Sie sind auf Seite 1von 4

Case 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 1 of 4 PageID #: 42180

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
TYLER DIVISION

Judge Robert W. Schroeder III

VIRNETX INC., et al

V. CIVIL NO. 6:10cv417

APPLE INC.
______________________________________________________________________________
MINUTES FOR POST-TRIAL MOTIONS HEARING
HELD BEFORE JUDGE ROBERT W. SCHROEDER III
NOVEMBER 22, 2016

OPEN: 9:00 am ADJOURN: 5:40 pm


______________________________________________________________________________
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFFS: See Attorney Sign-In Sheet

ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANTS: See Attorney Sign-In Sheet

LAW CLERK: Jenna Rea Deneault

COURTROOM DEPUTY: Betty Schroeder

COURT REPORTER: Amanda Leigh


______________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________

9:00 am Case called, parties announced ready, Court welcomes parties

9:03 am Mr. John Summers argues VirnetXs Request for a Finding of Willfulness (dkt.
#1047)

9:21 am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds

9:24 am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds

9:34 am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds

9:37 am Court questions Mr. Summers; Mr. Summers responds

9:38 am Mr. John Desmarais responds


Case 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 2 of 4 PageID #: 42181

9:43 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

9:51 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

9:59 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

10:12 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

10:18 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

10:24 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

10:29 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

10:36 am Break

10:46 am Mr. Summers replies

11:02 am Mr. Desmarais responds

11:06 am Court questions Mr. Desmarais; Mr. Desmarais responds

11:09 am Mr. Summers replies

11:14 am Mr. Chris Stewart argues VirnetXs Motion for Entry of Judgment and Equitable
and Statutory Relief (dkt. #1063) (Enhanced Damages)

11:25 am Court questions Mr. Stewart; Mr. Stewart responds

11:29 am Courtroom sealed

11:29 am Court questions Mr. Stewart; Mr. Stewart responds

11:36 am Courtroom unsealed

11:38 am Mr. Greg Arovas responds

11:46 am Court questions Mr. Arovas; Mr. Arovas responds

11:54 am Mr. Stewart requests the courtroom to be sealed; Mr. Arovas responds; Court
responds

12:13 pm Mr. Stewart replies

12:22 pm Mr. Arovas responds


Case 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 3 of 4 PageID #: 42182

12:28 pm Mr. Stewart replies

12:29 pm Break

1:33 pm Ms. Jeannie Heffernan argues Apples Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law
(dkt. #1062) (damages)

1:51 pm Ms. Heffernan argues Apples Motion for New Trial (damages)

1:55 pm Court questions Ms. Heffernan; Ms. Heffernan responds

2:03 pm Court questions Ms. Heffernan; Ms. Heffernan responds

2:14 pm Mr. Jason Cassady responds to the Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law

2:20 pm Court questions Mr. Cassady; Mr. Cassady responds

2:42 pm Mr. Daniel Pearson responds to the Motion for New Trial

3:01 pm Mr. Brad Caldwell responds

3:05 pm Ms. Heffernan replies

3:15 pm Mr. Pearson responds

3:17 pm Mr. Cassady responds

3:22 pm Ms. Heffernan replies

3:23 pm Mr. Cassady responds

3:24 pm Break

3:35 pm Mr. Robert Appleby argues Apples Motion for Judgment as a Matter of Law and
New Trial (non-infringement)

3:38 pm Court questions Mr. Appleby: Mr. Appleby responds

3:58 pm Mr. Austin Curry responds

4:16 pm Mr. Appleby replies

4:19 pm Mr. Curry responds

4:21 pm Mr. Appleby replies


Case 6:10-cv-00417-RWS Document 1071 Filed 11/22/16 Page 4 of 4 PageID #: 42183

4:22 pm Mr. Curry responds

4:24 pm Mr. Joseph Loy argues Apples Motion for New Trial Regarding Prejudicial
FaceTime Relay Redesign

4:35 pm Mr. Caldwell responds

4:42 pm Mr. Loy replies

4:43 pm Mr. Caldwell responds

4:45 pm Mr. Akshay Doaras argues Apples Motion for New Trial - Liability Jury
Instructions

4:49 pm Court questions Mr. Doaras; Mr. Doaras responds

4:51 pm Mr. Caldwell responds

5:07 pm Mr. Appleby replies

5:10 pm Mr. Caldwell responds

5:12 pm Mr. Appleby replies

5:13 pm Mr. Caldwell responds

5:14 pm Mr. Stewart argues VirnetXs Motion for Attorneys Fees

5:19 pm Mr. Arovas responds

5:24 pm Mr. Stewart replies

5:26 pm Mr. Caldwell replies

5:33 pm Mr. Arovas responds

5:36 pm Mr. Caldwell replies

5:37 pm Court asks for page and line regarding the Van Pelt issue

5:38 pm Mr. Pearson argues VirnetXs Motion for Pre/Post Judgment Interest; will submit
the Motion for Costs on paper

5:40 pm Court asks the parties to file their slides; Recess

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen