Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
DOI 10.1007/s40596-016-0593-0
EMPIRICAL REPORT
reviewed using the DBT adherence scale(Korslund and PGY IV year. Nineteen of the residents were in their PGY
Linehan. Dialectical Behavior Therapy Adherence Coding III year. Six were male, 19 were female. The demographic
Scale, University of Washington (Unpublished)) (by author breakdown of the 25 residents was as follows: 18
BSB, who is a trained DBT adherence rater). Caucasians, 4 Asians, and 3 African Americans.
Using the DBT adherence rating system, we rated the res-
idents on 62 DBT behaviors that comprise 10 scales. Each Basic Acquisition of Skill in Conducting Individual DBT
videotape was rated using the DBT adherence scale manual to Psychotherapy
assign a score of 05 on each of the 62 items. A zero rating on
an item indicates that the particular DBT behavior was not From the 25 residents who participated in the DBT curricu-
present and was also not required in a given session. An ex- lum, we rated a total of 45 tapes using the DBT adherence
ample of an item that would receive a zero rating would be the scale (20 baseline and 25 tapes from sessions chosen random-
discussion of termination, which would not be, nor should be, ly from a subset of the total number of taped sessions that were
present, in a first or early psychotherapy session. Any zero conducted in the second half of the training year). We were
score was not counted in the final adherence score. A score missing six baseline tapes due to technical difficulties, refusal
of 1 indicates that the DBT behavior was not used when of patients to consent to videotaping, or timing issues in which
necessary. Scores of 23 indicate that the behavior may residents did not record a videotaped psychotherapy session
have been present in a session but not as often, or in a skilled prior to the DBT intensive training.
manner, as was required to be DBT adherent. A score of 4 Among those who took the DBT curriculum, the average
indicates that the behavior was applied appropriately and de- DBT adherence score of the 20 baseline tapes was 3.2, with
termined to be DBT adherent. A score of 5 indicated excel- scores ranging from 2.1 to 3.9. A score of 4.0 is the cutoff to
lence in applying the DBT behavior appropriately and in a indicate DBT adherence. Thus, none of the residents demon-
DBT-adherent manner throughout the session A total score strated DBT adherence at baseline.
of 4 (an average of the number of items rated) indicates The average DBT adherence score of the 25 later session
DBT adherence. A paired t test analysis was conducted to tapes was 3.9, with scores ranging from 3.0 to 4.2. Eleven of
compare DBT adherence scores at baseline and follow-up. the 25 residents (44 %) obtained a score of 4.0 or higher,
indicating that they had demonstrated adherence to DBT in
Post-graduation Survey that session.
Residents demonstrated significant improvement in 7 of
A 20-item survey was sent to the 62 residents who were en- the 10 strategy areas of DBT clinical behaviors. There was
rolled in the Columbia Psychiatry residency program during no improvement in the areas of cognitive and irreverent strat-
the 5 years (20092014) of the DBT curriculum grant period egies, only a trend toward improvement in contingency man-
and who have since graduated. A description of the survey agement interventions (Table 1). Particular areas of growth
protocol was presented to the Institutional Review Board at were the following: (1) the ability to be directive in structuring
the New York State Psychiatric Institute and was determined individual psychotherapy sessions using diary cards and set-
exempt from review. The participants included 37 residents ting agendas according to the hierarchy of goals; (2) learning
who attended the didactic course only and the 25 graduates how to conduct problem assessments, particularly to define
who participated in the additional clinical training curriculum. problems in behavioral terms, helping patients specifically
The 20-item survey asked graduates to describe the nature of describe their thoughts, cognitions, and behaviors, and
their clinical practice, to indicate which (if any) DBT interven- conducting behavioral analyses when indicated; (3) engaging
tions they were incorporating into their practice, and to rate on in active problem solving using DBT skills; (4) approaching
a five-point Likert scale their level of comfort and confidence patients with a validating stance and utilizing techniques of
in treating individuals with BPD and with suicidal symptoms. warm engagement; and (5) balancing validation with change
We used a Fishers exact text to compare outcomes between strategies and seeking dialectical synthesis, which has to do
the two groups. with identifying opposites in a situation and trying to find the
middle ground. For example, if a patient is having an argu-
ment with her mother and claims that her mother is wrong and
Results that she, the patient, is right, the dialectical intervention might
be to suggest that perhaps mother and patient are both wrong
Participants and both right, which could lead to finding a common ground
or seeing the situation from the others perspective. (See
A total of 25 psychiatry residents enrolled in and completed Table 1 for or paired t test analysis comparing 20 pairs of
the course DBT for Self-Harm: A Clinical Training for baseline and later session adherence to individual DBT strat-
Psychiatry Residents. Six of the residents were in their egies and total DBT adherence scores.)
Acad Psychiatry
majority of residency programs routinely provide basic in- Clinician Psychiatry Track at Boise VAMC has created a DBT
struction in the recognition of risk factors and warning signs on a Shoestring curriculum which consists of an abbreviated 6-
for suicide, learning how to manage these risk factors and month didactic and supervision DBT track for psychiatry resi-
warning signs warrants further attention [18]. Thus, current dents and an 8-week DBT crash course for staff (La Croix.
standard levels of instruction may leave graduating residents Learning to treat patients with self-harm behaviors: two models
feeling under-equipped in the clinical management of suicidal for teaching DBT to psychiatry residents (Unpublished)).
behaviors, which may detract from willingness to and confi- Similarly, the University of Minnesota Residency Training pro-
dence in doing so. In our study, one residents comment re- gram developed an elective DBT curriculum, with weekly con-
flects the sentiment that the full-year curriculum did contribute sultation and study groups for trainees [19]. At the University of
to increased willingness and confidence: Without DBT train- Utah, residents operated a 6-month elective DBT clinic, attended
ing I would be very reluctant to treat borderline personality weekly combined lecture/supervision groups, and obtained on-
disorder patients, and patients with recurring SI or NSSI. On line DBT skills training [20].
the other hand, despite the enhanced exposure afforded by The inclusion of a comparison group to evaluate two levels of
these DBT curricula, about 25 % or more of the residents DBT exposure constitutes a strength of this study and resulted in
nevertheless reported feeling a lack of willingness and confi- our findings that even limited didactic exposure to DBT theory
dence in treating suicidal behavior upon graduation. Thus, and interventions without clinical practice can increase confidence
given the alarming increase in suicide rate in this country over and willingness to treat BPD and suicidal behaviors. Additional
the past decade, residency training programs are one of nu- exposure, in the form of clinical training and supervision, can
merous points of intervention that need to be examined for increase the likelihood and ability to utilize DBT interventions in
improved delivery of evidence-based and best practices for addition to impacting attitude change. Future evaluation studies of
suicide prevention. psychotherapy education can benefit from inclusion of a control
The fact that the graduates in the didactics only group re- group for comparison of different levels of training.
ported gaining as much as they did from the 6-h introductory Another strength of our study was that rather than relying on
DBT course is of interest. The exposure, albeit brief, influ- pre- and post-self-report surveys of DBT practice, DBT skill was
enced some of the residents view of BPD and how to con- evaluated through adherence coding of videotaped psychotherapy
ceptualize the disorder from a DBT perspective. Although sessions. With the advent of new videotape rating scales such as
unlikely, perhaps much of the skill, willingness, confidence, the A-MAP (Cabaniss, personal communication) for residency
and likelihood to use DBT and treat BPD gained in the clinical psychotherapy education, future studies can evaluate trainings in
curriculum can be achieved to some extent through a 6-h psychodynamic and CBT competency areas as well.
didactic course. More certainly, this finding suggests that there Limitations of the evaluation of this curriculum are the follow-
is much to be gained, in terms of educating residents to DBT ing: (1) we did not obtain a baseline rating of willingness and
principles, from relatively limited exposure through a didactic confidence in treating BPD and suicidality among the residents,
course. However, we believe that the small sample size, and and therefore, we cannot be certain that the post-graduate survey
the lack of videotaped sessions in the didactics only group, ratings of these attitudes were attributable to the clinical training,
limited our ability to fully evaluate the differences between the ratherthanbaselinedifferencesininterestinDBTorpsychotherapy
two groups regarding their ability to utilize DBT interven- competence in general among those who chose the curriculum. (2)
tions. In addition, it is possible that this finding might be The rating of the videotapes was not blindauthor BSB rated the
unique to this particular psychiatry residency training pro- tapes and she was also the primary supervisor of the residents in
gram, perhaps due to the competence level, contextual aspects learning DBT, and the tapes were known to be either baseline or
of a larger didactic program, or type of candidates attracted, later sessions when they were rated. (3) The survey did not differ-
and should be further studied in a variety of residency training entiate between recent and remote graduates, and therefore, the
programs. more recent graduates may have not had ample opportunity to
We present a comprehensive clinical training program that utilize DBT in post-graduate practice. In addition, the sample size
was funded by an NIMH grant and which benefitted from the is relatively small and we did not correct for multiple comparisons.
resources available, such as extensively trained clinical faculty Nevertheless, the residents found the DBT training to be an
and a strong psychotherapy training program within the residency important part of their training experience and one that posi-
training program. However, psychiatry residency programs are tively impacted their development as clinicians. DBT training
recognizing the need for and are finding ways to incorporate has given them clinical tools to better understand BPD pa-
certain aspects of DBT clinical training, such as at the State tients and self-harm behaviors, as well as how to intervene.
University of New York Upstate program, where residents can This DBT curriculum was effective in preparing psychiatrists-
elect to observe DBT skills groups [http://www.upstate. in-training and can provide a model for residency training
edu/psych/education/psychotherapy/dialectic.php] with limited programs to incorporate evidence-based practices for effective
resources. The University of Washington/Idaho Advanced treatment of BPD and self-harm behaviors.
Acad Psychiatry
Compliance with ethical standards 8. Kovach JG, Dubin WR, Combs CJ. Psychotherapy training: resi-
dents perceptions and experiences. Acad Psychiatry. 2015;39(5):
Disclosures Dr. Brodsky receives book royalties from Wiley-Blackwell 56774. doi:10.1007/s40596-014-0187-7.
publishers for the book The Dialectical Behavior Therapy Primer: How 9. Korzekwa MI, Dell PF, Links PS, Thabane L, Webb SP. Estimating
DBT can inform clinical practice. the prevalence of borderline personality disorder in psychiatric out-
Dr. Cabaniss receives book royalties from Wiley-Blackwell publishers patients using a two-phase procedure. Compr Psychiatry.
for the books Psychodynamic Psychotherapy and Psychodynamic 2008;49(4):3806. doi:10.1016/j.comppsych.2008.01.007.
Formulation. 10. Lieb K, Voilm B, Rucker G, Timmer A, Stoffers JM.
Dr. Arbuckle reports no conflict of interest. Pharmacotherapy for borderline personality disorder: Cochrane
Dr. Oquendo receives royalties for the commercial use of the systematic review of randomized trials. Br J Psychiatry.
Columbia-Suicide Severity Rating Scales and an honorarium as 2010;196(1):412.
President-Elect of the American Psychiatric Association. Her family 11. Dimeff LA, Woodcock Koerner EA, Beadnell B, Brown MZ,
owns stock in Bristol Myers Squibb. Skutch JM, Paves AP, et al. Which training method works best?
Dr. Stanley receives royalties for the commercial use of the Columbia- A randomized controlled trial comparing three methods of training
Suicide Severity Ratings Scales and royalties from Wiley-Blackwell pub- clinicians in dialectical behavior therapy skills. Behav Res Ther.
lishers for the book The Dialectical Behavior Therapy Primer: How 2009;47(11):92130. doi:10.1016/j.brat.2009.07.011.
DBT can inform clinical practice. 12. Dimeff LA, Woodcock EA, Harned MS, Beadnell B. Can dialecti-
cal behavior therapy be learned in highly structured learning
environments? Results from a randomized controlled dissemination
trial. Behav Ther. 2011;42(2):26375. doi:10.1016/j.
beth.2010.06.004.
13. Dimeff LA, Harned MS, Woodcock EA, Skutch JM, Koerner K,
Linehan MM. Investigating bang for your training buck: a random-
References ized controlled trial comparing three methods of training clinicians
in two core strategies of dialectical behavior therapy. Behav Ther.
1. Linehan M. Cognitive-behavioral treatment of borderline personal- 2015;46(3):28395. doi:10.1016/j.beth.2015.01.001.
ity disorder. New York, NY: The Guilford Press; 1993. 14. Frederick JR, Comtois KA. Practice of dialectical behavior therapy
after psychiatry residency. Acad Psychiatr. 2006;30(1):638.
2. Clarkin JF, Levy KN, Lenzenweger MF, et al. Evaluating three
15. Plakun EM, Sudak DM, Goldberg D. The Y model: an integrated,
treatments for borderline personality disorder: a multiwave study.
evidence-based approach to teaching psychotherapy competencies.
Am J Psychiatry. 2007;164(6):9228.
J Psychiatr Pr act. 2009;15(1):511. doi:10.1097/01.
3. Young JF, Klosko JS, Weishaar ME. Schema therapy: a practi- pra.0000344914.54082.eb.
tioners guide. New York: Guilford Press; 2003. 16. Cabaniss DL, Arbuckle MR. Course and lab: a new model for
4. Bateman A, Fonagy P. Mentalization based treatment for borderline supervision. Acad Psychiatry. 2011;35:2205.
personality disorder. World Psychiatry. 2010;9(1):115. 17. Brodsky BS, Stanley B, Cabaniss DL. Dialectical behavior therapy
5. Blum N, Pfohl B, John DS, Monahan P, Black DW. STEPPS: a for psychiatric residency training programs. Psych Ann.
cognitive-behavioral systems-based group treatment for outpatients 2013;43(4):1628.
with borderline personality disordera preliminary report. Comopr 18. Melton BB, Coverdale JH. What do we teach psychiatry residents
Psychiatry. 2002;43(4):30110. about suicide? A national survey of chief residents. Acad
6. Sharma B, Dunlop BW, Ninan PT, Bradley R. Use of dialectical Psychiatry. 2009;33:4750. doi:10.1176/appi.ap.33.1.47.
behavior behavior therapy in borderline personality disorder: a view 19. Nelson KJ. Dialectical behavior therapy. Psych Annals. 2013;43(4):
from residency. Acad Pychiatr. 2007;31(3):21824. 14950.
7. Sansone RA, Kay J, Anderson JL. Resident didactic education in 20. Lajoie T, Sonkiss J, Rich A. Development and clinical outcomes of
borderline personality disorder: is it sufficient? Acad Psychiatr. a dialectical behavior therapy clinic. Acad Psychiatry. 2011;35(5):
2013;37(4):2878. doi:10.1176/appi.ap.12110194. 3257. doi:10.1176/appi.ap.35.5.325.