Sie sind auf Seite 1von 8

Strategic Planning

Professional and
Interpersonal Skills
for ICT Specialists
Ariadna Llorens-Garcia, Xavier Llinas-Audet, and Ferran Sabate
Technical University of Catalonia

A study surveying experts and related literature reveals the most-


and least-valued generic professional abilities for engineers in the
information and communication technology (ICT) sector.

T
he current business environment is in- omy which generates competitive advantage, it
creasingly more complex, dynamic, and shouldnt be modified by training engineers or
turbulent in both the macro and micro developing electronic technology, since research
scales. This is especially evident when we shows that recently industrialised countries are
consider key issues such as globalization, politics, perfectly able to compete; but rather the issue
technologies, social and economic matters, sup- should be treated like other important social
pliers, clients, and product and services compe- fields like anthropology, psychology, sociol-
tition.13 This effect is particularly noticeable in ogy, communication, public health, education,
the information and communication technology architecture, design or management science.6
(ICT) sector, where escalation in the number and
propensity of changes necessarily generates in- In the same article, he concluded by suggesting
creased uncertainty and makes predicting market that
behavior more difficult.
Within this new paradigm, we must reconsider our engineers are no better than Chinese en-
the models of competitiveness established to date, gineersbut more expensive, and instead of
especially those that refer to resource and person- rediscovering engineering that has been par-
nel management. Manuel Castells contends that tially replaced locally by computers and ro-
capitalist production has passed from an industrial bots, or at a distance by Indian and Chinese
to an information model.4 He considers informa- people, we should build the knowledge-based
tion the new material base of technological activity economy by investing in the social disci-
and social organization, which is manifested in his plines and linking them to business schools.
network society model. Furthermore, the European
Union (EU) is clearly moving toward a new pro- Although Castells makes some relevant points,
ductive system, a knowledge-based economy, with we dont agree with such reasoning in its en-
the objective of becoming the most competitive tirety. The ICT sector faces savage competition,
society in the world by 2010.5 where the threat of new competitors (emerging
Along these lines, Castells claims, nations) is added to that of the well-established
competition (such as the US and Japan). Recent
Faced with the emerging nations, if Western Eu- reports from the European Observatory of In-
rope and the US have a knowledge-based econ- formation Technology (EITO; www.eito.com/

1520-9202/09/$26.00 2009 IEEE Published by the IEEE Computer Society computer.org/ITPro 23


Str ategic Pl anning

start.html) confirm this situation. Thus, its though character is intrinsic to a person, diffi-
important to work on the personal character- cult to modify, and well defined at an early age,
istics of the telecommunications engineers who people can work on and successfully improve in-
must direct a market that in Europe involves terpersonal skills, especially in a university envi-
approximately 614 billion, 6.1 percent of which ronment. Its this gap, this difference or guidance
belonged to the Spanish market in 2005, ac- in capacity development, this added value, that
cording to the EITO. Castells refers to in his article.6
There is a lovely Spanish proverb that translates Its important to clarify that theres much
as the swell and storms flatter the best naviga- ambiguity in terms, amplified by the subtle yet
tors (www.refranespopulares.com), echoing the meaningful variations caused by interpreting vo-
English adage fortune favors the brave. This cabulary in different contexts and the absence
leads us to ask (with regard to telecommunica- of exact translations between languages, that
tion engineers, computer scientists, and design- sometimes blurs understanding and precision.
ers), which ICT graduates professional abilities For this reason, we propose an approach we call
will make them the best navigators? 4C to define, categorize, and clarify the terminol-
ogy used when we reference the wide-ranging,
Professional Abilities complex concept of professional abilities. Our
To flesh out this question, given the confusion 4C approach consists of a principal C (compe-
and ambiguity that exists around the subject, tence), which incorporates or unites three others:
we must start by trying to specify exactly which knowledge, capabilities, and character. (We originally
professional abilities were referring to. We did a wrote this article in Spanish, where the word for
related literature review and found plenty of au- knowledge begins with the letter C.)
thors and studies that deal with this theme.79 Knowledge is the training and experience
Heres a look at several related studies: that professionals accumulate. It incorporates
not only explicitly learned knowledge (such as
Debra D. Bragg defined 98 outcome statements qualifications, postgraduate studies, and various
that she subsequently grouped into nine clus- courses and languages), but also all the unspoken,
ters by means of factor analysis.10 internalized experiential learning that takes place
John Arnolda and his colleagues defined 15 during a persons working life. Thus, knowledge
abilities.11 tells us, What have we learned?
George D. Kuh, based on an analysis of in- Capabilities (also known as skills, abilities, or
depth graduate interviews, employed only five proficiencies) refer to a repertoire of behavior that
categories of basic abilities that included a total some people are able to apply better than others,
of 13 skills.12 making them more efficient in particular situ-
Neville Bennet, Elisabeth Dunne, and Clive ations. This set of skills tells us, What are we
Carr only used four clusters that incorporated good at?
42 abilities.13 Finally, character indicates the features of our
Michael K. Badawy grouped basic abilities in personality and outlook and refers to our way
terms of administrative, technical, and inter- of being, thinking, and feeling, based on our
personal skills.14 individual experiences. Character traits tell us,
What are we like?
Despite this lack of consensus, we can broadly
define the concept of professional abilities as the Objectives and Methodology
combination of knowledge, skills, and character The main objective of our work is to define and
that people possess in relation to their profes- evaluate the professional abilities of an engi-
sional activity. neer who works as an IT professional in Spain,
In the literature, researchers have paid much primarily telecommunications engineers and
attention to identifying and defining the knowl- computer scientists. Their occupational profiles
edge a telecommunication engineer requires. will provide us with a useful tool for defining and
However, defining the personal abilities required conceptualizing curriculum plans for new quali-
has received relatively little attention. Even fications, which the EU Higher Education Area

24 IT Pro November/December 2009


project will require in 2010. European universi- Placements within the Technical University of
ties, institutes of higher education, and learning Catalonias Friends Association (www.upc.edu/
centers are currently drawing up such proposals. aaupc), which produces an annual report of the
This article presents a first attempt at defin- abilities and personal skills demanded by com-
ing the professional characteristicsin terms panies.16 The report is based on information ob-
of competence and aptitudethat an IT profes- tained through department surveys and details
sional should possess. It focuses more on inter- taken from related job vacancy listings.
personal skills and abilities than to knowledge The most recently published report (2003
and technical expertise. 2004) is based on an annual average of 730 job
Such an ambiguous objective is too general and descriptions, which corresponds to approximate-
broad, so weve defined a certain type of worker ly 20 percent of the graduates who received their
and a more specific geographic framework. In degree from Technical University of Catalonia
particular, we want to identify which skills an (www.upc.edu). This figure includes approxi-
ICT engineer should have, and be capable of de- mately 3,638 students in the 20032004 academ-
veloping, in order to find employment in compa- ic year, across all centers and including first- and
nies in the Spanish ICT sector. second-year students, according to the manage-
To identify these skills, we must begin by es- ment statement for that academic year (www.upc.
tablishing an initially broad set of professional edu/dades/2005).
abilities that are necessary for the development of To define the personal skills most valued in ICT
professional competence in computer scientists engineers in the Spanish ICT sector, we also used
and telecommunications engineers working as the White Book, which is produced by the Higher
IT professionals. Also, we must establish which Education Area project and details qualifications
types of occupational profiles those specialists in computer sciences.17 The White Book specifies
can bring to the sector. We analyzed the related generic transversal skills in relation to occupation-
literature to identify which skills and profiles are al profiles relative to the management and deploy-
significant. Also, using a panel of experts, we at- ment of computer technologies (www.escet.urjc.
tempted to evaluate and then rank the specified es/~eees/docs/g/VersionPreliminarLibroBlanco
abilities for each profile grouped in Mintzber cat- IngenieriaInformatica.pdf). These conclusions
egories. (Henry Minztber divided one organiza- form part of a huge piece of field work conducted
tion into three main parts in his organizational with a range of engineers and contributions from
configuration model: top management or strate- specialist colleges, associations, and well-respected
gic apex, middle management or middle line, and professionals from the computing sector.
operation or operating core.) We focused on an Finally, we consulted the study of occupa-
expert panel because we believe theyre able to tional profiles known as the Telecommunication
forecast tendencies and provide us with signifi- Engineering Project,18 produced by the National
cant conclusions.15 This approach is useful for Agency for Evaluation of Quality and Accredi-
the purposes of this article, but it also has limita- tation (ANECA, www.aneca.es/publicaciones/
tions, which well discussion shortly. libros-blancos/libro_blanco_teleco.aspx), as well
as the White Book for future university degrees
Abilities, Skills, Competence, or Aptitude in the ICT field.19 We also looked at other litera-
The range of skills or personal abilities that a ture on an international level, which endorsed
professional can bring to the workplace varies the selection of skills.2022
widely. Because putting such a general question After analyzing the data we extracted from
to the experts could have led to an infinite num- these sources, we drew up a list of the most im-
ber of responses, we felt it necessary to establish portant skills and abilities. Specifically, we cross-
an initial list. We first asked the expert panel if referenced the source material and noted the
they considered a preliminary aptitude filter to number of times each term appeared. The im-
be acceptable and then to rank each of the dif- portant skills for IT professionals include
ferent skills.
To carry out the initial filter, we referred to the change management,
Department of Vocational Guidance and Work commitment to customer service,

computer.org/ITPro 25
Str ategic Pl anning

PAFET
T he Proposal of Activities for Training Electronics,
Informatics and Telecommunications Engineers
(PAFET) was sponsored by the Official College of
on this project.) Furthermore, companies them-
selves are unable to agree on a definitive list of
Telecommunication Engineers (COIT), the Association profiles: large companies use specialized pro-
of Spanish Electronics and Information Communica- files, whereas medium and small companies have
tion Technology Companies (AETIC), and the Spanish more generalized profiles. In a small company,
Association of Telecommunication Engineers (AEIT) in the same person might take on the roles of sev-
2001. The PAFET initiative consists of four studies. PAFET eral staff members in a larger company.
1 focused on knowledge of the position of information Furthermore, the White Book has sanctioned
and communication technology (ICT) professionals. The the profiles of only a few generic groups, suggest-
following year, PAFET 2 responded to the necessity of ing that its impossible to find a fixed set of occupa-
updating and broadening the analysis in Spain in light of tional profiles because theyre in a state of flux. For
new conditions. PAFET 3 analyzed the extensive employ- this reason, we only defined three general profiles:
ment of ICT professionals outside their own specific sec-
tor. In 2005, the study was extended with PAFET 4, the software development,
objectives of which ranged from identifying new services systems design, and
to distinguishing the skills needed by ICT professionals. management and deployment of information
technologies.

commitment to excellence, This profile classification system conveniently


communication, groups many types of work into three categories
creativity, that define the whole sphere of information tech-
decisiveness, nology: software solutions, hardware solutions,
empathy, and information management. The fundamental
innovation, advantage of this classification is that its highly
leadership probable that these profiles will continue to be
knowledge management, relevant in the long term and, therefore, are less
motivation, prone to obsolesce.
negotiation, That said, the personal abilities for each profile
objective oriented, are flexible, due to their generality, and we might
personal development, discover that all the occupational profiles require
persuasiveness, a set of similar skills. For this reason, we opted to
proactive, look for more specific profiles and then group them
problem-solving skills, within the more general profiles, consequently
strategy and planning, and benefiting from the advantages of both approaches.
teamwork. Revising the epistemology, we found and se-
lected several research papers that helped us re-
Our next step was to assess each of these skills focus our subject. The goal wasnt to conduct a
against each of the different occupational profiles study of existing occupational profiles, but rath-
required by the highly profitable ICT sector. er to ascertain which skills best fit each profile.
In light of this, we referred to the Sectoral Study
Occupational Profiles of Telecommunications, conducted by the Eu-
Trying to specify occupational profiles isnt ropean Social Fund (www.ccoo.es) and the Tri-
a simple task because the sector is constantly partite Foundation, as well as the three PAFET
changing, making technical skills obsolete. reports (see the related sidebar), which were en-
The first report from the Proposal of Activi- dorsed by the Board of National Association of
ties for Training Electronics, Informatics, and Electronic and Telecommunications Industries
Telecommunications Engineers (PAFET) project (ANIEL), the Official College of Telecommuni-
clearly explained that the profiles arent static; cations Engineers, and the Board of Universities.
they have a life cycle, and they emerge, evolve, We also paid particular attention to research by
and disappear according to technological ad- the Career Space consortium (http://mural.uv.es/
vances.23 (See the PAFET sidebar for details luisupa/Career-Space.zip).

26 IT Pro November/December 2009


Table 1. Occupational profiles in the information and communication technology (ICT) field.
Occupational profiles Mintzbergs categories

Applications design for processing digital signals C


Design of communication networks C
Design of ICT products C
Development and maintenance of software and applications C
Development of research and technology B
Digital design C
ICT consultancy B
ICT management A
ICT sales and marketing management B
Integration and implementation testing engineering B
Management of ICT projects B
Network and data communication engineering C
Programming and multimedia design C
Radiofrequency engineering C
Security specialist in telematics B
Systems software design C
Systems specialist C
Technical assistance C

From all the cited literature, we compiled Table 1 indicates to which group each profes-
a list that we believe epitomizes all the pos- sion belongs.
sible occupational profiles of the Spanish ICT
sector. We specify the resulting 18 categories Expert Panel
in the next section, but the objective of the Our expert panel included ICT specialists who
study wasnt to identify occupational profiles had extensive work experience, prestige within
in relation to a set of tasks or certain areas the sector, a general overview of the sector, and,
of knowledge. Instead, we identified occu- at the same time, were knowledgeable of matters
pational profiles with regard to the personal regarding engineer instruction and training. We
abilities they call for. To achieve this, we in- interviewed 10 experts, including general direc-
troduced a second filter that let us incorporate tors of significant companies in the ICT sector,
the 18 profiles into three homogenous groups public institutions, and administration manag-
or sets of similar jobs, paying attention to the ers, along with university professors such as the
skills and personal abilities required to per- dean of the Official College of Computer Engi-
form them. neering of Catalonia and the dean of the Faculty
The method of categorization we used corre- of Computer Engineering of Barcelona. (The
sponds to Mintzbergs classification of business number of experts we selected fits with similar
organizations:24 studies based on expert panels.15) Their expertise
has been established by their status among their
Group A (strategic apex) includes senior man- peers, their years of professional experience,
agers who take overall responsibility for man- their own self-appraisal of relative competence
agement and formulation of strategy. with regard to our questions, and the amount of
Group B or (middle line) includes middle man- relevant information to which they have access.
agers with formal authority and responsibility We presented the experts with the list of skills
who coordinate and see that strategic policies and abilities and the list of occupational profiles
are implemented throughout the rest of the for Spanish IT professionals. (Each list under-
organization. went a prior analysis to check its validity.) We
Group C (operating core) includes the people asked them if the lists were either excessive or if
who carry out the work directly related to the we had omitted any skills or occupational pro-
production of goods and services, or company files. Finally, we asked the experts to confirm that
output. both lists were valid, needing no amendment.

computer.org/ITPro 27
Str ategic Pl anning

Table 2. Assessment of abilities by homogeneous group.


Homogeneous groups
Abilities A B C

Change management 0 0 20
Commitment to customer service 2 16 16
Commitment to excellence 0 2 12
Communication 1 8 10
Creativity 5 6 15
Decisiveness 2 2 2
Empathy 2 1 5
Innovation 0 5 16
Leadership 5 6 28
Knowledge management 1 4 4
Motivation 2 3 2
Negotiation 4 6 22
Objective oriented 0 5 13
Personal development 0 12 16
Persuasiveness 0 1 36
Proactive 2 3 0
Problem-solving skills 2 0 28
Strategy and planning 5 0 10
Teamwork 1 2 22
Mean average (m) 0.32 0.42 0.37
Standard deviation (sd) 2.47 5.92 17.45
Most valued (m + sd) 2.79 6.34 17.82
Least valued (m sd) 2.16 5.50 17.08

Next, we asked them to indicate which three those rated as least important, or less valued, that
abilities they considered most important to satis- fell below the mean average minus the standard
fy the tasks and objectives relevant to each occu- deviation.
pational profile, and which three they considered
least important, or less relevant, for that post. Results
We added a positive point when the expert con- The most and least valued abilities for the three
sidered an ability relevant and a negative point if homogeneous groups A, B, and C (strategic apex,
they judged the ability less relevant. middle line, and operating core) were as follows:
We transferred the sum of the experts marks
for each ability and profile to a 2D plane and an- Group A. The most valued abilities were strat-
alyzed the Euclidean distances to check against egy and planning, leadership, and negotiation.
the possibility of inconsistent values that could Creativity was the least valued.
have affected the subsequent conclusions. The Group B. The most valued abilities were a commit-
result of the analysis established the viability of ment to customer service and communication.
the opinions of all the experts who participated. Personal development, creativity, negotiation,
(Various studies and scientific articles support and leadership were the least valued.
this method of analysis.15,25) Subsequently, we Group C. The most valued abilities were prob-
computed and analyzed each profiles assess- lem-solving skills and teamwork. Persuasive-
ments and then categorized the results into the ness, leadership, negotiation, and change
three homogeneous groups. Table 2 presents the management were the least valued.
results alphabetically.
Finally, we noted the abilities rated as most im- These results demonstrate that the most
portant for the job, or more highly valued, that valued abilities differ for each group. Leadership,
exceeded the mean average of each homogeneous strategy and planning, and negotiation abilities
group plus the standard deviation, as well as are most important for the occupational profile

28 IT Pro November/December 2009


of general directors and managers. Commitment cording to our literature review, it would be wise
to customer service and knowing how to com- for future research to contrast them with data
municate are highly valued for middle managers. coming from primary sources based on surveys
Finally, problem-solving skills and teamwork are in the ICT sector. Also, due to the limitations re-
the most important for the operating core. lated to the number of experts we consulted, our
On the other hand, the least valued skills co- conclusions are preliminary. A quantitative study
incide across the groups. In the management would help reinforce our conclusions.
Groups A and B, creativity is the least valued If we base European competitive advantage on
ability. Leadership and negotiating ability are less a knowledge-based economy, so that technologi-
significant for Groups B and C. Furthermore, for cal activities and knowledge are a real alternative
Group B, less importance is given to personal de- to the exodus of the mass production industry,
velopment, and for group C, the least critical skills perhaps we must more clearly establish what has
are persuasiveness and change management. to be contributed and, consequently, how we
should train our future IT professionals. If tech-
nical competence is a commodity, and character

T
he two main ways to maintain competitive is defined at an early age, we must establish, be-
advantage in dynamic markets such as ICT tween interpersonal skills and competency, what
are through innovation and strategic flex- will add value and give a greater return for Span-
ibility.26 Therefore, it seems reasonable to con- ish IT companies.
clude that workers in this sector should possess
abilities and skills consistent with flexibility and References
innovation, especially those with the most man- 1. C.K. Prahalad and G. Hamel, The Core Competence
agement responsibility. Intermediate-level man- of the Corporation, Harvard Business Rev., vol. 68,
agers must also be responsible for strategy and all May/June 1990, pp. 7991.
operational activity. 2. R.M. Grant, Prospering in Dynamically-Compet-
Acknowledging that premise and our previous itive Environments: Organizational Capability as
studies,27 the results we obtained in this study Knowledge Integration, Organization Science, vol. 7,
are somewhat surprising. Creativity plays an no. 4, 1996, pp. 375387.
important role in innovation and strategic flex- 3. D. Leonard-Barton, Wellsprings of Knowledge: Building
ibility, but it isnt highly valued. In fact, its con- and Sustaining the Sources of Innovation, Harvard Busi-
sidered the least important for the professional ness School Press, 1995, p. 334.
groups that have the most responsibility. 4. M. Castells, End of Millennium, The Information Age:
Again, its surprising that abilities related to in- Economy, Society and Culture, vol. III, 2nd ed., Black-
novation and strategic flexibility (such as change well, 2000.
management, knowledge management, and the 5. Lisbon European Council, Presidency Conclusions,
capacity to innovate) dont appear among the Mar. 2000; www.europarl.europa.eu/summits/
most valuable skills. Moreover, the notion that lis1_en.htm.
change management is least important for the 6. M. Castells, Ingenieros o antroplogos? [Engi-
workers in core operations is also unexpected. neers or Anthropologists?], La Vanguardia, 19 Mar.
We intentionally chose an expert panel for 2005.
this study because we believed it would help us 7. D.C. Mc Clelland, Talent and Society: New Perspectives in
forecast the tendency of the professional needs, the Identification of Talent, Van Nostrand, 1958, p. 275.
especially considering how changeable the ICT 8. C. Lvy-Leboyer, Gestin de las Competencias:
sector is. Therefore, we must acknowledge that Cmo Analizarlas, Cmo Evaluarlas, Cmo Desar-
our conclusions are based on the knowledge and rollarlas [Competences Management: How to Ana-
intuition of the specialists we consulted. There lyze, Evaluate, and Develop Them], Gestin 2000,
seems to be a clear contradiction between the 2003, p. 161.
panel of experts evaluations, those suggested by 9. C. McCauley, M. Lombardo, and C. Usher, Diag-
strategic theory, and the case that Castells makes nosing Management Development Needs: An Instru-
in his work. Because our results also seem to ment Based on How Managers Develop, J. Manage-
clearly contradict what was initially expected ac- ment, vol. 15, no. 3, 1989, pp. 389403.

computer.org/ITPro 29
Str ategic Pl anning

10. D. Bragg, Educator, Student and Employer Priorities sors in R&D Laboratories: Using Technical, People,
for Tech Prep Student Outcome, Office of Vocation- and Administrative Skills Effectively, IEEE Trans.
al and Adult Education, Univ. Calif., Berkeley, 1997; Eng. Management, vol. 51, no. 1, 2004, pp. 1930.
http://vocserve.berkeley.edu/abstracts/MDS-790/ 22. M.A. Soderstrand, The New Electrical and Com-
MDS-790.html. puter Engineering Curricula at University California,
11. J. Arnold et al., Students Perceptions of Compe- Davis, IEEE Trans. Education, vol. 37, no. 2, 1994, pp.
tence Development in Undergraduate Business- 136146.
Related Degrees, Studies in Higher Education, vol. 24, 23. J.C. Dueas, V. Burillo, and J.L. Ruiz, PAFET 4:
no. 1, 1999, pp. 4359. Perfiles profesionales TIC para la implantacin de
12. G. Kuh, The Other Curriculum: Out of Class Expe- servicios y contenidos digitales [Professional ICT
riences Associated with Student Learning and Per- Profiles to Implement Services and Digital Content],
sonal Development, J. Higher Education, vol. 66, no. 2, 2005; www.coit.es/index.php?op=estudios_215.
1995, pp. 123155. 24. H. Mintzberg, The Structuring of Organizations: A Syn-
13. N. Bennet, E. Dunne, and C. Carr, Patterns of Core tesis of the Research, Prentice-Hall, 1983, p. 561.
and Generic Skill Provision in Higher Education, 25. D. Gregory, G. Davis, and S. Peter, Porters (1980)
Higher Education, vol. 37, no. 1, 1999, pp. 7193. Generic Strategies as Determinants of Strategic
14. M.K. Badawy, Developing Managerial Skills in Engineers Group Membership and Organizational Perfor-
and Scientists, Succeeding as a Technical Manager, John mance, Academy of Management J., vol. 27, no. 3, 1984,
Wiley & Sons, 1995. pp. 467488
15. C. Cabello et al., Tipologa estratgica de Miles y 26. Z. Shaker and G. Gerard. Absorptive Capacity: A
Snow y factores competitivos: un anlisis emprico Review, Reconceptualization, and Extension, Acad-
[Miles and Snows Strategic Typology and Competitive emy of Management Rev., vol. 27, no. 2, 2002, pp. 185
Factors: An Empirical Analysis], Cuadernos de Economa 203.
y Direccin de la Empresa, no. 7, 2001, pp. 365381. 27. A. Llorens, X, Llins, and J. Olivella, Anlisis de las
16. Oficina dOrientaci i Inserci Laboral. Associaci competencias profesionales y de las estructuras orga-
dAmics de la UPC, Observatori del mercat de tre- nizativas en el entorno de las tecnologas de la infor-
ball 2001-2002, observatori de les empreses 2002, macin y la comunicacin [Analysis of Professional
memria AAUPC 2002: rendici de comptes [Labor Competences and Organizational Structures in the
Market Report 20012002, Labor Market Observa- ICT Sector], IX Congreso de Ingeniera de Organizacin,
tory 2002, AAUPC2002 Annual Report], 2002. David de la Fuente Garca, 2005, pp. 327328.
17. J. Casanovas et al., Libro Blanco sobre las Titulacio-
nes Universitarias de Informtica en el nuevo Espacio
Europeo de Educacin Superior del Proyecto EICE Ariadna Llorens-Garcia is an associate professor of man-
[Informatics Degrees in the New European Higher agement at the Technical University of Catalonia (UPC). Her
Education according to EICE Project], white paper, research is in innovation methodologies for education in the
ANECA, 2004, p. 347. knowledge society. Llorens has a degree in industrial engi-
18. Natl Agency for Quality Assurance and Accredita- neering from UPC. Contact her at ariadna.llorens@upc.edu.
tion (Spain), Libro blanco sobre ingeniera de tele-
comunicacin: documento final del Proyecto Ing- Xavier Llinas-Audet is a professor of economics and head
eniera de Telecomunicacin [Telecommunication of the doctorate program at the Technical University of
Engineering Project, Final Document], white paper, Catalonia (UPC). His research is on worker profiles in the
ANECA, 2005, p. 703. knowledge society. Llinas has a PhD in informatics from
19. Natl Agency for Quality Assurance and Accredita- UPC. Contact him at xavier.llinas@upc.edu.
tion (Spain), Libro Blanco para los futuros ttulos
de grado en el ambito de las Tecnologas de la In- Ferran Sabate is an associate professor of negotiation,
formacin y las Comunicaciones [Future ICT De- decision-making, and project management at Technical
grees], white paper, 2004; www.uc3m.es/CG/EEES/ University of Catalonia (UPC) and is coordinating the
azcorr33-4754.pdf. Telefonica-UPC team force in the tendencies and evolution
20. J. Liebowitz, W.W. Agresti, and G.R. Djavanshir, of the information society. His research is on e-commerce.
Communicating as IT Professionals, Prentice Hall, 2005. Sabate has a PhD in business administration from UPC.
21. R. Cordero, G.F. Farris, and N. Di Tomaso, Supervi- Contact him at ferran.sabate@upc.edu.

30 IT Pro November/December 2009

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen