SUMMARY STATEMENT ON APPLICATION FOR

EXPEDITED SERVICE AND/OR INTERIM RELIEF

(suBnilITTED BY MOVING PART

Dte 10116t17

Tltlc' # 110344110
of
MItGr Dua v. New York City Department of Parks and Recreation

ordcr Suprcmc County New York

judgmcnt of Surrogrtcrs
by dccrcc Femlly Court cntcrcd on

Nrme Noticc
Judgc filcd on 20 2017

If from dministrtivc dctcrmintlon' sttc gcncy

lhe Expressive Matter Vending Rules (Title 56, SS 1-02 and 1-05(b) of the Rules of the Gity of New York)
Neture
rction
as a vlolalion of their fre speeeh and equal proleolion ights undr the Stqte Constituiion and as lnvalid uhdr NYC Ad.Code S 204073
orP
ordcr
Provisions of judgment epperled from

motion for summary judgment on plaintiffs'free speech and equal protection

lalms; Administrative Code and enjoined defendants' enforcement of the Rules aganst
matter vendors; and granted plaintiffs leave to amsnd their complaint to add a separation ol powers claim

eppellent
This ls for
stay-pending the rnoton and pending the appeal*of the injunction enjoining
efendants' enforcement of the Rules (which have been in effect snce May 2011)

If epplytng for r rtry, rtete reeson why

Hes sny undertking been If ?es', state mount nd

IIes epplicetlon been If yes, stete

court below for this Dlspositlon
IIe there been euy If "ycr",
herein ln thi court NO nd nture

Hes edvcrsery
of thls
 - -.-'- -"-t
ltie-foi Movnt Attorncv for Oooosition

Nme W. Carter Phillips Nizer LLP

666 Fifth Avenue
Address York, New York 10103
New York Gi$ Law Department (212) 841-0583
100 Churoh Street
New York, NY 10007 By: Jeffrey L. Shore
Kevin B. McGrath
Tel. No. 212-356-0844 Elizabeth Adinolfi

Appeering by Steiner
I

@o not writc bclow this linc)

DISPOSITION

J"-G*^

tu Justicc >,F
/- /l- /
DIG

Motion Dtc t[ ill<

't Opposltion I Rcply 3
EXPEDITE PHONE ATTORNEYS DECISION BY

ALL PAPERS TO.BE SERVED PERSONALLY. ru

Court Attorney
*Revled 02101"