1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

ACADEMIKE
Lawctopus' Law Journal + Knowledge Center (ISSN: 2349-9796)

ABOUT SUBMISSIONS ISSUES ADVISORS

STUDENT EDITORS CONTACT

Need For Uniform Civil Code

November13,2015byadmin LeaveaComment

YudhajeetSinha

1.CurrentStatusofUniformCivilCodeinIndia

1.TheviewofIndianConstitution

ThetermUniformCivilCodeinfersthesamesetofcommonlawstooversee
all people groups independent of their Religion, Caste and tribe. The regions
securedunderitaretheLawsidentifiedwithMarriage,Divorce,Adoption,and
InheritanceandsecuringandAdministrationofproperty.UniformCivilCode
isanorderuponthestateunderarticle44oftheConstitutionasmandateruleof
state arrangement. As it is given under Article 37 of the Constitution that
mandate standards of state arrangement are not enforceable by the Court of

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 1/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

Law.Anywaythisdoesnotunderminethecriticalnessoftheorderstandards.
JustafterIndependencetheCircumstancesweresuchthatitwasnotachievable
toforceanUniformCivilCodeonthenationals.Thatisthereasonithasbeen
securedundertheorderguidelineofstateapproach.

1.2.TheviewofSupremeCourt

TheSupremeCourtsmournaboutthenationsdisappointmenttoembracean
uniformcommoncodeasurgedbyArticle44hasresuscitatedacivilargument
thatwillassuredlynotagainbestowedawayfromplainview.Thewholeissue
has shockingly been contorted and misled from its exceptionally beginning.
Ideologues have deliberately utilized it as a stick with which to beat the
minorities, and Muslims specifically, through the risk of a majoritarian
homogenizing guideline dangerous of the valuable character markers seen in
thecurrentdifferingqualitiesofindividuallaws.

The bogey that an uniform common code (UCC) fundamentally involves the
annulment of individual laws needs to be let go. This is just not really. The
presenceoftheIndianSpecialMarriageActorIndianSuccessionActhasnot
stifledindividuallawsinthisrespect.Inactuality,theSpecialMarriageAct,an
uniform marriage code for all Indians, was backward altered in 1976 to give
that Hindus wedding under it would keep on being legislated by the Hindu
SuccessionAct.

Foreverycontra,theSupremeCourtsmostrecentobiteronthetemperancesof
anuniformcommoncodehappensinadecidingthatstrikesdowncertainunfair
procurements in the Indian Succession Act banning Christians from giving
propertytoreligiousandaltruistictrusts.Oncemore,Goasuniformcommon
code, a welcome legacy of Portuguese frontier principle, now joyfully exists
together with an assortment of individual codes accessible to supporters of
specificreligions.Anyhowitmakesaccessibleanalternativeandunderlinesthe
point that an uniform common code and individual laws dont speak to an
either/ordecisionandthattheonedoesnotorderthedevastationoftheother.

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 2/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

2.StatusandRoleofUniformCivilCode

2.1.StatusofUniformCivilCode

TherearefivewidesetsofindividuallawsinIndiafocusedaroundthereligions
declared by distinctive groups. Hindu law administers all Hindus, including
Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs. Muslim law applies to Muslims, Christian law
legislates Christians, and Parsee law applies to the Parsees. Jews have their
individual law. These individual laws spread property and individual matters
like marriage, separation, support, reception and legacy. The diverse laws are
overseeing these angles distinctively for distinctive groups in India.
Subsequently, the laws administering marriage, legacy or separation among
HindusarenotquitethesameasthoserelatingtoMuslimsorChristiansetci.

2.2.RoleofUniformCivilCode

Uniformcommoncodeshouldsupplanttheindividuallawsfocusedaroundthe
scriptures and traditions of each one significant religious group in the nation,
withatypicalsetoverseeingeachresidentinIndia.Theselawsarerecognized
from open law and spread marriage, separation, legacy, upkeep, guardianship
and appropriation. Article 44 of the Directive Principles in India sets the
executionofanuniformcommoncodeallthroughthenationasobligationof
the State. Article 44 says: The State should try to secure for the natives an
uniformcommoncodeallthroughthedomainofIndia.Thedestinationofthis
article is to impact an incorporation of India by bringing all groups into a
typicalstagewhichisatpresentareadministeredbyindividuallawsandwhich
dontstructurethequintessenceofanyreligion.Article37makesclearthatthe
mandate standards should not be enforceable by any court. By the by, they
are key in the legislation of the nation. The Supreme Court has
communicated for the institution of an uniform common code in the Shah
BanoiicaseandtheSarlaMudgaliiicase.TheSupremeCourtinSarlaMudgal
judgmenthadwatchedthattheGovernmentwouldbedecentlyencouragedto
depend the obligation to the Law Commission to realize the extensive

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 3/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

enactmentinkeepingwithadvancedideaofhumanrights.However,noneof
theseremarksaretyingontheofficialorthecouncilanddontsumtorequests.
Bestcasescenario,theypushsomeethicalweightontheIndianstatetomove
towardsforminganuniformcommoncode.

As ladies associations and others have over and again called attention to,
individual laws administering distinctive groups in India have a typical
gimmicktheyareallsexpredispositioned.Theindividuallawsareintended
toholdladiesperpetuallyunderthepredominanceandcontrolofmen.Ladies
experience numerous troubles and experience extreme trauma in matters
concerning their marriage, separation and legacy. Polygamy, renunciation,
triple separations are simplyacoupleofsamplesto demonstratethe potential
outcomes of badgering ladies. Indian ladies are formally conceded balance in
political rights through the Indian Constitution. Because of the distinctive
individuallaws,ladiesexperienceimbalance,hardshipandsavagery.Sexissues
needtobetendedtogenuinely.Thereisaneedtochangetheindividuallaws
andrealizeanuniformcommoncodetoguaranteeequityinthemiddleofmen
andladiesaswellastoachievesexequity.Intheeventthatitisexecuteditwill
establish the framework for ladies to overcome numerous social indecencies
like endowment framework, polygamy and so on which makes a lady feel
mediocreandcorruptediv.

An alternate issue, the individual laws are the primary driver of shared clash
amongindividuals.ThenonattendanceofanUniformCivilCodegoesagainst
theideaofequitywhichisoneoftheessentialprinciplesofourConstitution.
The distinctive individual laws for diverse religions are undermining the
believability of the common ethos of India. An Uniform Civil Code will
likewise streamline legitimate techniques included with the matters
administered by individual laws. It will likewise go far in advancing the
reasons for secularism, correspondence and national combination. It will
likewise make the partition of the State from the religion more finish and
compelling.

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 4/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

3.ReasonswhyUniformCivilCodeisneededanditsfunctions.

3.1.UnificationofIndia

AnuniformcommoncodewillhelpinincorporatingIndiamorethanithasever
been since freedom. A great deal of the ill will is brought about by special
treatmentbythelawofspecificreligiousgroupsandthiscanbedodgedbyan
uniform common code. It will help in bringing each Indian, in spite of his
standing,religionortribe,underonenationalcommonimplicitrules.

3.2.MitigationofVoteBankPolitics

An uniform common code will likewise help in diminishing vote bank

legislative issues that most political gatherings enjoy amid each race. In the
event that all religions are secured under the same laws, the lawmakers will
have less to offer to specific minorities in return of their vote. Not having an
uniform common code is impeding to genuine popular government and that
needstochange.

3.3.Solveproblemsofpersonallaws

Thedifferentindividuallawsareessentiallyanescapeclausetobeabusedby
the individuals who have the force. Our panchayats keep on giing judgments
thatareagainstourconstitutionandwedontmakeamove.Humanrightsare
abusedthroughhonorkillingsandfemalefoeticidethroughoutournation.By
permitting individual laws we have constituted a substitute legal framework
thatstillworksonagreatmanyyearsoldqualities.Anuniformcommoncode
wouldchangethat.

3.4.PresenceofUniformCivilCodeineverymodernnation.

Anuniformcommoncodeistheindicationofadvanceddynamiccountry.Itis
a sign that the country has moved far from rank and religious governmental

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 5/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

issues. While our financial development has been the most astounding on the
planet our social development has not happened whatsoever. Truth be told it
may be right to say that socially and socially we have corrupted to a point
wherewearenotcurrentorcustomary.Anuniformcommoncodewillhelpthe
general public make headway and take India towards its objective of turning
intoacreatedcountry.

3.5.Endowwomenwithfurtherrights

Anuniformcommoncodewilllikewisehelpinenhancingthestateofladiesin
India. Our general public is greatly patriarchal and misanthropic and by
permitting old religious principles to keep on representing the family life we
aresentencingallIndianladiestooppressionandabuse.Anuniformcommon
code will help in changing these age old conventions that have no spot in
todays general public where we do comprehend that ladies ought to be dealt
withreasonablyandgivenequivalentrights.

3.6.MetingoutofequaltreatmenttowardseveryIndian

At this moment we have individual laws focused around specific religions,

whichimpliesthatwhileMuslimscanweddifferenttimesinIndia,aHinduor
aChristianwillbeindictedfordoinglikewise.Thisdoesntappearasthough
correspondence to me. All the laws identified with marriage, legacy, family,
arriveandsoforthoughttobeequivalentforallIndians.Thisisthebestwayto
guaranteethatallIndiansaredealtwithsame.

3.7.PromotionofSecularism

PresentlywhatwehaveinIndiaisspecificsecularismwhichimpliesthatina
few territories we are common and in others we arent. An uniform common
codeimpliesthatallresidentsofIndianeedtotakeafterthesamelawswhether
theyareHindusorMuslimsorChristiansorSikhs.Thissoundsreasonableand
mainstreamtome.Anuniformcommoncodedoesntmeanitwillrestrictthe

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 6/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

opportunityofindividualstotakeaftertheirreligion,itsimplyimpliesthateach
individualwillbedealtwiththesame.

iWhy India Needs Uniform Civil Code, Daily Excelsior, available at,
http://www.dailyexcelsior.com/indianeeduniformcivilcode,lastseenon21st
October,2014.

iiMohd.AhmedKhanv.ShahBanoBegum,AIR1985SCC556.

iiiSarlaMudgalv.UnionofIndiaandOthers,AIR1995SCC635.

ivWhy India Needs Uniform Civil Code, Daily Excelsior, available at,
http://www.dailyexcelsior.com/indianeeduniformcivilcode,lastseenon21st
October,2014.

Youmayalsolike:

SCOPEAND ALTERNATE VALUEOF DIVORCE

EXTENTOF DISPUTE RELIGION UNDER
AMENDMENTRESOLUTIONINHUMAN HINDULAW
OF UNDERTHE LIFE
PLEADINGS CODEOF
CIVIL
Scopeand PROCEDURE
Alternate ValueOf DivorceUnder
Extentof Dispute ReligionIn HinduLaw
Amendmentof Resolution HumanLife
Pleadings undertheCode
ofCivil
Procedure

LEGAL INHERENT IRRETRIEVABLE

UNIFORM
FRAMEWORKPOWERS BREAKDOWNMETHODOF
GOVERNING OFTHE OFMARRIAGE
MAINTENANCE:
ADOPTION COURT ASOCIO
LAWSIN UNDERTHE LEGALSTUDY
INDIA CPC
Legal Inherent Irretrievable UniformMethod
Framework Powersofthe Breakdownof ofMaintenance:
Governing Courtunderthe Marriage ASocioLegal
AdoptionLaws CPC Study
http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 7/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

inIndia

AdsbyShareaholic

FiledUnder:Constitutional&AdministrativeLaw,FamilyLaw
TaggedWith:uniformcivilcode

Leave a Reply
Youremailaddresswillnotbepublished.Requiredfieldsaremarked*

Name*

Email*

Website

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 8/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

Comment

YoumayusetheseHTMLtagsandattributes:<ahref=""title="">
<abbrtitle=""><acronymtitle=""><b><blockquotecite="">
<cite><code><deldatetime=""><em><i><qcite="">
<strike><strong>

POSTCOMMENT

SEARCH

CATEGORIES

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 9/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

DirectTaxation
ADR
Arbitration&ConciliationAct
BankingLaw
Bankruptcy&Insolvency
BiotechnologyLaw
BusinessLaws
CivilProcedureCode&Law
ofLimitation
CodeofCriminalProcedure

competition
CompetitionLaw

Constitutional&
AdministrativeLaw
ConsumerProtectionAct

ContractLaw
Copyright

CorporateFinance
CorporateGovernance

CriminalLaw
CriminologyandVictimology

EconomicOffences
Economics

EnvironmentalLaw
FamilyLaw

GenderandLaw
HumanitarianandRefugee
Law
http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 10/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

Humanities

IndianEvidenceAct
IndianPenalCode

InformationTechnologyLaw
InsuranceLaw

IntellectualPropertyRights
InternationalCommercial
Arbitration

InternationalEnvironmental
Law
InternationalHumanRights
Law
InternationalLabourLaws
InternationalLaw

InternationalOrganization
InternationalTradeLaw

InternationalTreaty
Arbitration
InterpretationofStatutes
InvestmentLaw
IPRinPharmaIndustry

Jurisprudence
LabourLaw
LandAcquisition
LawandEconomics

LawoftheSea
LawofTorts
LegalHistory
http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 11/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

LegalMethods

LegalServicesAuthorities
Act/LokAdalats
MaritimeLaw

Media&CyberLaw
Mediation

Merger&Acquisition
OffencesAgainstChild&
JuvenileOffence

Patents
Penology&Victimology
PoliticalScience
PrivateInternationalLaw

ProbationandParole
ProceduralLaws
PropertyLaw
PublicInternationalLaw

SecuritiesLaw
Sociology
SpaceLaw
SpecialContract

TaxLaw
Trademarks
Uncategorized
WhiteCollarCrime

Women&CriminalLaw

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 12/13
1/30/2016 uniformcivilcode

RECENT POSTS

ScopeofEnforcementof
DPSPs
ContractsandQuasi
Contracts
Thesettingredsunofdark
water

MedicalNegligence
ComparisonOfTrial
ProcedureBetweenIndian
CourtsAndFranchCourts

Copyright2016GenesisFrameworkWordPressLogin

http://www.lawctopus.com/academike/needuniformcivilcode/ 13/13