Sie sind auf Seite 1von 46

Substation Automation and RET 670

Protection Training Transformer Protection


Differential
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


1

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Two-winding or three-winding
Two-winding variant up to 4 three-phase CT inputs
Three-winding variant up to 6 three-phase CT inputs

T2D1- T3D1-
T2WPDIF T3WPDIF
I3PW1CT1 I3PW1CT1
I3PW1CT2 I3PW1CT2
I3PW2CT1 I3PW2CT1
I3PW2CT2 I3PW2CT2
I3PW3CT1
I3PW3CT2
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


2
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Two-winding connections
Single CT on both sides

T2D1-
T2WPDIF

I3PW1CT1
I3PW1CT2
I3PW2CT1
I3PW2CT2
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


3

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Two-winding connections
2 CTs, on one or both sides

T2D1-
T2WPDIF

I3PW1CT1
I3PW1CT2
I3PW2CT1
I3PW2CT2
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


4
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Up to two instances
Can protect two objects with one RET 670 IED, or one object that
changes status
Two transformers
Generator / transformer separately
Generating status / pumping status for pump storage unit
Internal adaptation to power transformer vector group, turns ratio and CT
ratios
Tap changer position monitoring for increased sensitivity
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


5

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Unbalance currents due to factors other than faults
Currents that flow on only one side of the power transformer
Magnetizing currents that flow on only the power source side
Normal magnetizing currents
Inrush magnetizing currents
Overexcitation magnetizing currents
Currents that cannot be transformed to the other windings
Zero sequence currents
Error in the power transformer turns ratio due to OLTC
Inequality of the instrument current transformers
Different ratings of current transformers
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

Different types of current transformers

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


6
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Unbalance currents due to factors other than faults (cont.)
Different relative loads on instrument transformers
Different relative currents on CT primaries
Different relative burdens on CT secondaries
Different DC time constants of the fault currents
Different time of occurrence, and degree, of CT saturation
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


7

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Fundamental frequency differential currents (per phase) calculated
as the vector sum of the fundamental frequency current contributions
from all sides of the transformer all current contributions are referred
to a common reference first
Phase reference: first star-connected winding (HVMV LV),
otherwise if no star winding, first delta-connected winding (HV
MV LV)
For example, if the power transformer is Yd1, the HV winding
(Y) is taken as the phase reference winding; if the power
transformer is Dy1, then the LV winding (y) is taken as the
phase reference; if there is no star-connected winding, such
as in Dd0, then the HV delta-connected winding (D) is
automatically chosen as the phase reference
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

All current contributions are phase shifted with reference to


the phase reference side

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


8
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Magnitude reference: first winding (usually HV)
The magnitudes of all current contributions are referred to
the magnitude reference side (i.e. W1), i.e. the magnitudes
of all current contributions from all other sides are always
transferred to the W1 side
It is for this reason that all differential currents are normally
expressed in HV-side primary Amperes
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


9

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
In numerical differential protections, conversion of all current
contributions to the phase and magnitude reference sides is
performed mathematically by pre-programmed coefficient matrices,
which depend on the protected power transformer transformation ratio
and vector group connection
Once the power transformer vector group, rated currents and rated
voltages have been entered by the user, the differential protection
calculates off-line the matrix coefficients, which are then used in the
on-line calculations
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


10
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Two-winding transformer

Contribution Contribution
from W1 from W2
side to side to
differential differential
Differential
currents currents
currents (in
W1-side DCCL1_W1 DCCL1_W2
primary DCCL2_W1 DCCL2_W2
amperes) DCCL3_W1 DCCL3_W2
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


11

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Three-winding transformer

Contribution Contribution Contribution


from W1 from W2 from W3
side to side to side to
differential differential differential
Differential
currents currents currents
currents (in
W1-side DCCL1_W1 DCCL1_W2 DCCL1_W3
primary DCCL2_W1 DCCL2_W2 DCCL2_W3
amperes) DCCL3_W1 DCCL3_W2 DCCL3_W3
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


12
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Values for the A, B, C matrix coefficients depend on
Winding connection type, i.e. star (Y/y) or delta (D/d)
Transformer vector group, i.e. Yd1, Dy11 (which introduces a
phase shift between winding currents in multiples of 30)
Zero sequence current elimination set On / Off
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


13

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
On-line compensation for on-load tap-changer (OLTC) movement
The OLTC is a mechanical device that is used to stepwise
change the number of turns within one power transformer winding
consequently the overall turns ratio of the transformer is
changed
Typically the OLTC is located on the HV winding (i.e. W1) by
stepwise increasing or decreasing the number of HV winding
turns, it is possible to stepwise regulate the LV-side voltage
As the turns ratio (transformation ratio) changes from the
nominal, the actual primary currents flowing will automatically
adjust in accordance with the actual turns ratio
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

Turns ratio = NLV/NHV


and
IHVNHV = ILVNLV

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


14
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
On-line compensation for on-load tap-changer (OLTC) movement
However, as the transformation ratio changes from the nominal

NLV/NHV = Ur_W2 / Ur_W1

the differential function will calculate a resulting differential


current if the ratio Ur_W2 / Ur_W1 is fixed in the calculation

The differential function in IED 670 has a built-in feature to


ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

continuously monitor the tap position and to dynamically


compensate on-line for changes in the power transformer turns
ratio

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


15

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
On-line compensation for on-load tap-changer (OLTC) movement
Setting parameters define on which winding the OLTC is located,
and what the no-load voltage change is for a tap step
By knowing the actual tap position, the differential function can
then calculate the correct no-load voltage for the winding on
which the OLTC is located
For example, if the OLTC is located on the HV winding (W1), the
no-load voltage Ur_W1 will be treated as a function of the actual
tap position, and therefore for every tap position the
corresponding value for Ur_W1 will be calculated and used in the
differential current calculation
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


16
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
On-line compensation for on-load tap-changer (OLTC) movement
By doing this, complete on-line compensation for OLTC
movement is achieved the differential protection will be ideally
balanced for every tap position and no false differential current
will appear irrespective of the actual tap position
Typically, the minimum differential protection pickup for power
transformers with OLTC is set between 30% to 40% - however,
with the OLTC compensation feature it is possible to set the
differential protection in IED 670 to more sensitive pickup values
of 15% to 20%
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


17

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
On-line compensation for on-load tap-changer (OLTC) movement
Two-winding differential protection in IED 670 can compensate
on-line for one OLTC on the protected power transformer
Three-winding differential protection in IED 670 can compensate
on-line for up to two OLTCs on the protected power transformer
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


18
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
On-line compensation for on-load tap-changer (OLTC) movement
OLTC position is determined within IEC 670 by function block
YLTC
Within this function block, the OLTC position value is
continuously monitored to ensure its integrity if any error with
the OLTC position value is detected an alarm will be given which
should be connected to the applicable OLTCxAL input of the
differential protection function block
Whenever an OLTCxAL input has a logical value 1, the
differential protection minimum pickup, originally defined by
setting parameter IdMin, will be increased by the set range of the
OLTC
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


19

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Differential current alarm
The fundamental frequency differential current level is monitored
all the time within the differential function as soon as all three
fundamental frequency differential currents are above a set
threshold, defined by setting parameter IDiffAlarm, a delay on
pickup timer is started; when the pre-set time, defined by setting
parameter tAlarmDelay, expires, the differential current alarm will
be generated and the output signal IDALARM will be set to logical
value 1
This feature can be effectively used to provide an alarm when
OLTC position compensation is used and something in the whole
compensation chain goes wrong
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

This alarm can also be used to desensitize the differential


function (with some additional IED configuration logic that
connects the IDALARM output to an OLTCxAL input)

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


20
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Single circuit breaker applications
Calculated as the highest fundamental frequency current
amongst all the current contributions to the differential
current calculation
This highest individual current contribution is taken as the
single common bias current for all three phases

DCCL1_W1 DCCL1_W2
= DCCL2_W1 + DCCL2_W2
DCCL3_W1 DCCL3_W2
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


21

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Single circuit breaker applications
The current contributions from all windings are already
referred to the magnitude reference (W1) side (for this
reason, the bias current is usually expressed in HV-side
primary Amperes) and can therefore be directly compared
regarding their magnitudes

i.e. Ibias = MAX [DCCLx_W1; DCCLx_W2]


ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


22
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Through-fault stability for multi-breaker arrangements
Ideal CTs, external current summation

+A
+B Idiff

-A -B
To Diff Prot
+A -A -B -B

IDIFF = +B -B = 0
IBIAS = MAX(-B; +B)
Ibias
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


23

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Through-fault stability for multi-breaker arrangements
Real CTs, external current summation

+A
+B Idiff

-A -B
To Diff Prot
+A -A -B error -B error

IDIFF = +B -B error = error


IBIAS = MAX(-B error; +B)
Ibias
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


24
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Through-fault stability for multi-breaker arrangements
Real CTs, internal current summation

+A
+B Idiff

-A -B
To RET 670
+A
-A -B error

T2D1

to IBIAS calculation Ibias


ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

to IDIFF & IBIAS calculation


IDIFF = +A -A -B error +B = error

IBIAS = MAX(-B error; +B; +A; -A -B error)

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


25

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Multiple circuit breaker applications, on any or all sides
From any side, the current contributions from the two T-side
CTs are included in the bias current calculation, as well as
the resultant current contribution for that transformer winding
(which is the calculated sum of the two separate CT
contributions)
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

to IBIAS calculation

to IDIFF & IBIAS calculation

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


26
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Multiple circuit breaker applications, on any or all sides
IL1_W1CT1 DCCL1_W1CT1

From W1 CT1: A* IL2_W1CT1 = DCCL2_W1CT1


IL3_W1CT1 DCCL3_W1CT1

IL1_W1CT2 DCCL1_W1CT2

From W1 CT2: A* IL2_W1CT2 = DCCL2_W1CT2


IL3_W1CT2 DCCL3_W1CT2

IL1_W2CT1 DCCL1_W2CT1

From W2 CT1: (Ur_W2 / Ur_W1) * B * IL2_W2CT1 = DCCL2_W2CT1


IL3_W2CT1 DCCL3_W2CT1
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

IL1_W2CT2 DCCL1_W2CT2

From W2 CT2: (Ur_W2 / Ur_W1) * B * IL2_W2CT2 = DCCL2_W2CT2


IL3_W2CT2 DCCL3_W2CT2

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


27

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Multiple circuit breaker applications, on any or all sides
Therefore, in principle, want to include the following
contributions in the bias current calculation
DCCLx_W1CT1/2; DCCLx_W2CT1/2;
DCCLx_W1CT1+DCCLxW1CT2; DCCLxW2CT1+DCCLxW2CT2
However, for applications with two restraint CT inputs on one
side (such as for breaker-and-a-half applications), the
primary ratings of the CTs can be much higher than the
rating of the protected power transformer
In order to determine the bias current for such T-
configurations, the currents flowing on the T-side can be
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

separately scaled by an additional setting this is done in


order to prevent unwanted de-sensitizing (over-biassing) of
the overall differential protection

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


28
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Multiple circuit breaker applications, on any or all sides
When 1pu primary current flows through the T-side CT, want
this to contribute a 1pu component to the bias calculation
e.g.
Irated pri_CT = 1000A
Irated_W1 = 500A

1000/1 Irated_W1 = 500A


ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


29

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Multiple circuit breaker applications, on any or all sides
If no other action were taken, the contribution to the bias
calculation from the 1000A (= 1pu of the CT primary rating)
flowing through the T-side CT would be
= 1000A (= 2pu!!!)
Ibias (pu) = Ibias (pri A) / IBase, where IBase = Irated_W
Therefore, a scaling factor needs to be introduced (setting
parameters CT1RatingW1, CT2RatingW1, CT1RatingW2,
CT2RatingW2)
By applying the scaling factor, the contribution to the bias
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

calculation from the 1000A flowing through the T-side CT is


then determined as follows:
(I / CT1RatingW1)*Irated_W1 = (1000/1000)*500
= 500A (=1pu!!!)

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


30
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Bias current
Multiple circuit breaker applications, on any or all sides
curr(1) = MAX [DCCLx_W1CT1 + DCCLx_W1CT2]
curr(2) = MAX [DCCLx_W2CT1 + DCCLx_W2CT2]
curr(3) = MAX [DCCLx_W1CT1] * (1 / CT1RatingW1) * RatedCurrentW1
curr(4) = MAX [DCCLx_W1CT2] * (1 / CT2RatingW1) * RatedCurrentW1
curr(5) = MAX [DCCLx_W2CT1] * (Ur_W1 / Ur_W2) * (1 / CT1RatingW2) * RatedCurrentW1
curr(6) = MAX [DCCLx_W2CT2] * (Ur_W1 / Ur_W2) * (1 / CT2RatingW2) * RatedCurrentW1

i.e. Ibias = MAX [curr(1);.curr(6)]


ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


31

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Zero sequence current elimination
Selectable (per winding) Setting: On / Off per winding
Elimination of the zero sequence currents is necessary to avoid
unwanted trips for external earth faults whenever
The protected power transformer cannot transform the zero
sequence currents to the other side
The zero sequence currents can only flow on one side of the
protected power transformer
The zero sequence currents should be subtracted from the side
of the power transformer where the zero sequence currents can
flow for external earth faults
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


32
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Zero sequence current elimination
In most cases power transformers do not properly transform the
zero sequence currents to the other side a typical example is a
power transformer of the star-delta type (e.g. YNd1)
Transformers of this type do not transform the zero sequence
currents, but zero sequence currents can flow in the earthed star-
connected winding (e.g. an external earth fault on the star-side
causes zero sequence currents to flow on the star-side, but not
on the delta-side)
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


33

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Zero sequence current elimination
This results in false differential currents that consist exclusively of
the zero sequence currents if high enough, these false
differential currents can result in the unwanted operation of the
differential function (and unwanted disconnection of the healthy
power transformer)
The star-winding zero sequence currents must therefore be
subtracted from the fundamental frequency differential currents if
an unwanted trip is to be avoided
For delta-windings, this feature should be enabled only if an
earthing transformer exists within the differential zone on the
delta-side of the protected power transformer
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


34
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Zero sequence current elimination
If the zero sequence currents are subtracted from the current
contribution of any side to the differential currents, they are
automatically eliminated from the bias current contribution as well
Removing the zero sequence current from the differential
currents decreases to some extent the sensitivity of the
differential protection for internal earth faults
However, the automatic subtraction of the zero sequence
currents from the bias current as well counteracts this effect to
some degree

DCCL1_W1 DCCL1_W2
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

= DCCL2_W1 + DCCL2_W2
DCCL3_W1 DCCL3_W2

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


35

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Three-section operate/restrain characteristic
Highset unrestrained limit
Reset ratio 0.95

Idiff
Section 1 Section 2 Section 3
Idunre Settings:
IdMin
IdUnre
Slope Slope EndSection1
Section 2 Section 3
EndSection2
SlopeSection2
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

Idmin
SlopeSection3
End of End of Ibias
Section 1 Section 2

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


36
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Unrestrained (i.e. non-stabilized) limit
This limit determines the pickup (operate) threshold for big
differential currents for which there should be no doubt that the
fault is internal
This limit is constant
For measured differential currents greater than this limit,
instantaneous tripping is allowed, i.e. no supervision by blocking
criteria (waveform or harmonic restrain) is applied
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


37

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Restrained (i.e. stabilized) characteristic
This characteristic determines the pickup (operate) threshold for
differential currents with magnitude less than the unrestrained
limit it is possible for these differential currents to occur and
cause pickup for reasons other than internal faults
The pickup (operate) threshold is mostly not constant, as after
Section 1 it increases with increasing bias current magnitude in
this way the magnitudes of the individual fundamental frequency
differential currents are compared to an adaptive limit that is
dependent on the bias (i.e. restrain) current magnitude
Following a start (pickup), blocking criteria (waveform and
harmonic restrain) are applied before tripping is permitted, i.e. a
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

trip will only be released if not prevented by one of the blocking


criteria

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


38
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Restrained (i.e. stabilized) characteristic
Section 1
Most sensitive part
Characteristic a straight line
Current flow normal load current
Typical reason for existence of false differential currents in
this section is non compensation for tap position
Section 2
First slope (low percentage)
Caters for false differential currents when higher than normal
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

currents flow through the current transformers

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


39

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Restrained (i.e. stabilized) characteristic
Section 3
Second slope (higher percentage)
Provides higher tolerance to substantial current transformer
saturation for high through fault currents, which can be
expected in this section
The characteristic settings should be made such that
for internal faults, the differential currents are always safely
above the characteristic
for external faults, any unwanted (false) differential currents
are always safely below the characteristic
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


40
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Blocking criteria (phase segregated)
The two blocking criteria are the waveform restrain and the
harmonic restrain these two criteria have the power to block
(i.e. to prevent) a trip command being given by the differential
protection whose operate-restrain characteristic has measured an
operate condition (registered a start)
Instantaneous differential currents are calculated on which the
waveform and harmonic analyses are performed the same
matrix equations are used as for the fundamental frequency
currents, except now instantaneous values (i.e. sampled values)
are used instead
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


41

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Blocking criteria
Waveform restrain
Based on waveform recognition looks for the intervals
within each power system cycle with low rate-of-change in
the instantaneous differential currents that are typical to
power transformer inrush currents
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


42
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Blocking criteria
Waveform restrain
The waveform restrain function will activate a restrain signal
in those phases where this wave shape is detected
If the operate-restrain characteristic registers a start in a
particular phase, then the status of the waveform restrain
output for the same phase will be assessed, and if activated,
a block signal for that phase will be established
The BLKWAVLx output from the function block will only
become logic 1 if the waveform restrain output in phase Lx is
activated, and the operate-restrain characteristic has
registered a start in the same phase
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


43

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Blocking criteria
Harmonic restrain
Required to prevent unwanted tripping due to magnetizing
inrush currents, or due to magnetizing currents caused by
overvoltages magnetizing currents flow only on one side of
a power transformer, and are therefore always a cause of
false differential currents
Harmonic analysis (2nd and 5th harmonic) is performed on the
instantaneous differential currents, but only after the operate-
restrain characteristic has registered a start i.e. if the
operate-restrain characteristic registers a start in a particular
phase, then the harmonic analysis on the instantaneous
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

differential current in that phase will be started (phase


segregated)

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


44
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Blocking criteria
Harmonic restrain
For example, if the operate-restrain characteristic has
registered a start in phase L1, then the harmonic analysis on
the instantaneous differential current in phase L1 will be
started if the content of the 2nd harmonic in the
instantaneous differential current of this phase is above the
setting I2/I1Ratio, then a block signal for this phase will be
established
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


45

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Blocking criteria
Cross-blocking between phases
If a blocking condition is established in any phase, this phase
can cross this blocking condition to the other phases, i.e. a
phase may only cross-block the other phases if it itself is
blocked (and it can only be blocked if its operate-restrain
characteristic first registered a start)

IdiffL1 IdiffL2/3

Phase L1
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

blocked
cross-block

Ibias Ibias

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


46
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Blocking criteria
Waveform inrush
Settings: None
2nd harmonic inrush, CT saturation
Settings: settable level in % of fundamental
5th harmonic overexcitation
Settings: settable level in % of fundamental
Cross-blocking between phases
Setting: On / Off
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


47

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Overview of traditional transformer differential protection function

Blocking condition:
&
2nd harmonic, 5th harmonic
waveblock, cross block

restrained 1 TRIP
unrestrained
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

START

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


48
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Switch on to fault feature
The transformer differential function in IED 670 has a built-in
switch on to fault feature that ensures quick differential protection
tripping in cases where a transformer is energized with an
internal fault
This feature can be enabled or disabled by a setting parameter
SOTFMode
The principle of operation is based on the fact that a current gap
will exist within the first power system cycle when a healthy
power transformer is energized, and conversely will not exist if
the power transformer is unhealthy (is switched on to a fault)
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


49

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Switch on to fault feature
If this gap does not exist, the waveblock criterion will reset
quickly, i.e. within a time window that started when the
transformer was switched in
This quick resetting (within the time window) of the waveblock
criterion will temporarily disable the second harmonic blocking
feature, which then ensures fast operation of the transformer
differential function for a switch on to fault condition
This feature is only active during initial power transformer
energizing
When the switch on to fault feature is disabled, or once the time
window following switch-in has elapsed, the waveblock and
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

second harmonic blocking features work in parallel and are


completely independent of each other

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


50
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Fault position (internal / external) can be determined by comparing the
direction of flow of the negative sequence currents on all sides of the
transformer
This is done by simply determining the position of the source of the
negative sequence currents with respect to the zone of protection
the source of the negative sequence currents is at the point of fault
External fault: the negative sequence currents will have a relative
phase displacement of 180
Internal fault: the negative sequence currents will have a relative
phase displacement of about 0
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


51

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
What about transformation ratio and phase shift?
Before comparison, the negative sequence current contributions must
first be referred to the same phase reference, and put to the same
magnitude reference
Modern numerical transformer differential relays use matrix equations
to compensate for vector group and turns ratio
Negative sequence differential current contributions can be calculated
using the same matrix equations in this way all negative sequence
current contributions are automatically compensated for power
transformer vector group and turns ratio
The 0 / 180 criterion is then still valid
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


52
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Example YNd5 transformer

IDL1 _ NS 2 1 1 INS _ W 1 1 0 1 INS _ W 2


IDL 2 _ NS = 1 1 2 1 a INS _ W 1 + Ur _ W 2 1 1 1 0 a INS _ W 2
3 Ur _ W 1 3
IDL3 _ NS 1 1 2 a 2 INS _ W 1 0 1 1 a 2 INS _ W 2
NS contribution from W1 NS contribution from W2
NS
side to NS side to NS
differential
differential differential
current
currents currents
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


53

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Two-winding transformers
Operation of the internal / external fault discriminator is based on
the relative position of the two phasors representing the HV/LV
(W1/W2) negative sequence current contributions, i.e. on a
directional comparison between these two phasors
Three-winding transformers
Operation of the internal / external fault discriminator is based on
similar principles
Three directional comparisons are made
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


54
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
The Internal / External fault discriminator works equally well for
symmetrical 3-phase faults
When a symmetrical 3-phase fault occurs, negative sequence
currents (the negative sequence current source) will be present
until the dc component in the fault currents die out
This interval of time is long enough for the internal / external fault
discriminator to declare either an internal or an external fault
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


55

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Characteristic

Settings:
IMinNegSeq
NegSeqROA
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


56
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Operation (two-winding transformer)
The LV-side phasor is positioned along the zero degree line
then the relative position of the HV-side phasor in the complex
plain is determined
To perform the directional comparison, the magnitudes of both
phasors must be high enough to ensure that they are due to a
fault, i.e. both must be greater than the settable limit IminNegSeq
To guarantee good sensitivity, this IminNegSeq limit must not be
set too high
If the magnitude of any one of the phasors is below the limit, no
directional comparison will be made the internal / external fault
discriminator will not operate during transformer energization
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

(inrush)
The settable relay operate angle NegSeqROA determines the
boundary between the internal and external fault regions

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


57

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
CT saturation
During heavy faults, CT saturation might cause the measured
phase angle to differ from 180 for external faults, and from about
0 for internal faults
Effective means to counteract the negative effects of main CT
saturation have been integrated into the algorithm
At heavy faults, approximately 5ms time-to-saturation of the main
CT is sufficient in order to produce a correct discrimination
between internal and external faults
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


58
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Features of Internal / External fault discriminator
Discriminates between internal and external faults with very high
dependability
Detects even minor faults with high sensitivity and high speed
High performance differential protection is achieved by combining the
good properties of traditional differential protection with advanced
features of the internal / external fault discriminator
Unrestrained negative sequence differential protection
Sensitive negative sequence protection
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


59

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Unrestrained negative sequence differential protection
A start from the ordinary differential protection is required to
activate the unrestrained negative sequence differential
protection
If the internal / external fault discriminator categorizes this same
fault as internal, the blocking supervision is bypassed, and the
trip output is generated without any further delay
This logic guarantees a fast operating time, even for heavy
internal faults with severely saturated current transformers
harmonic distortions do not slow down the differential protection
operation
If the fault is categorized as external, the traditional differential
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

protection is NOT blocked, but additional trip criteria are posed to


ensure high external fault stability

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


60
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Overview of unrestrained negative sequence differential protection in
conjunction with traditional transformer differential protection
Blocking condition:
&
2nd harmonic, 5th harmonic
waveblock, cross block

Neg Seq Int /


Ext Fault internal
Discriminator &

restrained 1 TRIP
unrestrained
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

START

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


61

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal / External fault discriminator
Sensitive negative sequence protection
Gives sensitive turn-to-turn fault protection
Independent from the traditional differential protection
No start from the ordinary differential protection is required to
activate the sensitive negative sequence differential protection
If the internal / external fault discriminator categorizes the
disturbance as internal, a separate trip request is placed this
trip request must be confirmed several times in succession before
the final trip request is placed this security feature results in an
increase in the operating time
Nevertheless, an operating time of about 30-50ms is achieved for
very low-level turn-to-turn faults
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


62
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Overview of sensitive negative sequence protection

Blocking condition:
&
2nd harmonic, 5th harmonic
waveblock, cross block

Neg Seq Int / internal


Ext Fault &
I- start &
Discriminator internal

restrained 1 TRIP
unrestrained
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

START

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


63

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Open CT detection feature
The purpose of the open CT detection feature is to prevent a
maloperation of the transformer differential function if a loaded
main CT connected to the differential protection is by mistake
open-circuited in just one phase on the secondary side
Note: This feature is able to detect an open CT condition
(interruption) in one phase only it is not able to detect the
simultaneous interruption in two or three phases, for which
the differential function will operate and give a trip output if
the false differential current is high enough
This feature can be enabled or disabled by the setting parameter
OpenCTEnable
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


64
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Open CT detection feature
In order to prevent an unwanted operation of the differential
function for an open-circuit condition, the open CT detection
feature must operate within 10ms, to ensure in-time blocking of
the differential function
It is required to work only during normal load conditions, and is
automatically disabled during external faults, big overloads and
inrush conditions
Its principle of operation is based on the fact that, for an
interruption in one phase, the current in that phase will suddenly
drop to zero, while the currents in the other two phases will
continue as before
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


65

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Open CT detection feature
If the load currents are very low, or zero, an open CT condition
cannot be detected the open CT algorithm will only detect an
open CT condition if the load on the power transformer is in the
range 10 110% of the rated load
The search for an open CT condition starts 60 seconds (50
seconds in 60 Hz systems) after the bias current enters the 10
110% range
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


66
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Open CT detection feature
If an open CT is detected, all the differential functions, except the
unrestrained (instantaneous) level, will be blocked immediately
The unrestrained level will also be blocked after a settable time
delay tOCTUnrstDelay
An alarm signal will be given after a settable delay
tOCTAlarmDelay
The open CT algorithm provides detailed information about the
location of the open CT secondary circuit
Transformer side,
CT input, and
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

Phase
in which the open CT condition was detected

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


67

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Open CT detection feature
A detected open CT condition will be reset automatically by the
differential function itself once the condition has been repaired it
is not possible to externally reset the open CT detection
After reset, the open CT detection algorithm will again start to
search for an open CT condition within the protected zone
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


68
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functionality
Open CT detection feature
The automatic reset of the open CT detection requires the
following conditions to be fulfilled
The bias current must be in the range 10 110% of the rated
load for at least one minute
The current asymmetry must disappear, i.e. the open CT
condition must be repaired
Note: not only must the current asymmetry disappear, but
current symmetry must be detected
The above two conditions must be fulfilled for the time
interval defined by the setting parameter tOCTResetDelay
the differential functions will remain blocked until this time
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

delay has elapsed (the reason for this is to prevent a


maloperation immediately following the reconnection of the
open CT circuit)

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


69

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


70
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Simplified logic diagram for phase L1
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


71

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Simplified logic diagram for internal / external fault discriminator

Internal/ EXTFAULT
External INTFAULT
IDNSMAG
Fault
discrimin
ator TRNSSENS
t
AND
OpNegSeqDiff=On

IBIAS
a
b>a
b
Constant
BLKNSSEN
BLKNSUNR
BLOCK
TRNSUNR
STL1 AND
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

STL2
OR
STL3

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


72
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal grouping of Trip signals

TRIPRESL1
TRIPRESL2 TRIPRES
OR
TRIPRESL3

TRIPUNREL1
TRIPUNREL2 TRIPUNRE
OR
TRIPUNREL3

TRIP
TRNSSENS OR
TRNSUNR
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


73

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Internal grouping of Start and Block signals
STL1
STL2 START
OR
STL3

BLK2HL1
BLK2HL2 BLK2H
OR
BLK2HL3

BLK5HL1
BLK5HL2 BLK5H
OR
BLK5HL3

BLKWAVL1
BLKWAVL2 BLKWAV
OR
BLKWAVL3
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


74
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Differential current alarm
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


75

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Functions blocks for two- and three-winding functions

Analog quantity
Inputs for 2-W Trip outputs Analog quantity
Inputs for 3-W
OLTC inputs
Start outputs
Block inputs OLTC inputs

Block outputs

Diff current alarm CT output


Open CT outputs

Analog quantity
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

outputs

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


76
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


77

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings


Settings
General settings
Differential protection
TransformerDiff3Wind(PDIF,87T)
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


78
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings
Settings
General settings
Differential protection
TransformerDiff3Wind(PDIF,87T)
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


79

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings


ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


80
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings

WYE (Y); Delta (D)

0 [0 deg]; 1 [30 deg lag];


2 [60 deg lag]; 3 [90 deg lag];
4 [120 deg lag]; 5 [150 deg lag];
6 [180 deg]; 7 [150 deg lead];
8 [120 deg lead]; 9 [90 deg lead];
10 [60 deg lead]; 11 [30 deg lead]
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


81

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings

Off; On
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


82
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings

No; Yes

No; Yes
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

No; Yes

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


83

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings

Not Used
Winding 1 (W1)
Winding 2 (W2)
Winding 3 (W3)
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


84
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings

Not Used
Winding 1 (W1)
Winding 2 (W2)
Winding 3 (W3)
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


85

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection - Settings


Settings
Settings group N1
Differential protection
TransformerDiff3Wind(PDIF,87T)

Off; On
Off; On

Off; On
Off; On
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

Off; On

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


86
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Service values
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


87

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Service values
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


88
RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Service values
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


89

RET 670 Transformer Differential Protection

Transformer differential protection (PDIF, 87T)


Service values
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


90
ABB Power Technologies AB, 2007

2008-05-23 Substation Automation and Protection Training


91

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen