Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Special Draw a p
icture of
your sym
ptom.
Issue:
Pediatric
Integrative
Medicine
rt.
c t u r e o f comfo
pi
Draw a
FROM THE EDITOR
Spring 2003 Special Issue of Biofeedback
Pediatric Integrative Medicine
Donald Moss, PhD
This special issue of Biofeedback is devoted to Pediatric Integrative dren will appreciate the creative and Donald Moss, PhD
Medicine. I am grateful to Timothy Culbert, Rebecca Kajander, and innovative approach taken to the prob-
Judson Reaney, who have assembled a rich collection of articles lems of children in these pages.
showing the current state of the art in pediatrics, with an emphasis We also include here an article on children’s rights by Sebastian
on integrating biofeedback into a comprehensive integrative treat- Striefel. I also thank each of our authors and the AAPB production
ment, including both mainstream therapies and complementary staff headed by Publications Manager Michael Thompson.
and alternative therapies. The initial article by Dr. Culbert elabo- The Association News and Events Section includes messages
rates the orientation of this special issue, which emphasizes comple- from AAPB’s President Paul Lehrer, President-Elect Lynda Kirk, as
mentary/alternative medicine and integrative therapies (CAMIT). well as other Association news
AAPB owes an enormous debt of gratitude to Tim Culbert, Jud Proposals and Abstracts are now invited for new special issues on:
Reaney, and Rebecca Kajander. This team has exerted leadership Complementary and Alternative Medicine for Fall 2003, and Case
from the beginning in AAPB’s Pediatrics Section, and has presented Studies in Clinical Psychophysiology in Spring 2004. The editor also
countless symposia and workshops at AAPB’s annual meetings. This welcomes proposals for future special issues of the Biofeedback
is their second special issue on pediatrics. Anyone who loves chil- Magazine.
“In a sense, medicine is burning, as old ideas tive medicine and integrative therapies tary and alternative therapies (Kemper, et
and methods are fading on every hand. But (CAMITi) with increasing frequency al., 1999). Secondly, many US hospitals are
medicine’s fires are purifying: New life is (Ernst, 1999). Within the context of offering CAMIT services more routinely
emerging from the ashes as it always does. CAMIT as applied to pediatric populations, (Pelletier, et al., 1999). Many US medical
The reinventors are stepping forward, and
biofeedback and related mind/body schools are now offering coursework in
healing is in the wind. The rebirth has
approaches are situated firmly as a group of CAMIT (Wetzel, et al, 1998). Evidence
begun.”
(Dossey, 1999, p. 265) strategies that are well accepted by pediatri- for efficacy is increasing rapidly (Moher,
“There cannot be two kinds of medicine cians and for which excellent literature sup- et al, 2002). Finally, third party payers are
–conventional and alternative. There is only port exists (Culbert & Banez, 2003; Olness including CAMIT in health plans now
medicine that has been adequately tested & Kohen, 1996). Biofeedback, applied psy- more than ever (Spencer & Jacobs, 1999,
and medicine that has not, medicine that chophysiology and self-regulation skills pp. 371-390).
works and medicine that may or may not training, are approaches that are categorized The Cochrane Collaboration defines
work.” within the mind/body domain of CAMIT. CAMIT as a “broad domain of healing
(Angell & Kassir, 1998, p. 841) The purpose of this article is threefold: resources that encompass all health systems
“There is little doubt that CAM therapies • to provide brief background informa- modalities and practices and their accompa-
represent an ‘invisible mainstream’ within
tion on the evolution of CAMIT nying theories and beliefs, other than those
our healthcare delivery system. Whether and
and their relevance to pediatric intrinsic to the politically dominant systems
how these therapies and approaches are to be
productively included within the delivery of health care, of a particular society or culture in a given
health care remains a shared challenge.” • to discuss the area of biofeedback and historical period” (Zollman & Vickers,
(Eisenberg, 2000, p. 3 ) applied psychophysiology with chil- 1999, p. 394). This definition highlights
Abstract: This article reviews current dren and adolescents in the context the fact that many practices viewed by
issues, definitions, and usage trends in of CAMIT, modern Americans as complementary, alter-
Complementary/Alternative Medicine (CAM) • to discuss future directions for this native or “unorthodox” are perfectly main-
and Integrative approaches specific to pedi- area within pediatric healthcare. stream and orthodox in other parts of the
atrics. The article also discusses biofeedback world (e.g. Naturopathy, Traditional
Defining the Scope of Chinese Medicine, Ayurvedic Medicine)
and self-regulation skills training for children
within the context of the mind/body domain Complementary/ (Oumeish, 1998). The term “allopathic
of complementary/alternative medicine. Alternative Medicine and “medicine is increasingly used to describe
the dominant US model (Gundling, 1998),
Introduction Integrative Therapies although this may not be advantageous.
These quotations reflect the passion, Early definitions of CAMIT described Terminology becomes confusing in that
urgency and confusion being experienced them as therapies that are: many healing traditions such as Traditional
by western, conventionally trained health 1) generally not taught in US medical Chinese Medicine, Naturopathy and
care professionals as our patients and their schools, Homeopathy involve inclusive, complete
families increasingly embrace a wide variety 2) generally not provided at US hospitals, systems and have their own training schools
of therapeutic options that are often 3) lacking evidence of effectiveness, and certification within the US and abroad.
unknown, untested and unfamiliar to many 4) generally not reimbursable by third Many CAMIT practices are considered
in mainstream pediatric medicine. Health party payers (Eisenberg, 1993). legitimate replacements on their own to
care professionals are finding that their This perspective is problematic for a Western, allopathic medicine, hence the
pediatric patients, just like the adult popu- number of reasons. First, there are multiple term “alternative.” Others are seen as pri-
lation, are utilizing complementary/alterna- definitions of what constitute complemen- marily being utilized adjunctively with a
Children’s Rights:
Legal and Ethical Issues
Sebastian “Seb” Striefel, PhD, Logan, UT
Abstract: Serving children can be difficult father) called up by the military to serve tivity, impulsivity, and inattention. So how
and requires some competencies that are differ- elsewhere, and fear for one’s own life have do you ethically and legally provide services
ent from those needed in serving adults. become a reality. Increasing numbers of to children and adolescents?
Children’s rights from a legal perspective are children and adolescents need help in cop-
confusing because of the lack of consistency in ing with such stressors. La Greca developed
Competencies
laws, rules, and regulations within and across a widely acclaimed workbook for parents to Children and adolescents are dependent,
states. As children get older the legal perspec- use in helping their children cope with ter- vulnerable, often unable to protect them-
tive shifts from a nurturance to a self-determi- rorist attacks and other major stressors like selves, and cannot advocate for themselves
nation orientation which is consistent with the hurricanes (De Angelis, 2002).i Could you with policy makers. For example, few chil-
philosophy of self-regulation which is inherent do something similar to promote and dren or adolescents seek treatment for emo-
in biofeedback. Children have the same ethi- advertise your practice? tional or medical problems. In fact, the
cal rights that adults have, but the rights must Hoagwood said that “mental health is an greatest fear adolescents have is disclosure of
be tempered by factors such as the law, age, essential part of children’s health” (DeAngelis, confidential information to their parents
and cognitive abilities. 2001, p. 52). Even the U.S.. Surgeon (Feldman-Winters & McAbee, 2002) so
General has made a commitment to they often seek help only when it has
Introduction improve children’s mental health. Davies become an emergency. As such, practition-
Did you know that public health person- (2003) suggested that primary care practi- ers who do, or who plan to provide services
nel long ago identified ethnicity and race, tioners could perform an important health to children and adolescents, need to have a
family income and family structure, and the care service by lobbying for physiological broad range of competencies that are differ-
presence of one versus two parents in the self-regulation services to be introduced at ent in many ways from those useful in
home as important risk factors for whether the preschool level and then adding more working successfully with adults. The
teenagers engage in risky health related sophisticated knowledge and skills as the American Psychological Association’s (APA,
behaviors such as smoking, drinking, sexual children grow older and advance through 1998, 1994) “Guidelines for psychological
intercourse, violent behavior, and suicide the education system. Can you imagine a evaluation in child protection matters” and
(Carpenter, 2001)? However, school per- world in which children know as much “Guidelines for child custody evaluation in
formance, use of free time, friendships, and about the impact of different life styles, divorce proceedings” both point out the
family relationships are just as important diets, exercise, relaxation, stress manage- importance of various competencies,
(Carpenter, 2001). The message is, don’t ment, and mind-body connections as they including but not limited to, knowing
leave children or teenagers on their own. do about reading, writing, and arithmetic? about and understanding: normal and
Long before 9/11 children and adoles- Could your practice promote such knowl- deviant child and family development,
cents were being exposed to school and edge profitably? appropriate methods for evaluating poten-
community level violence, a rapidly chang- Applied psychophysiology and biofeed- tial child problems (both physical and men-
ing world of technology, and the lack of back have much to offer in the treatment of tal), psychopathology in children, nature of
appropriate health care services. Each of children via the training of self-regulation abuse and neglect, the role of human differ-
these factors can be extremely stressful. skills (Culbert & Reaney, 1998). For exam- ences, and cultural variations. Practitioners
Since 9/11 children and adolescents have ple, O’Conner (2001) pointed out that far should undertake a reasonable course of
had increased levels of exposure to terrorism too many children are receiving drug treat- education and training before working with
and war. Losing a family member in the ment for Attention Deficit Hyperactivity children to ensure that they are competent
9/11 attacks, fearing such a loss in a future Disorders (ADHD) in comparison to avail- in the skills needed to do “what is in the best
attack, being discriminated against because able prevalence figures. EEG and other interests of the child.” APA (Crawford, 2002)
one is a member of an identifiable minority behavioral approaches are alternative treat- has available a publication for helping pro-
group (especially as a member of a Middle ment approaches for dealing with hyperac- fessionals of various health care disciplines
East culture), having a parent (mother or to understand adolescents. It is called,
Integrative Approaches to
Assessment and
Management of Recurrent
Headaches in Children Rebecca Kajander,
CNP, MPH
Frank Andrasik, PhD
Abstract: The purpose of this article is to According to Apley, RAP is characterized by exhibited symptoms at follow-up (as many
provide an empirically-informed but clinically three or more episodes of abdominal pain as 76%), almost one-half of these children
oriented overview of conventional and alter- that occur over at least three months and have manifested other psychosomatic or
native treatments for recurrent abdominal are severe enough to interfere with activi- physical complaints (Sticker & Murphy,
pain (RAP). First, issues related to classifica- ties, such as school attendance and perform- 1979; Apley & Hale, 1973). Long term fol-
tion, epidemiology, and conceptual models of ance, social activities, and participation in low-up of children hospitalized for RAP (as
RAP are outlined. Second, conventional med- sports and extracurricular activities. These many as 28 to 30 years after) indicates that
ical and behavioral interventions for RAP are episodes are characterized by vague abdomi- a smaller number, between 30% and 47%,
reviewed. Third, alternative treatment strate- nal pain that may be dull or crampy, and is will have complete resolution of their symp-
gies, including biofeedback therapy, are poorly localized or periumbilical, and per- toms (Apley, 1959; Chirstensen &
described. Finally, the integration of conven- sists for less than one hour (Frazer & Mortensen, 1975).
tional and alternative treatments for RAP is Rappaport, 1999). The pain frequently In the four decades since Apley’s seminal
discussed. presents with nausea, vomiting, and other research, etiological models of RAP have
signs of autonomic arousal (Apley, 1975). become increasingly complex. As we enter
Introduction The majority of children with RAP do not the 21st century, these models are multi-
Recurrent abdominal pain (RAP) is a pri- have a specific physical disorder or organic variate and acknowledge the contributions
marily functional disorder that affects 10- disease. Most investigators report that only of a variety of biological, psychological, and
17% of school-age children and accounts 5-10% of affected children have an organic social factors (e.g., Drossman, 2000;
for a large number of referrals to pediatric cause for their pain (Apley, 1975; Apley & Walker, 1999). For example, a child with
health care professionals (Feuerstein & Hale, 1958). abdominal pain but with no psychosocial
Dobkin, 1990). A growing body of litera- Studies of the prevalence of RAP have problems as well as good coping skills and
ture provides empirical support for conven- found disparate results, with rates ranging social support is predicted to have a better
tional medical and behavioral interventions from 9% to almost 25% (Apley & Naish, outcome than the child with pain as well as
for RAP. At the same time, interest in alter- 1958; Oster, 1972; Scharff, 1997; coexisting emotional difficulties, high life
native treatment strategies is expanding. Zuckerman, Stevenson, & Bailey, 1987). In stress, and limited support. The child’s clin-
The purpose of this article is to provide an general, population-based studies suggest ical outcome (e.g., daily function and quali-
empirically-informed but clinically oriented that RAP is experienced by 10-15% of ty of life) is predicted, in turn, to affect the
overview of conventional and alternative school-age children (Apley, 1975; Apley & severity of the disorder.
treatments for RAP. The literature reviewed Naish, 1958) and almost 20% of middle
for this article was identified by means of school and high school students (Hyams et
Conventional Medical
both computer (e.g., Medline, PsychInfo, al., 1996). As children grow older, the inci- and Behavioral
MANTIS) and manual methods.
The term recurrent abdominal pain (RAP)
dence of RAP appears to decrease in boys Treatments
but not girls (Stickler & Murphy, 1979; Conventional interventions for RAP
has been used and defined in various ways Apley & Naish, 1958).
over time. Almost every paper or presenta- include reassurance and general advice,
Investigations of the prognosis for RAP symptom-based pharmacological therapies,
tion on RAP, however, begins with a refer- have yielded conflicting findings. Though
ence to Apley’s criteria (Apley, 1975; Apley and psychological/behavioral treatments.
many children with RAP have no longer Standard pediatric care typically consists of
& Hale, 1973; Apley & Naish, 1958).
Self-Regulation in the
Treatment of Nocturnal
Enuresis, Dysfunctional
Voiding, and Bladder Jennifer Lessin, MD Judson B. Reaney, MD
Instability
Jennifer Lessin, MD, and Judson B. Reaney, MD, Eden Prairie, Minnesota
Abstract: Urinary incontinence in child- Enuresis can occur at night (nocturnal dance rate in monozygotic twins and a 36%
hood is a troublesome and common problem enuresis or “bedwetting”) or during the day concordance rate in dizygotic twins.
that can take many forms. These include (diurnal enuresis). Primary nocturnal enure- Approximately 75% of children with noc-
nighttime or daytime wetting (nocturnal and sis, meaning the child has never attained turnal enuresis have a first degree relative
diurnal enuresis. Two causes of daytime wet- dryness for a substantial period of time, who has had the problem. If both parents
ting are dysfunctional voiding and bladder accounts for 90% of all nocturnal enuresis. have a history of enuresis, the child has a
instability. This article will discuss the differ- Secondary nocturnal enuresis occurs most 70% likelihood of having enuresis. For a
ent presentations of these problems in children, commonly at age five-eight years, after the review of nocturnal enuresis, etiologies and
consider etiologies and co-morbidities, and child has been dry for “an established peri- treatments, the reader is encouraged to read
present strategies for the evaluation and treat- od”, traditionally three months or more. the review of the literature by Uri S. Alon
ment of incontinence including the uses of self- Often but not always, there is a triggering (1995).
regulation training and urodynamic stressful event for secondary enuresis such Although there is a genetic predisposition
biofeedback. as the birth of a sibling, the death of a fami- to the development of nocturnal enuresis,
ly member, parental separation, sexual abuse many other factors come into play to cause
Introduction or a school transition or stress. However, enuresis, nocturnal or diurnal, for each
Control of urinary continence is a there may not be measurable psychologic individual child.
learned developmental skill that is attained stress differences between non-enuretic chil- These include:
in typically developing children by three dren and those children who do develop • The rate of neurological/develop-
years of age during the day and by six to secondary enuresis. This lends support to mental maturity
seven years of age during sleep with girls the hypothesis that a child’s genetic predis- • Psychosocial stress and family
typically achieving control earlier than boys. position leaves her vulnerable to losing con- dynamics
Control of urine is important to the child trol of urine at night in response to a • Constipation: The child reaches
as it carries with it a sense of mastery over stressful event or experience. functional bladder capacity sooner
bodily function, and fosters developing self- Estimates of the prevalence of nocturnal • Smaller bladder capacity: The child
esteem. Childhood urinary incontinence is enuresis are quite varied but fall into the reaches functional bladder capacity
one of the most common problems faced range of 10% to 15% at the age of five sooner
by youngsters and can also be a problem years, decreasing by approximately 15% per • Not producing expected diurnal
into the teen years. year, with the problem more prevalent in variation in ADH: Make larger
To qualify for a diagnosis of enuresis, a boys than girls. By the age of seven years amounts of dilute urine and so reach
child must have repeated voiding outside of the prevalence is approximately 7%. By the functional bladder capacity sooner
the toilet at least twice a week for a dura- age of eighteen years, nocturnal enuresis is • Degree of arousability from sleep
tion of at least three months. However, a rare in young women and is still a signifi- And less commonly:
child may also qualify for a diagnosis of cant issue for 1% of young men. We do • Urinary tract infections or urinary
enuresis if the problem causes significant know that there is a marked genetic, likely anomalies
emotional or functional distress with or polygenic, predisposition to the develop- • Diabetes mellitus
without qualification under the frequency ment of nocturnal enuresis but not diurnal • Sleep disorders, such as sleep apnea
and duration criteria. enuresis. Twin studies show a 68% concor-
Frazer, C. H., & Rappaport, L. A. (1999). Risser, A. L., & Mazur, L. J. (1993). Use of folk Stickler, G. B., & Murphy, D. B. (1979).
Recurrent pains. In M. D. Levine, W. B. Carey, & remedies in a Hispanic population. Archives of Recurrent abdominal pain. American Journal of
A. C. Crocker (Eds.), Developmental-behavioral Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine, 149, 978-981. Diseases in Childhood, 133, 486-489.
pediatrics (pp. 357-364). Philadelphia, PA: W. B. Sanders, M. R., Rebgetz, M., Morrison, M. M., Walker, L. S. (1999). The evolution of research
Saunders Company. Bor, W., Gordon, A., Dadds, M. R., & Shepherd, on recurrent abdominal pain: History, assumptions,
Humphreys, P. A., & Gevirtz, R. N. (2000). (1989). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of recurrent and a conceptual model. In P. J. McGrath & G. A.
Treatment of recurrent abdominal pain: nonspecific in children: An analysis of generaliza- Finley (Eds.), Chronic and recurrent pain in children
Components analysis of four treatment protocols. tion, and maintenance side effects. Journal of and adolescents (pp. 141-172). Seattle: International
Journal of Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition, Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 57, 294-300. Association for the Study of Pain.
31, 47-51. Sanders, M. R., Shepherd, R. W., Cleghorn, G., Wang, X. M. (1988). Electroimpulse acupunc-
Janicke, D. M., & Finney, J. W. (1999). & Woolford, H. (1994). The treatment of recurrent ture treatment of 110 cases of abdominal pain as a
Empirically supported treatments in pediatric psy- abdominal pain in children: A controlled compari- sequela of abdominal surgery. Journal of Traditional
chology: Recurrent abdominal pain. Journal of son of cognitive-behavioral family intervention and Chinese Medicine, 8, 269-270.
Pediatric Psychology, 24, 115-127. standard pediatric care. Journal of Consulting and Yanhua, S., & Sumei, Y. (2000). The treatment
Kline, R. M., Kline, J. J., Di Palma, J., & Clinical Psychology, 62, 306-314. of 86 cases of epigastric and abdominal pain by
Barbero, G. J. (2001). Enteric-coated, pH-depend- Sank, L. I., & Biglan, A. (1974). Operant treat- scalp acupuncture. Journal of Chinese Medicine, 62,
ent peppermint oil capsules for the treatment of ment of a case of recurrent abdominal pain in a 10- 27-29.
irritable bowel syndrome in children. Journal of year old boy. Behavior Therapy, 5, 677-681. Zuckerman, B., Stevenson, J., & Bailey, V.
Pediatrics, 138, 125-128. Scharff, L. (1997). Recurrent abdominal pain in (1986). Stomachaches and headaches in a commu-
Linton, S. J. (1986). A case study of the behav- children: A review of psychological factors and nity sample of preschool children. Pediatrics, 79,
ioural treatment of chronic stomach pain in a child. treatment. Clinical Psychology Review, 17, 145-166. 677-682.
Behaviour Change, 3, 70-73. Sokel, B., Devane, S., & Bentovim, A. (1991). i Electrocardiogram biofeedback is also
Oster, J. (1972). Recurrent abdominal pain, Getting better with honor: Individualized relax-
headache and limb pains in children and adoles- ation/self-hypnosis techniques for control of recalci-
commonly called heart rate variability
cents. Pediatrics, 50, 429-436. trant abdominal pain in children. Family Systems (HRV) biofeedback.
Medicine, 9, 83-91.
Integrating Biofeedback in
Community Mental Health
Settings: Experiences from
a Clinical Demonstration Kathleen Samilo, MA Lela Carlson, RN
Projecti
Kathleen Samilo, MA, Spring Lake Park, MN, and
Lela Carlson, RN, Spring Lake Park, MN
Abstract: Real life experiences in integrating In 2000, CCFR received a grant from the provision of peripheral biofeedback services
biofeedback and self-regulation skills training Bush Foundation to conduct a clinical at four different settings:
with traditional psychological and behavioral demonstration project utilizing biofeedback • CCFR main clinic.
strategies are important in creating new treat- as an adjunct therapy for the treatment of • Bell Center — a school-based, affiliated
ment paradigms. This article describes the children with serious emotional and behav- day treatment program which offers a
clinical experiences of a group of community ior problems. The grant provided funds for highly specialized setting for children
clinic-based and school-based therapists sug- training a number of the staff in the use of and adolescents with significant emo-
gesting that biofeedback training and related biofeedback and self-regulation skills train- tional and/or behavioral challenges.
techniques can facilitate emotional control ing for children with a wide variety of men- • Centennial Lakes Middle School and
and behavioral change in ways that tradition- tal health problems as well as paying for High School — specialized program
al “talk” therapies may not. This article initial equipment . A BCIA certified pedia- settings within each school for children
describes beneficial outcomes with the addition trician was hired as a consultant and pro- with emotional and behavioral disorders
of biofeedback as a therapeutic tool for a group vided on-site training and patient that has contracted with CCFR to pro-
of very challenging, complex children and ado- consultation for a period of 24 months at vide groups and support services for
lescents for whom “traditional” psychotherapy regular intervals. Targeted populations were youth in those programs.
doesn’t always connect. children and adolescents with anger man- The programs share 2 biofeedback hard-
Biofeedback has been a popular and suc- agement and impulse control difficulties, ware/software set-ups among the four sites
cessful addition for children and families at and mental health disorders such as general- (these include two Biointegrator systems –
the Central Center for Family Resources ized anxiety disorder, phobias, panic disor- one laptop and one desk-top, and also the
(CCFR), a sliding fee, non-profit commu- ders, obsessive compulsive disorder, “Freeze-Frame” heart rate variability system
nity mental health agency located in Spring intermittent explosive disorder, posttrau- (from HeartMath)—each site has the
Lake Park, a northern suburb of matic stress disorder, separation anxiety, equipment for 2+ days each week. These
Minneapolis, Minnesota. This article oppositional defiant disorder, depression, populations are highly at risk for conduct
describes the experience of integrating and attention deficit disorders. Co-morbid disordered behaviors and drug and alcohol
biofeedback and self-regulation training disorders in this clinical population includ- abuse. Often the children and/or their par-
with traditional behavioral and psychother- ed reactive attachment disorder, Asperger’s ents are interested in self regulation for vari-
apy techniques. Agency staff includes four Syndrome, Tourette’s disorder, bipolar dis- ous reasons – i.e. not wanting to take
child psychiatrists, one adult psychiatrist, order, fetal alcohol effects and learning dis- medications, wanting to reduce the need for
support staff and several part-time and full- abilities. These issues are long term and medications, or simply wanting to learn
time child psychology doctoral and master’s many of these clients are also seen for med- new skills to manage their symptoms
level clinicians at different school and clini- ication management by CCFR child psychi- and/or behaviors better.
cal sites. Clientele is quite diverse ethnically atry staff. Biofeedback has been used in this
and 51% of the families seen are low The youth we serve with biofeedback and demonstration program adjunctively with
income. The agency sees over 3,000 families other psychological services range in ages approximately 150 children and adoles-
annually. from six to seventeen. The grant allowed for cents. CCFR staff is finding peripheral
Integrating Biofeedback
in Community Mental
Health Settings
continued from Page 32
Book Available for
new dimension to their skill set. In addi-
tion, we are hopeful that adding neurofeed- Review
back to our array of peripheral biofeedback
Please contact Donald Moss at
modalities will aid us even further in the
dmoss@chartermi.net if you are inter-
treatment of at risk children.
ested in reviewing this book.
i Editors Note: Clinical experiences over Jason Mark Alster (2002). Being in con-
a number of years has suggested that trol: Natural techniques for increasing
biofeedback and related techniques can your potential and creativity for success
open up and facilitate psychotherapeutic in school (2nd edition).. Zichron Yacov,
and behavioral shaping processes in ways Israel: Rainbow Publishers. [With appli-
that traditional “talk” therapies may not. cations to ADHD and LD].
This article describes beneficial outcomes
with the addition of biofeedback as a thera-
peutic tool for a group of very challenging,
complex children and adolescents for whom
“traditional” psychotherapy doesn’t always
completely connect.
–T.C.
Coming in 2002! HEG option; Take home disk; Auto threshold adjustment; and more...
Ten Keynotes and invited speakers bring the latest research and clinical information to you. Come and hear:
Herta Flor PhD, James Gordon MD, David Shapiro PhD, Richard Gevirtz PhD, Adam Clarke PhD, Peter Kaufman PhD, Sharon Lewis RN PhD,
Susan Middaugh PhD, Jeannette Tries OT/MS, Yuji Sasaki MD, PhD
aapb News
& Events
Influences from the Great Traditions of
Applied Psychophysiology:
See This Year’s AAPB Program
Paul Lehrer, President, AAPB
This is my final suite of rooms at the old Commodore misinterpreted as overly detailed and too
chance to address Hotel, and go from room to room giving time-consuming, supposedly (as described
the society as your instruction. He was a crusty old fellow. in his book) taking 20 sessions or more. In
president. Primarily, When talking to me about the empirical fact, it was not the length of his training,
I want to convey my evidence for progressive relaxation, he once but the intensity of it that differentiates it
thanks to you for noted that I had missed reading one of his from most practitioners of “progressive
giving me this more obscure articles. “Oh, you don’t read, relaxation” methods currently in vogue. In
honor. No profes- do you,” he said (a little too matter-of-fact- an obscure but useful volume, Modern treat-
sional recognition ly). However his diagnostic and treatment ment of tense patients, (published by Charles
could be more abilities still surpassed those of many of his C. Thomas), he presented cases patients
important to me. My identification with medical colleagues. He easily diagnosed successfully treated in a single session.
our field has been very long and very deep. cases of what we now called irritable bowel Jacobson approached his relaxation tech-
It is my primary affiliation, among the syndrome (not a well-conceived diagnostic nique the way most biofeedback practition-
dozen or more professional societies to category in the early 1970’s), simply by lis- ers treat biofeedback. He was not just
whom I contribute dues. tening to his patients and palpating the concerned that his patients feel relaxed, but
I have had an interest in the training of abdomen - cases that were mostly being that they be relaxed. Despite his own
self-regulatory processes since childhood, (ineffectively) treated by various rudimenta- description of the method as asking patients
when I observed my parents work as music ry tranquilizing and antispasmodic medica- to tighten their muscles maximally in order
teachers with budding pianists, helping tions, some with considerable side effects. to feel muscle sensations, this was not the
them to avoid and recover from what we Indeed I still recommend that people read focus of his teaching. Rather, he advocated
now think of as “repetitive motion disor- his classic 1938 book, Progressive Relaxation. a “method of diminishing tensions,” where-
ders” due, in large part, to poor instrumen- Nowhere have I seen better-documented by people become progressively aware of
tal technique. From these early days, I evidence for the effectiveness of relaxation smaller amounts of muscle tension. In the
noticed books on relaxation by Edmund techniques for this troublesome chronic end, he taught patients to recognize the
Jacobson on the bookshelves. (See some of malady. He had profound distrust for the very subtle sensations of “residual” tension,
the fruits of this interest represented in fun suggestion of body sensations, as poor sub- that were present even when the patient was
and music at our social evening at this year’s stitutes for actual control of physiology. His not deliberately tensing, and seemed to be
annual AAPB meeting.) battles with originators of hypnotic meth- mostly relaxed - and to neutralize even this
It wasn’t until after graduate school that I ods, particularly autogenic training, remain minute level of residual tension by becom-
had a chance to work myself with this great some of the most colorful stories in our ing totally passive. Doing, he said, was the
doctor, who, at the age of 86, still commut- field. opposite of relaxing. The cornerstone of his
ed monthly between Chicago and New The particular method he used for con-
York to treat patients. He used to rent a ducting relaxation training has often been continued on Page 3A
This week another new physician showed thing about biofeedback. When I asked her Patients who suffer unexpected or unde-
up at the Austin Biofeedback what she thought it might be, she asked, “Is sirable side effects from medication(s);
Center/Optimal Performance Institute to it something like hypnosis?” “Sometimes,” I Patients who would like to learn psy-
spend the afternoon learning about biofeed- replied. “It depends on what the patient or chophysiological self-regulation to address
back. The University of Texas Medical client is coming in for.” She looked puzzled. the root cause of their symptoms rather
School sends new residents in Austin I explained to her that at our center we than just treating the symptoms.
through my center as part of their orienta- refer to people referred by physicians, den- I told her that she would see people com-
tion to complementary medicine. The new tists, and chiropractors as “patients” and to ing into our center for everything from
doctors sit in on our sessions with a variety everyone else who comes in as “clients.” chronic or intractable “medical” presenta-
of patients/clients and then have the experi- Replying to the doctor’s question about tions like pain, hypertension, bladder/bowel
ence of being hooked up and trained with when in the process it would be appropriate symptoms, insomnia, headaches, cancer,
peripheral and EEG biofeedback. I have to refer a patient to biofeedback, I suggest- and TMJ; to “mental health” presentations
been “selling” biofeedback to doctors in ed the following guidelines: like anxiety, PTSD, panic disorder, depres-
Austin for almost 20 years, and I am excited Patients asking for alternatives other than sion, OCD, and ADHD; to “optimal per-
that new physicians are now routinely com- medication for their symptom(s); formance” training for artists, musicians,
ing through the center as part of their com- Patients who are not getting the expected
plementary medicine rotation. outcome from medication or other treat-
continued on Page 7A
As is often the case, this new physician ments;
admitted outright that she didn’t know any-
method was differential relaxation: i.e., of his Foundation for Progressive Relaxation who, he said, suppressed students’ data that
relaxing muscles in everyday life, when not - to do roughly what our shirt-pocket sized didn’t agree with his theories. He also stud-
needed to perform a particular activity. devices do now. Although he tried SEMG ied at Cornell with E.B. Titchener, the great
Above all, Dr. Jacobson was an empiri- biofeedback in the 1940’s, he rejected it as a introspectionist. He quipped that Titchener
cist. Not satisfied with his clinical successes, treatment technique, because he did not was a wonderful tennis player, but “he
he was determined to measure low levels of want patients to depend on a machine for couldn’t introspect.” Jacobson’s own intro-
muscle tension empirically. In the 19920’s feedback. He wanted the feedback to come spective work started when he was a college
and 30’s this was not yet possible, so he directly from the muscles. student, where he wrote a philosophy paper
worked alongside scientists from and engi- Jacobson had no patience for the arm- on the nature of thought, and noted the
neers from Bell Laboratories to invent the chair philosophizing currently in vogue various body sensations that were part of
“integrating neurovoltmeter,” what we now among some of his Harvard professors, par- the thinking experience. In his last book,
know as the surface EMG recorder. He was ticularly William James, whom he consid- The Human Mind (also published by
concerned that the device was capable of ered to be an anti-empiricist, and plagued Charles C. Thomas), written at age 94, he
recording to an accuracy of one microvolt by his own psychosomatic tensions. He again speculated whether an intelligent
peak-to-peak - a level somewhat below the claims that James dismissed his own work creature with oozing tentacles could possi-
noise level of most SEMG equipment cur- out of hand, by saying “What does this tell bly have the same type of thought that we
rently on the market. His device filled up a us about human nature?” He had similarly
fairly large room in the loft-like laboratories harsh words about Hugo Munsterberg, continued on Page 6A
actors, writers, business professionals, stu- word out to professionals as well as the
dents, and sports. I explained how biofeed- public. We have had two teleconferences to
back was truly mind-body medicine that date and will have another before our
empowered patients and enhanced their AAPB Annual Meeting in Jacksonville. We
internal locus of control. are very excited about ideas generated to
Her next question was, “Can biofeedback date. I promise to keep you informed as we
really help all these things?” I told her progress.
that it was our experience that it could, We are also mobilizing our Membership
especially if we combined the appropriate Committee to attract new members with
biofeedback modalities and tailored a treat- additional membership perks and programs.
ment/training program specifically for the And we are actively renewing our connec-
presentation in question. She seemed more tions with State and Regional Biofeedback
and more interested as I explained how Societies for mutual collaboration to fur-
biofeedback worked and how we had many ther the field. We are asking each state and
physicians who referred patients to us for a regional biofeedback society to send a dele-
variety of problems. I told her that AAPB gate to the Council of Chapters meeting at
was putting the finishing touches on an our AAPB Annual Meeting.
Efficacy Book on the various symptoms, Our Insurance Committee is working
conditions, and presentations for which we hard to put together more information
use biofeedback modalities. regarding insurance issues and questions
By the end of her visit, she said, “This is requested from our members. One of the
amazing stuff. Why haven’t I heard more questions I am always asked by both doc-
about it before now? What kinds of things tors and patients alike is, “What insurance
coming through my primary care practice companies cover biofeedback and for what
would I send to biofeedback?” It was then diagnoses?”
that I realized that if we all had more We are looking closely at specific ways
opportunities to disseminate this type of that AAPB can be more involved in legisla-
information to doctors all across the United tive and advocacy roles. Each and every one
States and abroad, then we could more like- of these efforts is part of a choreographed
ly reach one of the goals I identified in my effort to “sell” biofeedback – to educate and
vision for AAPB: We must implement strate- deliver our services to a public that is hungry
gies to educate and deliver our services to a for self-regulation.
public that is hungry for self-regulation. Remember that our AAPB family is
Getting doctors and other healthcare pro- a volunteer organization. Volunteer
fessionals to refer is a key part of this goal. organizations need lots of volunteers to
But doctors aren’t going to refer patients to help us pull this off. So please be ready
us if they don’t know what biofeedback is, with your ideas, your time, and your
or how we can deliver our services, or what talent. Getting the word out about biofeed-
patients are appropriate to refer. In a word, back is a lot like voting – if we don’t vote,
we must “sell” biofeedback better than we we can’t really complain. Email me at
have in the past. lkirk@austinbiofeedback.com with your ideas
Selling or marketing biofeedback is some- and suggestions for service to this wonder-
thing that each of us individually and as an ful organization!
AAPB family must do better. Toward that
end, AAPB has formed a new Marketing
Task Force whose primary goal is to get the