Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Amanda Wilson
May 3, 2010
The college classroom is usually viewed as a setting full of mature adults. The general
consensus seems to be that these students are responsible for their own education. As teachers,
we need only enter the classroom and impart knowledge or facilitate discussion. The expectation
is that we are not responsible for the behavior of these adults in our classrooms. It is their own
responsibility; either they do the work and learn, or they fail. All the responsibility falls on the
student to be mature and focused on their education. This is simply not the case. We owe these
traditional students more than that. We must try to understand them a little better so we can
approach teaching them in a way that is productive for them and fulfilling for us.
In his paper, “Principles of Adult Learning,” Lieb (1991) quotes the pioneer of adult
words, these students are expected to have their own ideas about what they want to learn. They
are seen as being capable of gathering this knowledge themselves. They are expected to have the
discipline to stay focused and on-task. While these traits may be accurate for describing non-
traditional community college students, I feel they are less descriptive of the more traditional, 18
I teach beginning Spanish at a public liberal arts university. Typically, I have 28 students
in each of my classes. They range from freshmen to seniors, from 18 years old on up into their
fifties. The majority of my students, however, are freshmen and sophomores, and they are mostly
educational path that led me to this career, I realize that most of the focus has been on teaching
children, adolescents, and non-traditional college students. I remember little that focused on
range.
If I approach my classroom thinking my students are there for the joy of learning, that
they are totally self-motivated, autonomous learners, and that they carry within themselves all
the motivation they will need to succeed, I am failing them because I am not understanding
where they are coming from and what they need from me. I am also failing myself because I will
not be able to achieve my goal of teaching them to communicate in another language and be
I believe that students can be successful in learning a foreign language if they can interact
friendly classroom. I want my students to be comfortable and have a good rapport with each
other and with me. I set up my grading scale to take attention away from passing a test and
towards being engaged and active participants in the classroom. In general, my students seem to
like me and enjoy being in my class. The easy-going, friendly interaction we share makes them
more comfortable with themselves and more able to focus on learning and growing without the
By creating this comfortable space, students have the freedom to become more
Wilson 3
autonomous learners. They are free to make mistakes without harsh judgments. Although there is
some lecture involved when explaining grammatical concepts, the majority of my classroom
time is engaged in allowing the students the opportunity to practice the language through
interaction with their classmates and myself. They are required to create, rehearse, and perform
skits, engage in dialogue with their group members, and create their own meaning by pursing
personal interests within the scope of the course materials. This demographic is generally not yet
aware of any intrinsic goals of language learning. They are simply fulfilling the requirements of
a degree program. By allowing space for personal interest, I hope to help facilitate this group
becoming more goal-oriented. The focus of the class is to allow the students a safe place to take
the basic building blocks of the language and create a relevant context that helps them become
more aware of themselves and the world they live in. When they decide what they are interested
in, the students are free to become more self-directed as they develop intrinsic goals to pursue
more global awareness. The ultimate goal is to help a student evolve into a more informed global
citizen.
environment, I still have two types of students in my classroom that I have difficulty
accommodating. These two ends of the spectrum are the extremely introverted and the extremely
extroverted students. The far end of the introverted side of the scale leaves me with students
who are too shy or reluctant to speak up and engage in the active learning I promote in my
classroom. I would like to help these more introverted students become more actively engaged in
my classroom. The other side of the scale leaves me with students who are so outgoing that they
either dominate the classroom or make inappropriate comments, distracting the rest of the class
as well as impeding their own progress. I would like to help these more extroverted students
Wilson 4
participate in a more democratic, or fair, manner. What I would like to learn through this process
is: What can I do to help promote active engagement and democratic participation in my
interest, and boredom as they relate to the college classroom. These resources not only provided
some insight, but also helped me formulate interview and survey questions. I interviewed five
former students to get their perspectives on what I can do to further facilitate engagement and
student population to find some general attitudes about certain aspects of my classroom and the
way I approach teaching Spanish. Finally, I observed a very talented colleague as she
successfully engaged her students in her beginning Spanish college classroom. From this data, I
have gained insight into how I can improve the facilitation of engagement and participation in
my classroom and move toward more effective teaching and learning. Looking into both the
literature and my gathered data, I have developed five goals to improve my practice and three
Literature Review
Introduction
interest, and boredom, I found certain themes throughout the literature. The themes influencing
and influenced by student engagement and participation in the college classroom can be
summarized into two main categories: student perception and student interaction. Student
perception involves how student attitudes, emotions, and perspectives effect their engagement
and participation. Student interaction deals with the ways in which faculty and students interact
Wilson 5
as well as how students interact with each other, and how these interactions effect student
Student Perception
Students' perception of the educational environment has been shown to influence the way
they engage and learn in the classroom. The term educational environment in this context is
meant to represent everything from the students themselves to the faculty to the class materials,
showed a relationship between how students perceive themselves and their abilities with the
effectiveness of their learning. Handelsman, et al's 2005 study assessed emotional engagement in
relation to student learning. This study found that by looking into how learning the class material
affects students personally, faculty can steer overall engagement in a positive way. By creating
and facilitating situations that students' perceive to be personally valuable, faculty can increase
emotional engagement and thereby increase overall relative engagement. Providing an impetus
Students' perceptions of the faculty also play a role in their classroom engagement and
participation. A 2007 study published in the ASHE Higher Education Report on student
engagement in research and creative activities found that students felt satisfied with their efforts
to learn when there was meaningful interaction and collaboration with faculty and their peers.
Feedback helped spark and encourage their interest in learning. Being engaged in creative
endeavors, in which they had some control of the focus, helped keep them motivated, persistent,
and confident in their research. These types of activities and projects empowered students to take
Wilson 6
charge of their own learning. The motivation and confidence continues to fuel and facilitate
influence their level of engagement and participation in class. In Hu et al's 2008 research,
students self-reported that being involved with active learning projects and activities had an
overall positive effect on their college experience, although the effects were conditional on the
students. Some students benefited more, while others did not benefit as much. The students'
perceptions of engaged, active, and hands-on learning promoted their sense of positive effects.
Beran and Violato's 2009 study shows that when students evaluated teaching effectiveness,
teachers and classes that engaged in active learning and collaboration were closely tied to higher
The research shows that when students are engaged in active learning and they perceive
this engagement to be a positive learning experience, they achieve more. As the old adage states,
if you believe, you can achieve. Students learn more and learn more effectively, when they
believe they can. Engaging students in the active and creative learning projects helps them to
Student Interaction
Students’ interaction with faculty members and their peers influence the way students
learn. Unfortunately, as we learn from Herington’s 2008 article, situational and collaborative
aspects of learning have received little attention in higher education settings. Beran and Violato's
2009 study revealed that the more opportunities faculty and students had to interact, the higher
Wilson 7
students rated their learning experiences. This was attributed to the ability of instructors to help
develop and enrich students’ knowledge and skills as they had further opportunity to interact. In
Hu et al's 2008 study, continuous feedback was key in helping students to benefit in the broadest
terms and ways during an inquiry-based learning activity. Furthermore, this guidance and
feedback was necessary to maximize the desired learning and personal development outcomes.
The 2007 aforementioned study from the ASHE Higher Education Report also showed that
frequent and meaningful interactions between students and faculty were critical to learning and
personal development. The more contact inside and outside the classroom between faculty and
students, the greater student development and satisfaction, but the frequency and nature of the
interaction matters in producing desirable outcomes. The difficulty being that this requires a fair
amount a dedication and time from faculty. Faculty, especially at research institutions, seem to
Additionally, the 2007 study showed interaction with other students and development of
collegiality with their peers was found to enrich the students’ own educational experiences by
providing new and multiple perspectives. Alfonsi’s 2008 study of discussion groups showed
ways in which peers can help facilitate each others’ learning experiences. She had a more
extroverted speaker help facilitate discussion and encourage classmates as a way to keep that
student from controlling the discussion by redirecting their energy. This also helped to encourage
the more reluctant speakers. She also used a sign to help the more dominant student be more
aware of when they were taking control of the discussion. Additionally, she allowed the more
introverted speaker to communicate with her through written feedback to begin with. This
allowed those students to participate in a less threatening way and to receive feedback on their
Wilson 8
component to student engagement and participation. The more meaningful interaction and
collaboration and the more feedback, the better a student’s learning experience will be.
Conclusion
that encouraging these students to work on active and creative projects facilitates positive self-
perception. It is up to faculty to reflect on these findings and adjust curriculum planning in ways
that facilitate these attitudes. One weakness of the existing literature is the lack of the thread that
ties all this research together in such a way as to call attention to the need to encourage students
in these ways.
that is overlooked. While the research continues to show time and again that this type of
collaboration is one of the most effective ways to engage students, too often excuses like high
student to teacher ratios and encumbered teacher workloads hamper progress towards more
discourage ideas for creating functional solutions to overcome these perceived difficulties.
curriculum and course planning. Faculty must find ways to promote engagement in creative
class is imperative to continued improvement in learning. The first step in this direction is to
value student input in their learning. This is why I sought to illicit student input throughout my
Wilson 9
research, to determine what makes them feel more engaged. This information will help me adjust
the way I teach to work better with the way they learn.
Students’ interaction with faculty and their peers is invaluable to student engagement and
participation. The more feedback we can give students and the more opportunities we can give
them to collaborate, the more they will engage and the more meaningful the learning experience
will be. To this end, I currently employ these strategies—making myself as available to students
as possible by working in my office with the door unlocked whenever possible and by taking on
two instructional assistants with the skill to really connect with and help my students. In addition
to strategies I already use, I inquired of my former students as to how these strategies have
helped them and where they see room for further improvement.
Research Context/Setting
Spanish college courses. I teach at a public state funded institution and although we are moving
towards being a more research focused institution, the current focus is more aligned with
teaching. I am fortunate to have a great deal of freedom and control in my classroom. While it is
true that my general curriculum and my textbook are mandated by the tenured faculty of my
department, I am free to choose whatever path I believe will best help me achieve the course
goals. That is to say that while I am not free to choose what I teach, I am free to determine how
to teach. While I also receive feedback from peers once a year, I feel no other demands from any
improve how I teach my classes. I am currently in my fifth semester teaching these courses and I
can say with certainty that no two semesters have held very much in common outside of my
have perceived as being effective. This hands-off situation created by the administration allows
me to be fluid in my methods. While the freedom to teach the way I feel is best has many
The classes I teach are capped at 28 students. This is a moderate number of students for a
beginning foreign language class. While it would be ideal to have a smaller number because it
would allow for more individualized attention, there are advantages to this class size as well.
With this many students it is easier to employ group learning strategies, allowing students to
Participants
For this project, there were two primary participant groups. For the first group, I invited
28 freshmen and sophomore former beginning Spanish I students who fall into the 18-24 year
old demographic to participate in the broad attitude survey. While I did not expect all of them to
respond, I am fairly satisfied that I got 11 responses, which is a little over 39% and enough data
for a valid sample. The survey questions presented to the group, along with their responses are
The second group consisted of five former students who were interviewed individually
and classified into one of two groups, introverts and extroverts, with one individual classified as
somewhere in between the two extremes. These interviews were conducted with the aid of the
semi-structured interview guide found in Appendix B of this report. All data and reflections
The first individual, for the purposes of the study we will call her Mia, is 19 years old.
She's a freshman Criminal Justice major. Mia was in my 11:00 am section of beginning Spanish I
Wilson 11
in Fall of 2009. She is a very exuberant young woman, always smiling and joking around. She
tended to speak loudly inside and outside of class and showed no fear or anxiety when asked to
perform in front of groups. Her positive attitude and willingness to dedicate herself to her work
made her a model student. For the purposes of this study, Mia will be classified as an extrovert.
The next student I interviewed, Sabrina, is 18 years old. She's a freshman Political
Science major. Sabrina was also in my 11:00 am section of beginning Spanish I in Fall of 2009.
Sabrina is more reserved than Mia. Although she is always smiling and is a very pleasant person,
she is also much quieter. While Sabrina was always willing to work hard, she was less
enthusiastic about performing in front of the rest of the class or speaking up during group work.
She always kept up with the work and excelled in tests and assignments, but she was much less
likely to practice her language in class because of her shy personality. For the purposes of this
Lorie is 21 years old. She's a sophomore Foods and Nutrition major. Lorie was in my
9:00 am section of beginning Spanish I in Fall of 2009. Outside of class, Lorie is a very cheerful
and boisterous person. Inside class she was a little bit less so. Although more often than not, she
had the right answers or knew how to pronounce words correctly, she was less likely than others
to put herself out there. When asked to perform for the class, she always did well; but her
confidence in this area never seemed to grow. She did well in the course, but might have done
better given more oral practice. Lori seemed to enjoy the more social and presentational elements
of class more than some. For the purposes of this study, and due to her performance in class,
Lorie will be classified as sort of in between the two extremes of extroverted and introverted.
When called upon to perform, she would, but not to the extent of some of the others.
Micah is 20 years old. He's a sophomore International Business major and was in my
Wilson 12
10:00 am section of beginning Spanish I in Fall of 2009. Micah is a nice, polite young man.
Although he did not always perform well on exams or get all his homework done, he was always
willing to speak up and practice his language skills in class. Micah was never afraid to step up
and show his peers how to put themselves out there. Micah will be classified as an extrovert for
Dana is 19 years old. She's a sophomore English major and was also in my 10:00 am
beginning Spanish I class in Fall of 2009. Dana is very social outside of class, but very reserved
in my classroom. She came to class prepared most of the time but showed no desire to speak up
or take opportunities to practice her speaking skills. After speaking with her and some of her
peers, I found out that Dana is quite outspoken in most of her classes, especially her English
literature classes, but because she is not confident with Spanish, she turned inward in my class.
For the purposes of this study, Dana will be classified as an introvert because of her performance
in my class.
One more participant was added at the last minute. Due to comments from Micah during
his interview, I chose to observe a colleague of mine as she taught a similar course in a similar
setting at the same school as myself. For the purposes of this study, I will call her Mariana. She
is a native speaker, holding a Master's degree in Spanish from a U.S. institution. She is new to
my university, having only started here less than one year ago, but students already know her
name and recommend her to their friends. Sitting in her class, it was easy to see why she is well
liked. She is patient, clear, and obviously cares about her students. Further reflections on this
Research Plan
and an observation of my colleague. First, I employed a semi-structured interview method for the
above mentioned former students. The semi-structured interview guide I used can be seen in
Appendix B of this report. I asked the students about three main topics: what other experiences
they have in learning Spanish other than my class, what they thought about the methods I used in
the class they took with me, and what made them comfortable or uncomfortable in any class. By
asking them to reflect on other experiences they have had learning Spanish I was able to hear
what they liked or did not like about how those experiences played out. Here I gathered very
specific tips on things to avoid or new ideas to try. When the students were asked to reflect on
my methods from the class they took with me the previous semester, I received direct feedback
on which activities were the most or least memorable, what they enjoyed the most, and which
methods did not seem useful to them. It was interesting to see the preferences differed in
expected ways depending on whether the students were generally more extroverted or more
introverted. Some specific implications did emerge here related to which methods are preferred
by which group and how adjustments to these assignments might make them more engaging for
both ends of the personality spectrum. Finally, by asking the students what made them
could focus my energies to make my own classroom a more comfortable and safe environment
for my students to take the risks necessary to learn a foreign language. To finish the interviews I
asked for any additional comments, ideas, or advice the students might for me. This allowed me
to hear more helpful comments that I had not thought to specifically ask about and showed me
what was important to the students. These comments will help me shape future interview guides
and survey questions as I continue this research in future projects. All comments, notes, and
Additionally, I issued a broad attitude survey for a large group of former students to
complete. With this survey I hoped to measure general attitudes towards my teaching methods in
regards to active engagement and democratic participation in my classroom. The attitude scale
survey provided some insight into which methods students perceive as being the most effective
and the most interesting. While undergraduates may not be education specialists, they have been
going to school for more than a decade and they know what works and what doesn’t. I believe
that learning what they think is effective and interesting will help me focus on the methods that
are most likely to help me achieve my goals of facilitating learning for both the introverted,
extroverted, and all the in between students in my class. The survey consisted of twenty
questions. The first question was simply consent to participate in my research; the last was a
place for additional comments. Questions two to nineteen asked the participants to rate nine
teaching methods they experienced the previous semester in my class on a scale from strongly
agree to strongly disagree about each method's usefulness and level of fun. The full-text of the
questions and the resulting data are included in Appendix A of this report. Some of the results
were surprising. I hope to revise the survey to reflect new methods developed as a result of this
study and administer it again to a future group of students to compare the results. Especially the
reactions to textbook activities were a bit surprising to me and I will be interested to see if the
Finally, I observed my colleague, Mariana's beginning Spanish class. I took notes while I
observed her and wrote reflections immediately after the class on what I observed. This data is
cataloged in Appendix C, the research log of this study. The insights I gathered during this
observation were inspiring and I hope to model some of my future practice from what I learned
Validity
I chose to focus on four types of qualitative validity, described by Hendricks in her text
on action research, to validate this study: democratic, outcome, process, and catalytic (2009). I
chose democratic validity as the first way to validate my study because I chose particular
students to voice their opinions. I have chosen students to interview whom I attribute to one end
or the other of the spectrum of students, both those who are more introverted and those who are
more extroverted, whom I am trying to help accommodate. In addition, I chose one student who
falls between these two extremes of personality measures. Since my research question involves
finding ways to facilitate oral participation and learning outcomes for both the reluctant, or
introverted, and the outspoken, or extroverted, students, I have chosen to interview some of the
more introverted and the more extroverted students from my previous semester of teaching. By
looking at both ends of the spectrum and one in the middle, I have a clearer picture of the needs,
The second measure I chose is outcome validity because it speaks to how I will use the
results for continued planning, ongoing reflection, and deepening my personal understanding of
the topics I am exploring. Through this research I have learned which of my methods are
working well and which need improvement. I have also learned about new ideas while
conducting the interviews and observing my colleague that will help shape how I move forward
in my practice. I have taken what I have learned, reflected on what it means to me, and begun to
brainstorm ways to apply my understanding to the way I approach my classroom. I also plan to
continue to solicit feedback from my students in future research to continue the cycle and work
toward continual improvement of my practice. I hope that by taking their opinions into
consideration, I will continue to improve the way I teach and thereby help my students engage
Wilson 16
and participate in class and generally get more out of their learning experience with me. There is
so much more to learn and try as I continue my path to become the best teacher I can be.
Next, I chose process validity because I need to insure I have looked deeply at the
problem so I can understand the ways context and processes have impacted my results and how
this information carries me forward. To insure I have looked deeply and critically at these issues,
I have relied on two main methods: asking open-ended questions during the interviews that left
plenty of room for the students to tell me what they really think and writing out my reflections on
the interviews, the broad attitude survey, and the observation in a reflective journal style so I am
very conscious of conclusions I have drawn. All of these notes and reflections can be seen in
processes and outcomes will change my practices. This is the most important part of my study. If
the results do not change the way I approach my classroom, I will need to revise my research and
try again. While I believe that I am a proficient instructor, my primary goal is to improve. Any
insight I can gain from this study will help reshape my perspective and improve my practice. The
primary insight I have gained at this point includes five personal goals to improve my teaching.
I am very invested in my research topic because I am my research topic. I knew the first
step for me would be to distance myself a bit and try to view the focus of my study as my
teaching methods rather than myself. By trying to put a little intellectual separation between
myself and my methods, I was able to be honest with myself about improving the way I do my
job, but also get my students to be as honest as possible with me about their reflections.
I tried to be as clear, honest, and open-minded as I could while I asked these students to
Wilson 17
was not interested in having my ego stroked. While I did want and need to know what worked
well for them, it was also imperative to be honest about the aspects of the class that were not
particularly helpful. I believe this attempt was successful because I did get feedback on aspects
of my methods and performance that could use work, like my tendency to be too variable in my
daily teaching methods and my inconsistent use of the target language in class.
Beyond assuring them that I was open to criticism, I had to really and actually be open. It
was essential that I be neither overtly nor subtly defensive in my responses or my body language.
The last thing I wanted to do was shut them down or squelch their opinions. This was another
reason for including the broad attitude questionnaire. While I know who had access to the
survey, I set the responses to anonymous to allow for more freedom and honesty. I was open to
getting some negative or even potentially hurtful feedback in exchange for the chance of
obtaining some useful feedback to help me be a more effective teacher. Fortunately, I did not
receive any hurtful feedback. The students who participated in this research seemed to genuinely
want to help me. Their comments were not also positive, but they were considerably
constructive, especially considering the assumed maturity level of such a young research pool.
Data Representation
I ended up with three data sources, instead of two, once all my research was completed.
In addition to the survey and the interviews, I also observed a colleague's class and made note of
her methods. This was a pleasant surprise that came from one of the interviews. One student had
nothing but glowing recommendations of one of my newest colleagues. After speaking with her,
she agreed to allow me to observe and learn from her. Below, I will present the data for each
For the Learning Survey (see Appendix A), I asked a series of 20 questions, receiving 11
responses, from the 28 students surveyed, or 39% of the sample. The first question was one
requiring the participant to consent to the use of their opinions in this project. The next 18
questions, numbered 2-19, essentially asked first, if one of nine particular teaching methods were
perceived to be useful in their learning process, and second, if each method was perceived as fun.
Table A:
Responses to Q2-Q19 of Learning Survey
Q19: OralTBclass-fun
Q18: OralTBclass-useful
Q17: OralTBpairs-fun
Q16: OralTBpairs-useful
Q15: Text-fun
Q14: Text-useful
Q13: VocGam-fun
Q12: VocGam-useful SD
Q11: Review-fun D
Questions
N
Q10: Review-useful
A
Q9: GrpCult-fun SA
Q8: GrpCult-useful
Q7: DVD-fun
Q6: DVD-useful
Q5: Oral-fun
Q4: Oral-useful
Q3: Skits-fun
Q2: Skits-useful
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Responses
The final question asked for additional comments. The entirety of the results and comments can
be seen in Appendix A, but the attitude scale responses to the 18 primary questions can be seen
in Table A below.
While for the most part, it can be seen that most students agree that all nine methods are
Wilson 19
useful for learning Spanish and more than half are fun, which is good to know because this what
I strive for, some methods received more attention than others. The nine methods, in order of
questions asked in the survey are: skits, orals, the DVD project, the group culture research
project, student-led final exam grammar review, vocabulary review games, written textbook
exercises, oral textbook exercises done in pairs, and oral textbook exercises done as an entire
class.
The skits are prepared and practiced in advance, and students are allowed to use notes
while performing. The orals are prepared in advanced and memorized. They are performed
without the aid of notes, but students are permitted to have images as reminders of their
sentences. The DVD project is a final project that students work on in large groups. They write a
script, film it, and then edit a newscast in Spanish. In most cases, they will also include
commercials in this project, but all I require is that they focus on the news, weather, sports, and
entertainment of an assigned Hispanic country. The group culture research project asks the
students to choose a topic they are interested in and that is related to an assigned target culture.
For example, a group might choose to read about sustainability practices in Peru. To allow for a
depth of research and reporting on the cultural aspects of this project, it is done in English. Once
the students collect some interesting data, they share it with the entire class via a blog. The
student-led final exam grammar review is another group project. Since the final exam is
cumulative, as a final presentation, I assign each group to a chapter we covered during the
semester. Each group then prepares and presents a summary of the grammar they learned in each
chapter to review for the final exam. The vocabulary review games are sometimes student-led,
and other times I lead them myself. Examples of these games include Jeopardy, Bingo, and a
hot-potato-style vocabulary recall game, amongst many others. The written textbook exercises
Wilson 20
are simply the exercises in the textbook in which the answers are written out on paper. The oral
textbook exercises done in pairs are the exercises in the textbook done aloud with a partner. The
oral textbook exercises, done as an entire class, are the exercises in the textbook done aloud as an
entire class.
Table B: Table C:
Ranking of Methods by Percentage of Students Percentages of Students that Found Each
Who Agree Methods are Useful or Fun Method Useful or Fun, sorted by Method
Useful % Fun Method Useful Fun
written textbook 91% skits 73% 46%
exercises
oral textbook exercises 82% oral textbook exercises orals 64% 46%
done as an entire class done as an entire class
vocabulary games
oral textbook exercises 73% oral textbook exercises the DVD project 55% 55%
done in pairs done in pairs
exam review
skits vocabulary games
orals 64% the group culture the group culture research 55% 64%
research project project
the group culture 55% the DVD project student-led final exam grammar 73% 46%
research project review
the DVD project
46% student-led final exam written textbook exercises 91% 28%
grammar review
orals
skits
28% written textbook Oral textbook exercises done in 73% 73%
exercises pairs
Oral textbook exercises done as 82% 82%
a class
The results of this survey were surprising in many ways. The tables above illustrate the
preferences for each method over the others. Table B ranks the methods from most useful and
fun to least useful and fun. Table C lists the percentages of students who agreed that each method
was either useful or fun in the order they were presented in the survey. I was surprised to find
that 91% of students perceived the written textbook exercises as useful ways to learn Spanish,
Wilson 21
but I was not at all surprised to find this method ranked the very worst on the fun scale at 28%.
As I reflected in my research log, simply putting an exercise in a textbook is a good way to turn
students off to it. I am not a big advocate of textbooks. I use Internet sites to help students
engage in learning. The same information will be infinitely more interesting in a browser than in
a book. Taking that activity out of the written arena slightly dropped the students' perceived
usefulness. The usefulness of activities done as a class went down to 82% which also matched
the fun level. The usefulness of activities done in pairs went down to 73% which also matched its
fun level. This shows that they believe writing exercises is the most useful and least fun way to
learn Spanish, but doing the exercises orally are almost as useful and much more fun.
The other most useful methods, as perceived by the students, were the vocabulary games
ranking in at 82%, the student-led final exam grammar review and the skits at 73%, the orals at
64%, and the group culture research project and the DVD project at 55%. It is important to
remember that these measures are the students' perceptions of the effectiveness of these activities
and perhaps not necessarily true measure of the effectiveness. However, I would agree that these
statistics are valid based on my own observations of my students over the past few semesters. A
critical part of language learning is amassing vocabulary. Any activities that reinforce
vocabulary learning are going to be perceived as being useful because they are one more
opportunity to be exposed to and reminded of the language. It is also not surprising that the
grammar review project and the skits rank high on the usefulness scale. The grammar review
project essentially asks students to be so familiar with a grammatical topic that they can explain
to others. Modern day philosopher, Richard Bach, has it right when he says, “You teach best
what you most need to learn.” The skits allow the students to take all the grammar and
vocabulary from the chapter and build a potential conversation. Put together, these three
Wilson 22
particular activities, vocabulary games, the grammar review project, and the skits, allow students
to practice what they are learning, show they understand, and build a meaningful context using
On the fun scale, the vocabulary games ranked in at 73%, the group culture research
project at 64%, the DVD project at 55%, and the student-led final exam grammar review, orals,
and skits at 46%. Overall, I think it is interesting to note that for the most part, the methods were
ranked higher in their usefulness and lower on the fun scale, but the fun scale is relatively top-
heavy if you consider the fact that I am asking 18-22 year old students about how much fun they
are having while learning and working hard in a classroom. Over half of the methods were rated
by more than half of the students surveyed as being fun. That has to be counted as at least a
Based on this survey data, I would be interested in asking some follow-up questions of
future students. I want to know how they think these methods can be improved. What would
make skits, for example, more fun and useful for the students? I did receive some useful
feedback in the additional comments section of the survey as well. The full transcript of these
comments can be seen in Appendix A. These comments, as well as the comments made in the
five semi-structured interviews I conducted, revealed some of these answers and followed some
interesting themes.
The Interviews
The primary themes I traced through the interviews and the additional comments from
the survey relate to 1) the students' self perceptions and comfort levels, 2) the students'
perceptions of and interactions with their instructor, 3) the students' perceptions of and
interactions with their peers, 4) the students' expectations of the course, and 5) the students'
Wilson 23
perception of the methods and materials of the class, many of which can also been seen reflected
in the 18 primary survey questions. My research log, which also contains my reflections on the
As I looked over the comments related to the students' self perception and comfort levels,
I found it interesting that the students' comments back up the ideas espoused in the literature
review related to active and creative projects facilitating student engagement and learning. For
Mia, one of my extroverts, I observed from her comments that anytime I gave an assignment that
required the students to go out, get the language, and build it up into a real context, it was most
memorable and helpful for her. It was interesting to note that Mia was very excited about the
skits, and Micah, another extrovert, felt they were fun and good oral practice. On the other hand,
the most introverted two, Sabrina and Dana, thought the activities were fun, but complained
about having to deal with and get to know their peers. Neither was comfortable with these
exercises until they had time to get to know their classmates better.
Sabrina, the quietest of the five, named her favorite activity as the daily activities book,
saying that it made learning more visual. This activity requires that the spoken portion is
recorded individually. As an introvert, it is not surprising that she really liked an activity that did
not require her to speak up in front of the class. It is also interesting that Lori, who I classified as
near the middle of the introvert/extrovert scale, thought the sound recording was more trouble
than it was worth. She complained that the technology made it a pain when really the skits
accomplished the same task of oral practice of the language. She was not too shy to get up and
perform in the class and did not see any benefit to doing a project that allowed for a private
performance of oral skills. I was not surprised to find that this activity was preferred by an
Wilson 24
introvert, but not at all mentioned by the two more extroverted students. Although Lori, being
middle-of-the-road, did mention it, I was not surprised that it was in a less than positive light.
the material is more comfortable for her, like her English literature classes. However, she did
really enjoy the exam review presentations. She did not mind getting up in front of the class to
explain a grammatical concept in English and was glad for the experience. Having to teach the
concept helped her understand it. Her comments seem to ring true with the survey results that
again had 73% of those surveyed agreeing that this particular activity was useful for learning
Spanish.
In the survey comments, students asked that I allow more freedom in the methods they
choose for learning. One student said, “We all learn differently and especially in a foreign
language we want to do it our way.” This is what I hope to do, more than anything else. I want to
find the balance between my goals and theirs and find the space to allow them to learn in the best
ways possible. Overall, from these comments, I can draw the conclusion that creative and active
learning projects that allow for freedom of interest and learning styles are perceived to help
students feel more comfortable and therefore engage more effectively in their learning processes.
Students' perceptions of and interactions with faculty were summed up best when Mia
said, “When a teacher seems to care about your input, that matters a lot.” Whenever any of the
students were asked about their comfort levels in class or what makes them confident in the
classroom, the comments overwhelming came back to the instructor's attitude. Teachers who are
perceived by their students as real people who care about them inside and outside the classroom
help students be comfortable and successful in the classroom. To engage students, we have to be
Wilson 25
real people, not just teachers, and we must care about who they are as real people, not just
students. Sabrina said that what makes her uncomfortable in class is a teacher who is rude and
disrespectful and leaves no room for students' opinions and interests. Dana felt comfortable in
my classroom because she felt like I wanted them to learn. Lori felt a teacher's attitude makes a
big difference. When teachers are relaxed, more personable and approachable, a good speaker,
and knowledgeable, they make learning possible for her. Similarly, Micah felt that a teacher's
personality should be not too serious. They should like to have fun and laugh in class. By
connecting on a personal level, teachers are able to engage their students more thoroughly.
These comments draw to mind Parker Palmer's ideas on bringing the heart back into
education that he promotes through the organization, the Center for Courage and Renewal
(2008). The idea is that by becoming detached from our classrooms and students and trying to be
too clinical, we perform a disservice to our students and impede their learning. Students need to
see that we are whole and genuine people, not just tools for learning. Making our relationships
more personal and less institutional adds a critical element of authenticity and trust that is a vital
component of learning and growing. Students need to trust us. They don't necessarily have to like
us, but they do need to believe we care. That trust allows them to be comfortable with
themselves, take risks, make mistakes, and learn. Effective learning and improved student
Students' perceptions of and interactions with their peers can be seen reflected in two
primary ways: the acknowledgment that when they know their peers well, it is easier and more
enjoyable to learn collaboratively, but that dealing with peers in issues of scheduling,
collaborating, and conflict resolution are tough. Mia disclosed that what made my class fun was
Wilson 26
making friends and working together on projects. Shy Sabrina said that while the skits were
awkward at first, they became more comfortable as she got to know her peers better. Micah,
commenting on the skits, said he appreciated opportunities to connect with his peers.
Unfortunately, all is not a bed of roses. Both Sabrina and Dana talked about having a hard
time both scheduling time to meet with peers and learning to collaborate in some sense other
than just dividing the work and sticking it back together at the end. In Sabrina, Dana, and
Micah's class there were several major conflicts among peer groups that were never resolved.
While peer collaboration can make class more interesting and learning more productive, students
Students' Expectations
A huge theme in student comments dealt with their expectations of the class. Micah
spoke most strongly to this when he asked for more regularity in class. While my class tends to
be very free-flowing and variable, he felt that students should know what to expect every class.
For example, explaining one vocabulary theme and allowing a few minutes to practice, then
explicating one grammar concept and going over a practice exercise, are activities students can
expect with regularity. He felt that expectations help keep them on track and instill a sense of
awareness of their own learning. Dana also commented on needing to know what to expect in a
class and what would be expected of her. Their expectations of the class are vital to keeping
them focused.
Sabrina dreaded her Spanish class that didn't live up to her expectations. While she was
interested in learning to speak Spanish, the class was almost exclusively taught on the cultural
aspects. Mia also commented that she dreads a class if she feels she is not learning. Goals and
expectations are best when they are clear and shared. Students will learn what they want to learn.
Wilson 27
When teachers and students can collaborate and share their goals and make those goals explicit, a
their own self-perception and comfort-levels, are most successful when they are active and
creative projects that allow for student freedom of interest and learning style. The skits and exam
review projects seem to be most popular among my students. Even the introverts seemed to like
these projects when they are comfortable with me and their peers. While the survey showed that
students rank textbook activities high in usefulness, it is those that involve an element of
collaboration with a partner or the entire class that have the highest overall ranking. From this, I
draw that it is vital to use methods that also contain collaborative elements, but there needs to be
Observation Of A Pro
Thanks to Micah's comments in his interview, I had the opportunity to observe a truly
magnificent colleague in action. There are several elements I plan to steal from Mariana's style.
One of the first elements I plan to steal is her patient, clear, and concise interactions with her
students. She takes her time when explaining new concepts and slowly leads them through a few
examples. She then patiently gives them time to process the information and allows time for
practice and questions. Sometimes, I fear I get in too big of a hurry and rush my students. This
must be as frustrating for them as it is for me when at the end of the day, they simply do not
understand. As much as possible, I hope to adopt a more patient style that I believe will help my
Secondly, I plan to adopt, again as a suggestions of Micah's that I got to see in action in
Wilson 28
Mariana's class, the way she organizes her class and lets them know what to expect next. She
scaffolds the materials she teaches, and she uses consistent methods that let students get into a
comfortable routine. As Micah said, she explains the grammar and then allows for practice,
before moving to the next grammar topic instead of explaining everything and then trying to let
Finally, I hope to speak the language more and with more confidence, using familiar
repetitive phrases and showing the language existing in context as much as possible. Granted as a
native speaker, Mariana has an advantage, but I do not want my students to be at a disadvantage
because of my language skills. I hope to continue to improve and practice my speaking skills
and, as almost everyone commented in the individual interviews, use Spanish more in my
classroom.
Introduction
As I began this project, I developed the research question, “What can I do to help
classroom?” Initially, I intended to focus on the most introverted and the most extroverted of my
students. I wanted to know how I could help my introverted students engage more actively in
class while finding ways to help my most outspoken students participate in a more democratic
and fair-handed way. Along the path, I found that my lens was a bit skewed. While focusing on
both ends of the personality spectrum, what I was really looking at were my students as a whole.
I believe that as I draw conclusions on the data I have gathered, and while there are specific
implications for particularly introverted or extroverted students, I have become aware of ways to
improve the way I do my job for all my students. The real focus group here is not necessarily the
Wilson 29
extroverts and introverts; it is the traditional college freshman or sophomore. These young
students are not yet mature adults, not yet the autonomous, goal-oriented, and self-directed
learners we expect older or non-traditional college students to be. These students are at a critical
point in their development toward becoming adults. They need their college instructors to
provide them with an environment that will allow them to grow and become more mature as they
learn more about whatever specific topic we are trying to teach them.
To this end, as I pour over this enormous amount of data, literature, and reflections, I am
satisfied to find five main points that I believe can help me be a better teacher in general for
these students, as well as help achieve my goal of helping to promote active engagement and
democratic participation in my beginning Spanish I college classroom. From the start of this
project, I planned to learn about how changes in my behavior in the classroom could help make
learning more successful in my class. To that end, my five main points take the form of
statements of my future goals. Through this process, I also learned about some things that I do
already that seem to help promote engagement. Those I will list here as potentially transferable
Be patient
Wilson 30
First, I want to be more patient. As I saw in Mariana's classroom and heard in comments
from Micah, as well as from anonymous comments in the learning survey, I need to be patient. I
need to give students the time and opportunity to absorb and practice what they are learning
instead of rushing through explanations or asking for questions before students have time to
process the information. Some specific ideas I have to accomplish this are four-fold: 1) make
initial grammar exploration a homework activity, 2) slowly walk students through examples in
class, allowing them time to figure out the answers, 3) create and provide an easy to reference
grammar guide to use in class, and 4) use class time to work on more difficult activities to flush
My first tools on this journey are some wonderful videos I have discovered online. A
teacher named Señor Jordan has produced and published some very well done and free videos
online explaining grammar points for beginning Spanish students in a clear and interesting way
(2010). I plan to have students watch the video pertaining to the upcoming grammar topic for
homework. I will provide them with a guide to read over and use as a note-taking tool while they
watch the videos. The next class period, I plan to walk students through specific examples of this
topic on the board. These examples will afford me the opportunity to model the target language.
Additionally, I will give the answer to the first example, but allow the students time to think
about and answer the other examples themselves. This will allow them to see if they understand
I also plan to create and distribute a very concise grammar guide at the beginning of the
semester. This guide will summarize each grammar point in the order they will be presented in
the course. This guide, along with the note-taking tool for use while doing the homework, will
provide the students with a visual reminder of what we are covering and hopefully help them
Wilson 31
focus and be more confident in their knowledge of the Spanish language. Finally, after going
through several examples as a class, I will put students into pairs or small groups and have them
work on more difficult or complicated examples to flush out their questions and
misunderstandings. During this time, my instructional assistant and I can circulate through the
class answering questions, modeling good language use, and encouraging the students to
cooperate with each other and practice speaking with their peers. I believe these specific tools
and processes will help me slow down and become more patient and aware of my students and
their questions. As I begin my next round of research, I will solicit feedback from students on
these new methods to determine how they are playing out. This will allow me to be conscious of
needed adjustments and able to make those changes, as the class progresses.
Be intentional in planning
I want to become much more intentional and aware as I plan future classes. Taking into
account the overwhelming demand for more active and creative projects that allow for freedom
of student interest and learning styles, on the one hand, and making sure my classes are more
consistent in format, on the other. The specific ideas for grammar lessons above really put the
learning into the students' hands. They must watch the videos and take notes. I am stepping back
as the all-knowing provider of knowledge, to become a guide and facilitator of learning. I feel
this will cause students to perceive themselves as being more autonomous in their learning
processes. I want to continue using projects like the skits, the vocabulary games, the daily
activities project, the DVD newscast, and others to offer students a chance to take these
grammatical topics we are practicing and create a more authentic context. I want them to feel
like they are doing something with the language, not just memorizing rules and vocabulary.
While I do want to develop more of these types of activities, I also want to make some
Wilson 32
strategic changes to the specific directions and conditions of the ones I already use. I plan to
bring the focus of these activities away from “using the vocabulary” and toward creating
something that is important to them. They need to use the language in ways that have meaning to
them personally to help them engage and become more self-directed learners. I want to find ways
to fuse culture and language study in more meaningful ways that interest the students. While
doing all of this, I want to find a rhythm in my planning that will allow for some consistency for
students to rely on without becoming boring. I plan to use the upcoming summer to instigate
Because I value student input and I believe that by engaging their interests, I help them
be more successful, goal-oriented learners, I plan to spend the first day of each of my upcoming
fall classes discussing goals and expectations of the course. While my course material is dictated
to me and there are certain topics that must be covered as a proscribed part of the course, there is
room for student interests. I want to take a little time and basically say: “This is what I expect
from you,” as well as, “What do you expect from the class?” and “What do you want to learn?”
This will allow me to collaborate with my students to create a set of shared goals and
expectations. I make to be very overt and clear about how what we do on a daily basis
contributes to those shared goals to keep students focused. I need to be very aware of how I
present information so that I can scaffold information in a logical and consistent manner. I
believe if students can be made aware of the why behind what I want them to do, they will be
Another important goal I have is to spend a sufficient amount of time on positive group
Wilson 33
interactions and team building at the beginning of the semester. I know from the comments I
collected in this research that if my students can connect on a personal level with each other, they
will be more willing to engage in the classroom and they will enjoy the learning experience
more. I want to provide opportunities for them to make friends and learn together, finding space
for both introverted and extroverted students. I realize that not everyone will make fast friends.
To this end, I plan to research strategies to facilitate group interaction. I want to become more
aware of and provide resources to my students on topics related to working well with others.
Group work is important to learning but it is also essential to social maturity. Students need to
learn to cooperate with peers to be successful in pretty much any field. I believe emphasizing this
importance and providing tools to help students refine these social skills will help them grow and
mature as members of the larger community, while they are learning the specific skills I need to
As I have said in other sections, I want to model good language skills in class as often as
possible and encourage my students to practice even more. I want to be more intentional in
planning to be sure I am doing this and not just thinking about doing this. I may even write
myself a semi-script to help me remember to be intentional with my language use until the
practice becomes more natural to me. This will also help me to be less free-flowing and variable
and more consistent as teach. While adaptability is a key attribute for teaching because you never
know what will happen in a class, I know my students will be more comfortable when there is
more structure. I plan to accomplish this by creating more specific lesson plans and a broad
Three suggestions that have served me well and I would encourage other instructors to try
to transfer to their practices are: 1) Be genuine, 2) Value student input, and 3) Answer questions.
I spoke a bit about Parker Palmer earlier and his ideas about putting the heart back into the
classroom. His ideas really expound well the idea of being genuine in what we do. His
organization, the Center for Courage and Renewal, with the tag line, “Reconnecting who you are
with what you do,” provides resources and information about how important it is to be true to
ourselves and our beliefs and to really care about our students (2008). By showing our students
that we are real and complete human beings and not just teachers, we can develop a sense of trust
that facilitates all aspects of learning. I am well aware that on the surface this seems a bit too
“touchy-feely” for most of us, but taking the time to really reflect on these ideas, they just make
good sense. If we show our students only one side of who we are and only consider one side of
whom they are, we miss building relationship and making connections that make all of our
experiences richer. My students are not just bodies sitting in my class to learn the grammar rules
of speaking Spanish. They are sons and daughters. They are friends. They are young adults with
hopes and dreams. They are human beings with their entire futures laid bare before them trying
to sort out what they want, what they need, and who they are. Yes, looking at them this way
makes my job more complicated because suddenly I'm thrust into the lives of my students. I want
to know why they missed class, not to punish them, but because I'm worried about them.
Connecting with students this way helps me know how I can help them on their personal
journey. This is a lot of work, but it is infinitely rewarding to help. Perhaps I believe this because
I see myself as not only their Spanish teacher, but also as their mentor. I am someone who has
experienced a bit more life than they have and can help guide them. Perhaps this isn't the path for
every teacher, but it is something that each teacher should reflect on and make a choice.
Wilson 35
My second suggestion to instructors is to value student input. Students are our livelihood
and while I do not prescribe to a consumerist view of education, that students are paying us to
put the information into their heads, I do believe that student opinions and input should be
considered in all aspects of planning and teaching. The traditional college freshman has been
going to school for more than 70% of their lives. Trust that they have some insight into being
successful learners. If they didn't, they would not be in your classroom because they would not
have been accepted at your institution. Try not to get jaded by a few bad experiences with
students. If you show them you value their opinions and input, you will begin to develop a
relationship that is beneficial for your class and fulfilling for your career. We all learn from each
other and even 18-year olds have something to teach even the most seasoned professional. Look
Finally, we must answer questions. I know, what a silly suggestion, right? Unfortunately,
it is a common complaint of students and is again reflected in my research that students are,
justifiably, frustrated by instructors who won't or don't answer their questions. Remember, it's
okay to not know the answer, but it's not okay to pretend you do if you don't or ignore the
question entirely. Be sure you know your resources. I'm not above tracking down a colleague and
asking them a “stupid” question that I should really know the answer to. If you're uncomfortable
in these situations, it is okay to put the responsibility on the student to find the answer, but it
should be the instructor's responsibility to point them in the right direction at the very least.
Genuine instructors who value student input and can answer student questions are
valuable resources to any institution. These suggestions might help any instructor, in any field
improve their student and peer evaluations and become more likely to be hired or rehired, but
more importantly, following these suggestions might help create a more fulfilling teaching
Wilson 36
experience.
Conclusion
This study has been extremely valuable to me personally and professionally. It has given
me the opportunities to reflect and learn about how I do my job and how I can do my job better. I
have enjoyed learning how my students feel about their learning experiences and what
suggestions and ideas they have for me. Mostly, I've been inspired to widen my perspective and
continue this process of growth and renewal. Moving forward, I plan to setup further research
into how I can continue to modify and improve the way I approach my classroom with the
constant goal of providing the best learning experience for my students that I am able.
Wilson 37
Bibliography
(2007). Impacts of Student Engagement in Research and Creative Activities. ASHE Higher
Education Report, 33(4), 33-43. Retrieved from Education Research Complete database.
Alfonsi, C. (2008). Hey, Teacher! Get Off That Stage: Assessing Student Thinking with Socratic
Seminars. Ohio Journal of English Language Arts, 48(1), 65-71. Retrieved from
Beran, T., & Violato, C. (2009). Student Ratings of Teaching Effectiveness: Student Engagement
and Course Characteristics. Canadian Journal of Higher Education, 39(1), 1-13. Retrieved
“The Center for Courage and Renewal.” (2008). Retrieved from http://www.couragerenewal.org/
Freeman, M., & Mathison, S. (2009). Researching children's experiences. New York: Guilford
Press.
Handelsman, M., Briggs, W., Sullivan, N., & Towler, A. (2005). A Measure of College Student
Hendricks, C. (2009). Improving schools through action research: A comprehensive guide for
Herington, C., & Weaven, S. (2008). Action Research and Reflection on Student Approaches to
Hu, S., Kuh, G., & Li, S. (2008). The Effects of Engagement in Inquiry-Oriented Activities on
Student Learning and Personal Development. Innovative Higher Education, 33(2), 71-81.
Wilson 38
doi:10.1007/s10755-008-9066-z.
Kozanitis, A., & Chouinard, R. (2007). Les effets directs des variables d'influence de la
Higher Education, 37(2), 1-28. Retrieved from Education Research Complete database.
http://honolulu.hawaii.edu/intranet/committees/FacDevCom/guidebk/teachtip/adults-
2.htm.
Appendix A
Questions text:
Q1: Participant consent for action research project: The following questions are part of a survey
to collect data on your preferences in regards to teaching methods and styles. The findings of the
research will be written up as an action research study for a graduate course and used to improve
personal teaching methods. The findings will not be published in any public forum. Your
answers to the following questions are completely anonymous and are in no way tied to any
individual's name or user id.
Response: I confirm that I have freely agreed to participate in this action research project.
I have been briefed on what this involves and I agree to the use of the findings as described
above.
[Q2-19 response data in table, legend: SA (strongly agree), A (agree), N (no opinion), D (disagree), SD (strongly
disagree)]
Q2: Performing skits in class on chapter topics is a useful or effective way to practice speaking
Spanish.
Q8: Working in groups to research Hispanic culture is a useful way to study Spanish.
Q9: Working in groups to research Hispanic culture is an interesting or fun way to study
Spanish.
Wilson 40
Q10: Exam review presentations are a useful way to review materials and reinforce learning.
Q11: Exam review presentations are an interesting or fun way to review materials and reinforce
learning.
Q13: Vocabulary review games are interesting or fun ways to reinforce learning.
Q14: Written exercises in the textbook are useful ways to practice and learn Spanish.
Q15: Written exercises in the textbook are interesting or fun ways to practice and learn Spanish.
Q16: Oral exercises in the textbook performed as a dialog between partners are useful ways to
practice and learn Spanish.
Q17: Oral exercises in the textbook performed as a dialog between partners are interesting or fun
ways to practice and learn Spanish.
Q18: Oral exercises in the textbook performed as an entire class are useful ways to practice and
learn Spanish.
Q19: Oral exercises in the textbook performed as an entire class are interesting or fun ways to
practice and learn Spanish.
• I really enjoyed Amanda's class. The only thing I would comment on is the video final
project. While it was fun to do and film, the language skills - mostly the vocabulary-
neccesary was above the level we had learned making the project stressful for the
students and the TAs.
• I thought the methods used were good. More dialogue between classmates would be
beneficial.
• I thought the video project was fun, but it was hard writing sentences on a spanish one
level. I also wish that we would have taken more notes and written more things in class to
help practice skills we have learned.
• Interesting survey. I have taken Spanish before and for me personally the best way to
learn it is to do the exercises, but not make them burdensome. Working in groups can
help and writing stuff up on the board can help. Conversations between class mates can
work but it helps if people are confortable, and that you let them learn at their own way
and not to force your ways of learning on them. We all learn differently and especially in
a foreign language we want to do it our way. I know this is not always possible, but give
them a chance. Does not mean you can not work them or help them, but letting them try it
Wilson 41
their way first can really help and sometimes even allows students to open up.
• I really enjoyed your class and you were very understanding and easy to work with when
it came to grading and making up work.
• More time actually speaking in class and being spoken to in Spanish would be beneficial.
The video project is a good idea, and is fun, however there is less focus on Spanish and
more on the technology requirments. Quia is the most helpful, I think that requiring
students to complete quia on accuracy would increase retention.
• You really need to put more emphasis on making sure that everyone has learned the
topics, especially grammar. You should really do more oral practice in class, not
memorized sentences that students read from a piece of paper but periods of you asking
questions in spanish and students responding in spanish using the vocabulary and
grammar from the chapter.
Wilson 42
Appendix B
• Tell me a little bit about other Spanish classes you’ve taken and what they were like.
Prompt: activities used, format of tests, amount you spoke up in class, what was the
environment like?
• I used various methods to teach Spanish, which ones do you remember most? Which did
you prefer? Which were not as helpful to you? Why? What do you think would help them
be more useful?
• What did you have the most fun with? What was difficult, boring, or too much work?
• What makes you comfortable/uncomfortable in a classroom? Tell me about a class in
which you spoke up and participated a lot. What did you like most about it? What do you
think that teacher did to help? How did you feel about the subject matter in that class?
• What ideas or further comments would you like to share with me?
Wilson 43
Appendix C
Reflections:
Reflections:
Mia was very candid. She began by complaining a lot about her current Spanish class. This was
helpful to me because it showed me what methods she was not enthusiastic about. Her main
Wilson 45
complaints were a lack of grammar explication, a lack of open dialog with the instructor, and
boring textbook activities. Since I was Mia's immediately previous instructor, I can take these
as points to avoid or improve on in my classroom because her comments were overt
comparisons between my class and her current class. Generally, I spend the time in class to
explicate grammar in English. This is almost a taboo practice in the field, but I stand by the
students. They want this, it helps them, and it is an expectation they have of language learning.
I want to fulfill their expectations. If they do not perceive that they are learning, that may
impede their experience. I also try to keep an open dialog, always asking for questions.
Whenever a student asks a question I cannot answer, instead of brushing them off, I tell them I
will get back to them. I ask a colleague or look it up and always make sure to follow up with
the student. That way, they keep asking questions. Lastly, I don't use the textbook activities too
much. I try to create something they perceive as more fun. Simply putting an exercise in a
textbook is a good way to turn students off to it. I'm not a big advocate of textbooks. I use
internet sites to help students engage. The same information will be infinitely more interesting
in a browser than in a book. This is also why I employ Facebook as much as possible.
When I asked Mia about which methods from my class were most memorable or useful, she
immediately smiled and started talking about the skits. She went on about how fun they were to
make, how they encouraged interaction with peers outside of class, and how excited they were
to perform them because they were so funny. She also mentioned the exam review projects I
have students complete at the end of the semester. She said she enjoyed getting to teach her
own part of the book and that making a game to practice vocabulary was helpful and fun. She
said her only complaint was that the grammar explications were a little boring because her
peers just read from their notes, not really teaching. I might make the instructions on this
assignment more explicit and give role playing examples to help improve this aspect. Finally,
she talked about the DVD newscasts I have students create. She said they were hours of fun and
laughing and that through the process she learned a lot about the culture and even more
Spanish. Basically, she seemed to enjoy and appreciate discovery-based learning. Anytime I
gave an assignment that required the students to go out and get the language and build it up into
something was most memorable and helpful for her.
When it came to be comfortable in the classroom, Mia's comments moved along two main
themes: the teacher's attitude and the interaction with peers. She said that, “when a teacher
seems to care about your input, that matters a lot. It definitely makes it more comfortable,
makes it easier to come to the teacher if you do have a problem.” She continued by saying that
an apathetic mood from the teacher makes class uncomfortable, that teachers should care. We
talked a bit about the seating arrangements in a class. For the most part, she seemed to want to
be as surrounded by peers as possible. She thought bigger groups for collaborative work was
preferable to working in pairs, especially if it was the same pair every time. She said that if a
teacher lectures a lot and doesn't allow for classmates to become acquainted, they will be
apathetic towards giving their opinions or participating if the teacher asks questions.
Mia said that she dreads a class if it doesn't seem like she is learning anything. She said she
looked forward to my class because it was interactive and she made friends and had fun. I asked
her if my assistant was helpful. She said he was very nice and knowledgeable, that he taught
Wilson 46
them a lot. She said he could be a little distracting when he cut up with some of the boys, but he
was super helpful. He was always taking them to the library and helping them study outside of
class.
Mia made a few over suggestions for me to try. First of all, she would like it if I speak more
Spanish in the classroom to help them get use to hearing it. She said when I would pronounce
the vocabulary or when we would read the culture sections aloud in class, which are in Spanish,
that that was very helpful, but she would appreciate me using the language more in class. She
also said funny songs in Spanish would be a nice addition to my current activities. Overall she
said my class was well-taught and enjoyable.
In regards to my interviewing, there were definitely places where I worried that I led her a bit
too much. I also noticed that I didn't give her a lot of time to think before prompting her in
another direction. For the next four interviews I want to be more open with my questions and
more patient when waiting for responses.
I'm not super surprised by anything that Mia said. It seems to make good sense to me that
interactive learning is important. I was interested in how much value she placed on getting to
know her classmates. I want to spend more time on this in the future. The better they know each
other, the more comfortable they will be. They need to feel comfortable and confident to speak
and not be afraid to make mistakes. I was a little surprised at her enthusiasm for the skits. I also
thought they were a fun activity and it's nice to know at least one student agrees. I expected the
comment about speaking in Spanish more in class. This is consistent feedback I get from
students and peer reviewers. I think this stems from a lack of confidence on my part. I am
working on this constantly, trying to improve. My assistants are really helpful in this aspect.
They give me an outlet to practice. It is difficult to maintain usage of a language if you can't
opportunities to practice it. Moving forward from all this information, I want to focus on the
following objectives, 1) continue to develop and improve discovery-based learning activities, 2)
foster peer collaboration, 3) endeavor to continue practicing and developing my own language
skills for use in my classroom, and 4) be more intentional about presenting and clarifying goals
and expectations at the beginning of the semester, not just tell students what I expect from
them, but soliciting their expectations of the class and taking those reflections into account in
my planning.
Notes Sabrina’s interview: (introvert)
Reflections:
Sabrina was very reserved, but friendly, as is usual for her. It took a lot more prompting to get
her to talk than it did for Mia. I felt maybe I asked too many close-ended questions and perhaps
I led her a little too much, but I always feel like this is necessary with the introverts. I'm still
pretty sure she was honest with her opinions.
Sabrina mentioned as the most memorable activity, the daily activity book because it made
learning visual for her. I'm not surprised she would choose this activity. It was a individual
assignment, it does include illustrations, and the speaking portion is an individually recorded
sample. This is the perfect example for a shy student.
She did like the skits and said they were more fun towards the end of the semester when she
was more comfortable with her peers. Taking the time to get to know her classmates is a
priority suggestion for Sabrina. She is not immediately comfortable with strangers anyway, but
compound that with the nerve racking activity of learning a second language and the stress piles
up quick.
While culture is important too, she acknowledges, that's not the point of the class for her. What
made her look forward to my class was the fact that it was meeting her educational goals, as she
said, “I want to know how to speak Spanish.”
Notes from Dana’s interview: (introvert)
Other classes
• first review previous material
• page by page through textbook
Wilson 48
Reflections:
Dana's interview was very interesting and I learned a lot more about her. She is an English
major and wants to be a teacher. She was always so quiet during my class, but never afraid to
ask questions afterward. She really enjoyed the activity I had them do in which they had to
teach a grammar point. As a future teacher, she enjoyed the opportunity to get up and teach, as
part of a group. Normally, she's not particularly introverted, but she is very uncomfortable in a
Spanish class, because she feels less than competent. Teaching a grammar point as part of a
group, gave her the opportunity to focus on and learn the point very well with just enough
pressure because she was going to have to teach it, but not too much stress because she
wouldn't be up there alone. For Dana, a teacher with a good attitude can create a comfortable
environment just by showing students they care and want them to learn. She also stressed the
importance of various forms and sources of explanations because different people learn
differently. Finally, she communicated that nothing makes a classroom more uncomfortable
than unclear expectations. When she takes a class, she has expectations and it is frustrating
when she doesn't learn what she wants to.
other classes:
Wilson 49
• lots of worksheets
my class
• skits:
o putting together sentences helped a lot
o building 'real-life' sentences instead
o having before test would be very helpful
• daily activities book
o helpful
o sound recording was 'a giant pain in the ass' :)
was too much work
same thing as a skit
technology made it frustrating
comfortable
• teacher's attitude
o relaxed
o more personable and approachable
o good speaker
o knowledgeable
• expectations
o class should be what they expect
ideas
• daily activities project right at end was a little too much at once
Reflections:
Lorie's primary concerns were three-fold. First, she really appreciated discovery-based and
hands-on learning. Any activity that allowed her to create a real context in which to situate the
language was preferred to grammar drills in the textbook. Second, she wanted to be in a
classroom with an instructor who was relaxed, personable, and approachable. A teacher should
be a real, authentic person, not just a teacher. Finally, she wanted to know what to expect.
While my style of teaching is laid back and relaxed, it is also a bit erratic. Being more explicit
with students about my expectations would have been helpful.
Notes on Micah’s interview: (extrovert)
other classes:
• native speaker
o spends whole class talking to us and asking us questions
look at vocab page and ask, “Hay … en la foto?” and responded “Si, hay
… en la foto.”
o fewer QUIA exercises helps focus instead of being too frustrating or
overwhelming
my methods:
• group activities, despite conflicts with certain members
• skits
o connect with peers
o fun
o oral practice
Wilson 50
• QUIA
o too many activities
• review more
o start class with a review of previous class material
guys we did this last time
o then move into new material
now we're doing this
o the summarize at end and look forward to what's next
next time we will
o more structure, tie it all together
• pace was very fast
• regularity, they know what to expect every class
o one vocab thing, a little practice
o one grammar thing, a practice exercise
o expectations help keep them on track and be aware of their own learning
• assistant
o review sessions – bigger is better here
o corrected my paper, but didn't explain/couldn't explain why
his assistant wasn't as far along in her studies
o it's nice to know that there's help, even if you don't use it.
o LTS tutoring helps too
• comfort level
o teacher's personality
not too serious
like to have fun, laugh
talk to students, connect on a personal level
o knowing classmates
anything else?
• Group scheduling issues
• more explication of grammar, slower
• podcasts
o listen to grammar at home via vodcast, do acts in class w/teacher is great idea
Reflections:
The most important points I will take away from Micah's comments deal primarily with the
structure and expectations of my classroom. While it is true that I am hearing another plea for
more use of the target language in the classroom, Micah's biggest concern was not being
comfortable or confident in understanding my expectations. He pointed out that having a bit
more of a routine and a regular review of previous materials would help make my classroom
more comfortable for students.
After hearing about Micah's current instructor, let's call her Mariana, I decided to implement
another data set in the form of a classroom observation. With Mariana's permission, what
follows is a day in her classroom with me as an external observer.
Mariana began her class speaking Spanish conversationally with the students. She asked what
time it was and for them to pass in their homework. Students were on-task quickly and
responsive to her questions and comments. Whenever she asked students to turn to a page in the
book, she gave the number in two formats: the “correct” way, for example dos cientos trece, but
also as individual numbers to be sure they understood, for example dos, uno, tres. This seemed to
be a very effective method to get students to the correct page quickly without having to rely on
English and also reinforcing the target language.
Next, she told students what she planned to cover today. She asked leading questions to get
students to focus on the material and start thinking about it. For example, she asked when they
would use this new verb conjugation and with whom they would address.
Moving to the board, she slowly and carefully guided the class through the process with a first
example. She gave them all the elements they needed to conjugate it correctly and patiently gave
them time to process and hypothesize. She used the verbs and vocabulary pertinent to the chapter
in her examples. Moving on to second and third examples, she called on specific students to
follow the process and give the correct answer. Mariana gave gentle corrections and helped lead
students who weren’t following exactly right. She was very patient, giving them a little time to
think. In general, the students made almost all accurate guesses. This is mostly likely due to the
clear and concise explication of the first example. She continues through two or three more
examples of each part, calling on different students to participate.
She scaffolds each piece onto the next well; explaining first the positives, for example, and then
how to make them negative. She is obviously very well prepared, almost never checking her
notes as she goes through.
Any opportunity to use familiar phrases in Spanish is used well. For example, ‘hay cinco verbos
que son irregulares’ was one such phrase. Although the grammar may be confusing, this
sentence is simple, clear, and direct. She calls on the students to provide the information and she
writes it on the board, pointing out irregularities and accent marks that they need to pay special
attention to.
Before moving on to a new concept, she breaks the explication with a practice exercise. Again,
the page numbers, the activity numbers, and the directions to turn to a certain page and do a
certain activity are all given in the target language. Her consistent use of the directions and
numbers in Spanish in class shows clearly when students are very quickly on-task. She goes
around the room as students work and asks certain ones to put the answers to certain numbers on
the board. Again, her instructions are in the target language. The students quickly put the answer
up on the board. They then go through the exercise as a class. She has different students read the
entire sentence aloud, adding the correct answer. She then discusses with them whether or not is
correct and why. She uses the examples to point out other verbs that behave the same way.
Again, scaffolding the knowledge and tying everything together.
Students seem very engaged and comfortable in her class. They are not afraid to interrupt an
activity or explanation to ask a question. They participate willing and, for the most part, get the
correct answers. It is easy to see they are learning.
Finally, she lets them know what to expect for the next class period and returns corrected
homework from a previous class.
I’ve learned a lot sitting in Mariana’s class. Her grammar explications are clear and concise. She
is aware of her students and their concerns, allowing time for questions and for processing the
information. Her class time was used very efficiently. The students stayed engaged throughout
Wilson 52
the class. There was no unnecessary chatter. It is obvious after sitting in this class that her
students respect her. She’s a wonderful teacher and I aspire to be more like her.
Reflections:
Thanks to Micah's comments in his interview, I had the opportunity to observe a truly
magnificent colleague in action. There are several elements I plan to steal from Mariana's style.
First, her patient, clear, and concise interactions with her students. Sometimes, I fear I get in too
big of a hurry and rush students. This must be as frustrating for them as it is for me when at the
end of the day they simply don't get it. As much as possible, I hope to adopt a more patient style
that I believe will help my students engage more actively in the classroom. Secondly, I plan to
adopt, again as a suggestions of Micah's that I got to see in action in Mariana's class, is they way
she organized her class and lets them know what to expect next. She scaffolds the materials she
teaches and she uses consistent methods that let students get into a comfortable routine. Finally, I
hope to speak the language more and with more confidence. Granted as a native speaker,
Mariana has an advantage, but I don't want my students to be at a disadvantage because of my
language skills. I endeavor to continue to improve and practice my speaking skills and, as almost
everyone commented, use Spanish more in my classroom.
Q20: Additional Comments: (unedited responses)
• I really enjoyed Amanda's class. The only thing I would comment on is the video final
project. While it was fun to do and film, the language skills - mostly the vocabulary-
neccesary was above the level we had learned making the project stressful for the
students and the TAs.
• I thought the methods used were good. More dialogue between classmates would be
beneficial.
• I thought the video project was fun, but it was hard writing sentences on a spanish one
level. I also wish that we would have taken more notes and written more things in class to
help practice skills we have learned.
• Interesting survey. I have taken Spanish before and for me personally the best way to
learn it is to do the exercises, but not make them burdensome. Working in groups can
help and writing stuff up on the board can help. Conversations between class mates can
work but it helps if people are confortable, and that you let them learn at their own way
and not to force your ways of learning on them. We all learn differently and especially in
a foreign language we want to do it our way. I know this is not always possible, but give
them a chance. Does not mean you can not work them or help them, but letting them try it
their way first can really help and sometimes even allows students to open up.
• I really enjoyed your class and you were very understanding and easy to work with when
it came to grading and making up work.
• More time actually speaking in class and being spoken to in Spanish would be beneficial.
The video project is a good idea, and is fun, however there is less focus on Spanish and
more on the technology requirments. Quia is the most helpful, I think that requiring
students to complete quia on accuracy would increase retention.
• You really need to put more emphasis on making sure that everyone has learned the
topics, especially grammar. You should really do more oral practice in class, not
memorized sentences that students read from a piece of paper but periods of you asking
questions in spanish and students responding in spanish using the vocabulary and
Wilson 53
Reflections:
Four of the primary themes I've identified in my research appear here in the survey comments.
The most predominant seems to relate to advice on methods. This is appropriate since the
primary 18 survey questions dealt with nine teaching methods. The dominant comment relates to
the DVD project being too much work or not enough focus on what was actually learned in the
class. My first idea for adjusting this project for next semester is two-fold. First, I plan to be
more explicit with the directions for the assignment, pushing the focus towards pertinent
vocabulary. Secondly, and to help with the first point, I plan to devote more classroom time to
working on the script writing portion of this project. Another theme represented here is their
perceptions of and interactions with me. While my easygoing nature is appreciated, there is a
focus on being more explicit in my grammar explications and reviews and, once again, the desire
to hear me speak more Spanish in class. A third theme represented here is their perceptions of
and interactions with their peers. They value group work and interaction in the classroom and
facilitation of these interactions. Finally, the students' self perceptions and comfort levels are
expounded on in two ways. First, by letting me know that the DVD project was stressful and
second, by advising that I differentiate my teaching style to encompass different learners, as well
as being patient and allowing more room for experimentation in learning.