Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
PRACTICE
canal treatment since A clinical guide to
endodontics was published.
Provides greater guidance on the use
P. V. Carrotte1 of NiTi endodontic instruments, now
considered by many to be essential for
effective canal preparation.
Discusses developments in irrigation and
obturation, both essential for the best
possible prognosis of treatment.
This is the first of two opinion papers that aim to provide a review of changes and developments that have occurred within
the field of root canal treatment for both permanent and primary teeth since the publication in 2004 of the BDJs textbook
A clinical guide to endodontics. This, the first part, considers the changes in thinking and practice that have occurred with
regard to the treatment of permanent teeth, in particular the continued significant move toward the use of nickel titanium
rotary instruments. Knowledge of the changes discussed in this paper is essential both for the best possible prognosis of
treatment, and when obtaining informed or valid consent to treatment.
chamber, canal orifices, tertiary den- PREPARING THE ROOT will expose micro-organisms in dentine
CANAL SYSTEM
tine deposits, etc, and this leads to tubules and facilitate greater contact
greatly reduced operator stress. Cou- Irrigation with biofi lms, but research evidence of
pled with the resultant improved opera- the benefits of smear layer removal is
tor posture and comfort, the purchase Success in root canal treatment is limited. Practitioners should always be
of these adjuncts to treatment is highly dependent upon the removal of all aware that some micro-organisms are
recommended and will result in better infective agents and necrotic material more resistant to the effect of sodium
root canal treatment to a significantly from the entire root canal system. The hypochlorite than others, for example
higher standard. purpose of root canal instruments is to Radcliffe et al.5 found Enterococcus fae-
The reader who seeks guidance on create sufficient space for the ingress calis to be resistant. Bonsor et al.6 have
the quality standards for endodontic of effective irrigant solutions. Unless published work on the use of photo-
treatment expected of the competent appropriate antibacterial solutions are active disinfection showing improved
practitioner should refer to the recently able to penetrate to the apical constric- canal disinfection and there is ongoing
updated consensus report of the Euro- tion and remain in contact with the canal research into this technique. It should be
pean Society of Endodontology.3 This is walls and dentine tubules for a sufficient remembered when selecting an appropri-
a very useful document when revising length of time, micro-organisms may ate irrigant that as well as antibacterial
for both undergraduate and postgradu- remain in the canal. However effective action, irrigants should possess addi-
ate examinations. the obturation might be, late failure is tional properties such as good detergent
There are, however, four areas where the probable consequence. Although action, low surface tension, good tissue
significant change in concept or prac- many papers have been published on dissolution and no noxious residues.
tice has occurred. Firstly, there has this subject over the years, the recent It must, of course, be stressed that
been a significant move away from the paper by Hsieh et al.4 merits considera- irrigation must be passive. The tip of the
step-back technique of canal prepara- tion. The researchers used thermal imag- needle should be advanced to within 3
tion using iso 2% taper hand fi les. Most ing to measure the penetration and flow mm of the apical constriction and then
UK and European dental schools are of irrigant throughout the root canal. withdrawn slightly. It is good practice to
now teaching the use of greater taper They compared the depth of penetration place a rubber stop or marker on the nee-
hand or rotary nickel titanium fi les in a of three sizes of irrigating needle, (23 dle to measure the exact depth of pene-
crown-down technique. Secondly, these gauge, 25 gauge and 27 gauge) with root tration. Light fi nger pressure only should
preparation techniques may require a canals prepared to different apical sizes be applied. If irrigant is expressed into
different method of canal obturation. using a standard step-back preparation. the periradicular tissues under pressure,
The long-accepted gold-standard norm They reported that unless the tip of the a severe inflammatory reaction may
of cold lateral compaction of master and needle was able to penetrate to 3 mm arise instantly, as detailed recently in
accessory gutta percha points with a root from the apical constriction, effective this Journal by Witton and Brennan.7
canal sealer may not be appropriate for irrigation was not achieved. Further- Should this occur, the patient should be
these greater taper techniques. Thirdly, more, to enable the fi nest 27 gauge nee- reassured that the swelling will resolve
there has been a significant move in dle to penetrate to this depth the canal in two to three days. Anti-inflammatory
the practice of endodontic surgery to must be prepared to at least size 30, for agents should be prescribed, together
the routine use of the operating micro- a 25 gauge needle to at least size 45 and with antibiotics as infected material
scope and mineral trioxide aggregate for a 23 gauge at least size 50. Addition- may have been expressed from the root
(MTA). Finally, the traditional materials ally, if the tip of the needle was held at 6 canal (Fig. 1).
and methods used in endodontic thera- mm from the apex, irrigant only flowed
pies for primary teeth have come under throughout the canal when the fi nest Instrumentation
scrutiny. The fi rst three of these will 27 gauge needle was used and the api- Nickel titanium (NiTi) alloy has particu-
be considered here, and a second paper cal preparation was size 50. Unfortu- lar characteristics of super-elasticity and
will be devoted to the subject of pul- nately the canals in this research were shape memory. This has facilitated con-
pal therapy in primary teeth. It should only prepared using standard iso 2% siderable improvement in canal shaping
be remembered, however, that the main taper hand fi les with the step-back tech- procedures, particularly in curved canals,
purpose of the BDJs Clinical Guide nique. It must be asked whether canals and it would appear that these have been
series is to provide practical informa- prepared with modern greater taper fi le adopted by the majority of practitioners.
tion to guide and instruct the general systems, as discussed later, would have Many reports have appeared in the den-
dental practitioner and undergradu- shown different results. tal literature suggesting that these tech-
ate student. Practitioners intending to Sodium hypochlorite remains the niques are leading to an improvement
perform endodontic surgery to todays irrigant of choice for routine cases. It is in the quality of root canal treatments.
accepted standards should refer to the generally accepted that a second irrig- Most of these have been based on canal
relevant specialist surgical texts and ant should be used to remove the smear preparations in the teaching laboratory,
undergo appropriate further training in layer, either EDTA or citric acid. It seems but Molander et al.8 report improve-
these techniques. logical that removing the smear layer ment in clinical performance as well.
second wave commences, creating more with this, the radiograph is indeed not seen in Figure 4 shows a working length
space coronally and allowing deeper required. It has been suggested by some fi lm of a tooth being treated following
penetration. The temptation to force an authorities that for medico-legal reasons the separation of a NiTi instrument in
instrument to widen and deepen a nar- a radiograph should always be taken one of the mesial canals. The double s-
row canal should always be resisted. If with either an endodontic instrument or shaped curvature of the canal can be
a narrow canal is proving difficult to a master gutta percha point. This advice seen clearly. Had this shape been iden-
negotiate to full working length then misunderstands the difference between tified before treatment commenced the
hand fi les should be used to prepare the these two methods of working length rotary instrument would have been kept
apex with far greater control. confi rmation. As stated before, provided well short of the second curve and the
Once the working length has been that the electronic measurement concurs apical part of the canal prepared using
confi rmed and the rotary instrument with that calculated from the pre-opera- hand-fi les, thus avoiding the fi le separa-
has been used to the apex, iso hand fi les tive fi lm then the electronic measure- tion. Figure 5 shows a radiograph of an
should be used to feel or gauge the size of ment will be more accurate than any extracted tooth explored during a rotary
the apex and enlarge it accordingly. Irri- radiographic estimation. A radiograph instrumentation laboratory class. Note
gation will then be effective to the apex would only be required if the electronic how the two canals in the mesial root
and the case prognosis will be improved. measurement did not concur with the unite in a common orifice.
The fi le is inserted to length and its fit estimated length. This may occur if there
checked simply by feel. If the tip is loose is a large coronal restoration or crown Obturation
at working length the apical preparation which is contacting the fi le, if there is There have been two significant devel-
should be enlarged. If the fi le is tight, salivary contamination of the access opments in canal obturation since A
even exhibiting slight tug-back on cavity, or in retreatment cases. In these clinical guide to endodontics was pub-
withdrawal, the preparation is complete. and other situations where the accuracy lished: the introduction of synthetic
of the electronic measurement appears fi lling materials and the further devel-
Working length unreliable, a radiograph must be exposed opment of matching taper instruments
There has been a great improvement in and the subjective estimate relied upon. and obturation devices.
the accuracy of apex locators in recent However, when working in posterior ResilonTM (Pentron Clinical Technolo-
years and some practitioners no longer teeth with complex root canals more gies, Wallingford, CT), a thermoplas-
expose a working length radiograph. information can be obtained from the tic synthetic polymer-based root fi lling
Provided a good pre-operative radio- working length radiograph than sim- material, was introduced to endodontics
graph is available to calculate the esti- ple length confi rmation. Curves in the in 2004.9 The authors claimed that in
mated working length, and provided canals are particularly important when vitro research showed significantly less
the electronic measurement accords using rotary instruments. The radiograph apical microleakage around this material
resorptions and perforation repair. 1. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excel- 10. Taranu R, Wegerer U, Roggendorf M, Ebert J,
lence. Prophylaxis against infective endocarditis. Petschelt A, Frankenberger R. Leakage analysis of
Furthermore, a number of papers have London: National Institute for Health and Clinical three modern root filling materials after 90 days of
appeared on the subject of pulp capping Excellence, 2008. NICE clinical guideline 64. storage. Presented at the 12th Biennial Congress
2. Buhrley L J, Barrows M J, BeGole E A. Effect of of the European Society of Endodontology, Sep-
with MTA, although this was originally magnification on locating the MB2 canal in maxil- tember 15-17 2005, Dublin, Ireland.
described in 1996.18 The material, a soft lary molars. J Endod 2003; 28: 324-327. 11. Gulsahi K, Cehreli Z, Kuraner T, Dagli F. Sealer
3. European Society of Endodontology. Quality area associated with cold lateral condensation of
white paste, is not difficult to use once guidelines for endodontic treatment: consensus gutta-percha and warm coated carrier systems in
the practitioner has mastered the cor- report of the European Society of Endodontology. canals prepared with various rotary NiTi systems.
Int Endod J 2006; 39: 921-930. Int Endod J 2007; 40: 274-281.
rect mixing and placement techniques. 4. Hsieh Y D, Gau C H, Kung Wu S F, Shen E C, Hsu 12. Klevant F J, Eggink C O. The effect of canal prepa-
It is anticipated that MTA will quickly P W, Fu E. Dynamic recording of irrigating fluid ration on periapical disease. Int Endod J 1983;
distribution in root canals using thermal image 16: 68-75.
become a routine part of everyday gen-
analysis. Int Endod J 2007; 40: 11-17. 13. Carrotte P. Surgical endodontics. Br Dent J 2005;
eral practice. 5. Radcliffe C E, Potouridou L, Qureshi R et al. 198: 71-79.
Antimicrobial activity of varying concentra- 14. Friedman S. Treatment outcome and prognosis of
tions of sodium hypochlorite on the endodontic endodontic therapy. In rstavik D and Pitt Ford T R
CONCLUSIONS microorganisms Actinomyces israelii, A. naeslundii, (eds) Essential endodontology. Chapter 15. Oxford:
Dental practice continues to develop in Candida albicans and Enterococcus faecalis. Int Blackwell Science, 1998.
Endod J 2004; 37: 438-446. 15. Friedman S. Expected outcomes in the prevention
both practical techniques and scientific 6. Bonsor S, Nichol R, Reid T, Pearson G. An alterna- and treatment of apical periodontitis. In rstavik
knowledge and understanding. The mod- tive regimen for root canal disinfection. Br Dent J D and Pitt Ford T R (eds) Essential endodontology.
2006; 201: 101-105. 2nd ed. Chapter 14. Oxford: Blackwell Munks-
ern practitioner has a professional obli- 7. Witton R, Brennan P A. Severe tissue damage and gaard, 2007.
gation to keep up to date. The changes neurological deficit following extravasation of 16. Taschieri S, Del Fabbro M, Testori T, Francetti L,
sodium hypochlorite solution during routine endo- Weinstein R. Endodontic surgery using two differ-
can be so rapid that published textbooks dontic treatment. Br Dent J 2005; 198: 749-750. ent magnification devices: preliminary results of
quickly become out of date. This article 8. Molander A, Caplan D, Bergenholtz G, Reit C. a randomized controlled study. J Oral Maxillofac
Improved quality of root canal fillings provided by Surg 2006; 64: 235-242.
has considered recent changes in prepa- general dental practitioners educated in nickel- 17. Tsesis I, Rosen E, Schwartz-Arad D, Fuss Z.
ration and obturation of the root canal titanium rotary instrumentation. Int Endod J 2007; Retrospective evaluation of surgical endodontic
40: 254-260. treatment: traditional versus modern technique.
system. The next paper will consider 9. Shipper G, Orstavik D, Teixera F, Trope M. An J Endod 2006; 32: 412-416.
changes in paediatric endodontic prac- evaluation of microleakage in roots filled with 18. Pitt Ford T R, Torabinejad M, Abedi H R, Bakland L
a thermoplastic synthetic polymer-based root K, Kariyawasam S P. Using mineral trioxide aggre-
tice, in particular the treatment of the canal filling material (Resilon). J Endod 2004; gate as a pulp-capping material. J Am Dent Assoc
primary dentition. 30: 342-347. 1996; 127: 1491-1494.