Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
12 December 2003
The vomeronasal organ of the accessory olfactory sys- The VNO has a crescent-shaped lumen, the concave side
tem detects pheromones in several vertebrate species. of which has a pseudostratified epithelium consisting of
Recent studies of vomeronasal sensory neurons have receptor neurons, basal cells and supporting cells [7]. It
shown that they express MHC molecules, which in the is generally believed that the receptor neurons express
immune system help to discriminate self antigens from at least one seven-transmembrane G-protein-coupled
non-self antigens. These new findings, along with past receptor from either the V1R family or the V2R family
research demonstrating MHC-based olfactory discrimi- [8]. V1Rs are coexpressed with Gai2 G-protein subunits
nation, suggest the exciting possibility that MHC mol- and are restricted to the luminal VN epithelium. V2Rs are
ecules together with vomeronasal G-protein-coupled coexpressed with Gao and are restricted to the basal
receptors play a role in distinguishing related indivi- vomeronasal epithelium [9]. The fibers from the basal
duals from unrelated ones based on pheromonal cues. vomeronasal epithelium project to posterior AOB, whereas
the projections from the luminal receptor neurons termi-
nate in the anterior AOB [10] (Figure 1a).
The nervous system gathers and stores information and
Ishii et al. [2] and Loconto et al. [3] demonstrated the
enables organisms to interact with the world. The immune
expression of MHC class Ib genes in the basal layer of the
system defends animals against foreign elements. Recent
VNO. These genes are localized to the distal segment of
publications have begun to show that the nervous system
the MHC locus called H2-M. The genes expressed in the
might use the molecules that were considered to be exclu-
VNO fall into two families, M1 and M10. The M1 family
sively in the realm of immunological defense mechanism.
has three genes (M1, M9 and M11) and the M10 family
has six genes (M10.1 M10.6). MHC genes and V2Rs are
MHC class Ib molecules in vomeronasal sensory neurons expressed in specific combinations [2,3]. For example, the
Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules bind M1 family of genes appears to be exclusively expressed
peptide antigens and present them to T lymphocytes with a V2R family called V2rf, whereas the M10 family
(T cells). T cells mount an immune response only if they members are expressed with other V2Rs (Figure 1b).
recognize a foreign (non-self) peptide in conjunction with Loconto et al. [3] showed that vomeronasal neurons
self MHC. Of the two main classes of MHC, class I expressing the V2R called EC1 express only M10.5
molecules are expressed on the surface of nearly all (which is the same as M10.4 [2]; Figure 1b) out of the
nucleated cells, whereas class II molecules are expressed five M10 genes tested. The same group also found that
on antigen-presenting cells of the immune system [1]. , 25% of the cells tested expressed more than one M10
Recently, research groups headed by Peter Mombaerts gene and one cell expressed three M10 genes (Figure 1b).
[2] and Catherine Dulac [3] reported expression of MHC
class Ib genes in the neurons of the vomeronasal organ Possible functions of MHC molecules in the VSNs
(VNO) the chemosensory part of the accessory olfactory Loconto et al. [3] demonstrated that MHC molecules
system (AOS). The AOS in several vertebrate species are associated with V2Rs and b2-microglobulin. In the
functions as a parallel olfactory system that mainly detects immune system, class I molecules have a polymorphic
pheromones. Pheromones are defined as substances that a chain and non-covalently-bound b2-microglobulin.
are secreted to the outside by an individual and received by Therefore, it is likely that the MHC molecules in the
a second individual of the same species, in which they elicit VNO have a tertiary structure similar to that of class I
a specific reaction, for example a particular behavior [4]. molecules in the immune system (Figure 2). Interestingly,
In the AOS, vomeronasal sensory neurons (VSNs) sense association with the MHC molecule and with b2-micro-
pheromones and send signals to the accessory olfactory globulin seems to be essential for expressing the V2Rs on
bulb (AOB), which is located caudal to the main olfactory the dendrites of the vomeronasal receptor neurons [3].
bulb [5]. Often, when an animal senses pheromones it What is the role of MHC molecules in the VNO? Because
engages in stereotypical, hard-wired behaviors, such as MHC molecules function in immune surveillance, they
aggression or mating. Some pheromone-mediated behav- might have a similar function in the VSNs. Ishii et al. [2]
iors, however, depend on learning [6]. argue that this is unlikely, given that the VR1-expressing
neurons in the luminal part of the VNO do not express
Corresponding author: Ashok N. Hegde (ahegde@wfubmc.edu). MHC molecules. Therefore, it is possible that MHC
http://tins.trends.com
Update TRENDS in Neurosciences Vol.26 No.12 December 2003 647
(a)
AOB
Anterior
Posterior
VNO
V NO
MOB
Cortex
s
s s I b m o l e c ule
V1Rs
V2Rs
cla
Luminal
HC
M
Basal
(b)
M9 76100%
M1
5075
2549
1124
M1
0.6
1
M1
1 10
V2rf
M10.6
M10.5
M10.6
M10.5
V2ra
M10.1
M10.5
.5
10
M V2rb
V2rc
EC1-V2R
M
10
.4 .2
10
M
M10.3
TRENDS in Neurosciences
Figure 1. Expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules and G-protein-coupled receptors in the vomeronasal epithelium. (a) Organization of the
vomeronasal organ (VNO) and connection of the vomeronasal receptor neurons to the accessory olfactory bulb (AOB), which is located dorsocaudally to the main olfactory
bulb (MOB). Neurons in the luminal part of the vomeronasal epithelium express V1R vomeronasal receptors; those in the basal part express V2Rs and MHC Ib molecules.
The vomeronasal receptor neurons in the luminal layer (purple) connect to the anterior part of the AOB; those in the basal layer (orange) connect to the posterior AOB.
(b) Combinatorial patterns of MHC molecule and V2R coexpression. The MHC Ib molecules expressed in the VNO are shown outside the circle. The blocks in concentric
pattern inside the outer circle represent specific V2Rs, as indicated by color-coding. The length of the block approximately corresponds to the percentage of MHC-Ib-
expressing cells that express a given V2R gene (percentage scale is indicated to the right). The outer circle represents the data from Ishii et al. [2] and the inner circle
shows data from Loconto et al. [3]. The individual or paired names in the inner circle indicate coexpression of MHC Ib genes in vomeronasal receptor neurons that
express the given MHC Ib gene shown outside the outer circle. For example, cells expressing M10.1 can coexpress M10.5 or both M10.5 and M10.6. The inner circle
also shows expression of one V2R (EC1-V2R) in M10.4-expressing cells (9 out of 9 cells) studied by Loconto et al. [3]. The MHC Ib gene nomenclature is from Ishii et al.
[2]; the gene name conversion from Ishii et al. to Loconto et al. is as follows: M10.1 M10.2; M10.2 M10.1; M10.3 M10.3; M10.4 M10.5; M10.5 M10.7;
M10.6 M10.8.
molecules together with a specific V2R function as multi- to the T cells [11]. Two polymorphic domains of the a chain
meric units of pheromone detection. (a1 and a2) in the class I molecules provide a cleft that is
Does the presence of MHC molecules in the VNO have a capable of binding to a large number of peptides and
behavioral significance? A tantalizing possibility is that provide the immune system with broad discriminatory
MHC molecules in the VNO function to discriminate capacity [12]. Arguments against a discriminatory role for
pheromones of related individuals from the pheromones of MHC molecules in the VNO are: (i) MHC Ib molecules are
unrelated individuals. In the immune system, class I MHC not highly polymorphic; (ii) MHC Ib molecules expressed
molecules aid in recognition of foreign antigens by pre- in the VNO lack some of the residues crucial for peptide
senting short, intracellularly processed peptide antigens binding; and (iii) vomeronasal receptor neurons do not
http://tins.trends.com
648 Update TRENDS in Neurosciences Vol.26 No.12 December 2003
Box 1. Possible role of MHC molecules in distinguishing pheromones from related versus unrelated individuals
There are at least two plausible mechanisms for recognition of phero- a weak signal is transmitted to the accessory olfactory bulb (AOB) that
mone identity (i.e. similarity or dissimilarity to self) by complexes of does not produce a behavioral response. If the peptide bound to an
the V2R vomeronasal receptor with major histocompatibility complex MHC Ib molecule is from an unrelated individual, a strong signal is
(MHC) Ib molecules (Figure I). transmitted to the AOB that produces a behavioral response. Weak
signals in the AOB could be enhanced to generate a behavioral response
Differential signaling in vomeronasal sensory neurons or strong signals could be inhibited to suppress a behavioral response.
According to this model (Figure Ia), there has to be at least one peptide Such modification might depend on the substances released onto the
(or protein) component in the pheromone that carries the individual AOB. Reversal of behavioral outcome by modification of the signal in
the AOB can explain preference for individuals with dissimilar MHCs
identity (for example, fragments of MHC molecules). If such a peptide
during mate selection [19] and preference for related individuals during
from a related individual binds to an MHC-Ib-peptide-binding cleft,
nest building [26]. The selection for MHC molecules that weakly bind
peptides similar to self could be analogous to thymic selection of T cells
(a) in the immune system [27]. According to this scheme, the vomeronasal
sensory neurons (VSNs) bearing V2R MHC Ib complexes that respond
(i)
weakly to peptides similar to self are positively selected, perhaps by
elimination of neurons with strongly responding V2R MHC Ib com-
Weak No behavioral
AOB plexes. How can peptides in the pheromone lead to weak or strong
signal response
signal? There is precedence for differential signaling in the immune
system as well as in the nervous system. For example, the same T-cell
Enhancement receptor initiates different responses depending on the peptide bound
MHC Ib of signal [28,29]. In the nervous system, there are numerous reports of G-protein-
coupled receptors (GPCRs) differentially generating signals upon
Behavioral oligomerization with other molecules [30,31]. In the present model,
response when a peptide with low affinity is bound to the MHC Ib molecule, only
Self partial conformational change occurs in the MHC Ib molecule, allowing
V2R a weak interaction with its signal-transducing partner V2R and thus a
weak signal is generated. By contrast, when a peptide binds to the
(ii) MHC Ib molecule with high affinity, the conformational change is
complete, leading to a strong interaction with the V2R (bi-directional
Strong Behavioral arrow in Figure I) and a strong signal is generated. Such ligand-induced
AOB
signal response oligomerization of GPCRs has been reported [32]. Moreover, accessory
proteins called receptor-activity-modifying proteins (RAMPs) can alter
the signaling property of GPCRs [33,34] and MHC Ib molecules have
Supression
MHC Ib of signal been likened to RAMPs [35]. An alternative way of making the signals
from self-related peptides weak would be to increase the strengths of
No behavioral inhibitory synapses in the AOB through an activity-dependent synaptic
response patterning. This could occur during postnatal development when
Non- animals are exposed to familial pheromones.
self The predicted function of MHC molecules in the vomeronasal organ
V2R
differs from the function of MHC molecules in the immune system: MHC
(b) molecules are present on the antigen-presenting cells, and T cells
respond by generating intracellular signals when presented with a
VSNs Glomeruli Mitral cells foreign peptide and self MHC. However, MHC molecules indirectly take
part in the signal transduction in the immune system. For example, the
extracellular domain of CD8, a molecule in the T-cell receptor complex,
contacts class I MHC molecule on its a3 domain. The cytoplasmic tail of
CD8 contacts the Lck tyrosine kinase, which is part of the signal-
transducing machinery in T cells [36]. Therefore, it is conceivable that
MHC Ib molecules can influence signal transduction by V2Rs through
protein protein interaction as described.
OB
Differential
Segregation of MHC Ib-expressing VSN outputs in the AOB
local modulation A second model is that VSN outputs are segregated (Figure Ib). VSN
(e.g. learning) projections connect to several glomeruli, and second order neurons
(mitral cells) connect to glomeruli that receive projections from VSNs
expressing a specific MHC Ib gene (e.g. M10.1 or M10.4) but not to other
glomeruli. In this model, VSNs can recognize peptides similar to self and
peptides dissimilar to self in an equivalent manner. Some MHC Ib
molecules would have higher affinity to peptides similar to self whereas
others would have higher affinity to peptides dissimilar to self. This
M10.1
situation is like that of olfactory receptors, which tend to have a higher
M10.4 affinity for a specific odorant(s). The VSN projections expressing MHC Ib
molecules with higher affinity to peptides similar to self are segregated
TRENDS in Neurosciences from VSN projections with MHC Ib molecules that preferentially bind
peptides dissimilar to self. Recent work has demonstrated projections
from VSNs carrying a given V2R converge at mitral cells in the AOB [37].
Figure I. Plausible mechanisms for recognition of pheromone identity by com-
plexes of V2R vomeronasal receptors with major histocompatibility complex Examination of the work by Ishii et al. [2] and Loconto et al. [3] reveals
(MHC) Ib molecules. (a) Differential signaling in vomeronasal sensory neurons that there are several unique combinations of V2R-MHC Ib that are
(VSNs). (b) Segregation in the accessory olfactory bulb of outputs from VSNs likely to be sufficient to segregate physically the VSN projections. Also,
expressing different MHC Ib genes (e.g. M10.1 and M10.4). Loconto et al. [3] provide evidence for projection of M10.7-carrying
http://tins.trends.com
Update TRENDS in Neurosciences Vol.26 No.12 December 2003 649
The circadian clock in mammals is located in the hypo- signal transduction are basically unknown. A recent report
thalamic suprachiasmatic nucleus. At the core of the clock by Ikeda et al. provides new insights into the intracellular
are molecular autofeedback loops associated with clock signaling pathways involved in conveying circadian clock
gene transcription. However, the mechanisms of circadian information from the core loop to cellular functions. Cyto-
solic Ca21 is proposed to be a key substance linking
Corresponding author: Sato Honma (sathonma@med.hokudai.ac.jp). the pendulum to the hands of the clock.
http://tins.trends.com