Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
SUBMITTED BY:
RIJANA MALLA
BACHELOR IN SOCIAL WORK 3RD YEAR
KANTIPUR COLLEGE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT AND HUMANITIES
NEW BANESHWOR
KTM NEPAL
LETTER OF RECOMMENDATION
This is to certify that Ms. Rijana Malla has completed this thesis entitled
"Migrant Workers and HIV and AIDS: A study on Socio-economic
Condition " under my supervision and guidance. I, therefore, recommend
this dissertation for final approval and acceptance.
.
.................................................
(Research Supervisor)
Mr. Khem Raj Bhattarai
K and K college, baneshwor
TRIBHUWAN UNIVERSITY
K AND K COLLEGE,
ACCEPTANCE LETTER
Approved by
...
Mr. Suman pd. Shrestha
Principal
Mr. KhemRaj Bhattarai
Supervisor
..
External Examiner
Date:
Acknowledgment
Rijana Malla
Letter of recommendation
Acceptance letter
Acknowledgements
TABLE OF CONTENTS
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
Abbreviation
Page
Chapter 1: INTRODUCTION 1-9
1. 1 Background 1
1.1.1 What is migration? 2
1.1.2 HIV and AIDS: Definition 3
3. Introduction
3.1 Selection of the study 20
Location of settings 20
3.2 Research design 20
3.3 Source of data 21
3.4 Sampling procedure 21
3.5 Data collection techniques 22
3.5.1 Interview schedule 22
3.5.2 Observation of different organization 22
3.6 Reliability and validity of data 23
3.7 Field experience 23
3.8 Analysis of data 24
3.9 Limitation of the study 25
4. Data analysis 26
4.1 Background of the Respondent 26
4.1.1 Composition of respondents by Age Group 26
4.1.2. Composition by sex 27
4.1.3 Education 28
4.2 Family status 28
4.2.1 Composition of respondents by Family occupation 29
4.2.2 Composition of respondent with whom they are living 30
List of figures
Figure 1 age group
Figure 2 sex group
Figure 3 family occupation
Figure 4 living position
Figure 5 occupations of respondents
Figure 6 job qualification
Figure 7 occupations for living
Figure 8 economic supporter
Figure 9 economic problems
Figure 10 social behavior
Figure 11 reactions from family
Figure 12 support from family
Figure 13 difficulties for family
Figure 14 problems in marriage life
Figure 15 behavior getting
Figure 16 knowledge on HIV
Abbreviation
1.1 Background
As a developing country, Nepal has not been very successful in effectively
driving the country towards industrialization. Moreover the geographical
barriers that exist in the country act as obstacles to development (Major
Dipak Bahadur Gurung). With the globalization on the trend of people going
from one place to another has intensified. The production of exports item is
also difficult as Nepal is landlocked country. In this context, foreign migration
for employment is increasing day by day in Nepal as well. It has emerged as a
very attractive option among youths of Nepal. Along with men, foreign
employment has also started attracting as increasing number of women.
1
The labor migration is a form of mobility behavior of human beings that
occurs within a particular socio- cultural and economic context. Circumstances
of migratory behavior of human beings vary in accordance with socio-cultural
context. In tradition society migratory behavior of people has taken place as
households how to routinely respond to challenges, constraints and obligation
of rural living (Subedi, 1999)
Rao (1980), migration is a shift in the place of residence for some length of
time, while it exclude short visits and tours, it includes different types of both
voluntary and involuntary movements,
2
which they live.(UNIFEM, fact sheet, 2005 World Summit, 1416 September
2005) .
An estimated 38.6 million people worldwide were living with HIV at the end
of 2005, out of which Asias share comprised some 8.3 million people
(2.4million among adult women). HIV and AIDS has become a prominent
problem in the tiny South Asian country of Nepal. The first HIV positive case
in Nepal was reported in 1988. (Violation against women and HIV: cause and
3
consequences, Action aid Nepal,). Today the total number of people living
with HIV positives is: male- 8099 and female- 3905. Most of them are found
between the age group of 30-39.
The rapid spread of HIV-AIDS in India is of direct major significance for the
future development of the epidemic in its small northern neighbor, Nepal,
given the constant movement of large numbers of people between the two
countries and the necessity for the Nepalese economy to maintain these links
at all levels national, regional, and household.
4
Table no.2 Cumulative HIV infection by sub- group and sex
Data:
5
traditional societies are highly mobile and mobility has remained an integral
part of their customary life (Subedi, 1999)
It is seen in fact that over two million people of Nepal (10 percent of
countrys adult labor force) are working in abroad. The number of Nepali
migrant workers in India is three million. It is very big number in comparison
to migrant workers in other countries.
The reasons behind migration are almost the same in Nepal as in other parts
of the world. Poverty, limited employment opportunities, deteriorating
agricultural productivity, and armed conflict are some of the motives behind
international labor migration. There are many villages in Nepal where labor
migration has been established as a culture of a community; that is, going
abroad for work for awhile. Mainly by pushing rural residents, mostly sexually
active age groups, from war-torn areas to cities and to other country, the
conflict has helped to spread HIV. (UNDP, 2006)
6
harm. The worst abuses force women into sexual slavery. (UNIFEM, fact
sheet, Migrant Women in Search of Decent Jobs)
Beside all the realities, migration coupled with a general lack of knowledge on
HIV and AIDS, separation from families and partner put them at to risk to
practice unsafe sexual practices making them vulnerable towards HIV (UNDP
2006). In such case UNAIDS estimates at least 10 percent of the 2 million to 3
million Nepalese migrant workers in India only are HIV positive. And these
men are now infecting spouses and others in many parts of the country. Now
however in recent year, these people no longer appear to be returning to
Nepal for working their own country.
Estimates of internal and external migration for seasonal and long-term labor
range from 1.5 to 2 million people. It is necessary for the economic survival of
many households in both rural and urban areas. Removal from traditional
social structures can promote unsafe sexual practices, such as having multiple
sexual partners and engaging in commercial sex. A 2002 study suggests that
HIV prevalence is nearly 8 percent in migrants returning from Mumbai.
In this regard, the major focus of this study is on the following sets of the
research question:
7
4. What are they doing for survival?
5. What kind of behavior they are getting from their family and society?
6. What must be their major role in flow of information on HIV and Aids?
5. What kind of role they must play to flow information on HIV and AIDS?
Nepal is one of the worlds least developed Countries where most of the
population are living with poverty, unemployment, declining natural
resources, and more recently the Maoist insurgency ,which are major reasons
why international labor migration is an increasingly important source of
income. As the matter the number of migrant worker are increasing day by
day.
8
The literature available on the issue related to Nepalese migrant workers
and HIV and AIDS provide more or less important information of the condition
of workers. However, it is very necessary to make a systematic study since
only such studies could help one to know directly the facts and figures in real
situation. Therefore the research will be design to collect the first hand
information from migrant worker living with HIV and AIDS and will give the
answer to the question like: what is the socio-economic condition of migrant
worker? Are they facing any difficulties? What must be their role in
family/society to flow information on HIV and AIDS?
2. Introduction
9
In course of literature review, I visited different libraries, I/NGOs,
organizations working for migrant workers and other resource centers and
consulted different books, journals and research reports. That related
literature with the study has reviewed below.
2.2Migration history
Studies of migration can be classified roughly as neo classical, modern and
emerged. Through 1960s, the movement of people from countryside to cities
and their assimilation into the dominant culture comes under neo classical,
likewise structural in equalities and migration of people from less develop to
more developed region in search of job were the major focus of modern
studies.
10
2.2.2 Focus on the modern studies
Structural inequalities as cause migration are the major focus of migration
studies in modern period (Lewellen, 2002:131). Migration and some group of
non migrants often make migration decision jointly. Although, migration unit
is usually an individual, the units of analysis for migration are culturally
defined unit of production and consumption.
Today, almost 175 million people world-wide are thought to be living outside
their countries of origin. For many of them, migration is a real lifeline, but all
too often they face exploitation and abuse.
11
Labor migration is not a recent phenomenon in Nepal. For about 200 years
Nepali men, and to a lesser extent women, have been leaving their homes to
seek employment abroad. But both the scale and the nature of migration have
been changed significantly over that period. Even before the recruitment of
Nepali men as soldiers into the British army(as Gurkhas), which began in the
early part of the 19th century, Nepalese had fled from excessive taxation,
compulsory and unpaid forced system, and fear of land appropriation by state
authorities during and after the unification of the country. This was in large
part a migration triggered by push factors associated with the harsh socio-
economic condition and feudal agrarian condition where the exploitation of
tenants-cultivation was a consequence of the expansion of the state. But at
that time they mainly went to adjacent areas, in Sikkim, Bhutan, and India,
where land was more freely available for small- holder agricultural cultivation,
estates, and plantation, and new employment opportunities in factories and
mines and other sectors of the Indian economy were beginning to develop.
Migration was not always easy and certainly migration to Assam and other
parts of northeast India and later to Burma was fraught with difficulties.
12
Lanka, they significantly outstrip men. While some women reap benefits from
access to new employment opportunities, the vast majority end up at the
lower end of the job market as domestic and service workers, and as
entertainers, typically a euphemism for sex workers.( Migrant Women in
Search of Decent Jobs)
13
HIV stands for the Human Immune-deficiency Virus. HIV is the
cause of AIDS, which stands for Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome.
There are cells in your body which protect you from invasion by
bacteria, viruses, fungi and parasites. They also destroy cancer cells. The HI
Virus attacks and destroys these cells in your body so that they can no longer
fight diseases.
After you have been infected for a long period, usually 3 - 7 years,
many of these cells will have been destroyed and your body will not be able to
defend itself against infections and cancers. This is the phase of HIV -
infection when you become sick, and is known as AIDS.
HIV infection does not "just happen". You cannot catch it like a cold or
'flu. HIV is not spread by coughing or sneezing. You only get HIV by receiving
infected blood, semen or vaginal fluids from another person. HIV is not easy
to get.
You will not get HIV through everyday contact with infected people at
school, at work, at home, or anywhere else
You will not get HIV from clothes, telephones, computer keyboards or
toilet seats. It cannot be passed on by things like cups, knives and forks
14
You cannot get HIV from eating food that has been prepared by an
infected person
You will not get HIV from a mosquito bite. HIV does not live in a
mosquito. You also will not get it from bedbugs, lice, flies or any other insects
You will not get HIV from sweat or tears
The rapid spread of the disease is related to poverty and the lack of
access to socio-economic rights such as housing, clean water, sanitation and
health care.
Everyone and anyone can get HIV / AIDS, but those most at risk are
youth, women, migrant workers, long-haul truck drivers and sex workers.
15
Other poverty related diseases such as TB
Sexually transmitted diseases
South Asia, which is burdened with the one of the lowest human
development indicators and increasing socio-economic inequalities, is home to
the worlds second largest number of people on the move. Annually more than
200 million people are estimated to migrate within and between countries in
the region, in desperate search for a better life. This intense movement of
people is accentuated by the growing mismatch between pockets of economic
activity and deprivation brought about by the new global economic order.
(MOBILITY AND MIGRATION)
Asia is also home to the second largest number of people living with
HIV/AIDS and a region with one of the fastest rates of HIV infection in the
world. Though the HIV prevalence rates are still reportedly low, the huge
population of the region translates them to large numbers, there are over 7.6
16
million people living with HIV in South and South East Asia. In India alone
accounted for 5.7 million infections in 2005. All over South Asia there are
concentrated epidemics among the vulnerable groups such as sex workers,
injecting drug users and MSM (Men having Sex with Men). The infection is
steadily spreading to the general population, closing fast the window of
opportunity for prevention. Experience from the region and other parts of the
world clearly show that the apparent low prevalence does not offer any room
for complacence. (MOBILITY AND MIGRATION)
Ample instances have shown that the sate has failed to effectively
protect the rights of migrant workers in general and that of women migrant
17
workers in particular. Trade unions are the main organization to ensure rights
and opportunities of workers. However, these unions are able to operate only
within a country and do not have transnational authority and mandate.
Therefore, their activities towards ensuring migrant workers rights and
opportunities remain only as a pressure group insisting the government to
make recruiting agencies accountable and to have diplomatic bilateral
negotiations with host governments for protection or workers rights based on
the international labor laws and regulation. (UNIFEM)
Ngo like forum for Women, Law and Development (FWLD), Paurakhi
Nepal, NIDS, Unifem, UN etc are working for the rights of migrant workers.
To sum up the involvement and actions of various organizations in relation to
womens rights and opportunities for foreign employment, one thing for
certain is that if it were not for their actions, the issues of migrant workers
18
would not be visible. Nevertheless, still more actions seems to be needed for
further research on many pertinent issues.
3. Introduction
19
This chapter deals with the methodological aspects undertaken by the
researcher during the study on migrant workers and HIV and AIDS. The
chapter deals with the following
20
questionnaire, structured interview. Qualitative research method was
developed in the social science to study social phenomena. It includes
observation. Thus the study analyses the data and examines the relationship
between different variables.
The main part of the study is based on primary data which were
collected by interview and interacting with them using unstructured
questionnaire. The required primary data includes age, sex, marital status
family background, personal information and social status.
As migrant workers living with HIV and Aids is the unit of analysis for
the study. The respondent is from the hospital, so the universe of the study is
Sukraraj tropical disease hospital, Teku. But the sample size of the study is
only 20, as it is very difficult to take interview with all migrant workers living
with HIV and Aids.
21
3.5 Data collection techniques
To do research on migrant workers living with HIV and Aids was quite
difficult task as this issue has been always put confidential in front of all. That
is why I selected 20 numbers of migrant workers.
22
Primary data were collected from the migrant worker living with HIV
with the help of staff of the hospital. Before the questionnaire distribution,
researcher had briefed about the study and given questions in the schedule.
It was very risky and hard job for a researcher to do a whole research
alone with migrant workers living with HIV and AIDS. As we all know about
the issues of HIV and AIDS which has been rising day by day. The first HIV
positive case in Nepal was reported in 1988. Today majority number of people
from the different places of country has been suffering from the HIV and
AIDS.
23
HIV has been very confidential matter from the beginning. This is because of
the traditional society concept; people became afraid of interacting with HIV
infected. Another fact is that people being educated also feel somehow
hesitate dealing with them. This was observed during the time of interview. As
the sample of the study was at STDH, Teku, there were number of infected
people, who come over there for treatment. As all the HIV positive were not
migrant workers, it was giving problem in the study. As none of the
respondent was ready to talk with us, it was creating problem. As researcher
was new person for the entire respondent, so some of them were shying to
give answer. But finally after the visit of one and half week, we got succeeded
in completing our research.
During the time of research some of the respondent was very frank
and answered so easily. So as the whole this was great chance for researcher
to learn more about migrant workers living with HIV
24
Every research work has its own limitation and scope, so is the case
with the present study. The first was the limitation of time and finance.
As this research was to fulfill our academic requirement we had to
work in our own limit,
HIV and AIDS is very rare case, so there were difficulty while dealing
with those workers who are migrants we had to take care of certain things
during survey times.
Another was that there was limitation in the number of respondents as
well duration of time is short, there will be no applicable report.
25
This chapter mainly deals with important finding such as sex-age
structure and analysis of socio-economic characteristics such as occupation of
family head, living ways, behaviors among family, society, colleagues, and
economic status such as occupation of the respondents, status job etc.
Socio-economic characteristics
The study was conducted with 20 migrant workers living with HIV
Positive. Among 20 respondents, 70% were male and 30% were female.
26
Source: Field survey
The table shows that 70% are the male and 30 percent are the female
group.
Age group
Table no. 4
Age group Male (%) Female (%)
25-30 42.8 50
The pie chart shows that among the total number of respondents, the number
of the male is higher in majority than that of female and that is 30% female
and 70% is male.
27
Source: Field survey
4.1.3 Education
The combination of the group varies by various people with their reasoning
power as per their level of education. The group has their own level of
educated people; some were still continuing their studies and some left it at
very beginning.
Family plays vital role in encouraging the infected person. If one of the
members of family is infected by HIV then it is responsibility of their family to
help them in living.
29
Source: Field survey
On the basis of with whom they are living 20% of the respondent are
involve indifferent Ngo, 15%with husband and majority of the respondent that
is 65% living with their family. Most of the respondents are living with their
family and they are also engage with different organization.
30
Volunteering 10 75
Depends on family 2 10
Self dependent 3 15
Total 100
31
As most of the migrant workers are working as volunteer at different I/Ngos,
and some at press also, so 70 percent said that they are very happy with their
job and they think that according to their will they are doing this. But very
less (30%) did not defined and also some said that they want something
better job for them according to their qualification.
32
Source: Field survey
33
as they were dependent on their family. 75percentsaid that they had problem
and 25 percent said no.
34
Source: Field survey
The above doughnut shows that 90% of the respondents were not accepted
for the first time in their family and they did not get any support from them,
and very less respondents (10%) got supportive reaction for the first time as
they thought that its ok what they could do now. So everyone had a different
view.
During the interview, respondent were feeling very uneasy as its the
matter of HIV so they were not answering very openly. Among the total
35
number, 25 percent of respondent get support from the family, 25 percent did
not gave any reaction on support from family and majority of people (25%)
said no to the question. They said that they are doing every thing by
themselves.
36
Source: Field survey
The above doughnut shows that majority of the migrant workers(90%) said
that they are not getting any problem in married life, as many of them were
not married, and only 10 percent of the respondent said that they sometime
had to face difficulties. As we all know that HIV is the serious issue and
everyone must have knowledge on it.
37
According to our traditional society, people once get HIV are of no use,
they are just the burden of the country. So they always dominate people
instead of supporting. While asking about the behavior from the society, most
of the migrant workers (60%) answer that they get normal behavior from
society, and 40 percent said that the society around them are unknown about
their infection and some behave very rudely to them.
38
As all the migrant workers were came from different countries after
infection, so while we asked them about the knowledge on HIV and AIDS, 40
percent said that they were unknown about the fact and 60 percent said yes
they knew about the issue. Today in world, very most of the people have
knowledge on HIV and AIDS, but in other side at rural area of country, many
people are unknown about the issue.
NAPN 4
Sparsha Nepal 13
Sathi Samuha 3
4.5.3 In the last question what are your future plans, most of the
respondents want to do volunteer at the same organization where they are
39
working, and they are doing awareness program. Other remaining said that
they want another job according to their qualification. So they also told that
there should be effective plan and policies for them by government.
Majority number of respondents is living with their family. But we found that
though some of the respondents are living with their family, their family is
unknown about their infection.
It is found that most of the respondents are student and they had completed
their study from abroad. So they also told that the cause of their infection is
drug. They use to take drug by injection. Now after return to their home,
some are involved in different NGOs and some are self dependent, and doing
job at different office.
40
Some of the respondents being educated also hesitate to talk about the issue
and they think that being a HIV infected is cursed to their family, society. So
we were feeling so difficulty in dealing with them. But some were so frank and
told about their infection.
From the beginning of our traditional society, HIV infected people are not
accepted at any cost. But today at some places mostly at urban society there
is more acceptance of this fact and people being educated agree that HIV
infected should be treated well. Some of the respondent told that they are not
happy with their recent job, as they have to suffer from many difficulties and
their job does not suit as to qualification. But most of the respondent said that
they are happy and satisfied with their job and they are well treat.
Social status
With reference to the survey the status of migrant workers who has just
return from the abroad due to their infection have improved their social
condition some how with the increased in literacy rate of our country. People
41
have now knowledge about HIV and AIDS, so they treat well to those infected
person but at some backward part of our country there still need to flow
education about the issue. According to respondents, most of them are
getting supportive and normal behavior from their family and society.
Economic status
Not only social condition but also social condition of a person also makes lots
of differences in daily life activities. As most of the respondents were
dependent on volunteering at different organization, so their economic
condition are not so supportive. For this one main cause is not getting any
support from their family and their office seeing their qualification. So all
should be given equal opportunity in getting job, which is according to
respondents.
42
vulnerable to discriminatory practices such as forced testing, violence and
deportation.
43
mention conflicts and various forms of discrimination. Efforts on this count will
prepare the ground for a sustainable, multi-sectoral response.
44
Chapter six: Summary and conclusion
6.1 Summary
The present study deals with the socio-economic condition, the life style of the
migrant workers living with HIV and AIDS from the SukraRaj tropical disease
hospital,Teku. It is known fact that Nepali Labor migrants are scattered
around the world. Labor Migration is a predominant feature, both in terms of
its long history as well as in terms of migrants involved. Such as the number
of Labor migration working in India accounts 600,000 to 3 million. (Dixit,
1997, Dahal, 2000, Graner and Gurung, 2003)
45
Migration is a kind of mobility behavior of human beings that can be
classified according to motive, distance and duration. It can be classified into
two major types: internal and international. Both of them are temporary and
permanent. (Janawali,2004) the basic focus of the study is those migrant
workers who return back to their own country but they are infected with HIV
and now what is their socio-economic condition. The entire result of the study
was based on the field work with application of field survey by interview
schedule, key informant interviews in practice.
46
returnees have made immense contribution to society and have shared their
skills and knowledge to empower others. But amidst these successes, we
cannot ignore the horrors that some people had to go through in foreign lands
exploitation by employers and recruiting companies, and also stories of many
who were compelled to re- migrate unable to integrate back into society.
The research was completely based on the field survey and interview with all
involved and not involved person of the society. This was mainly based on the
fieldwork to get conclusion and objective of the study. Going through whole
study researcher thinks that researcher is completely satisfied with the study.
The study gave us the whole necessary fact that was to be finding out as to
match our objectives.
Most of the all migrant workers interviewed were from rural area. Some went
to abroad to continue their study and some in the search of work to improve
their economic condition. From the interviewed migrant workers, we came to
know that most of the female groups were sex workers and remaining very
few got infected because of their husband. Among the male group, some were
infected because of the drug injected in their body and some were infected
due to visit to other female sex workers and other reasons which was not
described.
The number of male workers were high than female workers because during
the interview time the female group were hesitating. Most of the respondents
were found working at different organization to live their life. But most of the
migrant workers are getting many problems in their daily life activities such
as: 1domination from the society, family and colleagues, 2.not equal
response to normal people and to those who are infected, 3.families have to
suffer from many challenges while dealing with relatives, 4.they have to
sacrifice many things to fulfill their daily life activities, 5.very few number are
getting family support beside that very less thinks that everyone should be
47
given equal opportunities as they are not getting proper support from their
family, job and also the government of our country.
6.2 conclusion
While completing the research the finding helps more in getting objective of
the study. The essential things of the research were to find the positive and
negative aspect of migration. From this research, researcher got conclusion
that today in our country most of the people are known about HIV and AIDS
48
and they are flowing information about the issue. Migrant workers who leave
their country to improve their socio- economic condition are behaving very
badly at abroad. So they have to work at harsh condition at any cost and
condition. This is one other cause due to which today in world the number of
HIV is getting high.
49
migration and trafficking as well as propagate violent uprisings. Only such
efforts will prevail in mitigating the effects of both HIV and conflict in Nepal.
And also there should be effective plan and policies for those migrant workers
living with HIV, who are living at very risk condition. A disease that was once
considered too alien for Nepal's traditional society has become a real threat.
We must take the initiative to prevent HIV infections among migrant workers.
Since migration is required to boost economic activities, we must prepare a
strategy to generate awareness among these workers," says Dr. Ram Hari
Aryal, a leading demographer. (Keshab Poudel)
From the whole study we can say that there is still need to improve the
socio-economic condition of the respondents. There must be equal
opportunity for all migrant workers.
Reference
David Seddon, British scholar, article HIV and AIDS in Nepal. the coming
crisis)
Dixit, 1997, Dahal, 2000, Graner and Gurung, 2003 Land and migration in
far western nepal
50
Fitting The Pieces Together: An Examination of Sources Related to
Farmworker Housing. 1996. Housing
51
(UNIFEM, fact sheet, 2005 World Summit, 1416 September 2005)
Website
1. http://www.nepalmonitor.com
2. Glossary Migrant UNESCO SHS.htm
3. http://www.niaid.nih.gov/
4. http://www.nccusa.org/publicwitness/mtolive/boycott
52
Annex
Questionnaire
(To be asked to migrant workers)
A) General Information
Name:
Caste/ethnicity:
Religion:
53
From (district)
Age:
Sex:
Education:
Marital Status:
Interview date:
B) Socio-economic Information
7. Does your family feel any difficulties because of your infection? If yes
what kind of.
10. What kind of behavior/ reaction do you get from your society?
54
12. Is your occupation enough for your livelihood?
15. Did you had any knowledge about HIV and AIDS before you have been
infected?
19. Are you doing any work to aware people about HIV and AIDS?
55
56