Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Abstract
In the present paper, the elemental composition of wood ashes obtained by the combustion of wood in a fireplace was determined with the use
of ICP-MS and ICP-OES techniques. Wood ashes may find a potential application as deacidifying agents and soil conditioners, since they contain
calcium (in the form of CaCO3 and CaO), potassium (in the form of K2 SO4 and K2 CO3 ) and significant levels of micronutrients. However, if
applied to soil, it is important to assess the bioavailability of particular elements to plants. This process can be simulated by proper extraction
procedures.
Various species of wood were combusted in a firestove in a single-family house. The ashes underwent multielemental analyses with ICP-MS
Varian Ultra Mass 700 (Australia) and ICP-OES Vista-MPX from Varian (Australia) in order to determine the content of macro- and micronutrients
as well as toxic elements. Ashes were also extracted with solutions of 0.1 M NaNO3 and water in order to simulate the process of elemental transfer
from ash (used as soil conditioner) to soil solution and consequently to plants. Also, the environmental impact of ash supplementation to soil was
assessed in these experiments. Soil was supplemented with 020% of ash. After elution, the eluent underwent multielemental analysis by ICP-MS
and ICP-OES techniques to determine the content of macronutrients (P, K, Mg), micronutrients (Fe, Mn, Co, Mo, Zn, Cu and Ti) and toxic elements
(Hg, Pb, As and Cd).
It was shown that fireplace ashes can be applied for deacidification of homestead gardens. Ash may be described as a valuable soil conditioner
with N:P:K formula 0:1:3. It is concluded therefore that in order to achieve full fertilization, additional supplementation with nitrogen fertilizer
would be necessary.
2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Wood ashes; Macronutrients; Micronutrients; Toxic elements; Soil conditioners; Soil deacidification; ICP-MS; ICP-OES
0039-9140/$ see front matter 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.talanta.2006.05.061
H. Gorecka et al. / Talanta 70 (2006) 950956 951
Table 1 Table 2
The operating parameters of determination of elements by ICP-OES The operating parameters of determination of elements by ICP-MS
Method parameters Al Ca, Mg, Na, K P value Method parameters Value
For this reason, it would be advantageous to apply wood ash to potassium was the same as in potassium fertilizers, but phos-
soil in the area of acid rain deposition [4]. phorus was lower when compared with phosphorus fertilizers.
The composition of wood ash varies and depends on both: In the literature [3,11], there is inconsistency in the reports on
tree species and combustion conditions [1]. Wood ash is consid- the availability of magnesium. It is thought that bioavailability of
ered as a rich source of potassium, calcium, magnesium and micronutrients (Fe, Mn, Zn and Cu) is low due to increased pH.
phosphorus, as well as micronutrients. The average reported Wood ash is also a good source of boron [4]. It was found that
composition is: Ca 180 g kg1 , K 27.9 g kg1 , Mg 9.7 g kg1 , the level of organic contaminants (PAHs, PCBs, chlorobenzenes
P 4.2 g kg1 , N 0.6 g kg1 . It was found that the availability of and chlorophenols) was low [5,6].
Table 3
The comparison of recommended and information (*) values obtained for Polish Certified Reference Material for multielement trace analysis Fine Flye Ash
(CTA-FFA-1)
Element Certified concentration Obtained result Recovery (%)
Mean Uncertainity Mean Uncertainity
Literature reports that the supplementation of wood ash to soil ing rates of important plant nutrients were recorded (Mg, Fe and
should be moderate [9]. If applied according to limestone needs, other metals) and rapid release of alkali metals (K, Na) was
wood ash would be considered a valuable soil amendment, not observed.
causing additional soil pollution [4]. It is also advantageous to Mahmood et al. [12] investigated the effect of wood ash on
use wood ash as amendment to acidic forest soil [7,8] usually microbial activity, plant growth and nutrients uptake by ectomy-
applied in the dosage 17 Mg ha1 [9]. corrhizal spruce seedlings. The authors found that ash treatment
Hallenbarter et al. [3] studied the combined effect of wood ash had a highly significant positive effect on plant growth as well
and liquid fertilization on nutritional status and growth of Nor- as on shoot and root concentrations of K, Ca and P irrespective
way spruce in a forest. The authors observed increased growth, on mycorrhizal status. Zimmermann and Frey [1] examined
but no major shifts in the levels and ratios of nutrients were the effect of wood ash on soil and microbial respiration in
detected. Arvidsson et al. [9] examined effects of the appli- soils fertilized with wood ash in the dosage 8 Mg ha1 . Higher
cation of wood ash on ground vegetation of Norway spruce biomass and bioactivity of soil microorganisms were observed
in the dosage 3 Mg ha1 . No visible negative response to the after supplementation with ash due to increase of pH as well
ash application was recorded. Voundi Nkana et al. [10] studied as the level of nutrients, therefore increased mineralization of
chemical effects of wood ash on growth of rye grass in tropi- organic matter was detected. Perkiomaki and Fritze [13] studied
cal acid soils. Plants grown on ash-amended soil showed higher the effects of wood ash on boreal forest humus microbial
biomass production than plants grown on lime and control treat- community. The authors found that the supplementation with
ments. Steenari et al. [11] studied the release of mineral nutrients wood ash resulted in increase of microbial activity. Similar
and other species from soils amended with wood ash. Low leach- results were obtained by Yrjala et al. [14], who studied
Table 4
The elemental composition of ashes from various tree species and soils
Element Literature data Oak Oak II Birch Apple tree Ash Coniferous tree Soil
Etiegni et al. [17] Huang et al. [18]
Table 5
The comparison of the composition of wood ash and soil (a), extraction efficiency (b) and bioavailability (c) of elements from ash, soil and soil supplemented with
ash
(a)
Macronutrients and micronutrients the level of which Elements the level of which was Toxic elements the level of which was lower in ash
was higher in wood ash when comparing with soil similar in ash and in soil when comparing with soil
Macronutrients: K (15 times higher content in ash than Cr, Nb, La, Ti, Al, Pd, Ga Fe, Be, V, Hg (91 times), Zr (3 times), As (3 times), Ag (3
in soil), Ca (13 times), Mg (11 times), P (10 times), Sb, Ge, Sn, Mo times), Ce (2.5 times), U (2 times)
Na (2.5 times)
Micronutrients: Cd, Pb, Bi, Ni, Tl.
(b)
The extraction efficiency of The extraction efficiency of the The extraction of the following The extraction efficiency of the
the following elements following elements reached elements decreased with increase of following elements did not change
increased after addition of maximum at intermediate level of ash supplementation after addition of wood ash to soil
wood ash to soil ash supplementation (510%)
K, Sb, Mo, Rb, Ge, B, V, Ga, Al, Cd, Zr, Ni, Nb, Co, Zn, Mn, Pb, Ca, Mg, P, Tl As, Cu, Fe, Ti, Bi, Sn
Na, Cr, U La, Ce, Be, Rh
(c)
Availability of the following, Availability of the following, Availability of the following, The following elements were The following elements were
elements increased with elements decreased with the elements did not changed available from soil (extraction available from ash (the level
the increase of the level of increase of the level of ash with the increase of the level efficiency was higher than of supplementation 5%)
ash supplementation supplementation of ash supplementation 5%)
Co, Zr, U, Sb, V, Cu, Ce, La, Rb, Ti, Cr, Al, Ca, P, Mg, Bi Mo, K, B Mo, K, Sb, V, Ti, Rb, Cr Mo, K, Rb
Ge, Ti, Nb, Fe, Sn, Ga, As,
Pb, Cd, Pd, Ni, Mn, Zn
changes in Archaea from coniferous forest humus after ash soil extract and plant was 0.1 mol/l NaNO3 (average correlation
treatment. coefficient: 0.649). For this reason, in the present study this
The aim of this study was to investigate the applicability solution was used to estimate bioavailability of elements from
of wood ash as a soil conditioner and deacidifying agent. The soil, soil supplemented with wood ash and wood ash to plants.
composition of wood ash and bioavailability to plants of macro-,
micro- and toxic elements from soil supplemented with ash (as 2.1. Wood ash and soil
the function of the level of ash supplementation to soil that was
in the range 020%) to plants were estimated. Also, the environ- Wood ash was obtained through the combustion of oak wood
mental impact was simulated under laboratory conditions. In the in a single family house in a fireplace (Supra, France) having
present study, the level of 39 elements was tested in the studied the following characteristics: power 15 kW, the rate of wood
ash material as well as in leached extracts. The concentration combustion was typical (0.060.07 m3 wood day1 ). After the
of many elements was very low and therefore could be detected combustion, the ash was collected, grinded and mixed. Soil used
only with the use of the very sensitive methods of ICP-MS and in the experiment was standard commercially available garden
also ICP-OES.
soil that was not enriched with neither organic nor mineral fer- the concentration of the majority of elements in the solution of
tilizers. The ash was introduced to the soil in quantities ranging 0.1 M NaNO3 after extraction and in plants have been previously
from 0 to 20%. The mixture underwent microwave digestion reported [15].
and afterwards the content of macronutrients, micronutrients
and toxic elements was determined. The effect of ash supple- 2.3. Analytical methods
mentation on plants was also studied by germination tests that
were performed on Petri dishes with the use of radish seeds. Ger- The samples of ash and soil underwent microwave diges-
mination efficiency was calculated as the fraction of seeds that tion by samples decomposition in Teflon bombs with the use
germinated. Also, the composition of wood ashes originating of Milestone MLS-1200 MEGA microwave digestion system.
from other tree species (birch, apple tree, ash tree and conifer- For digestion of 0.1 g ash and 0.5 g soil, a mixture of ultra pure
ous tree) was determined. concentrated acids (2.5 ml of nitric acid and 7.5 ml of hydrochlo-
ric acid from Merck) was used. Afterwards, the samples were
2.2. Elution diluted with demineralized water to the volume 75 ml. The
extracts were analyzed directly, without further digestion.
The ash and the mixture of ash and soil underwent the pro- The digested samples of ash, soil mixed with ash, as well as
cess of extraction with 0.1 M NaNO3 solution and water. The solutions of the extractants after elution underwent multielemen-
composition of the eluents obtained after extraction (4 h) of 10 g tal analyses with the use of plasma spectrometry: macronutrients
of ashes in 100 ml of extractant was determined with the use and Al were analyzed with the use of ICP-OES Varian Vista
of both: ICP-OES and ICP-MS. The eluents were analyzed in MPX (Australia) (Ca, K, Mg, Na, P and Al). The concen-
order to collect data on elemental solubilities in solutions consid- tration of micronutrients and toxic elements (except Hg) was
ered to be commonly used extraction solutions and to determine determined with ICP-MS Varian Ultra Mass 700 (Australia).
the level of bioavailability to plants. High correlations between Mercury was analyzed with Mercury analyzer AMA 254 (the
Fig. 2. Elution of elements from soil supplemented with ash with water.
H. Gorecka et al. / Talanta 70 (2006) 950956 955
operating parameters: sample mass: 0.2 g, drying time: ash and differences (Table 4). Also, differences in the composition of
soil, 10 s, extract, 50 s, decomposition, 200 s, waiting: 60 s), wood ash originating from the same tree species were observed.
atomic absorption spectrometer (Czech Republic). The operat- The average composition of wood ash was compared with the
ing parameters for ICP-OES are shown in Table 1 and ICP-MS composition of the soil to which it was introduced. The com-
in Table 2. The instruments were calibrated with the use of parison of ash and soil content is presented in Table 5a. It was
multielement standard solutions prepared from single elements found that wood ash is a source of macro- and micronutrients.
standard solutions (Ultra Scientific ICP standards 1000 and The level of toxic elements was found to be similar. This data
10,000 g ml1 ). The analytical process was validated by the support the theory that wood ash if supplemented to soil is a
use of an ash matrix standard. Polish Certified Reference Mate- rich source of macro- and micronutrients. It contains also some
rial for multielement trace analysis Fine Flye Ash (CTA-FFA-1) toxic elements, however since wood ash affects soil pH it would
from Institute of Nuclear Chemistry and Technology (Poland) probably decrease bioavailability of elements (supplied by ash
was analyzed and the comparison of obtained results and certi- and also present in soil) to plants.
fied concentrations is shown in Table 3. Uncertainty and recov- When introducing wood ash to soil, it is important to estimate
ery were calculated according to international standards [16]. the appropriate dosage. High dosages of ash might be dangerous
to plants and the microbial community, due to pH changes. In
3. Results and discussion the present study, the garden soil was supplemented with ash in
the quantity 020%. We examined the effect of ash level sup-
Many authors report [1,4] that the composition of wood ash plementation on germination efficiency of radish seeds (Fig. 1).
varies in dependent on not only tree species, but also on local We also studied the effect of ash content in soil on elemental
conditions (i.e. soil content) on which a tree was growing. In the transfer to the aqueous environment in order to assess the poten-
present study, the analysis of wood ash from various tree species tial transfer of toxic elements to ground and surface waters, as
(oak, birch, apple tree, ash tree and coniferous tree) showed large well as to determine the loss of fertilizer components: macro-
Fig. 3. Elution of elements from soil supplemented with ash with 0.1 M NaNO3 .
956 H. Gorecka et al. / Talanta 70 (2006) 950956
and microelements (Fig. 2). Also the bioavailability of elements less than 2% and in the case of Pb less than 1%. Bioavailability
to plants was investigated (Fig. 3). tests showed that the level of ash supplementation did not affect
The level of ash supplementation had a substantial effect on the availability of K. Bioavailability of the remaining macronu-
seeds germination. It was found that ash supplementation at the trients (Ca, Mg and P) was greatly reduced. The availability of
level 15% did not have strong adverse effect on germination of the majority of micronutrients and toxic elements decreased.
radish. Introduction of 20% ash resulted in almost total growth This showed that ash acted as a fertilizer that released nutrients
inhibition (Fig. 1). slowly. This also showed reduced environmental impact, since
The environmental impact of ash supplementation was stud- nutrients were not eluted to ground and surface waters. By
ied by extraction with water (Fig. 2). Extraction of ash, soil and taking into consideration germination efficiency of plants, the
soil supplemented with ash was performed. We found that the dosage of ash should not exceed 5%. Therefore, we concluded
level of ash supplementation had an effect on elements transfer to that the safe level of ash supplementation, when taking into
water (Fig. 2). The results of experiments on the extraction effi- consideration germination efficiency, bioavailability to plants
ciency are presented in Table 5b. Bioavailability of elements to and environmental safety would be on the level lower than
plants was examined through the extraction with 0.1 M NaNO3 . 5%.
Different results were obtained when comparing with the extrac- Summarizing, our data showed that it is possible to use ash
tion with water. Availability of elements is discussed in Table 5c. obtained by heating a single family house (annual ash production
150 kg ash year1 ).
4. Conclusions
References
In order to investigate the theoretical bioavailability of ele-
ments from soil and soil supplemented with ash, extraction [1] S. Zimmermann, B. Frey, Soil Biol. Biochem. 34 (2002) 1727.
procedures were also utilized. The environmental impact of [2] M. Narodoslawsky, I. Obernberger, J. Hazard. Mater. 50 (1996) 157.
[3] D. Hallenbarter, W. Landolt, J.B. Bucher, J.P. Schutz, Fostw. Cbl 121 (2002)
elemental transfer to ground and surface water was also inves- 240.
tigated. The level of 39 elements was determined in wood ash, [4] A. Demeyer, J.C. Voundi Nkana, M.G. Verloo, Bioresour Technol. 77
soil and extracts using the analytical techniques of both ICP- (2001) 287.
OES and ICP-MS. [5] A.V. Someshwar, J. Environ. Qual. 25 (1996) 962.
The experimental results showed that the supplementation of [6] E.D. Vance, J. Environ. Qual. 25 (1996) 937.
[7] J.S. Kahl, I.J. Fernandez, L.E. Rustad, J. Peckenham, J. Environ. Qual. 25
wood ash to soil resulted in increase of the levels of macroele- (1996) 220.
ments, microelements and toxic elements, the solubility in [8] K.J. Meiwes, Water Air Soil Pollut. 85 (1995) 143.
water and availability to plants was low. Wood ash was found [9] H. Arvidsson, T. Vestin, H. Lundkvist, Forest Ecol. Manage. 161 (2002)
to be a rich source of macronutrients: the concentration of K, 75.
Ca, Mg and P was 1015 times higher than in soil. Also, wood [10] J.C. Voundi Nkana, A. Demeyer, M.G. Verloo, Bioresour. Technol. 63
(1998) 251.
ash supplied micronutrients. Over 15 times higher levels of Mn, [11] B.M. Steenari, L.G. Karlsson, P. Lindqvist, Biomass Bioenergy 16 (1999)
Zn and B were detected. The level of some toxic elements was 119.
higher (Cd, Pb), but the concentration of other (Hg, As, U) was [12] S. Mahmood, R.D. Finlay, A.M. Fransson, H. Wallander, FEMS Microbiol.
lower when compared with soil. Although ash was the source Ecol. 43 (2003) 121.
of various elements it did not mean that they were readily [13] J. Perkiomaki, H. Fritze, Soil Biol. Biochem. 34 (2002) 1343.
[14] K. Yrjala, R.J. Katainen, S. German, S. Ulla, R.N. Aimo, Soil Biol.
available to plants and environment. We found that only potas- Biochem. 36 (2004) 199.
sium showed high solubilities in water, unlike the remaining [15] K. Chojnacka, A. Chojnacki, H. Gorecka, H. Gorecki, Sci. Total Environ.
macronutrients (Ca, Mg and P), the solubility of which sig- 337 (2005) 175.
nificantly decreased. The solubility of micronutrients supplied [16] Eurachem Guide. The fitness for purpose of analytical methods: A labora-
by the ash: Mn and Zn increased at intermediate levels of ash tory guide to method validation and related topics, 1998.
[17] L. Etiegni, A.G. Campbell, R.L. Mahler, Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal.
supplementation and decreased at higher levels. The effect on 22 (1991) 243.
boron solubility was reverse. The solubility of toxic elements [18] H. Huang, A.G. Campbell, R. Folk, R.L. Mahler, Commun. Soil Sci. Plant
supplied by ash (Cd and Pb) was very low: in the case of Cd Anal. 23 (1992) 25.