Sie sind auf Seite 1von 8

See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/26680617

Hip dislocation and femoral neck fracture:


Decision-making for head preservation

Article in Injury August 2009


DOI: 10.1016/j.injury.2009.06.166 Source: PubMed

CITATIONS

15

4 authors:

Moritz Tannast Philip Mack


Universitt Bern Connecticut Children's Medical Center
167 PUBLICATIONS 4,592 CITATIONS 8 PUBLICATIONS 150 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Bernd Klaeser Klaus A Siebenrock


Inselspital, Universittsspital Bern Inselspital, Universittsspital Bern
68 PUBLICATIONS 377 CITATIONS 290 PUBLICATIONS 11,633 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

The Zeitgeist of Challenging the Evidence View project

Consensus Statement on Compartment Syndrom View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Moritz Tannast on 01 March 2016.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 40 (2009) 11181124

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Injury
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/injury

Case report

Hip dislocation and femoral neck fracture: Decision-making for head preservation
Moritz Tannast a,*, Philip W. Mack b, Bernd Klaeser c, Klaus A. Siebenrock a
a
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Inselspital, University of Bern, Murtenstrasse, 3010 Bern, Switzerland
b
Shriners Hospital for Children, Springeld, MA, USA
c
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Inselspital, University of Bern, Switzerland

A R T I C L E I N F O

Article history:
Accepted 22 June 2009

Introduction Illustrative case example

Hip dislocation with femoral neck fracture is a rare injury in Written consent was obtained from the patient for the
young adults and is a challenging problem. It is fraught with publication of this case report. A 31-year-old man presented to
potentially devastating consequences including avascular necrosis our level I trauma centre as a transfer from a rural centre 3 h after
and subsequent early secondary osteoarthritis. being involved in a motor vehicle accident. The patient was healthy
We identied only 30 cases reported in literature that bear this and had no previous medical issues.
fracture pattern (Table 1). Of note 17/30 cases were treated by On primary survey the patient was haemodynamically stable.
open reduction and internal xation and 9 of these 17 have Physical examination revealed a stable pelvis with abduction,
developed avascular necrosis leading to eventual prosthetic external rotation and shortening of his right lower extremity.
replacement. Based on this evidence in literature many authors Distal pulses were palpable with sciatic, femoral and obturator
have even proposed primary hemi- or total hip arthroplasty. nerve function grossly intact. Pelvic exam was stable. A routine
Although femoral head viability and risk of subsequent anteroposterior pelvic radiograph, Judet views13 and additional
avascular necrosis were of major concern in all prior reports none computed tomography showed a completely displaced trans-
of the previous reports or discussions has alluded to decision- cervical femoral neck fracture with posterior hip dislocation in
making based on intraoperative integrity of the medial femoral addition to a transverse acetabular fracture (Fig. 1). The only other
circumex artery (MCFA) and retinacular vessels for deciding orthopaedic injury noted was an intraarticular distal phalanx
between osteosynthesis versus joint replacement. The precise fracture of the thumb. There were no additional systemic injuries.
knowledge of the MFCA topography and surgical anatomy has led The patient was taken to the operating room with in an hour of
to the development of the safe surgical hip dislocation, a technique presenting to the emergency room (5 h after the primary injury).
developed at our institution for complete dislocation of the femoral He was placed in a lateral decubitus position with his right hip
head without the risk of avascular necrosis by protecting the exposed through a previously described modied Kocher Langen-
MFCA.8,9 Accurate knowledge of anatomy and intraoperative beck approach.31 After splitting of the fascia latae and the gluteus
assessment of its integrity is an essential step for hip-joint maximus muscle, the femoral head was found lying posterior to
preserving surgery. the greater trochanter (Fig. 2A). The tendon of the piriformis
The purpose of this article is to use evidence-based medicine to muscle was partially torn as were the triceps coxae and the inferior
give current perspective in modern orthopaedic management of portion of the gluteus minimus muscle. A trochanteric ip
this devastating injury pattern. We have presented an illustrative osteotomy was performed and a z-shaped capsulotomy was
case report to outline the steps in decision-making. We further completed. By means of a retrograde-inserted Schanz screw, the
provide an algorithm for the management of this injury that will head was gently reduced. Careful inspection at this point revealed
hopefully aid clinicians in approaching these patients. an intact vessel bundle of the MFCA in the posterior aspect of the
femur with a preserved retinaculum in the posterosuperior
femoral neck leading to the femoral head (Fig. 2B). By lifting up
the femur with a bone hook, the intact tendon of the obturator
externus was evident, thus suggesting a preserved extracapsular
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +41 31 632 2222; fax: +41 31 632 3600. course of the MFCA.9 Based on the structural integrity of the
E-mail address: moritz.tannast@insel.ch (M. Tannast). retinaculum and the intact obturator externus muscle/tendon a

00201383/$ see front matter 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.injury.2009.06.166
M. Tannast et al. / Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 40 (2009) 11181124 1119

Table 1
Overview of the literature of hip dislocations associated with femoral neck fractures (ORIF = open reduction and internal xation, AVN = avascular necrosis of the femoral
head, THA = total hip arthroplasty, TO = trochanter osteotomy).

Author, Number Age of Direction Intraoperative Treatment Associated fractures AVN Surgical approach
year of cases patient dislocation bleeding of of the pelvis/hip
(years) the head

Baba 1 36 Anterior ORIF Pelvic ring fracture, Yes Lateral


et al., 20021 acetabular fracture transtrochanteric
Dummer 2 48 Obturator THA Posterolateral
et al., 19992
50 Posterior THA Posterior
Duygulu 1 52 Posterior ORIF Pelvic ring injury, No Posterolateral
et al., 20063 acetabular fracture,
femoral shaft fracture
Esenkaya 1 39 Anterior THA Lateral
et al., 20025
Fernandes, 1 60 Posterior Unipolar Femoral head fracture Posterolateral
19816 hemiprosthesis
Fina 5 65 Posterior Unipolar
et al., 19707 hemiprosthesis
36 Posterior Unipolar
hemiprosthesis
10 Anterior ORIF Yes
50 Posterior ORIF Acetabular fracture Yes
57 Posterior ORIF Femoral head and Yes
shaft fracture
Hougaard 2 62 Conservative No surgery
et al., 198811
63 Unipolar
hemiprosthesis
Izquierdo 1 17 Obturator ORIF Fragment at the Yes Lateral
et al., 199412 posterosuperior neck transtrochanteric
Klasen 2 19 Posterior No ORIF Acetabular fracture Yes
et al., 198414 bleeding
41 ORIF Acetabular fracture No
Kumar 1 33 Posterior ORIF No
et al., 198515
Maini 1 25 Posterior ORIF Greater trochanter fracture Yes Posterolateral
et al., 200416
McClelland 1 28 Obturator Bipolar Indentation fracture Posterolateral
et al., 198717 hemiprosthesis of the femoral head
Mehara 1 45 Posterior Unipolar Indentation fracture of Posterior
et al., 199518 hemiprosthesis the femoral head
Meinhard 1 27 Central ORIF Acetabular fracture No Posterolateral with TO
et al., 198719
Meller Y 1 24 Posterior Unipolar Femoral head fracture Posterolateral
et al., 198220 hemiprosthesis
Mestdagh 1 52 Central Traction, Pelvic ring injury, No Posterolateral with TO
et al., 199122 secondary THA acetabular fracture
Newman, 197423 1 40 Posterior Conservative Acetabular fracture No No surgery
Peterson 1 33 Posterior Bone grafting, Yes SmithPetersen
et al., 195025 traction
Polesky 1 81 Anterior Unipolar Acetabular fracture Anterolateral
et al., 197226 hemiprosthesis
Sadler 1 77 Anterior ORIF Yes WatsonJones
et al., 198527
Saragaglia 3 41 Posterior ORIF No Kocher Langenbeck
et al., 198728
22 Posterior ORIF Acetabular fracture No Kocher Langenbeck
38 Posterior ORIF Acetabular fracture No Kocher Langenbeck
Present study 1 31 Posterior No ORIF Acetabular fracture No Surgical dislocation
bleeding

decision was taken to perform osteosynthesis with 6.5 mm course of the MFCA (Fig. 4A). The 2-phase bone scan conrmed
cancellous screw xation. Additionally, the defect in the ante- that there was perfusion to the femoral head and showed a
roinferior femoral neck was grafted with autologous cancellous posttraumatic increase of bone metabolism in the femoral neck
bone obtained from the greater trochanter. The acetabular fracture and head (Fig. 4B). The patient was kept NWB on crutches. A
was anatomically reduced and xed with a 7-hole-3.5 mm follow-up bone scan 3 weeks postoperatively (again performed in
reconstruction plate (Fig. 3B). this case as an exception due to the rare nature of the injury and
The initial postoperative course was uneventful. Due to the rare femoral head preservation that was performed) re-conrmed the
nature if the injury in this patient, to conrm the integrity of the preserved perfusion and viability of the femoral head (Fig. 4C).
MFCA and the femoral head blood supply, a selective femoral At the 8-week follow-up, radiographs unfortunately partial loss
angiography and a bone scan were performed postoperatively of reduction and early signs of implant failure. The compliance of
(although this is not a routine for our institution). The femoral weight-bearing status of the patient remained questionable.
angiography demonstrated the integrity of the extracapsular Nevertheless, a prompt decision was taken to revise the xation
1120 M. Tannast et al. / Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 40 (2009) 11181124

Fig. 1. The preoperative anteroposterior pelvic radiograph (A), Judet views (B, C) and computed tomography show the severely displaced lateral femoral neck fracture with
posterior dislocation of the femoral head in combination with a transverse acetabular fracture.

and perform an additional valgus intertrochanteric osteotomy to At the most recent follow-up, 4.7 years after injury, the patient
decrease the Pauwels angle and convert the shear forces to remained completely asymptomatic with full, symmetrical, and
compressive forces. Surgical approach was performed through the unrestricted range of motion of the hip. According to the Medical
original skin incision and the trochanteric ip osteotomy was used Research Council (MRC) muscle strength grading system, the hip
again (Fig. 3C). Intraoperatively, brisk bleeding present after abductor strength was M5. The total Merle-dAubigne hip score21
drilling of the femoral head was a reassuring sign.10 Inserting the was 18, depicting an excellent outcome. Routine roentgenograms
2 mm laser-Doppler-owmetry24 probe demonstrated strong showed no radiographic evidence of avascular necrosis of the
pulsatile signals emanating from the femoral head (Fig. 4D). The femoral head or progression of arthritis (Fig. 3D). The patient has
patient was carefully instructed to be compliant about NWB this returned to his full-time occupation as a forester without
time and repeatedly reinforced that this was the nal salvage restrictions.
procedure.
Radiographic examination, 8 weeks after the revision (4 months Relevant surgical anatomy
after the accident), showed signs of healing in both the femoral
neck and the transverse acetabular fracture. Patient was eventually A detailed knowledge of the vascular supply to the proximal
progressed to PWB at 8 weeks and then with documented good femur forms the essential basis for safe hip preserving surgery. The
signs of healing, progressed to FWB at 12 weeks. medial circumex femoral artery (MFCA) provides the main and

Fig. 2. (A) Intraoperatively, after splitting of the fascia lata and the gluteus maximus muscle, the femoral head (*) was found lying posterior to the osteotomized greater
trochanter (OGT). (B) This gure shows the view from anterior after reduction and provisory xation with k-wires (KW). The retinaculum with the terminal branches of the
medial circumex femoral artery was intact (arrows).
M. Tannast et al. / Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 40 (2009) 11181124 1121

Fig. 3. (A) Osteosynthesis was performed using two 6.5 mm screws via a modied Kocher-Langenbeck approach with trochanteric osteotomy. The acetabular fracture was
xed with a 7-hole-3.5 mm reconstruction plate. (B) Eight weeks postoperatively, a delayed union with loss of reduction and screw breakage was observed. (C) A 20-degrees
valgus intertrochanteric osteotomy was subsequently performed using the same trochanteric ip osteotomy approach used previously. (D) At latest follow-up (4.7 years after
injury), no signs of avascular necrosis are present after partial hardware removal.

critical blood supply to the femoral head in an adult.9,29 The deep dislocation of the femoral head is possible without the risk of
branch of the MFCA runs towards the intertrochanteric crest avascular necrosis. Knowledge of this topographic anatomy, the
between the pectineus medially and the iliopsoas tendon laterally anatomical course of the MCFA, and the importance of an intact
(Fig. 5A) along the inferior border of the obturator externus muscle obturator externus muscle, are absolutely critical in the intrao-
(Fig. 5C). After crossing this tendon posteriorly, a constant perative decision-making for preservation of the native femoral
trochanteric branch is delivered adjacent to the proximal border head.
of the quadratus femoris (Fig. 5C). Thereafter, the deep branch of Femoral neck fracture with hip dislocation is a rare injury. As
the MFCA runs anterior to the tendon of the triceps coxae muscles mentioned before, we could identify only 30 cases with this
(gemelli and obturator internus muscles) to perforate the hip fracture pattern upon a thorough review of the English literature
capsule obliquely just cranial to the insertion of the tendon of the (Table 1). Treatment options based on literature review include
superior gemellus and distal to the tendon of piriformis. It then conservative treatment, traction, osteosynthesis, hemiarthroplasty
splits into two to ve retinacular vessels lying in a mobile layer of or primary total hip arthroplasty. The only reported case in which
connective tissue on the posterosuperior aspect of the femoral successful conservative treatment was achieved was presented by
neck and enters the femoral head lateral to the bonecartilage Newman.23 He suggested attempting closed reduction before
junction (Fig. 5D). performing open surgery. However, closed reduction, even when
performed gently, may be proved to be very harmful and these
Proposed algorithm manoeuvres are hard to control. Such manipulation could create
additional damage to the frail bridge of preserved retinacular
Management of femoral neck fractures by itself can be a vessels thereby causing denite devascularization.4,26 Some
challenging problem. To add to it an associated hip dislocation can authors who recommend immediate endoprosthetic replacement
make the situation more complex and therefore decision-making justify their approach by pointing the high likelihood of ques-
becomes more a matter of experience than objectivity. Based on tionable viability.7 These reports have failed to assess and report
the previous technique of safe surgical dislocation described at our the intraoperative integrity of the MFCA or the viability of the
institution, we believe that an algorithmic approach can be used femoral head. McClelland based his decision to abandon femoral
for these difcult injuries. Our proposed algorithm is outlined in head preservation and osteosynthesis by the noted absence of
Fig. 6. capsular bleeding and absent bleeding of the round ligament.17
However, we now know from anatomic studies that the medial
Discussion epiphyseal artery via the round ligament typically perfuses only
the area adjacent to the fovea and rarely supplies a signicant area
Femoral neck fractures with hip dislocation are a challenging of the head in adults.9,29
problem. By protecting the MCFA and its retinacular vessels Although intraoperative drilling of the femoral head is a reliable
adjacent to the posterosuperior femoral neck, a safe and complete sign of femoral head vascularization,10 it may be less reliable in
1122 M. Tannast et al. / Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 40 (2009) 11181124

Fig. 4. (A) A selective angiography of the femoral artery was performed postoperatively to conrm the integrity of the extracapsular course of the medial femoral circumex
artery (CFA = common femoral artery, SFA = supercial femoral artery, PFA = profund femoral artery, MCFA = medial femoral circumex artery, LCFA = lateral femoral
circumex artery, PV = perforating vessels). (B) This bone scan which was taken postoperatively after the rst operation shows posttraumatic changes with increased
perfusion and bone metabolism in the right femoral neck and head (arrow) indicate preserved viability of the femoral head. (C) The control scan three weeks after the index
operations shows persistent increase of perfusion and metabolism in the femoral neck and head as a sign of ongoing bone healing and preserved viability of the femoral head.
(D) At the time of revision, the laser Doppler owmetry shows a strong pulsatile signal emanating from the femoral head.

dislocated fractures for multiple reasons. Hip dislocation can lead compromised, the perfusion of the head can be preserved due to
to traction, compression and spasm of the femoral, deep femoral existing collaterals that are not under traction, e.g. the inferior
and their circumex arteries.30,32 These pathological factors may gluteal artery.9,32 The intactness of MCFA and the retinaculum as
be reversible by early reduction of the dislocation.30,32 Although such remains an import sign and decision-making point to proceed
the blood ow of the MFCA during head dislocation might be with femoral head preservation despite presence or absence of
M. Tannast et al. / Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 40 (2009) 11181124 1123

Fig. 5. (A) The deep branch of the MFCA runs towards the intertrochanteric crest between the pectineus medially and the iliopsoas tendon laterally. (B) The MCFA then runs
along the inferior border of the obturator externus muscle. (C) After overcrossing the tendon of the obturator externus muscle, a constant trochanteric branch is given off
adjacent to the proximal border of the quadratus femoris. Then, the MFCA undercrosses the tendon of the triceps coxae muscles (gemelli and obturator internus muscles) to
perforate the hip capsule obliquely just cranial to the insertion of the tendon of the superior gemellus and distal to the tendon of piriformis. (D) It then splits up into 25
retinacular vessels lying in a mobile layer of connective tissue on the posterosuperior aspect of the femoral neck and enters the femoral head lateral to the bone-cartilage
junction.

Fig. 6. Proposed algorithm.


1124 M. Tannast et al. / Injury, Int. J. Care Injured 40 (2009) 11181124

femoral head bleeding upon intraoperative drilling in these [9] Gautier E, Ganz K, Krugel N, et al. Anatomy of the medial femoral circumex
artery and its surgical implications. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2000;82:67983.
complex cases of femoral neck fracture with hip dislocation. [10] Gill TJ, Sledge JB, Ekkernkamp A, Ganz R. Intraoperative assessment of femoral
In our experience, femoral neck fracture associated with hip head vascularity after femoral neck fracture. J Orthop Trauma 1998;12:4748.
dislocation does not represent an ultimate sign of irrevocable [11] Hougaard K, Thomsen PB. Traumatic posterior fracture-dislocation of the hip
with fracture of the femoral head or neck, or both. J Bone Joint Surg Am
avascularity to the femoral head. As shown in our illustrative case, 1988;70:2339.
the retinaculum with its mobile layer of connective tissue on the [12] Izquierdo RJ, Harris D. Obturator hip dislocation with subcapital fracture of the
posterosuperior aspect of the femoral neck remained in continuity femoral neck. Injury 1994;25:10810.
[13] Judet R, Judet J, Letournel E. Fractures of the acetabulum: classication and
and protected the terminal branches of the MFCA. Any attempts at surgical approaches for open reduction. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1964;46:
closed reduction could have denitely harmed the remaining 161546.
perfusion of the retinacular vessels and we would certainly not [14] Klasen HJ, Binnendijk B. Fracture of the neck of the femur associated with
posterior dislocation of the hip. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1984;66:458.
recommend that. As mentioned in our proposed algorithm, we
[15] Kumar S, James R. Dislocation of the hip with associated subcapital fracturea
suggest an open reduction and internal xation utilizing the MCFA successfully treated case. Injury 1985;16:53942.
preserving trochanteric ip osteotomy as soon as possible and if [16] Maini L, Mishra P, Jain P, et al. Three part posterior fracture dislocation of the
the patient is stable enough to undergo the anaesthesia and hip without fracture of the femoral head: review of literature and a case report.
Injury 2004;35:2079.
surgical procedure. In our opinion, preservation of the dislocated [17] McClelland SJ, Bauman PA, Medley CF, Shelton ML. Obturator hip dislocation
femoral head via osteosynthesis, the trochanteric ip osteotomy with ipsilateral fractures of the femoral head and femoral neck. A case report.
surgical approach and assessment of the MCFA integrity provides a Clin Orthop Relat Res 1987;224:1648.
[18] Mehara AK, Das Ramchandani G, Sharma CS, et al. Unusual posterior hip
safe and rationale strategy for attempted joint preservation. dislocation with ipsilateral fractures of the femoral neck and head. J Trauma
1995;38:6589.
[19] Meinhard BP, Misoul C, Joy D, Ghillani R. Central acetabular fracture with
Conict of interest statement ipsilateral femoral-neck fracture and intrapelvic dislocation of the femoral
head without major pelvic-column disruption. A case report. J Bone Joint Surg
There are no conicts of interest. Am 1987;69:6125.
[20] Meller Y, Tennenbaum Y, Torok G. Subcapital fracture of neck of femur with
complete posterior dislocation of the hip. J Trauma 1982;22:3279.
Acknowledgements [21] Merle dAubigne R, Postel M. Functional results of hip arthroplasty with acrylic
prosthesis. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1954;36:45175.
[22] Mestdagh H, Butruille Y, Vigier P. Central fracture-dislocation of the hip with
The authors thank Dr. Harish Hosalkar for his help in manu- ipsilateral femoral neck fracture: case report. J Trauma 1991;31:14457.
script preparation. [23] Newman JH. Posterior dislocation of the hip with ipsilateral subcapital frac-
ture of the neck of the femur, treated conservatively: a case report. Injury
1974;5:32931.
References [24] Notzli HP, Siebenrock KA, Hempng A, et al. Perfusion of the femoral head
during surgical dislocation of the hip. Monitoring by laser Doppler. J Bone Joint
[1] Baba T, Hitachi K, Kaneko K. Fracture-dislocation of the hip with ipsilateral Surg Br 2002;84:3004.
femoral neck fracture. Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol 2002;12:1024. [25] Peterson LT. Dislocation of the hip associated with fracture of the neck of the
[2] Dummer RE, Sanzana ES. Hip dislocations associated with ipsilateral femoral femur. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1950;32:2749.
neck fracture. Int Orthop 1999;23:3534. [26] Polesky RE, Polesky FA. Intrapelvic dislocation of the femoral head following
[3] Duygulu F, Calis M, Argun M, Guney A. Unusual combination of femoral head anterior dislocation of the hip: a case report. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1972;54:
dislocation associated acetabular fracture with ipsilateral neck and shaft 10978.
fractures: a case report. J Trauma 2006;61:15458. [27] Sadler AH, DiStefano M. Anterior dislocation of the hip with ipsilateral
[4] Epstein HC, Wiss DA, Cozen L. Posterior fracture dislocation of the hip with basicervical fracture. A case report. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1985;67:3269.
fractures of the femoral head. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1985;201:917. [28] Saragaglia D, Carpentier E, Farizon F, et al. Posterior dislocation of the hip
[5] Esenkaya I, Gorgec M. Traumatic anterior dislocation of the hip associated with associated with fracture of the neck of the femur. Apropos of 3 cases. J Chir
ipsilateral femoral neck fracture: a case report. Acta Orthop Traumatol Turc (Paris) 1987;124:4548 [In French].
2002;36:3668. [29] Sevitt S, Thompson RG. The distribution and anastomoses of arteries supplying
[6] Fernandes A. Traumatic posterior dislocation of hip joint with a fracture of the the head and neck of the femur. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1965;47:56073.
head and neck of the femur on the same side: a case report. Injury [30] Shim SS. Circulatory and vascular changes in the hip following traumatic hip
1981;12:48790. dislocation. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1979;160:25561.
[7] Fina CP, Kelly PJ. Dislocations of the hip with fractures of the proximal femur. J [31] Siebenrock KA, Gautier E, Woo AK, Ganz R. Surgical dislocation of the femoral
Trauma 1970;10:7787. head for joint debridement and accurate reduction of fractures of the acet-
[8] Ganz R, Gill TJ, Gautier E, et al. Surgical dislocation of the adult hip. A technique abulum. J Orthop Trauma 2002;16:54352.
with full access to femoral head and acetabulum without the risk of avascular [32] Yue JJ, Wilber JH, Lipuma JP, et al. Posterior hip dislocations: a cadaveric
necrosis. J Bone Joint Surg Br 2001;83:111924. angiographic study. J Orthop Trauma 1996;10:44754.

View publication stats

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen