Sie sind auf Seite 1von 15

Research Challenges in Wireless Networks

of Biomedical Sensors

Loren Schwiebert Sandeep K. S. Gupta Jennifer Weinmann


Department of Computer Department of Computer Department of Electrical and
Science Science and Engineering Computer Engineering
Wayne State University Arizona State University Wayne State University
Detroit, MI 48202 Tempe, AZ 85287 Detroit, MI 48202
loren@cs.wayne.edu sandeep.gupta@asu.edu aa5685@wayne.edu

H 'S
o
#CRH
H
GFIC 8'  ?TC?W  N* C oG 'C ]
 4'H)
ABSTRACT W |
, #6!#
>COMHIC'H H8
H '>k EH  c<`;8)
 
  !" #$% 
  & (' )
Ct<T 'SG  gH
#H 'SN
I=?J p
GC';C k8'8*J -
*  
+,#
 -/.#01 24365874954: 2;5<>=?;@A'B8'C D E
 6 I
# I*
#
e B#rCpF*#J  # H
#H '
K,H
G 
8F#

G,H
H
G,IC 8' C =?J K
GC';C LJ'*J H'HE <MA'
;x< =?J  ]
 8G ';C I8'8*J H'HEI Ol ?;I
H'
GF 
%8
#GN8
H 8'POQ 'MH8!8'; R#  #CR #C 
#MH*;P 
8HSH
#H '-U
#? ?
8_ UH * 6%?C'<=ZS Hu*H
G  *#HS!T
J  'U 'V>'8 
T#' W H-YXZ#H> 8
N 8'H
#H '|=?8
,'8OQ8'H'
G  oHIC'H |H8
H '<Ui7 x 
'[*#J'U U  # J \E ] F*
#C ^=?J FC
N8_ 8'
   6)
 F
C 
P Of #&H
#H ']C
T &
GC';C PJ'*J -UXZH
#*# 8'`WEW bac HVW ;A 
RdR ]?=?J'H^
8'HOcC-^XZ#V6)
HIC'H xH
#H '`
|%g' C !JE
4_#%8
H!g M*#  R<C A=?
#G
J e%=V8'C
Te *# ;A 
TCVCTC F O?HIC'H NH
#H '
OC'M ] C'G4)H |##AE
U O`
8 =Z 'hZCOfHIA'H ZH
#H '-
 H#  GCR # 
U'H
Y'HC';I4 
G Z
H )
X`;
# R # 
8MC'S8_%8 6 u#'A!M S  J 
4';  H%88 f O=?J'Hg
#8 \=V 'h
G]#*#^ M #Y
#&OQ 'gA
G

o%8'HOQ 'IC
COg H-
$C)8TA <YOc *#J H)i  8';
<Z8
8'GCE)i8j6
<ZC
T(H J)
XZo #C 
FCO&HIA'H FH8
H 'FC'P8_ 
H!PC
T(#4)
CkHG
l-nm*#'H #8'<^N%
#Gk HoH
HC'6
n*#I
#
H8'
#Gk f #F*H8> OY HF#& &#' #Ek
 >%HHJ)
 I##J 
 %'[ *J'
-fm 'M4_C<! #]=?J'H?
#8 H)
-]SA=V!8'<%OQ8=8_#C| #C 
,# I 
?=?g
=V 'h
GLH*# 
pH * D%,*#J H';C)iCOQe
q'rC<=V 'h
8_ C
D #"
8'W k
q #H,#-m ' 8_# <]J)
H' *# 4)iOr'Z
N#JsR8'
fG GC'; # # C 
#?at J  *Gu6)
;C'HE,
8'W N
(
#8 \=V 'hu O?HIC'H uH
#H 'N u  C ,E
# 
C'P \ECEe
 68_%8 e "CvU #8E(H#* 
xw
I
E'# 8x TA gC
N%UCO8ENC
T|8sR8 !JE|H  |=?J 
'8W H' 4   A!8
F OS J'*#I
n W 8d;<M
n'[*#J'
HIC'H fH
HC'-^m 'f8_# <C
#8 \=V 'hg OHIC'H fH8
H 'g8* 

# ICIC


#-gXZ#Z
8HHJ ;C MC# A 
#)iH%8y
%E I
 FTA MH
C'? N H';C4h6 H'  kA!
-
H *# 
#o=?;zC'"CW JEqsR4'
oOr'{ H'; 
T H *#)
8
H 'V  I
oHIC'%C Z*# P
T*8 VrC
T
]#4)

-
8 
x-&IA'H SH8
H 'S*# p#8 4 S #u*#H| OY G ^C'

@ # p %8'<|=Vn#H8'%e #e% 
  u O6 
;Cf=ZC%
>
TR<RrI
4 \=ZC'hk F*
#C 
l<T'%C'H
HIA'H pH
#H '-~}e$ 
z8_#rC
 #,;TC 
#GpOQ 'k=?J'8)
8']'H
8
P & 6#'C 8 ? H' #-
H`
8 =Z 'h
G] O#*IC
#)iF%#]HIA'H fH
#H 'gA'H';E#f
T
  
, #C 
 OUHIC'H &H
HC'C'F HPI
EpC
T
 *#'U#'
TA'HE ##' ;6O 'Y=?J'HZ
#8 \=V 'h
G Ox&'8 

 C'l-p&
8_#C6N%  * 
L#8 88 
(C 
G$%C4#<
'W #H-M&*'? M FC   C S G  ' *M'HA'4k
P 
=?J eHIC'H |H8
H 'N#W H'* BC
Go 6H# '
P
,*#W)
A'B EL *#W H';C 
GB #k
8LOQ 'P 'pC# A 
#)iH%8y

Gk=?J'HNN*
A 
, k'8rE,
#OC'IC 
e kkT H
C
Te
#CZC#' ;u =MC';(! 
Gk=?J'H6
#8 \=V 'h )
W ;C 
,OC'>O*'H 8'>#' HH
#G#-FIA'H &H
#H ' * " H %

#G6H*# 
?O 'S*IC
#)i 
6HIA'H ?H
HC'-
#W H'* e #' *G#* F o8_TC*W 6WEW  O>
L * C)
N P8 8 & 8!> OUHH
#
$4j
JEk'#*#F% J)
*# 
l-&S8 \=V 'h&COVHIA'H &H8
H '&T!u H %8
p#' %H
1. INTRODUCTION OC'ZIC ?
H'
 C'G SCj]*#  
#G<!=?#8'?
#HW 

XZ#Y'8
g!#
`CO#G#)i%8'HOQ 'IC
Y8'' W)
%8';A *#'M!>%
k#Jj*# M 6 ;!-
X 'HC';~=Z H*%C'H b
~TA'H K E>C 
T pJ)
Z XZMW ? Of # C 
#]
JEIH8';A 4#Z SH*#'HOcC O`#'C)
8
Dm#*
A  
S';C
 N>^)  <"F]&)  !C %HuC
T% 8
  C # C 
#f O#
A!HIC'H xH
HC'-Y&

C
TpNS&i)  - 
#GM
8
S=? > #YCOC'

# #C 
#<#=M)
!4'<MI C I*#H
#G(,=?J'Ho
8'HO k , HpI
H*%4' C'? 6N=?J' 8

#8 
l<8!
P
o H8]=?#8'N=?J'


88 
PIEN%&% HH-YmC'M8_# #  <!OC'MH] J ;A'HE
 #C 
<Z #k#W H'* 
L O>H8
H '8* L%k#
oE
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for \\8 
GI Or'CJ'8';COr -|m '& *  N8_ *W &
#)
personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are  '
#G#<l=?'8>=Z*# $'[ *#'N8_ 
H!u#'C 8 
" o %8';C 
not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies 
M# G #)t %8';A *#'>8
J'
#
-
bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to \
z p %8'<>=Ve
H #8',C
 #8'$CA  
C'K O
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific HIC'H uH
#H '>" #CVCA  
- \
BC'H *#rA'<f=Z
permission and/or a fee.
Copyright 2001 ACM X-XXXXX-XX-X/XX/XX ... 5.00.

A'U
8'W >
8F%##]HIC'H xH
HC'x TA ` %8';C ^=?J 

#k*IC
L%E( B %
A oOQ 'PA'*IH H- V8)
 *H6 #H 8|C'6#  ,
#H #F #6*I
$%E"
T
CH6%C*H&CO` #&C
 C I*HV O` #H>< ?'8)
HC';N'l ?%UH  NJsR8'`Or'@ #HYO 'f
8 =Z 'h
G
G 
4' FHIC'H H
#H '-F\
$ NOQ=?
#G#<f=VNy#'W u#H8'%F

*#F%8'u O]'%Hn#  MCA  


6CO&HIA'H FH8
#)
HC'<|
*T
GLL#  | #C 
@=ZBC'e8*#'H'
JE
=V 'h
G
x<! #?C'H JyT C#'8 
T-YXZ
N=Z]#H4' %M #Z#' #)
I=?J D=?'8 8Hp
8 =Z 'h
G(COu C# A 
<
OQ=Zp EPH>COg*'S  ]
oH
#G6 H'# 8-

2. BIOMEDICAL SENSOR APPLICATIONS


]J *#G$ F 84#
 G E$OC'N#  ^HIC'H H8
H '|
W S'8rA !JEq
#8=<]B
*N%8' O|
8'W 
#G(#'% HqC#)

# C 
#>T!u8'G l-SXZ8H6 #C 
A'N'  Ep8)  "!$#&%'('(*) +  ,-+./01/$23+.4657(89 /) :0*) /;<=  ,:>
H4' %I |G!S
I #uCOx #]%C 
  %TC8 U C V)
CgH
HC'>
#8 \=V 'h]=?gT!|
k |CJ ,C
T =V)i%
#G
COgO* *#'> lTA  8
 -
]J *#GL
#EL$HI M8' HW)iH8 
qCO>% HH #p #C) H 'MC'H';E < 
#Gu=?J PJ V C 
o=?J 
I ]8E < ZH#=?
o



^C'Z#H8'%R<J ^H#* |%V *#` TA f 4'MC'UI
E mfG*'u-UXZ8' *#V'W ?
>H*'HOcC| Of #&'8 
T
%C 
  M*H8FOC'6=?J'H# MH8
H '-L]N # u'8) ';C #8'u T
BF%##
GP H8 |
k #6'8 
T- &
h!
HC';k#' G 'HH<TI
EI '&=?`%8|CTA'
- HIC 8'NWEW  TC NT!%8
(#' %HR<g HIHIC'H
H
#H 'UC'M CF*#%
| Z'8 
T&
TNC'MHIC 
#*G 6C
T
G 
#*G p P%u8rp
$  8N=?J p' C !JE$J H  uOC'-
2.1 Artificial Retina
XZ#68_# #6# YCA  
B=Z6#H*H|
e8 ;  XZ8HSH
#H 'Y#'*?8 H'C%HG
TCU=?;IC'?
8'H 

k # ]TC%8'>? uC'H Jy  `'8 
-SXZ]H*# kpG #)  E> Y*
#8'JE
G? HH*V
S];C!'H%
#H<  ;h
#G
G I k#JsR8'
I'[ *J'
6CO #CSH
#H '-\
Y
C'I  %8';A 
#GS%8T C'fCO# #Y'8 
MOr'@ G  `W F*#)


#oH4  
x<?=Zpy#'W kH8'%p k'8 
Te'W #Hk#8!J)  C 
l-UXZ]4# 'H%
#H&Z G J ; gac
C'HETd;< HH
  JE

  
 %u=?J #
| MIC'H g
#H '^C
T|\
G ';A   4'WEW  #'*
#G4# lH8'  f8F*#
A  
x-V HrA'>HG

ai# $dS#'AW8 NA }(E


I ;C  S
!8'HJ \E"C
T$  >'HG  g%
G>*#HO 'U] 'H C# C
 < J #*G N #VHTC
G>%4)
gE |\
#W J *# -]&
# O^ |G ! S O^ ]#'AW8 &S *#r  \=V
k8' *#M?rA'G8'S 6IC ;o #
8'CHkHTC
G
;#'
C JE, 
"C'H JyT8rCU'8 
P=?J BH*j
| H*  %8 =Z
G!
#G 6
>H*TCx8 'H 8_R-



OQ*
#8 
TC EF C =K%8'H
#Y=?J  *# YH 
 'Y=?J 6 J  SNH=?
L
mfG*'p<Y IOQ'
H # COS #o'8 
$

H
I  H FC ?C
C ; S 8!c-^\
I ';8'Z |' ;I  
 ;C8 |=?J B 68' H
HC'NC'H';E -PXx';
#HHH 
e
 
G !Ct<?8F*#
A  
n#'  8 TC C'kHG
#JyTC
 JEnC' 8E u=ZC'h> >O  =?-6XZF ;hpH #FCOV #N'8 
TIW F*#)
4j
P
HCrCp 
L*'H'
I#HG
IF*#W %p#8!J)  C "8 H'C JELac  
,C'H Jy  g'8 
TP#'W #H4dS Ek 
 %l- H
#H '
( #oHIA'H 6H
#H 'I;x-eXZHk8 88 H' ?HG
 
*'H'
JE < HIA'H fH
#H 'g;#<  ;u=?J I?8'H8
H '< C']
8'H 6
4# THG
T Z Eu ?G!C
G   u
IC 8'
! %8
#*J 6OC'P
L8_)!p W 
G,WEW  CO"'4 
- *
#8'JE
GF HH*#NW H'*#8 *#'S
 >'H%
Hu&A'H' k 


mfG *#'B ##8 
L *#W H';C 
 OS o#HG
l-XZ HIA'H N  F
8'!u o #F#';C
x-6G
 ^ H';
HHH
"OQ'  
H8
H 'P  \=VB %
8
  p
K
GC';C LJ'*J o
K
HIC'H ]H
#H '] 
I
8E!>=Z 'h?
pFH C'SI
#)

 
A'H';ECOH
#H '-zXZ#k
 8G ';C J'*# IP,N*J 8_
G
4'<!
#JEF
F #V'!8'H?J'8 
l-YXZZ'H*# 
#G>
*'G  


;l<f%4';C 
G$A  S+<f=?J e
)i4# ,W=?J 4#u
T,T HG
 >OQ'  uG!C
G kA'F;h!p*$ E #F8' H
HC'
$H*#% 'H Ne n$GC' e O]
#
4  
-,XZIJ'*#J F  
6 &HG
T RC
T' C !S

#HJ \EC
o%? H';
#HJ H *#
%C  H';
HJ U
6'!?CT # J -VUC4I

#8 
   O&  HIA'H IH
HC'-z^!
*TC JE <U  H8
H 'oA'H';En=?&%
C
( *#
*##' %6H*#'HO 6=?#8'6 F 4'I ;
#"H8
#) *HPOC']% o'8# 
p
P H';
#HHH 
k
kNOQT ;hIWEW)
HC'F%
T#l-"XZ6F  He EB*H
G"k ;
 [ *  C
TK;#'
 JEq#rC
L=?J 
K #p8E -@] #*#G
 KTC4hH # %
T
G#<U=?;K CP
K##H! 
 # u8'H8
H '>C'H';E$C
T$ HH  A ,4 H'
&T!u%


;"
p =?> uH
HC'& I%N%
T# I #N;l<%=?  #8!%R<V # ;T 
#G$C  #%
6  =?J'HI
4 H)
 ;LH8
H '6  C n
Lp#' %oH*'HOc 8- V8OQ 'P P%
T) =ZC'h
#G$ O? HI8' H
HC'N=?J L
(8_ 8'
 V' HH
G

#G ]
 <# #>
J' <T4_#8# M #>#' %|C'C<%]8!C  *
#J M
oC';#8'M u#' 8H? #S88_IHG
T M u%& H';
#H H)

 ? A@
=?J pNG  JE$
8'H ?H*#W ;
#-V8!8'; l#'C  E#%&4# # I F > #C'H';E -

 B
!>%
POcC#'C o #' *G pWPC
TP #&H
#H 'SC'H';E XZY' H
fOQ 'g H';
#HJ H 
#G?
OC'IC 
o: 3`: N ^'8 
T
! J' EB%
B#*J -PXZH
#H '|OC' " ( 8) C'?%8' #UHU  *-^XZ#?*#'% H? OR ^'!8'H T= O
H' A'H';ElvV ;nH
HC'6p8'#*" TC N=? Z'8W 6
A ;6] I8 8'
> #uIC#
#GF%8 =Z8
k 
#*# ]I G
#'8 
T-,XZ#  W ;C
P%8 =Z
n CW 
F 4'*# 
F M'H*# 
#Gu
#*#' GC%HG
TCV=?;P8
T #]*#U H
C'A_IC 8Ek 8'
-]XZ8HN8' *#MW ;C'H ]=?J $ TA I G - *#'H'
JE <R N 8 * ^I #
GOr'
#*# & 6)
'88 ;
#G* A'|HT %N
p
A'> u
Tk ;C%8'& oP% 
 ->XZ  G 6  '; 
BC H 8'
, 
# =VU*#
T#4'W  l-IXZ#6*J IC 
% 
 f `  |
u #Y'4 
? HH*#<!C =?
GS
;C8 g%8 =Z
G u OZ # >'8HC';B=?V
C |%F'C +,=?J * u %8 H 8'
#IHIC'H uH
HC'6A'H';E(
B 6'8 
 =? #* F%8'HOQ ';A 
#G *
#8'W ;C
T
#G,CO> 8H #' 8HH-Di I 
# 6OQ H# p B#
#>'8 
T- ' HH
G$
8'
TCEB*H
Gk #  # J FCO]
JE" 
]
B C
 ;C!8'H
( OM 8*#'H'
|8_)i  8'H8
#) H
#H 'A'H';E#-,XZ*<g=V 'h,
(
8'
#
4 
#Gp HIHIC'H
* P%  '8' HTC  C&'H*  
D T
q #pI *# - dXZ*<S
F*#J )i4 H'#IC'H';EBH* Z'W 8H |=?ZT!6 p
##
FH* ^H
#6H G  E,sR4'
E <`#8%
T
#Go*#%
$=?8'

n I'8 
T$C4n8 H'pC'H';E(6#  R-LXZP%8')
8';C JEn#rCn8 H'6
8e ,G 
8';A  HG
 TCHn

=Z8'HC   f'8H*# 


"=?J "GC'C 4' H&
p % ';C
!8
 <C=?M
H';C JEu CNH8
H 'UA'H';Eg*#%
| ZIC* 

8B $
oC'IHTC  C JE)i '
(
#OQ 'IC 
x-BUC4
C'H';EP=? xT!& N H';
HJ ?H 
o
#OQ 'IA  
kH*;
 U ]C8'; R*
 H E6CO` ]H*T %H8
-U#<C4PHIC'H
H
#H 'M=?xAS F%&  ';
C I=?J   #8'MHIA'H MH
HC'
TCHI
o
P ICGS#' HH
#G6 G  'J HG
#I u
 H' 
H8 ZCOlHIC'H UH
HC'?C'H';E< ;IHTA';C <H8
T#
#Gu
#*# ^ 
O*#
8 
T JE #JsR8'
?'8 
TC`A' -

2.1.1 Networking and Processing Requirements


\
I MH4  
x<# SOQ*
#8 
TCl'[*#J'
Z O` &WEW 
C'?H8'%N 
#G&=?J FHZ#HG
F# 
-^XZ#Z#' %H
H*  
SC'C   C o E H>'[*#J'
-
\
pC';#8'S P ;!| u
 H
kO*#
8 
T J \E < \=ZC)t=ME
 F*
#C 
q=?|%,
#D%8 \=V
@
z8_ 8'
TC6)
* 8'&
Tk8 'H  ^ C
 SH TA S=VNC
$#'ArN
#*# ? 

;
IC'H  M C
 NC
T(#4 8'
JO? I#8H'nICGI

$  # / 8,;+./$07/$2&+.46,; + :0*) /$+.4*(0 +.4 H8


-g}e? H|
8N \=V )t=MEFN*
A 
N=?J 6 #Z'8 J)

3>
TCM 
6H" TA 6=Zo
#8 4'
#P C 6 #
P'8 
T,C'k %8';C 
Ge 8_%8 l-
H
#H '

VH #8P
#*# FOQ'
& 8';<=ZC H
# CJ \EI F'C #&#J'8 ?
#*#
F #&'8 
TC` 
M 8 8'
SJOg >C 
]HM=?TA
&8_%4  OQ' / C >
#*# ]C H 8'
l-&XZ#S=?gC  #C u*#'
H8
H '=?J eC
,4_ 4'
T g' HH
G WE#W 8|PO*#
T# 
) *
#8'W ;C
T
#GFCOf >HG
T 
GI%8 =Z8
o & 8';F
TI 
;C] H%8 6 O&' +
G, # %C 
rCM O>
C'H JyT C?'4 
- HIC'H |H8
H 'NA'H';E,C|=VVC 6 %8';C 
B OZ #F=?J'H


&
)iG
#Ge# CG
 W $
TLI 

TC
P%4';C 
#I=?S H  F*
#C 
o#'C  -
'[*#J'S H';
#HHH 
oCOf#C ;OQ' b ]H
HC'?C'H';E N
P8_) XZ# 
e| kH P*" p$ B HIC'H |H
#H 'FC'H';E
4'
T VW N *# 4'-pXZ8HP'[ *#'8
NA'o
n #J 

$NH
#Gu4# oO 'S*IC
o'8 
TC` C
 ;A 
x-ZSM >'4)

   
" o
 'ICZO*#
8 
#
GBCO& #k#8 <U=?# ;K*#HF=?J'8) HA'4o#'GC'HH<I
E Ox H&4# #Z=? l%&
#H8'H POQ ']

B
H8F*#
A  
eOQ'  $ 8';pN%B
$ J'CO yT
 RWEW CO^o  $ 6H
#H 'SC'H';E"a ! FC'H';Eo O

4E G CHH&


F &HIC'H ?H
#H 'SC'H';E- ;<!=?#8'? ;;TCV| u |H8
H 'ZC'H';ETd;-^XZM'
mfG *#' u#88 U #S' HH
GNW YOQ' b8_ 8'
 %I G  
o
My#'|C ]

8'  RCOY '_#IA JEo NP C-
'8# 
F > H';
#H HH
F & U'8 
T>#' W H-^ 8'; XZ4'8OC'<` #N' HH
G =?^%F%8'HOQ 'p%8'  JEB


 *
p
B
,8E G rCHOQ'; F*#r,#J'8 > | *# * &   kCP$C #' 8HH
Gk l-&8
<x#C ;P=?Y%F H';
#W)
' J)t  F| DOC'F#C ;I'#*#8 
eC
T"#' HH
#G(ac- G#-<^ ) J H "OQ*'NC'|yT!F %4'NH8
l-oSJ  *G , IC8 *TC


%8VGI#4 8 
%d;-kXZ#P 8';o=V*#r,%P8F#
$=?  '#]C
TI
#?
P S8E > %8';C >

kC
TC  GI
#
8'ac C)


k CH8'F% 
 4'uOQ 'F * IC 6OQ *H
G-$XZ  #
B8
#) '8 \EB O]%HH# P  *4d;<^ *#'N
J   ZWEW  =?M%8';A o

8#^ V'8H*J ;
YI G?
>> TC8 gOC'IC ^OC'U=?J'H W H'8 JE$
A sB#-S\
pC 8'S=Z ';<l
uJ & OUA ;P%8'

H';C
HHH

6ac 'U CHC
Y dx M8E!ZO 'UH*#H[ *
^8) H
#H 'M8'HEIC> C-g}e] 
I
I
*T JE6A
G> 
8#
G| EF #]#rC
F;-^XZ#SH4 *
ImfG*#' H=? F*#J  #8)i 8!RW F* A  
x-
>=?J'HY H';
H8!8'V C YV
H ? #?%E <!#*# Y
C U=?J #
XZu%=Z8'>F*W S%uC'8OQ*JE$
H'  p P! " ICG
#>'8 
T- n p'8 
TL
zH*'H'*#
T#
#Gn HH*#-~Y ;H8
H 'pC'H';E

=
&*'M*J IC ]'HA'4oG!CxM uH*%C'H ]
oC'H';EP OU %4';C g=?J FHg TC
N
Z8' u O*#'H'
-fXZZ%=Z4'
HIA'H |H
HC'|4#<x ;,=?J ek , PGC'r, OZ8 88 H'#- C
%$'C #q
sR4'
o=ZE-&
$ 
zo n*H
XZ#
W G!C 
?
 N*
#8'W ;C
T#
#GN &H* R#' 8HH
#G =?J'S 'A | #%=Z8'<RCJ *#Gk=Vu=V* kW `'[ *J'
COZ F#'; 
$=? U
T#A F=?4 8'|C'|
  #6H
#H 'uC'H';E =?J'HNC ;I F*
#C 
p o J > #F
*N%8'>COV=?J'-
=?V%#rC
$=?J e*#
JOC' #W H'*  
x-Pm*#
8 
T JE < XZ|%=Z4'> * k%|#'Ar  Eo # 

GI6TA H 8'HEo
A'

 
8 88 H'#oC'H';Eu=?J #
, 
8'N OM #I *# Ba 8
#) |8E!-? H
Tk # 
$] I*#Hu
#*4 ;
8<T'C #kE
H';C'8 
T!dg=?%T!M W F*#rA ] #M'8 
T#JsR8'8
 JEN T
Sm  'I /HG
T -z~ J';n# 
KI,# C)## C'H';E <
%4' #8';CE, CB4 H'#IC'H';E<fH
#6 FOQ*
#8 
|CO =?;p
!4'H SG & %=V8'-] ]&% 'H ;C
 ? I
C  TC
#Hp C'*#TC'H ICO>  '4 
eC'p8'HEL#JsR8'
- 8
#) !8
"JOU F%=V8'H*'6&=?J'R<x #6A ;P8F*#
A  


H';CE <
>IC* <=Z%4'!*']G '8H*# 
$8 ; 
8#l S%^=?J'Hg
uC';#8'` ]
# +g #U
*N%8'l O=?J'
H
l<=?# &
I S%8'#8'HE <! ]'8 
T|M%8 H 8'MA ?#4 8 H) 
o#'A!S  8_ # J EoCOg >WEW k-

#Gk 
, 'u *#
TC 
B H';
#H 8
 -$atm# '|8_# #<` W ]Or 8'>8
H 8'
GP fOcC8  '<R #NH
"TC&%
pI #
%4'H
N
n%8'8!P #J'6 * 8'u
J C'w N!8'H CV'8) *HM'; #OQ'[ *8
^OC'Z% %=V8'V
#*4 ;
8SC
T6#C ;
Or'HB=?#
e h
GpA | 6
J  '|*#H
#Gk%8'#8'; YH 
x< H';
#HHH 
x-^XZ#V*IC
%Eg W E&=MC 4'Y
T> *xTC
H
#P #%8'#8'; Y'8 
TkTCN%4 H 8'N 8% '; ^'H  * 
x< C H 8
*C 
,4C';C8 8'W NH C'| o=ZC 8'-PXZ#u'!

 Camera Image
DSP
power/data (RF) invivo wireless retina neural
Processing Unit transmission transceiver chip interface
VLSI Sensors

CCD Camera
1000 x 1000 image Image PostProcessing Based on Wireless
Wired Connection
128 x 128 image Designs from Interface Smart Sensor
(data reduction NCSU and
feature extraction) IIT.
$  #  / 8-).).0  +  )2 /$=+.4   +.(0,  /$) +.4:).()
  / :89+


 *#'&#HG
OQ' /*#H
G8_ H'JEPG  OQ'[ *#
<T J  *G  %HH# 6 C |A
G o%8 H 4'|*
T8'W ;
#
GP OV FC'G!C
xw 
Or'[ *
#
, #F=&&+F';C
GF
"%6*Hl- VC*HCO 
T#J 
p8* k
#G 8
H -MS'HC';4'>C'
  *&'W H'8 
|
$ NH +86 OY F


I C 
"%  h
Ge
e! 
G,,G I
# C'6=?J KHIA'H H
HC'
#rC
,
B #68E <fkG"OQ'[ *#
8E <`
B I&S+6';
#G< C4# 8! -ZXZ#H
HC'S=V*#rk
J  ']!8 ?CO^
J H'
=?`%*#Hl- C'H oC'%
z#_# <]A_EG8
x<S
q8 TC
 L#4 8'

C'H N C E(*#'
G H';C
H#rC
-pXZN*#rB H$%P*#H
OC'& H  %C';C  'HE C'; )t'HA'4p8_%8'
;A  
x-


2.2 Glucose Level Monitors

XZ# >6>C 
T %
W J *# ?CO`S J xw >acS\dg&C 
 %\
)

 
W J * p O|>  %4  C
TK& G W !"
  #
4E& H Hp'8)
 2.4 Cancer Detectors



#8'u> 6H8
,
GkC*H6CO?#C B

 
%C'H 6A - ? 
|% Y> - CO# # >&%*# C 
ST R<%=?J 
  %8 x
I J t- # A 
x TC `C'HYOQ'@# C%8  "#A N'8% 'H (
D - *#'H'
JEnp 
n )
 
 

#*T#M#C'H YH H<!W H'h!<GN F'HH*#'<
T
H< 
G|% S!?TC
4'?#  G
 H <=?J p ;  8 
4=


h #
#8EL#HCH<?C
TKC* ;C 
#-q]F oH!
L #
#G CH^#  G
 HN
I  i-gSJ  *G| 4'Vf
]
*H!
 *HCOgC o
P  &
J o ;A <# Z ?A'? TC V M?  #
#]
P=q u#'!8
 UC
8'<A'JEP#8 4  
oZh8EF 
H H> C M
##MH4'  *]C H 8
 
  J t-ZX^E## % H'A 
H*#'
GI >JO8)t #'C 
#
#Gk H H-|}DJ'H#  #C
OQ '^  %8 `
#*TfMW H'8 `'8G
| O##8 <C8_8'8 H <
H*#
H
#H 'MIE EI|h!8E6' >
PC'JEo#8 4  
x-U *T#UT!

  

CW8 
<C
TN#Z# F
# C'
G#-`}DJ'H^  H=?
 TA ZC
4'MZ8_*T?
J H'S_ #< =?# ;PCsR4 V 

"
H8
H 'NIEeAsR ';(p '8sR88 !=MEB p H'A 6rC%8 <   T= 
" #6C' H*#'H' *
T
GoI *# ' J t- H
HC'
 Ep'A 
#G P 'u
#HW 
<fC*#';A <`
T$H
CH  =?J ( o J \Ee "8 8 u HP;T
#GF
e #o#  =
4 NOQ 'Z
J  '
#GuG * HS!8 - *'H'
JE <! 
# C' C
p%  k
pH*#H%8 S C 
#-? SSh!JEP TC &
E  )
# 6G* H? 8!< & C
8 Y^*Hu >#';hN]yT
G 8'v &'
C'I J M*# P%8 8 IN*;IH 
4'M=? P ]H
HC'
COM " |#rC"
eI W |W H'x<l=?;Bu
TCJE#+8,J #8' TC
=?J  *# -VXZS]H% C JEp*#H8O*#xOQ 'S%# >=?#T!


IC
*T JEn '68 H'
# JE -DXZ# 8
W ;C
#';h
#G,H8';  NO JEkW C'HE COg8'H ;C
k E%M O^C
4'<%C'uA S#G 'Hh%<
F,#EeA!8'6"%8'( O]E A'6C
# ICGI I  HH*#  'PA'p
'HH
l- S8HC';KP He%
#GB
T#*#8 L



C
Tq#  qHH 
K C C'- }DJ'H #  &H8
#)  C
GFH8
H 'V
ou
##<8
T #
#GF#EH 
#U N#  G
 H
HC'o8* q%p C
 
K pC 
I
#- XZpH
#H ' *C'U=?J  *# ?A
G| N#6| WE t-UXZ>H8
H 'M*#H
=V*#r
J  'Y ?G*#H]!ZC
TF H';C
HJ U #M'H*J U  
, # u 86T!F # # J E" k#JsR8'
 C 6%4 \=Z8
(#JOr)
k=M'W \=ZC ;KH E -BXZ#N=Z * n =OC'Ip 8HF
CH  O4'
] E%M Og8 <Tr
JOQE
G6C
4'*?8 -
=ZEF 
#J  'Y MG*#HS 8!UH8!8'; #  8U# JE < Y=Z
CS'A 
#G '|C*#';A 'H*J -MXZ#|G* Hu=V*#r  H
2.5 General Health Monitors

%
J  '  '>'G * C'JE <T 8'H 
G6 #TC 
]H 
#8'& 
}DJ'Hu# YH
#H '|T!IC H %
e'%H,OC'

.
*8 *C 
#<gC =?
GpOC'u 'H'4   H*'|C'8'-oXZ
*HV f#rC
> 'g
#GW G 
8';CC |
J  '-`>>
WEW  *# $8!
p%N ;Ch!
p
FW 8$OQ*#'H #8' ?
H*
"*#r
TC`%8
>=Z 'h
G?
uH8!8'; !#JsR8'
x 4 H'HE
>
)
C*#  IC  JE$%u
CW4 $=?#
"8'H ; 
$ #'H# pG*8H


W H'*8
 ;A 
nH
HC'IWEW N ,H*%C'H lOQ$8 8
6'4)
 x'C4#l-fXZ`=Z * u A=(OQ '^MC'VC*#';A V
H*#

C*#
 M F 'H'4 ] #>#' k-
 
HA'4u#*'
GMHTC TG `
>G '*#
T) H>W *# J t-^Y ;
 OU HNJ)H+" ;hCG>=V* $T!No C'8 Ep OUH
HC'
TA k=Z * @8
W ;C
Ez
J  'kA'  *kH*#W ;C
pC'p W)


H*86
J 
J'
8
 -(&
o#'%  M=Z * nL%# 
2.3 Organ Monitors
  

BA'JEn  <g 8'6=V8'IC8'F #< Cp%#I=Z J 
GkOQ ' =?J L#GW !P#' -, =M =?
GB
IZ
; 

G"


C
p 'G
$#
TA  
k
k  > JA i-Z&A'Ek< TA  8
 ]
HIC'H oH
#H 'pG o
TC$=?'8 8Hk H';
HHH
z
#OQ 'IA)

# 'P W P L=?k=MCJ 
#GeOC' C
q 'G
q
 - &
) 
o % *# M
W 
TCxC #J \E <'HH*#' <#C'M
 H';C8 
#M Of
)
OQ 'H *#
TC 8E <]C'k T
K
p #'; O p#C'H o
K!8' W 
TCxH C  N*H<C =?
GP# 4  'Z 6%8 H 4'?#  G
 H

 
    # |OC'& H';C
H C
 SG*#
*HR<OC'S #8'|&!8'HEoHC'H G!CW H'
W 
TC` H H?
u

#)i
  H!]I
#
8'-gS
C 8'
=?
#= COg <##%
#
GN
# 'G
p
!!R<
o=?4 H*;K# SG CH*#'$ N<MYVN<V pN<Z
 CC' #C'H

 
$ H';
#H 
6 #oC'G!C
%8OQ 'kJ 6
#$ 
G 8'IrC-LmC' ';C 6OQ 'u% 6=?J BC'H u#HCH-oXZH
J  '
e%

"

#W ;
8<Y#'H8' C 
n I C)\p#*#'uOC'pA'H <?AA)\ *HN
C ^
#EN
6> 8  'w ^ j6MH8 H 
G<!* Y H& >
J  '
#*'NOC'I$ !4'<VC
T !A)\"#*'NOC'Iphr
8E  
JA t-ni F &C k
TP%8'HOC'I
# O^H r8'SC'?y'8yG 8'-

#N=VC'F#C 
#Go=?J eIHI c<xy
J N[*
J \EpCOZ%=Z4'
3. EXISTING CHALLENGES 
eN*
# C 
eNJ ;Ct<YJ N N
C 6H*#''H
#Gp TC NJ H  

o # MH88 
x<#=Z|H8'%> >IC
E4 
G ?O '?=?J'8)
HP F*
#C 
L=?J q# ]H
#H 'o
8 =Z 'h TA %=Z8'=??%o'IC

G$OC'I#*# ;C 
x-LXZ4'kC' H )
A'?*
 [ *MC'^O*
C
; JE6sR4'
YOr'  #8'YH
HC'Z
#8 H) 8';CZ%HHJ F pA!8' 6 IHH*u TA FA'Ho% *H
=V 'hB # C 
nI 
#- ]J *#GeH H*#H8 u OM 8H  O^ # S
#W H'; 
-&
#|8 o=V*#rp% IE P#C ;
'[*#J'
UIE%]HTA'IEF #8'M#' # I 
< #  #'HH
4
# Hk-
8F#
TC 
( O? H'[ *#'8
uICh!F=?J'H6
#8 \=V 'h ) A ;P #'HH
BC =?> N N  *
&COM#C ; o%

#G"CO?# VH
HC'FHG
#y
JE(JsR8'
NOr' #8' H';
#HJ H (
(OQ8=Z8'I#J -nXZ8' C'oI
E(sR4'
I GC)
E%NCO]H
HC'6
4 \=ZC'h-B]F '8H*J 6CO] #HP#JsR8'
#< 'J VOQ '] #'HH
GFA ;< ;o=?J  # 
;CGZ C ]C'
JsR8'
|'HC';n#' uC'HP
(#JsR8'
uH*# 
N   ##' #' C FOQ 'usR4'
| #C 
#-6
,IC
E  H8<fH*;
#H#' ?A'>'[ *J'l-  6=?J n P
H*
L
J C'<U # H
#H '=?]%4'HO ' %8'J)
#p%  
GB O> #k
'

-KXZkH8
H 'PIEn
 
)
*TCEL' H IA ;BC
T(' En # *#F* A  o' #
G 
3.1 Low Power 
#u!8'HEp
*# 8-]SJ  *Gk #|H
HC'J HJOU=?g hJE
}q'8 8HUH
#H 'Y
4 \=ZC'hgT!V%=V8'^'W H'8 
<=?8 #8'
%8'HOQ 'H S Cl' HH
GF Ol SC ;<rA'GC*#
 U O
#8EBC'I# U 'N #8'H=?H-$XZN N#*#
C N
JEB 
A ;PG  SW Y%u8OQ & I H';C
HJ -]&
#8'G E$4j
4Ep
#SHIC% EH  TH+S Ol ]H
HC'<##*# V Hu% *#H&COx #
h!8E <R #6H|A ;o   F*#
C  <l #FH|%=Z8' #6H
)
CH
#? OR=?J'-g}DJ  *# Y=?J'U H*#JEN>
W ;
UH*'
H 'S=? ^
H*#-]\
$##J 
p HG
 g #'HH
l<RI G
CO?%=Z8'<f #8'A'P
JE, O8=  # 
#-p&
#6u k!

 #'HH
K G  P H(%p
#nO 'I #k'8 
TB'W 4)

GC';C n%=Z8'FH*#JE <^H*;CpTA H 8'HE -eXZ#FH*#
H-P\
, #u
#W ;
8<` #6I G8u8
G Or' #68_ 8'
TC
%=V8'MOC'?
JEP| J  <=V!8'<
P=?J P
#H8' C)
C8';o=?Z hJEB% #'HHB%8OC'I%
G H';C
HJ H 

W U 84#
 [ *-giOT M
##MY # 
N
F #M%E < Y

 6
8'
 VH8
H '<`'#*#
G #  *
| O?
#OQ 'IA)

# M'; 8 C% u'#  & #&C H 8'HEICM Or 


CZ=Z * P%]'8)

6 C U
Y %M H';C
HJ H N '*G F ?J 6TC
T)
[ *#'l- g HH!u%=Z8'&H*#'8<RH*;$ SH C'|C
Tk#';A  
x<
=?  l-S&
|8 PO '&'HH
G6 #uICGu*HS6O '
'A p
#H*#j8 8
 P%=Z4'oOQ 'o

**#%8';A 
x- XZ
 OlHG 
;C 
l-YqHI %A' Ol ?I G?Z8_#C
#6C
T
 #V |C
I8_ 8'
TCt< =?J'HVH*#'8SCO`%=Z4'Z%
G #]
JE
G G uC'6
# R-XZG %6o%
<x 
#<fC'|#G <



OQ H# |H  * 
x-V&  
MOC']%A=V8'?H*#JEoC'H*HHo

#8%
T
#G&
F M8 #N%
#G>E R-g&
#Z 8HMG)
H88 
- -
G uC'I#HA!4'l<^ CW 
NC' uC' 8
, TA'" 
}q'8 8HH
HC'|
8 =Z 'h]'[ *J'FH uOQ 'COV
#8'G Ep 


HZJORC
E| OT #U H'
#`OQA=-YiO 4Eu##<C gG g
#C 
 %8';C  -$XZF8
8'GCEBu*HBOQ 'NA'  *|O*#
8 
#N
(C4
  C'G 8'|OA *#'|#'H8
 - f
<f
<f
T"#G #4 8 

##<
*T
G&'*#


#G] #ZH
HC'< #' 8HH
G> V
OC'IC)
C'N g!4'HEk *# ;A 
TCE 
 8
H<%#=Z!4'->]
k8_ 8'
TC

x<Y
eA ;  F*
#C 
l-PW# JE <f |%=Z8'u=? V%
#' 8HH ']=? x
o 6CHH W ] ?#' 8H-
8!
JEL W H'#*# n
L8
H*#n 
Gp o
#86
L #
&
D "
#BTC
TR<>G HG
TCu[* J \Eq=V*#r#8 ;A e

#8 \=V 'h%-(]


n!
(
H*## 
n OS%=Z8'F=Z*# LC = #
G e'#*#
TC
8E$';A -"XZN=V*#re
#H*#' TA u #I 'H'4

##M N%>'4C'G  HF*# ;C


 *HJE < 8'8E'#*8
#GN #

#OQ 'IC 
6G 8 H 
G$OQ' IH
#H ' p P8_ 8'
TCM#4)
*#H Og
=?  PO ']';TA'G
G-
&C'?S!8'-^&GI'#*#
T#
4E < =Z8!8'<M!8'HE8W JE
U  #C=?J'HfH
#H 'g >  
T 
#W H'; 
x=?J 
=?J ( I#'8  *F *#
NCO]%A=V8'F C N6CrC-,XZ
'8G!C';( "%A=V8'<Y
*T
G$ PA #HHTA eOQ'  *H
#G
 (" H'*( OPq8
 ;
 [ *(  C ;LO*H
x<
#,%=V8'->%8
T#
#GL
D=?8'"
 #"%Eq "H
#H '
=?; 
;C pH8'; |
p% 
GL J'$
#OQ 'IA  
@ C)
I Cl<M #p =MCBC*#
 6 O#C o#HHTA K C'-
G4 8'kOQ '$
4' H#*# ;A  
TCu%=V8'p#' 8HH
GDC
T
'
# S 
;C 
I'[*#J'ZF*#4F =V8']#HHTA  
x<HN 
 8*#';C8E -kXZ#8'IC'H 6=MEu o=Z 'h$=?J B 8H HH*#-
B
 o# I G  k HH*#pH*#'H'*#
T
#G, #pH
HC'-@
 #
&
G  ? `OC'&J o=?J' 8

#8 
#-MmC'&
#W ;
8<


 H6COV u'8 
TI#' W H<lO '|
#W ;
8<x #N %4';C *#'

 
pH
HC'F
##PG u%I=?J'e $k
#C' Ee8F*#
A  

COR M8E ?Y =V8'V 


6 M8 ']%Eu %8';C *'- # 

 t-UXZM=Z *  C =zOC'] #&H
#H ']
& FH8
HC
T
 8  'NC'F*
H*'6 OV 68sR88 u OZ';C H
#Gk F %4';C *#'
#' 8HgHM#C ;M=?V UN*
# C 
u
V * | #

COV #N8E!->i >>%HH# N TC &TC8 8' I C |A'F*#H*T JE$C#)


H
* 6 ' HHK
O 'IA 
x-qXZk8F*#
A  

H8
 V=? R #'!]
P #S=MA'8'Z %4';C *#']=?J P #&H
#H '

> *  *HJ M
#8'G Eo8_J JEIO 'SH
#
GN '?'
G
C&NG '=M p  8NC
To #>F*#
&WEW =V
lw S%| #| 
A ;<E 8r
GF
G4'S >%8OQ ' &
8HC'HEP'4C'G -
4sR8 !JEn FTA N #H  8 4'r-n F F*
88'H ; 
n=?8 #8'
 uF4_#%88 , C |OC'6HPCA  
<YH*;(CF 
C
EH*## k8sR88 G  *'P
L o
+8EIA  o' 8 

G*#Ho
J C'
#G#<g #oCJ \EB p H';C
HJ NC ;k $C
(8_)
Cu=Vc-$SJ  *G B=ZPC'IW Z
C u8'H ; 
(COM 8sR4 NCO
8'
 ]#P=? ]% '[ *J'(OC'O*'H 8'I#C ;"#' HH
#G#-
;#'
 
;A  
k
P >%E <#'8HC';8']A'u8*#'H'
JE
XZS8_ 8'
TCg#|IEk% 'H*#J #H#rEp*#
J <TOQ '>
)
W *E
Gu 8sR4 -
W ;
#-IXZ#u| 8'HE"C H H';C8 !6 #<`OQ 'uJ u A=?|O*'H 8'
 *# ;A 
p
$  |=?J $G 'A 8'#' 8HH
GP  J 
3.2 Limited Computation 
,H|
# #J ,%=Z4'NH*##E -6S 4'u # C 
#NG
 * ;C 
ug#J'8 JE|J |#*Y ] #UJ u *#

#8I
TNH
HC'V=?J P C'HE
G|CTC U TC VN*
# C 
CO^%=Z8'-ZSJ  *G  ]S ;h
#=? #G TC ]H
#H 'SC'|
C
=?J n ;( #8'6C
TeH
e* F
I  %C';C ! C ;pW)
4_#%88 e $T!I P#*# 
Gp%=Z4' O]=ZC'hW ;A 
F '
 G -Um 'V
W ;
#?=?  #SA'H JyT  T'4 
#'W #H< 8'
8!
k T
)i8r #<# |  *
? O^8* ;C 

G ]%|
 E#%CO^H
HC'&OQ '& #%8'#8'; xH
"C
Tk
C MM% HH #&=?J  u %H
#H '?ZHG
#JyTC
 JEPH
#JsR8'8
 ? E#%>OQ 'S >yT
#|#8 ;Cf H
x<%C>sR4'
SC'H ] O

n P  # J I O>"G 
8'kH8
H '-XZ# F H'*#oOQ '
6'4 
k#' 8HF
#OQ 'IC 
n#JsR8'
JE -kXZ#F * BG!
p C'8 EBCO]' H
#<Y
ICOM=?4(u I%=Z8'N J ;A  
x-
SW ]C*#';A &'# A 
kCO`=?TA ?M
 'ICEP 8*#'H'
G
 F*#
C 
6U!4'HEF8_%
#H!Z
6 8'^ OR%=Z4'< ^' C)

&8E -
!8EF '?%=Z8'VV*HF u8F*#
A Z T
6 | * -
G ^%Z% *HM #ZH
HC'VA'ZOC'UJ ;C'HEu'

TCH
8
3.3 Material Constraints =?J o
#|%] Ol'8 H'  %C'Z%C*HS OxW M8
W H';C
 - U8)
U *#H6 #CgH
HC'>=? ^%F#rC
k=? #
" #
%E <# #|HT % <TH+<RC
T IA 8'  ?=? f%'W H'8 l-?XZ# C*Hu O^ H|J ;C 
#<%F*#4 '8HC';p8sR 'H &S*'H'
JE
H+ 
nH %oC'o#8 4'
#B
nTA'H 6 EB #oC# A 
x- %
GP'88 k =MC';$#'A
G6 uTA H 8'HEkJOF OYH
HC'
m# ']8_# #  <NHIC'H ?H
#H '&#HG
#o 6H*#%C'H M &'8 
 
nk
8 =ZC'hR<`O 'N IC
B*#'% HI O]#'  
G 
#Gp *H4)
'W #HNN*W |%HI Y
 *G B  y =?J #
e
e8E!-oSW) O*#
HCOV N
8 =ZC'hR-uXZ#*H*TCEp H';C
H C 8
 P
#
H*#
G]F*J Z;#<C4u=?J FI
EH8
H '<=? %Z*Hl< OC'u =%=Z8'|'[ *J'8
 <lOC'u
86 6C H 8'HE"TC|%

 ;"8C8'
GP6HI f%C'H  
$ O^ '8 
T<R ;p;pF*#W #88 R<# #>H
HC']
#]#4O*
#8 -
%PHI M
#*#G( "  A I #-(G!CW H'
W 
T  XZU U
C U #] H<#A=V!8'<O 'V# H
HC'-^W#4)

J  '<#
P >C 8'?
l<
o
#JEo%&W=M =ZR<%HF #  JE <%
uH
HC'>] # 
l<J S=?f'I 
p
p%4';C 

H+COMP^=V*#r"%6H*#j6
-6XZ#6H
HC'IE$T!N  OC'&H8!8'; lE A'<% HH #N #-VXZ l#' #*#'8
8*#'!?A'*
F Z'8 
> 'MC C ?>%
? 'UA'H   CG 
u'HhY HH  C F=? FH
HC'U#rC
;C 
NI h!YOQ'[ *8

CV=Z8 c<#T
Gu
PT 4 V
P #SH
#H '?HG
o
IIA 8'    C
&
T$ CW*#W 
] OUH
HC'>#'; 4   c-m*'H 8'H)
*#H-  ' <fTCH,*#%
,= 6%E"' 8 |=?J , H8
H '<`J
^!
@JOI u O B#*# ;C 
T |HH*8,'  *HJE@#W) IE %|Jj*J ] W=MC"
|H
#H ']O '>
# 4'-?m 'S8_# 6)
8*HH"
,%F'H!l<x |COM
o*HFJOZ #FH
#H 'uC

C <l
$ F HFCOV #N'8 
TI#' W H %HpCOZHIC'H
AOJE$C
T 4sR8 !JEPO*
#8 
p
#%E -VXZ*IC
6) H
#H '< ]H%JyTS  8
ZCO`C4IH
#H 'Z'8rA !S | 
N*
#UWEW  ^HG
u &8FC fOQ 'G
6H*#W ;
8g
u #
4'!u
eG!
#G p
, I*
#8'JE
G HH*=?M#4 8'

%E -`i f` #8'8OC'VCO* W f%C'H ;
8Y ?T!^ YH
#H ' U%8';A 
FCO# #VH
#H '^
#8 \=V 'h%-f>8%
T
#G?
| V'_)
J \E"%8 \=V
" 6G
G r$C
T" #6H
#H 'N#'%8<g#JsR8'8

&

##S% H COU# C uIC 8'  -]XZ#H|IC 8'J)


C>F*#W >C8 CPC'H'8'&%8 \=V
p  T*#r>C
T uH
#H ' !  ;CG>MIE6%]'[ *#'l- ZCHo
POQ# ;h6OQ' b 
8%
#
vf#A=V!8'<x 8E$N*W 
# |
#J  6 %8';C 
TA 
<` F%T '| OV 6H
#H '|=? Y%IAW*#W l-i |
CO? H
#H '-pXZ#I%E,IE"%G 
e  '\W88 N # 
<  *G  M C M #>TA  8
 w ?#';C
=? ` HI#  M F M
4=
=?#4"TC
"!8'HN8sR8 
p FH8
H 'w |C Ep O*
#8) OC' ORW F*#t< J #*G 6 'U W 
G&N*W g%M88 | 
   C ? -^ 

G>
#8=qH8
H 'U*# P'; W C JEPC 4'


P'%8'JE -^XZ#VG U
#*T? #?H
HC'M
]%8
G
N
8';C8 
l<U8!
(JO? I  8
FCO? IH
HC'# 8

8
CH* A o EyT'*#V HH*- kC 4'rC&A' HF'W H'8 

C ;T
#Gu';#CE -|S
8<R u # 
pH
HC'|C'N8_)
6
u
#V C ?A'&
C M #!8'H8EPAsR8 I E6% JE * #-^6)
# 
C'N#'
N PI
#J 
"  #' F% H < P=?4 %8 | ]%V %8';C 
  OC'^8_ 
T%8'#fCO -`\
 
 8*#'F=?#
e P A 8 F
( I (%G 
( $ G*# C  CH> O`4'
CEP C
 #<E A'Z '?8!
P##8

 #kH*#'HO pCO> kH8
H '-qO& #k
T#J 
#I
#H # #  OR %8';C 
IC'?8_%8 R-f\#C JE < MH
#H 'U=V*#ru'I 

%E(C*Hpp' 4  
L=?J n PH
HC'<Z
# 'I M %8';C 
 
PO '] JOu Og #|TC 
-ZSJ  *G %A=V8'SI
#)
A!4'u
B4_ 8
T#$%4' " OZ N 
# |% HH #-P C'JE <  G 
?MW  x% 'H ;
< #&=ZC'h
#G6#%'[ *#'8Z TC
#F
# 'I `%8';A  
BCOU #NHIA'H H
HC'H * $
 & *#H  #C%H
HC'V'I 
O*#
8 
T c<%8' U=?  #]'GC)
# ICG| P #N%E ->mC'>8_#C<%ChCGFCOU _FC'>TC+8) * A'
#O*#H
" OM  
T g%=V8'-N
8N u8_ H'; 8 '% ' 
A';# *?H*#W ;
8<T
8 *#
GN H> C ? 8*#'S SN'H*# ]CO ac8_ 8'
 # > #?%ETd`%A=V8'ZH*##ENH * 6%M T 4 ZC
T
#G   g
8'; 8 
=?J  <#F*W Z%|A #R- % 'H ;C<R%=Z4'S'W H'8 
>W g #JE <%#*# ? |H
#H 'S=?
XZ#8'6A'6 
SO '| ;hCG
GP uH
HC'|
>
,# ) '[ *J'H*j
?%=Z8'?OC'&;#'
>O*#
8 
T J \E -
8TA eIC 4'rC- 
IA 8'  pOC'$  XZY
#G )t 8'  8
l=V*#r>'[ *#'UZ'
4=M #U%=Z4'
6
8 *#PWE
 #8 o% JE#4'F '6G  ]%JE8'< H*'<CVTA H 8'HE6%=V8'V=V* %]
#H*#j8 8
 YOC'V #S
#G 
4 ; <g 'u4'; <^C #*#Ge
# u U OZ #H6=? U%H*J H)  O% V C YU%8
#G>#' %HR-^XZ4'SA'MH!8';CTC 4'
TC !
CIO '6T ;h  G
#G"H8
H '-"}D# PG  H ;hCG
G$F
#8'H %=Z8'NH*'<g#=Z!4'- 
 4'W 
G 'HC';( |%
#Gp
)
=?J "'H%8  P F%E <l uCHkTC%  ' 4'I g#' %8'H) #*#8 I
k*#H
GFC 
oOr'=Z h
#G6 FG 
8';A %=Z8'-U
<g#HHTC 
#GpF*;" 8HN#C | TC
BC 8'uIC 4'rC-kXZ# H% C%
#H&I #MCOf+8 8 H'&IA 8'  TU=V '
I
H #
4_#8H6C 6F #
L#HHTA n '*#GnTA'H F O] PH
#H '  OM #6H  -P}q
,W H'rNC'6 ; h
x<xW H'Hu |#*# |
, TC

##| TA C'N


C &
# H"
$G  H<lH*#4" S |H
HC'
#) IC 4'rCc<T=?;"] 
k8
!8'H k
8 H'J E -S A'>
)
;C8 Z% 
 -YXZ#Z  +IA M HHC 
PVh!JE6 | *#H 8'GCE 'g84
C!#';C 
`
u H&%YTA'
HH ?%=Z4'
%4'I
8
 N# I G 6 k H*'H'*
#
Gk HH*#-pW JE <f # H
#H '-^&=V!8'<!=?J IC
EN O% #H?4#< M
#8'G EFG
)
H8
H '| ;hCGuH * "%uTA'H  OY uHIC'H &H
HC'|
NJ H) 8';A oW x
#Z F%& H';C
WO4'H'P=?J'HHJEk
N #&%E <
H8O-/ $8'HEW ; 
#BIA 8'  o C k
z%,GC'=?
@
z  ? #M 
#GF *# ? O` &%EoC'>
# ?#';C8  c-Y ??C H
H
oH*#W H';C &
#*T#S# C
TC
TI *#
*#
#J H'r  
i- *
#C' C > #HF HH!F 84#
 [ *S
"'rCJE"G
#8';C 


XZ#H|IC 8' C ST!>#Gk 4'I R
#*#8 J E '%8'H < PC*
| O]
#8'G EB
#R-"S 8'u% HH # J 
8 *#


=?#4$I h] #/G $4#&OQ '&H
HC'TC4h  G 
#G#-&> C) *H
#GF
T*8 ;C
<'C #P E';FOQ'[ *#
|a SmYdY '?
)

TR<#*#
h!>C*
*
# H' <## ?
C ?T!C
_ C 
OQ';A'Bac dYHG
T -Z
8& >8
8'GCEP H';!8 ?
o=Z!< 8'


 E 8'< =V!8'-^XZ#g
#` TA f V#  
T=? ' 4 g=?  f
?
#>OC'f=?J'f ?C'H'HE #U
#8'G E&OQ'@* HrU ?
H #


J'
B
" #N%E -uS*
*~
# H' <l
$ FC 8'>T
l<R S%E - Sm,
#*4 ;
8S V #> # J E N F*#
C M 

#8'H |=? ,'H%8 | o #6%E <`I h
GPJ FPOCH #P;  I
E,H
HC'6HF*# ;C
 *HJE -$ |<f
( I #8'F
l<^6


OQ 'S# lH
#H '- F*#4IC'>#J'4 o%Ck<
#EoC& N H';C
HJ Z NNH
G 
#8W 
C 
l-P  uC H$% *
T$ E" 
# O?HG vg TA |<f 
'8 8'?F*#W M%>H #& N #& H';
#H H 4'-^XZ?M h!8EI 
3.4 Continuous Operation
 
C*H] HH*#V=?#
P#C 
#G|=?J I %
8
 Y
H #? ?%E -
}q'8 8HPH8
H 'I
#8 \=V 'hT!I o% 
  M ,

8

A 
XZFm M  >H%8JyTk F- C)W - !p&S+u';C
GuOC'*
'G*)

B
 *#'M!M
PI
EF=ZE#<
6'HC';4'SA'S #
#h
#GNCOf
#8=
 C P\
#*W H' C)\
y8) #CR*HMCO &mV-XZ#?';C
G >
C# A 
&C JE - W S O^ HH8
H 'S
4 \=ZC'h<%=Z8!8'<

C &8
W H';C
k Eo 
#NCOUHG  ]OC'>H# 'H &#W ;
#<%H*#4$C
A'n#HG
z K%4';C e
 C H 8'HE%=Z8'-XZ
#H] TC Y=Z * I%S*#HFOC'M# %H8
H 'Z
8 =Z 'h-gi %
#
M
pN lHIC'H ?H
#H '-
H#*#rp%|
C l<T=Z8'<T TA S #8'u S 'u #H '  
$
>  G
 W  8?C'C
 #8'M% 'H ;C
VOC *#'] TA Z HSWEW)
#F%E$C #G4'>OQ'[ *#
> 
"C > =V8'|
#-u\
$H%8) Y=? l
 N
C'% ';C  -Z
] HSH
HC'?C'&G 
G
8rCl # C 
#]H*#4PCZ ?'8 
TN'W #H<|#   % 
o
$C
T 
J  '? #*#I
o%E < #8'|C'
A'H';E <Y=?#4(
!8'H u G  F
 $4 H'  M%=Z8'<YIEB H h!JEk %|A'HE
#G6'H%
#H&Or' #JsR8'
S%#  -S
k 


%8
H 8'l- CHVH*;| x ^G*8HV 
# C'<C#JsR8'
xTA  8
 xT!
#JsR8'8
 
# 'I  $!6CO&G * Hk
n #J'6#  nW H'Ck-
XZ?H
#H 'Y=? T!Z >%MyT
#8)t *
#| G !Z M'%8'UC'
3.5 Robustness and Fault Tolerance
7
kC4,TA  8
 -6\
, 4'> OM #N'8 
To#'W #H<f 4'6
U  #C?H
HC'IC'k8_%4 e ,  W P"
G$ <V 

,'G*#rA' H 
#Ge%8 \=V
K #pG!C
G - VC*H$ O& <
J F N
C #8H';CI "H*'GC JEL CW*#W 6H
#H '68!8'HE"=Zh%<
oH8
H 'uG %F  B
" #C'o%8 \=V
, =ZoG!
#G <

x<^ 'F!
eE!C'-,W JE <U$H8
H 'F=Z*# n CW 6OC'!8'<
CJ *#GBPC'u'C W JO8 F=V*#r$%F
$ |';
#G6CO
';C #8'M TC

J'8 JEI
P P O` #- YJ ;CGZ=?x
# F%
AW*#W FA ^ ;F
##V S
#H*#'U#'%4'^H
l<! Hu
NOQ)
 #- VC*Hu OY <% |H
#H '
#8 \=V 'h H#*#rp%u8_)
TC4hoOQ'/ |TA 
->>  G
 W  8>=? ^%uJ ;C`OC'> W 
G
H'8JEo' *W SC
T OcC*J ] 8';
-V\
kC'H * A'<T >O *#'
#'C  E#%86 OS H #C6=Zc-n}DJ  *# 6 #k<^ 8'
CO
#
##kH#* n
C  *#H o
J'k
8 =ZC'he BCH
=Z * %o
"C'IOQ# ;h(
n=?TA I IC8 *TCEL 8*#'H'
G
 %8';C 
x- XZ%W u8 #, OM ;
G # ||I h
G 



H #> #>%E -
W H' #*# p
#8 \=V 'h%<%
#N=?#8'N ;"H8
H '>
#uC
" %8'H)
kC 4'rCpF*W  H%,A'8O*#Ez; H
D K!  z*#

#)
A >C*# 
# *HJEFOr'bJ U
G%C'< *#GW % %4';C 

#$
 4'; 8 
"=?J , N%E -FXZ>=?VC Hk  ,
,'4)
=?#

8HC'HE -fOl>H
#H 'M YW 6=ZC'h
#G#< #
F MH8
#)
#*#
Gp O *#' ';A -e>8H G

G$HPH
HC'
( 6)
HC'Z
P #?H*#'H'*#
T
#GuC'|H * W  %O*#
8 
oCZ
C'I c-


 C
 
#G6F*# # SH
HC'&
##M=?x  FC'&'#*W 
8H



Tl< V8
8# VH*# F=Z 'hN=? #
P
#r*TCH
#H '
TC
e 

Go
#
  #H
HC'F
##- k
E,HI c<

##6 F=V JO>$H


HC'C

#,
#G8'6#' HI#C ;<UOQ '
=M)%=V8'pHIC'H H
HC'p#W H'* D 
GL( C'G4'"C'

#W ;
8<^ TC 6A ;kH*# nW M%'!LC
Te HH(

=?M h!8Ee *#H H# I G  " #I HH*#o TC


(
#o C'G <
JOSN*
# C 
(FOQ*
4  

G-n&
#I=ZEe BC4#!I 
%=Z8'H)i
H*#
#GFH
#H 'S ;hR-
=V*#r"%N oT!FH8!8'; ^HIC ^ %
#
S=?J'"  G8 #8'
C ?O*#
8 
$ S6G '*#x-ZXZS
##G ]% #'H CO


|H
#H
#G| 4h%< F*
#C 
# 4h%<H4##*#
#G| 4h%<
C
T C 'uoA ;P#  ;h%-NXZ>=Z * ,%FPG  "=ME$ P H  C 
3.6 Scalability
g'  *]
#W H'; 
S8
 
R<H*#4pC] #
oOC'>=
%=Z8'f
>
yT
A    #V C
xC'C< OQ '8` ^H
)
#II JO*#
8 
#
Gp ;h,Or' 6'W N O? I %
#


k #
# <% ]=Z` S'#*8
#G6%=Z8'S
H* 
pC
G H 'P (%p' C !JEKHI S=?J D O*#
8 
 J \E -  V8
#A'*? %
#
- 4' uW V 6
#,OQ 'NH*#W ;
  ZC*#
 |COMO*
#8 
)

C';#8'? 6
#H*#'& C ? &#'%4'&#C ;F?%
GFH
]
T  J \E - \
qC';#8'P (
#H*#'k pH8
H '
8 =ZC'hPA'"W C
'8!R< 4'C'uNOQ8=  # 
#M TC ]C
k%*Hl<=?8 #8' %=Z8'HOQ*U |
8HC'HE <`I
EpHIC YH
#H '|IE$
p k%
 CP
T6=V 'h
o8
\*
#8 
=?J oC4P #8'-g}DJ IF*#)
 
H
#GJE6C'V
 F
C 
l<!
*#
G;;hH*< TA' EF;84h%<
C
Tk8E'#*#
T#
4E ;;h  t-&&
| Og #Hu ? | 6) &H8
H 'M8F*#
A 
#Gu 
#GW Z #H!<  Z=Z8 lC

q #(CON;84hH*<MnH# p4'H' 'p8 8 
DH4#- I F *# #*# <l  OVN*
# C 
p=?Y%u ; h
G
}q K4#4hH*#<M ;zA ;eH G $ PH
o 
#G(=? q  C<%I
#
G| 4j
?*HCOf >=?J'H]H%8 H'*#k-
;84hH*/  *NT H$*#%
p N
#wR#
&C'> \=V#w  *#'H'8
 Y=?J'HVH8
H 'V#'C  Z
C UH*j
JE6H*#% 'H
88
 Z Of #>H*COf S=Z ';M
SH G -^}D
]
*N%8'Y Ox =M)i%=Z8'?H8
H 'V
l<!
 'Z UJ MC'V TC
#H G | M'8!l<TF;;hH*]#*# P
#>
#) 8HZ#'C  g=? #H Z ] VH+M
#HA'HENOQ '^#  #C
8
G(HCG-XZ#$ =Z(  *8kC'p #
DC'R-O
8#-
#8EoC'> #> < #
o #8'>]NG k#' T # J EP C M #  VM Hu %C'H ;
V 'C +8& TA ZJ MZ*
#C'V=DIC
E
8H GP=MCFH
u=? #* A ;p  H-BiO? 8EeC'o#JsR8'
< H
#H 'f=?
# S%Y C SICh!Y #VWEW zO*#
8 
 c-
#=Z!4'< #
I &8H G&T M%8
CJ 8'o
I H';
#H HH
Z ? &% 
< &S%8 H 4'S #* k
k #u J \Eo 
#8'CH
C
T
#Z 6%H
] G 
x- ?
*N%8'U Y ? 4#
   G E%8Y 'M'8y
F 
6 
'HG
I ]WE#W 8C4 M ]H
HC'M *
ZV
#8' Hl-

S #8'IOC'PCO|8'H' 'oC'H'8 
z
*#pTA'J \E4#4h
G
C
T 8E('#*#
T#
4E@;84h a d  
J t- S
E OI 8H
H;8g
N%M*H >
H*'V V
GC'J \Eu OT #MA ;S%
#G
3.7 Security and Interference
H';C
HJ H R< J  *G I #8ECTT!M H';8)i sR-g}D# ]TA'J \E S|=?J L
Ee Z
O 'IA 
x<^ #oHH*P OS
#y%
#)
;84h
GP>';C 4'H6C
T"# 
# *#H6
E$C'HE <%J   J \E6C'H-USJ  *G 6J UU %C'H ;
g TA U #M EH 
6C'
 >J k8'H'C'|#8 88 
$  # J -N%8JyTC JE <l
#8) FTC 
|H6 #NOQ# ;hpOQ' #6H
#H '<gJ ||
 |
)


#J ITC'J En4#4hnC
q8 8 I"H
Gp# I4'H' '-zXZ# P
OC'IC 
k C ]
8HC'JEpH#*  %'! #CW &#*JE -U\

C ; # N4#u=?


$8'H'C'C'u';C'- <R
p u #8' ##J 
l<#J MM
# ?HJ'; &OQ ']C
o *# H #8'V NG 
kCHZ 

l<
o#4 8 ?uG 'A 8']A' 4 \ECOg8'H' '-UXZ#&HCG> MH8
H 'U 'Y ? H# E -f Y*# 6%S#
#G8' *< 
FOcA ; c<
H'C eCFo
*#F%8'<R=?# ;eu# #"E, '#4 8'
 OC'|Oc H6' #
G > kC%A'|
ePTA  8
 w G  *#H
J  '
G 
4';C  '-&XZ|'IC
#8']COU # ] *# ;A 
p>C%
# * * -LXZ C F H'*#  OS8'H'
 *I G %
G"#'C)

&
6 #H G -V}q
#H G | ?'8 l<# >'IC
) W88 I
I ]8E ] 'VO ']C
E #8'ZO*#
8 
PCO` #S#  #C
8'> * $
Tp TA'l- V H"*%
p #FG8
8';A  ' H
#H '- VC*Hu O^ 8H|'[*#J'
<J & S C| TC
C ?M;H8
x<# lH
#G8)iJ ?8'H'C'<TCW ] l# *# 4)#J M8'H) W H'8 H8*#'J \Ep84
HS%N#*# >
$ CN C &=V*#r$#'4)


'C'<>C
TqC
EK#K
*F%4' Ou8'H'C'oC
D%$#8 88 l-@\
!
SI *#>
 4'; 8 
$=?J " #HuWE#W 8-SJ #*G pJ

 
C';#8' ,#*#   <VJ  
TCSC';=ZC'<ZH*;KCI IE$H A H H'; 8 !N  
#8'HE# |C ^COZ FC ;<gC
E$
#)
H#JOQ |'GW 8'NC
T & GC <f >'[*#J'l- Z HB*%
" # 
GCO*c<lW H'
#GI
8'HE  
p=Z*# $%|  I#*# ;A  
TC JEp
)
C# A 
x<C 4'UIE>
# `%Y'  @OC'f 8HV #J 
   6) 
#H Z >%Z#';C8  OC'U #HM*H-gXZU^A'E6
6 %

HH*#| C ? ?


6  *MH*  
$C ? M - C
q%k8_  L e8'C p8j8 8
 TA PC'p%HH# 
U8 \=V
 ? O] P#'% HL # C 
#6O '6  
o &
#8 \=V 'h-YXZ8'& V
F
#6OC']NHJOr)C'G!C
+C 

=?J'HpH8
H '
8 =ZC'h 
K $G 'A k
*N%8'P Ou%  #'C  Z , =
T  #* ZH8
H 'F
( #o
#8 \=V 'hB "#4)
8 n Ee H H6 C N G  F%I8 %(=?J ( I*#HoCO 8'
N #'_J \E"
,
*N%8'CO?
G%C'
#GkH
#H '-
#HP
8 =Z 'h<YJ FN
 F*
' H
T #P $8_%8 N*
' &C'&] 8'N
EP'[ *J'
? P#!8  $6'*# 
#G#'  8
COg  *
#] Og #H
8 =ZC'h?
p C|
o 
4_ ] #-  
GNH
HC'Z 6#4 8'
&C #M 
GFH8
H 'M C M
#
XZ#>
"p  u#' COV
8'HOQ8'
8F%8 =Z
p=?J'8) nN*
# C - SJ  *GDH*#4D'   pC'"
  * 

:
H]
4 \=ZC'h]
k%8W ;C
T#
#G6
8_ M 6 ;k #8'] ']!
OC']
8 =Z 'hMCOgH
HC'] C ?A'  8  EIHJEI\W88 
G
#o% HH En OS
T8 
G"HG
 F=?J 
L
P%8'H
x-ei  C'G M
*#F%8'x OH
HC'gOQ' 
6CJ' 
#Z '^IC
* JEW H'8=?

>8 C'> C >


O 'IA 
pOQ' 
#N%4'H
xw >
#8 \=V 'hkH#*#r  % *# &NyT8rR< #HHH*&#6
# SC'Hu
 xH
HC'

# SI
#OQW >J HJOY
$H 
#u8 H w &#H EpWEW k-M
8'H)  #C 
< =?4'? #MH
HC'ZA']H*'GC JE#rC
FC
T


OQ8'
#I G  u HpNOQ' C 8'| \E%COM=?J'HF 6) p
*#F%8'6
T  8
I O> #pH
HC' A'$#8 8'
#
N*
# C 
l<%H*;p S8'=M!|A!
] ' V*8  C "#- %8OQ '
TR- YE$

Go #>
#OC'IC 
,
 P uH
HC'
!8';Cf 
&8_ W SOC'|#C
#GP=?J p <% #*G pJ >>
C 
,8_#  J 
#Go # 
O 'IA 
e
, #6HG
BCOZ FH
HC'
8 C'&C ? M &=?; 
#>=? x%> > W ?8sR8 ! -  #C 
x<## +PN*
# C 
IW H';C 8G]
o%>#4)
yT
#pO '|#  ^H
H
#Go ; Hh-FXZ6%=V8'|8_%
TJ *#'
OC'?*#  
#GN' *# 
Gu ; ?C
TP#
#GFh
=?#G > Ox 
3.8 Regulatory Requirements
] H#  #CVH
#H 'NC'I%
G *H, k H'C N#W)
4 \=ZC'h,  %GCEn
n%P! #l-,XZ*<^
#8'G E(4j
4E
 H< J f`
# fH*'#'H
GM TA ` #Um# uC
T&'*#G?&#
# W H';A) C
6%Z ; 
uOQ'  
C# A 
#)iH%8yM# H
)

LatmfSdV'G * C ] J'S W 
GP
k*H-&XZ8'uF*#W ]% H '&
8 =ZC'hR- *#'H'8
 JE <#'HC';4'C'u
W G!C 
#GP=?# ;


H > #
#& C M 8H|#Z=?`
# ?TA'k<
o% 8
#) % GPG % #kW 68sR8 ! OQ 'I  
#W H'; 

 C JEp#x<  W ]H*W88 - g' #*'SOQ 'S#'C 8 
GC) H8 gOQ 'H FOQ 'US#  #C#H8
H 'Y
#8 \=V 'h%<C'H *#rA'JEF%=Z4'

]T!%8
$#!8  %oOQ '>8 
#  ` H'  -?}D# u
#I  I
 G 
-
8W 
#G&g*HOQ '^' 
C'HEuA ;< J gf Or 
F
H*j
fOQ ' SJ #*G q=Z,
z #CEz4_##J #H"y#_K %   G<

8 8'

#GI #N4sR8 !
#H&COU #NH
#H '
#8 \=V 'h-&}q  4'&A'SH ]4_#8# 
#-YXZ8']U #]HH*#SCO`
##MOcC *'
#'8 
Tk#' W H<^OC'F
#W ;
8<Y*H
Gk #6OTC4hB
T  >#H*HH,C%CN
$H8 
- -uXZ8'N > HP #N H6

  G
#W <|'8HC';8'Z
IW F*#rA ] #SH8
H 'Z
T8= =?;L$H8
H 'F 'FH
HC'C'P  8(
(F#-"O? IH
)
#>#';C
p 8 J \EP OYu W ?C -UXZ#C <#=Z8!8'<# ?*#
T # H ']A'>  8oH  8EP
o #&Fl< MH * o
# MC*HC
E
P!8' +N=?C J >H8
G#<xJOZC
E #
G#- 
U8' `OQT ;h #' <!OQ 'Z #]#W ;
#&%8 =Z8

#8U=?l
# U%S;TC
GC)
Or' *#I
B 8W H*W4 N=?]%P
8HC'HEBO '68_# 

G 
G-g}D
P
MA' HF#  I
oC 8'ZTC'H MCO` #S%E <
#NJ ;C 
#
p*H8OQ*
H& OU#' C \E%N#<lC&=Z =V!8'<?"

#)iW ;C 
C'HEL C
6' A   , #  'H
C?G* 
#G6#' 8#*'M Of'4yT
8
Z%8OQ '!8
 * R;#'
#  *'-V\#CE < H8
H ']' #
G6H#*#r
xw ]A'HEPOYC
pC'
#rC
;C 
k
o*#I
#- * H)W H'4 4#l<l8_ 
#$ %A!u N l<x '|A=?
, Ek 
m# '? M' H
x<!
o#' C \E% 8M=? xT!> 64 TA 
w ]H #<T J  *G k S C' C

$#W ;C
| *  G!
#MW H'8 VW ;C
T#C';#^CORTC 
YCOQ8 \EN%8OQ ']
EN*#I
| W H)  J 8'
C !Z' #
G - V *HMCOT g% HH # J E < #ZN*#)

#GBC
% #
#-XZP=?'8 8HI H';C
HHH
 O#C ;$F*#W
A 
B'   UN*W & = OQ ' # HJ *C 
,
"HF )

# ]TA' H*'H'*
#
Gu HH*S
P ;#'
>O*#
8 
#) A  
-V&
I &C 8'ZT
l<JO` #&*#W 8'
Gu
o%>#


#G C
Tk%=Z8'>*#  +C 
" OY HN#88&F*#W >CHo%u%8) =?J  *# I  eF*#4n%=Z4'o8
H*## 
L
 #k*W 8'#R<

#G
x-B>HG
(OQ 'AO8 E(F*#W F%okO*
C
; UOQC *' CO o*W 8'
#Ge ##' ;H#* n( BC
A!4'; M'#*#


#  gH
#H '|!#
<%!8
,A > uA' W |W ;CG- %=Z8'?'[ *#'8
-
]CH
TC> #8
S OgHG
P8jC8EI=? R%]'[ *J'!
}DJ'Hf
#8 \=V 'h`CO#  !H
#H '`=?!'[ *J'YG#JE
OQ 'S#'C  \E%- *#W +
TL #C 
#)iH%JyT$'     ,%p#J)
U  #C^H
HC'8'C 6J  
TCt<lO*#
T# 
; ` HH*# %l- }e"C'"*'H'
EL=ZC'h
#Gn
#
#G(#'  8
C YA'Z
C ^
#8'8
 f
NW gC 8'g E%f OTH
HC'^
8 =Z 'h< TA &!|G
#8'; ^CC EkOC'>H
#H '
#8 \=V 'h] O^ H

 JE <lH * "=V#P  U *#H OU J ;C 
Gk4OQ) \E%> uoW ;A'H 
#Gk%
OQ' =?;B8'H ;C
B  +C 
#
OQ8 CO>I
E(CO& #Hk H H<MH*sR8'8'6CO& #Hk H H C
%Z' +FOQ 'ZH%8JyT?# # #C 
-Y\
6C 8'


A' hJEP N%&=? 
#G!*
4'Z 6C
&H

P  =ZC';#< =ZZS
# g

| S#HG
6?*
 [ *YH*  
NOQ '^!4'HE
A'- ]HC';4']
o lH
HC'SN*W M8
H 8']8 J)  #C? # C 
l-K
W  l<Y=Zk% H  C N 4#
 [ *
 gC
Tk ';CfHH*] TA >
 &C'HN
p W &C 8'SH
#H ' C
P%S#8!%FOQ 'M#  TH
#H 'V C V
I%?*HIC
C# A 
-"i Fu
#CI TC NHI*#
H8'*#* *'8) *#r
G ;hUOC'MC
# +6H *# 
I OlH%8y&C# A)
HC';8'g * |%8'HOC'@ W gC
T> H'  f=?J F` C gA' 
#->]>
p4_C<%4j
&=?J'H>
=?  p*# GN
#
#G8' *^ > M!  *#
8'-^^!
u=? 
O 'F
#H
< J '[ *J'pOC'u Y #C 
-PN H'; #8)iCsR>8_W
Y%HH? TA U%8M TA VH*sR8'^OQ'  #H] 
g=Z*#  %8 =Z
(' HH
G"A!8'#FC
Te F*
#C 
B8j
)
A!4'   hN  *g#
G 8'^
u #ZHC';NOQ 'Y]*#'-gXZ8'8OQ '< -F>%
#
GP
$ NH
HC'N TCJ  8<` F #C 


J ^^%8';C !Y &T!Z# G 
^A!8'HG ^ O HV 8W 
#G& #) IENC'H'!?C UsR4'
^%
Y
F Y#8H G
6H%8 H'*#k<#*# Y
4';C 
#- T4_## uHG
kOC'> # +
GTC
T=?r k*CG|OC'#JsR8'8

#' 8HH
Ge!8 IC =?IOC'P
L
OC'KH
x-qm=M)

G C'6H FH%Jy6HH*> C >=V6T!u  
H #8'=?#

4. RESEARCH APPROACH

#8H G

GN#'C  MOC'M=?'8 8H]8F*#
A  

o#  H
HC'
U  #CY=?J'HNH
HC'u
8 =Z 'hA68'H ;C
e# 
)

4 \=ZC'h
;CGYA!8'^C 8'g E#%8g OT=?J'HY
8 =ZC'h-f\
uG
#8'; c<!=?J'8)

 

HM
##VC'S
#Hr8' N%]#  <H*;oCV=?J I* C'  XZgOQ'[ *#
8ES';
#Gg=ZYH8 xO '`N*
# C 
#l# E
#
  #<6<u t- 
q#  #C>H
#H 'p
##< 
p% 'H ;C
 ]'u
k u#HG
,C
Tk%8'HOQ 'IC
| OU
#=Z!4'<FA'e' C !JE W ;C 
C'HE - XZpy_  8
H
#H 'N
8 =ZC'hR-PXZ#8'up#J'8 ' A  
H# (%4)

\=V
$OQ'[ *#
8E"C
Tp HH*F=ZC'
G-6XZ#6G#8'> # 8HuH8
H
G
##S
k#6
# ]'[ *J'# J E COg H
)
OQ'[*#
4E| O #Z bHG
TCc< UG#8'ggJ ^ #H '# 
H '?' C !> F ;k #8'< &'HC';k#' ;T
#G-
 EN #Z HH*S
TN 'M Z HH*M=ZC'
G-^&
#MJ V XZoH*IA' +8e'H*J 6'H
n
8_ A' OC'I
8 =ZC'h
#8H';CS u*H]=Z8'ZOr'[ *
#VOQ 'M F*#
C 
- % GM=?#8'&C4I=?J'H?H
HC'MZ C=? #
P';C
G
&=V!8'<f #6=Z8'u 6Or'[ *
#8E <x # C'G4'N=?U #  OMoH%Jy
*#F%8'S OZ
G%C'-Im '|4_C<l N
#8


#
TS#
H
^T!V &%-`}BZ=?  8'8OQ 'MA C']A'H';
G 6
||CzHN=?J I>IA_#N* CORO*'V
#G)
]I h!YM H';#4)Cs6%8 =Z8
FC
 8

T? 8
H
#`
 # % '- XZIH
#H 'u
B ##G | OM #
8 =Z 'h"T!NO8=V8'

#TC
T C
TPG 'A 8'S HH*#>=MC'
#G6
#> #8'-
8 G % '< #*# Y ;H
#H 'UT ^ MCM H';
HHH
6';C
G -

XZu*IC
%E & %Hk W E  O^=MA 8'-&
8
\
 
C t<U=V AoC
TCE+( #o%=V8' HHC (=?J n'4)
 H%8 p L ,
8 =Z 'hq  %GCE@=?J  #JsR8'
G
*#F%8'o O
=MA 8'?CH '#M MCOx'; # C 
l< ]%8'
; G &COx=ZC)
8 G % '-?}e|
H #8' \=ZC)#
H
T `
8 =Z 'hP %  C)


8'|
$ N HH*#6TC|o%A'
#G 
, NHG
TCUW H'8
G  Go=? q '<?O *#'<&H_R<S
qG k
#G% '  P=ZC
 OV  HG
T c-P&=V!8'<x F=ZC 8'u
 8
 ||
C


" '8)#
#H
TCM
8 =ZC'hn=?J H_L
#G% '-Do O
*
#JO ' '*G  *#  %E -omTC N
B%
#IC''J) 8H
8 =Z 'h  %G  8>C'H#=?
k
pmfG*#'8 NP-

 
C !8Ek'HEk
TpCHC'"HS
4'G Ek=?#
pC'  XZ%=V8']*H  EoN H';C
HJ H 8'?&uO*
#8 
kCOf |W)
=Z4 H 8'F HH*86H*;n NF*H8  J t-(XZ6 C' A  
n
;
#U
T>
*#F%8'l O# l H';
#H H l-frA'JE < g'!4'

#8'G Ek HC'# 
l<% * =?J k #u% HH Ep O^ W)


8_%
#Z%=Z4'] u'!S &8H G -VC'? H'; #8)i sk8_)
H*I# ICG*F oA 
#Gk Ep';rA 
x<f# A  W  fA
G] 'Y
8 G % 'gg]
8 =Z 'hS=? F]HIC 4'
>#HG
pCOg H
HC'&C
To#H
#H 'S
8 =Z 'h- # C8 8'<=?YT
#GZO8=V8'f
#G% 'xl'#*8&=?J'8)
HF;TC

#U8


n
BHF%=V8'F4_#%8
T#,'
G
 \
F ';#4'Y >A 68_HH!Z'; #
 4'HO8'
#] ^=Z 



H G -]mC'& *#'S#'
TC'HEo=ZC'hR<=ZuT!|  

;
T
Gu F ; 
km M  8
H< ?IEI% # # > 
 8
8'GCEol ]&
#+I
e783Z1 J t-
*H6 #I#HG
TC l<^*
# 8
H,H Or'[ *
#8EB
#-

-
S
km M 'G*#rA 
x<T=Z8'<TICh!MJ &IC
T#C  'HEIOQ '
 g F*#
C 
p
k uH Or'[ *
#8Ep
T
H#',H%88 H'*/ 4#
 [ *-NXZ# 
#8' H8| #F 6)
I*#H
mfG*' 
5.1.1 Two Dimensional Analysis
6 FH#A= >  %G &=?J $#JsR8'
G
*#F%8'

8_J \EPCOf > H';C


H!4']
&H
#H '-  O&
G %C'-Ki C'I C IC6 
*#F%8'N O&
G%C'

8' H? >
*#F%8'MCOY J 8'
C !TA M
4' H-
 SR=MC`

#&A' 4'<#  H
HC'f
#8 \=V 'h`A'U%=V8'

W H'; 
#l-YXZ#8'8OC'< ]N*
A 
Y#'C  
=Z&#I=? RT!? u
#H*SN
I   *
ZCO 01
03
05

-  &

#8'G E -`OOCH<=VUH#*#r|! r

 
#)i '
 00
02
04

#'C  ]H*;kC k 
  &FXZ k C#)
#' ;k
W  l-
12 14
10 11 13 15


  A'E <=ZNC'u*#'H'
JEpC
TCE+
#GI #|%8'HOC'I
8NW)
H*#o HH  C z=?J z#JsR8'8
 P
#8 \=V 'hn % G- &
# h
'*oW *T 8oCOu #H$HH*<S# J \EK
C kC
DHH*- 21 23
24
25

XZ#I[ *W 


,=ZIC'H8h
#G pC
W=Z4'N=?TA u  #%W 20 22

 %GCEoOQ ']=?J'HS
#8 \=V 'hCOfH
#H '< HH*
#Gu=V>

8
H'f #u#  8
 S O^ #HNH8
H '>
T #|H
HC' C)
30 32 34

fA'Yy#_S' C !^ ? ; #8'-^&
#gOc 4  'f
> #Y;  33 35
31
CO`  %GCEoV #>C*
U O`


OC'M ?=?J'H?8)
 -XZ#Nf OY

 
p=? g C'HEo=? p #NC# A 
x<
H
#k oH G kTA H 8'
qC
TnC8'; ?H G pG
#8';C 
41
42
43
44
45

';A IC'FOQ*
#8 
|COZ N U #C 
l-I&=Z8!8'< 40

 *#'|W *E$H * ,'A 6H6


#H G  |=?#4,
,%6*H
C
G$=?J nh
#=? #Go O? P #CM #C 
n $H8) 50 52 54

4 >C
$ ''rA  % G E -?]G! 
l<T G ! ` ]
C S 6y
T
51 53 55

(H
G , % G EK TC okC#' #' C $OC'$ C# A 
<
#*# ?';C #8'S#'Aru6W H'*8 *'k
 JEH& Og #|# 
S
T
3  # /  /'/;$> +.4  - 4
/$ )
G !6G*# 
#6
, N%W ;  8|Ho TA |oC'F
#OQ '
H
p?%HH-
\
N ; |? ?%=Z8'V* G ]OQ 'Z' *# ] 4'HV #S  8 8'
 Ol ]
4 \=ZC'hF #' *G 6 ]
8'C'MZH=?
x-YX` &|H#=?


p%=V8'P* G p=?
K #kTA q
W   H';!P 
#Ge 
5. PRELIMINARY RESULTS


( H8 
l<V=V #' #EL#H4' %P P'H*J 6OQ'  *' GMCOx #&
4 \=ZC'h%-^\
I% P H8< #&
#8 \=V 'h
HW M O
'
C'HEB
!8W  GC 
(
(%=Z8'H)i8j8 8
 u % G6
T 
##-]Y#G u' *# 
GI
HW &COUA
G68H G8& 6 
=?J'HS
8 =ZC'h
#GF#'C  -Y}e&=?x'4O8'? F ;kH8
#) * 8'MGMCO` #S
#8 \=V 'h6=?4'S 4'>C'SO8=V8'?
G %C'-
HC'&;  ]o9%:!74- \
8'C'k'* 
#Gnh!#o "HCGp
D " #" Ou 

4 \=ZC'h%<V=?4' 8'  I"
#HW 
I
*#F%8'F O&
G%C'
OC'u ;B
##-F\
BH FCH<g
#G8'uC >=V8'6; H
, 
5.1 Power-Efficient Topologies
&*'>
J   gW *#>!uOQ *H"
,C
TCE+
#GP #N%8'HOQ 'H) G!Z&H  A'U
*#F%8'` OT H';C
HHH
-gm#' ;CMMC
T6 <

IC
Y O=?J'HgH
#H 'g
#8 \=V 'h`=?8
NA'H';
#G|
NJsR8'
GV' *# 
G&#HHTC 8YHg%=V8'^ T
u
8' 'g'* 
G&
F 
 %G -o
8F=ZCHH*68
H'^A!8' #F C
CO CHM8_ UOQ ' |
G %C'-YXZZZ% *H]  
G%C'
00 01 02 03 04 05

10 11 12 13 14 15
 ,
*' !$#&%0 +   /$  /+.0 
&8 G % ' Xx';C
HHH
 ] 
  * 3
&H


 =
 

 
 "


= 
  "

20 21 22 23 24 25

 
  ! "
 C
 "

30 31 32 33 34 35

40 41 42 43 44 45

  # /  /$'/$$>  +.4  :4


/;)
50 51 52 53 54 55

 ,
' # ; /  +.(0 
&8 G % ' Xx';C
HHH
 ] 
 Xx ;  f=Z8'




  

=
 "

00 01 02 03 04 05




=
 C C "

 


   "

10
11 12 13 14
15    " 

21 22 23 24 25
20

31 32 33 34 35
30

 ,
*'  # =/$+.(06  
/  ,$0 3/   ().). *,;+. /0 
45

,$0 :$4
/$ )
40 41 42 43 44

&G %C' 
Xx';
#HHH 
  3
]  
  * &H




51 52 53 54 55
50

  # /  /$'/$$>  +.4 :4


/;)








"
"

#8 \=V 'h,I h!|G'* 


G$#Jj8*J - }DJ (J #8'|'*# 
#G
W H';A G E <SCP #p
*#F%8'6 O|
8 G % 'P
#8'CHo #p%A=V8'

HH C k


#8' H8]OQ '? >C
*F%4'M Of H';C
HHH
#-

; # <T=Z|
H #8'S |%=Z8'&#HHTA p%8 \=V
k #

H *#'&
oW 
TC 
POQ '?|H G &H

#
G S#  4 8'

B
COx #?
8 =Z 'huOC'M
8 =ZC'hY=?J  uC
TI
G %C'-UMyG )

 ,
*' # =/$+.(06  
/  $ , 0 3/   ().). *,;+. /0 

*' C
TPNOC'&8 
M O` H& =ZN
8 =Z 'h  %G  8-
] =Z,
H"OQ' ;  <
4' H
GL "
*F%4'

#G% 'U#88' H8Y #Z


*F%4'g O% H';C
HHH
U
u #Z  )
CO
,$0 :$4
/$ )
;C`%=Z4'> HHC k
k WEW k-VXZ?'H*J S
p
JEo%
A H H'*#  | SCrCJ \EP O`uH# 'H W ZTC P%8 =Z
 # &8 G % ' 
Xx';C
HHH
  3
] 
 * &H

B
H *#'PC
TeW 
TC 
x-krA'N
TCJE#HN
e%8
8 *#

  
 = 


 "


Or' ; # #<=?#46H#=?V&H C'Y TC'H
FOC'V
#8 \=V 'h
 "
=?J  "
Tnp
8 G % '-(XZ#8'P 6p H'; #8)iCsq%8 =Z
( #

*#F%8'& OZ
#G% '|C
Tp u  ; Y%=Z8'uHH C "
" #
WEW k-x&=V!8'<A ` H'; #8)iCs6#' h`
|H%  CH`=?#8'
#|C  C EkCOVCJ 8'
TA  H 'H 8W &C ?C
p%*H  
C
pC
; G>OQ '? &%A=V8'S*TG8 ? * A  
-
003 013
,
'   #!  
   /   ,; )


023

   3
| ('* 
#Gkac&C f=Z8'&]=ZC'Cd
002 012



  
022 SG% ' X  * &H

011
! !  ! !-  !

9 
001
021
A     - !C!






103 113 !   -  !
123 C ! AC - ! #
000 020
010

102 112 122

101 111 121


%=Z8'Z#HHTA 6
6 ?WEW k-^X` %G  8V=?J IOQ8=Z4'Z
*6)
203 213 %8'MCOf
#G% '? HHC P 8HM%A=V8'<# J  *G o ] %  C)
223 G?=?J k '&
G%C'?'[*#J'>O8=V8']#-
100 110 120
V *H, e
*N%8'o O6
#G% '"sR4' =?J  #JsR8'8

202 212 222 % G<#
#&8_%4 Z#JsR8'8
 U %   GZ |T!S#JsR8'8

%=Z8'S*CG|';C -]^!
*#'SHF*#rA 
] O^ #


)
201 211 221 OQ'8u H|H=z TA &JsR8'
M %   GST!|#JsR8'8
 ?
 OZ%A=V8'N8j
#8E -IXZ'
C'HE$'H*# |H#A= TA  
 ;C %=Z8'g8
H*## 
`'#*8&OC'f %   Gg=?J O8=V8'

  #  /  /' /$$> +.4   :4


/;)
200 210 220


8 G % 'vRC #*#Gk   %G  8&=?J p '
8 G % 'S'4)
[ *J'kO4=Z8' #<M p%=Z4' 8_%
#L EIC
E
## 
'8 P #HIH G F
4' HN I%=Z8'F* G -BS
#G

SAz  %G < ?%W U%A=V8'U8j


#8E6ZC4#!N=?J 

,
' #  $ ,;0 % 0 +   /$ =/$+.(0 3/    ().). *,


&Cz % G EI=?# ;P =?M* O*'M


8 G % '-YXZ

+ /0 % G E6%8'HOC'U%W <  J  *GI


O HOC'&H  #C 
#-
CD % G EIEu
C V%

   3


S8 \=V 'h gC  X  * &H

5.2 Wireless Communications Protocols
 

C \
8'C'    "
&4'N=ZF#'H
> =ZoN*
A 
$#'C   TA >=Z8'


  
6&8 G % ' UG  C ,
#8H G
n ,'* 
8'GCEn
#H*  
x-Km ' #k*'%H



\
8'C'  - !uk # ,
 O#HG
#
GeG 
8';CS#*#'% HkN*
# C 
n#'C  IOC'
F&8 G % ' UG  ,
=?J'H #  &WEW 6=V" HH*k C I
##P
K 
WEW 
8o#)'88 
TC` F*#
C 
o=?J p
o8_ 8'
TC


#' 8HH 'M  ?8_ 8'
TC H';
#H!8'&ac
#8OQ 'H I  
1 587S5;3t13t: 9xd;-V
#Z ?#rC
Y OR
##Y=?J 
6 M%E
V'#8 4'
#6C
TFy_R<!=Z]CHH*? TC Y ? H]W ;C 

5.1.2 Three Dimensional Analysis


&
mfG *#'L8 $n #'4)\
H
 
#8 \=V 'hD %   G E |=MC'F OV #F% H 

G-Sg F*#
C 
">=?J'H-

=?J LHJ_(
G %C'<U=?#4nTC6HoC
; G86#*#P $J  XZ k(`*#H&OC'frMCHf
T&=VVCHH*^ TA fC 
#8

#8'
|WE8 H'HE -|
CF<R F' *# 
GoTC #%8 \=V
,
E C'I%8'HOQ8 JEeWE
#4'
+e
(C'P=MC'P OM #%G
#

G
G !
BH *#'IC
T,#W 
TA 
,=?J #*# |W' *# 
GP=Z*# e J)  O^ ; H -
=ZE#M'H*#J ?
o >C>
*F%4'Z O` H';
HHH
#?*# M#JsR8'H) }e| H8'!| TA &8
8'GCEkC
"%u
H8'!kEo'#*#
GC'


8
 Z
*#F%8'U Ol'8# 
#<C\*W ]CZ
P =ZN#
H
T % H>CO 
TC 
#Gk#*#CHu


l-]
,
8'W 
GoOc 4



F
G%C'-  % *# p *#'p#H
#H '"
8 =ZC'hqk TC B8F*#
A  

X` ,eC'oA =?J  n
8 G % 'o
T C=?J z TA H 8'
zp#8 4'
#W  ,
q%8'#-~Y ;
#"TCo 

&  &

#G% 'U=? P>y_6


*#F%8'Y OR H';C
HHH
x- 
H #4'
#G H';
#HJ SJ &C ;6
|
"C -?XZ#&S*#] I # # 
G

%C  Y


8'C'g
#G U'* 
G#<A=VU
*#^ ^O=?
G ky_(XZ k8 #(C N  k H*) E 8'-B~XZ k


 H8' C 
 MaWAd`UGV' *# 
GS
u U HMCOT  q
#8 \=V 'h H;]TCZ SP# 
;CGS C M
##V
PHo=?#

 =Z8'u%=Z4'u#HHTC 


B TC
,
8' '|'* 
G#- ai!d&XZ# 4EC'U
C `H
#
G A'8
#G>A ;-fXZ` #` ?Hf%=Z4'

*#F%8'` O H';C
HHH
#UC
T' 
<!
| #U  ;C%A=V8' *CGS
68_ 
T6TA H 8'HE6JO-^
6 MO  =?
Gu=Z]#'H8

HH C o
P & ' 8
H
 R
8 =ZC'hPMH? TC
P # 
o TA'> \=Z6 '!C4#<8 *#W 8'H)iTCHk
P H'4) HR<
=ZC)\
H
 ?
4 \=ZC'heOC'I% L#G k 6=V] 
8' ' OQ'  >%8'H%88 ! Og#H
#H ']=?'8 8H&
4 \=ZC'h-
' *# 
G-
X` u6#'8H
? #>'H*J ] Og H';C
HJ H 
G < IW)
5.2.1 Cluster-based Approach
CG< ; =?J k|';
#JEI; H
H *#'|C
T W 
TA  
x< \
| *#'f8 *#W 8'H)iTCHu'   c<=Z^=ZC'h
| Y #M TA f
)
'*#GpC4pCOg u#JsR8'
]
4 \=ZC'h-?XV=ZP#JsR8'8
 ?' *# H) 8'GCE
#H*  

I%?'#*#6 E6W #* C 
G| TA V
JEI

#G&#'C  g=Z4'M*HR<CJ *#GN
JEu
#Vg#'8H
u#8'- HI OQ'; 4  
 O% #M
#8VA'? A=V6 N*
# C U=?J 
XZ#Ny#'W H8 IHC'H W C x<R=?# u uH
"*#H& # FT HFW ;C 
l-PXZH6
##uA'6    6
T$C4
    # U%=Z8'^A fC4|
#G% 'x ]H8 88 f ^
#G% '`H8' 8'N u
(4C'G PCO]A ; OQ'k*#W 8'FCO?
FA'*#
T

 
6 #u#W 
TA 
p TA S ] W ]'IC
#
G6%=Z4'-?>8) J -UUC4k #8']  88 &#C ;NOr'
##?
J ?*W 8'<6)
;C o O #Hk \=VB'* 
#G(#'C   
q%kOQ*
K
i< #'8HHZ &C ; u 
C S'#*
C
8EIC
T6 H';
#HJ V 

 

=?#8'nJ B"H=?
TA "%A=V8'H)=MC'n'* 
Gq'*p #  #'HH#C ;& > #] H?W ;C 
x-YXZU8 u UH  A'
%=V8'*CGkCOS #o
#8 \=V 'h%-nXZ#o'H*# FH= TA F 4' 6  xU @#'  8f'%HkEPS
+IC
k8 S   t-
V& H';#4)CsP%8 \=V
6 M
*#F%8'^COR
G%C'VC
TF Z C ;  \
( #J'W *TE <g kC*# # '6CHH*P TC N oWE#W 8  
Base station START ADDRESS1 ADDRESS2 ... ADDRESSn END 1 2 ... k subscription 1 2 3 .... k C

..... address of leaders selected by the Base Station solicit by leaders length depends data transmission and control
on the number of cells channel repeated till any leader fails

  # 5 < ).84  2 /$ 8 '*) +  
*,$) 
 * /$+ / 8/'
.. in the cluster
..
.. ....

.... .
.
.... ....
Base station
Cluster based approach
Long Distance Transmission Cell
.....
   #'(*) +  ,;)  <  * /$,$8 4
Short Distance Transmission
.. Level 1 cells
..
.. ....

.... . Level 2 cells


J p


#)t'
#8=MC|H*#'8NCO^
8'GCEk
k=?;p
 .
NC] #
4'G Eo 8!xO -]XZJ'SG f? 68_ 
ToWE#W 8 .... ....
JO4  S
N YZ ;F E6E
T M*#W 8'
G| OR
##-
Tree based approach
S=Z!4'< #M ?
# ?C
HH*>OQ '? H
HC'S
#8 \=V 'h? M #8E
=?f%|#'A #I=?J $6

**#?H*#'8uCOY
8'GCE -VS
8 Long Distance Transmission Cell
Short Distance Transmission
 3  "! #    ,;)  5 / :'
 *#'oH"
#8'
qo C P O'#*8
#G(
4'G E
#H*# 
x-
&*'?W ;C |*W 8'
#G ##'!C4 T M =Z6IWC'& # 
; G 

-?XZNA ;P>8#'8HHpC > #NH *#'N


p
#N
JE
' 
?#C ;| Z H';C
HJ H 6 N #&8_ 8'
 %' HH 'v ##K# 
;CGp O #oH;p TA kC&
P
 TC

 *W 4'Y=?Th
=(=?# ;6C 8'Y
^T!`\

Tu
F=?TA
 ';8'-
-]&
JEIHIC %H*#H8 V Ol ?
ZICh!]|
GN#W ;
#
]Or 8'k8 *#W 8' !$%
DOC'l<S
 
DC4z*W 4'
H';
#HHH 
p
 8
>8
8'GCE ?
#H8'!R-
=?MT!6 $H
T(#C ; p I #8'F O? TA F*#W 8'-"&8'

&
XZ#8'ZA'VH8'; !HH*#g
!>#8'-gmfJ'W <C=ZYF*#W `A  G 
x< #8'? Y ?%HH# J \E6 OxH 
MJOR ?r>U

H F=ME" OM# 
#Go=?# ;B
##H#*#r"%68'-P8) 'G * C R-^X`&A u # g'# 8k< =VZ#' %HV S*HMXZ k|-

TR<` N'I 

#Gk
|H*# PW 
n *W 8'-IS=b  Y ;k
>
o &*W 8'?=?x%|C  A pNHC S
p|OQ';C-
 
6 #6 C 
nCO
k
## #6=?#4e8 *#W 8'u FW 
XZ&  C 
k
I
# V%S8_# J JEP#
S V=V&C
IH #JE
#|H
HC'>C'|'#8 4'
# C
T y#_#l<
To
JEo TCH O  = 6C';#8'u
,=?#4" 6
##Z\
" F8 *#W 8'-PS
W ;A 
K G   TCSh
=?GpC%*# F  WEW k<UJ I%W =Z?W ;A FA' 8'< ;
#MU=MC'?CO%=?ZW 
^ M*W 4'
OQ 'P k H$W ;C 
K e
 
TC k #k8'-@O>=Vp8 
"=?#
x<f
T"
#6C4B
#F u=MA'I OMJ |%HJ 
(

#8'S' W  JE <T 4' S6G k;TC


> C S
>Or'; -Z&
8&  #8'S8 SA ;FOQ'  Cx &
#8
8 88 I #4'?IEF
C Z%S #S%8W M4#-Ym# 'M8_#C<! # 
(J u8 *#W 8'<^J F
e #'H| I#C ;pC
T, H';C
HJ u | 
 #8'|IE$
C %6
JE"#W H'* p #'*#G#*# & 6
#8 H) &T HW ;A 
x-
=V 'hF
T6H8!8'; # O% # IEu%?
6
G? O% #]
#8 \=V 'h%-
&
, 6C 8'uTC
TR<`  HIW ;C 
eTCNG   TCVh
=?#G  5.2.2 Tree-based Approach
COU #|WE#W 8C
Tp&
"I%4 H 8'>% H 
$ I
#
TA N ) \
> #f ##' ;u #Y HUW ;C 
uH8 f
Y 'gC'^
#8
4'-"m 'F8_# <`=?  #
Gp #8'<^ #P HIW ;C 
k%6J |; '
,T HB
BO 8 C'NH*#4B  8'|'_#J \E

;Ch!>
F
H #8';A 
k S

#
H';C 
#]
To J) u H8Og
T
##>
HJ EI 8' HM ]WE#W 8k-^XZH&H8 
 A SC'M8'V

H8'VC' ZC
TFHY
HTA'H8'ZA' -
U #
II h!]=D
 8
HJ \EN H';
HHH
l< ;PC Mu#JOr)
i u
(CHk ; h!
p 8*#
 u C'*#| 4'uO 8 C'FH*#4B  O4'
>OQ'[ *#
8E -S&& C &'8!| & H';
#HHH 
BA 
8W ZCORN*
# C 
N8 -<
6#'A!ZA!8';CTWEW %8'H) #'#8y
"
#F* HG
TCJ)i C)i
H';C pC
e 
"'[ *W
OQ 'IC
p EL4# H
GnC
q I ]
*#F%8'6 O|8'I=?  ^ H';
#HJ H 
#GM
Y ?%Y xTA'
-gX`?I h^ #x'[ *8W <
 # I l%HJ 
#
G#- U#' H%8 !Z; '
|=?#AU ]*HV #VH*#H8'
GS#'C)
&
# u8'&Au%8
$

C R<TC4$
N
k #   l=V>

IC'8'-M&
#S #&; '
oT!SH8 
WEW   | p4# HPk*W 8'u 6W 
x-p
e*'NH;8<^  8'|C'
<xJ |  #J' *#'
$  HJ N4#  '
x-6XZ|
)
 #8'u H';
#H NkHG
 U
#*#'H'
JE,*# NA 6sR4'
uOr'8) 
*?*
l `
##M
#>WEW ~C'8C8'l-
[ *#
-UXZ#>OQ'[ *8
?C
k%  A pE #TCHW ;C) UEuO  =?
G| ?C%CM8 R<=ZZ=?T # ; 
I>H

#
G

x-UY8'HEI

#)i8'?
>
P #>WEW HC
? R &Or'8) H'^OC'f ^
4 \=ZC'h%-`}D#
|M
#^=MC
x ]H
T#C ;<CJ `=?
[ *#
|C
T"r
JyT> #6
#6OQ'[ *8
8Ep C | sR4'uJ  # H
NJ ^ &J ^TC'8
 ^
##Z ENS=M)i
4'G Eu H';
HHH
l-^XZ
%8W FHG
 J)t  )i
 HI';A #-pXZ#I
#6 #
o\
u 68 *#W 8' TA'
=? V8 FA ;oOQ'   VJ |4#r'
x<`'H 
'8#'H
oE C ?OQ'[*#
4E - A ;NJO`'[*#J'l<#
P
P *#'
I H';
HJ MJ M N MC'
-Y&
#JE

&
XxoW 
DB*W 4'<Z o
# T  ,
OC'   #8'PCO S4#r'
P O` #S' C ?
#NacTCH&W ;C 
RdY=?x%]'[ *J'

&
#F*#W 8'| % *# J >

- V* & #8'FI%HHJ \E$ TA II h!> #|G$
#8'G Eo H';
HJ ]  |TCHNW ;A  
x-SXZ
H8!8'; &
#8 H
 J'NW
D'[ *8W  A kC%*# P $C XZ k@Or'; >W H'*#8 *#'?G!8
k?yG*'F -

&
-PXZ#|=?V *HIoH 
x- X`p! r,H*;B  H
#<
=V"C# o(XZ kH;8 TA P=Z o 'G
TCEq*HqCP
5.2.3 Performance Comparison
;TC

#!'H8' C 
N#'C  c-g
| #fH4#<C
` H';C
HJ \
( # FH8 
L=Zk'H
F #o'H*# CO& *#'PC
T JEH O
p#
C'HEB
I
nH F8 'H'H%
T#
#G" k #J'6 '8H-eXZ# M =Z|#'C  -UXZ?TA'; 8 4'U=Z?*#H#*'
#G ?6)
START ADDRESS1 ADDRESS2 ... ADDRESSn END 1 2 ... k subscription 1 2 3 .... k C
Power Consumed by network where distance between cells is 10 mm
7e+08
address of children of the base station selected by the base station solicit by parents subscription by the data transmission and control
Clusterbased approach
children channel repeated till any parent fails
Treebased approach
6e+08

  "!$!;# 57< ).8 4   2 /; +    


*,;)  * /$+ / 89/'
repeated for each level in the tree

System Power Consumed (pJ/s)


5e+08

4e+08

Power Consumed by 1600 cell network and distance between cells 3e+08
8e+08
Clusterbased approach
Treebased approach 2e+08
7e+08
System Power Consumption (pJ/s)

6e+08 1e+08

5e+08 0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600
Number of cells

 6! #  /   89/0*). *+./$0 )  0  


:  /$2 0/ :)
4e+08

3e+08
(0 + 460 +  $/  
2e+08

1e+08
+C 
N W < OQ 'f #^
8 =Z 'hS=? *H* JE%Y
|

*#*x)
0 8';A  
I
F
C Y'[*#J'Z'G*#rA'V'W ;A'H 
G#-YXZ#Y=V* F

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Distance between cells (millimeters) TA ^
E| 'HH
G&C'^ h )i*| ; U
#J rC +C 
 *  ; h!

$ ! #  /  : 89/0*). *+./$0 ) () + ,$089


 +   -0  C(
@ p
J   u H- XZ8'(" HDL
zOC',#J)

0 /  -) 2 /$   : 


,$) 
 ,;0 '() +  
*,$) 
 ,  * /$,$8 4:)  #J'4  
TCMN*
A 
x-"XZ#6G F%I
##BO '6*#)


G '; #
G$ P#'C  MC'H Or \=ZC'k
( P%E -, N=? ?C H
G!?  T4_## J \EF Ox|W ;
T#C';FOQ 'M#  #C=?J'HMH
)

C'H
KC'oG!
n
LXf # k-&*'6
4 \=ZC'he
HW n O& H '-p 6H
HC'<^H*;( |OC'FG * HP
J  '
#G#<f=V* 

)#
H
T ZC'H';EeCOS
##u=?J n #IT HIW ;A  
n   '8 k
#OC'IC 
OQ' # #  K
Tn H';
#H 6  e

C%A!u #FA'H';E -&XZ#FW ;


8F O^ #N HuW ;C 
$OQ' / # 8_ 8'
 g 8oac *# *  H# ETd;->XZ|'8 
T#' W H<x

8
8'kCOu #"C'H';Eq=MCkCHH*K n%p \=?" TC o O| # IC 8'FT
l<g=?Z%I'
G$J F
#OQ 'IC 
nOr' 


8'H)i
#W ;C
-UNOC']
*']
 JEH <=Z!&
8
#) 8_ 8'
 ?#8"acC8'; d|
Te H';C
HJ H 
G,$HG
T M $ 

H';A p
p u%=Z8'>%8'HOC'I
8NCOU #| =ZP#'C  ->}B HIC'H oH
#H 'k
D $8E  -&
#"W ;C
T#C';#+z'   >OC'

W *#I > C' C 


k O^%=Z4'S8
H*## 
I=?J  'H%4 ]  %  #M=V*  %  c<T#*# M%4'T #?
 ?'C W -

W ;
8P%4 \=Z8
e
N |=ZMCu #
*#F%8'> O?
u
XZ4'  H"  HH*#  O&F*# # PH
#H ' F*
#C H)

#
8 =ZC'hR- 
G>=?J 
6 #M
8 =Z 'h| #' *G 6 J NT
=?  l- *#'H'8

#'C  NT!6%8
B8'A B p ^=?J B |
B 68 *)

,
' # 3,; ,  +   ) ,;0 +.4:-,;'(:)"*) 
 0 +.4   *
 C'U' k-YKH# 'H H)t';
#G]N*
A 
I J 8'
C !]IEF%

   2 /; 6,$0*896,$0 ,$'> ).()
V*4     t-o
F |W ;C
TA';#+A  
x< V*8  C eu%4)
 
#GI
u O^ #NC'u% *#rA'>'    SO '&=?'8 8H
)

 gC'; 4 8' VC *#



88 
I%8 \=V
%8'H
TC%8 H'
#ZH*;I U# ?#
#<

  
^&]<!C
T|T G 8'- V*4   F^HG
uOC'^=?'8 8HHEF6)

   3
Xl';
HHH
p8W F C#J F*#
A 
#Go=?J e 8HI#uC uH# 'H F#W ;
#<g
#k '

 
S8# 
 W F C# TC
" '_#IA JEB P4 8'- 
#GI=?J $J >

T
J'*J H'HEoW F C# #8H G
x< V*4   z Hn sR4'o=Z8' A ;B';C - XZPIE
&*#F%8'V O^
## N)?  #'A! I%|
H*#j6
SOQ '>#  `=?J'H>H8
H 'S TC
>W ;
#%8 \=V
k
## &)]F C'NA ;6
 8
H!<H*;p ] >'8 
T'W 8H <=?4k=?
T!M*#
T'#g ORH8
H 'Y
8#
G&*RA gO *#'Y &yT!8^ 
C4kH8
l-

  
S
# #8'u#'  8MN #P\UY !- kW ;
A';BO 'N=?J'8)
mfG *#'>A?H=?g V'8rA 
H#6%8 \=V
N%A=V8'^
H*)

 
H `]& JA t-IXZ|G!|PH*#j8 8
 JE"G eA ;P';A FOC'


NC
T>W ;
8U%8 =Z8

#8-gSlC
%YH8
x<A g8 *#W 8'H)
W lOC'HCMCA  
< %8 \=V
N #`C
T6 #-
 HK '!C4qH#=?o%8 H 4'I
8'GCE)4j
4E -mf G *#'e
WYYp! -ZgCH&A H H'; 8 !Y%C*HY O ^*# J H)i
u *# #
#)
8TA'S #|%A=V8'>8
H*## 
pCO^  \=VP'    &
C 
KC
Te
#8'HE# 
(;TC
H $#'!8
 | ;C%8'
G
OQ*
#8 
I OR ?
*N%8'^ Ox
Y
6 #?
8 =Z 'h%-U&
#] G!C

 Ol SA ;< =?# ;IM


I
#8'
Z
4'
I=?#
P#C
#Gu=?J 
#*W 8'H)i Ho '!C4k%4'HO '?%8 H 4'-



#y%
  #CC ;- V *HM # gW ;C
T#C';N^

T
OC' xS&<TH*;$ S #H|O *
T '*#G *# S*#  
#G<%\UY
-PCT # OZ H';C
HJ H 
G A!4'| 
GpW ;
8-IXZ
6. RELATED WORK
g_W 
#G|N*
A 
6'    ZC'?
C V
#HA' JEIH*OQ) IW 'g';=?TC4h] ] # xx TA fJ f8
H*#lF*; '^%=Z4'
y
?O '? #
M O^#  #Cl=?J'HSH
HC']
8 =Z 'h< TC
C 8'S J 8'
C !-


*oI 
JE( $  8
W H';C
 IC
T('[ *J'
F#H*HH &
$8 #K TA kIEq%" ', # # " nJ)

& &
*#POC'- \
qJ  
x<] 8'$A',
#8 \=V 'h
Ge'[ *#'8
 C&=?J'H H
#H 'o I "XZp>H 
*J "S8H
C ICHBF*#W 6%o
#Hr8'n%8OC'p#8H G

GB"
#8=' ) atXZ k>d>'   c-pXZ kC =?NF*J 6*#H8'| p 8H
 8c-}q
n
H #8'
#Ge,'   MO 'I#  MH
#H ' BH
G k';#BOr'[ *
#8E(=?J  *# P
 4'HO8'
#-zi I ;!8

#8 \=V 'h<TJ ]IEP% 8# ;CO 'SJ ? 6T!|F#Gk


J   J) SE   A 
#G *#
 [ * uHC &  ;$*H8'& OU4
)
& 
 

#c-XZ k Ie#C ;,';A p  pCO%8 \=V


D eh# S
# #8']
8'8W 
#G'HC';$8sR 'H S
p4'C 
GI8_ H'8E
C
T@ #<?
D (h#
8'8
 - XZ8H,#C ;,';A  HI ^C
TpA=M)i%=Z4'|H
HC'>& FIA'H >>*#W >#'AW88   t-

&
H#*#r%pH*#j
OQ '  &*'H'
JE%4'!L  XZ=ZC'h,|
C u#J'8 JE, # #I o# YH
#H '<
C# A 
-U]
 #8'V# 
;CG? Ol*H
#G| #]XZ kq#'C  ) =V!8'<`% *#H   ^ H';
H8!8'uC'*#H"OQ 'uN*#)
8g M8
8'GCE)i8j6
8E| C Y
F%ZG!C
#6 E|H4##*#
#G#-
A 
x- &# C] H';C
H8 8'P'[*#J'pB
8)i Or)iH G  C 

; 

MC4N ; HhFY HHG
& MC
TF;TC

8#H <! YY%W) %8 =Z
n H';
#HJ H 8'I
n'8!8'IC
Tn
#kA'k*Ck

H# IOC'6k
##6  H 8 pOC' G !
(%8'e OM - UE  
o#-
C =?
G$ FH
HC'N k%=V8'6=?
B=?
B
 u
e*#H<gG 'C  
^W H'
D783&1  VT!6'%He  F*
#C 
"#8

  &
C*#
 MCO^%=Z8']C
%
H8'!kC ?C4
# - C pJ'8 kJsR*H
OQ 'SH  C| )i ';
TC 
p
H
HC'
S #IC

o783f1  
T#*#8 uSW *E TA'
#G>XZ k
4 \=ZC'h-(XZNT %4'6  C u I
8eO 'N G JE(
 4)
C
T6\UYe-S
F 8'^ Ol
#8'G EN
H* 
x-fm 'U C'HE) G ';A 
G( p'* 
GeO*#
8 
I=? D #$ # C 
l-*;

&

#G&
*N%8'`COT
f
| VHN* C |
4 \=ZC'h%<\UY, ! -  ##' ;^=Z *  H|%M*H8OQ*O 'U #CT #C 
-
8
HW 
JEpHH C $CF ? 'C ? TC
pXZ k@OQ '  6 O? # HH*#u
! !B
(HG

#G"8F*#
A  

& 
#F#C ;P#JsR*H
"'   c-uXZN' H
"J pOC'> > C'G  #'C  PO 'P=?J'Hk F*#
C 
=?J 
D*IC
%E


H8'TC
8E"
B8
8'GCE$
#H*# 
, TA |XZ kC' C'F#'HH$
f8'H
 Y]'I&4 \=ZC'hFa RSS4dM'HA'4l-
8
8'GCE)i
H8'
G-nXZ*<YWYY ! - p6
#8'
JEe
TC#) R]@
 # 8S#C ;F8F*#
A  
o%4 \=Z8
k8 H'
|#4)

 &
''rA UOQ 'gH
#H '`
8 =Z 'h-`\
W l< C
u8
8'GCE)i
H8'
G ]
$

C'S*#I
P%Eo E CTCJ  JEk *
G#J)
k H*#4  ?XZ k Z'8
#6OQ '? SH
HC'? N
#)   8*#'H'
M #' *GP >%E  
t-
H*'> J']
#G6OQ-
]`

#C'8'< H*' Eu
'8  C Eu f]IWC'f'8)
[ *#'8
YOQ 'Y M \E%MCOx#  #C 
#V
H #4'

#S %8'-MS=Z!4'<T*'H'
SH *# 
#S 6=?J'H&
#8 \=V 'h )
7. CONCLUSIONS
IA'H PH
HC'k sR8'o $#' H,CONHG
JyTC
$C




#G#<%H*#4pCS\UYq !- 6C
T V*4   x<TT!H*'J \E 
T 
# M H'A 
-n&8 =ZC'h
#GBF*#J  # HIC'H FH
HC'
'8  C E6'^CU*W H';A F E| ZO  =?
G|8_#C 
p
B # C 
)H%8JyTIH*# 
B k FTA u#HCH u

 8*#'J \E 
^'  g\UY(->#'ArY J H*)
#' H
#GI ##'!C4l<%=?;k=? `'[*#J'u'HC';k=? "I#JOr)
O4'
?%8'H%8 !] u'H !
C'H';EI O`
A!RC
TI4 
GC)

B
% 'H FO '6
y%#8
  C J Ee #' *G( #o=?J'n[ *C


G6'# 8-

  
#'  8E$a}D VdY#'C  R=?;o MHG
#JyTC
 T=?M

SY=?J'HM
8 =ZC'hU OxH
HC'MC'S#8!%6OQ 'M#  )

 
B#HG
CpH=?
@
t- ]
JE <?'T *#G783
 S #C 
<? kh
#A=?GkG 
OQ'  Hp8)
1 >T!pH=?
q C  & pH8*#'J \EK;T
#H

;C 
&H#*#rp%N*Hk OcC J ;A 6 N#!8  
S O
#'A #P
kWYU-NC'88 8EP
4sR8 !-
H
#H '
#8 \=V 'hFOC'
4=~ #C 
#-n\
nI
EB H<U 

   H
#H
#G>IC 4'rCUC
T|A=M)i%=Z4'V4 H'
YC'EN8_W gOC'

1 ;
 f8'HOQ 'I
# S  # J E ^'  @XZ - !&&+n\
)
H
G6 #H>#' -UXZ|HG
kCOf=?J'H&
#8 \=V 'hMOC'
#*#W H'  c<|
y<S
 #CacH $d6TC
Tq 8*#'H)
 6
8HPH8
H 'Nu #6  4)4' CV
#8_ NW 8(
e' +
Gp 


'
JEzHTA' ED=?J'H `] WEW ,ac- G#-SWYUg)
%
#8y | O? #HH
HC'- UEe
#8' H
#G$ #N*
# E$ O

;
-4_|8_*T
#GMWYUY-<& &mYd;<4 #8'f 6)
'HA'4#8'k 'HH
G( H$'<? #k  p*#
 ] 
F*#
A  
oWEW &ac- G#- V*8  C x<##''8 ;C'HEPC';)
*IC
o%
#8y ?A'| ;!o=? x%';CIC C JEP'#*#R-
Hf#
#4d;< 
>

)iN*
A 
>WEW Uac- G#-AJ)
g_#%#J *6#!8  
F O>#rC
(HIC'H H
#H '6 
8'=M!FC
4d;-NXZ4'6F*;$
#8'
"A!8' NF*)
'E  R#' Z'H
MC'?%8
8y# Z F
T  )
*TCT
8'HO8'8
S%8 \=V
V*8  C P
T\UY(- -
*TCM V=VR ZH 8 4 \EP Z|=?#-UXZ8']V ]*#V%
)
 *#P#
$ EL
I *6OC'k
#C p C PJO
8y# >  %8'H
>=?J eJ ;C 
G #HCHFC
Tp J'>O 
8H? =Z ;
#G  8Z%8';A &A ZCW ?&8 8'U C'H <
 ] H|C 
SG 
"
$
#T
#k[ * J \EkCOY JOQ- V)

8'HO8'8
=Z * B
# u%HG
Jy
-pXZ#8'<^=M)
 ] 
F C I
J  '6OQ 'PC
8'=?]'8A!8'
G
!4'<VH8' G '; A  
K
n%8'HOC'I
#
;
#G  8&A'u8 C   
t-
JO] HI \=V
TA 
]IC
 ;C

J'] J x- &H*TCx'?H*#4pC]'4)

J V# G 
HZC
TCG8)t' C PIC* C'V#8G
#8';C 
I8Or)

*#F%8'> OM'HA'4(GC'*#|T!%8
eW *TE#
#G H
#H ' O88 u 
#NC
T" 'A
#GoHG OQ 'u H6
#r*TC >=?

#8 \=V 'h-^] #*#GF #HMH


HC'V
#8 \=V 'hU#>
# YIC ;N # 
 H'#*# VGC'C JE ? J'f=VJ)%8
#G#-gS g
JE=? #HV
)
'[*#J'
ZOC'&#  #CxH8
H ']
#8 \=V 'h<%F'8Of'8= # #* Z%8'H
T JEI%
#8y UOQ' J'Z'C6CJ  C
T
=Z8 J)i%
G<#*# VH 8 \EI=?xCH6%
4y VOr'b #J'M
8' H

 
CO^H>COg Z=ZC'ho]
*TPOQ '] 8 
#H-
YE 8'|
,& HH8' UT!N#' %He 
#GP #6H
#H ' #'*8 J \E"C
T,H 8 4 ; V8
H'*# 
-P&
#N #F ;
 J)

sR4'
Y E%f &'*M%=Z4'U*# G -U ZH
HC'VA' GCE" S'8yT
#l<l  ^W >OQ '|C'H'8 
Go4'
# F#C

T#J 
#u=?V%6'#*8l-oS #6=Z ' e% * A  
( G <


*#H"OQ 'NN*
# C 
,
, #8'OC'u #6H
#H 'N #C)

x-U&
+8I
(783V1 J gT!&#'% H *#H
#G6*W 4'SCO >#IC
TPOQ ']H*;kM=? x
#Eo
8' H-

 
H8
H '>
T 'C ;C 
G #u8 *#W 8'S  P[* +u%A=V8'S*W)
CGS 
G>H
#H 'V
TN8_ 
TFH8
H 'UJO- V GC=MC 783^1
'% Hp H+
G,TC H 4'HEn JOQ8 p
 W IC8'IIC_J)
8. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
+
#G6=?'8 8H&TC
T=?r k8j8 8
8E -V&
#| Og 8Hu XZN * C'S=Z * $ h!|  TC
h #NC

E *?'8O8'8


A'#J'4 E #  & u #C%H
HC'? # C 
#?  OC'f 8'`
#W H'*8 !U8
 %=?# ;|%> ]#'A!g 

 
   
H8'% 
#MT %4'- [ *TC J ENCO% ^TC%8'-f}eZ H> TC
h &E
u++#
 gA


g'8
 x=ZC'h J #<<!  ` HS4_C
>#'A
G ] W 8'Ba}(E
$ ;C  S
!8'HJ \E < #C;  QdIC
T
%=V8'>8j6
8EP #' *G k % G Ek8
H'c-M
H| %8'< f%SJE a}(E
? ;C  &
# 8'HJ \E <!&TA'H 
^ OxY4 H'  
#=Z!4'<f IC*# C'|T!6O 8*HB
nAW*W 
#G 6 H';C
W) 
 #*# 8'Y^
G 
8'
#Gd`O 'Y 8'Y
#*# ^
6I
EN H%4 
HH
u';
#G<
u#
Y Y % G E <OQ 'Y]V
#8 \=V 'h%-  Og #Z=Z 'h%-
?.&0100SR#2W1 9541#53c: 95N: 9T6Y: 0N0 ? <5
    

&8 =Z 'h- 9 13c: 95<


9. ADDITIONAL AUTHORS

S 
T ^C*# # ' ?E" a}(E
F ;C   &
# 8'H)
  - 'U ;0Z9D Q9R77424Q9DBU8#8T2W:1#5VF$3t:/6Y: 098;?#3i742
#!aW d  ! AT  <g&8  %8'| -

Y*#H
G TC
E <
JA NR- HT%- ]9

   
HJ E <^>TA'H 
u OSY4 H'  ]
 * 8'NY
#G
88'
G#<
W XQ Y D
 
u783 U: 2 C9 -T&##H
)i}BH8E

8I  #d;< Sh';CTC
h C']at]'+
Tu ;A 


S #
G< kCH ;*H8 H <x-
!  "  #!    
S
!8'HJ E <>TA'H 
VCO  *# 4'?8 8
&
TP^
G
#8'H)



#G#<|IC  #d;< VC  CTC
]

TA) J |>C 
T l\
#W J *#  Of>  %8 <>GW ! <TC
T  
8E


$
IC  ]at]'+
k ;C  S
!8'HJ \E <l>8TC'H 8
 > O  *# 4' >H H->  %8 8> ;C W -TS\ Y*#C 
pS#-
#$#$#%#% !&#'#$## !(
    & 

8Z
|Y
#G
4'
#G#< d;< C) ! <%>A 
TCx
W J *# & O^& J x< kC';B -

  
kC
H  ;TC|a}(E
$ ;C  S
!8'HJ \E <V>C'H 
CO JA N- R->C'H 
MCO^&CJ k
 &*#I
8'-T 
) * "+
 

* 8'^
G 
8'
#G#<
 
^8 H'CVC
T #d;< S

*  S8% 'H ? O u- R-
JyT SG W H'HEoOQ '

 
C
TKS'Ge]*
4'pa}(E
k ;C  &
# 8'HJ \E <U>TA'H 
6CO Xx';
#H 
S8
?
o |S'G
g' *'

^8 H'C
T  * 8'xY
#G
4'
#G#< ,# # #,(-
 #d;- 
ToXx';
#H 
;A  
p&8 =ZC'h YXl';
H# 
]C ;


 A -
  

J |>C 
T  *#
x
SrA 
pC
T  H*#'8
-T
10. REFERENCES
  
^';C8  f&* #> F #>>8 4'
C 
o O^S*I


 ; 
 >A 
TCf]8'
 *# ]C
TkTC|&
#W H';C 
l- ^

^_%H*'>  S#Fm#'[ *


#8Eomf #- S%C'H ]
#-l<

   
 %P\#rC
;  U C 8 8'<% - ?< V8 #H< F<l -
 H  A8 H4'!8'- C'-
 - G C  4' h C# 8 4'-  c- J      
    
u- S I
C 
kC
T u- S  W)i>C
x-%Xx% G E
>} -u-#]' *#Gx<#N-T
#hA'<#
T F- - *#W 
o}(C
x-


H'x O *# # }DJ'H]&4 \=ZC'h]*#H
G
>.W[Z]\^6_\12$< G8
   
 #-
  

U*#'] ! - |}DJ'HSS8 \=V 'hITC?& Xx';


#H f=V8'>SC\*W 
-\


  ;  
 H  =M=M=- - *Il- * N=Z =?J'H- RO\-
- ;
! A  <xC -
  

,- U'; *#h*#< - V*;h%<TC
T ,-%& h
l-#>>

uu-#C #x< #-#}B
IC

x< ,-  4#TCt<


 
#*# 8'+ C
8']> CG
 W 
>;. 9T3i742;9%13c: 9%1Y6 : 9.@742749?;5 7F:C9
>
#G U'CW Y-T;=?%4'H - f=Z4'&gj
SX` %G  8SOC'S}q'8 8H
X`  t- ^'8H ] Hu C) #<T&C 
 `S8'
T * ]
T 
#H ']&8 =ZC'h-#\

@]1 2W1  7 P @M2W:5;745;59D <l8# N%8']  -T  #%C'-


      
 |S#
W H';A  
x<&8  %8'| -TS    |A


OQ  AOr x- T[T-
TC- GA C#* CTC A#'HW'  C!C)  
 
 
 uS8'C

#8'& 8 4 \E - 
88'SmT 8 ]C
TkmfG*'-

  $ $
 #- H_ -


 H  A=M=M= - 
#8'-  'G CC
8'
O -

A
#- UE 8'?C
TpN-#>CHH8'- ]  J \E) ZCH  
  
 V*8  C $&%
p%JyTC 
l- V*4   kS gCG-

/.&00102": 43:58<R -


>8 H
#) k h
G
}DJ'H&8
H ']S8 \=V 'h  H  A=M=M=- # *#8   l-  -

  
atg_ 8
T# S#W H'; 8 8d;-

 
a` g-Xf
#G
   
#- #-T>C' C) l*
TA)S-T
^'C  xO '


#  C
 '% ';A 
x-}DJ)\mfYat-8RdM
 V*4    X`%   G E)i>%
#
]Xx';C
HHH
$4##*#
#G6

/.&000bAoQ27  7455
 
N*J ;
#*#]&%8';C 
TC';C8 8'+
G6 # ^' k-
6Y: 0F0?9#<513t: 9#5|1 9 BW|783XQU: 2cYCQ9Dd6Y: 9 @742749'5;74<` -
}DJ'HSS8 \=V 'h-#\

 & .
 H  =M=M=-  
l- 8k-

A
S-}(A'
h!783M1 TIC'H M>*#W
'.&001076Y:C098$?3i742;<
N*
A 
GN=?J p    : 9
 
#-#}e h!8'- S
COQ|C ]C
EPh!4EIH +8 U
pC
T JEH? Of}z


  9
*#8)  8 8' #*# 8'-
#aWCd 
A < !C
*C'HEk -    

CH*#rA 
x- H  AG '*#%8'H)
 
 

 8-  'G CG ' *#   A> *#


 C> *#
& r8' A)
#-& #8I

B783Z1  ^sR88 ? Og>4 ; `
o}q'8 8H
?  <5 @


! - +x-

=Q5432; ?
&4 \=ZC'hkF* A  
x-\
". g.
?
:6 ;2

J3 : 9 742749 47u: 9

'5   ?`
 uX&-%N- R8'IC
x- f8'H
TCf]'F&8 =ZC'h
'.e]2 P. LC5;3i740F5
  $
3i7 P.#0 13t:C9<#T G  A< !
*TA'HE -
f ?  

 
&A'H)iy o
H'; %Eo8F*#
A  
x-
f- UT GC=MA 783V1 TEW b>HG
kHH*MOQ '
   
: 249T1 < a C) d <^ -

>.&0100.;9T3i742;9%1 3t: 9%1 6Y: 9.@742749?5;7F:C9


x=M) f=Z8'< x=M) W ># 'H S
G >}DJ'H

6 : 0N0 ?9C;5 1 3t: 95<l -


&4 \=ZC'h
#G#-#\

@]742454: 9T19AP27  7455BY


 

f-%&*#4#P783Z1 #&rC
IOQ '  #CfS#C 
-T

3 ED!FG6 IHJ#J#J
& Y1C27 C<Tm#'*C'HEoC-
   
J NR- ]!
# *B783M1 #SJ H' S_# |E
TCH>
k&*#I


U'CW C
4'SSSHH  A o=?J pX`*# 'SS';<

 ?K
g'JO8';A  
&A <TC
Tkg_#'HH
k O g'G W 8'

MLN.;9PO 745;3t: 9T13t: 9#5<

]  '- x1 : 2H1 3t: 2

:
aW!d T <f&8 %8'|-
   

J |F-#^W H'
l< |-&A

l< #-S #IC

l<
T R- *IA'-

8
 *'HE T 
#G ZC     ';
TC 
p

/2,: 6Y: 0F<TCG&


&4_
8
H ']S8 \=V 'h-
A <f -
  

J uXZ>}B 'h
G6S'*oO ']} xS  ;
A';#-#WYU

     
-|}DJ'H x  f?'FS8 \=V 'h-
 H  =M=M=- I
;- - C'G CGC'*# ! ! -

 
;
J } - u-S
+IC
x<u- TC
T';ChC
l<%



N- ZCrCh ' H#
TC
x-%^
4'G E)^j8 8
  F*#
C 

31 QU1 ).;9T3i742;9%13c: 9%116Y: 9.@742H749?5;7F: 9p."L 5;3i740/.?58i749'5;745;<


g'    ]OC']}q'8 8H 8'H8
H 'S&4 \=ZC'h-

  
-
J Y-#&*l-#X`%   G E 
H'lO ' *# #  gC4h!4  S