Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Mr. Rhodes
23 February 2017
An uncomfortable silence fills the bare waiting room as a young girl sits listening to the
ticking of the clock, wearily watching the large door across from her. Fiddling with her hands
and tapping her foot anxiously on the leg of her chair, her head throbs with worries. Suddenly,
the doorknob turns and a warm smile brightens not only the dim psychiatrist office waiting room,
but the girls anguish. A painless smile crosses her face as she rises and follows the woman into
a back room. Without saying a word, the woman fills the girl with a sense of comfort, a feeling
that maybe she will finally feel better. The doctors ability to offer a comfortable and positive
environment from the initial interaction makes the process of treating the young girl much easier
for both the psychiatrist and the patient. A career specializing in child psychiatry requires the
ability to have a keen sense of how to communicate with minors, as well as an understanding of
how to gain the patients trust, and uncover a diagnosis that will provide a happy and secure
In a world without psychiatry, the concept of mental illness does not exist. In the early
1800s, the method of handling those whose minds differed from societys idea of normal,
suffered many hardships throughout their lives. In early 1800s Ireland, individuals deemed
mad often ended up living the rest of their lives imprisoned inside a five foot deep hole within
their homes, covered by bars to prevent them from standing up (Shorter 1-2). In other areas of
Thomas 2
Europe, psychiatrists told stories of patients found chained up, restrained in their homes, or
bound to a stake in public places such as workhouses or poorhouses. While exposed to the
community, the public often ridiculed the mentally disabled, creating awful sayings or rhymes to
antagonize them (3). Throughout a significant portion of history, individuals with mental
illnesses or disabilities lived under unfortunate circumstances. A majority of those labeled mad
received unjust treatment from their families, who rarely strayed from conventional societal
views and seldom offered any level of acceptance or assistance. This led to many mentally
unstable individuals roaming the city streets as the village idiots, most of whom actually
suffered from schizophrenia or mental retardation since birth (1-2). When asylums finally gained
credibility in the Middle Ages, wrongful treatment escalated. One of the oldest psychiatric
hospitals in Europe, Bethlem, stands as a prime example. Founded in the 13th century, this small
hospice center, housing only six insane men, continued to develop further in the following
centuries. Eventually, this hospital developed the name Bedlam, also meaning chaotic
madness. Scholars recount horrible conditions that occurred within these walls, where neglected
patients laid manacled to the floor in gruesome conditions (5). Most psychiatric hospitals at this
time simply housed the insane, without attempting any forms of treatment or recovery.
Over the centuries, many forms of treatment and medication came into play in the world
of psychiatry. The first appearence of medicine to treat the mentally ill in the 1800s began with
John Haslams use of laxatives to cure insanity. Haslam and many others at the time believed
that toxins within the colon induced insanity, in turn making laxatives a cure to purge their
systems (Shorter 196). Other new medicines included the use of opium, morphine, and chloral as
hypnotic (196-199). Eventually, in an attempt to not only sedate but subdue symptoms, Charles
Locock introduced bromine into the equation (200). By the late 1800s and early 1900s, bromine
became the most widely used sedative in public asylums, due to its reasonable price and success
rates (200). In April, 1938, Ugo Cerletti took inhumane treatments to a new and disturbing level
with the introduction of electroshock therapy (218). After years of using animals to test the
effects of giving electric shock to the brain, Cerletti and his assistants discovered that placing
electrodes on the patients temples achieved the most practical results (219). With a wide range
between convulsive and lethal doses to the subjects brain, more experimentation began to take
place (218-219). On April 15, 1938, the first human attempt took place on a 39-year-old engineer
from Milan, who ultimately slipped into an epileptic fit and ceased breathing after experimenters
turned the machine up to over 90 volts of electricity (219). Once the patient finally let out a deep
sigh after 48 seconds, Cerletti and his team confirmed their hypothesis that electrical currents
possess the potential to safely produce convulsions in humans (220). After 11 treatments of
electroshock therapy, the patient showed much improvement, appearing well even a month after
discharge (221). Electroshock therapy soon became the first independent therapy method utilized
by psychiatrists, replacing the roles of neurologists in treating mental illnesses with techniques
such as spa therapy for nerves (224). At around the same time, another form of treatment
surfaced. While experimenting unsafely with the lobes of the brain, psychiatrist Gottlieb
Burckhardt introduced a new surgery that later became known as lobotomy (227). By destroying
a certain part of a human brains lobe, this treatment tamed wild patients who continuously posed
problems to psychiatrists trying to manage them. However, as a result of the the procedure,
patients lost much of their judgement, as well as control of many of their cognitive, social, and
Thomas 4
motor abilities (225-227). Considering the widespread uneasiness of this method by the
psychiatry community, lobotomy quickly disappeared just as quickly as it came into the world of
mental illness (228-229). Although still vaguely present even today, these harsh treatments began
At this time in history, Sigmund Freuds views caused much controversy within the
community, as they still do to this day. Freud began his work with the human mind in a similar
manner to many other doctors at the time. Working as a neurologist, Freud utilized hydrotherapy,
electroshock therapy, hypnosis, and dietetic therapy (Shorter 146). In order to convey a sense of
care throughout the treatment process, Freud shifted to psychoanalysis. Through communication
between the doctor and patient, psychoanalysis created the belief that the patient received
sufficient emotional care. Through his work with psychoanalysis, Freud developed a theory that
repressed sexual impulses pose as the driving forces of neurosis (152). Although many do not
agree with this, Freud still remains one of the most influential public figures within psychiatry
and psychoanalysis.
When considering education options for pursuing a career in the field of psychiatry, the
appropriate path may not appear clearly. Many educational and professional opportunities lead to
careers in psychiatry, but the most beneficial course of study includes focusing on natural
school. Those pursuing careers in psychiatry must attend medical school following the
acquisition of a bachelor's degree in order to have the authority to prescribe medicine (Fukami).
In general, the majority of colleges and universities in the United States offer psychology and
pre-medical majors, making the cost, reputation, and campus activities some of the main factors
Thomas 5
in deciding which school to attend. Based on this, some schools that make the best fit for
potential psychiatrists in the south include the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
(UNC), the College of Charleston, and Elon University. The differing sizes and semblances of
these colleges offer a multitude of opportunities for an array of students. UNC, for instance, has
a large student body of almost 30,000 students, the College of Charleston with almost 12,000,
and Elon University with approximately 6,500 students (College Search: SuperMatch).
Although Elon offers a smaller, more intimate atmosphere, the tuition poses as an issue for many
applicants. With a tuition averaging slightly over $31,000, compared to UNCs in-state tuition of
a little over $8,000, the differences in price may sway families when making their decision
(College Search: SuperMatch). In the case of the College of Charleston, in-state tuition costs
about $11,000, however the in-state and out-of-state costs differ; students living out-of-state,
such as in North Carolina, pay $28,000. Besides the cost and majors offered, the location of the
school and the acceptance rate play a big role in the decision-making process as well. UNC and
the College of Charleston sit in the middle of small urban areas, in comparison to Elon
University, where suburbs and small towns surround the campus. As far as acceptance rates,
UNC becomes more of a reach, considering the acceptance rate of only 28 percent (College
Search: SuperMatch). The College of Charleston, on the other hand, accepts 78 percent of
applicants and Elon University accepts 54 percent (College Search: SuperMatch). Considering
all of these factors, the decision of which college to attend lies within the individual students
After leaving college to enter the world of psychiatry, a physician must feel comfortable
working closely with patients struggling with conditions such as anxiety, depression, stress,
Thomas 6
suicidal thoughts, or mental disabilities. Persisting as some of the main challenges within this
profession, these aspects require an extensive knowledge and understanding. In order to obtain
this knowledge, psychiatrists must identify relationships between different factors affecting the
minds of young individuals. The World Health Organization (WHO) report Health for the
Worlds Adolescents, identified that the main cause of both illness and disability in youth from
the ages of 10 to 19 stems from depression, while the third mortality cause within this age group
comes from suicide. These statistics support other studies proving how 40-50 percent of these
cases result from stressors and negative or traumatic events (Ciubara et al 398). Based on this
conclusion, results indicate that a correlation between depression and anxiety may exist,
considering they coexisted in 30 percent of the cases presented (399). Although anxiety does not
contrast, depression has visible signs such as anger bursts, social withdrawal, and feelings of
sadness or helplessness (399). Currently, a large percentage of children and adolescents remain
underdiagnosed due to the current staffing crisis in the psychiatric field of medicine, proving that
the diagnosis and treatment protocols require assistance (401). In some cases, psychiatrists must
deal with young patients who have gone through traumatic experiences. Children who have
experienced trauma often hesitate to talk about how they feel. Indicators of post-traumatic stress
include fear, anxiety, emotional pain, pessimism, nightmares, fatigue, difficulty concentrating,
and a sense of loss. In order to overcome these feelings, children must go through stages of
emotional recovery to move past their traumatic experiences, making trust crucial between the
psychiatrist and patient (Cole 90-92). The patient may consider opening up about their
experiences voluntarily if presented with a safe and comfortable environment. Whether through
Thomas 7
behavior to determine the best course of treatment. Varying forms of communication may also
help the child lighten their emotional load without even realizing it (94). With the ability to make
a child feel safe and comfortable when talking about difficult topics, followed by watching their
progress, a career in psychiatry provides both difficult and rewarding experiences for individuals
they will need to deal with disturbing and heartbreaking situations. Although rewarding, this job
also exhausts individuals emotionally, resulting in the dwindling number of people pursuing the
career. One must have the ability to set feelings aside and not get caught up in the emotions
evoked by the job. With a thin line between helping a patient and becoming too emotionally
involved, this job requires a special type of person who realizes the road to recovery does not
always end with them, even though they may help the young patients take their first steps to
patching their physical and emotional scars. Setting negative factors aside, a career in psychiatry
also boasts exciting experiences and opportunities. Within this field, a doctor will walk into the
office never knowing what the day will hold. The multitude of possibilities make each day an
adventure in which the psychiatrists get to explore the human mind. Considering the fact that
each client comes with their own issues, a psychiatrist never stops learning or encountering new
situations (Fukami). With the right mindset, a job in child psychiatry poses as a journey to better
To provide a sense of comfort to a child, a psychiatrist must gain the patient's trust, and
analyze how they speak and move in order to come up with an appropriate diagnosis. The
Thomas 8
younger the patient, the more difficulty the individual may experience when trying to
communicate how they feel. Because of this, child psychiatrists must invent creative ways to
examine and analyze a childs behavior. This may include methods that seem strange for
diagnosing an illness, such as drawing pictures, playing with puppets, or telling stories (Pierini
112). Depending on how the patient draws a picture or reacts to a story, certain responses
provide an idea of how to come up with a diagnosis, and allows the therapist to understand how
the childs mind works. Playing with the children allows the therapist to observe their behavior
within a controlled setting, while analyzing how their responses may shift (Pierini 111). Before a
patient gets to this point however, they must trust their therapist. By providing a positive and
empathetic attitude, as well as acknowledging and making an effort to listen closely to the patient
from the very beginning, children will more likely let a therapist deeper into their mind, no
matter the means of communication (Hartzell et al 178). Playing with children in order to
analyze their behavior and come up with a psychiatric diagnosis makes this field unique
compared to other careers, considering how creativity plays a significant role in the treatment
process.
makes sense that pets might soon become a more common form of therapy in situations dealing
with mental health and disabilities. Many children do not know exactly how to react when
stepping into a psychiatrists office, making first impressions extremely important. The first 10
to 15 minutes of the appointment become critical in determining how the rest of the visit will go
(Hartzell et al 177-178). With evidence depicting positive interactions with animals benefit
people by creating a sense of comfort and happiness through the release of endorphins, including
Thomas 9
pets in therapy sessions has the potential to benefit both the patient and the doctor
(Chandramouleeswaran et al 5). Some of the uses of animals within the therapy setting include
pet visitation, animal-assisted therapy, and hippotherapy, a form of physical therapy that utilizes
the movement of a horse. In allowing pets to become a part of the treatment process, oftentimes
the need for psychotropic medications decreases due to the increased social interaction, as well
as the fact it provides a form of sensory stimulation to bring patients into touch with real life
show pet assisted therapy benefits people suffering from disorders such as autism, attention
deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), grief, dementia, and chronic physical disabilities
ability for children with autism to focus and better their communication. In recent studies, the
decrease in autistic rating scale (Chandramouleeswaran et al 6). Owning a pet gives individuals a
companion that provides unconditional love, comfort, and stress relief, proving the utilization of
animals within the therapy setting might benefit mentally and emotionally disabled patients.
Implementing pets into the therapeutic treatment process makes up only a single piece of
the new discoveries and advancements within the field of child psychiatry. While some of this
new knowledge generates excitement, other aspects uncover concern. One example of this
includes the need for a better understanding when it comes to global child psychiatry. Currently,
more than 200 million children around the world do not have the ability to reach their mental
developmental potential (Tripathi et al 1). Although many factors play a role, one of the more
significant traces back to immigration and the stress that comes with it. Considering how every
Thomas 10
childs mind functions differently, American children do not compare to those who must move to
a new country and adapt to a completely new and foreign way of life. With every immigrant
child comes a much different history American psychiatrists must take into account when
deciding upon a treatment plan. Between the stress of moving and altering ones lifestyle, to the
hardships and trauma faced back home, psychiatrists must approach these children with patience,
as well as a different and deeper understanding. Immigration takes quite a big toll on a child,
especially when they become expected to learn and translate a new language for their parents as
the only bilingual member of their family (Childrens Mental Health Field 6). Young refugees,
on the other hand, pose a challenge due to the situations they come from. Between 80 and 90%
of these children faced some form of trauma, whether in the form of mass killings, lack of food,
or forced labor (Fritz 5). The experience of traveling to America results in unique challenges,
such as political unrest, extreme poverty, or persecution, all of which may lead to mental illness
or violence (Fritz 1). With a growing need for global mental care for children, the 42% of
psychiatry programs that offer training in this specialty must rise quickly in order to provide the
care necessary (Fritz 6). However, it might become quite difficult to recruit psychiatrists willing
to specialize in global child mental health when staffing poses a challenge right in their own
backyards.
Staffing the field of psychiatry has presented a major issue in recent years. By the year
2020, statistics show an estimated 8,312 people employed in child and adolescent psychiatry,
although the nation will need 12,624 (Childrens Mental Health Field 4). With a growing
disorders, the shortage of doctors to accommodate for their growing patient lists must change. In
Thomas 11
order to accomplish this, the quality of teaching in medical school needs to focus on psychiatry
as much as other medical specialties. Due to the lack of time spent encouraging medical students
to consider a career in this field, postgraduate training in psychiatry has fallen behind the rate
other medical specialties take in students, with psychiatry residency programs growing at nearly
half the rate of programs in other fields (Volpe et al 261). According to medical students, some
of the factors deterring them from choosing a career in child psychiatry include a less prestigious
reputation, a limited amount of exposure during training, lack of respect within the medical field,
and difficulty with treatments, considering the complexity of the field (263-264). In an
experiment conducted where psychiatry residents sat and listened in on psychiatry lectures
within a medical school, some noticeable issues became apparent. According to these residents,
although the instructor taught with interest and in enthusiasm, only 52% of the classes began on
time, yet 75% ended on schedule. Additionally, of the 68% of lectures that involved the use of
audio-visual aides, 30% had some sort of technical difficulties (Melamed et al 516). Based on
this information, the residents concluded the main problem lies within using class time
efficiently and preparing lectures around the idea that technology may fail or malfunction.
Although this experiment does not speak for general medical students, psychiatry residents serve
as adequate reviewers considering they become the targeted audience once students choose a
specialty within psychiatry (Melamed et al 518). In the end, the main problem continues to trace
back to the point students enter medical school. In the past decade, the number of training
programs dropped from 120 to 113, while the number of trainees dropped from 712 trainees in
1990, to 680 in 2003 (Wun Jung 24). Because of the lack of early exposure to psychiatry, along
with the limited availability of relevant electives, lectures, and various treatment environments,
Thomas 12
students do not even get the chance to consider a specialty in child psychiatry (Volpe et al 264).
In order to provide children globally with adequate mental health care, medical schools must put
a much more substantial emphasis the quality of teaching and encouraging students to pursue
careers in psychiatry.
In almost every career, the comparison of men and women within the workplace poses a
great interest to many. Considering that female enrollment in medical school has now reached
nearly 50%, the number of women within all medical fields, not just psychiatry, will most likely
continue to rise (Georg et al 645). Keeping this in mind, an increase in the number of women
going into the medical field may not benefit the field of psychiatry as much as one may assume.
With the new and expanding opportunities for women in medicine, many have begun reaching
higher, by pursuing careers in more challenging, prestigious, or rigorous medical specialties men
previously dominated (Volpe et al 264). However, when analyzing the roles of males and
females specifically within the field of psychiatry, their different approaches in the diagnosis and
treatment process reflect which gender the scale of child psychiatric employment tilts toward.
For instance, in a study conducted in 2007 by American psychiatrists, the research collected
helped identify whether the gender of psychiatric residents affects their decisions when it comes
to diagnosing patients and coming up with treatment interventions (Mihai et al 233). Although
the researchers discovered no significant differences between male and female psychiatrists
within certain scenarios, women appeared more receptive to psychotherapy overall. Due to some
of their natural characteristics, women tend to boast a more emotionally expressive attitude
when dealing with patients, as well as an interest in discussing problems instead of rushing to a
conclusion or acting immediately. Men, on the other hand, appear to let their masculinity play a
Thomas 13
larger role in their approach. This causes them to become more controlling and independent,
more likely to hide their emotions, and more intent on proving power and working based on
action, rather than discussion (237). Based on this information and womens general role in
society overall, it appears female psychiatrists place greater importance on emotions and
personal relations compared to their male counterparts (Georg et al 639). Considering their
willingness to spend time establishing an emotional connection with their patients, female
psychiatrists have the potential to take over this field in the future.
Technology has started to become a staple in the the current working world of psychiatry.
With the use of the Internet and electronic devices, treatment processes in all medical fields stand
to advance more in the near future. Psychiatrists benefit from these changes by having the ability
to utilize these technologies when communicating with patients, keeping client records, and
developing diagnosis and treatment plans. For instance, in a case study conducted at the
University Hospital of North Norway, psychiatrists and nurses experimented with the use of
doing so, psychiatrists gained access to nurses, physicians, and patients no matter their location,
which made assessments and treatments much easier (Trondsen et al 1). In the event that a
patient does not have the ability to contact a psychiatrist in person, the use of VC provided an aid
for face-to-face interaction, even when distance posed an issue. After introducing this
technology, patients remained calmer and more willing to accept psychiatric help, which
strengthened communication, decision-making, and the quality of care between the doctor and
patient (3-4). For nurses, the VC worked as a safety net to increase confidence and certainty
when assisting a patient whom they do not see in person (5). To make the job easier in everyday
Thomas 14
medical practices, the introduction of innovative information technology has proven useful.
Developing electronic patient record systems increased documentation accuracy, decreased time
coordinating patient care, increased information access, and decreased the multitudes of
patient records, information overall becomes more accessible and accurate when compared to
paper-based records that rely on overlapping and unstructured content, as well as handwritten
documentation (482). With implementation of this system, individuals do not have to worry
A career in the field of psychiatry requires an individual willing to deal with difficult and
provides the opportunity to guide patients toward happy futures through a multitude of methods.
With new forms of treatments and technologies becoming available, the field of psychiatry as a
whole stands to come out of its staffing crisis and advance in the future.
Thomas 15
Works Cited
Ammenwerth, Elske, Frauke Ehlers, Ulrike Kutscha, Ansgar Kutscha, Ronald Eichstdter, and
A Case Study From Clinical Psychiatry." Disease Management & Health Outcomes 10.8
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=7008955&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Indian Journal Of Psychological Medicine 36.1 (2014): 4-8. Academic Search Complete.
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=94741874&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
"Children's Mental Health Field Seeks Increased Workforce, Improved Training." Brown
University Child & Adolescent Behavior Letter 22.11 (2006): 1-6. Academic Search
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=22955402&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Ciubara, Anamaria, Roxana Chirita, Stefan Lucian Burlea, Ancuta Ignat, Smaranda Diaconescu,
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=112808837&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Cole, Ester. "Understanding Post-Traumatic Stress In Children And Adolescents." Baltic Journal
Of Psychology 11.1/2 (2015): 90-96. Academic Search Complete. Web. 15 Feb. 2017.
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=117908862&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
"College Search: SuperMatch." Family Connection. Naviance, n.d. Web. 14 Feb. 2017.
<https://connection.naviance.com/family-connection/colleges/supermatch>.
Fritz, Julia C. "The Changing Face Of America's Children: A Look At Global Child Mental
Health." Brown University Child & Adolescent Behavior Letter 30.5 (2014): 1-6.
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=95510748&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Psychiatry: Survey Of Doctors And Students." Medical Education 33.9 (1999): 639-647.
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=5814193&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Hartzell, Monica, Jaakko Seikkula, and Anne-Liis von Knorring. "What Children Feel
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=42211257&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Melamed, Yuval, Gil Ophir, Yael Nechama, Ruth Abramovitzh, Netta Notzer, and Alan Apter.
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=23274990&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Mihai, Adriana, Michael H. Allen, Julian Beezhold, Codruta Rosu, Aurel Nirestean, and Cristian
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=45363044&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Pierini, Alessandra. "Being A Transactional Analysis Child Therapist: How Working With
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=97587157&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Shorter, Edward. A History of Psychiatry: From the Era of the Asylum to the Age of Prozac. New
Tripathi, Adarsh, Amit Arya, and Kabir Garg. "Preventive Psychiatry in Children and
Adolescents: Current Status and Future." Journal of Indian Association for Child &
Adolescent Mental Health Jan. 2016: 1+. Academic Search Complete. Web. 2 Jan. 2017.
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=112067225&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Trondsen, Marianne Vibeke, Stein Roald Bolle, Geir yvind Stensland, and Aksel Tjora.
Emergencies." BMC Health Services Research 14.1 (2014): 544-551. Academic Search
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=100104685&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Volpe, Tiziana, Katherine M. Boydell, and Antonio Pignatiello. "Choosing Child And
Academy Of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 22.4 (2013): 260-267. Academic Search
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=91812251&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.
Wun Jung, Kim. "Child Psychiatry's Staffing Crisis." Behavioral Health Management 23.5
<http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&AuthType=ip,custuid&custid=s845
5861&db=a9h&AN=11275966&site=ehost-live&scope=site>.