivery beds 1. room for children at the eye ward (will happen
the needs for buildings/rooms/functions that were 4. extend general theatre: recovery room, sluice, when the eye OPD is built)
identified in the programming workshop. In the separate scrub and water supply for minor theatre, 2. extend paediatric ward: more beds, malnutrition
meeting the flow analysis and the zoning analysis connect to sterilization room, room, playroom, office
was presented. After that the programme summary x. family planning is already under construction 3. general ward: build one new which is for medical
list produced during the programming workshop male and female, include proper isolation rooms
was presented and discussed. The staff were asked with separate toilets in the new building, renovate
to prioritize within certain categories of function Outpatient areas the existing general ward to only be for surgical
needs. 1 being the highest priority to 5 being the 1. eye OPD male and female, include extension of the existing
lowest priority. The outcome is presented here. 1. waiting bay for patients: both outside OPD and one for area for leprosy patients,
inside OPD 4. ICU
2. move RCH closer to OPD, and extend it with 5. place for where visitors/relatives can meet the
immunization room, post natal exam, and waiting patients who are mobile, recreation/dining room/
area space for patients
3. surgical room at OPD: for minor injuries, bruises,
cuts etc
4. expand OPD: widen doors for accessibility of Staff and administration
stretchers, room for doctors, registration room, 1. on call room for doctors, clinicians and lab
5. Parking at OPD: for both staff and visitors, safety technicians
is important 2. social welfare office
3. resource center
4. social hall
Support, goods and materials 5. new layout for the OiC in the administration office
1. extend mortuary
2. new modern pharmacy
Participants reflecting before the discussion started.
3. kitchen
4. cement floor under the washing lines for laundry
36
Priorities within different
sizes of projects
37
2.4. DEFINING A WAY FORWARD
causing illness or injuries.
SHOPS SHOPS
This masterplan with agreed priorities and medical MORTUARY COLLEGE OUTPATIENT DEPARTMENT
IMAGING
environment, and through improving wayfinding
FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL. LAUNDRY
PLANNING EYE
THEATRE
for patients and relatives to have less stressful INFUSION
DENTAL
VISITOR ENTRANCE
EMERGENCY ENTRANCE
DELIVERY ENTRANCE
OUTPATIENT ENTRANCE
SHOPS SHOPS
WASTE ZONE
KITCHEN
OUTPATIENT
PUBLIC DEPARTMENT
SQUARE
MORTUARY
REPRODUCTIVE
CHILD HEALTH
PAEDIATRIC EYE
WARD CLINIC
EYE WARD
CASUALITY GENERAL
INTENSIVE UNIT THEATRE
CARE UNIT
SHORT
STAY
FAMILY WARD STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDRY
PLANNING EYE
THEATRE
INFUSION SUPPLY
DELIVERY STORE
ADMINISTRATION
SOCIAL
HALL WORKSHOP
PRIVATE WARD MATERNITY
WARD
PHARMACY RESOURCE
CENTER
NEW
BUILDING
EXISTING
BUILDING
STAFF ENTRANCE
GOODS ENTRANCE
39
Zoning plan proposal
DISPENSARY
- more defined outdoor spaces
- less overlapping of inpatient and outpatient areas
SPECIAL
EYE WARD
CTC
CARE GENERAL PARKING EYE CLINIC
TREATMENT OFFICE THEATRE
CLINIC
PAEDIATRIC PHARMACY
INPATIENT WARD
FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDRY
PLANNING EYE
OUTPATIENT THEATRE
INFUSION DENTAL
DELIVERY
SUPPLY
DIAGNOSTICS STORE ADMINISTRATION
& TREATMENT
SUPPORT, MATERNITY
GOODS AND WARD
MATERIALS WORKSHOP
STAFF AND
ADMINISTRATION
40
Zoning in the future 1:000
VISITOR ENTRANCE
EMERGENCY ENTRANCE OUTPATIENT ENTRANCE
DELIVERY ENTRANCE
DISPENSARY
PAEDIATRIC EYE
WARD CLINIC
EYE WARD
CASUALITY GENERAL
INTENSIVE UNIT THEATRE
INPATIENT CARE UNIT
SHORT
STAY
OUTPATIENT
WARD STERIL.
PAEDIATRIC FAMILY IMAGING LAUNDRY
WARD PLANNING
EYE
DIAGNOSTICS THEATRE
& TREATMENT INFUSION SUPPLY
C-SECTION
DELIVERY STORE ADMINISTRATION
THEATRE
SUPPORT,
GOODS AND
MATERIALS
SOCIAL
PUBLIC AND HALL
MATERNITY WORKSHOP
NON-HOSPITAL PRIVATE WARD WARD
FUNCTIONS PHARMACY RESOURCE
CENTER
STAFF AND
ADMINISTRATION
STAFF ENTRANCE
GOODS ENTRANCE
41
Flow plan proposal
shorter
MORTUARY
COLLEGE
SOCIAL - the outpatient flows are collected in one main area
OUTPATIENT
- the visitor flow is diverted so it does not pass the
HALL
DEPARTMENT
DISPENSARY
- the delivery flow is kept to only going to one
building
SPECIAL
EYE WARD
- the entrance for goods deliveries is changed to the
east side of the hospital so the main entrance is less
CTC
CARE GENERAL
TREATMENT PARKING EYE CLINIC
PAEDIATRIC THEATRE
WARD CLINIC
- the goods deliveries and the outpatients no longer
INPATIENT
PHARMACY
enter through the entrance by the public square
PHYSIO. STERIL.
which makes it less congested
FAMILY IMAGING LAUNDRY
OUTPATIENT PLANNING EYE
THEATRE
DENTAL
EMERGENCY DELIVERY C-SECTION
INFUSION
THEATRE
CARE SUPPLY
STORE ADMINISTRATION
DELIVERY
MATERNITY
WARD
VISITORS
WORKSHOP
STUDENTS CANTEEN
PRIVATE
WARD
STAFF
GOODS AND
MATERIALS
42
Flows in the future 1:1000
VISITOR ENTRANCE
EMERGENCY ENTRANCE OUTPATIENT ENTRANCE
DELIVERY ENTRANCE
PAEDIATRIC EYE
WARD CLINIC
EYE WARD
CASUALITY GENERAL
INPATIENT INTENSIVE UNIT THEATRE
CARE UNIT
OUTPATIENT SHORT
STAY
WARD LAUNDRY
PAEDIATRIC FAMILY STERIL. IMAGING
EMERGENCY PLANNING
WARD
CARE EYE
THEATRE
INFUSION SUPPLY
C-SECTION
DELIVERY DELIVERY
THEATRE STORE ADMINISTRATION
VISITORS
SOCIAL
STUDENTS HALL
MATERNITY WORKSHOP
PRIVATE WARD WARD
STAFF PHARMACY RESOURCE
CENTER
GOODS AND
MATERIALS
NEW
BUILDING STAFF ENTRANCE
GOODS ENTRANCE
EXISTING
BUILDING
43
Proposal for gradual development
in 10 steps and building projects
VISITOR ENTRANCE
EMERGENCY ENTRANCE
DELIVERY ENTRANCE
OUTPATIENT ENTRANCE
SHOPS SHOPS
WASTE ZONE
KITCHEN
OUTPATIENT
PUBLIC DEPARTMENT
SQUARE
MORTUARY
REPRODUCTIVE
CHILD HEALTH 8
6 5
GENERAL GENERAL
6 LAB
MEDICAL WARD SURGICAL WARD CARE
PARKING
TREATMENT
DENTAL CLINIC
PHYSIO.
DISPENSARY
7
PAEDIATRIC EYE
WARD CLINIC
EYE WARD
INTENSIVE
CASUALITY GENERAL
1
The following 10 steps and larger building
CARE UNIT 10 2
UNIT THEATRE
SHORT
projects are a synthesis between the STAY
WARD
priorities of the hospital and the conditions FAMILY
PLANNING
STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDRY
EYE
given by the site and the buildings. After THEATRE
pre-planned development
PRIVATE WARD MATERNITY
WARD
HALL
9 WORKSHOP
PHARMACY RESOURCE
- to be sensitive to local culture CENTER
44
Step 1: Eye clinic
department through which patients arrive.
45
Step 2: Casuality unit
and emergency flows Build a casuality unit and short stay ward with easy access
from the main gate, and renovate the general theatre and
the imaging department to create good connections.
46
Step 3: Private ward
and maternity ward Build a modern private ward, and extend
the maternity ward to use the old private ward areas
Problem description
The current maternity ward has 24 beds and two
and have a new main entrance to the building.
47
Step 4: Pharmacy
- too small
- shelves are attached to the walls and get attacked Build a new pharmacy building
by insects close to the back entrance of the
- too warm for storage of medication hospital site and the infusion
- windows lead light into areas that should be dark unit and supply store.
- not enough space for walking with a trolley
- difficult to clean due to the small spaces and the
floor inclinations
- lack sinks for washing hands
- too small doors to bring in larger items
48
Step 5: Reproductive
Child Health Clinic
the outpatient department and the laboratory.
49
Step 6: Surgical ward
and medical ward Build a new medical ward next to the existing
general ward, and reorganize the previous
general ward to become a surgical ward.
ward in connection to it.
51
Step 8: Outpatient areas
Build a new main building for the outpatient department,
and move other outpatient functions into the previous
outpatient department and kitchen buildings.
The OPD building is not adapted for people who Care treatment clinic:
have trouble walking and need wheelchairs. There - waiting areas
are stairs leading up to the reception at the entrance. - educational areas
Inside the building, many doors and the half- - several consultation rooms
outdoor corridors are not wide enough. - toilets
52
Step 9: Social hall
and resource center
53
Step 10: Intensive care unit
casuality unit and general theatre.
54
55
56
3. THE EYE CLINIC BUILDING
57
3.1. DIAGNOSING THE CURRENT CONTEXT
Starting point Background information
When I came to Kolandoto I had in mind that I Kolandoto Hospital Eye Department
wanted to draw a building proposal. I was looking
for the right project. Already the first week the Kolandoto Hospital Eye Department consists of
hospital management told me about their ongoing three units:
plans to build an eye clinic through a collaboration 1. First, there is the eye clinic to which patients come
with CBM (www.cbm.org). The hospital was in to see the opthalmic nurses or specialized eye doctor
the process of creating a funding application with if they have any troubles concerning their eyes.
justifications of the need of the building as well as 2. Second, there is the eye operating theatre in which
information about the needed funding. A draft of a wide range of eye surgeries are done each week,
this application already existed, and I was asked from cataracts to removing foreign objects.
to improve it with more information through text, 3. Third, there is the eye ward to which patients can
pictures and illustrations. A proposal for a building get admitted while in need of more close eye care,
design together with a tender from a local company which often is before and after surgeries.
had been prepared before. After I produced this
funding application I asked the hospital if they Kolandoto Hospital Eye Department is one of two
would allow me to draw another proposal for the hospitals in Shinyanga Region that offers eye clinic
eye clinic, explaining that I wanted to do it through services. The other one is the Government Regional
many discussions with the staff and also incorporate Hospital of Shinyanga. However, it is only Kolandoto
ideas of how to make it a climate adapted design. Hospital that provides the service of eye surgeries
in the region and some surrounding regions.
Shinyanga Region has a population of more than 1.5
million people. They and the people in surrounding
regions are the target group for this project.
58
The female wing in the ward.
The existing building for the eye clinic and the eye ward.
The doctors room in the clinic. The eye theatre to the left, and the eye ward and clinic to the right - connected by a path with a roof.
59
The problems
There is currently a shortage of space to The risk of transmission of diseases and infections
accommodate the amount of patients and activities between inpatients and outpatients is high due to
in the eye department. On average the eye outpatient that some spaces are shared and the flows of the two
clinic sees about 40 patients per clinic day and types of patients cross each other in crowded spaces.
the space available is not adequate to facilitate the In the current situation the outpatients sit and
appropriate sitting/waiting area, screening, vision wait in a small space which is connected by open
testing, counseling and doctor consultation. Patients indoor spaces to the wards where the inpatients
are staying. Relatives of inpatients have to pass all
especially the elderly, women and children are thus
the waiting outpatients to bring food to their sick
faced with an uncomfortable and crowded waiting
family members three times per day. Inpatients
area that exposes them to sitting directly under the
coming back to the ward from a surgery also has to
sun for long hours as well as sitting on the ground. pass through all the areas where outpatients wait.
All outpatients often arrive in the morning, and
many have to wait before seeing the doctor, and if
Poor patient privacy they need to use the washroom in that time they
walk through the inpatient ward to use the same
As an effect of the lack of space, the patient privacy washrooms as the inpatients.
is also poor. Patients often sit and wait in the same
room as where other patients are being examined.
It is also common that treatment of patients is
discussed in areas where other patients and relatives
can hear due to that there are rarely any rooms
empty of people to do councelling in.
Patients waiting inside the examination
and refraction room.
60
The current building layout
Scale 1:150
61
3.2. DREAMING OF THE FUTURE
ENTRY / EXIT
Vision EXAMINATION / COUNCELLING
optometry room
Building programme waiting area
~22m2
and connectivity ~85m2
62
Sustainable building techniques Wall characteristics Roof characteristics
west east
south
N/S
- Orient the building with the long axis going west E/W
to east to reduce the amount of solar radiation
- Vents at floor and roof level. - Medium sized windows.
reaching the walls.
- Opposite openings for cross ventilation. - Maximize windows on N/S facades and mimimize
- Adapt up to 30 degrees to catch the prevailing
- Separately ventilated roof. windows on E/W facades.
winds.
- Limited ventilation during daytime to avoid hot - Provide outer solar shading devices: horizontal on
air, and increased ventilation at night to cool the N/S facades, and vertical on W/E facades.
structure. - Provide windows in opposite walls for cross
ventilation.
The roof is made of bamboo from Kenya. Rainwater is directed to the ground inside the pillars. The water tank is integrated in the design.
The stone for the walls come from a quarry nearby. Patients wait around a green and open courtyard. The roofs are leaning to the middle of the building
where the rainwater is collected in a gutter.
64
Key words
Calm Comfortable Clear
doctor
registration
- natural colors - a range of types of shaded waiting areas - supportive signs in the design
breeze
- views to nature and where people walk - well ventilated building catching the small breeze - logical movement for patients
- diffused light through semipermeable brickwork - windows protected from solar radiation
65
3.3. DEVELOPING ALTERNATIVES AND CONSENSUS
Opinions
The first building proposal
The first building proposal poses a lot of questions: - why have both an optometry room and an optician
The drawings - where is it placed? the site is missing... room?
- how do you arrive to the building? - maybe the rooms are too large?
This building proposal was developed by JIMCON - where is north and south in the building? - maybe the whole building is too large?
LTD in 2014, who also provided a tender with a - is the sunshading sufficient? - how can rain water collection be incorporated in
budget for constructing the building. The total cost - where is the staff toilet? the design?
for the building would be maximum 102307 euro. - is this considered aesthetically appealing? - how can the cost estimated be lowered?
Please note that these drawings are not to scale in - is there a risk for congestion in the corridor?
this document. - do you want the staff tea room next to the main
waiting area?
66
Finding a site 2.
3.
67
The chosen site
Site analysis
building
wind
sun
electricity line
tree
people walking
68
Pictures of the site
This panorama is taken from the kitchen building. The eye ward is in the green building to the left. The building at the far end is the pharmacy.
To the left in the grass you can see an inspection hole for the main water line that passes from right to left in the picture.
In this panorama you see three buildings that defines the site. The kitchen is to the left,
the outpatient department building is in the middle, and the green building is the current eye clinic and ward building.
This panorama is taken from standing by the gable of the eye ward. Patients coming to visit the eye department
enter the hospital site through the outpatient department and then walk along this corridor to arrive to the eye department.
69
Sketching alternatives
Alternative WIDE
Process Alternative LONG
In alternative WIDE, the building has a corridor in
Through a sketching process three different layout In alternative LONG, all the necessary rooms the middle, and rooms on each side. The waiting
alternatives were developed. These were presented are organized along one semi-outdoor corridor. area is clearly visible from the connecting outside
and discussed with the opthalmic nurses and the The corridor is connected to the waiting area for path that the patients arrive through from the main
eye doctor to really understand the programmatic patients all along the corridor. The roof is planned outpatient department. The water tank for rainwater
and spatial needs for specifically Kolandoto Eye to be a pent roof, leaning towards south where the collection is integrated in the design of the building.
Department. This process was part of creating the gutter leads the rainwater to the water tank that is The roof is planned to be a gable roof but opposite,
diagram about programme and connectivity shown integrated in the building. This alternative requires meaning that the rainwater flows inward towards
on page 62. to have a visual acuity screen for 4 meter testing one gutter above the corridor, and then is led to the
(normal is 5 meter). One of the existing rooms in the rainwater tank. This alternative requires to have a
eye clinic/ward building is used as a tea room. visual acuity screen for 4 meter testing (normal is 5
meter). One of the existing rooms in the eye clinic/
ward building is used for tea room.
70
Alternative 5METERS Feedback
In alternative 5 METERS, the building is adapted This is a summary of design opinions from the - Ensure good ventilation in the whole building.
to having a visual acuity room for 5 meter testing. opthalmic nurses and eye doctor: - Waiting areas can be half outside and half inside.
Also the optometry room is 5 meters long. The - 1 toilet for staff is needed, 2 toilets for patients are
washrooms are close to the waiting area, which in - The VA room needs to be 6m so that it is possible to needed.
turn is facing the path through which patients arrive check visual acuity on 5m. - Prefer a design with rooms on two sides of a corridor
through in an open way. There are rooms on two - Keep the WC away from waiting areas since it will because it provides better privacy to patients.
sides of a central corridor. The roof can be a normal be smelly. Also since some patients wont go to the - Have space for examination bed in the doctors
gable roof, on which water is collected to a gutter toilet if others in the waiting area will know where room.
on the south side leading to an external rainwater they are going. - The nurse room could possibly be multipurpose,
tank. And solar panels are facing the ideal direction - Have WC next to waiting area so it is easy to access. and function as tea room too, even though it is not
slightly towards north on the north side of the roof. - Ensure good ventilation around the WC. ideal.
One of the existing rooms in the eye clinic/ward - Separate the registration room from the room for - Have a TV in the waiting area to entertain patients.
building is used for tea room. medications and payment, since the one dealing
with money should be alone.
71
3.4. DEFINING A WAY FORWARD
72
Plans and perspectives
73
View when arriving to the waiting area
When a patient arrives to the waiting area he/she the roof of the building but it has half walls are The examination room that most patients go to first
starts by the registration and payment before sitting made of semipermeable bricks instead of normal is the visual acuity room, where their sharpness
down to wait for an examination or consultation. brick walls. Another alternative is to sit along the of vision if tested. This room needs to be at least 6
There are several different types of waiting areas outdoor path, where the patient can look at people meters long for the test to be done well. After the
with different characters to choose between. One passing by. If a patient is going to the optician he/she visual acuity test, the patient leaves the room to sit
waiting room is more indoor than outdoor, it has can sit and wait in the waiting area that is a bit raised on a bench in the corridor that forms a line to see the
wooden benches and a TV for distraction. Another on top of the underground water tank. doctor who is in the next room. If surgery is needed
waiting area is more outdoor in an area still under a date is booked and he/she goes to the payment and
medication room to pay for the surgery.
74
Plan 1.100
75
Sections and perspectives
76
Section A-A 1:100
Rainwater is collected through the roof and led to an underground water The roof is adapted to catch the prevailing wind for good ventilation. The
tank. The water is then pumped up to another tank above the toilets, roof is ventilated between the roof and the ceiling. Each room also has its
before being used for flushing and washing hands. own vents both at floor level and ceiling level.
rain rain
wc wc wc
water tank
sewage
77
Section C-C 1:100
78
Roof
The roof is designed to collect rainwater. Water is directed to two gutters This detail shows the meeting point between the wall, the ceiling, the
that lead to an underground rainwater tank. wooden trusses, the gutter and the iron sheet roofs. Lighting for the
corridors is also integrated in the detail.
79
Elevations
North elevation 1:100
This facade is along the outer corridor of the
building. The corridor is divided in two long ramps
to connect the surrounding lower areas with the
higher areas.
80
East elevation 1:100
81
Materials
Between ceiling and roof: local sisal poles. Walls: interlocking compressed soiled blocks Locally manufactured bricks of compressed soil
(extotig.gr) (Makiga Engineering) and a small portion of cement.
Walls inside: plastered and painted off white Roof cover: green iron sheets which is Roof structure : wooden trusses
considered beautiful by many locals
Half-walls: semipermeable bricks Floor: polished concrete floor with Columns and ring beam: reinforced concrete.
exposed aggregate
82
Collaborations Budget
It has come forward in discussions with the hospital There is a budget that was estimated for the first
management, that they are interested in using this building proposal. The idea is that if this proposal
design proposal for the eye clinic and implement is taken forward, it has to be able to be built within
it. A first step is to secure the funding, which is the same budget. But to know that, more detailed
hopefully soon done through the collaboration with drawings of the building proposal are needed. Before
CBM. I will, through Architects without Borders, asking a contractor for a tender for constructing the
continue to develop the proposal based on feedback building.
from Kolandoto Hospital. Kolandoto Hospital will
look for a local contractor who would be able to The budget in the justification and funding
build it. application for the first building proposal is between
86701 - 102307 EUR. That means that that proposal
costs maximum 293 EUR / m2 to build.
83
84
4. THE MATERNITY THEATRE EXTENSION
A story about finding a building project and then trying to implement it fast in a good way.
Annika Danielsson - June 2015
85
4.1. DIAGNOSING THE CURRENT CONTEXT
There was a thought from the beginning of the I started the process of finding a building related I was told that the existing operating theatre for
collaborative development project to do some quick project to do by sketching 8 different ideas based on c-sections at the maternity department apparently
and easy interventions connected to the building, observations from the hospital. The project ideas was not in use due to that the hospital felt that they
water and electricity infrastructure during the included building recreational social areas outside could not guarantee the needed hygienic conditions
two months long stay in Kolandoto. The funding the general ward (appendix IV), to renovating the for performing safe c-sections. There was no
came from three different sources. The NGO I Aid general theatre doors to eliminate the dust coming proper place for the doctors to change clothes or
Africa gave 20 000 SEK and the NGO Engineers in (appendix II), making new entrance signs to the scrub before the surgeries, and no proper place for
without borders gave 20 000 SEK. In addition,
hospital, constructing a new public path for visitors cleaning the used equipment and linen. Instead,
the two engineering students and I had together
(appendix III), build a roof over the waste collection pregnant mothers who were in delivery and in need
received a scholarship of 50 000 SEK from ARQ
area by the incinerator, and buying a machine for of emergency c-sections had to be transported out of
forskning. So there was a joint budget of 90 000
SEK that needed to be split through prioritizing manufacturing special building blocks. The ideas the maternity building, and along an outdoor path
among different projects. In the end approximately were summarized on one A4 each and presented to go into the general operating theatre.
45 000 SEK was used for water related projects such to the medical officer in charge along with the
as testing the water quality, doing a test pumping information of that we probably had 20 000 SEK
of the existing borehole, and buying and installing available for this. He then in turn talked with his
a new water pump. Approximately 5 000 SEK was staff during a morning meeting in which they
used for renovating the doors to the general theatre. decided that they would like to start with renovating
And approximately 30 000 SEK was used for the the general theatre doors, but they would also
maternity theatre extension. like to start an extension to the existing maternity
operating theatre.
These projects were however not identified or
decided upon before arriving to Kolandoto. So,
when I arrived there, I had still no idea of what type
of or scale of building related intervention that we
would do.
d by CamScanner
86
4.2. DREAMING OF THE FUTURE
Goal
existing
delivery room
The goal of the intervention was that Kolandoto
Hospital should be able to conduct safe c-sections from ward
in a good environment.
existing
from ward operating theatre
Building programme
from general
entrance / theatre
changing room office room
87
4.3. DEVELOPING ALTERNATIVES AND CONSENSUS
The site Pictures of the site
Plan 1.200
The maternity building seen from a distance. The direction from which patients and staff
arrive to the maternity building.
This in the area where an extension is possible to do. There are three windows in the wall of the existing
The existing theatre is just inside the wall. theatre towards the side for the extension.
88
Initial design proposal
Feedback meeting
The drawing to the right was presented and
explained at a meeting with several doctors and
management staff. At that time I also showed the
exact real size of the rooms for the people to really
comprehend the size and comment on that as well
as the flows of material, patients and staff through
the building. The one feedback that the staff had
was to have only one sink in the scrubbing room
and also to change the side of the sink so that it was
to along the wall to the sluice room. That way the
plumbing would be done easier and shorter towards
the western facade where one inspection chamber
could be built. At this meeting the decision was Iron sheet roof.
taken to move forward with the building plans.
89
4.4. DEFINING A WAY FORWARD
Plan 1.100
Final design proposal
Revisions
Some additional revision were made to arrive to the
construction drawing.
- The width of the new path on the western side was
decreased.
- All rooms were shortened a bit to ensure that the
iron rods holding up the roof over the path to the
north would not need to be moved.
- An updated measurement of the existing building
was made and the width of the extension was slightly
adjusted to that.
- A small indention of the new concrete block walls
shown in the construction drawing was made, to
make it possible for the plaster to connect smoothly
to the existing building.
- The width of the concrete block walls were adapted
to the actual width of the block we were to buy for
the construction.
Materials
Roof: wooden trusses and iron sheets
Walls: cement blocks
Doors: wooden doors
Windows: aluminium frames
90
Budget Timeplan
Budget decisions
The initial budget was discussed with the hospital
management. The budget was higher than hoped
for and it was obvious that the construction could
not be completed with only the funds from the
Swedish donors. Then it was decided that the
hospital would add the remaining needed money to
complete the building, as they had offered before as
well. The floor tiles were removed from the project,
and a simple cement floor was chosen instead.
91
4.5. CONSTRUCTING THE BUILDING
After the lists of materials were agreed upon the Once the construction started I spent a lot of time
responsible craftsman, myself, a driver and often a on coordinating the different craftsmen and the
hospital employee who acted as a translator went time management of the construction. Throughout
together to buy the material. The lists of materials the construction we tried to keep a good speed to be
with the estimated costs was of big help in the cost able to finish as much as possible before I was going
negotiations to not be tricked into paying too much. to leave Kolandoto.
Sometimes we also decided to now buy everything
at once. For example, we did not buy all of the With my previously limited knowledge on
estimated 39 kg of nails for the roofing at once, but construction processen in the context, it was difficult
added more later when it was needed. to try to make a detailed timeplan so I relied to a
large extent on the experts - the craftsmen. I tried
to make a comprehensive plan in the beginning and
Plastering around one of the door frames. stick to it. But I realised fast that it had to be dynamic
since people were a bit time optimistic sometimes
and since the exact order of the steps in the process
not was clear from the beginning.
92
Construction supervision
I supervised and checked the quality of the work
at the construction site. Several changes had to be
made during the process. One issue that was up for
discussion among the roofing craftsman, the hospital
management and me was that the inclination of one
of the roofs over the paths was leaning towards the
facade. At first a gutter was the plan to divert the
water from the facade, but this later changed into
changing the inclination of the roof to the other
direction instead.
93
Documenting the process
1. The site for the extension. 2. The two trees has been taken down. 3. The roof over one of the paths is taken down and the
The existing theatre is just inside the wall. water pipes crossing the site are being moved.
4. Digging for the foundation. 5. The first cement blocks have been places and the 6. The walls are coming up and one can start to
craftsmen are double checking the measurements. see where the windows and doors will be.
94
7. The walls are higher and the AC in one of the 8. The wooden frames for the ring beam of 9. Another layer of bricks above the ring beam.
existing windows is removed. steel reinforce concrete is taken down. Wholes for the plumbing were made.
10. Wooden trusses are put in place for the roof, 11. The wood was treated to last longer. 12. The iron sheets and the gutter boards are put up.
and preparations for electrical wiring is done.
95
13. The stump of the tree is removed and the ground 14. Plastering the walls. 15. Building the new path for the entrance doors, at the
smoothened in preparation for the new path to be built. same time as electrical wiring is going on.
16. The wooden frames for the doors are installed, and 17. The inclination of roof over the path to the left was 18. The corners for the windows and doors
so are the switches for internal and external light. changed to direct rainwater away from the building. are plastered to look good.
96
19. Pipes for the water and plumbing are installed. 20. The cement floors are made, and one more layer of 21. An inspection chamber for the plumbing is made,
brick is added for the new path. and the ceiling boards have been put up.
22. Wooden doors and aluminium framed windows 23. The doors are varnished and 24. The building is painted.
are installed. glass installed above the doors.
97
98
5. DISCUSSION AND REFLECTION
99
5.1. HEALTHY HOSPITAL DESIGN ...
This relates back to the overarching issue of the right The masterplan proposal improves the healing
OUPATIENT ENTRANCE
shops shops
to health and the question posed in the beginning: environment by for example suggesting more KITCHEN waste zone
public
square
OUTPATIENT
DEPARTMENT
How can a masterplan for Kolandoto Hospital defined outdoor spaces that can be used as part of mortuary REPRODUCTIVE
CHILD HEALTH
lab
support the access to appropriate healthcare in the care and care giving environment with recreation GENERAL
MEDICAL WARD
GENERAL
SURGICAL WARD
PARKING
CARE
TREATMENT
CLINIC
a healing environment free from factors causing in nature. Wayfinding and clarity that will make
DENTAL
PHYSIO.
dispensary
illness or poor health? the experience more pleasant and less stressful for PAEDIATRIC
WARD
EYE
CLINIC
During the process of developing the masterplan also improved in the proposal.
paediatric IMAGING
OUTPATIENT STAY
ward WASHING
family WARD steril. imaging laundry
LINES
planning eye
DIAGNOSTICS
approach the question were revealed. There are The process of creating a masterplan in itself is
MATERIALS
maternity
PUBLIC AND ward SOCIAL
workshop
NON-HOSPITAL HALL
some ways to deal with creating an environment that an approach to improve the access to appropriate
PRIVATE WARD
FUNCTIONS
PHARMACY RESOURCE
STAFF AND MATERNITY CENTER
ADMINISTRATION WARD
does not cause illness or poor health, some ways to healthcare. A proper masterplan with agreed CAPTIAL LETTERS = new
small letters = existing
try to create a healing environment, and some ways priorities and medical justifications can be used as a A masterplan for peoples health.
STAFF ENTRANCE
GOODS ENTRANCE
to improve the access to appropriate healthcare. base for resource prioritization within the hospital,
and resource mobilization from possible donors for
One way to try to make the environment in the implementation of the identified building projects.
masterplan proposal less dangerous for peoples It also provides better possibilities for the hospital
health has been to analyze and design the flows of management to really have ownership over the
patients, staff, visitors and goods at the hospital site. development process at the hospital, especially in
Dangerous delays in service delivery are minimized relation to the international development sector and
in the proposal, as was the case with the long and possible donors. This might speed up the process
inefficient emergency flow. The flow of outpatients for delivering the needed and future needed health
have been defined, shortened, and kept to one area care services to the surrounding communities.
in the hospital site in an attempt to decrease the The resource mobilization and prioritization
risk of spread of infections and infectious diseases. possibilities are also of help in the ongoing process
Unnecessary congestion of visitors around more for the hospital to become a Council Designated
clean and critical services such as the general theatre Hospital and provide cheaper service to the people
and the maternity theatre are decreased in the and fill a service void in the health care system. A climate adapted sustainable design for an eye clinic.
proposal to minimize risk of infections and delays.
100
... for a healthy environment ... for a healthy approach to the
international development sector
This topic relates back to the overarching issue of
sustainable building techniques and the question This topic relates to the overarching issue of the representative within the international development
posed in the beginning: How can sustainable relation to the international development sector sector shared the ideas, the decisions, the funding,
building techniques for a tropical be applied to a and the question posed in the beginning: How is it and the responsibilities during construction for the
building design at Kolandoto Hospital? possible to implement a good quality architectural maternity theatre extension project.
intervention at Kolandoto Hospital during a two
The climate adaption of a building and building months study visit? Another approach is to make the process
for a healthy environment was investigated through
participatory, through communicating a lot with
the process of creating a design proposal for a Within the collaborative development project different people in different formats and settings.
new eye clinic. Early on in the process it became setting of this thesis I was in a situation where I could We had office meetings, site meetings, skype
clear that the first step was to clarify what type of be part of creating problems concerning ownership meetings and informal side discussions. The
tropical climate Kolandoto has, since there are six over and benefits from the project. To try to mitigate meetings and discussions were with nurses, doctors,
different defined climatic types within the tropical this risk I used different approaches in finding and management staff, patient relatives, craftsmen,
climate. Kolandoto Hospital is in the hot semi-arid implementing a building related intervention. funding organizations, material suppliers etc. In
/ savannah zone. The next step was to research and
each meeting I tried to have a humble approach and
summarize different techniques that are applicable One approach was to try to incorporate a shared listen to the expert knowledge of different aspects
to that specific climate. ownership throughout the process by first being for the project.
aware of the possible power imbalance due to
The last step was to merge and incorporate the history and the sources of funding in a project of
techniques together with all other design criteria this kind, and trying to counteract it. This started in
regarding flows, connectivity, room size, and the process of trying to find a project. I gave several
atmosphere for the building into the final design alternatives of smaller projects to the hospital
proposal. The building is oriented with the long axis management along with a request to give project
going east-west in the design proposal, and windows ideas of their own, and also gave information about
are well protected from sun rays to minimize solar the exact available funding. With that, I handed
radiation and create a good indoor climate without over the decision of what to try to implement to the
using mechanical climate control systems. The hospital management who held a discussion in an
roof is ventilated between the ceiling and the high occasion when I was not there and then came back
reflectivity roof for similar reasons. The walls are to me with their decision. I avoided the situation in
suggested to be built with compressed soil bricks which I would come with a project suggestion, and
which is a technique that require less cement during the hospital saying yes to the incoming funding
manufacturing and assembly of the bricks. Another irrespectively of their internal priorities around A maternity theatre extension through joint efforts.
benefit for the environment is that the bricks are development. In the end, the hospital as well as I as a
locally produced and hence need less transport.
101
5.2. THE ARCHITECTS ROLE AS ...
... a hospital planner ... a designing architecture
and process leader consultant ... a project manager
In the large scale of creating a masterplan for In the scale of a middle-sized building design I In the small scale of building an extension to
Kolandoto Hospital I had the chance to be a had the opportunity to be a designing architecture the maternity theatre my job was to be a project
hospital planner that needed to apply a holistic consultant who got the specific task of drawing manager. The work included finding a good project
approach to the multitude and complexity of design a design proposal for a new eye clinic building for the available funding, designing the building,
considerations to find a feasible proposal. I used my presented to me from a client. Different creative supervising and coordinating the construction, time
previous knowledge about specific requirements methods had to be used to understand the conditions planning and book keeping. With those tasks I had
for hospital environments alongside an openness of a site, the size and connectivity requirements of to handle uncertainties and make sure the project
to the specific requirements of Kolandoto Hospital. a programme, and generate ideas for the design of moved forward in a good way anyway. Problems
As a process leader for the masterplan I had to see the building. The work required to move between needed to be solved along the way and decisions
situations from different perspectives and apply my abstract design concepts of the building being calm, connected to quality and budget and outcomes had
skills in facilitating workshops and meetings to get clear and comfortable, to tangible and technical to be taken in collaboration with different actors.
other peoples ideas and knowledge to the surface details of construction. The connections between
before merging them, the priorities of the hospital small scale choices for materials to the global vision
and my expertise in a final masterplan proposal. of building environmentally friendly were seen and
highlighted in the design process.
102
5.3. A RICH PROJECT WITH ...
... different scales ... several focuses ... many stakeholders
The sub-projects in the thesis spans over a variety The three sub-projects in the thesis had different This thesis was set within the larger framework of
of scales - from the large scale planning work of focuses, but knowledge from the different focus areas a collaborative development project called Healthy
creating a masterplan proposal, to the middle scale was also integrated in the other sub-projects. The Hospital in which many different stakeholders
of an eye clinic building design proposal, to the overarching issue in focus for the eye clinic design were involved. Kolandoto Hospital played a huge
small scale of building a minor extension to the proposal was sustainable building techniques, role in terms of being the case and setting for the
maternity theatre. Outcomes of the different scales and knowledge from that was also applied in the thesis. The villagers and staff of the hospital were
of sub-projects supported the other sub-projects. maternity theatre extension project through for wonderful in welcoming all discussions and ideas
The knowledge about available building materials example the naturally ventilated space between the that I put forward, and responding with honesty
and local construction techniques gained through roof and the ceiling to create a good indoor climate. and enthusiasm. The NGO I Aid Africa, was
implementing the building extension, was useful The research done for the masterplan project invaluable in acting as the coordinator and project
when designing the building proposal. Knowledge regarding the overarching issue of the right to health, leader with the help of their previous experience of
and understanding of how indoor and outdoor space was also used in the design proposal for the eye clinic collaborating with the hospital around aid projects.
normally is used at the hospital was gained in the eye building design through for example incorporating The NGO Architects without Borders was key in
clinic sub-project, and later used in the masterplan clear wayfinding in the design proposal, which is providing guidance in architectural discussions for
proposal in terms of the layout of building volumes a feature that is part of a healing environment for the set up and fulfillment of the thesis. The NGO
in relation to each other. The trust built through peoples wellbeing. The overarching issue of the Engineers without Borders helped with technical
clearly showing that the hospital should do the relation between the hospital and the international knowledge concerning water and energy issues. The
prioritization of projects in the masterplan process, development sector was in focus in the maternity tutors and fellow students from Chalmers University
is assumed to have made it easier for hospital staff to theatre extension project, but also well incorporated of Technology that were involved in the project,
clearly voice their opinions concerning the design in the masterplan project. The masterplan proposal provided both encouragement and academic
of the maternity theatre extension project without is adapted to how the hospital intermittently receives guidance in carrying out the field study and finishing
fearing that the donors would leave. Another funding for physical improvements from donors in the thesis. Financially, the Healthy Hospital project
example is that the credibility of my intention to the international development sector. The design and the thesis work was supported by the hospital,
create feasible design proposals for the masterplan of the masterplan with ten stepwise infill building the involved NGOs and by scholarships from the
and eye clinic building was probably supported projects is expected to make it easier for the hospital Swedish International Development Cooperation
through implementing the concrete building to own the development and clearly communicate to Agency (SIDA), Stiftelsen forsk foundation and
extension to the maternity theatre. In addition to the the donors what the hospital would like to prioritize. ARQ foundation. To take in and balance the diversity
aforementioned scales of the sub-projects, the long- These are just some examples of how the knowledge of perspectives, experiences and opinions from the
term timescale of the collaborative development gained through the focus in one sub-project has many stakeholders have been both a huge challenge
project that forms the framework of the thesis was a influenced the proposals in the other sub-projects. and a crucial framework for the realization of the
good foundation for a successful thesis. thesis.
103
6. REFERENCES
Published sources
Caira, C. (2011) Mpongwe Mission Hospital Masterplan WHO (2002) Prevention of hospital-acquired infections Wikipedia (2015) Shinyanga. Accessed 20150305:
2011-2021 Gteborg: Fototext AB - a practical guide. 2nd edition Malta http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shinyanga
Clancy, C. C. (2008) Designing for safety: evidence- Online sources World Health Organization (2013) The Right to
based design and hospitals. American Journal of Health. Accessed 20140813: http://www.who.int/
Medical Quality, 23(1), 66-69 Bing (2015) Map of Africa, Tanzania, Shinyanga. mediacentre/factsheets/fs323/en/
Accessed 2015201: www.bing.com/maps
Francis, Susan (2007) Future-proofing Buildings Unpublished sources
for Healthcare Hospital Engineering and Facilities Butaro Hospital (2011) Partners in Health. Accessed
JIMCON LTD (2014) Drawings of proposed optical
Management 20140920: http://www.pih.org/pages/butaro-hospital
department building to be built at Kolandoto area in
Shinyanga municipal
French, M.A. (ed) (2011) Change by Design - building Butaro Hospital / MASS Design Group (2011).
communities through participatory design ArchDaily. Accessed 20140714: http://www.archdaily.
Kolandoto Hospital (2015) Draft Project Idea Form for
com/?p=165892
construction of an eye OPD
MASS Design Group (2013) Standards for Health
Infrastructure. Ministry of Health and Social Welfare Cary, J. and Martin, C. E. (2012) Dignifying Design.
UN-Habitat (2015) Energy and Resource Efficiency
Republic of Liberia New York Times. Accessed 20140914: http://www.
Building Code for Tropical Climates Unpublished
nytimes.com/2012/10/07/opinion/sunday/dignifying-
report draft.
Mkony, M. E. (2009) Designing Healing - A Conceptual design.html?pagewanted=all&_r=1&
Model for Promoting a Healing Health Care Environment
Vision (2014) CBM Statistics
in Tanzania. Gteborg: Department of Architecture Google (2015) Map of Kolandoto Village. Accessed
at Chalmers University of Technology 20150201: www.google.com/maps
Danielsson, A. (2014) Visit Report: Kolandoto Hospital
July 2014
UN-Habitat (2014) Sustainable Building Design for Landguiden (2014) Tanzania. Accessed 20150302:
Tropical Climates - Principles and Applications for East http://www.landguiden.se/Lander/Afrika/Tanzania
Africa. Nairobi: UN-Habitat
MASS Design Group. Accessed 20140917: http://www.
WCED World Commission on Environment and mass-group.org
Development (1987) Our Common Future.
WHO and OHCR (2008) The Right to Health. Accessed
20140813: http://www.who.int/hhr/activities/Right_
to_Health_factsheet31.pdf?ua=1
104
Other good sources
Dokkedahl, T. L., Vang Petersen, F. S., and Andersen, Standard Guidelines and Drawings for District and UN-Habitat (2012) Going Green: a handbook of
S. (ed) (2013) Developing architecture: learning from Regional Hospitals in Tanzania (2009) The United sustainable housing practices in developing countries.
Sierra Leone. Architecture Sans Frontier Denmark. Republic of Tanzania, Prime Ministers Office, Nairobi: UNON Publishing Service Section
Denmark: Forlaget PB43 Regional Administration and Local Government
Zaretsky, Michael. (unknown) Research Informing
Hamdi, Nabeel. (2004) Small Change: about the art of Vanamo, Pilvi. (2010) Kijiji Cha Watoto : Village of Design: A Zero-Energy Health Center in Rural
practice and the limits of planning in cities. New York: Children. Master thesis KTH School of Architecture Tanzania. University of Cincinnati
Earthscan
105
7. APPENDICES
Appendix I: Placement suggestions
WAITING RM
RCH
EXTEND THESE RMS
PRIVATE WD PHYSIO.
SHIFT SOCIAL XRAY
X RAY EXTEND WD
HALL AND CASUALITY RM MINOR
EXTEND POST-NATAL PARKING
KITCHEN TO THEATRE
EXAM RM RECEPTION
SCHOOL EXTEND WAITING AREA
EXTEND IMMUNIZATION RM OPD
EYE OPD
CASUALITY
This map shows all the suggestion on RECOVERY RM
placement of different spatial needs SLUICE SUPPLY STORE
EYE OPD
at the hospital, that were put forward MALNUTRITION RM FAMILY PLANNING ICU
during a programming workshop
STAFF
with the head of department staff at
CUBICSAT
the hospital. DELIVERY RM
106
Appendix II: Door renovation
Scanned by CamScanner
The door gap lets air and dust enter
directly into the theatre.
We went to the timberyard to find the best material. The inner parts of the old doors are reused. Two of the three doors we renovated, before painting.
107
Appendix III: A new public path
This proposal originates from the analysis of flows The visitors going to the eye ward today pass over the Proposal: It is recommended to only start with the
through the hospital. The aim of the proposal is to parking area where the hospital is planning to build path going from the gate to the general ward. The
have less congestion around the paths in front of the a new eye clinic building. A new public path from path going from the gate towards the OPD should
family planning and CTC. Today all visitors that to the entrance square towards the OPD areas (right in only be constructed once the new eye clinic building
the general ward, the pediatric ward, the maternity the illustration below) and the path connecting to is finished. When the final design for the public
ward and the private ward start by walking up to the the eye ward would be useful for visitors going to the path is made, it is also important to consider the
family planning building, and then from there go eye ward. Both of these paths would also be useful rainwater and that the whole hospital site is sloping
to the different wards. A new piece of a public path for staff walking between the general ward and the slightly towards west and the main entrance area.
from the entrance square towards the general ward laboratory in the OPD area. A cost estimation for
(left in illustration below) would be useful for all building this public path was done and is included
visitors to the general ward and the pediatric ward. in the Survey Report given to the NGOs.
current
visitor flow
future
visitor flow
new
public path
current
visitor flow
future
People already walk along part of the suggested path.
visitor flow
new
current
public path
visitor flow
future new eye clinic
visitor flow building
new
108 public path
Problem description:
The general ward accommodates both patients
who are immobile and mobile. The more mobile
patients sometimes gets bored from trying to stay
in bed the whole day and are hence often walking
outside the ward to sit along the walkway. Relatives
bring food for the inpatients three times per day.
Patients sometimes eat the food by their bed, but
many also walk outside to sit along the walkway, on
the walkways or on the ground to eat.
Proposal:
The proposal is to build social areas for inpatients
in connection to the general ward. The social areas
should facilitate for sitting under a roof. Some of
Scanned by CamScanner
the activities that would take place in the social
areas include: looking at nature, breathing fresh air,
playing games, talking/socializing, watching other
people passing by, and eating the food brought by
relatives. It has been shown that patients recover/
heal faster if they have regular contact with family
and nature.
Cost estimation:
To the right is a section sketch showing the current A preliminary cost estimation for a section of
walkway leading to the general ward in the middle. benches and roof on one side of the existing walkway
The suggestion is to add two new roofs along that for 10 meters was done and is included in the Survey
walkway, one on each side, under which benches Report to the NGOs. The total cost estimated for
and tables are built. A closer assessment of exactly those 10 meters is 1046000 TSH. A guess is that it
where along the path this is suitable, and how would be good to provide such social areas for
many seating places can be included, along with approximately 30 meters in total, which means
a more detailed design, should be made before that a budget on approximately 3138000 TSH is
implementation is started. advisable. While budgeting for such an intervention
is is however advisable to maybe increase the budget
with minimum 20%, which makes for 3765600 TSH.
Patients eating on the ground.
109
Appendix V: Reorganization of the imaging department
Problem description:
The proposal includes three modifications to the
The layout of the imaging department today is a
building: 1) Exchanging a current window in the
problem since the doors for entering the department
x-ray room to become a door. This window is 1260
are too narrow for a stretcher to go through without
mm wide, and the staff express that a door this size
trouble. This means that there are situations in
would also be enough for patients on stretchers.
which patient who cannot walk have to be carried on
The door has to be thick with metal protection.
his/hers mattress to be able to enter the x-ray room.
2) Remove one old piece of a wall in the current
This is troublesome, dangerous and painful for the
reception room to make the room have enough
patients who sometimes are severely injured. The
space for accommodating ultrasound examination
current entrance situation also causes the patients
activities. Before making this one has to ensure that
going for x-ray to have to enter and then turn back
the stability of the building structure is not affected.
360 degrees in the building which makes taking an
3) Building a floor and roof for the new waiting
x-ray even more troublesome for the patient and the
area. It is an area of 2.8 m times 5.1 m. This probably
staff.
requires four new pillars.
Proposal:
Cost estimation:
The proposal includes changing the layout of the
A preliminary cost estimation was provided in the
imaging department to facilitate for an easier and
Survey Report to the NGOs. The total preliminary
not dangerous entrance situation for patients.
cost is 1345000 TZS.
Carrying a patient through the door.
LAYOUT TODAY
LAYOUT PROPOSAL
110
Appendix VI: Inpatient and visitor flows
WARD
PHARMACY
MATERNITY
At nighttime the OPD is closed. This has the WARD
SPECIAL
LAUNDRY WORKSHOP
effect that outpatients will enter through the main CANTINECARE
CTC
GENERAL
PARKING
gate, and are then expected to find their way to PRIVATE
WARD
PAEDIATRIC TREATMENT
CLINIC
THEATRE
WARD
the appropriate ward where the examination and
PHARMACY
consultation can take place. INPATIENT
FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDRY
OUTPATIENT PLANNING
An overall issue with the outpatient flow is that is
DENTAL
quite spread out throughout the whole hospital EMERGENCY DELIVERY C-SECTION
INFUSION
THEATRE
CARE SUPPLY
area. This causes confusion and also means that the STORE
outpatient flow is crossing for example the inpatient DELIVERY
and emergency flow. MATERNITY
WARD
VISITORS
STUDENTS CANTEEN
PRIVATE
WARD
STAFF
GOODS AND
112 MATERIALS
Appendix VIII: Delivery and emergency care flow
them. It is not clear where someone from the staff GENERAL WARD
open space in front of the family planning building, DISPENSARY WASTE ZONE INCINE
gather enough people to carry the patient through FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL. CHILD HEALTH
IMAGING LAUNDRY
REPRODUCTIVE
PLANNING EYE
the doors on a mattress. CHILD HEALTH
THEATRE
DENTAL
INFUSION
DELIVERY
The main issue is that the emergency flow is too STORAGE ADMINISTRATION
PRIVATE TREATMENT
WARD PAEDIATRIC
WARD CLINIC
The delivery flow is that the pregnant mothers PAEDIAT
WA
mainly come through the main gate. They are taken INPATIENT
to the maternity ward where they are examined. If INPATIENT
OUTPATIENT
the mother needs to wait before delivery, she might
OUTPATIENT
be admitted to the ward. If the delivery is ongoing, EMERGENCY DELIVE
she might immediately enter the delivery room in CARE EMERGENCY
the maternity ward. be performed. There is an operating room for CARE
DELIVERY
c-sections in the maternity building, but it is not in MATER
DELIVERY WARD
However, if the mother needs a c-section she will use at the moment since the staff feel they cannot VISITORS
be transported out from the maternity ward and ensure proper hygienic conditions due to the lack of STUDENTS
VISITORS
on to the general ward where the c-section will a changing room, a scrub room and a sluice room. PRIVAT
STUDENTS WARD
STAFF
STAFF
GOODS AND
MATERIALS
113
GOODS AND
MATERIALS
Appendix IX: Staff and student flow
The college and the hospital are closely related and COLLEGE
PUBLIC
collaborate on many areas. Part of the education for MORTUARY SOCIAL
HALL
WASTE ZONE
OUTPATIENTPUBLIC
INCINERATOR SQUARE
DEPARTMENT
the students is done at the hospital taking part in the WASTE ZONE INCINERATOR SQUARE LAB
kitchen and the social hall. This results in that 500 CHILD HEALTH
GENERAL WARD
REPRODUCTIVE
students pass through the hospital area three times CHILD HEALTH
SPECIAL
EYE WARD
per day to get their food at the kitchen and social CARE
CTC
GENERAL
COLLEGE
KITCHEN
PARKING EYE CLINIC
hall. This flow is unnecessary and not related to the PAEDIATRIC
TREATMENT
CLINIC
OFFICE THEATRE
be there at all. The students are also part of creating FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDRY
PLANNING SPECIAL
EYE
congestion along the path in front of the CTC CTC
THEATRE
DENTAL SPECIAL CARE GE
and family planning. The students also take the DELIVERY
INFUSION CTC
PAEDIATRIC TREATMENT TH
CARE GENERAL
CLINIC
opportunity to exit in other directions than to the PAEDIATRIC
STORAGE TREATMENT
WARD ADMINISTRATION THEATRE PARKING
CLINIC
college, using the hospital area as a way of taking a WARD
INPATIENT
MATERNITY
shortcut to reach other parts of the village. INPATIENT
WARD
LAUNDRY
FAMILY
PHARMACY
PHYSIO. ST
WORKSHOP
OUTPATIENT FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL.
PLANNING
IMAGING LAUNDRY
CANTINE
What there is to say about the staff flow is that they OUTPATIENT
PRIVATE
PLANNING
WARD EMERGENCY DELIVERY C-SECTION
INFUSIO
enter from two gates and then the flow of staff is all EMERGENCY CARE
DELIVERY C-SECTION
INFUSION
DENTALTHEATRE
over the hospital and is hence not mapped further. CARE THEATRE SUPPLY
DELIVERY STORE
MATERNITY
DELIVERY WARD
VISITORS MATERNITY
WARD
VISITORS
STUDENTS
PRIVATE CANTEEN
STUDENTS WARD
STAFF PRIVATE
WARD
STAFF
GOODS AND
GOODS AND MATERIALS
MATERIALS
114
Appendix X: Goods and materials flow
and goods that are used and reused at the hospital. MORTUARY SOCIAL
HALL
OUTPATIENT
DEPARTMENT LAB COLLEGE
MORTUARY SOCIAL
The goods delivered to the hospital mainly arrives GENERAL WARD HALL
and to the wards. Solid waste is carried in buckets FAMILY PHYSIO. STERIL. IMAGING LAUNDR
OUTPATIENT
MATERNITY PLANNING
to the waste zone, where it is either burnt in the WARD
LAUNDRY WORKSHOP
DENTAL
incinerator or thrown in pits dug in the ground. EMERGENCY CANTINE DELIVERY C-SECTION
INFUSION
THEATRE
The illustration is a rough simplification of the flows CARE PRIVATE
WARD
SUPPLY
STORE
of equipment and consumables. DELIVERY
MATERNITY
WARD
VISITORS
STUDENTS CANTEEN
PRIVATE
WARD
STAFF
GOODS AND
MATERIALS
115
Appendix XI: Mapping of buildings
The general theatre building. The nursing station during a tea break.
116
Maternity ward and delivery Paediatric ward Eye ward and clinic
Approximate size: 390 m2 Approximate size: 230 m2 Approximate size: 470 m2
Building condition: good Building condition: good Building condition: good
Quick problems: Quick problems: Quick problems:
- too small rooms in general - have both eye ward and eye clinic in the same
- congested building
- lack changing room, scrub room and sluice room - congestion
for the c-section operating theatre
117
Eye theatre Pharmacy Laundry
Approximate size: 100 m2 Approximate size: 210 m2 Approximate size: 70 m2
Building condition: good Building condition: poor Building condition: poor
Quick problems: ? Quick problems: Quick problems:
- small rooms - laundry falling on the ground while drying
- small entrance
- difficult to clean
- sunlight
- lack sink for washing hands
118
Imaging department Central sterilization unit Physiotherapy
Approximate size: 100 m2 Approximate size: 40 m2 Approximate size: 30 m2
Building condition: poor Building condition: fair Building condition: poor
Quick problems: Quick problems: ? Quick problems:
- narrow doors - too small
- tricky internal logistics for patients - dilapidated
Patients waiting for the x-ray. The physiotherapy building is in a poor condition.
119
Infusion unit Supply store Dental unit
Approximate size: 80 m2 Approximate size: 40 m2 Approximate size: 40 m2
Building condition: good Building condition: poor Building condition: good
Quick problems: Quick problems: Quick problems: ?
- hot and humid inside - too small
- internal logistics
120
Outpatient department Laboratory department Leprosy ward
Approximate size: 330 m2 Approximate size: 210 m2 Approximate size: ??
Building condition: poor Building condition: good Building condition: poor
Quick problems: Quick problems: Quick problems: ?
- lack proper waiting areas - stormwater runoff - far away from the rest of the hospital
- congestion along paths - lack proper waiting areas
- poor accessiblity
- leaking roofs
- small rooms
- dilapidated
121
Reproductive Child Health Clinic Care Treatment Clinic (CTC) and Special CTC Administration
Approximate size: 230 m2 Approximate size: 150 m2 Approximate size: 300 m2
Building condition: poor Building condition: good Building condition: fair
Quick problems: Quick problems: Quick problems:
- too small - waiting areas for special CTC (patients with both - internal logistics
- lack some rooms HIV and TBC) - lack large meeting spaces
- far away from the laboratory
- dilapidated
122
Social hall Cantine Mortuary
Approximate size: 280 m2 Approximate size: 60 m2 Approximate size: 50 m2
Building condition: poor Building condition: good Building condition: good
Quick problems: ? Quick problems: ? Problems:
Quick problems:
- lack good refridgerator capacity
The cantine.
There is a social hall located within the hospital area
for the students at the college.
123
Workshop Kitchen Main entrance
Approximate size: 150 m2 Approximate size: 80 m2 Approximate size: 320 m2
Building condition: fair Building condition: poor Building condition: fair
Quick problems: ? Quick problems: Quick problems:
- dilapidated - some unfinished shops
- rainwater runoff
The workshop is for smaller reparations. The main entrance to the hospital is through a small
square with some dukas (shops) around.
124