Sie sind auf Seite 1von 13
 
Human Rights Alert
 (NGO)
 
י כזלדאה
 
Joseph Zernik, PhD
"
ינרצףס ירד
 
PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel "
 
33407" ,
 
6133301Fax: 077-3179186 Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org
 ירבע
 
][
ןלהל
November 05, 2017Nadav Argaman, Head of Shin-BetPrime Minister's Office, Ben Gurion City, Building CJerusalem 91950By fax: 02-5605000, and by email: sigalM@pmo.gov.il 
RE: Computerization of the election system – false and misleading Ministry of Interior
 Freedom of Information Act
Response.
Dear Mr Argaman:Thank you very much for your responses on my previous inquiries, pertaining to lack of integrity and/or deceit and breach of trust in the Central Election Committee’s conduct.On September 12, 2017, I also filed a FOIA request (attached) with the Ministry of Interior, pertaining to conduct of the Public Committee for Review of Computerization of the Election System and recommendations of the State Ombudsman in this regard.Following reminder, I received the attached letters, dated October 31, 2017 and November 02, 2017, which I deem false and misleading. Also attached is my November 05, 2017 reply to the Ministry of Interior, again requesting compliance with the
 Freedom of Information Act
, and a lawful FOIA response.Renewal of conduct of the above referenced Committee could have been a constructive measure for renewal of public trust in the Central Election Committee. In view of rumors regarding pending general election, which are repeatedly published by media, the matter is also of high urgency.The
Shin-Bet Act
(2002), Article 7(a) says: The Shin-Bet is charged with the safeguard of State security, procedures and institutions of the democratic regime against threats of terror, sabotage, and subversion…
 
I hope that you could exert your influence and at least help in bringing the Ministry of Interior into compliance with the
 Freedom of Information Act
, if not renewal of conduct of the Committee.I would be grateful for your attention to this important matter and confirmation of receipt by return email.Truly,
1/2
 
Joseph Zernik, PhDHuman Rights Alert (NGO)
CC:
Computing experts, legal scholars,activists, wide distribution_________________________________________________________________________05,
במבונל
2017
שאר
"
בשה נמגרא רשמארלשממהןיינב
,
יירקבוירוג
91950
ילשורי
"
או ב
 – :
 ריחבה כרעמב שחמן דינה
 
ינפהדרשמידילעעדימהשפ חק חם יקיא
 
בכנהןמגרארמ
 
, 
שה בוש לע ו ו בור
" 
הרשירסוחןיינעב מ וק וינפלעכ
 / 
ינומא רפהוהמרמוא
 
ימהשפוחקוחיפלעהשקבלע יזכרמה וריחבה עו בוש ב
. 
םויב
12,
במטפסל
2017,() ,
גונב פרוצמםינפה רשמלםגע ימהשפוח שקבי שגה
 ,
ני מהרקבמ וצלמהו וריחבה כרעמבושחמ ניחבל ירוביצהה עווה ולהנ הל
.
זןיינעב
 ,
וימםיפרוצמהםיב כמה אי לביק רוכז רחאל
31,
בוטקואל
2017 ,
וימו
02 ,
רבמבונל
2017. ,
יעטמוםיירקשכם וארלשיש
 
וימםינפה רשמלי בוג פרוצמןכומכ
05,
במבונל
2017 ,
ויק אבוש שקבמה
. ,
י כהבוש וע ימהשפוחקוח
 "
וביצהןומאשו יחלהנוב עצ ויהללוכיהיהלנה ירוביצהה עווהלשה לועפשו יח
 .
עםירקבל וש ח רושק ב ומסרפ מה ועומשהרואל יזכרמה וריחבה עווב
. ,
בורמ ופיח םגןיינעבשי וריחבה מ קה
בשהקוח
)2002,(
יעס
7) ,(
מוא
: 
ני מהןוחטיב רימשלע קפומ ורישה
, 
טרקומ הרטשמהיר ס
 
ורטימויאינפמוי ו סומו
,
לבח
,
ונר ח
... 
ילעע ימהשפוחקוחםויקל וחפלאיבהלך עפשה אליעפהללכו שהווקמינירה
. ,
עווה לועפשו יחלאלםאםינפה רשמ
 
עה וא
 
יינעלךבל מוש ושחז
. " ,
זוחלאו בהלבקרושיאלעןכו
,
הכרבב
 '
ינרצףסויר
Human Rights Alert - NGO
 :
םיק עה
, ,
ינטפשמבושחמלםיחמומ
 ,
בחרהצופ םיליעפ
2/2
 
Human Rights Alert (NGO) 
י כזלדאה
 
Joseph Zernik, PhD "
 נרצףסו רד
 PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel "
ת
33407" ,
ת
6133301Fax: 077-3179186 Email: joseph.zernik@hra-ngo.org
 
[ ]
להל ירבע
September 12, 2017Ms Zivah Sherbaf Head of the FOIA BranchMinistry of InteriorEmail: Meda@moin.gov.il 
 
,
zivash@moin.gov.il RE: Freedom of Information Request regarding Ministry of Interior and the Central Election Committee – records, which are related to findings and recommendations in the State Ombudsman’s reports
Dear Ms Sherbaf:Please accept instant Freedom of Information Request. Please confirm receipt by return email, including a duly designated FOIA request number.Instant FOIA request is addressed to you, pursuant to instructions in the Ministry of Interior’s Internet page. [
1
] It should be noted that your title, as published in the Ministry of Interior’s Internet page is not “FOIA Officer”. Additionally, I have found no reference to a FOIA Officer in that page. Furthermore, I have found no reference to a FOIA Officer in the Ministry of Interior’s 2016 FOIA Annual Report.Therefore, I herein file a preliminarily request: a) A copy of a lawfully made appointment record of the Ministry of Interior’s FOIA Officer, or an exact reference to an official publication of such appointment. Additionally, I herein request that the response on instant FOIA request be signed by a lawfully appointed Ministry of Interior’s FOIA Officer.
I. Requester
Name: Joseph Zernik ID:  Address: PO Box 33407, Tel Aviv, Israel Fax: 077-3179186
II. Requested Information
The requested information is detailed in the Hebrew FOIA request below. Here only ageneral description is provided. The request is based on the State Ombudsman’s published report following the 2015 general elections.The request includes photocopies of specific paragraphs from the State Ombudsman’s published report and asks for documents that are specifically referenced in the
1
ד מה
 
שפוח
 
וח
 -
ם נפה
 
דרשמ
1/5

Ihre Neugier belohnen

Alles, was Sie lesen wollen.
Jederzeit. Überall. Auf jedem Gerät.
Keine Verpflichtung. Jederzeit kündbar.
576648e32a3d8b82ca71961b7a986505