Sie sind auf Seite 1von 33

Table of Contents

Features:

11 Breaking the Chain


How a simple change to socioeconomic policy might yield a bounty of good results to our interior.
Dr. Francis Liao-Santiago, M.D
22 Know Thy Enemy
A scholarly inquiry into the philosophy of Capellan Mech design.
Leftenant Colonel Yves Fitzgerald
24 The Wages of Sin
A professional perspective on the cost of soldiering.
Captain Isaiah M. Rosner
26 In Pursuit of the Hound
Dare we again follow the path set for us by good First Prince Ian?
Subaltern Hedwig Kirchherr
28 The Acme of Warfare
How proper planning and good execution make the difference between success and disaster.
Major Benjamin F. Marion
30 The Continuing Cost of War
A military chaplain explains why our Civil War was a catastrophe like no other.
Major Jacob Pontiac Brothers

Special Insert:

14 A Tribute to Ian Davion

Departments:
2 From the Desk of the Editor In Chief
3 Letters to the Editor
4 Culture
7 The Loyal Opposition
8 Boys and Their Toys
12 The Support Troops: Naval Support

Staff:
Leftenant General Thomas J. Jackson (Ret.) Editor in Chief
Major Winston B. Thompson (Ret.) Production Director
Sergeant Major Roy Solomon (Ret.) Editor

The Review (ISSN 1337-G4M3R) is published monthly by War College of Goshen Publishing: publishing@wcgoshen.edu.goshen.fs.comnet. Yvonne Steiner-Davion,
Commander-in-Chief; Lft. Gen. Thomas J. Jackson, Editor in Chief. Delivery charges subsidized in part by the War College of Goshen and paid to the ComStar HPG Station,
Goshen. 3067, War College of Goshen Publishing. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without written permission is prohibited. The War College of Goshen
logo and The Review logo are protected through trademark restriction throughout the Inner Sphere. CUSTOMER SERVICE AND SUBSCRIPTIONS please see our ComNet
site at service.wcgoshen.edu.goshen.fs.comnet or write to customerservice@wcgoshen.edu.goshen.fs.comnet. No subscriber information is shared with any outside entity.
From the Desk of the Editor in Chief
It is often said that Hindsight is 20/20 and indeed over these centuries of existence as the Federated
there is some truth to this statement, in that ideally we Suns. Failure to do this would be paramount to
do learn valuable lessons from our actions, and that it forgetting the very great men and women of our rich
is most often on the other side of our actions that we history upon whose shoulders we now stand in the
fully understand the events which led up to them. On present.
the other hand, it can easily be said that our window
on the past is more often than not of the stained- So as you, the reader, begin your perusal of this third
glass variety. It is in fact the nature of man to cast the issue of the forty-second volume of The Review, I ask
stories of his history in a more legendary lighting than that you pause to reflect both on the impact of our
that of reality. Events were either more terrible or current events, and on the perspective of our history.
more wonderful than what would be considered an And as a form of fuel to the fire of this most noble
accurate report. endeavor, may I offer to you the perspective found in
a previous similar time when our nation mourned the
This is not, however, to denigrate cataclysmic death of an icon and
the value of such reports on, and sought to rebuild in the wake of
reminiscence of, our most recent
All past eras have devastating loss. Scattered
Civil War. As I have stated throughout these following pages
previously, at this time it is of dire suffered egregious you will find stories and
necessity that we learn what remembrance of the death of Ian
Davion, the Hound upon whose
lessons we can from our recent times, and all look to shoulders stood The Fox, Hanse.
turmoil and make use of those
lessons to press forward towards a Our hope in adding this focus to
brighter future. However, even in
some past as having this issue is that it will give you, the
such a short span of time as these reader, pause to reflect on the trials
past two months since an official been less painful, less and turmoil surrounding Prince
peace the tendency of man to see Ians most noble life and death, and
upon the tumult and recovery in the
his past through stained-glass stressful, filled with wake of his departure. Some of
windows has already been made
what you will find within these
manifest. And while it is not wrong
to eulogize our beloved dead in this
less upheaval. It is pages is most clearly eulogy, and
fashion, it would be an egregious some is most clearly fact. As you
error to allow these eulogies to not to the past we read these pages may your heart
completely color our view without be stirred and your intellect
challenged.
providing an accurate context for must look, but to the
perspective. For, you see, not only
do stain-glass windows color what All past eras have suffered
is seen through them, they also
future. egregious times, and all look to
distort. some past as having been less
painful, less stressful, filled with less upheaval. Just
I believe that there are two powerful means of as those presently look to the time of Hanse Davion,
maintaining an accurate perspective as we press so too did many during his time look to the time of his
forward in development. The first is obvious: that of predecessor, Ian, for while the Third Succession War
maintaining a keen awareness of current events dragged on for ages, the Fourth was anything but
outside our borders and of fully assessing and wine and roses for the peoples of the Federated
understanding their import upon our lives and society. Suns. The same holds true for all generations of man.
This I believe is somewhat commonplace, for without It is not to the past we must look, but to the future. If
it our society would already have slipped into a we do not make strides to improve our lot, spending
malaise of introspection. The second means, effort merely in the lamentation of times past, we do
however, is much less readily apparent, and so I nothing but disservice to those who have fought and
would to it direct the readers attention: the context of died to give us our present and open the door to our
our prior history. future. The road before us is by no means easy, but
the path is true and has been marked clearly by those
Indeed, as we seek to maintain clear eyes and heads, who have gone before. Never let us forget from
we must ever compare recent events, be they whence we came.
mundane or cataclysmic, to those in our past which
have so powerfully shaped who we have become Lft. Gen. Thomas J. Jackson (ret.) E.I.C.

2
Letters to the Editor

Dear Goshen Review: it seriously. Secondly I do not wish units which can be split into smaller
to offend that minority, but neither do parts and combined into combat
I had quite a fright this morning while I wish to stop speaking the truth as teams as needed. I cannot laud
reading your latest issue at breakfast best I am able. To those to whom Gen. Voss enough for this unique
on my lovely seaside veranda. You astrology is nothing but a distraction and innovative concept. Why, this
see, I had just finished reading my let me say that astrology--along with will revolutionize the entire AFFS
horoscope in the Lackland Gazette other occult practices--offers special and make us a new combat force for
before turning to Father Thomassis risks that make it a serious the future. What would be even
stern warning against consulting with undertaking. For those to whom nicer, however, would be if General
mediums, spirit guides and witch astrology is a cherished religious Voss were familiar with the AFFS as
doctors. I was nearly convinced that practice the dangers described in my a whole, considering that for quite
my silly habit was bringing down the article to military effectiveness apply. some time the Ceti Hussars RCTs
wrath of God upon my head. But have made use of just such an
then I remembered my horoscopes Let me be clear: any religious organizational scheme. Rather than
advice: Take little heed of practice has the potential to interfere advance these concepts as
blowhards today, and I felt much with military readiness. Individuals something new and unique, why not
better after that. might interrupt battle to engage in focus on a unit which has
prayer (as in the famous case of successfully applied these very
Cordially, ELH MechWarrior Abrahim ibn Faud) ideas? Continually snubbing one of
Morgan Defire, but a commander or an army that the most valuable combat groups of
Marquessa of Lackland does so is derelict. Armies can the AFFS is a heinous misdeed
accommodate religious call only so which can only damage the morale
Dear Goshen Review: far, and any commander incapable of those who are members of it.
of squaring his heavenly and earthly
In your June issue you ran an article duties should resign his commission Sincerely,
entitled Navigating by the Stars and assume a life of contemplation. Lft. G. Kincaid
which pointedly condemned
consulting astrologers regarding I do not back down from my calling
when to marry and give in marriage. the stars unworthy of our My Esteemed Colleagues,
This advice will be poorly received genuflection. That it is traditional
on the Hindu worlds where arranged religious practice to do so is not You published an excellent article in
marriage is a sacred cultural tradition news to me, but such traditions held the June 3067 issue entitled Artwork
and matches based on caste, tribe, back Europe in the Middle Ages and of Deception. That such an
and birth star are prized. If not for India in the Republican Era, and to outstanding piece appears on the
the article on Diwali in the same some degree they hold back the pages of The Review is a credit to
issue I might have suspected an Federated Suns today. I do not both the publication and academy as
anti-Hindu bias had crept into The grant that that all religious traditions a whole. It is to my deep regret,
Review. It would please me to see are equally good. No religious figure however, that I must submit this
future articles celebrating Hindu of consequence ever has. letter to point out a glaring error.
culture instead of denigrating it. This article has wrongly been
Sincerely, attributed to one Lft. General Pavel
Sincerely, Father F. Thomassi V. Miliukov. Though I would be
Mrs. Iyer A. S. proud to have said article on my
Pavopolis, Brantapur C.V., I cannot take credit for this
Dear Readers of The Review, work. I implore you to give credit to
Fr. Thomassi replies, the true author of this work, who
I would like to extend my rightly deserves proper recognition.
Marquess Defires and Mrs. Iyers congratulations to The Review staff
letters are typical of the responses in general, and to Major General Yours,
that my article generated; either they Angela Voss in particular, for the Lft. General Pavel V. Miliukov
make light of my heavy-handed wonderful article in the June 67
warnings or they chastise me for issue entitled The RCT Must The article was authored by Herr
giving offense. (Interestingly, most Change! In this insightful article she Doktor Gottfried von Bazillac. The
responses were from women.) advocates a full reorganization of all Review regrets the error.
Firstly I do think that astrology AFFS RCTs into fully integrated
represents a serious problem combined arms units rather than
because a significant minority takes maintaining the cohesion of separate

3
Culture
performing songs of the noble and holy
Minstrel Boy The Minstrel Boy to the
cause of the rebels.

war is gone Eventually identified and sought for


arrest, Rigbarddan is pursued by
The famed Columbia Players theater In the ranks of death you officials of the government for sedition.
troupe of New Avalon has recently will find him; He is surrounded by those who he
developed and produced a new play, knows not but nonetheless hates for
The Age of Minstrels. Drawing their what they represent. Knowing that the
His father's sword he hath
inspiration from the classic song of likelihood of his safe and timely parole is
girded on,
Thomas Moore, the drama hearkens slim to none, he chooses to fight his
back to old Terra, in the idyllic ages aggressors. Though somewhat more
many years before spaceflight when And his wild harp slung
learned in combat since Antrim, he is
wars were fought less for territory than behind him;
quickly struck a mortal blow. With his
for ideals and basic human rights. dying breath, rather than allow the
The performers attempt to link our "Land of Song!" said the instrument of his own private battle to be
recent conflict to all those of warrior bard, taken and perhaps used by those he
humanitys past, showing that morally opposed, Rigbarddan rends asunder his
just conflicts are never futile, though "Tho' all the world betrays one true possession, that which defined
the pursuit of victory may be. thee, his life, the weapon with which he
Bookended by solemn renditions of waged his war: the pipes of his heritage.
Moores song, unaccompanied by One sword, at least, thy
instrumentation as by folk singers of rights shall guard, This play seeks to redress some of the
old, the all-male Players chronicle the concerns harbored by many of our
fictional life of an idealistic youth of old One faithful harp shall surviving Civil War participants by
Ireland. illustrating that their own plight is neither
praise thee!"
unique nor without precedent. Many
The play is set during the Irish parallels can be drawn between this old
The Minstrel fell! But the
rebellion near the end of the 18th war and our recent one, for who among
century on old Terra, opening with foeman's chain
us cannot see Rigbarddan as a fallen
young Rigbarddan Flanagan breaking MechWarrior choosing to destroy his
with his loyalist family, who supported Could not bring that proud
magnificent machine of war rather than
the throne of Great Britain over soul under; allow it to be taken by the enemy and
independence for Ireland. Fleeing his used against his own? The writers were
fathers wrath, he joins with the rebels. The harp he lov'd ne'er careful not to pass judgment upon either
Lacking military skills, Rigbarddan spoke again, side of our recent conflict by showing
became a piper in the small faction, only that some battles must indeed be
helping to rally and inspire his more For he tore its chords fought which cannot be won, showing
capable fellows. asunder; sympathy for those whose cause was
defeated but counseling patience and
Betrayed by their own, Flanagans And said "No chains shall humility for the victors rather than
group was among those at Antrim who sully thee, become despotic. Thus, despite dealing
were either slaughtered wholesale or with a civil war and so not deflecting the
captured and executed. Rigbarddan Thou soul of love and issue to something lighter, the Columbia
himself, being unarmed, was spared Players embrace the recent upheaval
brav'ry!
by the mercy of an anonymous soldier and try to soothe the souls of those who
who was appalled at the actions of his fought in it by treating both sides with
Thy songs were made for
own. Left to his own devices, dignity and humility.
disowned by his family, betrayed by the pure and free,
his own leaders, and violently Though the engagements of the Players
separated from his friends and They shall never sound in
are limited to New Avalon, due to their
compatriots, Rigbarddan reevaluates slavery!" refusal to travel by JumpShip, they have
his path in life. Undeterred by his lack licensed the drama to other theater
of military acumen, Rigbarddan companies across the Crucis March.
reaffirms his conviction to dispel the Should the play be as well-received as
yoke of terror and oppression of the The Minstrel Boy
the original New Avalon performances, it
foreign leadership. He initiates an is expected that further licenses shall
ancient form of propaganda campaign, By Thomas Moore follow and spread the play to the rest of
traveling to villages and towns and the Federated Suns. (This is reputedly

4
Culture
of particular interest to the Davion Assault Guards, preserve this music, most Neo-Contemporary material
who adopted The Minstrel Boy as their official song has been lost. Few taped recordings of performances
in the Second Succession War, whose posting on Lee have survived the centuries of war and neglect.
has prevented their attendance of any performance.) Books of music have fared better, but some Neo-
Contemporary composers never bothered to publish
When that comes to pass, the Capellan and Draconis their music in written form, and many others
Marches will be the beneficiaries of perhaps the finest composed in styles ill-suited to existing transcription
dramatic blending of history and dramatic license conventions. Surprisingly the music of earlier periods
since Truman and Johnsons Rise and Fall of Amaris. has survived better due to its more uniform
transcription onto paper staves.
Stanley Garrison was born and raised on Goshen, but
a congenital lung defect precluded military service. The Star Leagues collapse brought about a quick end
He has directed numerous plays at the WCG in to the consumer-driven music industry. With the halt
conjunction with the Drama Department. of royalty cheques musicians now depended upon
wealthy patrons or the State for their income.
Musicians in the pay of the warrior nobilitythe only
musicians employedwrote martial music using
themes drawn from the cultural heritage of their
respective Great House. Themes deemed too foreign
were suspect and quickly disappeared from use.
The Music of the Sphere Thus began the Neo-Romantic period, the music of
which was much simpler technically and thematically
than that of the Neo-Contemporary Period. The
Given the drastic social and economic changes of the succeeding three centuries were a time of nearly
past thirty-five years, it is unsurprising that the great nonexistent musical innovation, though not wholly
changes in the field of music have gone largely without merit. There was a return to modal music and
unnoticed. Music is thought by many to be a trifle, an small-ensemble choral music, and some
amusement for the working class and common soldier musicologists believe that wind band (military brass)
or an indulgence for the wealthy and well-born. This music saw its best composition since Sousa.
attitude is short sighted because music is a bellwether Nevertheless the Neo-Romantic Period is universally
that can indicate the health of a culture, and despite regarded as a musical dark age that saw the death of
our current distress the signs are largely positive. It countless genera of musical styles and techniques.
appears that we are undergoing a major transition in
musical style, the first such transition since the Here in the Federated Suns the beginning of an
beginning of the Succession Wars. There is reason emergence from Neo-Romanticism may be underway.
to hope that the current trend toward greater variety It can be traced back to First Prince Hanses heroic
and sophistication in music may continue, perhaps capture of Star League-era codices (books) in 3012
returning us to Star League-era levels within our on Halstead Station. The booty included several texts
lifetime. However, the transition is still tenuous and on composition and theory around which a tiny
subject to reversal given unfavorable events, and so Department of Modern Music was established at
the future of our musical heritage remains ever NAIS. Their experiments with cockpit recorders and
uncertain. voice synthesizers led to a revival of the mysteriously-
named Moog Music, a kind of atonal electronica
The music of the Star League bore little resemblance reminiscent of a Star League-era fad. At the same
to the music of the Successor States. Star League- time, Davion troubadours were incorporating Lyran
era music was colorful, complex and structurally fluid. musical themes into their own compositions, creating
There was music to suit every taste available in every the first new popular music style in over three
corner of the League. Recorded hard copies of centuries. The Federated Commonwealth brought an
performances were cheap and durable, and the infusion of Lyran cash and technical savvy which
economics of a trillion-strong consumer market made widely available many instruments that had
guaranteed infinite variety and accessibility. This was become exceedingly rare and expensive, including
the Neo-Contemporary Period, the music of which the euphonium, the keyboard-accordion, the full
was typified not so much by common sound as by spectrum of double-reed instruments (the bassoon
universal exuberance and confidence in the state of and contrabassoon, the oboe and bass oboe, and the
things. It was music for a wealthy people who English horn), and to a lesser degree the piano.
believed in the durability and superiority of their There was a revival of complex orchestral
culture; in opulence and comprehensiveness it has composition, and despite wartime fiscal distress the
never since been equaled. Despite the efforts of patronage of Lady Melissa guaranteed that lavish
academics and aficionados on many worlds to performances went to production. With the protracted

5
Culture
Civil War such productions have dwindled to act presents the wedding of the Queen of Birds, a
nonexistence, but it was not long ago (though it feels peafowl, to the King of Beasts, a lion. In the second
an eternity) that our music reflected a belief in our and final act, the lion is killed offstage by a hunter, the
nations limitless potential. beasts chafe under the peafowls ineffectual rule, and
war between birds and beasts erupts after escalating
Tragically, there appears to be a slowing of the atrocities and reprisals by either side. The peafowl
incipient musical renaissance. Moogism appears to sings her swansong in the finale, and as she dies the
have peeked already and is showing creative decline. curtain goes down on her blood-spattered throne
Anti-Lyran sentiment in the face of the Civil War has room. There are no political screeds, there is no
weakened support for the new styles. Even more incitement to treason, and there is noforgive me
worrisome is the strong public nostalgia for bestiality, as was suggested by the Bishop of Filtvelt.
Succession Wars-era music. High Lonesome modal
warbling and rustic fiddling are once again the sounds The plays politics are the real cause of the outrage.
heard in the streets, and a new generation of Davion The lion and peafowl clearly stand for Hanse and
youth appear to be forsaking the forward-looking Melissa, and the play appears to sympathize with the
music of their fathers in favor of the music of their birds (Lyran Alliance). Feathered costumes shimmer
grandfathers time. It remains to be seen whether under spotlight as the fierce-looking foxes and bears
history will regard the current period as the beginning devour birds with a clever stage trick. The closest to
of a new era of music to rival the energy and creativity an overt political message in the plays text is a
of the Star League or a small blip in the long dark soliloquy against exogamy by one of the foxes in the
ages of Neo-Romanticism. first act, but the overriding mood of the play is one of
resignation to fate. Importantly the peafowl appears
to die of sorrow rather than at the hands of an
Paul Lombrice is an alumnus of GCW and of the assassin, and the royal marriage isas biology would
Goshen Players, for which he played the alto dictatefruitless; no Peafowl-Lion offspring are left to
saxophone and composed. vie for the throne.

The play is metaphor and not simple allegory, and


suggestion that it slanders the Ruling House is
absurd. Whats more, the play is a wonder to see and
hear; the animal costumes are exquisite, and the
singing truly first rate. If not for the themes of murder
and mayhem I would recommend it to all without
Carnival of the Animals reservation.

Now we attend the unpleasant business of


It is in character for us to fret over abstractions like censorship. Attorney-General Anton Comstock of the
freedom and justice while more prosaic problems Barrony of Avalon has threatened to enjoin production
abound. Our Navy is hemorrhaging money, our cities of the play under centuries-old anti-sedition laws. No
are only now slowly being restored, and the social small amount of clamoring in the public square in
unrest in the aftermath of Civil War has brought favor of just such an action can be heard, in Avalon
suspicion and strife. In spite of all this, the issue that City and elsewhere. It is troubling but understandable
has caught the attention of our people and leaders is that in these trying times commitment to the Six
a play called The Marriage that has been in Freedoms grows thin. Were the play a true
production only three weeks in a single small theatre incitement to sedition and devoid of artistic merit I
in Avalon City. Fewer than two thousand patrons would join the voices of those calling for the curtain to
have seen it, and yet to hear some opiners, this play come down. Nevertheless, it is our commitment to
is a greater threat to our nation than ten-thousand freedom that sets us apart as a nation, and I am
Capellan MechWarriors! confident reason will prevail in this matter.
As one of the few reviewers who has actually seen Issachar Nahum, WCG '49
the play, I feel it necessary to recount a summary of Sir Nahum is Theatre Critic for the New Avalon Herald
the plot to counter the egregious misrepresentations and Critic-at-Large to The Review
that have appeared in various newspapers. The first

6
The Loyal Opposition
For centuries our nations ambitious foreign policy good were left in place: the public schools, the
had brought steady gains against the Capellan courthouses, the public baths, the political halls, and
Confederation while holding the hyper-aggressive others. In the future, these symbols of Capellan
Draconis Combine at bay. The worlds we won commonweal should be found and razed upon our
became firmly Davion in their allegiance and their arrival. The more brutal we are on the first day, the
assimilation into our culture was swift. In contrast, our more quickly we set that world on the path to
more recent acquisitions have proven difficult to hold, normalization into Davion culture and the Davion
and many already have slipped from our grasp. What polity.
is the solution to this riddle, that worlds gained in this
generation have proven so much more difficult to hold In the long run this seemingly senseless cruelty
than those of generations past? The standard answer serves a very real and very just purpose. By showing
is that the newer worlds are more inherently Capellan our most recent conquests too much mercy, we have
(or at least more anti-Davion) than the rest, or that subjected the denizens of these worlds to a
Capellan partisans are more effective in the modern generation (or more) of unrest. By telegraphing our
age. Though the latter observation is no doubt fact, it forbearance, which will always be interpreted by our
begs the question, what is making them more enemies as weakness, we have encouraged
effective? Compounding the paradox is the dissidence, strife, and ever-escalating guerilla
observation that the Fourth Succession War, though violence. In the end we will put down those worlds,
catastrophic for our enemies and costly to us, was the and we will do so using the requisite amount of force,
least deadly and damaging to property of the four. In but the threshold rises with each passing day and with
fact there is no paradox, only this truism: just as one each perceived Zhanzheng de Guang victory. We will
who desires peace must prepare for war, one who prevail, but at a price far higher than we might
wishes to rule benevolently must conquer brutally. otherwise have paid.

It is not surprising that as the ease with which our Therefore it is time to be both clever and resolute.
armies conquered worlds increased, the difficulty with Our policy should emphasize the liberation of
which we held our gains increased as well. Our latest servitors and a psychological operations campaign
conquest into the heart of Capellan space has calling attention to the rumored gulag worlds not
produced new problems by its very efficiency. It has appearing on Capellan star charts. Inter-caste strife
created the phenomenon of the so-called Citizen Afar, is our greatest non-military asset in the long struggle
a Capellan patriot on a world in the hands of the against the Confederation, and it must be exploited. It
Federated Suns. There are also now so-called was genius of the highest order to foment the schism
Copperheads, Davion citizens who give aid and of the Saint Ives Compact, and bungling of equal
comfort to Zhanzheng de Guang terrorist networks. order to allow Tikonov to fall back into Capellan
The relative ease with which worlds have passed from hands. The emphasis upon winning battle while
the Capellan banner to the Sword-and-Sunburst has neglecting the waging of war on all fronts political,
falsely suggested to these folk that the process easily economic, cultural and philosophical has turned us
may be reversed. Our failure to be clumsy and brutal away from the legacy of First Prince Hanses genius.
in conquering has made our conquest seem less real, He knew well the centuries-old maxim that the best
perhaps even subject to public approbation. These victories are not those that come on the battlefield,
Citizens Afar do not believe that House Davion is and that a nation may win every battle and yet lose
here to stay, and so they agitate, chafe, and do not the war if care is not given to small matters.
accept. The more even-handed we are in our
treatment of these worlds, the greater and the longer Lft. Col. Ndugu Bowunga (ret.), WCG 30
the suffering of the populace. Institutions of the public

7
Boys and Their Toys
The personal Mech of Ian Davion was an Atlas, and tied to the monstrous gyro which can often be heard
with this issue of The Review being in tribute to our screaming in its efforts to keep the Mech upright
fallen First Prince it seemed fitting to feature this during maneuvers. Given the top-heavy chassis
venerable BattleMech in his honor. With the same configuration accentuated by the enormous
commanding presence with which First Prince Ian shoulders, this conclusion seems somewhat
strode the halls of the Royal Palace, the Atlas has, foregone. Though it encounters criticism rarely due to
since its earliest days off the assembly line, its combat efficacy, engaging the Atlas in close
dominated the battlefields of humanity. Wonderfully combat is actually one of the best means to defeat it.
conceived and outfitted with versatility and It has been advanced that the very aura of invincibility
functionality of utmost concern, the Atlas is a combat which the Mech seems to exude actually works
unit to respect. against some of its MechWarriors who react poorly
when confronted by unimpressed foes. Facing an
enemy who stands and fights is at times surprising
Produced for centuries on Quentin, the classic AS7-D and can cause the Atlas pilot to hesitate. When
version of the Atlas was the same Mech designed by fighting up close the unsteadiness of the chassis aids
General Kerensky himself. The steadfastness and in bringing down these giant Mechs.
reliability of the Mech is such that despite the loss of
Quentin to the Draconis Combine after the War of Since new Atlas production on Quentin was lost, it
3039 the number of Atlases in the AFFS forces did has come to pass that enemy forces now field this
not decline significantly as raids and reprisals caused Mech in greater and greater numbers. Thus it is
losses throughout the military. The D has a number important that MechWarriors in the Suns learn the
of detractors who note that its lack of long-range specifications of those variations extant among the
armament is a liability exacerbated by the Mechs hostile ranks in order to combat those forces more
slow top speed. However, the duty of engaging in effectively. First, the Combine in short order made
long range slugging matches was never intended to use of our captured facility, turning out a new variant
be filled by the Atlas with more appropriate units like completely reversing the close combat focus of the
Awesomes already serving well in that capacity. D. Extended-range large-bore lasers and a Gauss
Rather, the Atlas is possessed of a remarkably thick Rifle allow it to deal out punishment while it closes
slab of armor covering it from its broad feet to its with the enemy rather than only absorb it. It also
leering deaths-head allowing it to weather those very mounts an anti-missile system, actually improving its
long range barrages of enemy firepower as it slogs its defensive capability beyond the copious armor. A
way ever closer to the enemys strongholds. The poor weapon-heat profile, however, is this variants
determination embodied by the Atlas combined with sole shortcoming. The supply shortage of Freezers in
its hideous appearance lends the Mech its near- the Combine is highlighted in this otherwise premier
legendary mystique, but the nightmare only truly Assault Mech. Only its inability while firing to avoid
begins within range of its numerous shorter-ranged exceeding its heat dissipation limit curbs this
weapons. Combining a Class-20 Autocannon with an fearsome machine. Those facing off against one of
array of lasers and missiles, as well as swinging fists, this type are advised to concentrate fire from multiple
an Atlas can batter and blast enemies into ruin in units, trying to close distance as quickly as possible,
short order. hitting it from all angles to overwhelm the overtaxed
gyro. One should take note of the fact that the rear-
However as professional soldiers it is not for us facing lasers are pulse versions now, and much more
merely to propagate unfounded myths, for as the very accurate. While the Draconians made excellent use
example of First Prince Ian attests, the Atlas like all of rediscovered technology and our captured facility to
other Mechs falls in battle to superior enemy turn out their superior combat machine, a number of
numbers, tactics, and knowledge. While it is unusual poorly-conceived variants joined our own TO&E.
that a MechWarrior who helms one of these brutes Among these was the AS7-S, swapping the Ds heat
will state it openly the Atlas is not light on its feet, and sinks for Freezers and adding twin Streak-2s to the
some would go so far as to label it clumsy. This is rear-firing lasers. The addition of rear-firing missiles
due in part to its being the first Mech to mass one was acknowledgment that the fate of so many Atlases
hundred tons. While later designs have learned was to fall beset on all sides in close combat. But two
lessons for which the Atlas was the test-bed, none of small short-range missile batteries only slightly
those in charge of the assembly lines ever dared deterred the enemy, and catastrophic explosion of the
tamper with success by meddling with the intricacies added ammunition lost us more Atlases than the
of its construction. Though the precise mechanism of capture of the Quentin factory. Once the trickle from
its ungainliness has never been determined, it is likely Quentin was shut off, only the S was supplied to the

8
Boys and Their Toys

9
Boys and Their Toys
AFFC ranks from DefHes factories. This was obfuscate which variant the enemy is facing and allow
3
considered a stopgap solution at best, providing a the friendly C net to survive longer. The Combine
3
well-established machine though of dubious quality. has added a new C -slave variant which drops just
one of the rear pulse lasers to free up the required
The Lyran replacement for the S model, however, space. It also adds in an additional heat sink to
was a distinct improvement. The reduction of the support the large lasers. In the event this variant is
LRM rack by five missiles per volley was offset by the encountered one should proceed with caution as its
3
addition of an Artemis system. The arm lasers were three C lancemates are sure to be in close support.
upgraded to ER Largesa nod to the success of the
Combine version. In addition, this new version A number of limited modifications have been reported
mounts the recently developed Heavy Gauss Rifle. over the years, and non-standard configurations
This massive gun complements the armament, which different from those described here should be
is enhanced by the use of Freezers, to eliminate even expected. Most of these were motivated by supply
the small deficiency of the Combine variant. Add to problems during the Succession Wars but some by
the mix that the S2 has CASE installed to protect it pilot or unit preference. Most focus on reducing the
from ammo explosions or catastrophic hits to the close range combat ability and increasing long-range
HGRs capacitor system. This Mech also makes use effectiveness. For example, a mercenary unit which
of the new Light Fusion Engine, described as took part in Duke Robinson's actions reportedly
something of a midpoint between salvaged a Combine -CM Atlas but
standard fusion engines and extra- It is not for us merely to modified it greatly to match the
light engines, suffering something overall unit profile. Techs from the
of a midpoint of the vulnerabilities propagate unfounded First Robinson Rangers report that
of the others as well. The S2 has the modification including adding a
a devastating weapons array, a myths, for as the very second Gauss Rifle at the expense
superior cooling system, and of the large lasers and a shuffling of
additional defensive systems. example of First Prince the other armaments.
However, this is a rare Atlas variant
in that it lacks rear-firing weaponry. Ian attests, the Atlas like For the MechWarrior fortunate
Thus the best plan of attack against enough to be piloting a classic AS7-
one of these is by use of greater all other Mechs falls in D, the effectiveness of your still
numbers so that one or more can reliable Mech can be enhanced
pour fire into the rear torso. Note battle to superior enemy with the new autocannon ammo
that some Atlases of this variety which the NAIS developed recently.
can be found in friendly hands, as numbers, tactics, and A ton of armor-piercing or precision
pro-Victor forces brought them over ammo, catered to the expected
during the Civil War. Few of these knowledge. opposition, can rejuvenate the
are known to have been salvaged, classic configuration. Ofttimes it is
as the thick armor either allows just such a slight surprise which
these beasts to survive the fight or requires those in can mean the difference between victory and retreat
opposition to destroy them utterly in order to put them before those who write off the venerable variant
down. because it lacks the newer weaponry.

A slight modification to the K is the CM variant. The Atlas has survived the fall of the Star League, the
3
This variant drops the left arm laser and installs a C depravities of the Succession Wars, the invasion of
master computer. Rare in the AFFS, it is seen more the Clans, the sundering of the Federated
often in the DCMS and the ComGuards. However, Commonwealth, and even the loss of one of the
the actions of Duke Robinson during the Civil War greatest MechWarrior-Princes of the Suns.
resulted in several of these being captured. The best MechWarriors come and go, but the Atlas lives on. Its
tactic to use against this Atlas is to take advantage subtle details might change, but the basic framework
ofthe short range of the rear pulse lasers. The lack of remains. Never a beautiful machine, it is something
a left arm laser should allow one to maneuver toward to be respected for its destructive ability, but not
its rear along that quarter. The attacker should feared for its appearance. Knowing its limitations in
consider aiming at the command computer in the left every form helps not only to use it more ably, but also
arm but be advised that most of the Atlases of this to defeat it when in the hands of the enemy.
variant in the AFFS have had a dummy barrel
installed on the left arm. This deception is to Sergeant-Major Martin Trevithick, AFFS and Captain
Huy Nguyen, AFFS (ret.) are filling in for Captain
Rosner, who was called away and unable to file his
usual column.

10
Breaking the Chain

Since the end of the First Succession War the problem. The military receives its budget largely
economy of the Federated Suns has operated in a without earmarks for specific projects. Its officers
state of permanent crisis. The constant threat posed must decide how best to spend, and given the
by our neighbors and the costly supply chains expectations placed upon them, they will naturally
inherent to our vast and sparsely developed nation favor projects of greater military utility. Again, this is
make the defense of the Federated Suns an not to say they are heartless skinflints, nor that
enormous challenge. Since the military cannot be military men dont know the value of a well-placed
neglected and our guard cannot ever be relaxed, we dam or a dredged channelcertainly they do. But as
have never experienced respite from the strain of a military men their eyes naturally turn towards those
wartime budget. While the AFFS is always flush with worlds on the frontier and away from the relatively
cash and can-do, other Ministries are perennially safe interior, so when the purse is opened the
starved for funds and ill-equipped to fill their given Outback is left empty handed.
role. When a need arises anywhere in the Federated
Suns the first call is often made to the AFFS. Today The solution is obvious: to cut the budget of the
a significant portion of the military budget is spent on AFFS, to close garrisons on non-border worlds, and
what properly could be called non-military projects. to use the savings to fund the civilian public sector to
On some worlds the local garrison commander has a oversee the development of those worlds. Tax
larger budget for capital improvement than the local revenues from a developing world can be used to
civilian government. The administration of projects build factories, fund schools and fill libraries. Private
not of military utility by the AFFS has displaced the business and interstellar corporations heretofore leery
need for civilian bureaucracy throughout the poorer of the worlds anemic performance would sense new
regions of the Suns, where the civilian public sector is opportunity and rush to set up shop, putting that world
scarce and military omnipresent. How did this on the path to economic recovery. Once that world
unnatural state of things come to pass? can stand on its own taxes may finally be collected
and used to support military activities elsewhere,
In the aftermath of the First Succession War the transforming the world from a drain on the military
AFFS was instrumental in the rebuilding of our budget to a contributor of the national economy. This
shattered infrastructure. As soon as the shooting necessary and prudent liberalization of the national
stopped the largest, best funded, most mobile and economy is centuries overdue and would bring
best equipped organization in the Federated Suns immediate improvement to GDP. Had these
was put to work in roles traditionally undertaken by measures been taken fifty years ago there would
civilian industries (chiefly large construction projects have been no need for an infusion of Lyran capital to
other than urban development and demolition) and revive our ailing economy. The change would bring
civilian government. It has remained so to the benefits to the military as well. Relieved of the burden
present day. The expected end to hostilities never of ministering to our own poorer worlds, the AFFS
arrived, and civilian government never got the staff could instead be used to help stabilize and
budgetary infusion necessary to reassert its traditional Davionize our new acquisitions from the Capellan
role. It seems that the choice made in the face of our Confederation, where the public sector plays a much
near extinction some three centuries ago will continue larger traditional role than here.
to shape our economic policy decisions for the
foreseeable future. This is regrettable because Sadly these sensible changes may never take place
burdening the military with the proper responsibilities because they are politically untenable. The military
of civilian government has hampered economic and the public both equate cutting the budget of the
development and put a drag on the military, and in the AFFS with pacifism and a deficit of patriotism.
end has benefited no one. This is not to say that the However, a nation dependent upon its military in civil
AFFS staff are unscrupulous or ineffective matters is not truly free. Let the military concern itself
administratorsthey are notnor do we deny that on with military matters, and let common markets and
many worlds the AFFS personnel are the best- private enterprise flourish unfettered by the heavy
educated, most disciplined, and most capable men glove of military bureaucracy. We cannot afford
and women on handthey are. Rather, we argue another century of backwardness in the heart of our
that the military should attend to its primary purpose, realm.
the defense of the nation, and the civilian public
sector be developed at long last to relieve the AFFS
of duties to which it is less well suited. Francis Liao-Santiago, M.D., was born in the Capellan
Confederation. He is a retired country doctor in
The persistent poverty in the Outback illustrates the Bethsaida village, Goshen.

11
The Support Troops: Naval Support
The AFFS naval service has long been regarded as The Naval Service is far from the simple transport
the lesser service within the Department of the Army service that some consider it to be, though that is its
and Navy, but clearly it is just as important since primary missionto move the ground forces and their
without a viable navy it is impossible to move ground supplies and support them when and where needed.
forces and protect them in transit. To accomplish this, the naval service divides its
assets up in several ways: first the DropShips.
To understand naval service organization it is
important to understand some basic naval The Naval Service operates a variety of DropShips to
terminology. To the uninitiated many naval terms move troops and materiel. Although many people
may seem interchangeable; in fact, they are not believe that the DropShips, and in a few cases
each word has a very specific meaning. The basic JumpShips, assigned to the Regular Army or March
unit in the naval service is of course the ship. Above Militias belong to and are operated by them this is not
the ships and their captains are the Squadron and its true; all AFFS DropShips belong to and come under
commander. Each naval squadron generally consists the control of the Naval Service. That being said,
of one basic type of ship: either DropShip or about a quarter of all AFFS DropShips are attached to
JumpShip. All ships in the AFFS, with the exception specific army and militia units on a more or less
of WarShips, are assigned to a squadron even though permanent basis.
many operate separately. As a general rule of thumb
Light Commodores command DropShips, Of the army and militia units that do have DropShip
Commodores command JumpShips and Vice support attached, which are universally either very
Admirals command WarShips. A ships executive prestigious BattleMech regiments or Regimental
officer is usually one rank below that of the Combat Teams, less than 10% have anything close to
commanding officer. full DropShip transport capacity, average capacity is
closer to 15%, and only a very select few have
DropShip squadrons average six ships. JumpShip JumpShips. The truth is that DropShips are far too
squadrons are, however, based not on number of valuable, expensive, and rare to be allowed to sit
ships but on docking collars. Although JumpShip around, only occasionally being used when one
squadrons always consist of a minimum of two ships ground unit needs transport.
they average twelve docking collars each.
Commodores usually command DropShip squadrons As a general rule of thumb each Regular Army and
and Rear Admirals commonly command JumpShip March Militia Regimental Combat Team normally has
squadrons. between two and four DropShips attached. These
DropShips utilize whatever JumpShips might be in the
Above the Squadron is the Group, which consists of area, frequently they must contract with commercial
two or more squadrons. Mixing DropShips and JumpShip operators. This allows the ground
JumpShips within a single unit usually only occurs at commanders to maintain lines of communication
the group level or above. Most group commanders between their subordinate units, which are frequently
are Vice Admirals. spread over several planets. All fleet commands are
kept fully advised of all operations by naval assets
The next larger grouping of ships in the naval service attached to the ground forces.
is the Task Force. With the exception of the Naval
Assault Task Force, a task force is usually an ad hoc All AFFS DropShips are grouped into one of four
assembly of ships for a particular mission. Task types of DropShip squadrons based on mission type:
forces, including Naval Assault Task Forces, are Naval Escort, Naval Assault Transport, Naval General
normally commanded by Admirals. Transport and Naval Support.

Above the Task Force is the Fleet. Fleets are As its name implies the Naval Escort Squadron is
regional commands within the AFFS, responsible for organized and equipped to escort other naval assets.
a particular region of space rather than a specific As a consequence most are equipped with carrier and
collection of ships. Each of the Naval Services fleets assault DropShips and have, at a minimum, one
corresponds to an AFFS Combat Theater, with each Naval Wing for fighter support. The Federated Suns
fleet commander answering directly to the theater Navy relies heavily on Leopard-CV and Avenger class
commander. Ships are moved between the fleets as DropShips in its escort squadrons; most of the naval
needs dictate although each fleet is usually services few Achilles and Vengeance class
guaranteed a minimum of naval assets to fulfill DropShips support WarShip task forces. This is not
operational requirements. an ideal situation but makes the best use of available
assets. Most escort squadrons also have a Marine
company, or at the least a platoon, distributed among
its ships for boarding and security support.

12
The Support Troops: Naval Support
The naval service classifies its transport DropShips Most support squadrons consist of stores ships to
into two major categories: assault landing and resupply other ships without landing or docking at
general. Assault landers, such as the Union, space stations; tenders are common too. A few even
Leopard, Fury and Triumph, are designed for putting operate mobile drydocks and tug DropShips. All
combat troops into a drop zone on contested planet. AFFS Hospital DropShips are operated by support
But most naval service transport operations are not squadrons even though they transport and tend far
combat related. In fact they are rather mundane, more ground forces soldiers than naval service
moving troops and supplies among existing duty spacers.
stations in relatively safe areas. Most of these
operations are conducted by the General Transport Naval Service JumpShips operate much like
Squadrons, although the assault transport squadrons DropShips. Although at any given moment about half
are often used for general transport duties if not of all Federated Suns Navy JumpShips are operating
required elsewhere. In either case the average individually all belong to a JumpShip squadron. The
transport squadron of either type consists of six or bulk of the missions for independently operating
seven DropShips of various types. JumpShips are of the most mundane types, moving
supplies, equipment and personnel between existing
The naval service further divides its assault transport duty stations well within Federated Suns territory. As
squadrons into two categories: BattleMech and a general rule of thumb JumpShips operating within
conventional forces. As the categories suggest these one jump of an active combat zone or outside
squadrons are intended to transport certain types of Federated Suns space do so only in squadron
units onto a contested planet. The typical BattleMech formation, with escort, for protection.
assault transport squadron carries a full BattleMech
regiment as well as one or two conventional The Naval Assault Task Forces are the only
companies for support. The typical conventional permanent task forces within the Federated Suns
forces assault transport squadron can carry a Naval Service. Each is built around one of the Naval
combined arms brigade. Services few WarShips. Besides the WarShip itself
each task force includes a supporting JumpShip
General Transport Squadron form the backbone of Squadron, two Naval Escort Squadrons, a Naval
the Naval Services DropShip fleet, moving the Aerospace Fighter Regiment and a battalion strength
majority of the equipment, supplies and personnel Marine contingent. Each Naval Assault Task Force
that are shifted around each year. These squadrons usually also has a tender DropShip assigned to
are made up of a wide variety of cargo and personnel provide maintenance and repair, resupply and
transports, most all of which are built to civilian medical support. Exact composition of each WarShip
standards. task force varies from task force to task force but two
general rules do apply: all JumpShips are lithium-
Although it is avoided when possible, General fusion battery-equipped and the aerospace fighter
Transport Squadrons are used in contested space regiment, at a minimum, consists of three fighter
although only with a strong escort force. General wings, usually spread evenly between the WarShip
transport squadrons commonly bring in the follow-on and the two naval escort squadrons.
forces once a landing zone has been secured to
reinforce the initial assault force. During the Fourth As the size of the Federated Suns WarShip fleet
Succession War several general transport squadrons expands the prestige of the naval service will also
even won battle honors when they brought in the expand, quite possibly to the point that the navy
actual assault force due to the lack of adequate becomes a co-equal service with the regular army.
transport assets. But until that day it will remain a support arm of the
AFFS focused on supporting the ground troops, first
The last DropShip squadron type is the Naval Support and foremost.
Squadron. It is equipped to provide all sorts of
support, such as salvage and repair services, supply Commodore Henri Rollet, FSN
and medical support to other Naval Service assets.
The Review staff would like to congratulate
Commodore Rollet on his recent appointment to
command the Sixteenth Naval Escort Squadron. His
knowledge and skills will be sorely missed at The
Review but are needed more in active service. We
wish him well.

13
A Tribute to Ian Davion Valor. Its such a simple word. Short and unassuming it may be, but it
possesses and conveys a power to all who hear it spoken. Its a word for
which those who embody it live forever in the hearts and minds of those
who survive them. It is a word reserved for those who exceed the
standard that others achieve. Often it comes at great personal sacrifice,
the very offering up of which defines their courageous effort. For others,
such feats seem to spring eternal and often, with accolades seeming to
become clich and gauche about their person.

What is it that makes someone truly valorous, to be worthy of the highest


honors of the land? Is it a birthright? Perhaps in other lands, but not in
the Federated Suns. While those from foreign nations might have a
sense of duty and bravery instilled in them, the very act of indoctrination
they experience in their upbringing negates the notion of valor. Rather, it
is when those who have big plans, great aspirations, and lofty goals who
willfully give up those dreams as just another portion of their sacrifice
that makes them valorous. The nature of these particular aspirations
varies from person to person and is totally dependent upon their unique
circumstances.

For the poor farmer in the Outback, the goal might simply be raising a
large enough crop that his family can survive a harsh winter and perhaps
raise his children healthy and free of pain. For a simple laborer, it could
be the dream of a life of luxury, free of the daily drudgery and the
hardness of her life. For the military inductee, it could be simply the
desire that he and the rest of the unit survive the night under enemy
bombardment. Valor comes to the fore when that individuals personal
dreams no longer matter. When they set aside their own hopes, their
own dreams, their very lives, so that their fellows, or spouses, or
children, or nation, might go on, might survive the depredations of the
enemy, then the valorous show themselves.

Valor is not universal. All militaries of all times and all nations, past,
present and future, have had among them those whose courage failed
them. There will always be those who shy from the enemy, who cower in
their foxhole, who run from the onslaught. But for the rest of us who do
not face the darkness every moment of every day, there will be those
who drive back the night by showing their true mettle. They are the
valorous. They are the people who through their individual sacrifice
ensure that our nation and way of life will never expire, that the night will
never finally fall on the Federated Suns.

The issue of The Review which you currently hold in your hand is
dedicated to one of those valorous individuals. While he was born of
high station and had at his disposal the entirety of the nation, he was
First Prince Ian Davion epitomized proved at his end to be among the best of us that ever lived. First Prince
Ian Davion was a true hero. He was a man who gave of himself the
the best ideals of the Armed Forces ultimate sacrifice. He did this not in search of any accolade, for truly as
the leader of the nation he needed none. He did it not to gain any
of the Federated Suns and the respect or fealty from his men, for he had already earned that many
times over by his magnanimity in living and serving with them, not above
nation that it serves. His loyalty, them. He gave his life that his mens lives might go on, that their time
had not yet come to be extinguished, that he might deny the enemy their
not just to the nation he led, but to prize of defeating his loyal fellow troops. Then, as now, we can mourn
the loss of the valorous. But always remember, they chose to give it,
the peoples of it whom he served, and they would not take it back.

was ever unwavering. Lft. Gen. Richard M. Stockwell (ret.)


Senior Editor
-- Hanse Davion
A Tribute to Ian Davion
Editors note: This article was written in 3063, intended
for publication on the fiftieth anniversary of Prince Ians
Funeral. Due to The Reviews publication hiatus during
the civil war, it is printed now for the first time.

THE FUNERAL OF IAN DAVION

With the many enormous upheavals of the past forty Avalon City. The Procession had reached the site and
years, a tragedy which occurred but a few years earlier the caisson had stopped. The midnight black caparison
is often forgotten. The grand success of the Fourth horse, stirrups holding Ians own boots in reverse, drew
Succession War, the shame of the War of 3039, the to a solemn halt behind, the hilt of a long sword bobbing
shock of the Clan Invasion, the reformation of the Star above the classical English riding saddle. The
League, and the formation and sundering of the pallbearers removed from the caisson their charge and
Federated Commonwealth have each overshadowed the Procession entered: three troops in front and three
the previous historical events which led up to them. It behind the burden borne upon the shoulders of six more
was the death of First Prince Ian Davion which propelled somber-faced individuals. All twelve wore the same
Hanse Davion to power, subsequently resulting in the black dress uniform, unfettered by decorations, citations,
formation of the Federated Commonwealth and so many unit symbols, or rank insignia of any kind: the official
other glories and disgraces. Fifty years ago this month, funeral dress of the Armed Forces of the Federated
newly christened First Prince Hanse Davion laid to rest Suns. Only a small cloisonn on their lapels, indicating
his predecessor, giving homage in a manner which, to their branch of service, was to be seen. Among each
those who might be watching, showcased his own group, pallbearers and honor guard, each branch was
capabilities as a leader. represented only once.

The crowd was hushed that fair spring day outside The unity of all branches of the AFFS was never more
fully demonstrated than at the funeral on that November
day. While most proper AFFS funerals have honor
guards composed of a mix of enlisted troops and
The Symbolism of Six officers, there is often great honor to be found for those
who carry a fallen commander. Though they might have
failed in death to protect their leader, most who serve
The Federated Suns constitution enshrines the under that man or woman prefer to demonstrate that
following Six Liberties: the rights to personal liberty, they serve him or her even after death. To protect ones
fair treatment, privacy, ownership of property, commander along the path to the final rest is the truest
ownership of weapons, and the right to participate in way to show this loyalty. But in the case of this funeral,
planetary government. The symbolism of six that honor was held by every one of the members of the
members in each troupe has always symbolized the honor guard; for the man they were to bury was no foot
soldier, no mere MechWarrior, no Field Marshal, and no
Six Liberties, which every member of the AFFS is
General, but the First Prince of the Federated Suns, Ian
pledged to defend. Six AFFS servicemen carrying the Davion himself.
fallen demonstrates that the Six Liberties support the
fallen in death as they did during life, that the Liberties Prince Ians pallbearers included some members of his
endure and the defenders efforts were not in vain. Fourth Davion Guards RCT, as well as his brother and
The six armed troops of the honor guard signify the successor, the newly crowned First Prince Hanse
Six Liberties protecting the fallen just as the fallen died Davion. Delivering their burden to its destination, the
honor guard formed a protective phalanx interposed
defending the Six Liberties. It is a relationship that can
between the slain First Prince and the gathered
never be segregated, for the Six Liberties and the multitude as the pallbearers took position behind. First
AFFS are symbiotic, one being unable to survive and Prince Hanse then disengaged himself and strode to the
serve the nation without the other. podium to deliver his eulogy. Taken from file footage of
the funeral, the following is a faithfully transcribed
recounting of his address, which he chose to begin with
the traditional opening line for an AFFS funeral.

16
A Tribute to Ian Davion

We are gathered here today to lay to rest a hero of


the Federated Suns. The Importance of Unity
First Prince Ian Davion epitomized the best ideals of the
Armed Forces of the Federated Suns and the nation that The unity of services is paramount.
it serves. His loyalty, not just to the nation he led, but to
the peoples of it whom he served, was ever unwavering. While there are rivalries among the
various service branches - for example
We are gathered today because that duty extended to
the men directly under his command as well. between MechWarriors and infantry or
between aerospace pilots and tank
In every military action, a need to withdraw and regroup
can arise. Sometimes even our remarkable forces can crews - the congregation of all services
be overwhelmed by a numerically larger enemy, forcing in honor of the slain demonstrates the
a strategic retreat. This is what happened when enemy
forces managed to arrive on Mallorys World to support true brotherhood of all AFFS members.
the aggression there against our nation. That all are equal in death is

When Prince Ian realized the nature and number of the demonstrated by the lack of ranks or
enemy, he wisely and correctly ordered a retreat to medals on the official plain black dress
preserve the lives under his charge. As he was ever
one to do first what he might instead order of others, he funeral uniform of the AFFS.
ordered his men ahead while he held the rear against
the enemy. If at all possible, the six members of

It was this bravery, self-sacrifice, and dedication that led each troupe are to be drawn from a
to his death. Along with a few select exceptional separate branch of the AFFS. Thus
volunteers, whose own loyalty to their commander
refused to allow them to leave him behind, our beloved there should be one MechWarrior, one
Prince Ian held off immense numbers of enemy aerospace pilot, one ground vehicle crew
MechWarriors, who without the rearguard effort would
surely have perpetrated a cowardly massacre of the rest member, one infantryman, one member
of our defenders on-world. Singled out, and likely of the Support Services (often a
identified by his prowess and courage, Prince Ian
became the focus of the enemy. He fell, after hideously chaplain), and one member of the AFFS
long and savage combat, to fire from the enemy leader, Navy (a crew member of a DropShip,
Yorinaga Kurita.
JumpShip or WarShip).
That Prince Ians body was recovered is owed to the
extraordinary performance of the Kell Hounds The honor guards and pallbearers are
mercenary regiment. It was the personal effort of that
units commander, Morgan Kell, which drove off the routinely not just a mix of service
craven slayers. For this singular service, I extend to branches, but also a mix between
Morgan Kell not only my personal gratitude, but the
most sincere and respectful appreciation of the entire enlisted troops and officers. It has never
Federated Suns. [At this, Prince Hanse broke with been recorded that any officer refused to
protocol and left the podium. He approached a man
among the gathered crowd in attendance, a man not serve in either capacity for a fallen
outfitted with an AFFS funeral uniform but one of red enlisted troop, nor has any enlisted troop
and blacka uniform, it should be added, that was
similarly and respectfully not adorned with any symbols refused to carry or escort an officer. It is
of rankshook the mans hand and then embraced him. considered a particular honor to carry
Morgan Kell, it was later said, was stunned by the true
personal expression and citation of the new First Prince. ones commanding officer to his or her
Tears were seen to sparkle briefly in Prince Hanses final rest.
eyes as he returned to the podium and resumed his
address.] But our nation is lessened not just by the loss

17
A Tribute to Ian Davion
of such an able and dedicated battlefield commander noiselessness was more ear-numbing than the
and talented MechWarrior. We have lost our leader, our Brobdingnagian expenditure of ordnance had been.
First Prince, my brother, our brother, for he considered
all citizens of the Federated Suns as his family. I can As the salute ended, the body of Prince Ian was lowered
only hope that as I assume the mantle of leadership, I into the hallowed ground of the New Avalon Memorial
might someday be half the leader as was Prince Ian. Cemetery. The gathered multitudes attempted to grasp
Truly I can only succeed him, for none could ever hope what had occurred. Every member of the AFFS on-
to replace him. [So saying, the new First Prince stood world had joined in the honor guard volley to pay
down from the podium and resumed his place amongst respect to the beloved fallen Prince. The true scope of
the pallbearers.] The melancholy notes of Taps the honor salute to Prince Ian, however, only became
mourned through the gathered host. Duke Aaron clear later, and to those who were present it made the
Sandoval of the Draconis March was seen to weep gesture that much more remarkable. For what had
openly and unabashedly, and he was certainly not the awed them at the actual funeral was duplicated in
only one. perfect lockstep, shot for shot, on every world of the
Federated Suns. Every member of all branches of the
Two of the pallbearers removed the resplendent Sword military not involved in active combat simultaneously
and Sunburst flag of the Federated Suns from the plain regardless of the respective sidereal time of the world
wooden casket. Before Taps completed, they had they were oncame to parade ground formation and
folded the flag into a tight triangle with the sword folded fired six shots to honor the fallen First Prince.
entirely within. The Flag was handed to Prince Hanse
who turned smartly and approached his mother, Jennifer It was a display of absolutely unprecedented and
Campbell, where she was seated at the front of the unimaginable military coordination on an inconceivable
crowd. Kneeling before her, he spoke to her in low scale. Prince Hanse, in a display of organizational skill
tones as he held the Flag out to her as reverently as one pulled off with perfect covert aplomb, had demonstrated
would handle the last original copy of the Crucis Pact. the ability of his nations military to perform a heretofore
Though his precise words were unknown, it is believed unheard-of level of coordination. It was a lesson lost on
that he spoke the traditional ceremonial phrase, This his enemies, thankfully, but illustrated the same ability
Flag is presented to you on behalf of the Armed Forces that saw the remarkable conquest of half the Capellan
of the Federated Suns, the First Prince and a grateful Confederation scarcely a decade and a half later.
nation as a symbol of our appreciation for your loved
ones faithful and dedicated service. All our peoples But it is with hindsight that such parallels are drawn. At
mourn your loss, for it is a loss we all share. the time, and to this author even now, it was simply the
manifestation of the absolute love and reverence that
As he finished, Prince Hanse came to parade ground Prince Hanse felt for his brother. He gave to his brother
attention and snapped as smart a salute as any member a unique honor, a salute unmatched in history, the
of the AFFS ever dreamed. He rejoined the pallbearers grandest and most remarkable sendoff ever paid to any
as the honor guard came about and brought their official of any nation. And it was paid to a man who, in
weapons to bear. At precisely 6:00 p.m., New Avalon life, would have refused it. That, in this authors opinion,
time, the six troops in unison took aim and fired the first is the true mark of Prince Ians heroism: that he did not
of their six volleys. But it was not the simple reports of seek fame or repute or notoriety; he was just another
six standard issue service rifles that greeted the ears of soldier, a MechWarrior of great skill to be sure, but
the assembled. Rather, a cacophony of sound so nothing more or less. He died as he lived, fighting for
terrible and magnificent assaulted the ears of everyone the Six Liberties and the one nation that spawned them.
present that, despite the surprise all were too stunned to He died with his boots on, fighting for and alongside his
give voice to any response. Explosions reverberated in men with an enemy in his sights and a curse on his lips.
the distance as aerospace fighter squadrons appeared Would that we could all be so lucky.
in the air like apparitions venting their lasers and
cannon, artillery shells were launched, and BattleMechs The author, Leftenant General Hillnas, served as a
discharged their arsenals, all in perfect unison. And as captain under Prince Ian in the Fourth Davion guards
the six honor guards fired their sixth and final shot in and was among those in attendance at both Prince Ians
salute, so too in perfect synchronicity did the distant and Prince Hanses funerals. General Hillnas came out
guns, Mechs, and cannon all fall silent, the aerospace of retirement to support Prince Victors cause and was
fighters melting invisibly and silently into the atmosphere killed in action during the Civil War. He too died with his
from whence they had sprung. The sudden vacuum of boots on and an enemy in his sights.

18
A Tribute to Ian Davion
Ian's Lament
The namesake held the world,
The heir holds the line. COMMENCEMENT
The enemy breaks through,
When Atlas' pilot is a'dyin'. Very few of the Federated Suns remember the many
things which First Prince Ian Davion did to distinguish
It was with these twenty words that the death of a himself from those who came before him to head our
beloved First Prince was mourned. One would think nation. What many of the readers may not know is that
that the combat death of a First Prince as revered as Ian Davion, soon after he took the reins of power,
Ian Davion would have had more lasting delivered the commencement address at the War
repercussions. Indeed, it seems that the peoples of College of Goshen. It was for the graduating class of
the Federated Suns scarcely recall their fallen 3001, the first of the new millennium. (It was his own
NAMA which had the honor of receiving Prince Ians
leaders within moments of the official burial. Though
address for the Class of 3000.) Following is a transcript
penned by an anonymous writer, the words speak from the WCG archives of the address Prince Ian gave
powerfully to those who understand the context. that day, the last by a First Prince.

First Prince Ian commanded the Fourth Davion My fellow soldiers, please bear with me if I seem
Guards, and he did so from the front. When uncomfortable. I truly do hate to wear the dress
circumstances resulted in the Guards being uniform. I would much rather be in the field, stripped to
the waist in my cockpit and lobbing shells at the enemy!
outflanked by Combine invaders on Mallorys World,
[Applause and laughter follow.]
the First Prince ordered his command company to
pull back from the enemy, while Ian himself All of you have already received your assignments, and
remained behind to delay the Second Sword of soon you will be leaving this fine institution to join
Light. He drew a line in the sand of that canyon another fine institution. For all of you now, and
floor, and he sold his life at a high cost to the enemy. forevermore, are members of the Armed Forces of the
Federated Suns, the AFFS. This is no small thing.
Holding off the larger numbers of enemy all by
While our nation might have the largest military of all the
himself, fending their forces from the controls of his human nations, each and every one who chooses to
Atlas, he refused to budge. It was only moments serve is of the finest character and ability. And you who
before reinforcements arrived in the form of the Kell persevere and complete Academy training are the
Hounds, under the command of Morgan Kell himself, cream of that already fine crop.
that the First Prince was struck down by Draconian
weapons. But do not let your stature as academy graduates go to
your head! I, too, graduated from an academy, but it
was the veterans whom I met after joining the Guards
Though he surely would have enjoyed life had it who gave me my real education. The sergeants who
continued on, it can truly be said that First Prince Ian have seen and done it all; the senior officers who are so
was among the minority of the line of his forebears cool under fire; even the buck privates whose mistakes
who saw their charges escape the grip of oppression remind you of your own, making it easier to teach them
before his light was extinguished. While it did not how not to err again. Be proud, but be humble as well.
end the Succession Wars, the love that the First You have earned the respect of your fellow cadets and
your instructors, but you have to start all over with those
Prince held for all his people was evident in the
of your new units. Remember that you must earn their
sacrifice he made to ensure that his troops survived respect as well, and the first step in that journey is to
to fight the Dragon another day. In so doing, First give them yours.
Prince Ian Davion displayed the ultimate to which
someone of his office might aspire: to do no less for The one truth you must all remember is this: when battle
his people than what he asked from them. That he comes, as it always seems to, it is the man or woman
is not celebrated as other First Princes are beside you who must follow your lead. You cannot
expect them to charge ahead of you and absorb the fire
recognized testifies only to his short reign and not directed at you. No, what you must do is be willing to
his true abilities. One might only wonder at the make the sacrifice that will allow your men to carry on
further greatness such a self-sacrificing First Prince and ensure victory over the enemy. I am not urging
of the people as Ian Davion might have reached. anyone to give their life needlessly. What I am saying is
that your life is no more important than that of your

19
A Tribute to Ian Davion
fellows, and you must remember that. For if you expect I know not whether I am such a leader, though I strive
them to give their lives for you, but you are unwilling to every day to be one. However, may all those under my
give your life for them, you might be rudely surprised. commandand as First Prince, that is pretty much all of
you [laughter from crowd]may you all know this: I will
It is a true leader who knows that he has instilled in his never allow others to die if my own life would be the cost
charges the proper training that should he die in their to preserve theirs. Every one of you and all the peoples
defense, they will not be laid low by his death but can of the Federated Suns are my charges, and my life is
continue on and complete the deed he began. It is the paltry in comparison. I hope that, as you all move on to
true leader who knows his men by their names and your new assignments, none of you have to make such
shies not from associating with them. It is the true a declaration, but I can trust that all of you would
leader who knows that his life is a small price to pay to willingly do so. Because you are now members of that
ensure that his mens lives go on. It is this type of greatest of societies, the AFFS.
leader who need not hope that his men would make the
same sacrifice for him; rather, he trusts it, he knows it. Thank you. [Applause]
It is this leader who knows that his men would sacrifice
themselves for each other following his example, so that It was on the 28th day of October in the year of Our Lord
fewer will die, exacting as large a price from the enemy 3013 that First Prince Ian Davion proved to the entirety
as they might before completing the journey to Heavens of humanity that his words were not mere hyperbole
Gate. that he was, indeed, a true leader.

Sensor Failure on Mallorys World?


A comprehensive review of the sensor logs from the BattleMechs of the Fourth Davion Guards which were present at
the battle in which First Prince Ian Davion was killed demonstrated a uniformly unusual defect. In every case, the
logs show the First Princes contact disappearing from detection some time before the fatal shot from Yorinaga
Kurita.

In order to analyze the last battle of Ian Davion completely, interviews were conducted with those of the Fourth
Davion Guards at the time who were still alive and could be reached. The timeline of the battle was defined and
consistent even after more than fifty years with the accounts at the time. The Guards were retreating in order to
regroup. Caught in a narrow defile, only one Mech could pass at a time. In a show of courage and self-sacrifice, the
First Prince ordered his men ahead so that he might stave off the pursuers. Comparison of this data with the sensor
logs from the AFFS Record Archive showed agreement to this point. However, it was at this point that the First
Princes Mech suddenly disappeared from the scanners of all those present. Visual logs were not preserved, and the
canyon in question is known not to possess deposits of minerals which might have interfered with sensors.

During this time, the First Prince was said to have fought and defeated no less than four enemy Mechs. Given the
narrow confines of the canyon, it seems inconceivable that he absorbed such little enemy fire as to continue strongly.
Yet every statement of the event clearly indicates that the First Princes Mech was in no worse condition when they
retrieved his body as before his comrades escaped, aside from the head damage which killed him. The only
conclusion is that the First Prince managed to evade all incoming fire from his enemies for quite some time while at
the same time disappearing from sensors.

Compounding the mystery is another finding. The Kell Hounds had been doggedly moving to support and relieve the
Guards. The Hounds communicated their position as they neared the Guards, to prevent any friendly fire incidents.
As the word was relayed over the open Guards communication channel, the contact from the First Princes Mech
uniformly reappeared on all sensors within range. Within moments, the fatal shot was fired by Yorinaga Kurita,
whoaccording to the sensor logshad been discharging his Warhammers weapons steadily at no apparent target.

The disappearance and reappearance of the First Prince from Mech sensors were also evident in the logs of DCMS
Mechs salvaged once the Kell Hound relief had driven off the Combine force. A request made to the Draconis
Combine for corroboration received no reply. The Kell Hounds were willing to share information, but none of the
Mechs involved were still in service to the unit and the units logs of the event had been classified by Morgan Kell.
Rumors of similar circumstances have surfaced through the years regarding Kells own uncanny knack to evade his
enemies. Knowing this, an attempt was made to contact him directly regarding this mystery. A terse communiqu
from Kell himself in response to the information request noted that Ian Davion was a true man of honor. A fine

20
A Tribute to Ian Davion
MechWarrior and courageous leader, he exemplified the best of humanity. I hope in his judgment I put to good use
the lessons I learned from him.

Was it some lost technology that allowed Prince Ian to dodge Mech sensors as well as enemy weapons? If so, it
was apparently lost with him. Or was it? Might the means to such have been taken as salvage by Morgan Kell? This
is considered unlikely, given the universal reputation for honorable conduct by the man. This leaves but one
explanation, which generates only more questions. That Prince Ian disappeared from Mech sensors is clear from the
evidence, but the means with which he accomplished the feat seem destined to remain unexplained.

Editors Note: It is rare that a WCG student publishes in The Review, but a senior project investigating supposed
inconsistencies in sensor logs during the battle in which First Prince Ian Davion was killed came to our attention. The
reader is left to his or her own devices in interpreting the data. Cadet Marina Vasquez condensed her dissertation
into the summary presented here.

21
Know Thy Enemy

With the renewed focus on the Capellan design could retain 100% combat effectiveness even
Confederation Armed Forces after the debacle of the with nearly 40% engine shielding degradation due to
3057-58 war and the near-disintegration of AFFC/S damage; even at close to 70% shielding degradation,
units facing them, the first scholarly examinations of the heat levels remained easily manageable. Those
the CCAF in nearly thirty years were initiated under who underestimated the Vindicators utility sometimes
the aegis of the retired (and now deceased) Field came to regret it. Hauptmann General Mitchell
Marshall Ran Felsner and various military think tanks. Weintraub, formerly of the 8th FedCom RCT, was
It soon became apparent that there were (at the time) famously ejected from Second Try in 3057 by
two distinct periods of Capellan Mech design, known Capellan forces equipped for the most part with the
jejunely as First and Second Period designs; the lowly Vindicator. Though woefully outmatched by
former a relic of the days of Romano Liao and her such Davion designs as the Enforcer, Shadowhawk
Not a step backwards orders, and the latter a and Griffin, the Vindicators on Second Try absorbed
product of the so-called Xin Sheng movement with a inbound fire that would have crippled those designs.
greater emphasis on speed and maneuverability. By contrast, the Davion equipment lost included two
With the later development of Stealth Armor analysts Rakshasas, top-of-the-line machines with a price to
noticed a new trend, the Third Periodalthough it is match at 18.9 million C-bills apiece. With the cost of
in reality an adjunct to either of the earlier styles. This the Vindicator a modest 3.5 million C-bills, a FedCom
document concerns itself primarily with the First force would have to destroy eleven Vindicators for
Period. every two Rakshasas lost simply to even the bill; a kill
ratio of 11:2 has rarely been achieved in any modern
The First Period of Capellan design is one of slower, war, excluding the Clan Invasion. The Vindicator was
heavily armed units that can hold ground or keep up a made with just such an attritional conflict in mind.
steady, well-supported advance. This is most suited Despite unspectacular performance, its low cost and
to heavier designs, as light Mechs and some of the durability mean that against Davion machines it can
smaller medium Mechs cannot be expected to do often cause more losses to the enemy than to itself by
much more than die valiantly when tied to one fighting to the bitter end. This explains the Mechs
location. Therefore, the principal function of Capellan low speed in a rational if frightening manner: the
light machines, or indeed any rapid-moving machine, Vindicator is most effective when its pilot has no hope
is to act as a harassing force, being not tied down to a of orderly retreat.
location and thus capable of receiving aid from
heavier machines in a short period of time; or failing All the effort of the light and medium Mechs would be
that, making behind the lines raids on the enemys in vain for the First Period force were it not for the
rear an attractive proposition. One such design is the heavy Mechs of the CCAF. The Cataphract is a
CCAFs Raven BattleMech. The Raven is in many departure from form for the parsimonious CCAF of the
ways a flagship Mech of the First Period of Capellan 3050s. It costs nearly 15.4 million C-Bills, and is
military development: it relies on heavier designs in unimpressively protected by modern standards (in
prepared defensive positions to provide the real fairness, the contemporary F-C Caesar, derived from
firepower, and its purpose is to make life miserable for the Cataphract, is even less well protected). It lacks a
an invading force with its Narc pod and TAG. The big gun with a serious knock-out punch, relying on
offensive punch resides with the other, heavier, an ER PPC and an LB-10X autocannonsolid
Mechs in its company: Vindicators, Cataphracts, and weapons to be sure, but the expense of their delivery
Catapults. systems almost fails to justify their deployment. The
MASC system offers some improvement over the
The paradigmatic Capellan medium machine is the standard movement curve for the weight class, but
Vindicator. For many years one of the few Mechs still the Mech would have benefited much more from the
produced within the Confederation, it served double- incorporation of jump jets, allowing it to maneuver
and triple-duty in roles that it was never intended to with the Vindicator in any terrain; for a long time, this
fill, such as operating as a makeshift heavy Mech in choice was utterly inexplicable. When viewed in light
spearheading attacks, leading light lances, defending of what we now know of CCAF doctrine during the
fixed positions and fighting in dense urban areas or period of its inception, however, the picture becomes
on gently rolling savannah. Its pilots often found their clearer. The heavy units of the CCAF were in fact
machine outmatched by more specialized designs. discouraged from maneuvering to engage enemy
As a generalist, however, the Vindicator is difficult to forces; bitter experience with precision AFFS combat
top. It ran cool in the days when most Mechs ran hot drops during the Fourth Succession War, wherein
as a matter of course, and the initial upgrade kits Capellan units were isolated and destroyed, had
carried this to an extreme; AFFC analysis of several convinced the demoralized Liao forces that it was not
nearly-intact 3L-series Vindicators turned over to the a viable strategy to react to enemy movements; they
NAIS by Wolfs Dragoons in early 3053 indicated the determined, rather, that they should instead focus on

22
Know Thy Enemy
defending important objectives with the full strength of
a command (this in fact bears some similarities with
the Lyran concept of materialschlact, and may have
been inspired by that technique, although it must be
emphasized that the materialschlact is an offensive
concept, as opposed to a static one). In the minds of
the Cataphracts designers, jump jets would have only
encouraged pilots to leave their fortifications. MASC,
on the other hand, could be engaged for the critical
phase of a counterattack to recover lost ground,
where out-and-out ground speed was essential in
reaching optimum weapons range. To defend against
more maneuverable Mechs the designers contented
themselves with adding rear-firing lasers that would
have been out of place on a Mech ten tons heavier.
Conceived just after an infusion of Free Worlds
League monies in exchange for the then-flawed
Triple-Strength Myomer, the Cataphract upgrade was
intended as a showpiece design (as it had been in
3027). No expense was spared to produce a design
which was generally regarded as a failure; this
eventually resulted in the newer and radically different
CTF-4L, which corrected almost all of the flaws of the
design and is in many ways a truer expression of a
First Period design, despite being a product of the so-
called Third Period.

First Period Capellan designs were typified by a


reluctance to rely on maneuver warfarea
questionable choice given that speed often acts as a
force multiplier and AFFC/S units tended to
outnumber their Capellan foes thanks to the organic
armor, infantry, and aerospace support fielded by a
full-strength Regimental Combat Team. The primary
goal of a Capellan unit from this period was to engage
the enemy in such a manner as to make the cost of
final victory prohibitively high. Changes came with
the Second and Third Periods of Capellan design, but
Capellan design philosophy remained (and largely
remains) reactive to Davion advancements both real
and perceived. Review of documents concerning the
Second and Third Periods is underway, and despite
the current truce it seems certain that we will again
face Capellan equipment on the battlefield.
Continued study of our ancient foe is the best
preparation we can make.

Leftenant Colonel Yves Fitzgerald (GCW '49)


coordinated with the MIIO's Foreign War Material
Analysis Commission to produce the highly regarded
3060 edition of the Threat Book.

23
The Wages of Sin
To be a soldier is to be a businessman; the soldier is, balance the accounts of the lives they have taken, kill
at heart, a merchant in the grim business of death. themselves, be it to escape or to devise some final bit
Everythingthe defense of civilians, upholding of fairness from the exchange.
national honor, rebuilding in the wake of a disaster
is secondary to the soldier's ability to do mighty and Those best suited to the actual task of killing
irrevocable harm to his designated enemy. The proficiently and in quantity are those we are least
human heart is uplifted when members of the military inclined to make soldiers. The sociopath, the sadist,
flock to the scene of a flooded city bearing aid and the berserkerthose to whom killing is most natural
relief for the beleaguered populace, but such gestures and who are immune to any emotional ramifications of
do not a soldier make. Any significant civilian group their actions. They are also those most inclined to
with time, inclination, and organization, can bring depart from the focus of the soldierthe killing of his
together such an effort of relief and mercy. A soldier sovereign's enemiesand into killing for self-
who is building up homes in a disaster area while his gratification or self-advance. These are poor soldiers,
comrades fight and die for the sake of their mission is least controllable and most prone to the breakdown of
useless as regards his stated profession. Aspirations any sensible military plan or discipline. I can hold up
to noble purpose and assertions of higher callings are no finer example of this than the Clans. Fearsome
well and good, but let honesty rule the day and call a combatants they may be, but time and time again
spade a spadethe ultimate and defining purpose of have they been brought to the altar of war and made
the soldier is to bring death to the enemies of his to pay the price in blood. Tukayyid, Port Arthur,
sworn sovereign, be that ruler a cause, ideal, a lover, Coventry, Strana Mechty; accounts tallied, costs
or the nation of his birth. exacted; lesson taught but never learned. It is not to
these we can reasonably entrust our safety as
The death trade of a soldier citizens and soldiers, but
is a costly and demanding rather to the stable, the
market. Every business caring, the controlled. But it
requires investment capital, is these, the good and noble
and the soldier provides the of society, who will be most
most potent capital of all: his burdened by the grim
life. He wagers on the ability soldier's task. The good
of his life to reap a profit by man's conscience will
impacting the battle around struggle with the death he
him, the reward being varied brings to the world,
and oft intangible, and the regardless of noble cause or
method being uniquely sacrificial gesture.
uncompromising. Yes, it is
most often that the victors of I landed with the Heavy
a fight take more prisoners Guards on New Avalon. I
than they kill. This, however, would not be the case fought for that precious,
had those victors not come to the battle fully prepared glorious jewel of this nation with every fiber of my
to give out death to their opponents. No soldier in his being. I went into battle fully aware of what I was
right mind would surrender to an enemy comparable there to do; I was there to kill. During a combat drop
in arms to himself yet unwilling to actually do him behind Loyalist lines, in which we were attempting to
harm. Every soldier must enter the battlefield secure an airfield, my lance was supported by
prepared to kill, and must turn that determination into Leftenant Percy Doyle's lance. That was the whole
actual, ugly, bloody, disgusting killing. remaining force of Echo company; our third lance had
been lost in the days preceding this engagement.
There is a high cost to this investment. The emotional The fight for the airstrip was as brutal as any other
effects of killing another human being can be battle of the war. I lost two of my best friends,
devastating, even to the prepared. The psychology of Sergeants Dwayne Courrier and Dannica Belarys, in
the matter has been exceedingly well documented that fight. We ended a total of sixty-seven human
from the time of the Great Wars of the late 20th lives in various vehicles and Mechs, and twice that in
Century. Veterans of countless campaigns and unarmored, unaugmented infantry before our
engagements reach a point, seemingly without reinforcements arrived and the remnant surrendered.
warning, where it is literally impossible for them to After the fight, we had exited our Mechs while combat
raise their weapons and continue in the soldier's repairs were being enacted, and I found Lft. Doyle
craft. Some return to life and establish a semblance digging graves for the men we'd killed. Not our men,
of normalcy; others shamble on through existence our enemies. "I can't leave them like this, Captain,"
hollow and haunted wrecks, retaining only the barest he told me. "I can't bear the thought of telling another
shape of humanity. Some, seeing no other way to mother I left her son out in the rain after I killed him."

24
The Wages of Sin
Doyle had never actually told any mother any such at least one of this graduating class will go on to
thing. But the image, the thought that he may become, at the very least, a Colonel in a major
someday have to do that, however unlikely, had Regiment of this military. It will be your duty to take
seized this incredibly professional, dedicated soldier these decent, human souls, and commit them to the
around the heart, and would not let go. Doyle was a grim task of destroying other decent, human souls
man not prone to sentiment. He despised my who happen to be the enemies of this nation. You
unofficial status as Battalion Chaplain, discounted any cannot avoid this responsibility, and I pray you never
religious beliefs out of hand, and was least likely of flinch from it. Indeed, you must make this transaction,
any in the unit to participate in the Regiment's sacrificing the consciences of the few in the pursuit of
traditions. Yet here he was, desperately searching for the rewards our bloody craft entails. We are soldiers,
a tiny fragment of peace to assuage the mental our purpose is to kill. However, we kill and do these
demands of his hateful craft. In the end, we disposed things out of loyalty to the Freedoms of this nation,
of their remains as much in line with proper AFFS the Rulers of this nation, and the People of this
procedure, treating these fellows of our nations nation. The reward we seek is the protection of all
military with the respect they deserved regardless of these things, and it is a good reward to seek. But
their side in the conflict. seek it knowing the cost you and others will pay. Give
our enemies the full measure of death, gentlemen,
This, future members of the Armed Forces of the and may God be lenient in accounting the cost to your
Federated Suns, is the high cost of war. Statistically, souls.

Captain Isaiah M. Rosner (ret.) is a Professor of


Military Philosophy at the War College of Goshen. A
cum laude graduate and alumnus of the College, he
currently teaches the 400 level course Ethics of
Wartime Command from which this lecture was taken.

25
In Pursuit of the Hound
Though his reign was brief, First Prince Ian Davions hold the 1FSACR raiders in awe, dubbing them
influence upon the Federated Suns can still be felt. Green Demons.
Known as the Hound, rather than following a trail, he
in fact blazed one. Perhaps his most enduring legacy Revons at times appeared almost to feel guilty for the
has been the pursuit of a strategy of aggressive ease with which he took his booty. On one occasion
raiding against the Capellan Confederation and the he raided storehouses of raw grain but left untouched
creation of a specialized regiment to execute that a nearby harvest of tobacco, apparently judging the
strategy, the First Federated Suns Armored Cavalry deprivation of the Capellan solders tobacco ration an
Regiment (1FSACR). The goals of this strategy were unnecessary cruelty. Later he habitually left civilian
threefold: to relieve the chronic supply problem in the wares and foodstuffs untouched, even though he
Capellan March, to force Capellan units to adopt a knew that the CCAF routinely re-appropriated civilian
defensive posture, and to soften up the property for military use. He explained to his men that
Confederation for eventual invasion. The 1FSACR one day the Capellan civilians would be brought
succeeded brilliantly at all three, and despite under the banner of the Federated Suns and that it
operating under the cover of official secrecy the unit would do no good to starve them in the meantime. It
quickly became famous throughout the Federated must have impressed (or perhaps confused) Capellan
Suns for its raiding prowess. The units success civilians to be treated more generously by an invader
prompted the development of new Mech designs than by their own government, which parsimoniously
well-suited to its style of combat and inspired other rationed out the most mundane of goods.
units of the AFFS to train maneuvers first developed
under Col. Todd Revons, first commanding officer of The effect of these raids upon the CCAF was
the 1FSACR. enormous. Having failed to catch Federated Suns
raiders time and again, orders came down from the
A peculiarity of Liao economic policy makes raiding Strategoi to stop giving chase. The Capellan strategy
the Confederation particularly fruitful. Capellan became one of indomitable defense, a strategy not
collectivism ensures that warehouses are always fed dissimilar to Lyran Concentrated Weakness in which
first; that is, supplies often remain in inventory rather only the most important sites on a world would be
than being deployed where needed because of defended. In practice, CCAF commanders often felt
political pressure on the military (and civilian) more inclined to protect their own hardware than to
economy. Ian Davion predicted that weaknesses defend their cities and storehouses, so indomitable
inherent to the Capellan political system would cause defense came to mean ordering ones forces to a
his adversaries to make poor decisions on and off the defensible spot and staying put, effectively giving the
battlefield. Politics is the eternal hobgoblin of the invader free rein over nearly the entire planet.
Capellan military, constantly twisting the proper
coordination of the armed forces. Politics influences The apparent ease with which the 1FSACR raided the
the distribution of goods of every sort, so that Capellan Confederation helped give the CCAF its
strategically vital but politically insignificant worlds are reputation for incompetence throughout the Inner
chronically late in their munitions and rations, even Spherea perception which became a potent
their mail. This damages troop morale and combat weapon. Divided and demoralized, the CCAF began
readiness beyond the dint of any propaganda to to resemble penned sheep encircled by wolves. The
repair. people of the Confederation came to doubt the armys
ability and even its desire to protect anything but their
Shortly after Prince Ians new regiment was own personnel and equipment. Traditional Capellan
unleashed upon the Confederation a new bounty of veneration of the CCAF yielded to contempt and
Capellan goods ranging from short-range missiles to resentment, even among the soldiers themselves.
MREs began to appear in AFFS supply chains. Vitae The ruling Liaos and Strategoi on Sian continued their
magazine photographed for its cover in June 3026 a dreamy paper-war in which every catastrophe was
humorous scene of Federated Suns infantrymen viewed as a minor setback and House Liao was
puzzling over instructions printed in Hanyu on a always just one well-planned counter-offensive away
packet of freeze-dried pork noodles. Indeed, new from a dramatic reversal of fortune. Meanwhile even
manuals had to be printed and distributed throughout the well-indoctrinated soldiers on the Davion front
the AFFS to deal with the sudden influx of Capellan could not help but notice that they had effectively lost
booty. Col. Revons came to regard the Confederation control of their border. Davion farm boys were
as his own personal storehouse and he took to raiding tromping about unchallenged while the Capellan
it for everything his unit needed, often neglecting MechWarrior hid in his stronghold worrying that if the
entirely to requisition basic supplies through normal invaders came too close he would have to fire his
AFFS channels. The raids were brazen and autocannon and afterward file a report justifying the
demoralizing to Capellan defenders, who began to expenditure of the shell. Capellan officers at this time
routinely received contradictory orders such as to

26
In Pursuit of the Hound
protect equipment at all costs, and to engage
invaders wherever possible, and not to budge from a
strategic position. House Liao has never lacked for
brave soldiers and capable officers, but hampered as
it was by inferior equipment and a broken command
structure the CCAF could only watch itself deteriorate
under relentless pressure from House Davion. By the
time Hanse Davion launched Operation Rat the
Confederation was set up for complete collapse.

Because he lived, and because he presided over the


4th Succession War, Hanse Davion received the
credit for that wars success. His predecessors
significant contribution to that success should be
remembered as well. Raiding has been de-
emphasized in the decades since the 4th Succession
War; a raiding campaign nowadays is likely to be
seen as an alternative rather than a precursor to a
campaign of seizing and holding territory. The
1FSACR has remained one of the Federated Suns
most important and most decorated units, particularly
in operations against the Clans, but with the collapse
of the Sarna March and the loss of Tikonov the AFFS
High Command has concerned itself chiefly with
maintaining supply lines and stamping out guerilla
activities. The tremendous gains into Capellan
territory have had this drawback: worlds we hold are
worlds we can no longer raid for supplies. Instead we
have to defend these worlds against infiltrators who
know the ground as well asor better thanwe.

It was once thought that the 1FSACR represented the


future of the AFFS. However, efforts to duplicate the
1FSACRs formula for success among other units
have gone nowhere. With its high rate of attrition and
retirement the 1FSACR itself must continuously draw
veteran MechWarriors from other units to fill its ranks;
in the words of current commander Gen. Rudolph
Chapman it tends to chew up and spit out old
MechWarriors due to its mission profile. An army of
naught but armored cavalry units would wear itself out
if forced to fight a protracted war. The near-
annihilation of the Confederation shook the Strategoi
out of their torpor. Better strategies and faster
designs are evening out what was once a one-sided
struggle between the Great Houses, and it is unlikely
a raiding campaign today could have the unqualified
success of the 1FSACR in times past. Even so, it is
time the raiding campaign got a second look. With
Capellans once again feeling their oats and causing
us headaches on the worlds of the former Tikonov
Commonality, it is high time they were reminded what
happens when Davion neighbors come calling. It is
time to follow the trail blazed by the Hound.

Subaltern Hedwig Kirchherr, Marlette Crucis March


Militia

27
The Acme of Warfare

On 24 October, 3029, Morgan Hasek-Davion individuals for the routine tasks that are required of
captured a Capellan Death Commando DropShip him or her. Unfortunately, advanced tactical training
intent on destroying the ship-making capabilities of is quite specialized and very time consuming, so is
the Federated Suns. Morgan had a small force of not covered sufficiently during most academy training.
Mechs with which he successfully defended the It is essential that all raid team personnel receive
planet Kathil. After the brief, bloody battle, he loaded specialized tactical training and an in-depth course in
up a reinforced Mech company for a quick trip to raid planning and execution.
Sian, the capital of the Capellan Confederation. His
goal: to extract a Davion MIIO agent who had been PLANNING The planning phase of a raid will have a
compromised. He was able to sneak into Liao space direct effect on the potential for success. Well
utilizing the IFF signal from the captured DropShip. planned and documented raids have a higher
He deployed a smoke screen and his troops probability of success. For example, the Halstead
performed a combat drop right in the middle of a Liao Station raid, led by Hanse Davion, was in the planning
parade ceremony. After several minutes of fierce process for a little over a year. It was a very difficult
fighting, the agent was recovered and Hasek-Davions target with the amount of forces arrayed against the
troops were loaded back onto their captured DropShip Federated Suns but it was successful due to the
and headed for friendly space. This is a perfect amount of planning that took place before the
example of a raid. execution phase. The plan should identify the target,
and give a complete description of the terrain and a
The term raid conjures up many different mental complete inventory of equipment and logistical needs.
images depending on personal background and It should also assign individual duties to raid
experience. For most personnel, designate team
military men and women, it leaders and give some
could represent a wide background on the target to
variety of green role be hit. Usually, a target is
missions, from sabotage to identified and must be hit.
prisoner snatches; or black Standard tactics begin with
role special operations from the planning stage. How
counter terrorism to much firepower will we
interstellar hostage rescue. need? Will we need to carry
off items? What types of
Since the dawn of warfare, units will we need? Are
the raid has been an integral there civilians in the area?
part of most sound military What type of terrain will we
strategies. In our recent have to deal with? Are there
past we have seen some any special considerations
very successful raids carried out. The most famous is for the local atmospheric conditions? All these
Morgan Hasek-Davions afore-mentioned rescue questions must be answered before any troops hit the
mission on Sian. During the Succession Wars, as ground.
technology declined, the ability to produce fresh water
became a vital source for a planets well being. Thus, PREPARATION Preparation begins long before the
the water raid was resurrected from ancient times raid with surveillance of the target. An advance site
when nomadic tribesmen would fight over water sites survey of the location determines available avenues
in the desert terrain of ancient Terra. Raids can also of approach and withdrawal and aids in selection of
act as diversions to put pressure on an attacking force the proper number of qualified personnel and team
and make them withdraw from their primary mission in leaders. Preparation also includes the selection of
order to defend themselves. During our recent civil the pre-raid assembly point. Also of importance is the
war, we saw several displays of this. The most study of the site survey, maps, charts, photos,
notable was during the Jade Falcon Incursion. diagrams and other available documents. Individual
General Archer Christofori took his Avengers into tasks must be assigned. Who will make the entry or
Jade Falcon space and began raiding their worlds in initial contact; who will remain on security/support;
an effort to make the Jade Falcons halt their attacks who will escort the prisoners/cargo? These are some
into the Lyran Alliance. of the questions to be addressed before any raid can
be attempted with any hope of success.
The key elements of the raid are as follows:
INTELLIGENCE Good intelligence, like planning, is
TRAINING Basic training at any military academy or critical to the success of a raid. Intelligence collection
advanced individual training will prepare most may start several hours before a raid or several

28
The Acme of Warfare
months, and can be divided into two primary and tasks must be kept simple and described in a
categories: Information about the target and its clear and concise manner. The raid plan may be
location. In some cases, you will never have all the complex but it should not be complicated. Complex
intelligence about a target that you desire. Is it better raid plans can work smoothly if individual tasks are
to conduct this raid with minimal intelligence and kept simple and well synchronized. Simplicity will
possibly accomplish your mission? Or should you breed confidence in any plan.
wait for all available intelligence and possibly miss
your opportunity? You must weigh your alternatives. The planetary raid is a tactic that has fallen by the
wayside of the more pressing planetary assault or
COORDINATION A raid is a complex operation invasion. Most military commanders think that if you
broken down into a series of manageable are going to the trouble of moving hundreds of tons of
components. Without coordination, a raid becomes equipment and spending millions of C-bills in
sluggish, clumsy, disjointed, unprofessional and transportation, fuel and equipment costs, you might
potentially dangerous. as well go the extra mile and just invade the bloody
planet. But those commanders are not fully cognizant
Everyone must know: of the effect a raid has on morale, both national and
militarily. Showing the enemy you have the capability
What organizations are involved to conduct a raid of his resources can be of immense
Individual duties before, during and after the raid strategic value. Not knowing when an enemy will
Team/Unit assignments strike puts citizens and troops alike on edge, waiting
The final briefing location for that first burst of gunfire. If troops spend too much
Radio frequencies, codes and call signs time living on that edge, living with that fear of the
Timings for transportation, communication and unknown, it saps their strength making them even
execution
more vulnerable and susceptible to the light we
Davions are working to shed on all mankind.
EXECUTION There are three factors to consider in
executing a successful raid: Speed Surprise
Simplicity. Raids are not single step activities but
Maj. Benjamin F. Marion, Class of 57
must be well organized and orchestrated. The initial
moments are critical and success may depend on the
time it takes to get total control of the situation.
Movement must be swift or targets will have time to
run or to destroy/sabotage the goods/valuables you
have come for; members of the raiding party will face
increased resistance as the enemy has more time to
organize and the raid may fail.

The element of surprise may come from the use of


ruses, distractions and diversionary operations, and
the tried and true method of attacking at night. It may
also require a pre-raid assembly point, covert
insertion hours or days in advance, and rapid
movement on a secure communications net. Surprise
is also dependent on operational security, so
dissemination of pre-raid information should be on a
need-to-know basis only. Select only trusted
personnel who will work to prevent the leak of dates,
times and places. If security is compromised and
surprise cannot be achieved, the raid may have to be
aborted. During the Marik Civil War, Wolfs Dragoons
forces staged an assault against Anton Mariks
fortress on New Delos. The main attack was a
diversion from the small raiding force, led by Captain
Natasha Kerensky, which infiltrated to the rear of the
fortress, battered their way inside, surprising the
defenders and killing Anton Marik.

Simplicity is also an important factor that will


contribute to the success of the raid. Individual duties

29
The Continuing Cost of War
The High Command has recently noted a tragic carry forever the burden of their actions.
aftereffect of the Civil War. Across the whole of the
Federated Suns, veterans of the war are turning down It is this heaviest of burdens, the inescapable guilt
that darkest of paths. As is typical of any major and regret that caused a black despair which no drink
conflict, the toll taken upon the survivors is more than or fix can salve. Instead, these bravest of men and
physical; it is also psychological. This leads many to women, these heroes of epic quality, these people
self-abusive lifestyles. who in order to preserve the Six Liberties for all their
brethren willingly forego those freedoms to serve the
Drug addiction and alcoholism are common enemies State and its peoplesand make no mistake, they
which are often tolerated. Many sanctioned are truly the best and greatest of us allhave sought
treatments for post-traumatic stress syndrome include solace in the worst imaginable place.
anti-depressant medication, but the embarrassment of
many professional warriors to any admission of Our Nation is currently beset as never before. Truly
weakness prevents the self-identification and quest credible and hostile forces are poised on all borders,
for aid that might lead to one of the many safe and forcing our depleted and war-weary Armed Forces to
legal non-addictive treatments available despite the maintain a high level of alert. That our veterans have
confidential nature of treatment. The bottle at the had no stand-down time to convalesce and attempt to
corner pub or the pills from the local dealer are come to terms with their actions, and that they know
quicker fixes; however, with the dawn comes not only they likely will soon be called upon again to perform
the hangover and the come-down but also the return the same actions which slaughtered their fellows so
of the memories of blood and guts and killing and recently, has left many with the belief that only one
death. avenue of escape remains to them. The
inescapability of their situation has led a great number
Addictions, however, despite their proliferation, are of our troops, members of the finest military force in
not the plague of which I write. No, I am writing about human history, with no resort but to take their own
that shortest of all the dark paths taken by those lives. Usually when our troops returned home from
whose psyches are so damaged by experiences too war, it was a leave-taking of another realm. But now
horrendous to relate to those who were not party to there is no return, for it was in their own home where
them. Even the most graphic news coverage cannot our troops fought, and against their own family at that.
convey the horror that was visited upon our troops. We all shared the horror and bear with us forever the
This conflict was the worst in our history. It is not recollections of targeting our own and firing our
simply because nearly every shot was fired within our weapons at them in anger.
own borders; it is not just because of the increasing
body count, as many wounded in battle are This interminable guilt is felt by those on both sides of
succumbing only now to death; it is not just because the conflict, do not doubt; but together, just as we are
of the unprecedented scale of the conflict. Make no once again whole, we can begin to heal. Seek out the
mistake: this was a war that needed to be fought. But company of your fellows, your chaplain, your
for those tasked with the actual fighting, regardless of commander, or your unit medics and surgeons.
which faction they supported, there could be no true Those who claim that our greatness will be shown by
victory. There could only be losers, for the enemy how well we were able to kill our own will learn that
upon whom they fired were their own brothers and our greatness will truly be demonstrated by how well
sisters. we are able to heal our own. That is the true measure
of a hero, a nation, and a people, and none are
Much is said about the quality of our military, and with greater than the Federated Suns and those who
good reason. There are some who would try to seek defend it. Yes, the mission will never end, for we
some positive aspect of this conflict in the belief that it shall always need defenders against the forces of
was only because we were facing our own brethren tyranny and oppression. What we do not need is for
that our forces were devastated to a degree that our our own to aid those enemies unwittingly by
many ancestral enemies could never have hoped to weakening our defense by our own actions.
realize. However, these people are oblivious to the
true nature of the situation. Yes, the toll taken in this Major Brothers is Chaplain of the War College of
conflict was egregious, and it was wrought by our own Goshen, a post he has occupied faithfully in all ways
hands, but those who worked this horror upon their since 3053. He joined the faculty as Deputy Chaplain
own, whatever their motivation or justification, have to in 3044.

30
Credits:
Overall Concept/Content Editing: Jonathan B. Andrus (MadDogMaddux)
Original Design and Logo: Chris Thompson (TeamNutmeg)
Cover, Insert and other Graphics: Ken Nabors (Yuri Hikado)
Text Editor: Geoff Swift, PhD (97Jedi)
Layout: Tobias Francis

Authors:
Thomas J. Jackson: Jonathan B. Andrus (MadDogMaddux)
Morgan Defire, Iyer A. S., Fr. F. Thomassi: Tobias Francis
G. Kincaid: Geoff Swift, PhD (97Jedi)
Pavel V. Miliukov: (miatezhnyi)
Stanley Garrison: Geoff Swift, PhD (97Jedi)
Paul Lombrice, Issachar Nahum: Tobias Francis
Ndugu Bowunga: Tobias Francis
Martin Trevithick and Huy Nguyen: Geoff Swift, PhD (97 Jedi) and Chris Thompson
(TeamNutmeg)
Francis Liao-Santiago: Tobias Francis and Chris French (LiaoFan)
Henri Rollet: Duane Bywaters (boilerman)
Yves Fitzgerald: Edward McEneely (3rdCrucisLancers)
Isaiah M. Rosner: (fallen_angel)
Hedwig Kirchherr: Tobias Francis
Benjamin F. Marion: Ben Klinefelter (Shadow6)
Jacob Pontiac Brothers: Geoff Swift, PhD (97Jedi)

Special Insert: A Tribute to Ian Davion was conceived, designed, and written entirely by Geoff
Swift, PhD (97Jedi)

End page Hatchetman figure and photograph by Frederic Lagoanere (Foxbat).

Atlas figures throughout by Ken Nabors (Yuri Hikado).

Ad graphics by Ken Nabors (Yuri Hikado) and Chris Thompson (TeamNutmeg).

Original Goshen G Logo by FASA, used with permission.

Disclaimer:
WizKids LLC has sole ownership of the names, logos, artwork, marks, photographs, sounds,
audio, video and/or any proprietary material used in connection with the game Classic
BattleTech. WizKids, LLC has granted permission to The Review to use such names, logos,
artwork, marks and/or any written materials for promotional and informational purposes on its
website but does not endorse, and is not affiliated with, The Review in any capacity
whatsoever.
The Review was built with Word 3007.
Hey Goshen Alums!
Looking to show your Goshen Pride? Why not with a figurine of the Mech
you (or the MechWarrior you sponsor) piloted in the Training Battalion?
Rostens will make your figurine to order! Rostens figurines are made of
high-quality alloys and can be painted with authentic-looking battle damage
and personal insignia by our top-notch artists! Order yours today!

For ordering information, contact us at orders@info.rostens.interconnectednessULTD.fs.comnet

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen