Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Figure 1Location maps (two inset maps) showing structural features and distribution of producing fields (black
patches) in the Oriente basin, Ecuador (compiled from Canfield et al., 1982; Dashwood and Abbotts, 1990; White et
al., 1995), and the outline of the Sacha field showing line of a north-south well-log cross section (Figure 26), posi-
tion of an east-west seismic profile (Figure 28), and cored wells used in this study.
of oil. To enhance further oil production, it is The principal reservoir, the Lower Cretaceous
important to gain a clear understanding of the Hollin Formation (Figure 2), traditionally has been
reservoir in terms of its depositional origin. considered as braided fluvial deposits with sheet-
The primary purpose of this study was to devel- like geometries (Canfield et al., 1982; White et al.
op a viable sedimentological model to predict the 1995). Macellari (1988) proposed a fluvio-deltaic
distribution of the Cretaceous Hollin and Napo environment for the Hollin Formation. White et al.
reservoirs in the Sacha field. Our objectives were (1995) interpreted the overlying Upper Cretaceous
to (1) describe cores and interpret depositional Napo Formation as fluvio-deltaic deposits in an
processes, (2) calibrate depositional facies with incised valley-fill setting. Our study, based on con-
wireline logs, (3) establish sand-body geometries ventional cores from the Sacha field area, shows
using stratigraphic correlations of well logs and that tidal processes were much more important
seismic data, and (4) develop a depositional than fluvio-deltaic processes in depositing sands of
model by integrating core, outcrop, log, and seis- both the Hollin and Napo formations. A possible
mic data. reason for this difference in interpretation is that
654 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
Figure 2Generalized
stratigraphic column,
Oriente basin, Ecuador
(from Smith, 1989).
CORE STUDY
Description
Cross-bedded sandstone with erosional bases is
present in the lower Hollin (well SA 133) and in the
upper Hollin (well SA 130) intervals but is absent in
the Napo T and U intervals. This facies is com-
posed of dark gray (oil-stained), fine- to medium-
grained sandstone. Sand grains are moderately well
sorted and subangular to subrounded. Depositional
matrix is generally low because sand usually com-
prises 100% of this facies. The most diagnostic fea-
ture is cross-stratification. Planar cross-stratification
is common, with dips of cross-beds ranging from 10
to 20. In the lower Hollin, the basal part of this
656 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
facies contains quartz granules about 3 mm in size. (well SA 133), upper Hollin (well SA 122), and
Rare mudstone clasts are also present. The cross- Napo U (well SA 119) intervals. This facies is
bedded sandstone is interbedded with very fine composed of light brown (oil-stained), mud-
grained sandstone with mud layers (i.e., mud draped, cross-bedded, fine-grained sandstone.
drapes) in the lower Hollin (well SA 133). This Cross-beds dip up to 18. Some intervals show
facies has a thickness of up to 5 m in core and bidirectional cross-beds. Sand grains are poorly
exhibits a blocky motif in wireline logs (Figure 3). sorted and subrounded. Depositional matrix is
low to moderate because sand comprises
90100% of this facies. This facies is 1.5 m thick in
Interpretation the SA 122 well and shows a fining-upward trend
On the basis of cross-stratification and basal lags, with a basal erosional surface and a basal lag com-
this facies is interpreted as high-energy fluvial chan- posed of carbonaceous and mudstone clasts.
nels with traction structures. A lack of interbedded Carbonaceous fragments are common throughout
fine-grained (levee) facies suggests low-sinuosity this facies.
streams. The interbedded sandstone units with
abundant mud drapes indicate some tidal influ-
ence. The vertical gradation of these fluvial chan- Interpretation
nels (e.g., 9930.5 ft, 3028.8 m, well SA 133) into Cross-beds, erosional bases, basal lags, and fining-
tidal channels likely indicates a transgressive upward trends provide evidence for channel depo-
coastal plain setting. sition. Bidirectional cross-beds and foresets with
mud drapes indicate deposition in tidal channels.
Elliott (1986) considered cross-bedded sandstone
Heterolithic Facies with Erosive-Based with an erosional base, basal lags, and fining-
Cross-Bedded Sandstone (Tidal Channel) upward trends in association with heterolithic
facies and flaser bedding to represent estuarine tidal
Description channels. Shanley et al. (1992) interpreted cross-
A heterolithic facies with erosive-based, cross- beds with mud drapes as tidally influenced fluvial
bedded sandstone is present in the lower Hollin strata. In this study, the main difference between
Shanmugam et al. 657
Figure 4Symbols used in sedimentological logs (for Figures 9, 15, 21, and 22).
tidal and f luvial channels is that tidal channels drapes are ubiquitous, resulting in a heterolithic
exhibit cross-beds with mud drapes, whereas cross- facies (Figures 5, 6). Rhythmic alternation of the
beds in fluvial channels do not typically show mud sandstone and mudstone layers (i.e., sandy rhyth-
drapes. mites) is a diagnostic feature. Thick-thin alterna-
tions of successive sand layers (i.e., bundles) are
well developed in some intervals. Double mud lay-
Heterolithic Facies with Cross-Bedded ers are common (Figures 5, 6). Mud offshoots
Sandstone, Full-Vortex Structures, (i.e., top-truncated drapes) in ripples also are
Rhythmites, and Double Mud Layers common.
(Tidal Sand Bar) Dips of cross-beds range from 15 to 36. In rare
cases, bidirectional (i.e., herringbone) cross-
Description bedding is present. Some cross-bedded units dip
A heterolithic facies with cross-bedded sand- 22 (well SA 126) and show normal grading along
stone, full-vortex structures, rhythmites, and dou- foresets. Graded beds are 23 cm in thickness.
ble mud layers is common in the upper Hollin Internal truncation surfaces (i.e., reactivation sur-
(wells SA 122, SA 126, and SA 130), Napo T faces) generally dip at lower angles than dips of
(wells SA 126 and SA 133), and Napo U (wells associated cross-beds (Figure 7). Some cross-beds
SA 126, SA 129, and SA 132) intervals. This facies show mud-draped tangential toesets and fanning
is composed of light brown to dark brown (oil- (i.e., thickening) of the foresets (full-vortex struc-
stained), fine- to medium-grained, cross-bedded tures) (Figure 8A). Crinkled laminae are common,
sandstone with abundant mud drapes (34 mm to and they are conformable to ripple bed forms
8 cm in thickness) (Figure 5). Sand layers com- (Figure 8B). Small carbonaceous mudstone clasts
monly vary in thickness from 3 mm to 3 cm. Sand are present in some intervals (well SA 126, 9859 ft,
grains are moderately to poorly sorted and sub- 3006.9 m). Individual sandstone beds range in
rounded. Depositional matrix is generally low thickness from 5 cm to 2 m. Amalgamated units are
with visual estimates of sand near 100%. Mud 510 m thick (e.g., Figure 9).
658 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
Description
Heterolithic facies with flaser-bedded sandstone
and rhythmites is rare in the lower Hollin (well SA
133) but common in the upper Hollin (wells SA
122 and SA 126), Napo T (wells SA 126, SA 130,
and SA 133), and Napo U (wells SA 126, SA 129,
and SA 132) intervals. This facies is composed of
light gray, very fine grained, ripple-bedded sand-
stone with abundant mud drapes (23 mm to 1 cm
thick). Sands are poorly sorted and subrounded.
Depositional matrix varies from moderate to high
because sand comprises 50100% of this facies.
Flaser bedding is diagnostic of this facies (Figure
11). Rhythmic bedding (rhythmites) of sand and
mud layers is common (Figure 12). Double mud lay-
ers (Figure 13), wavy bedding (Figure 13), and
lenticular bedding are also common. Reddish
brown elongate mudstone clasts (siderite?) are also
present (Figure 14A). Dimensions of clasts are up
to 7 cm long and 1.5 cm thick. Carbonaceous, glau-
conitic, and micaceous fragments are dispersed
throughout. In some intervals, there is a concentra-
tion of carbonaceous fragments and plant resins
(Figure 15). These resin (i.e., amber) particles are
golden yellow in color and vary in size from a few
millimeters to a centimeter.
Crinkled laminae are also associated with this
facies and are common in some upper Hollin inter- Figure 7Core photograph showing sandstone with
vals (Figure 14B). Merging of crinkled laminae is mud-draped reactivation surface (arrow). Note steeply
present (Figure 14B). Individual sandstone beds dipping cross-stratification below reactivation surface.
range in thickness from 3 to 35 cm (well SA 126, Tidal sand bar facies. Upper Hollin, 9887 ft (3015.5 m),
upper Hollin). Amalgamated units show a thickness Sacha 130 well.
of up to 5 m (well SA 126, Napo U).
Bioturbation is common, and some intervals in
the Napo T contain Rhyzocorallium (well SA 133,
9690 ft, 2955.4 m; well SA 126, 9660 ft, 2946.3 m) Associated intervals of concentrated carbonaceous
and Ophiomorpha trace fossils (well SA 133, 9698 fragments with resin particles may be interpreted as
ft, 2957.8 m). Napo U cores exhibit Skolithos (well a marsh environment (Figure 15); however, we give
SA 132, 9411 ft, 2870.3 m) and Ophiomorpha trace little importance to marsh facies because it compris-
fossils (well SA 132, 9418 ft, 2872.4 m). In some es less than 1% of all cored intervals. Also, evidence
cases, this lithofacies grades vertically into bioturbat- of rooting is lacking. Conceivably, these carbona-
ed glauconitic sandstone (i.e., sandy shelf). ceous fragments were transported onto the tidal flat.
Figure 8(A) Core photograph showing cross-bedded fine-grained sandstone with tangential lower contacts and
mud-draped toesets. Note fanning of the foreset or full-vortex structure (i.e., double-headed arrow). Also note the
lower bounding surface with wavy mud drapes. Tidal sand bar facies. Upper Hollin, 9880 ft (3013.4 m), Sacha 130
well. (B) Core photograph showing fine-grained sandstone with multiple crinkled laminae composed of mud layers
(horizontal arrow). Note crinkled laminae are conformable to ripple bed forms (vertical arrow). Tidal sand bar
facies. Lower Hollin, 9932 ft (3029.2 m), Sacha 133 well.
Mud-draped silty ripples and double mud layers, as other environments. Because of the presence of
composed of clay laminae 23 mm thick, are pres- double mud layers and rhythmites, this facies is
ent (Figure 16). Thick-thin alternations of silt and interpreted as a subtidal mud flat (Nio and Yang,
clay layers show cyclicity (Figure 17); they are 1991). Thick-thin alternations of silt and clay layers
called rhythmites. showing cyclicity have been interpreted to repre-
Carbonaceous fragments are common, and sent tidal influence on inner estuarine sediments
siderite layers and pyrite nodules are rare. This (Kuecher et al., 1990). The silt layers represent trac-
facies ranges in thickness from several cm to 3 m tion deposition from ebb and flood tides, whereas
and is commonly associated with tidal channel and the clay layers represent deposition from suspension
tidal sand bar facies. during slack-water periods. The thin layers are inter-
preted to be deposits of neap tides and the thick lay-
ers to be deposits of spring tides. The absence of
Interpretation burrows in this facies suggests that either the rate of
Lenticular bedding is common in tidal-flat envi- sedimentation was too high or the salinity was too
ronments (Reineck and Wunderlich, 1968), as well low to support burrowing organisms. We envision a
662 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
Figure 9Sedimentological
log of core from the Sacha
130 well showing tidal
sand bar facies overlying
fluvial channel facies,
indicative of a transgressive
phase. Lower to upper
Hollin. Note that these
cored facies show blocky
log motif (see Figure 3).
See Figure 4 for
explanation of symbols.
relatively level area of mud (silt and clay) accumula- grains are moderately to poorly sorted and subround-
tion along the margins of an estuary. The marginal ed. Some intervals are argillaceous, with high deposi-
area, which we call a subtidal mud flat, was likely tional matrix (>10%). Sand comprises 80100% of
covered by shallow water. this facies. Bioturbation is ubiquitous (Figure 18).
Glauconite content is up to 40% in the Napo T (well
SA 133, 9688 ft, 2954.8 m). We observed faint planar
Bioturbated Glauconitic Sandstone cross-stratification in the upper Hollin (well SA 129,
(Sandy Shelf) 9951 ft, 3035 m). Mudstone clasts (4 cm) and mud
layers are also present. Calcareous pelecypod frag-
Description ments and Rhyzocorallium and Ophiomorpha trace
Bioturbated glauconitic sandstone is present in the fossils are evident. Pyrite and siderite nodules are rare.
upper Hollin (wells SA 126 and SA 129) and Napo T Individual depositional units are difficult to recognize
(wells SA 129 and SA 133) intervals (Figure 18). This because of bed destruction by bioturbation. This
facies is composed of greenish gray to light brown facies reaches thicknesses of 6 m or more due to
(oil-stained), very fine to fine-grained sandstone. Sand amalgamation.
Shanmugam et al. 663
Figure 14(A) Core photograph showing fine-grained sandstone with elongate mudstone (sideritic?) clasts (arrow).
Tidal sand-flat facies. Upper Hollin, 9841.5 ft (3001.6 m), Sacha 126 well. (B) Core photograph showing fine-grained
sandstone with crinkled laminae (arrows). Note merging of crinkled laminae in the middle. Tidal sand flat facies,
upper Hollin, 9870 ft (3010.3 m), Sacha 126 well.
666 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
Figure 15Sedimentological
log of core from the
Sacha 126 well, upper
Hollin. See Figure 4 for
explanation of symbols.
DEPOSITIONAL ENVIRONMENTS AND cyclicity (muddy tidal rhythmites), (4) double mud
MODELS layers, (5) cross-beds with mud-draped foresets, (6)
bidirectional (herringbone) cross-bedding, (7) reacti-
Evidence for Tidal Processes vation surfaces, (8) crinkled laminae, (9) elongate
mudstone clasts, (10) full-vortex structures, (11)
Tidal processes and related depositional features flaser bedding, (12) wavy bedding, and (13) lentic-
have been discussed by many workers (e.g., Klein, ular bedding.
1970; Visser, 1980; Terwindt, 1981; Banerjee, 1989; Diurnal inequality and tidal cyclicity are consid-
Nio and Yang, 1991). Sedimentary features indica- ered to be diagnostic properties of clastic tidal
tive of tidal processes in the Hollin and Napo for- deposits (de Boer et al., 1989; Kuecher et al., 1990;
mations include the following (see Table 6): (1) Nio and Young, 1991). Most areas of the Earth
heterolithic facies, (2) rhythmic alternation of sand- experience semidiurnal (i.e., two tides per day)
stone-shale couplets (sandy tidal rhythmites), (3) periodicity (de Boer et al., 1989). One key element
thick-thin alternations of silt and clay layers showing of the tidal system is that alternating high and low
Shanmugam et al. 667
Figure 20Outcrop photograph showing an angular unconformity (arrow and dashed line) between the basal con-
tact of the Hollin Formation and the underlying Misahualli volcanics. Hollin Loreto Coca Road (see Figure 1 for
location). The basal part of the Hollin Formation exhibits features of both fluvial and tidal channel facies (see Fig-
ure 21 for a measured section).
Figure 21Sedimentological
log of the outcrop at Hollin
Loreto Coca Road (see
Figure 1 for location).
Note base Cretaceous
unconformity and its
angular relationship with
underlying volcanics.
The measured interval
is interpreted to be
composed of mixed
fluvial and tidal channel
facies. See Figure 4 for
explanation of symbols.
into two end members (Figure 24): (1) wave-dominated general model proposed for a tide-dominated estuary
estuary and (2) tide-dominated estuary. Bay-head by Dalrymple et al. (1992). We propose the following
deltas, central basins, flood-tidal deltas, washovers, general stages of deposition for the Hollin Formation
and barrier bars, although they may be influenced by (oldest to youngest) following the regional uplift and
tides, characterize wave-dominated estuaries. In the erosion of the Misahualli volcanics (Figure 25):
Hollin and Napo formations of the Sacha area, we do
not recognize any of these wave-dominated deltaic Stage 1: Minor fluvial channels (low-sinuosity
facies. streams) and common tide-dominated estuary dur-
We do recognize, however, major facies of a tide- ing lower Hollin deposition.
dominated estuary. Evidence for a tide-dominated estu- Stage 2: Well-developed tide-dominated estuary
ary in the Hollin, Napo T, and Napo U includes and shelf environments during lower and upper
(1) an erosional unconformity at the base of the Hollin deposition.
Hollin, (2) tidal channels and associated fluvial chan- Stage 3: Drowned tide-dominated estuary during
nels, (3) tidal sand bars, (4) tidal sand flats, (5) subtidal upper Hollin deposition.
mud flats, (6) sandy and muddy shelves, and (7) deep- Stage 4: Well-developed shelf environments (i.e.,
ening-upward (i.e., transgressive) successions. In par- complete drowning) with glauconitic sands and muds
ticular, the preservation of delicate mud drapes indi- during the final phase of upper Hollin deposition.
cates a protected environment, such as an estuary. During Napo T deposition, stages 2, 3, and 4
The depositional model proposed for the Hollin were repeated. Following deposition of the B
and Napo formations is a modified version of the limestone and overlying shales, stages 2, 3, and 4
Shanmugam et al. 671
Table 5. Comparison of Interpretations of Depositional Facies for the Hollin Loreto Coca Road Outcrop by De
Souza Cruz (1989) and by This Study
Table 6. Comparison of Interpretations of Depositional Facies for the Hollin and Napo Formations by White et al.*
and by This Study
were repeated again during deposition of the Napo U Napo T, and Napo U formations to be tide-dominat-
interval. Finally, deposition of the A limestone took place ed estuarine facies, we suggest that the tidal environ-
(see Figure 3). The carbonate intervals signify regional trans- ment persisted throughout the deposition of the Hollin
gressive deposition. Because we interpret the upper Hollin, and Napo formations (i.e., time transgressive).
672 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
Figure 22Sedimentological
log of core from the
Sacha 132 well Napo
U sand showing a
transgressive
(deepening-upward)
phase. Note that this
cored interval,
composed of multiple
depositional facies,
shows a fining-upward
log motif (see Figure 23).
In the absence of core,
this interval could be
misinterpreted as a
channel-fill facies based
on a fining-upward log
motif. See Figure 4 for
explanation of symbols.
Although both the Hollin and Napo formations Tide-dominated estuaries commonly occur in
exhibit similar depositional facies and episodes of mesotidal and macrotidal ranges (Harris, 1988). Davies
drowning, there is an important difference. The basal (1964) defined microtidal, mesotidal, and macrotidal
Hollin is marked by a major angular unconformity, ranges as 02 m, 24 m, and >4 m, respectively; there-
indicating erosion prior to deposition. In contrast, the fore, we infer that the tidal range for the Sacha area was
Napo T and U formations rest on shelf facies with- likely more than 2 m. Double mud layers in cross-beds
out any evidence for erosion. Stratigraphic correla- of the Hollin and Napo resemble those of the modern
tions show that the shelf facies beneath the tidal facies Oosterschelde estuary in the Netherlands (Visser,
in the Napo maintains a uniform thickness regionally, 1980). The mouth of the Oosterschelde estuary is 7.4
indicating a lack of incision prior to Napo deposition km wide, and its tidal range is 3.5 m. In terms of depo-
(Figure 26). sitional processes, large-scale bed forms observed in
Shanmugam et al. 673
Figure 24Morphological
components in plan view
of two end members of
estuarine models.
(A) Spatial distribution of
facies in a tide-dominated
estuary. (B) Spatial
distribution of facies in a
wave-dominated estuary.
Vertical dashed lines
show facies boundaries.
Wave-dominated estuarine
facies are considered to
be the typical fill of an
incised valley (see Figure
27). Simplified from
Dalrymple et al. (1992).
Reprinted with permis-
sion from SEPM.
discernible incision at the base of Napo T and considered to be the result of uplift and erosion
Napo U reservoirs (Figure 26). In fact, both the associated with the early Mesozoic tectonic activity
Napo T shale and Napo U shale maintain their in the Oriente basin (Dashwood and Abbotts, 1990;
thickness through the entire length of the north- Balkwill et al., 1995). Although most sequence
south cross section of the Sacha field (Figure 26). stratigraphers consider uplift under the all-inclusive
These underlying shale units should exhibit a lateral term relative sea-level fall, we wish to emphasize
change in thickness, if they had indeed experienced the tectonic origin of the base Cretaceous uncon-
a major downcutting or incision. This is perhaps the formity. Estimated tectonic subsidence rate during
most convincing evidence for lack of incision deposition of the Hollin and Napo formations
beneath the Napo T and Napo U sands; howev- ranges from 3.714 to 9.143 m/m.y. for the middle
er, if an incised valley is much wider than the length north of the Oriente basin (Jaillard, 1995), indicat-
of our stratigraphic cross section, then we cannot ing that the basin was tectonically active during the
establish the existence of an incised valley without Cretaceous deposition.
additional seismic data and a regional study. The current trend in sequence stratigraphy is to
The regional sequence boundary in an incised explain most coastal erosion and deposition related
valley-fill system is related to relative sea level fall to incised valley-fill systems by allocyclic processes,
(Zaitlin et al., 1994b). In the Sacha field area, the such as sea level changes (Zaitlin et al., 1994b); how-
angular unconformity at the base of the Hollin is ever, there is no evidence for subaerial exposure in
Shanmugam et al. 675
Figure 25Interpreted
paleogeography of the
Hollin Formation showing
four stages of evolution
from bottom (older) to top
(younger). (1) Depositional
model for the lower Hollin
showing fluvial and
tide-dominated estuarine
facies. During this time,
deposition took place
above the unconformity
that separates the Hollin
from the underlying
Misahualli volcanics.
(2) Depositional model for
the Lower to upper Hollin
showing tide-dominated
estuarine and shelf facies.
Note well-developed sand
bars and sand flats in the
estuary. During this time,
tidal facies were deposited
over fluvial and tidal facies.
(3) Depositional model for
the upper Hollin showing
drowned tide-dominated
estuarine facies with
well-developed open
shelf facies. During this
time, shelf facies were
deposited over tidal facies.
(4) Depositional model for
the upper Hollin showing
complete drowning of the
area by transgression and
establishment of
widespread shelf facies.
Approximate position of
the Sacha area is shown
by a rectangle to illustrate
dominant facies
encountered in the cores.
676
Oriente Basin, Ecuador
Figure 26North-south stratigraphic well-log cross section across the Sacha field. Each correlatable unit (e.g., upper Hollin) is composed of
multiple depositional facies (e.g., tidal channels, tidal bars). Note the uniform thickness of Napo T and U shales, suggesting a lack of major
incision. See Figure 1 for line of cross section.
Shanmugam et al. 677
Figure 27Generalized model for incised valley-fill system. Note that the incised valley is filled with wave-dominated
estuarine facies (see Figure 24B). Also note coarsening-upward trends of parasequences. From Zaitlin et al. (1994b).
Reprinted with permission from SEPM.
the Sacha cores that would indicate a lowering of sea fluvial deposits overlie shallow-marine parasequences
level. In contrast, there is ample evidence for deepen- (Figure 27); however, such a relationship is absent in
ing or drowning in the lower Hollin, upper Hollin, the study area because tidal and fluvial facies of the
Napo T (Sacha 133), and Napo U intervals, indi- Hollin unconformably overlie the Misahualli vol-
cating possible rises in sea level. Autocyclic process- canics, not shallow-marine deposits (Figure 21). More
es, such as lateral migration of facies, can also explain important, there is no evidence in the core for fluvial
the vertical changes in facies. erosion within the Napo Formation in the Sacha area.
An incised valley-fill system is characterized by a In fact, the fluvial facies are completely absent in the
basinward shift in facies (Zaitlin et al., 1994b). This Napo Formation in our study area.
is typically the result of a fluvial valley incising into Coarsening-upward parasequences are one charac-
the exposed shelf during falling sea level. As a result, teristic of incised valley-fill systems, often occurring
678
Oriente Basin, Ecuador
Figure 28East-west seismic profile across Sacha field showing the base Cretaceous angular unconformity. Note truncated reflections suggesting
erosion along the unconformity. Also note a lack of deep incision at the base of the Hollin and within the Napo formations. See Figure 1 for posi-
tion of seismic profile.
Shanmugam et al. 679
both beneath the incision and within the valley fill winnowed the associated fines. Measured perme-
(Figure 27). In describing properties of parase- ability (horizontal) ranges from 1 to 9300 md.
quences, Kamola and Van Wagoner (1995, p. 29) stat- Although mud drapes are ubiquitous in this
ed, In siliciclastic, shallow-marine settings, parase- facies, they are not considered to be major perme-
quences are composed of beds and bedsets that ability barriers because they tend to be too thin
record continuous, gradual upward shallowing. . . . (i.e., 34 mm thick) and discontinuous. This facies
Most parasequences are marked by an upward-coars- is expected to have good vertical and lateral com-
ening change in grain size, an upward decrease in munication.
mud, an upward increase in thickness of the beds, This reservoir facies is characterized by an elon-
and an upward change in the beds and the trace fos- gate bar geometry, parallel to depositional dip.
sils reflecting an upward decrease in water depth. Vertical amalgamation of sand packages is a diag-
The grain-size and bed-thickness trends are reversed nostic feature of this facies (e.g., well SA 130,
in parasequences composed of subtidal-tidal flat upper Hollin), where multiple bars are stacked
deposits, where deposition still records an upward both laterally and vertically, and the deposit is more
decrease in water depth. As one might expect, sheetlike. Individual bars range in thickness from 5 cm
parasequences do not occur in the underlying pre- to 2 m. Amalgamated units show a thickness of up
Hollin Misahualli volcanics. More important, coarsen- to 10 m.
ing upward and thickening-upward trends are absent As indicated by the gamma-ray curve, this facies
in the Hollin and Napo formations. Although parase- is characteristically clean and exhibits a blocky
quences in subtidal environments may show fining- character; however, the wireline-log motif alone is
upward trends, the Hollin and Napo formations do not a reliable indicator of depositional facies. For
not show shallowing-upward trends that are charac- example, the blocky log motif in the Sacha 130 well
teristic of some parasequences. (Figure 3) represents both fluvial channel and tidal
An incised valley-fill system is generally charac- sand bar facies (Figure 9).
terized by a vertical association of wave-dominated
estuarine facies composed of fluvial, bayhead delta,
central basin, and barrier beach in an ascending Reservoir Facies II
order (Figure 27); however, wave-dominated estu-
arine facies are absent in the Sacha core. Reservoir facies II comprises both tidal and flu-
Outcrop, core, seismic, or well data do not cor- vial channels. This facies commonly occurs in the
roborate an incised valley-fill model, applied to the inner estuarine setting. Although both fluvial and
Hollin and Napo formations by other workers. tidal channels are cross-bedded, the tidal channels
Estuarine facies are quite complex, as this study are distinguished by their mud drapes. This facies is
shows, and may not always fit into a general incised composed dominantly of medium- to fine-grained
valley-fill model. sand. Sand percentage is commonly 90100%.
Sands in this facies are not as clean when compared
to tidal sand bars because of moderate matrix con-
RESERVOIR FACIES tent; therefore, reservoir quality is somewhat
lower. Measured permeability (horizontal) ranges
In the core and outcrop examined, we recognize from 30 to 3400 md.
four reservoir facies on the basis of lithofacies (i.e., We infer that most of these channel sands are
sand percent), inferred sand-body geometry, bed lenticular in geometry. The tidal channel facies is
continuity and connectedness, and depositional 12 m thick. The fluvial channel facies is up to 5 m
permeability barriers. All four facies types generally in core and up to 10 m in outcrop. Fluvial channels
exhibit similar porosity values (1520%), but their tend to exhibit slightly better reservoir quality than
permeability values differ. tidal channels.
Comparing the wireline logs to the core, this
facies exhibits fining-upward and blocky motifs.
Reservoir Facies I Again, caution must be exercised in using log motifs
to interpret depositional facies because both trans-
Reservoir facies I comprises tidal sand bars that gressive sequences and fluvial sequences can show a
are dominantly composed of fine- to medium- fining-upward log motif. For example, the cored
grained sand. This facies is most common in the interval of the Napo U in the Sacha 132 well shows
outer estuarine setting (Johnson and Levell, 1995), a transgressive phase of deposition in which tidal
closely associated with tidal sand flats (reservoir sand bar facies grades vertically into shelf facies (see
facies III). Sand percentage in this facies is common- Figure 22). This transgressive interval is seen as a fin-
ly 100%. The sand is clean and devoid of deposition- ing-upward trend in wireline logs (see Figure 23). In
al matrix because strong tidal traction processes the absence of core, this fining-upward trend, based
680 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
solely on its wireline log motif, could be misinter- This facies varies from bars to sheetlike geometry.
preted as a fluvial channel facies. Thicknesses of individual units are difficult to deter-
mine, but this facies can reach a thickness of 6 m or
more due to vertical amalgamation. Commonly, there
Reservoir Facies III is a gradation between this facies and the three tidal
reservoir facies.
Reservoir facies III is composed of tidal sand-flat
deposits and comprises dominantly fine-grained
sand. The most diagnostic feature of this facies is its CONCLUSIONS
flaser, wavy, and lenticular bedding. Sand percent-
ages of this facies range from 50 to 100%. Sands are The Cretaceous Hollin and Napo formations in
fine grained and have a high matrix content. The the Sacha field are prolific producers of hydrocar-
sands thus are not as clean as sands of tidal sand bars bons in the Oriente basin, Ecuador. To enhance fur-
and channels; therefore, the reservoir quality of this ther oil production, it is important to gain a clear
facies is lower than the tidal sand bar and channel understanding of the reservoir in terms of its depo-
facies. Measured permeability (horizontal) ranges sitional origin. A sedimentological analysis using
from 0.1 to 1000 md. 516 ft (157 m) of conventional core from seven
Reservoir facies III is one of the most common wells established seven depositional facies, namely
facies in the Hollin, Napo T, and Napo U inter- (1) fluvial channels, (2) tidal channels, (3) tidal
vals (Tables 24). Although this facies can occur sand bars, (4) tidal sand flats, (5) subtidal mud flats,
throughout the estuary, it commonly occurs land- (6) sandy shelves, and (7) muddy shelves. The
ward of the tidal bars. Sand bodies are likely to be seven depositional facies can be grouped into four
laterally extensive (i.e., sheetlike geometry) and reservoir facies: (1) tidal sand bars with excellent
are often connected to tidal sand bars. The sand reservoir properties (i.e., 100% sand, low matrix,
bars tended to migrate over the sand flats during elongate bar geometry), (2) fluvial and tidal chan-
megaripple formation. As a result, these connect- nels with good reservoir properties (i.e., 90100%
ed facies may behave as single reservoir f low sand, moderate matrix, lenticular geometry), (3)
units. In the tidal-flat facies, neap bundles with tidal sand f lats with moderate properties (i.e.,
higher numbers of crinkled laminae (i.e., mud lay- 50100% sand, high matrix, sheet geometry), and
ers) may be of poorer reservoir quality than spring (4) shelf sands with relatively poor properties (i.e.,
bundles with fewer crinkled laminae. Individual 80100% sand with high matrix and glauconite, bar
sandstone units range in thickness from 3 to 35 to sheet geometry).
cm. Vertically amalgamated units show thickness- Based on the presence of mud drapes on bed
es of up to 5 m. In wireline logs, this facies forms, heterolithic facies, double mud layers, bidi-
exhibits an irregular character in comparison to rectional (i.e., herringbone) cross-bedding, sandy
the other two sand-rich facies (i.e., reservoir tidal rhythmites, muddy tidal rhythmites, crinkled
facies I and II) because it contains more intercalat- laminae, flaser bedding, wavy bedding, lenticular
ed finer grained material. bedding, and deepening-upward (i.e., transgres-
sive) sequences, we interpret the cored intervals of
the Hollin and Napo formations to represent tide-
Reservoir Facies IV dominated estuarine facies.
We propose four stages of deposition for the
Reservoir facies IV is composed of shallow- Hollin Formation (oldest to youngest) following the
marine shelf sands. This reservoir facies is consid- regional uplift and erosion of the Misahualli vol-
ered to be the least important of the four types canics: stage 1 (lower Hollin deposition) represents
because of (1) high glauconite content, which can minor fluvial channels (low-sinuosity streams) and
result in considerable compaction and reduction in common tide-dominated estuary; stage 2 (lower and
primary porosity, (2) high depositional matrix, upper Hollin deposition) represents a well devel-
which can occlude primary porosity, and (3) high oped tide-dominated estuary; stage 3 (upper Hollin
bioturbation, which can mix sand and mud result- deposition) represents a drowning of tide-dominated
ing in a poorly sorted texture. Measured permeabil- estuary; and stage 4 (upper Hollin deposition) rep-
ity (horizontal) ranges from 0.06 to 150 md. The resents well-developed shelf environments in the
sandstones are very fine to fine grained. The sand is Sacha field area. Stages 24 are repeated during
moderately to poorly sorted and subrounded. Some Napo T and U deposition.
intervals are argillaceous because of the high depo- An important aspect of the proposed model is
sitional matrix. Sand content ranges from 80 to that tidal sand bars in the Sacha area are predict-
100%. Glauconite content is up to 40%. Calcareous ed to align in an east-west direction paralleling
shell fragments and bioturbation are ubiquitous. the direction of sediment transport, whereas the
Shanmugam et al. 681
conventional fluvio-deltaic model would predict Spring Canyon Member, Blackhawk Formation, Utah, in J. C.
north-southtrending distributary mouth bars with Van Wagoner and G. T. Bertram, eds., Sequence stratigraphy
of foreland basin depositsoutcrop and subsurface examples
an easterly sediment source. from the Cretaceous of North America: AAPG Memoir 64,
Outcrop, core, seismic, or well data do not cor- p. 2754.
roborate an incised valley-fill model, as applied to Klein, G. deV., 1970, Depositional and dispersal dynamics of
these deposits by other workers. Estuarine facies intertidal sand bars: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, v. 40,
p. 10951127.
are quite complex, as this study shows, and may not Kuecher, G. J., B. G. Woodland, and F. M. Broadhurst, 1990,
always fit into a general incised valley-fill model. Evidence of deposition from individual tides and of tidal cycles
from the Francis Creek Shale (host rock to the Mazon Creek
biota), Westphalian D (Pennsylvanian), northeastern Illinois:
REFERENCES CITED Sedimentary Geology, v. 68, p. 211221.
Lopez, R., and R. Vera, 1992, Characteristicas de la glauconita del
Balkwill, H. R., G. Rodriguez, F. I. Paredes, and, J. P. Almeida, nivel T de la Formacion Napo Y su relacion con el petroleo:
1995, Northern part of Oriente basin, Ecuador: reflection Escuela Politecnica Nacional, Segundas Jornadas en Ciencias
seismic expression of structures, in A. J. Tankard, R. Suarez, de la Tierra, Facultad de Geologia, Minas Y Petroleos, 16-19 de
and H. J. Welsink, eds., Petroleum basins of South America: dicimbre, Quito, p. 41.
AAPG Memoir 62, p. 559571. Macellari, C. E., 1988, Cretaceous paleogeography and
Banerjee, I., 1989, Tidal sand sheet origin of the transgressive depositional cycles of western South America: Journal of South
basal Colorado Sandstone (Albian): a subsurface study of the American Earth Sciences, v. 1, p. 373418.
Cessford field, southern Alberta: Bulletin of Canadian Mello, M. R., E. A. M. Koutsoukos, and W. Z. Erazo, 1995, The Napo
Petroleum Geology, v. 37, p. 117. Formation, Oriente basin, Ecuador: hydrocarbon source
Boyd, R., R. W. Dalrymple, and B. A. Zaitlin, 1992, Classification potential and paleo environmental assessment, in B. J. Katz, ed.,
of coastal sedimentary environments: Sedimentary Geology, Petroleum source rocks: Berlin, Springer-Verlag, p. 167181.
v. 80, p. 139150. Mutti, E., J. Rossell, G. Allen, F. Fonnesu, and M. Sgavetti, 1985,
Canfield, R. W., G. Bonilla, and R. K. Robins, 1982, Sacha oil field The Eocene Baronia tide dominated delta-shelf system in the
of Ecuadorian Oriente: AAPG Bulletin, v. 66, p. 10761090. Ager basin, in D. Mila and J. Rossell, eds., Excursion
Dalrymple, R. W., B. A. Zaitlin, and R. Boyd, 1992, Estuarine facies guidebook: 6th IAS European Regional Meeting, Leida, Spain,
models: conceptual basis and stratigraphic implications: p. 577600.
Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, v. 62, p. 11301146. Nio, S.-D., and C.-S. Yang, 1991, Diagnostic attributes of clastic
Dashwood, M. F., and I. L. Abbotts, 1990, Aspects of the tidal deposits: a review, in D. G. Smith, B. A. Zaitlin, G. E.
petroleum geology of the Oriente basin, Ecuador, in J. Brooks, Reinson, and R. A. Rahmani, eds., Clastic tidal sedimentology:
ed., Classic petroleum provinces: Geological Society of Calgary, Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists, p. 327.
London Special Publication No. 50, p. 89117. Odin, G. S., 1985, Significance of green particles (glaucony,
Davies, J. L., 1964, A morphogenetic approach to world bertherine, chlorite) in arenites, in G. G. Zuffa, ed.,
shorelines: Z. Geomorphology, v. 8, p. 127142. Provenance of arenites: Dordrecht, D. Reidel, p. 279307.
de Boer, P. L., A. P. Oost, and M. J. Visser, 1989, The diurnal Reineck, H. E., and F. Wunderlich, 1968, Classification and origin
inequality of the tide as a parameter for recognizing tidal of flaser and lenticular bedding: Sedimentology, v. 11,
influences: Journal of Sedimentary Petrology, v. 59, p. 99104.
p. 912921. Shanley, K. W., P. McCabe, and R. D. Hettinger, 1992, Tidal
De Souza Cruz, C. E., 1989, Cretaceous sedimentary facies and influence in Cretaceous fluvial strata from Utah, USA: a key to
depositional environments, Oriente basin, Ecuadora field sequence stratigraphic interpretation: Sedimentology, v. 39,
trip guide: Tercer Congreso Andino de la Industria del p. 905930.
Petroleo, Petrobras Research Center, Brazil, 65 p. Shanmugam, G., M. Poffenberger, and J. Toro lava, 1998, Tide-
Elliott, T., 1986, Siliciclastic shorelines, in H. G. Reading, ed., dominated estuarine facies in the Hollin and Napo (T and
Sedimentary environments and facies: Oxford, Blackwell U) formations (Cretaceous), Sacha field, Oriente basin,
Scientific Publications, p. 155188. Ecuador: 1998 AAPG Annual Convention, Extended Abstracts,
Feines, H., and J.-P. Tastet, 1998, Facies and architecture of an v. 2, K-Z, p. A590A594.
estuarine tidal bar (the Trompeloup bar, Gironde estuary, SW Smith, L. R., 1989, Regional variations in formation water salinity,
France): Marine Geology, v. 150, p. 149169. Hollin and Napo formations (Cretaceous), Oriente basin,
Galloway, W. E., 1975, Process framework for describing the Ecuador: AAPG Bulletin, v. 73, p. 757776.
morphologic and stratigraphic evolution of deltaic Terwindt, J. H. J., 1981, Origin and sequences of sedimentary
depositional systems, in M. L. Broussard, ed., Deltas, models structures in inshore mesotidal deposits of the North Sea, in
for exploration: Houston, Houston Geological Society, S. D. Nio, R. T. E. Shuttenhelm, and Tj. C. E. Van Weering,
p. 8798. eds., Holocene marine sedimentation in the North Sea Basin:
Gansser, A., 1973, Facts and theories on the Andes: Journal of the International Association of Sedimentologists, Special
Geological Society of London, v. 129, p. 83131. Publication No. 5, p. 426.
Harris, P., 1988, Large-scale bedforms as indicators of mutually Visser, M. J., 1980, Neap-spring cycles reflected in Holocene
evasive sand transport and the sequential infilling of wide- subtidal large-scale bedform deposits: a preliminary note:
mouthed estuaries: Sedimentology, v. 57, p. 273298. Geology, v. 8, p. 543546.
Jaillard, E., 1995, Sedimentologia del Cretaceo y Paleogeno de la Walker, R. G., 1992, Facies, facies models and modern
Cuenca Oriental del Edcuador, Informe Preliminar del stratigraphic concepts, in R. G. Walker and N. P. James, eds.,
convenio OSTROM-PETROPRODUCCION, Quito, 96 p. Facies models: response to sea level change: Geological
Johnson, H. D., and B. K. Levell, 1995, Sedimentology of a Association of Canada, p. 114.
transgressive, estuarine sand complex: the Lower Cretaceous White, H. J., R. A. Skopec, F. A. Ramirez, J. A. Rodas, and
Woburn Sands (lower Greenland), southern England, in G. Bonila, 1995, Reservoir characterization of the Hollin and
G. Plint, ed., Sedimentary facies analysis: IAS Special Napo formations, Western Oriente basin, in A. J. Tankard,
Publication No. 22, p. 1746. R. Suarez, and H. J. Welsink, eds., Petroleum basins of South
Kamola, D. L., and J. C. Van Wagoner, 1995, Stratigraphy and America: AAPG Memoir 62, p. 573596.
facies architecture of parasequences with examples from the Zaitlin, B. A., R. Boyd, R. W. Dalrymple, and D. Leckie, 1994a, The
682 Oriente Basin, Ecuador
stratigraphic organization of incised valley systems: stratigraphic organization of incised-valley systems associated
implications to hydrocarbon exploration and production: with relative sea-level change, in R. W. Dalrymple and B. A.
Canadian Society of Petroleum Geologists, Calgary, 17 p. Zaitlin, eds., Incised-valley systems: origin and sedimentary
Zaitlin, B. A., R. W. Dalrymple, and R. Boyd, 1994b, The sequences: SEPM Special Publication 51, p. 4560.