Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287207071
CITATIONS READS
0 156
4 authors, including:
Alan Phenix
Getty Conservation Institute
26 PUBLICATIONS 140 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
ESCAPE: Expert System for Characterization using AMDIS Plus Excel View project
All content following this page was uploaded by James Druzik on 18 December 2015.
1
Bright ideas: exploring
ways to document
DOCUMENTATION Dan Flavins Fluorescent
Light
rescents sont de plus en plus difficiles trouver standards will cause the diameter of fluorescent lamps to shrink by a
et menacent de tomber dans lobsolescence.
third, thereby substantially altering one of the key sculptural components
Cet article discute de plusieurs aspects fonda-
mentaux des mthodes de travail de Flavin,
of Flavins artworks.
des critres gnraux de documentation et des
All of these factors underscore the need to comprehensively document
avances ralises ce jour grce lexplora-
tion de la spectroradiomtrie comme technique Flavins materials and outline a strategy to fabricate replacement fluorescent
de mesure et de caractrisation du spectre de materials when they are no longer commercially available. These research
rayonnement mis par lventail de ses tubes needs sparked a collaboration between Dia Art Foundation, the Flavin Estate,
fluorescents.
and the Getty Conservation Institute, designed to undertake a thorough
documentation of Flavins equipment and determine means to analyze
Resumen
Durante ms de 30 aos, Dan Flavin (1933
and measure the color and intensity of Flavins fluorescent lights. Now
1996) trabaj con luz fluorescente disponible continuing with collaboration from the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum,
comercialmente, cuya gama de colores, as which has received funding from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation for
como la longitud de los soportes, eran limita-
this purpose, the research goals are to devise a methodology to accurately
das. A pesar de la regularidad de su medio, su
paleta se puede expandir dramticamente, con
measure the color of emitted light from fluorescent lamps and create a
variaciones sutiles y combinaciones de color matrix of materials to inform custom formulation of Flavins fluorescent
que aparecen en las paredes, suelo y plafones media in the future.
de las instalaciones de una pieza de arte deter-
minada. Esto se vuelve especialmente complejo
cuando se combinan lmparas de diferentes
Flavins Fluorescent Lamps
colores en una obra, o cuando el trabajo est
The equipment that Flavin used was, for the most part, made from standard
integrado en contextos arquitectnicos com-
plicados. La fotografa estndar de su trabajo size fluorescent lamps and fixtures in 2', 4', 6' and 8' lengths. His chosen
es especialmente difcil e inexacta y se requiere color palette of fluorescent lamps came from commercially available
un mtodo efectivo para su documentacin, colors and included green, blue, pink, yellow, red, filtered ultraviolet, cool
ya que las lmparas fluorescentes se vuelven
white, warm white, daylight, and soft white. The range of lamps includes
difciles de conseguir conforme tienden a ser
obsoletas. Este artculo analiza algunas de las mainstream, high volume products from the major manufacturers General
sobresalientes caractersticas de los mtodos Electric, Philips, Sylvania, and Osram.
de trabajo de Flavin, los requisitos generales de
documentacin, y los avances hasta la fecha en As with any electric light, fluorescent lamps need to be replaced as they
la exploracin de la espectro-radiometra como fail. However, unlike other light sources, such as tungsten filament bulbs,
tcnica para medir y caracterizar el espectro de
fluorescent lamps do not usually reach an abrupt failure point; instead they
la radiacin emitida por su paleta de lmparas
fluorescentes.
gradually lose their performance over time as a consequence of their use.
The useful lifetime of linear fluorescent lamps can be anything from 5000
hours to 60,000 hours depending on the operating conditions and type of
control circuit. The point at which a lamp is considered ineffective and
needing replacement is dependent on the specific illuminating function
and context; some contexts may allow a greater tolerance of reduced or
altered radiant output than others.
2
Bright ideas: exploring
ways to document
DOCUMENTATION Dan Flavins Fluorescent
Light
the way in which the color and intensity of a given lamp combines with
or impacts an adjacent fluorescent lamp of another color.
made available for a study of both their phosphor powder coatings and
quality of emitted fluorescent light. Details of these lamps, including
product-specific information contained in manufacturer-applied markings,
are given in Table 1.
Table 1
Product details of Flavin fluorescent lamps contributed to the project Dan Flavin Ltd Studio, New York. With
the exception of the General Electric Trimline T8, these lamps are all 2, 1.5 diameter, 20W T12-type lamps
4
Bright ideas: exploring
ways to document
DOCUMENTATION Dan Flavins Fluorescent
Light
reflected surfaces. CIE never intended this and both can be used for either
subject. Berns et al. (2000) indicate that CIELUV may have received this
misconception because it is based on a uniform chromaticity diagram
which is preferred in the lighting industry.
For this reason, Flavin lamp chromaticity was examined using the CIE 1976
UCS diagram which is a more uniform color space with coordinates defined as
u' and v'. From this color space simple statistics can be calculated on average
Flavin lamp chromaticities, and ultimately it should be possible to recommend
acceptable and unacceptable color differences. This does not avoid the need to
analyze spectroradiometric quantities associated with Flavins works because
the interrelationships between fluorescent colors as they mix on wall surfaces
is also dependent on lamp luminosities. Typically, we would wish to augment
chromaticity with radiometry and photometry.
0,80
0,60
Radiance (watts/sr/m2)
Green
Pink
0,40 Red
Yellow
Blue
0,20
0,00
380 480 580 680 780
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 7
Spectra of green, pink, red, yellow, and blue lamps from the Dan Flavin Ltd Studio, New York
5
Bright ideas: exploring
ways to document
DOCUMENTATION Dan Flavins Fluorescent
Light
has much lower overall radiance it simply does not generate much light.
Not surprisingly, when evaluating the spectrum of the white lamps: warm
white, cool white, and daylight (Figure 8), the warm white has the strongest
emission in the yellow-to-red part of the spectrum and the lowest in the
blue; the daylight lamp is characterized by the most uniform distribution
of wavelengths.
Figure 8
0,20
0,16
Radiance (watts/sr/m2)
0,12 Cool
White
Daylight
0,08
Warm
White
0,04
0,00
380 480 580 680 780
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 8
Spectra of cool white, daylight, and warm white lamps from the Dan Flavin Ltd Studio, New York
The values of radiance (in watts per steradian per square metre) for each of
the differently colored Flavin lamps are given in Table 2, which confirms
the significantly lower output of the red and yellow tubes. When normalized
to the brightest lamp in the group of colored tubes, it can be seen that the
red lamp radiates only 10 percent of the energy of the green. The spectral
emission characteristics of a lamp are, however, only one factor that
contributes to our visual perception of it. The visual brightness of a lamp
is influenced also by the correspondence of the spectral emission with
the spectral sensitivity of the human visual system. How bright a light
source appears to our visual system is defined by its luminance, measured
in candela/m2. Luminance data for the colored and white Flavin lamps
are also given in Table 2.
Table 2
Radiance and luminance data measured for the colored and white Flavin lamps
Lamp Type Green Pink Red Yellow Blue Cool White Daylight Warm
White
Radiance (w/sr/m2) 22.76 18.94 2.23 9.58 18.15 17.12 18.99 16.79
Normalized 1.00 0.83 0.10 0.42 0.80 0.90 1.00 0.88
Luminance (cd/m2) 11480.00 5409.00 241.20 4294.00 913.30 5992.00 5842.00 6222.00
Normalized 1.00 0.47 0.02 0.37 0.08 0.96 0.94 1.00
For the white lamps, the warm white is the brightest despite having the
lowest overall radiance; the cool white and daylight lamps are 96 percent
and 94 percent as bright, respectively. The colored lamps vary enormously
6
Bright ideas: exploring
ways to document
DOCUMENTATION Dan Flavins Fluorescent
Light
Conclusion
Dan Flavin is the most widely recognized 20th century American artist
using fluorescent light to give form and color to his art. As discussed,
variation is inherent to Flavins artwork and was, to a degree, historically
accepted since the artist was using industrially produced materials. This
project seeks to document the artists practice and range of media, both in
terms of creating a historic reference regarding the materials used, and in
terms of creating a standard by which fluorescent lamps are reproduced
in the future given their pending obsolescence.
The data presented here are the first steps towards quantitative description
of the color palette of Flavins fluorescent lamps, and measuring the
variation of these properties over time (emission spectrum, radiance, and
luminance) is an important project goal to aid in understanding the color
shifts that may occur in his works over prolonged periods of operation.
The strong variation in luminance of colored lamps that is particularly
important because the relationship of mixed colors is sensitive to differential
losses between lamps.
References
Berns, R.S., F.W. Billmeyer, and M. Saltzman. 2000. Billmeyer and Saltzmans
principles of color technology. New York: Wiley.
7
Bright ideas: exploring
ways to document
DOCUMENTATION Dan Flavins Fluorescent
Light
Butler, K.H. 1980. Fluorescent lamp phosphors: technology and theory. University
Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Kitai, A.H. 1993. Solid state luminescence: theory, materials and devices. London:
Chapman and Hall.
Ronda, C.R. 1997. Recent achievements in research on phosphors for lamps and displays.
Journal of Luminescence 7274: 4954.
Srivastava, A.M., and C.R. Ronda. 2003. Phosphors. The electrochemical
society. Interface Summer: 4851.
Yen, W.M, S. Shionoya, and H. Yamamoto, eds. 2007. Practical Applications
of Phosphors. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
Materials list
Photo Research, Inc., 9731 Topanga Canyon Place, Chatsworth, CA 91311-4135, USA
http://www.photoresearch.com/current/pr670.asp
Appendix 1
Fluorescent lamp phosphors
The history, technology and science of fluorescent lamp phosphors is widely described in
the literature. An excellent introduction to the subject can be found in the short reviews
by Srivastava and Ronda (2003) and by Ronda (1997), and more detailed, comprehensive
accounts are given by Butler 1980, Kitai 1993, and by Yen et al. (2007).
The fundamental process by which fluorescent lamps operate involves conversion of the
ultraviolet emission generated by a rare-gas/mercury discharge plasma into visible light at
high quantum efficiency. Fluorescent lamps effectively consist of a discharge lamp which
has on the inside a coating containing one or more phosphor compounds; the phosphors
absorb the emitted UV and re-emit radiation at longer wavelengths.
Although not the first generation of fluorescent lamp phosphors, the revolutionary innovation
of the 1940s, which led to the broad commercial development of fluorescent lamps, were
halophosphate materials: essentially calcium halophosphate [Ca5(PO4)3 (Cl, F)] doped/
activated with Sb3+ and Mn2+ compounds. The blue Sb3+-activated emission in combination
with the complementary yellow Mn2+-activated emission provided a resultant white light.
The color (temperature) of the lamp can be varied by varying the proportion of Mn 2+ or
the relative proportions of Cl and F in the halophosphate. Generally, now, halophosphate
phosphors find use only in low cost, low specification products.
The major technological development since the 1970s has been the adoption by manufacturers
of rare-earth triphosphors, which offer the possibility of high efficiency and high color
rendering. Triphosphor lamps contain three phosphors that each emit in relatively narrow bands
respectively in the red, green and blue parts of the spectrum. The most common red-emitting
phosphor is europium (Eu3+)-activated yttrium oxide; green-emitters are commonly terbium
(Tb3+)-activated cerium magnesium aluminium oxide (CeMgAl11O19) or terbium (Tb3+)- and
cerium (Ce3+)-doped lanthanum phosphate (typically La0.60Ce0.27Tb0.13PO4); blue-emitting
phosphors are usually (Eu2+)-activated Sr/Ca/Ba/Mg chloroapatite [(Sr,Ba,Ca)5(PO4)3Cl],
or (Eu2+)-activated barium magnesium aluminate [BaMgAl10O7 ]. By blending together the
red, green and blue phosphor components in the correct proportions, a net white output of
various hues can be generated, usually giving a distinctive triple-peak emission spectrum
for white triphosphor lamps. Cooler color temperatures are created by increasing the relative
proportion of blue-emitting phosphor.
Some manufacturers publish the composition of their lamp phosphors (see, for example,
http://www.sylvania.com/BusinessProducts/MaterialsandComponents/LightingComponents/
Phosphor/FluorescentLamps/)
Speciality colored fluorescent lamps will be created by inclusion of particular phosphors
to give the specific color intended.