ISDP2-10 Pre-Demo

Doc. Ref. No. Issue Version Date

UTP-EE-DEPT-ISDPII-10 1.4 1/10/2016

ISDP Part II PRE-DEMONSTRATION SCORE SHEET

(To be assessed by ISDP Coordinators only)

Team No. : Team Name :

Team Supervisor(s) :

This Pre-Demo session will assess Course Outcomes 1 and 2 of ISDP IIs three course outcomes:

Course Outcome
Description
(CO)

CO1 Construct a fully functioning prototype by integrating hardware and software subsystems as outlined in the design concept.

CO2 Develop and perform tests on the subsystems to assess strengths and shortcomings of the project and propose further improvements.

Develop technical documentations to demonstrate proof-of-concept and modify design based on feedback from relevant parties to produce a
X CO3
reliable solution.

Instructions for Teams and Coordinators:

1. Pre-Demo is assessed in 2 sections: a) Individual task demonstration (pg. 2) and b) FMEA review (pg. 3), both for individual scores ONLY.
2. Each team member shall demonstrate individual task/capability of prototype but CAN be assisted by other member(s).
3. Failure Mode Effects Analysis (FMEA) review is also assessed individually according to assigned task to each team member.

Open
1

Team No. : _______________
TASKS Bad
0 <4
Power Management Able to discuss power/
energy management
Autonomous Bot is able to either move
Maneuver forward, reverse OR turn
Ambient Sensing No / very poor sensing of
heat OR sound
Heat/sound sensor not
integrated to Bot
Colour & Shape No / very poor colour OR
Identification shape detection
Colour/shape sensors not
integrated to Bot
Wireless No / erroneous
Communication communication / display
Wireless module
not integrated to Bot
Open
Team Name : _________________________________
Grade, Range of Score and Associated Attributes
Satisfactory
4 5.9
Able to discuss power/
energy management
Some idea of power
management strategy
Bot is able to turn
autonomously at 1 curved
section OR 1 T-junction,
under 3 minutes
Able to detect either heat OR
sound
Either heat OR sound sensor
integrated to Bot
Able to detect 1 colour OR
1 shape only
Some integration of
colour/shape sensor to Bot
Some/partial wireless
transmission of message
Wireless module partially
integrated to Bot
Good
6 7.9
Good discussion/ calculation of
power/energy management
Good power management strategy
Bot is able to turn autonomously at 1
curved section AND 1 T-junction
(no need to detect colour/shape),
under 6 minutes
Able to detect BOTH heat AND sound
BUT no/ incorrect response from Bot
BOTH heat AND sound sensors
integrated to Bot BUT not fully-
functioning
Able to detect 2 colours OR
2 shapes
Good integration of sensors BUT
not fully-functioning
Detect AND transmit correct message
for 1 shape
Good integration of wireless module
BUT not fully-functioning
ISDP2-10 Pre-Demo
ACTUAL
Excellent
SCORE
8 - 10
Excellent discussion/ calculation of
power/energy management
Excellent power management strategy
Bot is able to turn autonomously at 1
curved section AND 1 T-junction
(no need to detect colour/shape),
under 4 minutes
Able to detect BOTH heat AND sound
AND correct response from Bot
BOTH heat AND sound sensors fully-
integrated to Bot AND fully-functioning
Able to detect 2 colours AND
2 shapes
Colour/shape sensors fully-integrated
to Bot
Detect AND transmit correct message
for 2 shapes
Wireless module fully-integrated
to Bot AND fully-functioning
TEAM SUBTOTAL
2
 ISDP2-10 Pre-Demo

Failure Mode & Effects Analysis (FMEA) Score Range

[CO2 PO8 / PO11]

Bad Satisfactory Good Excellent

0 <4 4 5.9 6 7.9 8 - 10
Incorrect identification of Identified failures modes and failure Identified failures modes and failure Comprehensively identified failure modes and
failures modes causes causes failure causes
Detection of failure Detection of failure
Comprehensively identified the effects of failure
modes.

Failure Mode & Effects Analysis (FMEA)

Individual Score [CO2 PO8 / PO11]

ACTUAL ISDP Coordinator Signature/ Initial

No. Team Members Name Student ID Subsystem / Task
SCORE and Brief Remarks

Power/ Energy
1 Management

Autonomous
2 Maneuver

Ambient
3 Sensing

Colour & Shape

4 Identification

Wireless
5 Communication

---------------------------------------------
ISDP Committee Member (Sign/ Initial & Date)

Open
3