Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Ms. Presley is a Scientologist. The Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR) -- which awarded Mrs.
Weathers its prize -- was formed by the Church in 1969. In fact, the Washington lawyer who launched a
U.S. class- action suit against Ritalin's makers and the American Psychiatric Association is also a senior
Scientology official.
Scientology, in its fight against Ritalin, is pursuing a broader agenda: to undermine the psychiatric
profession. "While alerting parents and teachers to the dangers of Ritalin, the real target of the campaign is
the psychiatric profession itself," the Church stated over a decade ago in its newspaper, Scientology Today.
The Los Angeles-based Church, founded by the late science fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard, has been a
long-time foe of psychiatry. Its teachings include Mr. Hubbard's belief that humans are made of clusters of
spirits, called "thetans," who were banished to Earth about 75 million years ago by an evil galactic ruler
named Xenu. The Church has assembled a celebrity cast of followers, including actors John Travolta, Tom
Cruise and Kirstie Alley.
Mr. Hubbard's breakthrough came in 1950, when he published the book Dianetics: The Modern Science of
Mental Health. One of the Church's staples is a process called clearing, using a crude device -- essentially a
lie detector -- called an E-meter, which measures electrical changes in the skin while subjects reveal
intimate details of their lives. Clearing comes from Mr. Hubbard's claim that unhappiness springs from
mental aberrations called "engrams." Counselling sessions with the E-meter clear these engrams from the
mind.
Psychiatrists and psychologists called the idea worthless, which infuriated Mr. Hubbard. In his writings,
which form the basis of Church doctrines, he said if psychiatrists "had the power to torture and kill
everyone, they would do so. ... Recognize them for what they are; psychotic criminals -- and handle them
accordingly."
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 3 of 22
Totalitarianism, rather than representing the will to dominate others, is about the destruction of
alternate viewpoints and the homogenization of thought as a continual process.131 This continual
movement, which simultaneously destroys and purifies, is the true direction of totalitarianism. The
momentum of totalitarian domination aspires to be unlimited as it spreads around the globe, as exemplified
by Scientology's desire to "clear the planet." The momentum also arises in the enemy status of psychiatry
declared by Scientology. Here, the organization functions as a "movement whose advance constantly meets
with new obstacles that have to be eliminated."134 Another significant part of this motion involves the
constant changes and revisions in policy which characterize all totalitarian movements. As Arendt states,
"the perpetual-motion mania of totalitarian movements can remain in power only so long as they keep
everything moving and set everything around them in motion."135
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 4 of 22
2NC OVERVIEW
The anti-Ritalin movement is orchestrated by the Church of Scientology and their front
group the Citizens Commission on Human Rights. They put out bogus and distorted data
that people like the aff authors rely on. Why? Because they're an evil totalitarian cult
obsessed with destroying psychiatry. This has a few implications:
1. The case has zero credibility. the 1AC is propaganda from a totalitarian organization--
it's impossible to functionally separate the content from the source--throw out every 1AC
card for bias.
3. On the policy-level, the case is outweighed and turned--the plan locks in a major
legislative victory for the Scientologist movement, which enhances its prestige and
efficacy, with the result of homogenizing thought and flipping the Zimmerman impact
--it's a disad and solvency turn.
4. The aff's good intentions are precisely the problem--the only way Scientology can gain
ground is when well-meaning people cite its work second-hand, as the 1AC did, and
obscure the Scientologist origin.
Stephen Barlas and Psychiatric Times staff, Psychiatric Times November 1996 Vol. XIII
Issue 11, URL: http://www.psychiatrictimes.com/p961110.html
In exploring why CCHR and Scientologists have made psychiatry and psychology such a target, Kevin
Dwyer, assistant executive director in charge of government affairs and professional relations with the
National Association of School Psychologists, explained that psychiatrists and psychologists are their
competition. "It is a competitive game," Dwyer explained. "They are trying to make sure they don't lose the
grip on those people."
Peter Dockx, a CCHR spokesperson, declined to answer questions about the Psychiatry booklet and
requested that questions be submitted in writing. Answers were provided in the form of a memo from Jan
Eastgate, president of CCHR International, to Dockx.
Eastgate said the brochure proved so popular that "hundreds of thousands" have been printed in seven
different languages. Moreover, she argued, "It is ludicrous to think that Scientology is in 'competition' with
the incompetence, brutality and lies of psychologists or psychiatrists." Much of her response reiterates
antipsychiatry statements cited in the booklet.
Dwyer said he does not worry so much about people taking CCHR's Psychiatry booklet seriously. "What I
worry about," he explained, "is people quoting this material secondhand, without the attribution to the
Church of Scientology."
VOTE NEG TO EXPOSE AND REJECT THAT LINKAGE. NOW THE LINE-BY-
LINE…
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 5 of 22
It was first described in 1902 and was referred to as Minimal Brain Dysfunction in the '50s, a name which
perhaps more accurately described the physical problem causing the behaviour problems. Modern
techniques of visualising brain activity such as Positron Emission Tomography (PET scanning) have
proved conclusively that ADHD results from certain parts of the brain under-functioning and has nothing
to do with poor parenting.
Using the same technology, Ritalin and other similar stimulants can partly address this problem, thus
reducing the associated behavioural and concentration problems.
Ritalin is no new wonder drug; it was introduced in 1957 and was used quite successfully until a Church of
Scientology lobby group called The Citizens Commission on Human Rights aided by a sensation-
seeking media asserted Ritalin was dangerous, addictive and often used to subdue normally healthy and
exuberant children.
Despite being in use for almost 40 years, there is no evidence suggesting children become addicted to these
drugs.
As a parent of five children between the ages of four and 11, one of whom is a diagnosed ADHD sufferer
and a Ritalin user, I take extreme exception to your report.
It is shallow, ill-informed and could only have one possible effect on readers.
It could instil sufficient fear into parents that they will refuse Ritalin as a legitimate treatment for their
child, thus depriving the child from a quality of life you and I take for granted.
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 7 of 22
The uproar over Ritalin was triggered almost single-handedly by the Scientology movement.
In its fight against Ritalin, Scientology was pursuing a broader agenda. For years, it has been attempting to
discredit the psychiatric profession, which has long been critical of the self-help techniques developed by
the late L. Ron Hubbard and practiced by the church.
The church has spelled out the strategy in its newspaper, "Scientology Today."
"While alerting parents and teachers to the dangers of Ritalin," the newspaper stated, "the real target of the
campaign is the psychiatric profession itself. . . . And as public awareness continues to increase, we will no
doubt begin to see the blame for all drug abuse and related crime move onto the correct target --
psychiatry."
The contempt Scientologists hold for the psychiatric profession is rooted in Hubbard's writings, which
constitute the church's doctrines. He once wrote, for example, that if psychiatrists "had the power to torture
and kill everyone, they would do so. . . . Recognize them for what they are; psychotic criminals -- and
handle them accordingly."
Hubbard's hatred of psychiatry dated back to the 1950 publication of his best-selling book "Dianetics: The
Modern Science of Mental Health." It was immediately criticized by prominent mental health professionals
as a worthless form of psychotherapy.
None of the cases has been successful in court. However, "these efforts, which have been widely reported
in the news media, have created a climate of fear among physicians, parents and educators and have sown
anxiety and confusion among the general public," the Journal of the American Medical Association
reported in 1998.
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 8 of 22
CCHR = SCIENTOLOGY
CCHR was co-founded by Thomas Szasz, and its members take pains to emphasize this fact. Their
connection to ''the Church,'' as they call it, is spoken of less frequently. CCHR is separately incorporated,
and although virtually every CCHR member worldwide also happens to be a member of the Church of
Scientology, this is by choice, the organization says, not by compulsion.
Diller himself is, however, torn by the same conflict many parents have concerning Ritalin. On the one
hand, he says: "As a citizen I must speak out about the social conditions that create the living imbalance.
Otherwise I am complicitous with forces and values that I believe are bad for children." On the other hand,
though, he concludes: "As a physician, after assessing the child, his family and school situation, I keep
prescribing Ritalin. My job is to ease suffering and Ritalin will help round- and octagonal-peg kids fit into
rather rigid square educational holes." 3
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 10 of 22
BLOCK IS LINKED
The network later discovered Dr. Block is a medical consultant to CCHR, and the study she quoted was a
report written the day after the massacre by CCHR vice-president Marla Filidei, amid reports that one of
the Columbine killers, Eric Harris, had been taking the antidepressant Luvox.
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 11 of 22
BAUGHMAN IS LINKED
Ultimately, Dr. Baughman believes, the psychiatric community must answer for the destruction of a
significant portion of America's future. "The victimization of children," he said, "leaving them illiterate and
not educable, is criminal."
The Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR) is an international watchdog group established by the
Church of Scientology in 1969 to investigate, expose and bring to justice psychiatric violations of human
rights.
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 12 of 22
This court finds that the evidence of Peter Breggin, as a purported expert, fails nearly all particulars
under the standard set forth in Daubert and its progeny. . . . . Simply put, the Court believes that Dr.
Breggin's opinions do not rise to the level of an opinion based on "good science." The motion to exclude
his testimony as an expert witness should be granted. -- Magistrate Judge B. Waugh Crigler in Lam v. The
Upjohn Company, No. 94-0033-H, W. Dist., of VA (Harrisonburg Division, U.S. District Court, 1995)
The court believes not only is this gentleman unqualified to render the opinions that he did, I believe that
his bias in this case is blinding. . . . I find that he . . . was not only unprepared, he was mistaken in a lot of
the factual basis for which he expressed his opinion. . . . The court is going to strike the testimony of Dr.
Breggin, finding that it has no rational basis. -- Judge Hilary J. Caplan in Lightner v. Alessi, No.
94013064/CL174959 (Baltimore City Circuit Court, 1995).
Dr. Breggin's observations are totally without credibility. I can almost declare him, I guess from
statements that floor me, to say the he's a fraud or at least approaching that He has made some
outrageous statements and written outrageous books and which he says he has now withdrawn and his
thinking is different. He's untrained. He's a member of no hospital staff. He has not since medical school
participated in any studies to support his conclusions except maybe one. . . . I can't place any credence or
credibility in what he has to recommend in this case. -- Judge James W. Rice in Schellinger v. Schellinger,
No. 93-FA-939-763 (Milwaukee County Circuit Court, 1997)
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 14 of 22
WHITAKER IS LINKED
In place of antipsychotic drugs, Whitaker extols the virtues of "love and food and understanding, not
drugs." Like many antipsychiatry advocates, Whitaker romanticizes the early eighteenth century era of
"moral treatment" in which psychiatric patients were humanely treated. At that time, claims were made for
impressive cure rates, culminating in 1843, when Dr. William Awl, director of an Ohio asylum, announced
that he had achieved 100 percent recoveries; thereafter he was known as "Dr. Cure Awl." The failure of
"moral treatment" alone as a cure for insanity was clearly established in 1876 by Dr. Pliny Earle, who
showed that the prior claims had been highly exaggerated. Whitaker highly praises the more recent version
of "moral treatment," Soteria House, started by Dr. Loren Mosher. Mosher was a protégé of Dr. Ronald
Laing's, and Mosher's experiments, like Laing's along these lines, have all passed into history because they
failed.
In a similar vein, Whitaker discusses at length the WHO multi center schizophrenia study that reported that
individuals from developing countries (Nigeria, Colombia, India), "where such medications are less
frequently used," had a better outcome than did individuals in developed countries. In fact, the study
reported that the percentage of chronically disabled patients was similar in all the countries. What did differ
was the percentage of complete cures_40 percent in developing versus 25 percent in developed countries.
As has been widely discussed, the fact that more patients in the developing countries had a very acute onset
of their illness suggests that many of them probably had a reversible viral encephalitis or other organic
cause of their schizophrenia like symptoms and thus had better outcomes.
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 16 of 22
Some medical experts agree that the use of Ritalin in the schools has grown dramatically over the last two
decades, but not to the level claimed by Clarke.
For example, Clarke has maintained that in Minneapolis, 20% of children under 10 attending mostly white
schools in 1987 were on Ritalin and the percentage was double that in predominantly black schools.
"If they are saying that is the statistic in Minneapolis, they are lying," said Vi Blosberg, manager of health
services in the 39,000-student district. She said that fewer than 1% of students districtwide were taking
Ritalin or other drugs used to control hyperactivity during the year in question.
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 17 of 22
SZASZ IS LINKED
The fact that Scientology aims at world domination in the form and language of "clearing" is a
major sign that the movement is indeed totalitarian. As Arendt has noted, "The struggle for total
domination of the total population of the earth, the elimination of every competing nontotalitarian reality, is
inherent in totalitarian regimes; if they do not pursue global power as their ultimate goal, they are only too
likely to lose whatever power they already have."116 Totalitarian movements do not think in terms of
national borders. Instead, the movements are distinctly borderless in their goals for domination. The Sea
Org is an excellent example of L. Ron Hubbard's desire for Scientology to exist without the limitations of
national borders. Created by Hubbard as a means to escape government control, the Sea Org is an elite
group of Scientologists who sail around the world on a gigantic boat wearing naval uniforms117. What is
distinct about the Sea Org is that it epitomizes Hubbard's ideological goals for Scientology. Not subject to
any national laws, the Sea Org was Hubbard's fantasy of a planet where Scientology could roam and spread
without limits. According to Arendt, all totalitarian leaders consider their country of origin to be "only
temporary headquarters of the international movement on the road to world conquest."118 Scientology is
similarly international in the scope of its organization. In fact, the movement is even inter-planetary in the
desire to spread its ideology: After they clear earth, Scientology plans to "clear the universe."119
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 20 of 22
The RPF is still in use in Scientology organizations throughout the world. Those assigned to RPF
can only speak when spoken to, eat table scraps, and sleep shorter hours than other Scientology staff.169
RPF members are meant to comply immediately and unquestioningly with any order. They work a full day,
doing physical labor, and are expected to spend five hours confessing their "overts" and revealing their
"Evil Purposes."170 The RPF is, in effect, a Scientology penal colony.
The fact that both Ethics and the RPF originated on the Sea Org is not a coincidence. The Sea Org
was Hubbard's fantasy of a world of his own creation, which could sail limitlessly without the constraints
of national or governmental borders. Scientology's horrific punishment systems only serve to verify
totalitarianism's fundamental belief that in a fictitious world, everything is possible.171 One cannot help
but be reminded of the Nazi concentration camps when hearing about incarceration in the RPF. Physically,
there are unavoidable similarities between the two camps. Undesirables are separated from the rest of
society, under the pretense of an movement that "functions according to the principle that whoever is not
included is excluded, whoever is not with me is against me."172 Conditions are disgusting and prisoners
are trained to comply with all orders. The incarcerated are targeted as enemies of a movement whose
purifying motion must continue in order to prove its ideology. Of course, a critical difference is that the
Nazis systematically killed their prisoners. The RPF does not lead to death, as it did for so many in Nazi
camps. Therefore, the forced labor camps of Scientology differ is this crucial respect. In addition, the RPF
is not designed for those psychiatrists and government agents said to be conspiring against Scientology, but
for the members of the movement itself. This too, however, is the tendency of totalitarianism, which always
turns against even those in the movement, for nobody is safe when everyone must be on guard.173
Dowling @ IFL Phil Kerpen
Xenu Critique Page 21 of 22
WE MUST CONFRONT
WHO IS XENU?
I'm going to tell you a story. Are you sitting comfortably? Right, then I'll begin.
Once upon a time (75 million years ago to be more precise) there was an alien galactic ruler
named Xenu. Xenu was in charge of all the planets in this part of the galaxy including our own
planet Earth, except in those days it was called Teegeeack.
The story doesn't end there though. Since everyone has a soul (called a "thetan" in this story) then
you have to trick souls into not coming back again. So while the hundreds of billions of souls
were being blown around by the nuclear winds he had special electronic traps that caught all the
souls in electronic beams (the electronic beams were sticky like fly-paper).
After he had captured all these souls he had them packed into boxes and taken to a few huge
cinemas. There all the souls had to spend days watching special 3D motion pictures that told them
what life should be like and many confusing things. In this film they were shown false pictures
and told they were God, The Devil and Christ. In the story this process is called "implanting".
When the films ended and the souls left the cinema these souls started to stick together because
since they had all seen the same film they thought they were the same people. They clustered in
groups of a few thousand. Now because there were only a few living bodies left they stayed as
clusters and inhabited these bodies.
As for Xenu, the Loyal Officers finally overthrew him and they locked him away in a mountain
on one of the planets. He is kept in by a force-field powered by an eternal battery and Xenu is still
alive today.
Source: http://www.xenu.net/archive/leaflet/xenuleaf.htm