TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
Richard £, MeSLvain
General Manager & Vico President
Warman Zauipnent. (International) Inc,
Madison, Wisconsin
1. Cave
Senior Project Engineer
Warman Equipment (Internstional) Ltd,
Artarmon, N.S.W, fustratia
1. Zureomerton
Pumping of tailings is usually one of the major op
erations in any mineral treatment plant, Because
it ds often necessary to transnort tatlines over
considerable distances, the heads" required for punp= F
ine are often higher than for other operations ins
treatnont. plant,
Introduction of Legislation controlling environnent
and pollution often requiros tailings disposal areas
to be Located at considerable distances from the '
froatment plant. ich friction losses are encoun
tored ‘and tailing pumps to develop higher heads are
required,
One installation in the north of Jepan collectives
2y pumps tailings frori throo mines a distance of ule
miles to a disposal area in coastal sxanps. ‘i
164‘TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
Hodorn mining mathods hava allowed exploitation of
Large low grade mineral deposits, | munber of
plants throurhout the world are milling nore than
$0,000 tons per day. Most. of this waterial has to.
be handled as tailings.
The coarser the sizing of the tailings particles
tho hichor the velocity required for transvortation
and consequently the higher the head and the higher
the poxer requiresent, If it 4s possible to sepa-
rate the coarser fractions of the teilings and dis~
pose of these close to the plant, considerable sav=
ings ray bo made, (See Fig, 1 for various mothods
used.) The velocity required for the longer dis-
tance haul (of fine solids only) is reduced and cone
sequently Less power is required,
In association with underground mining operations,
At ds often possible to utilize the separated coarse
or fractions as underground fi11 material.
For very long pipelines where high pressures aré
required, positive displaconent pumps are employed
for shorter distances and lower pressures, centri-
fugel pumps are preferable:
&
For a punping syston, the flow rate, pipe size, com
centration (density) of solids, punp size and speed
should be capable of handling maxiaua requirenents
and at the sane tine provide econonically for aver~
age conditions,
2.2, . SONCENTRATTON
It ds usually preferred to punp solids at as higit
a concentration as possible, This Teluces water
usage (or return water pumping) and, within Limits),
reduces the size of pumps, pipelines and motors.TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
(A) In plant segregation
(1) Primary rejeets such as non-
magnetic cobber tailings.
(2) Screen rejects on barren
sized pieces.
3) Scavenger etreuits for
Process water and mineral
value return.
(®) Tattings and segregation systenis
(1) Spiral classifiers
(@) Cyclones
(3) Sereens
(4) Hydraulic sizing equipment
for process solution return p
(€) Thickeners for the entire plunt tail-
ings are currently used in most mineral
Process plants. Flocculating agents
are normally used. ‘The water circuit
is completely closed with the over flow
and tailings pond water recirculated. q
Methods of segregating tailing by particle size and q
water reclanation. Figure No. 1
2
Es
IAL K
»— eg
7 ie N=
: *
2
Ea
e
6
wo 06 10500 wo 700
OscHARGE Imp dpm
Wead depression as a function of concentration of
solids by weights {lmenite 0,17 millimeter.
184
Figure No. 10“TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
To dovelop a required head of slurry At is necessary
to run a puap at a higher speed than that which is
required to dovelop the sare head of water. then
Hm has been determined ER is then apslied to obtain
fia, Pomp speod for Hr may then be selected fron
pup water performance curve,
To calculate pump horsepower, the water efficiency
obtained from the curve must be modified ty BM to
obtain officlency on slurry.
4,5. HBAD sup pours cuncimatzos
‘The folloiing 4s an oxanple of the estimation of
pump speed and power consumed when pumping a slurry
mixture,
Duty; A punp de reautred to handle 1800 (200%
tons por hour of tailings having a specific cravity
S= 2,65, at a concentration C= 504 solids by
weight agcinst a total dynamic head Hix = 160 fost of
slurry, Average particle size of sélids d50 = 150
microns, (100 mesh) °
Solution:
(1) Weight of solids an slurry = 1800 TPH
(2) Weight of volune of uater equal t6
volune of solids 1800 «= 680 TPE
2.65
(3) Weight of water in slurry Ow of 50% = 1800 TPH
(4) Total weight of slurry add (L) and (33600 TPH
(5) Total’ weight of equal volume of water
add (2) and (3) = 280 TPH
= (6) quantity of starry 2180 x 200. = 992% PHS
60x
7 6, of Sm] .
See TO ‘yoo = 1s (sm)
185TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
(8) % solids by volune (Cv)
eivide (2) by (5) x 10
100 = 27,4
£20 6 108 = 27. & (Cv)
Velues for Sa (7) and Cy (8) can also bo read direct
fron Fig. 7 using $ of 2,65 and Cw of 50% solids by
weight.
(a) The head ratio (HR) and efficiency ratio (ER)
for this duty may be obtained fron Fig, 11
where s = 2,65 and 450 = 150 microns, (100 mesh),
the derating factor iss
k= 0,075
Using the equation in Fig. 111
R= R= 1- kx
a
1 = 0.075'x 27.
0,90
(b) Total head in fect of mixture Hin = 160 fect
(elven)
Required Head on Water (Hw):
Hin . 160, = 178 feot of water
i 0.95
Fron the aman Series ‘Mt punp selection chart,
Fig. 12, a Verman 16/1 HA pimp has been
selected for this particular duty, The per
fornance curves for the 5 vane closed inpeller
in this punp aro shown on Fig, 13 and wil be
used for determining pump speed and efficiency
as follows: y
(c) Referring to the 5 vane closed impeller per
formance curve Fig. 13, the speed at which the
186‘TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS.
Tos 70 9399333
1872 von aandzy
ony ? eAbau V S995 weuxey 203 axey> uoqa00Teg
1H Wwio
(50m susie ova
Cav 230 OV3H TWiOL
TAILING DISPOSAL TODAYTRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
WARMAN EQUIPMENT eons
Pune TAPELLER RA cenrmrvca
“pee [rmane [vere [omnes | wre [unre | om | tire ruauen ESV 580%,
Jena| HAH | 3 Ptoceoverac| a2 testa 70
A SITRTE FEREGR SNES TON CLEAR WATER [HHL TACRTC[cOaCUR | WoW FSET
= FoR 16/14GAM PUMP
p600
Performance curves for 5-vane closed impeller in
pump. Figure No. 13
Late 188TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
pump must operate to develop a head of 178 feet
of wator wher, handling 9925 US gallons of water
Por minute is 505 RP. Note that this is also
the speed required for the punp to develop a
head of 160 feot of mixture when handling 9925
gallons of slurry mixture,
(a) The punp efficiency (ew) corresponding to the
178 fect of water is 76% when pumping water.
(e) Tho efficiency (en) shen pusping the sand mize
ture is then given by:
oy xm
78x 0.90
686
(£) Pump Shaft Horsepower consumed
Qx Sn xn x10
“35,000 % en
9925" 1.45 x 160 x 8.33
33,000 x
= 855 HP
5S. MADEREALS oF consmaUCsToN
Sl. REQUIRE
This discussion is Limited to materials suitable for
resistance to wet abrasive wear as encountered with.
an slurry pumps, ani is mainly concerned with appli-
cation to centrifugal slurry pumps,
Materials to be suitable must M1fil1 the following
requirenentss
(2) Provide an economical cost wear performance,
(44) Bo suited to forming to the required shapes and
tolerances,
G11) Have the, necessary mechanical strength.
190TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
vergus auton eh one sk SSO Be
frenetic
5.2. RUBBER
pobber has a unique abitity to withstand cortain
Feet of abrasion, This 4s apparently duo to the
Beer rebounding after snpact with abrasive parti
vreeydthout. denage to the rubber. ‘The size of ab-
iSiyo particles which ean effectively be acconno~
date) by Tubbor 4s Linited, Where particles
Garfictently Large to oat or tear the rubber 1 will
freak dom quickly, ‘The exact size of particle
there rubber ceases to be economical is dependent on
Ning factors, but most materials vp to 35 mesh sre
handled by rubber parts with mich coerser (up to 1/2")
particles sometimes punyed with conbinations of
rubber and metal.
Whore conditions are best sulted to its use, @ cood
abrasive resistant rubber will outlast tho hardest
alloy Sorns by as much as 10 to 1. Mechanical.
strength of rubber presents limitations of its use
and Lt must be fully supported or reinforced,
‘Tho use of rubber in high head centrifugal puns is
Limited and special care must be taken in design and
construction to avoid breakdown of rubber at points
of high energy dissipation. Tailings from most pro-
cesses are of a sizing ideally suited to handling
with rubber components unless rubber is precluded
for other reasons,
5.3» HARD Cust 2
Eevly designs of slurry pumps used chilled cast iron
coxponents; in nore recent tines the notallurey of
parts has becone more sophisticated, ani ost of the
« Lesding elurry ponp mamifacturers are using «lloy
dons vith consistently controllod hardnesses of the
order of 600 Erinell. These irons, for many eppli-
cations, provide the most economical compromise bee
‘tween cost and wear performance, ¥
191)
‘TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
5.4, CERMTOS
Various corantes are used for some components; how
ever, except for special applications, end coneider-
ing present manufacturing techniques, ceramics do
not appear to be attractive because:
(3) Cost As high compared to performance,
(41) Manufacture to required tolerances is diffi-
cult
(341) Parts are sonovbat fragile and require special
care in handling.
55. SxuMHETTe =
Various synthetic elastomers including Neopreno,
Butyl, Mtrile, polyurethano and others navo some:
application where their special properties lve then
an advantage,
For gonoral abrasion resistance, however, they have
no particular merit, compared to natural rubber,
5.6. SoucrnstoNs oN warnNe yapmer ats
The present trends on metal to elastomers back to
motel parts ney seen like simple changes in fashion
but the established results are very clear when
eritical pump-cireuits (with a puap change out) dime
prove frou less than six weeks to over six months
contimious operation,
4A careful review on the total systen is justified
but, reslistically, the oporators are being held ac-
countate for production and total costs, Tho pump
manufacturer mst offer a well designed pump which
wall produce the desired results, preferably include
ing completely interchangeable parts of very hard
alloy, rubber and other elastomers,
192‘TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
6. DESIGE F
Slurry punp designs are a compromise between hydrau=
de performance an¢ resistance to wear, Large dia~
neter inpellers require a lower speed and therefore
reduce wear at the vane inlet; on the other hand,
Large Anpellers result in lower hydraulic efficiency.
‘gain, a conpromise must be nade to establish an
econonic balance between cost and performance,
Wear is greatest whore turbulence is greatest or
where eddics occur, High velocities do not necessar=
ily cause a high wear rate, Severe wear occurs dovn
strean of any disturbance to flow such as sudden
change of section or projection into the flow,
Whore rubber Liners are used, it is advantageous 4f
Liners are so constructed that they are self con
tained components which can be sinply attached and
renoved fron the pump, Linings vhich require bond-
Ang to casings with adhesives have many disadvantages;
there is always tho risk of wearing through the eas-
Angs before a breakthrough in the linings is detected,
Inferior material cannot bo econonically offset by
Ancreasing thickness of components. As wear occurs
the rate of wear increases and the bad effects are
therefore cumlative, As woar occurs hydraulic per
formance is elso inpaired and this can only be part=
ly offset by component design.
7. SERIES OPERATTON OF CENRTRUGAL PUMPS
Installation of centrifugal pumps in series may con-
sist of several pumps close coupled in one pumping
tation or single pimps epaced at intervals along a
peline,
Advantages of arranging punps collectively in one
station include the following:
‘ton,
(4) Simplicity of control, inspection and opera»
193TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
(44) Grouping of electrical controls and instrue
mentation in ono conter,
(454) Central maintenance and spare parts handling
4s simplified,
‘The main objections to grouping of punps are assoct=
ated with the higher pressuro to be contained and its
effects on pipelines, glands, bearings and punp ease
ings. If stool pipelines are being used then pipe
Line pressure is not a consideration unless special
conditions apply.
Advantages of spacing pumps at intervals along the
pipeline include:
(4) Possitle use of centrifugal sealing and avoide
ance of necessity for gland sealing water,
(44) Reduced pipeline pressure allows use of cheap-
er pipeline materials such as polythene or
asbestos cenent.
(444) Where tailings are corrosive or toxte the dane
ger of high pressure blowouts with risks to
personnel are reduced,
Where miltistage installations are enployed in a
single station, thrust loads on pipevorie betnoen
stages ean be quite largo and special care must bo
given to layout of puns and anchorage of pipework
to onsure that all loads are satisfactorily acconno-
dated without danago to pumps or pipework,
8. VARIABLE SPEED ooNSTDSRATTONS
Variable speed drives for tailings punps ean be
beneficial for tho following reasons:
(4) Quantity of tailings to be handled may vary.
duo to variations in mill conditions or vari=
ations in grade of head fecd to the mill,
194Gi)
(asi)
(Gav)
(@)
“TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
Zt may be required to pam at optiman density
An order te conserve water,
Length of cischarge Line may vary depending
on tailings dan condi tions,
Static head may increase height of'dan is
raised.
Punp perfomiance varios as pumps become worn.
With a fixed speed installation, punps must
be speeded to moot the required maximum cone
itions when parts are worn, ‘This means that
pumps are running faster than necessary when
parts aro new; parts are therefore being worn
Sut faster than necessary and power consunpe
‘tion is higher than it would be at optimun
speed,
Reliable speed variation with suitable control will
allow control of density, mininun power consumption,
and mexinun life of wearing parts,
Mthough variable speed often Looks attractive at
first glance, careful. assessnent of all factors often
shows
At to be unjustifiable, Inspection of many
Anstallations where variable speed units are often
dein
‘run at top speed either because the variating
equipment ds unserviceable or because the operator
finds
%
91.
At more convenient,
ie
peves
RECIPROCATING PULP DRIVES
Positive displaconent reciprocating pumps are nor=
nally
driven through reduction gear boxes due to the
relatively low speeds required,
Snatd
units may have a belt drive betveon the motor
and the goar reducor; larger units would be direct,
coupled.
195TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
PULP DRIVES
Centrifugal slurry pumps may be direct coupled, belt
driven or driven through gear reducers with or with=
out sone for of variable speed coupling.
For punps up to 300 HP, Yubelt érives usually prow
vide the nost convenient forn of drive,
With large pumps, rotational speeds are lower and for
the higher horsepowors, belt drives are not practical
and coupling of pumps through gear reducers becones
necessary,
With such installations some form of speed variation
in the drive is usually warranted.
Another possibility for large drives is to direct
couple pumps to slow spocd motors, This is usually
more. costly; however, reliability is increased and
noise Level reduced,
93.
931. Doe
Since the development of heavy duty solid state ro
Uflers, D.C, motors are Finding increasing accept
ance for pimp drives, Discussion herein, however,
As Limited to drives’ suitable for use with A.C, in
duction motors.
{SLB SPABD DRIVES.
votons
HoTORS
93-2, VARTABLE SPEED A.C,
The simplest form of spood variation which can be
obtainod is to use a slip ring induction notor and
comnoet permanently rated rosistors into the rotor
cireuit, This provides the lowost capital cost but
is wasteful of power.
A nore sophisticated adaptation of the slip ring
motor 4s to provide means to rectify the current
Eaken fron tho rotor circuit, invert to mains fre-
196“TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
quency and feed this power back into the stator su
ply.
wis systen provides an efficient means of epeed
Taig eyster provadii tioned elcetriocl hardveres how
ware ntreduoes moro points of possible trouble,
She Saving of this systen 4s that the control cation
font can be arranged so that the motor can be rin as)
a fixed specd machine, Af the controls fail.
Special A.C, motors with various conmtator arrencen
ments are available to provide speed variation over
wide ranges ard up to high horsepower ratings. Bf
ficiency of these machines is high and with modern
Arduetion regulated types the reliability is high and
maintenance is reasonable,
Mo wltinate for A.C, motor speod variation is pro-
ably the use of squirrel cage motors with frequency
variation, Such equipment is being developed.
9.303 VARIABLE SPEED COUPI-INGS
Variable speed couplings allow speed variation by con
trolling slip within the coupling, Two main types
are available being the so called eddy-current coupe
‘Lng and the other the fluid coupling.
‘These couplings are not highly efficient because the
slip which occurs is a direct energy loss. In select
Ang euch couplings the full load slip at maxim
speed should be considered because this determines
the maximan efficiency which can be obtained, -
Efficiency at any reduced speed will be less, The
centrifugal punp follows the variable torque charace
teristic and is easily controlled, The maxinun loss
ds at about 2/3 speed which 4s at’ tho most desirable
operating point.
9.3:l, TW SPEED yOTORS
Where a mumbor of pumps are arranged An series (or
With positive disphacenent pumps in parallel) it ds
id 197TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
not normally required to provide variable spoed drives
for all units, One or two units with variable speed
drives operating in conjunction with other Mixed
speed units will usually provide sufficient control,
One novel. noans of providing variablo output fron
a multiple puny installation without using sophisti+
cated equipment is to install two speed motors on
all or sone of the punps. The installation of 6
pole ~ 8 pole machines vill allow stepping down of
output with very simple control equipment, With
modern motor winding techniques, two speed notors
are only fractionally larger and more costly than
single speed machines of the sane rating,
10, GRAVETY FLOW
‘Tho Adeal plant location provides for gravity flow
of the tailings, Tho sane enorgy concepts avply on
tho transformation of vertical drop equivalent head
for useful transportation on gravity as is used on
head generated by centrifugal force. This applies
only to closed-full pipe operation,
‘A review on open fume and drainage concepts is
covered by ARCO (+),
The accepted method of dissivating excess energy 15
the use of Jrop boxes, Refer to photo "Fiz. 13" of
a model by Lee Aplin of the Clarkson Co, ‘This method
roquires considerable individual design following
some of the basic concepts of physics and practical
enginosring,
Tho use of orifices and carefully selected pipe sizes
is an art when applied to dropping sand £411 down
soveral thousand feet into the mine workings (on sand
£111 operations),
n. gosts
Costs of the total systen depend so mich on the site
and operating conditions that estinating the costs
198ST ‘om sxnf7q-48z0u9 eesoxe Supredzssxp xoy x0q doxp 30 Topo
TAILING DISPOSAL TODAY
“a
200“TRANSPORTATION OF TAILINGS
any rule ds difficult, Messrs, Wasp, Thompson ané
jude (5) illustrated the importance of consider’
the quantity as a vital factor.
The equivalent distance should be determined. A
detailed Hyevaulic Profile and Gradient Plot similiar
{o'Ric. 4, bat in greater detail, is of value for
Hin phases of route selection in establishing the
cost .
‘the equivalent horizontal Length on the systen shown
on Fiz, lis epproxinately 15 miles. The total power
4s 12000 to 11000 HP with a capital cost of perhaps
$2 million exclusive of the pine and power Lines.
The cost at 12-16 million TYP (including pipeline)
for 15 miles (horizontal distance) chowld follov
Vasp-Thonpson-fude ostinated at .35f to lsd ver
tonemile, ‘The six mile haul with 1325 ft, lift re~
sults An about 1f per ton-mile and 6,6¢ por ton of
tailings.
At 12-16 miltion tons per year, and at 6.6¢ por ton,
the total cost 1s avery sigmfeant figure, Com
Eidoring thet sone plants are discharging tice this
mount am with future total heads in oxcess of 1000
foot of slurry on a minerel with a snall recovery
Tate, tho reswitant transportation cost as