Sie sind auf Seite 1von 6

Railway Infrastructure Monitoring by Drones

Francesco Flammini1, Concetta Pragliola1, Giovanni Smarra1


1
Ansaldo STS
Via Argine 425, Naples, Italy
{francesco.flammini, concetta.pragliola, giovanni.smarra.ext}@ansaldo-sts.com

commissioning is no longer required), as well as low


Abstract-In recent years, there has been an increasing interest in maintenance and instrumentation costs. Due to some current
the adoption of drones for monitoring a variety of drone limitations (e.g. flying autonomy, payload weight),
infrastructures. Infrastructure monitoring systems are widely developing real sensing applications is not yet an easy task.
adopted to detect faults before they can lead to severe failures.
They can be found in a number of civil structures, including However, due to the middleware platforms that are already
bridges and viaducts, and also in many other applications of available for WSN, the software integration of sensed data
smart-maintenance, prognostics, health and security monitoring. should not be an issue [20].
This paper explores the usage of drones in railways for early The aim of this study is to leverage on the already available
warning, situation assessment and decision support applications. research results, frameworks and tools for drone-based
It leverages already available technological and research
achievements for drone-based surveillance. The aim of the study monitoring and control with the aim of frequently and
is to preliminarily evaluate drone capabilities in a railway automatically checking railway infrastructure parameters to
monitoring framework including structural faults and security provide an early warning system to detect faults and security
threat detection as well as investigation on the consequences of threats, including natural hazards and intentional attacks. The
natural hazards and intentional attacks. idea is to use wireless interconnected Drones and their
Keywords-Situation assessment, physical security, structural sensing payloads to communicate events to remote control
health, diagnostics, maintenance, mass-transit centers using mobile terminals (GSM-R/GPRS and others).
In the past years, we have developed frameworks allowing
for the integration of heterogeneous sensor networks and the
INTRODUCTION
detection of events [22]. The integration of those technologies
In recent years, the global drones market has had a with drones potential addresses the growing interest in
meaningful growth and it is expected to have a worth of $91 intelligent maintenance strategies, as also underlined by the
billion over the next decade [23]. This means that there has recent calls of the European Shift2Rail Joint Undertaking
been an increasing trust to adopt this technology within [25]. In fact, integrated and remotely controlled smart-drones
several contexts [17] and also an emerging interest to can become very attractive for infrastructure managers and
research new areas of applications. For example, Drones are other customers due to their cost-effectiveness, easy
employed within a variety of infrastructure systems, e.g. in installation and maintenance. All these factors contribute to
Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) applications, in which keep low the time-to-market as well as the acquisition and
reliable data concerning the integrity of structures are operational costs for the end users. Furthermore, drones can
collected in order to evaluate repair or retirement needs. be used where there is no power source or wired
Furthermore, modern railway security systems used in telecommunication facilities (which is rather frequent on
infrastructure protection applications include a set of different railway lines), since the system can be powered by batteries
sensing technologies integrated by appropriate management and/or solar cells and it exploits wireless transmission for
systems. Such systems are still highly dependent from human both drone-to-drone and drone-to-control center
operators for supervision and intervention. One of the communications.
challenging goals of the research community in this field is
the automatic detection of both natural and malicious threats BACKGROUND
scenarios.
This paper presents a preliminary study about a drone- The main elements of an Unmanned Aircraft System are:
based railway monitoring system. Since wireless sensor the aircraft (UA), the control station (CS) and the
network technologies have begun to be considered as communication link. There are several ways to classify the
substitutes of traditional tethered monitoring systems in UAVs with reference to the main parameters: maximum take-
structural engineering and critical infrastructure surveillance off weight (MTOW), operating conditions (altitude and
fields [4][12][6], drones perfectly fit in such a context adding range), autonomy and size [17]. In many civil applications,
the unique feature of sensor/camera mobility. Drones enable especially for professional purposes, there is an interest for
detailed monitoring of large physical structures with few units vertical take-off UAVs (VTOL, vertical take-off and
and promise ease and flexibility of deployment (extensive

978-1-5090-0814-8/16/$31.00 2016 IEEE


Figure 1 - Reference drone-based railway surveillance architecture

landing), rotor-wing, with MTOW less than 25 kg. They are The Payload is the load added to the frame. It is upper-
commonly denoted like small drones[7]. bounded by the MTOW and its value is determined by
The basic architecture of a small drone consists of: frame, subtracting the weight of all the fixed elements (such as
brushless motors, electronics speed control (ESC), flight frame, motor, battery, etc.) to the MTOW. Typical payload
control board, Inertial Navigation System (INS), power values range from 0.5 kg for the most commercial drones and
source, gimbal, payload, landing gear [17]. The frame is the 2.5kg for professional ones. In general, landing gear is used
load-bearing structure designed to be strong and lightweight to protect the drone during landing phase and to balance the
and the most used for professional drones is the carbon fiber load of the aircrafts fuselage. In fact, the vertical load due to
frame for its physical strength, specific toughness, light the weight is distributed along the landing gear structure.
weight. Some frame configurations are reported in [16]. There are many applications in which drone-based sensor
The brushless motors provide the mechanical energy networks can improve human abilities of perception and
necessary to the propellers rotation [17]. The ESC controls control. Relevant examples are automation, industrial and
the propellers angular velocity of the drone. It is driven by a commercial building monitoring for safety and security, etc
Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) signal. In fact, by varying In particular, as for railway line security monitoring, though
the duty cycle value, it is possible to increase and to reduce considered a need by the operators, that is rarely performed in
the propeller rotation. In this way, the drone performs yaw, railway systems due to the length of the lines and the
roll, pitch and throttle movements and shifts along the difficulties in providing lineside power supplies and
longitudinal and lateral axis. The flight control board telecommunication facilities in an affordable way
represents the intelligence of a drone since it manages the Presently, conventional methods for railway infrastructure
commands received from the CS transforming them into surveillance employ analogic or IP cameras, wired intrusion
actions towards the sensors or others controller on board. The detection and other structural monitoring sensors (i.e.
INS consists of 3-axial accelerometer, 3-axial gyroscope and piezoelectric accelerometers). While fixed wired sensors
3-axial magnetometer for measuring accelerations, angular provide a very reliable source of information, they are time
rates and magnetic values respectively. Acquiring the consuming to install and quite expensive to operate and
measurements provided by the INS, it is possible to evaluate maintain. Each installed sensor/camera can cost thousands of
the 3-axis Euler angle measurements. These angles then are Euros and that makes extensive surveillance unfeasible when
used for the aircraft orientation control during the flight. there is the need to cover very large geographical areas, as in
Since drone orientation measurements are affected by noise, the case of railways. Therefore, in recent years many research
specific algorithms for a good estimation are used [17]. Most efforts have been devoted to the development of new
drones are powered with Lithium-polymer batteries (Li-Po) technology sensors, including Wi-Fi cameras, WSN smart-
which guarantee better performance in terms of lightweight, sensors (also known as motes or smart-dust) and Optical
safety and flexible form factor. The gimbal is the structure Fiber Bragg Grating (OFBG) [22][21].
which holds the camera on board. It is based on the same In Table 1 we show a comparison between fixed sensor
concept of the gyroscope since it decouples the axis of a networks (both traditional and WSN) and drone-based sensor
camera from the movement of the aircraft. Moreover it is networks.
made up of brushless motors to adjust the position of the
camera in all directions: up/down, left/right,
forward/backward [27].
DRONE-BASED RAILWAY INFRASTRUCTURE MONITORING
TABLE I The aim of drone-based railway surveillance is to perform
COMPARISON BETWEEN SENSOR NETWORKS AND DRONES-BASED SENSORS
an extensive monitoring of (a part of) a railway infrastructure
Fixed Sensor Drone-based Sensor system against common threats (see Figure 1 - Reference
Characteristics
Networks Networks
drone-based railway surveillance architecture). In railway
sensing unit fixed variable environments, drones are suitable for three main applications:
installation capability limited unlimited
sensors number few to many very few
sensor distribution sparse to dense semi-continuous 1. Structural monitoring, especially for critical assets
node maintainability low to average very high
node redundancy low to high very high
like bridges and tunnels, for fault detection (i.e.
diagnostics/prognostics).
sensing capability nearly full limited 2. Environmental security monitoring, that is fire,
sensing compatibility nearly full limited
node accuracy low to high low explosions, earthquakes, floods and landslides
node reliability low to high low to average detection along the track.
node cost low to high high
3. Physical security monitoring, that is detection of
transmitted data raw or processed raw or processed intrusions, objects stolen or moved, graffiti, etc.
transmission accuracy low to high low to high
transmission reliability low to high low to high 4. Safety monitoring, e.g. to early detect failures on
transmission range low to high low to high track elements/devices or obstacles on the track.
transmission BW low to high low to high
network topology fixed or changing fixed or changing
5. Situation assessment and emergency/crisis
management, that is to monitor accident scenarios
and coordinate the intervention of first responders.
As mentioned above, conventional monitoring systems 6. Forensics, to investigate about the causes of
consisting of a large amount of sensors are either high-priced accidents and safely detect the presence of
or made-up of cheap sensors (WSN). On that regards, drone- dangerous substances in case of CBRN (Chemical
based monitoring has the potential of adopting more Biological Radiological Nuclear) terrorist attacks.
reliable/expensive sensors without the need for buying and
installing a large amount of them. Hence, drone-based Drone payload can integrate sensors of different nature to
surveillance can be the perfect trade-off between traditional provide diverse functionalities, depending on energy
sensing and WSN smart-motes in all those applications where consumption and maximum allowed weight (e.g. temperature
suitable sensors are available. The basic principle lies in a sensors, intelligent cameras, etc.). For instance, self-powered
multi-drone architecture that is able to collect data locally on chemical sensors could be mounted on-board to provide quick
a specific point of the infrastructure and send relevant data and safe analyses of incident field earth samples. Another
(measures environmental parameters, events, alarms) to possible application is the graffiti detection on perimeter
remote control centers for online and/or offline analysis. walls or trains stored in depots, as introduced by the railway
Figure 1 shows a possible overall hardware architecture of company Deutsche Bahn by equipping drones with infrared
drone-based surveillance. Fixed distributed smart-sensors are cameras to individuate people during the night responsible of
installed along the railway line both in fixed (e.g. bridges, these acts [9]. Regardless of the specific application and
tunnels, stations, etc.) and mobile (passenger trains, freight payload, both the hardware and the middleware can be reused
cars, etc.) locations [4]. They are integrated locally using to fit new monitoring applications.
local wireless infrastructures (e.g. Wi-Fi, ZigBee, etc.) and
then data is collected by WSN gateway nodes to be
Track assets and depot monitoring
transmitted remotely by means of WAN (Wide Area
Network) infrastructures, like the 2G,3G cellular networks,
A further drones limitation, in addition to weather
satellite links, or Fiber Optics geographic networks along the
conditions and payload weight, is the remote control range
line. With the availability of large bandwidth (in the Gb/s
via Wi-Fi or in general through a radio link provided by a
range) provided for example by fiber optics link, it is possible
hand-held radio transmitter and a receiver module on-board.
to transmit high-resolution videos at very high frame-rates
However, these ones are much easier to overcome in railway
(e.g. 25 FPS) for a superior situational awareness at the
applications.
control rooms. In case of drones, those links could be In fact, it can be assumed that railway systems [2] are
leveraged by fixed drone stations to quickly download large always equipped with wireless MAN (Metropolitan Area
amount of on-board recorded data Network) or WAN (Wide Area Networks), based on Wi-Fi,
GSM-R GPRS or any other commercial infrastructure like
UMTS and LTE. Low bandwidth networks like GPRS are
strictly required to control drones and transmit alarms to the
control center; if high-quality video streams from cameras
need to be shown to the operators in order to verify the alarm
and/or supervise the situation, higher bandwidth is required could be appropriate to detect changes in scenes (e.g.
that can be provided by Wi-Fi or UMTS/LTE. obstacles, stolen objects, damages, etc.) in reasonably fixed,
In order to achieve extensive coverage in railway automatic and periodic patrolling routes, without even
applications, let us refer to the following specification and running motion tracking software [24]. Such an analysis can
implications associated to one of the most widespread be also performed off-line on more powerful computers, after
professional drone, DJI Phantom 4 [19]: the drone on-board recorded video has been downloaded on
drone smart-parking stations, like the Dronebox [1]. Such a
Max Speed 20 m/s = 72 km/h VCA (Video Content Analytics) change detection application
Approx. Max Flight Time = 30 = 0.5h is not much different from the one already developed for
Consequently, Max Distance = 36 km indoor applications like Empty Vehicle Detection [3].
On-board laser measurement units featuring precision of less
than 1cm could also be investigated to monitor structural
integrity of critical assets like catenary, electrical substations,
track lines, tunnels, rail bridges and viaducts.

Chemical Warfare Agent (CWA) detection

With reference to the typical payload values aforementioned,


the drones are able to carry several types of sensors. The
CBRN industry produces lightweight, portable and battery
powered detectors that were designed for military battlefield
applications but are nowadays commercially available for
civil applications. For instance, let us consider the following
Figure 2 - Railway line monitored by drones: a typical scenario Smith Detection LCD 3.3 CWA Detector relevant
Specifications [26] (see Figure 4 - Battery-powered, portable
and lightweight CWA detector).
The max distance covered at full speed is such to allow the
drone to land on wireless recharging pods [15], located Size: 10.54 x 17.93 x 4.65 cm
approximately on GSM-R Base Transceiver Station (BTS), Weight: 0.65 kg including batteries
since (see Figure 2 - Railway line monitored by drones: a Batteries: Alkaline/Lithium type 40/75 hours
typical scenario):
An object of this kind does not need any electrical
GSM-R inter-BTS distance = 6-17 km connection, due to being self-powered. The sensor could be
freely picked up and released among larger toolsets to be
Train depot perimeter fence (see Figure 3 - Example railway possibly added automatically to drone payloads (e.g. using
depot layout.) is also in the same range, depending on the mechanically operated systems like pliers or electrically
specific depot size; however, depot coverage is less operated system like electro-magnets). Therefore, the main
challenging than full line, since power supply and telecom effort would be to integrate this sensor with drone hardware
points are much easier to reach and therefore a radius-based to implement advanced functions. In fact, it would be useful
rather than longitudinal flying time evaluation can be to read data measured by the instrument in real time instead
performed. of waiting that the drone comes back to the landing pad. This
Therefore, the research challenge is to design fast sensing could imply for example the customization of the most
applications including video content analytics and motion common linux-based board equipped with analog-digital I/O
tracking algorithms that are able to work reliably on (quickly) and with low-cost commercially available wireless
moving and possibly vibrating cameras. Robust algorithms communication modules based on the modern technology like
for simple recorded video footage frame-to-frame comparison Bluetooth (IEEE 802.15.1), NFC, RFID. We have explored in
previous works the motivation and possibilities of real-time
CBRNE detection in rail-based infrastructures [8]. In case of
drones, since the extensive coverage requirement for real-
time detection would not be fulfilled, and due to the attractive
possibility of free movement, a much more promising
application is related to the aforementioned post-incident
assessment. In such a scenario, the nearest drone would be
equipped with the appropriate on-board sensor from the drone
station and remotely operated to land in specific points of the
Figure 3 - Example railway depot layout.
disaster area in order to analyze the substances spread on the retrieval processes hard tasks to achieve. Such a scenario is
field and possibly pickup samples for further laboratory quite realistic in the context of railway infrastructures where
analysis. If a CBRNE contamination is detected, then first different kind of sensor systems are adopted for security and
responders will be advised to wear appropriate protections to diagnostic purposes (e.g. temperature sensors, CBRN sensors,
reduce the risk of intoxication. intelligent cameras, etc.).
After smart-sensor information is integrated in a cohesive
and easily to access repository, then a reasoning about
detected events could be automatically performed (decision
fusion) either on-the-fly or offline. In order to achieve that
objective, the DETECT framework could be employed [5].
The basic assumption behind the DETECT framework is
that threats can be detected by predicting the set of basic
Figure 4 - Battery-powered, portable and lightweight CWA detector events (i.e. the patterns) which constitute their signature.
Threat scenarios must be precisely identified during
Vulnerability Assessment and Risk Analysis. DETECT
operates by performing a model-based logical, spatial and
Multi-drone/sensor information fusion
temporal correlation of basic events detected by different
sensor subsystems, in order to recognize sequence of events
Like for other networked sensors, drone sensors would
which indicate the likelihood of threats. DETECT is based on
benefit from appropriate integration platforms for
a real-time detection engine which implements the concept of
heterogeneous sensor systems allowing for multi-sensor
cognitive reasoning by means of soft computing approaches.
information fusion. Those integration platforms are not just
The framework can be interfaced with or integrated in
middleware for sensor networks, but software architectures
existing Physical Security Information Management (PSIM)
enabling the deployment of applications based on multiple
systems. It can serve to generate warnings or even to
diverse drones/sensors, allowing applications to easily access
automatically trigger appropriate responses for emergency
data sensed by a network [12]. Drone sensors plus fixed
management. The correlation among events detected by both
sensors information fusion would allow increasing the
drone-based and fixed sensors could further contribute to
dependability and trustworthiness of measures data or
lower the number of false alarms, thus improving the overall
detected events. It would also allow the design and automated
PSIM reliability [8].
detection of more complex threat scenarios based on multiple
Threats are described in DETECT using a specific Event
drones/sensors [5].
Description Language (EDL) and stored in a Scenario
Furthermore, the synergy of WSN and drone technologies
Repository. Starting from the Scenario Repository, one or
can be leveraged in scenarios in which clusters of light WSN
more detection models are automatically generated using a
motes (weighting few hundreds grams at most) are loaded on
suitable formalism (e.g. Event Graphs, Bayesian Networks,
drones and spread on appropriate areas by precise positioning
Neural Networks, etc.). In the operational phase, a model
or air launched in case of parachute-equipped motes [18].
manager macro-module has the responsibility of performing
Drone can then host (or serve as) master-nodes or mobile
queries on the Event History database for the real-time
gateways to collect WSN sensed data [11]. In such a context
feeding of detection model according to predetermined
where there is also the possibility of an on-air
policies. When a composite event is recognized, the output of
communications among drones creating a sort of Net-Drones
DETECT consists of: the identifier(s) of the
[14], there are several studies to optimize handover problems
detected/suspected scenario(s); an alarm level, associated to
and new algorithms have been developed to better manage
scenario evolution (used as a progress indicator); a likelihood
the coverage problems avoiding numerous energy-consuming
of threat, expressed in terms of probability (used as a
handover attempts. After some time, motes whose battery is
threshold in heuristic detection).
exhausted could be automatically picked up by drones to
In case of drone-sensor decision fusion, it is essential to
bring them to maintenance facilities.
complete the description of primitive events with further
For sensor network information fusion, the SeNsIM
information like sensor position and orientation in 3D-space
platform could be employed [6]. It provides a unique
(for fixed sensors, the positioning information is obviously
interface for local networks that allow a generic user to
embedded in sensor-id) and possibly event detection
express queries by means of an intuitive query visual
trustworthiness index, given by dynamic environmental
language. It was conceived with the aim to bridge the gap
parameters possibly impacting sensor reliability, like
between heterogeneous sensor systems and to provide a
temperature, vibration, presence of smog/fog/rain, etc. The
generic user/application with a unique way to manage, query
latter information is already supported by the latest
and interact with them. The major issue of an integrating
framework developments.
system lies in the heterogeneity of the hardware to sense data
and of the repositories, these make data management and
CONCLUSIONS [7] F. Flammini, C. Pragliola, G. Smarra, R. Naddei, Towards
Automated Drone Surveillance in Railways: State-of-the-Art and
In this paper, emerging applications of drones in the Future Directions, submitted to ACIVS (Advanced Concepts for
railway domain have been investigated. Even considering the Intelligent Vision Systems) 2016 conference.
[8] F.Flammini, N.Mazzocca, A. Pappalardo, C. Pragliola, V. Vittorini,
constraints of legacy requirements used to guarantee railway Augmenting Surveillance System Capabilities by Exploiting Event
safety and security, drones could represent a promising Correlation and Distributed Attack Detection, chapter from book
technology to efficiently monitor railway and mass transit Availability, Reliability and Security for Business, Enterprise and
Health Information Systems , A Min Tjoa, Gerald Quirchmayr, Ilsun
infrastructures. It has been shown that drone research and You, Lida Xu, Springer.
technology advancement are increasingly providing new [9] Future of Rail 2050. Arup, pp 45, 2015.
means supporting the integration of hardware and software [10] G.M. Shafiullah, A. Gyasi-Agyei, P. Wolfs, Survey of Wireless
Communications Applications in the Railway Industry, in Proc. 2nd
features, including synergies with WSN. In fact, drone-based International Conference on Wireless Broadband and Ultra Wideband
sensors can be advantageously integrated in existing security Communications (AusWireless 2007), Sydney, Australia, August,
2007.
surveillance systems by appropriate sensor integration [11] I. Deaconu and A. Voinescu, "Mobile gateway for Wireless Sensor
platforms, middleware and frameworks like the mentioned Networks utilizing drones," in Proc. RoEduNet Conference 13th
SeNsIM and DETECT frameworks [4]. In such a context, it is Edition: Networking in Education and Research Joint Event RENAM
8th Conference, Chisinau, pp. 1-5, 2014
worth continuing to investigate drone-based monitoring [12] J.P. Lynch, K.J. Loh, A Summary Review of Wireless Sensors and
especially from the viewpoint of the definition of a reference Sensor Networks for Structural Health Monitoring, in The Shock and
WSN-drone architecture and flexible standard interfaces Vibration Digest, pp. 38-91, 2006
[13] K. Dalamagkidis, Handbook of Unmanned Aerial Vehicle,
(NFC, Bluetooth, etc.) to seamlessly recognized and integrate Valavanis K.P., Vachtsevan G.J. Springer, pp. 44, 2015.
new payloads (devices, sensors). In the meantime, the [14] Kyung-Nam Park, Byeong-Moon Cho ; Kyung-Joon
presence of built-in PTZ on-board cameras allows to easily Park ; Hwangnam Kim, Optimal coverage control for net-drone
handover, pp 97 99, 2015.
experiment functional scenarios, e.g. providing a rough (i.e. [15] L. Angrisani, G. d'Alessandro, M. D'Arco, V. Paciello and A.
visual) integration of existing portable detector displays for Pietrosanto, "Autonomous recharge of drones through an induction
preliminary testing purposes. based power transfer system," in Proc. Measurements & Networking
(M&N), IEEE International Workshop on, Coimbra, pp. 1-6, 2015
With the ongoing enhancement of drones endurance and [16] "Multi-Rotor Frame Configurations", Coptercraft, 2016. [Online].
allowed payloads, the challenge will be to increase the level Available: http://www.coptercraft.com/multirotor-frame-
of automation (with the help of VCA [7]) to reduce the need configurations/. [Accessed: 18- Sep- 2016].
[17] P. Daponte, L. De Vito, G. Mazzilli, F. Picariello, S. Rapuano and M.
for human interventions, even in critical situations. In other Riccio, "Metrology for drone and drone for metrology: Measurement
words, the number of scenarios in which railway drones systems on small civilian drones," Metrology for Aerospace
would be useful will be proportional to the performance (MetroAeroSpace), 2015 IEEE, Benevento, 2015, pp. 306-311.
[18] P. Wei, Q. Gu and D. Sun, "Wireless sensor network data collection
growth of drones. Therefore, the research will move towards by connected cooperative UAVs," in Proc. American Control
a tighter integration with railway components, also following Conference, Washington, DC, pp. 5911-5916, 2013
the advancements in the fields of intelligent/smart- [19] "Phantom Series - Intelligent Drones - DJI", Dji.com, 2016. [Online].
Available: http://www.dji.com/products/phantom. [Accessed: 18- Sep-
maintenance and the IoT (Internet of Things) [25]. 2016].
[20] S. Hadim, N. Mohamed, Middleware for wireless sensor networks: A
survey, in Proc. 1st Int. Conf. Comm. System Software and
REFERENCES Middleware (Comsware06), New Delhi, India, Jan. 8-12, 2006.
[21] S. Kim, S. Pakzad, D. Culler, J. Demmel, G. Fenves, S. Glaser, M.
[1] "DRONEBOX | HUS UNMANNED SYSTEMS", DRONEBOX | HUS Turon, Wireless sensor networks for structural health monitoring, in
UNMANNED SYSTEMS, 2016. [Online]. Available: Proc. 4th international conference on Embedded networked sensor
http://www.hus.sg/. [Accessed: 18- Sep- 2016]. systems (SenSys 06), Boulder, CO, USA, 2006.
[2] "ERTMS | The European Railway Traffic Management [22] S. Li, Z. Wu, Development of Distributed Long-gage Fiber Optic
System", Ertms.net, 2016. [Online]. Available: http://www.ertms.net. Sensing System for Structural Health Monitoring, in Structural
[Accessed: 18- Sep- 2016]. Health Monitoring, Vol.6: 133-143, 2007.
[3] F. Buemi, M. Esposito, F. Flammini, N. Mazzocca, C. Pragliola, M. [23] S. Peasgood, M. Valentin, Drones: a rising market, an Industry to Lift
Spirito, Empty Vehicle Detection with Video Analytics, chapter your Returns, Sophic Capital,2015.
from book Image Analysis and Processing ICIAP 2013, A. [24] S. Qian, J. K. Tan, H. Kim, S. Ishikawa and T. Morie, "Obstacles
Petrosino, Springer, 2013. Extraction from a Video Taken by a Moving Camera", in Proc.
[4] F. Flammini, A. Gaglione, F. Ottello, A. Pappalardo, C. Pragliola, A. International Conference on Connected Vehicles and Expo (ICCVE),
Tedesco, Towards Wireless Sensor Networks for railway Beijing, pp. 268-273, 2012
infrastructure monitoring, in: Electrical Systems for Aircraft, Railway [25] Shift2Rail JU IP3 Website: http://shift2rail.org/research-
and Ship Propulsion (ESARS), p. 1-6, 2010. development/ip3/ [Accessed: 30may- 2016].
[5] F. Flammini, A. Gaglione, N. Mazzocca, C. Pragliola, DETECT: a [26] Smith Detection LCD 3.3 High Performance CWA Identifier And TIC
novel framework for the detection of attacks to critical infrastructure, Detector Website:
in Safety, Reliability and Risk Analysis: Theory, Methods and http://www.smithsdetection.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=ite
Applications - Martorell et al. (eds), Proc. ESREL08, pp.105-112, m&id=86&Itemid=600#.V0xpDDXRjmU [Accessed: 30may- 2016].
Valencia, Spain, September 22-25 2008, pp. 105-112 (CRC Press, [27] "Understanding Brushless Camera Gimbals - Drone Flyers", Drone
Taylor & Francis Group), London, 2008. Flyers, 2015. [Online]. Available:
[6] F. Flammini, A. Gaglione, N. Mazzocca, V. Moscato, C. Pragliola, http://www.droneflyers.com/2015/06/understanding-brushless-camera-
Wireless Sensor Data Fusion for Critical Infrastructure Security, in gimbals/. [Accessed: 18- Sep- 2016].
Proc. International Workshop on Computational Intelligence in
Security for Information Systems CISIS08 - Advances in Soft
Computing, pp. 92-99, 2008.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen