Sie sind auf Seite 1von 10

NEW CAR RATINGS Our new Overall Score will help guide you to

the 250 best-performing, safest, and most reliable vehicles

FORD F-150
Our highest-rated
pickup truck.
See page 78.

70 WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org | APRIL 2016 |


How to Read the Ratings Charts
d Recommended Vehicles Survey Results involve experiences covering 230,000 We buy and test about
did well in testing, have average Reliability and Owner Satisfaction vehicles less than 3 years old. 70vehicles each year, driving
or better predicted reliability, polls taken annually of Consumer them for thousands of miles
and performed adequately if Reports subscribers. Safety identifies whether and putting them through more
included in a government or Reliability results are based a vehicle has a frontal crash than 50 tests.
insurance-industry crash test. on about 740,000 vehicles prevention system. NA means Some tests, such as those
Models with subpar crash-test owned by subscribers who no such system is offered. Opt. for acceleration, braking, and
results are identified by (!). responded to our 2015 Annual means its available on some fuel economy, are objective,
Auto Survey by reporting versions, but not necessarily instrumented tests. Other tests
Overall Score accounts for on problems with their vehicles. on the one we tested. Models that evaluate seat comfort,
a vehicles performance in our Predicted reliability is based with standard systems are rated ride quality, and ease of use
road tests, results from our on a models latest three from C to Z based on their of controls, are subjective, and
reliability and owner satisfaction years of data. ability to warn drivers or brake graded by our experts.
surveys, the availability of a Owner satisfaction is based autonomously to prevent a crash.
frontal crash prevention system, on the percentage of owners We Rate Cars Using
and, if applicable, results from who said they would definitely Road-Test Results display test These Symbols
crash tests by government and buy the same car again. The findings relevant to each vehicle
5 4 3 2 1
insurance-industry test facilities. information is drawn from category. Better Worse

ELECTRIC CARS, PLUG-IN HYBRIDS, and SUBCOMPACTS


5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS
Acceleration
Recommended

Predicted

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash
Reliability

Road-Test Score

Overall MPG
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear

Luggage,
Suitcases+Duffels
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls
OVERALL
SCORE

ELECTRIC CARS AND PLUG-IN HYBRIDS


d Ford C-Max Energi $34,940 69 C X NA 77 94/37 8.1 136 50.5 X X/4 X/4 C 1+1
BMW i3 Giga $50,450 64 V X Opt. 79 139 7.5 131 55.0 X 4/Z X/C C 1+1
! Nissan Leaf S $29,860 63 C X NA 71 106 10.3 136 52.5 X X/X X/C X 2+1
Ford Focus Electric $40,990 54 B C NA 72 107 10.2 140 52.5 Z Z/4 X/C V 1+1
Mitsubishi i-MiEV SE $33,630 45 C* C* NA 35 111 14.7 132 52.0 V 2/C C/3 C 1+1
CARS: SUBCOMPACT
d Honda Fit EX $19,025 66 C X NA 67 33 10.0 132 55.0 X V/V X/X X 2+2
d Nissan Versa Note SV $17,495 66 Z V NA 61 31 10.9 135 54.5 X C/3 C/X Z 1+2
d Chevrolet Sonic LT (1.8L) $17,290 65 C V Opt. 66 28 9.3 128 54.0 X C/C C/2 X 3+0
d Scion iA $17,570 65 X* X* C 60 35 10.3 139 55.0 Z C/C C/2 C 3+0
! Hyundai Accent Sport
(hatchback, MT) $16,695 64 X V NA 68 32 8.5 136 55.0 X C/C X/C Z 2+2
Toyota Prius C Two $20,850 64 Z X Opt. 55 43 11.3 135 51.5 C V/V X/C X 1+1
! Hyundai Accent SE $16,050 62 X V NA 65 31 10.3 134 51.5 X C/C X/C Z 3+1
Chevrolet Sonic LTZ
(hatchback, 1.4T, MT) $19,870 61 C V Opt. 60 30 8.9 130 55.0 X C/C C/2 X 1+1
Toyota Yaris LE $17,290 55 Z* C* NA 47 32 10.8 137 54.0 C C/2 C/C X 1+1
Kia Rio EX $17,275 53 V B NA 64 30 9.5 138 55.0 X 2/C X/C Z 2+3
Kia Rio EX (hatchback) $17,475 51 V B NA 62 29 9.9 136 55.0 X C/C X/C Z 1+3
! Nissan Versa SV (sedan) $15,490 48 C* B* NA 56 32 10.6 140 54.5 C C/2 C/X X 4+0
Ford Fiesta SES (hatchback, MT) $17,795 44 B V NA 66 32 10.7 134 55.0 Z C/X X/2 C 1+2
Ford Fiesta SE (3-cyl., MT) $18,720 44 B V NA 66 35 9.0 125 56.0 X C/C X/1 C 1+3
Miles-per-gallon equivalent (MPGe). Miles per gallon while running on gas engine.

*Based on limited data. **Powertrain has changed since last test. | APRIL 2016 | WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org 71
SUBCOMPACTS, SMALL 2-DOOR, COMPACT, and MIDSIZED SEDANS
5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS
Recommended

Predicted

Acceleration
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road-Test Score

Overall MPG
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear

Luggage,
Suitcases+Duffels
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls
OVERALL
SCORE

CARS: SUBCOMPACT continued


Ford Fiesta SE $16,595 42 B V NA 64 33 10.9 142 52.5 X X/X X/2 C 3+1
Smart ForTwo Passion $18,730 41 V* X* NA 41 36 11.2 132 52.5 C V/1 X/- C 1+1
! Mitsubishi Mirage ES $16,050 34 C* C NA 29 37 12.1 138 52.5 V C/1 C/C X 1+1
CARS: SMALL 2-DOOR
d Mini Cooper (base, AT) $27,400 64 C X Opt. 68 31 8.3 133 54.5 Z C/C X/1 C 1+1
d Hyundai Veloster (base, MT) $20,340 63 C V NA 67 31 9.2 131 54.0 X C/C X/1 X 1+3
Honda CR-Z EX (MT) $22,810 58 C* X* NA 54 35 9.3 139 52.0 X 2/C X/- X 4+1
Scion tC (AT) $21,130 52 C* C* NA 44 27 8.6 134 54.0 C V/V X/2 X 2+0
Volkswagen Beetle 1.8T (AT) $22,485 47 B C NA 59 27 8.4 136 51.0 X C/C X/2 X 2+1
Fiat 500c Pop (MT) $21,000 44 B C NA 52 34 11.0 129 53.0 X 2/C C/1 C 0+2
! Fiat 500 Sport (MT) $18,600 39 B C NA 54 33 11.3 134 55.0 Z 2/C C/1 C 1+0
CARS: COMPACT
d Subaru Impreza Premium $21,345 79 Z C Opt. 79 27 9.2 129 52.5 X X/C X/C Z 2+2
Subaru Impreza Sport
d Premium (hatchback) $22,345 77 Z C Opt. 76 26 9.4 127 52.5 X X/C X/X Z 2+2

d Toyota Prius V Three $28,217 75 Z X Opt. 73 41 10.7 138 55.0 C X/C X/X X 32.0
Mazda3 i Grand Touring
d (hatchback, 2.0L, MT) $24,040 74 X X Opt. 73 32 8.2 133 54.0 Z C/C X/C C 2+2

d Mazda3 i Touring (2.0L) $21,740 74 X X Opt. 72 33 8.3 133 54.5 Z C/C X/C X 2+3
d Honda Civic LX $20,275 73 C* X* Opt. 76 32 8.7 129 56.0 X X/C C/C Z 3+1
d Kia Soul Plus $24,115 72 X X Opt. 74 26 8.8 127 53.5 X C/C X/X Z 24.5
d Honda Civic EX-T $23,035 72 C* X* Opt. 75 31 7.1 129 54.5 X X/C C/C C 3+1
d Toyota Corolla LE Plus $20,652 72 Z X NA 71 32 9.9 138 54.5 C X/C C/X X 3+1
d Kia Forte LX (1.8L) $19,570 71 C C NA 78 28 10.1 128 52.5 X X/X X/C Z 3+1
d Volkswagen Jetta SE (1.4T) $21,235 71 C C Opt. 79 32 9.1 131 53.0 X X/X X/X X 3+2
d Scion iM $19,995 69 Z* X* NA 64 31 10.0 133 52.5 X C/C X/C X 1+3
d Ford C-Max Hybrid SE $26,685 69 C X NA 77 37 8.4 138 53.0 X X/X X/X C 28.0
Volkswagen Jetta Hybrid
d SEL Premium $31,940 68 C C Opt. 75 37 8.1 138 52.5 X X/X X/X X 2+1
Volkswagen Jetta Sport
d (1.8T) $22,610 68 C C Opt. 74 30 8.5 137 52.0 X X/X X/X Z 3+2
Volkswagen Golf SE (1.8T) $25,315 63 B Z Opt. 82 28 8.7 130 54.0 X X/X X/X Z 2+1
Mitsubishi Lancer ES $17,515 63 C* C* NA 62 25 9.8 144 49.5 X X/C X/C Z 3+1
Ford Focus SE $20,280 54 B C NA 72 28 9.2 141 52.5 X X/X X/C C 3+1
Ford Focus SE (hatchback) $22,185 53 B C NA 71 28 9.3 137 52.5 X X/X X/C C 2+1
Dodge Dart SXT (2.4L) $22,025 53 B C NA 68 27 9.3 127 54.5 X C/C C/C X 3+1
Nissan Sentra SV $20,570 51 B B Opt. 65 29 9.7 129 55.5 C C/C C/X X 3+2
! Fiat 500L Easy** $24,595 31 B V NA 50 27 9.5 132 51.5 X 2/C C/X C 2+2
CARS: MIDSIZED
d Toyota Camry Hybrid XLE $29,052 84 Z X Opt. 87 38 7.6 133 51.0 X X/X X/X X 3+1
d Toyota Camry XLE (V6) $32,603 84 Z X Opt. 86 26 6.4 136 50.5 X X/X X/X X 4+0
d Subaru Legacy 2.5 Premium $24,837 83 X Z Opt. 89 26 10.2 128 55.5 X Z/4 X/X Z 3+1
d Toyota Camry LE (4-cyl.) $24,089 83 Z X Opt. 84 28 8.6 131 53.5 X X/X X/X X 4+0

72 WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org | APRIL 2016 | *Based on limited data. **Powertrain has changed since last test.
MIDSIZED, LARGE, LUXURY ENTRY-LEVEL, and LUXURY COMPACT SEDANS
5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS
Recommended

Predicted
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road-Test Score

Overall MPG

Acceleration
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear

Suitcases+Duffels
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls

Luggage,
OVERALL
SCORE

CARS: MIDSIZED continued


d Honda Accord LX (4-cyl.) $23,270 82 X X Opt. 85 30 7.7 136 53.0 X X/X X/X X 3+2

d Honda Accord EX-L (V6) $30,860 81 X X Opt. 84 26 6.3 139 52.5 X X/X Z/4 X 3+2

d Mazda6 Sport $23,590 77 X X Opt. 79 32 7.5 132 53.0 X C/C X/X X 3+2

d Hyundai Sonata Hybrid SE $26,950 77 X X Opt. 80 39 8.2 140 50.5 C X/X 4/Z Z 2+2

d Ford Fusion SE (1.5T) $27,720 77 C X Opt. 81 24 9.2 125 52.5 Z Z/4 C/X X 3+2

d Hyundai Sonata SE (2.4L) $23,315 76 X X Opt. 78 28 9.2 139 50.5 C X/X 4/Z Z 3+2

d Ford Fusion SE Hybrid $28,290 76 C X Opt. 80 39 8.3 140 52.0 X Z/4 C/X X 2+3

d Volkswagen Passat SE (1.8T) $27,485 76 C X Opt. 82 28 8.6 129 52.5 X X/X 4/Z X 3+1

d Ford Fusion Titanium (2.0T) $33,180 75 C X Opt. 78 22 7.4 130 53.5 Z X/X X/X V 3+1
Volkswagen Passat SEL
d Premium (V6) $33,720 74 C X Opt. 79 23 6.8 132 52.5 X X/X 4/Z X 3+0
Nissan Altima 3.5 SL $31,610 64 V V Opt. 80 24 6.3 133 52.0 C C/X X/X Z 3+1
Nissan Altima 2.5 S $23,410 62 V V Opt. 77 31 8.2 140 51.5 C X/X X/X Z 3+2
Chrysler 200 C (V6) $33,620 53 B X Opt. 66 25 6.9 138 51.5 C X/X X/C X 3+1
Chrysler 200 Limited (4-cyl.) $25,790 51 B X Opt. 63 30 9.8 130 53.5 C C/C C/C X 3+1
CARS: LARGE
d Chevrolet Impala 2LTZ (3.6) $39,110 81 C X Opt. 91 22 6.9 130 54.0 X Z/4 Z/4 X 4+2
d Kia Cadenza $39,030 81 X X NA 83 22 7.2 132 51.5 C X/X X/X Z 3+2
d Toyota Avalon Limited (V6) $40,670 80 X X Opt. 81 24 7.0 132 53.5 C C/X Z/4 X 3+2
Toyota Avalon Hybrid
d Limited $42,501 79 X X Opt. 80 36 8.2 138 52.5 C C/X Z/4 X 3+1

d Hyundai Azera $37,185 79 X X Opt. 80 23 7.2 132 51.5 C X/X Z/5 X 3+2
Chevrolet SS $47,170 76 V* Z* C 87 17 5.1 118 56.0 Z C/C Z/4 Z 3+1
Nissan Maxima Platinum $41,995 73 C* X* Opt. 81 25 6.5 132 53.0 X C/X Z/C Z 3+0
Ford Taurus Limited (3.5, V6) $37,885 69 C C Opt. 72 21 7.2 135 50.0 C X/X X/X C 4+2
Dodge Charger R/T Plus (V8) $40,375 62 B X Opt. 85 20 6.1 128 50.5 X 4/Z Z/4 Z 2+3
Dodge Charger SXT (V6) $34,510 61 B X Opt. 82 22 7.4 134 52.0 X X/X Z/4 Z 3+1
Chrysler 300 C (V8) $45,650 60 B X Opt. 84 20 6.1 134 49.5 X 4/Z Z/5 X 3+1
Chrysler 300 Limited (V6) $38,335 60 B X Opt. 83 22 7.4 137 50.0 X 4/Z Z/5 X 3+1
CARS: LUXURY ENTRY-LEVEL
d Volkswagen CC Sport (2.0T) $32,800 74 X C Opt. 78 26 7.5 133 52.0 X X/X X/C X 3+1
d Audi A3 Premium $31,495 73 C Z Opt. 77 27 8.3 124 53.0 X C/C X/2 C 2+1
d Buick Verano Leather (2.4) $27,750 71 C C Opt. 73 24 8.5 129 54.5 X X/X C/C X 3+2
d Lexus CT 200h Premium $32,012 70 Z C Opt. 65 40 11.0 133 54.5 X 2/C X/C X 1+1
d Volkswagen Jetta GLI SE (MT) $27,740 68 C C Opt. 74 27 7.2 132 54.5 X C/C X/X X 3+2
Acura ILX Premium $30,820 57 V* C Opt. 61 28 7.5 132 54.5 C V/V X/C C 2+2
Mercedes-Benz CLA250 $36,500 53 B V Z 64 28 6.6 124 54.0 X 2/C X/2 V 2+2
CARS: LUXURY COMPACT
d Buick Regal Premium I $34,485 78 X X Opt. 83 24 7.4 125 53.5 X X/X X/C X 3+1
d BMW 328d xDrive $50,475 77 C X Opt. 86 35 8.5 132 54.0 Z X/X Z/C C 2+1
d Volvo S60 T5 Drive-E $39,925 77 X C C 80 25 7.9 128 54.0 X C/X Z/C X 3+0

| APRIL 2016 | WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org 73


LUXURY COMPACT, LUXURY MIDSIZED, and ULTRALUXURY SEDANS
5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS
Recommended

Predicted
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road-Test Score

Overall MPG

Acceleration
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear

Suitcases+Duffels
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls

Luggage,
OVERALL
SCORE

CARS: LUXURY COMPACT continued


d BMW 328i $43,195 75 C X Opt. 84 28 6.3 132 54.5 Z X/X X/C C 2+1
Mercedes-Benz C300
(4MATIC) $47,560 65 B X Z 85 26 6.8 136 55.5 X Z/4 Z/C V 2+1
Lexus IS300 (AWD)** $43,823 65 Z C Opt. 58 21 8.7 138 53.5 X C/X X/2 C 2+1
Cadillac ATS Luxury (turbo) $43,295 57 B V Opt. 79 23 6.5 125 57.5 Z X/X Z/2 B 2+1
Infiniti Q50 Premium
(AWD)** $44,855 57 B V Opt. 75 21 5.6 126 54.0 X C/X X/X C 2+0
Acura TLX 2.4L $35,920 57 B X Opt. 79 27 7.4 129 54.5 X X/X X/C C 2+2
Acura TLX SH-AWD $42,345 55 B X Opt. 75 25 6.5 129 55.0 X X/X X/C V 2+2
CARS: LUXURY MIDSIZED
Mercedes-Benz E250
d BlueTec (4MATIC) $62,980 87 C X Z 93 30 8.3 131 54.0 X Z/4 Z/4 C 3+1
Audi A6 3.0 Premium Plus
d Quattro $56,295 84 X Z Opt. 90 22 5.7 132 52.5 X Z/5 Z/4 C 3+1

d Infiniti Q70 (V6) $53,825 82 C X Opt. 90 21 5.8 128 54.5 X X/X 4/Z X 3+2

d Lexus GS 350** $58,858 82 Z X Opt. 83 21 6.2 137 53.5 X X/X Z/4 C 3+1

d Mercedes-Benz E350 $57,965 82 C X Z 86 21 6.3 131 51.0 X Z/5 Z/4 V 3+1

d Lexus ES 350 $43,702 79 Z Z Opt. 78 25 6.7 139 51.5 C 4/Z Z/4 C 3+2

d Lexus ES 300h $44,017 79 Z Z Opt. 77 36 8.2 140 51.0 C X/X Z/4 C 3+1

d Infiniti Q70 Hybrid $58,655 78 C X Opt. 83 25 5.6 131 52.0 X X/X X/X X 2+1

d Hyundai Genesis 3.8 (AWD) $52,450 78 C Z Opt. 89 20 7.2 129 53.0 X 4/Z Z/4 Z 3+1

d Hyundai Equus Signature** $58,900 76 C X C 80 19 6.5 140 49.0 X 4/Z Z/5 X 4+0

d Lincoln MKZ 2.0 EcoBoost $41,365 75 C X Opt. 84 23 7.4 124 53.0 Z Z/5 Z/C B 3+2

d Lincoln MKZ Hybrid $41,915 75 C X Opt. 83 34 9.2 129 53.0 Z Z/5 Z/C B 2+2
Buick LaCrosse (Leather,
d eAssist) $34,935 75 C X Opt. 80 26 9.2 130 52.0 X Z/4 Z/4 X 2+1
Buick LaCrosse Premium I
d (V6) $37,555 72 C X Opt. 76 20 7.2 137 52.5 X X/X Z/4 X 3+1
Cadillac CTS Luxury (V6,
d AWD) $58,780 70 C X Opt. 81 21 6.8 127 54.5 Z 4/Z Z/C B 2+2
BMW 535i $58,375 66 V X Opt. 81 23 6.1 137 51.5 X Z/5 Z/4 V 3+1
Cadillac XTS Premium $57,200 62 V C Opt. 82 22 7.2 128 53.0 X 4/Z Z/4 B 4+1
Acura RLX Tech $55,345 59 B C Z 75 23 6.5 128 51.5 C C/X Z/4 V 2+3
! Lincoln MKS (base, 3.7) $50,070 59 C C Opt. 66 20 7.1 137 51.5 C X/X X/X V 4+0

CARS: ULTRALUXURY
d BMW 750i xDrive $110,645 87 C* X* Opt. 99 21 5.3 131 52.5 X Z/5 Z/5 C 2+4
d Lexus LS 460L $82,504 86 Z Z Opt. 89 21 6.2 140 48.5 X Z/5 Z/5 C 3+2
d Audi A8 L** $91,275 86 X* X Opt. 91 21 5.5 126 52.0 X Z/5 Z/5 V 3+1
Tesla Model S P85D $127,820 77 V Z Z 100 87 3.5 118 55.5 Z 4/Z X/C V 4+3
Tesla Model S (85 kWh) $89,650 77 V Z Z 99 84 5.6 128 53.5 Z Z/5 X/C V 4+3
Porsche Panamera S** $105,110 73 C* X* Opt. 81 20 5.5 116 56.0 Z X/X X/X V 1+2
Mercedes-Benz S550
(4MATIC) $114,475 73 B Z Z 96 18 5.1 128 51.0 X Z/5 Z/5 V 2+3
Jaguar XJL Portfolio** $81,575 70 V* Z* NA 82 19 5.5 138 52.5 X 4/Z Z/5 C 2+1
Maserati Ghibli S Q4 $89,010 59 V* V* NA 71 19 5.4 115 53.5 X 2/C X/C C 2+2
Miles-per-gallon equivalent (MPGe). Miles per gallon while running on gas engine.

74 WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org | APRIL 2016 | *Based on limited data. **Powertrain has changed since last test.
SPORTS/SPORTY CARS, WAGONS, and MINIVANS
5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS

Acceleration

Acceleration
Recommended

Predicted
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road-Test Score

Overall MPG
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

Dry braking
60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Quarter Mile, Sec.

Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Driving Position

Controls
OVERALL
SCORE

SPORTS/SPORTY CARS OVER $40,000 (EQUIPPED WITH MANUAL TRANSMISSION)


d BMW M235i $50,400 94 Z Z Opt. 98 25 5.2 13.8 115 58.5 Z C/X X X
d Porsche 911 Carrera S $110,630 87 X Z Opt. 95 23 4.1 12.4 108 59.5 Z V/V X C
d Audi TT 2.0T (AT) $50,600 81 X* Z* NA 84 26 6.3 14.8 113 58.0 Z C/C X V
d Porsche Boxster 2.7 $59,600 74 C Z Opt. 83 23 6.1 14.5 112 58.0 Z C/C C C
BMW Z4 sDrive28i $55,225 70 C* X* NA 74 28 6.1 14.7 122 54.5 X 2/C C C
Ford Mustang GT Premium
(V8) $43,295 64 B Z Opt. 84 19 4.9 13.4 121 54.5 Z C/C X X
Chevrolet Corvette Stingray
3LT $73,260 64 B Z NA 92 20 4.3 12.6 107 57.5 Z V/V C Z
Dodge Challenger R/T Plus
(V8) $40,860 54 B Z Opt. 70 20 5.5 13.9 119 51.5 X C/C C X
SPORTS/SPORTY CARS UNDER $40,000 (EQUIPPED WITH MANUAL TRANSMISSION)
d Mazda MX-5 Miata Club $29,905 79 X* Z NA 80 34 6.7 15.1 124 57.5 Z V/1 V C
d Volkswagen GTI Autobahn $31,730 75 C Z Opt. 82 29 6.6 15.2 132 55.0 Z C/X X Z
d Scion FR-S $25,025 74 C C NA 78 30 7.2 15.5 126 56.5 Z V/V X X
d Subaru BRZ Premium $27,117 74 C C NA 79 30 7.2 15.6 126 56.0 Z V/V X X
d Nissan 370Z Touring (coupe) $38,565 73 C* X* NA 81 23 5.3 13.9 120 58.0 Z V/V V X
d Mini Cooper S $29,945 72 C X Opt. 81 30 7.2 15.5 130 56.0 Z C/C X X
d Subaru WRX Premium $29,742 70 C Z Opt. 75 26 6.0 14.5 120 59.0 Z V/V X Z
Ford Mustang Premium
(4-cyl., AT) $33,080 59 B Z Opt. 76 25 6.4 14.9 125 53.0 Z C/C X X
Ford Focus ST $28,270 55 B C NA 74 25 6.6 15.1 122 53.0 Z 2/C C X
Fiat 500 Abarth $26,050 52 B C NA 66 28 8.0 16.1 125 55.5 Z 1/V C C
Hyundai Genesis Coupe 3.8 $28,375 50 B V NA 64 23 6.2 14.6 138 54.0 Z 2/C X Z
Ford Fiesta ST $24,985 50 B V NA 74 29 7.3 15.6 118 57.0 Z 1/C C C

SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS
Recommended

Predicted

Front Crash

Overall MPG

Acceleration
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Road-Test Score
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls

Cargo Volume, Cu. Ft.


OVERALL
SCORE

WAGONS (ALL-WHEEL DRIVE)


d Audi Allroad 2.0T Premium $43,570 81 Z X NA 82 22 8.1 131 53.0 X X/X X/C C 28.5

d Subaru Outback 3.6R Limited $36,835 81 X Z Opt. 85 22 7.4 134 55.0 C X/X X/X Z 34.0

d Subaru Outback 2.5 Premium $28,852 80 X Z Opt. 82 24 10.5 133 53.5 C X/X X/X Z 34.0
Volvo V60 Cross Country $46,475 60 V X C 73 21 8.1 127 49.5 X C/X Z/C X 26.0
MINIVANS
d Toyota Sienna XLE (FWD) $35,810 80 X X Opt. 80 20 8.8 134 49.0 C X/X 4/Z X 70.5
d Honda Odyssey EX-L $38,055 78 C X Opt. 84 21 8.4 136 47.5 X X/X Z/5 X 61.5
d Toyota Sienna XLE (AWD) $38,201 78 X X Opt. 78 19 8.5 139 48.5 C X/X 4/Z X 70.5
Kia Sedona EX $34,795 69 C X Opt. 70 20 8.0 133 48.0 C C/X 4/Z X 46.0
Ford Transit Connect XLT
(2.5L) $28,015 69 C* V NA 76 21 10.9 132 53.0 X C/C C/Z X 61.0

| APRIL 2016 | WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org 75


MINIVANS, and SUBCOMPACT, SMALL, and MIDSIZED SUVs
5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS
Recommended

Predicted
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road-Test Score

Overall MPG

Acceleration
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls

Cargo Volume, Cu. Ft.


OVERALL
SCORE

MINIVANS continued
! Nissan Quest SL $39,040 65 C* V NA 79 19 8.4 143 51.5 C X/X X/X C 62.0
! Chrysler
Touring-L
Town & Country $37,505 62 C C NA 72 17 8.1 141 49.0 C X/X X/X C 61.5
! Dodge Grand Caravan R/T $37,295 62 C V NA 72 17 8.1 141 49.0 C X/X X/X C 61.5

SUVs: SUBCOMPACT
Subaru Crosstrek
d Premium $24,215 76 Z X Opt. 74 26 9.7 130 53.0 X C/C X/X Z 23.0

d Subaru Crosstrek Hybrid $27,132 75 Z X Opt. 74 28 10.1 131 53.0 X C/C X/X Z 23.0

d Mazda CX-3 Touring $25,800 67 X* X* Opt. 64 28 9.6 135 53.5 Z C/C C/2 C 18.0

d Honda HR-V LX $22,045 66 C* X* NA 66 29 10.5 132 55.0 X V/V 2/X Z 32.0


Chevrolet Trax LT $25,560 53 V* C* NA 55 25 10.8 130 54.0 C 2/C C/C C 26.0
Jeep Renegade Latitude $27,525 46 B* C* Opt. 56 24 9.9 130 51.5 C 2/C C/C X 30.5
Fiat 500X Easy $26,600 39 B* C* Opt. 50 23 9.8 130 52.5 C V/V C/C X 19.5

SUVs: SMALL
Subaru Forester 2.5i
d Premium $27,145 83 X Z Opt. 85 26 8.7 127 52.0 X C/C 4/Z Z 35.5

d Toyota RAV4 XLE $26,802 76 Z C Opt. 75 24 9.0 135 51.5 X C/C X/X X 37.0

d Hyundai Tucson Sport (1.6T) $28,670 75 C* X* Opt. 79 26 8.4 128 53.0 X X/X X/X Z 29.5

d Mazda CX-5 Touring (2.5L) $28,090 74 X X Opt. 74 25 8.0 133 52.5 X C/C X/X X 33.0

d Hyundai Tucson SE (2.0L) $25,920 73 C* X* Opt. 76 24 11.0 129 54.0 X X/X X/X Z 29.5

d Nissan Rogue SV $29,920 71 C C Opt. 74 24 9.5 134 54.0 C X/C C/X Z 31.5

d Volkswagen Tiguan SEL $37,020 69 C C NA 74 21 8.5 140 53.5 X 2/X X/X X 30.0

d Honda CR-V EX $27,500 69 C X Opt. 73 24 9.0 134 51.5 X C/C X/X C 36.0
! Ford Escape Titanium (2.0T) $36,600 62 V C NA 79 22 8.2 134 52.5 X X/X X/X C 35.0
Mitsubishi Outlander SEL
(4-cyl.) $28,405 61 C* B Opt. 59 24 10.0 132 50.5 V C/C C/X X 32.5

! Ford Escape SE (1.6T) $28,040 59 V C NA 75 22 9.9 133 52.5 X X/X C/X X 35.0
Jeep Cherokee Limited (V6) $37,525 47 B C Opt. 71 21 7.7 133 51.5 C C/X 4/Z Z 31.0
Jeep Compass Latitude** $26,190 43 B* B NA 52 22 10.3 145 48.0 X C/C C/C Z 26.5
! Jeep Patriot Latitude** $25,790 40 V B NA 56 21 10.3 141 51.5 X C/C C/X X 29.5
Jeep Cherokee Latitude
(4-cyl.) $27,490 40 B C Opt. 58 22 10.9 138 51.5 C C/X C/X X 31.0

SUVs: MIDSIZED
d Kia Sorento EX (V6) $37,915 84 Z Z Opt. 84 21 7.4 131 49.5 X X/X X/X Z 37.5
Toyota Highlander Hybrid
d Limited $50,875 83 Z Z Opt. 85 25 8.3 138 49.0 C X/X Z/4 X 40.5

d Toyota Highlander XLE (V6) $38,941 82 Z Z Opt. 84 20 7.5 134 50.5 C X/X Z/4 X 40.5

d Nissan Murano SL $42,065 78 Z Z Opt. 77 21 7.7 131 50.5 C X/X X/X X 33.5
Ford Edge SEL
d (2.0 EcoBoost) $39,755 76 C* X Opt. 84 21 8.8 132 51.5 X X/X 4/Z X 39.0

d Honda Pilot EX-L $39,585 76 C* X* Opt. 80 20 7.5 136 49.5 C X/X 4/Z C 48.0
Chevrolet Equinox LTZ (V6) $36,925 71 X C Opt. 69 18 7.1 138 50.5 C X/X 4/Z X 33.5
GMC Terrain SLT2 (V6) $36,675 71 X C Opt. 69 18 7.1 138 50.5 C X/X 4/Z X 33.5

76 WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org | APRIL 2016 | *Based on limited data. **Powertrain has changed since last test.
MIDSIZED, LARGE, LUXURY ENTRY-LEVEL, and LUXURY COMPACT SUVs
5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS

Acceleration
Recommended

Predicted
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road Test Score

Overall MPG
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls

Cargo Volume, Cu. Ft.


OVERALL
SCORE

SUVs: MIDSIZED continued


Chevrolet Equinox 1LT
(4-cyl.) $26,350 71 X C Opt. 68 21 10.7 138 50.0 X X/X 4/Z X 33.5
GMC Terrain SLE1 (4-cyl.) $26,745 71 X C Opt. 68 21 10.7 138 50.0 X X/X 4/Z X 33.5
Hyundai Santa Fe Sport
(4-cyl.) $28,370 70 X X NA 73 23 9.7 132 50.5 C X/C X/X Z 35.5
Hyundai Santa Fe SE (V6) $36,290 68 V X NA 81 20 7.6 133 51.0 C X/X 4/Z Z 40.5
Ford Explorer XLT (V6) $39,275 64 C C Opt. 67 18 7.9 135 49.5 C X/X X/X V 42.0
Toyota 4Runner SR5 (V6) $37,425 61 Z X NA 55 18 7.7 131 48.0 V 2/X X/X X 44.5
Nissan Pathfinder SL $40,470 53 B V NA 72 18 7.7 137 47.0 V X/X X/X Z 39.5
! Dodge Journey Limited (V6) $36,975 45 B V NA 64 16 8.1 139 50.0 C X/X X/X X 37.0
Jeep Wrangler Unlimited
Sahara $36,340 26 V X NA 20 17 8.9 151 45.0 V 1/V C/C C 34.5

SUVs: LARGE
d Dodge Durango Limited (V6) $43,525 76 C Z Opt. 83 18 8.3 134 48.0 C 4/Z Z/4 Z 44.0

d Chevrolet Traverse LT $39,920 74 X C Opt. 77 16 7.9 141 50.0 X X/X X/X X 48.5

d GMC Acadia SLT2 $41,315 72 C C Opt. 77 16 7.9 141 50.0 X X/X X/X X 48.5

d Ford Flex SEL $42,155 71 C X Opt. 73 18 8.5 141 48.0 C X/X 4/Z C 47.5
Ford Expedition EL Limited $63,080 67 Z Z NA 61 14 7.2 136 45.0 V X/C X/X X 71.0
Toyota Sequoia Limited (5.7) $54,005 66 Z X NA 60 15 7.1 146 47.0 C 2/X 4/Z X 61.0
Nissan Armada Platinum $55,400 57 C* B* NA 59 13 7.2 142 48.0 V C/X 4/Z X 58.5
Chevrolet Suburban LTZ $69,790 54 B Z Opt. 74 16 7.9 139 47.0 V 4/Z X/X Z 62.5
Chevrolet Tahoe LT $60,100 52 B X Opt. 67 16 7.7 136 45.0 V C/Z X/X Z 47.5
GMC Yukon SLT $62,125 52 B X Opt. 67 16 7.7 136 45.0 V C/Z X/X Z 47.5
GMC Yukon XL SLT $67,370 50 B Z Opt. 67 16 7.9 139 45.0 V C/Z X/X Z 62.5

SUVs: LUXURY ENTRY-LEVEL


d Audi Q3 Premium Plus $40,125 80 Z X NA 77 22 8.4 132 51.5 X X/X X/X C 24.5
Buick Encore Leather $30,555 73 Z C Opt. 69 23 11.0 127 55.0 C X/X X/C X 26.0
Mini Cooper Countryman S $32,500 67 C C NA 68 26 8.3 135 54.5 Z C/C X/C V 19.5
Mercedes-Benz GLA250 $42,210 61 V* C Z 70 26 6.9 128 54.5 X C/C X/2 V 23.0

SUVs: LUXURY COMPACT


d Lexus NX 200t $43,284 77 Z X Opt. 74 24 7.5 132 49.5 X C/X X/X C 28.5

d BMW X3 xDrive28i (2.0T) $44,595 76 C X Opt. 82 23 7.3 130 53.0 X C/X X/X C 33.0

d Audi Q5 Premium Plus (2.0T) $43,675 75 X X Opt. 78 21 7.9 130 52.0 X C/X X/X C 32.0

d Lexus NX 300h $51,224 75 Z X Opt. 71 29 8.9 136 49.5 X C/C X/X C 28.5

d Acura RDX $38,990 72 X C Opt. 75 22 6.6 132 51.0 C C/X Z/4 C 31.5
Porsche Macan S $63,290 70 V Z Opt. 85 19 6.4 130 51.0 Z C/Z Z/4 C 29.0
Volvo XC60 T6 $42,245 67 C C C 71 17 7.4 132 52.5 X C/X X/C C 32.5
Lincoln MKC Reserve $46,485 55 B X Opt. 72 19 7.8 125 54.0 C C/X X/C C 30.5
Land Rover Discovery
Sport HSE $49,895 47 B* X* Opt. 58 21 8.6 136 50.5 C 2/C 4/Z C 33.0

| APRIL 2016 | WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org 77


LUXURY MIDSIZED/LARGE SUVs, and PICKUP TRUCKS
5 4 3 2 1
d Recommended ! Caution (subpar crash-test results) Better Worse
SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD-TEST RESULTS
RESULTS

Acceleration
Recommended

Predicted
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road-Test Score

Overall MPG
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Front/Rear
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort

Controls

Cargo Volume, Cu. Ft.


OVERALL
SCORE

SUVs: LUXURY MIDSIZED/LARGE


d Lexus RX 450h $57,565 81 Z Z Opt. 80 29 7.5 138 50.0 C Z/4 Z/4 C 30.0

d Lexus RX 350 $51,630 78 Z Z Opt. 77 22 7.5 139 49.0 C Z/Z Z/4 C 30.0

d Acura MDX Tech $51,410 76 X Z Opt. 79 21 6.8 135 52.0 C X/X X/X V 34.0

d Buick Enclave CXL $43,260 76 X X Opt. 77 15 7.9 142 50.0 X X/X X/X X 44.0

d Porsche Cayenne (V6) $63,805 75 X Z Opt. 78 19 7.8 134 50.0 X X/X 4/Z B 33.0
Mercedes-Benz GLE350
d (ML) $56,960 75 C X Z 75 18 6.8 138 48.0 X 4/Z Z/4 C 37.5

d Toyota Land Cruiser** $84,820 75 Z* Z* Z 68 14 7.3 140 46.0 C X/X Z/4 X 43.0

d Lexus GX 460 $58,428 74 Z X Opt. 70 17 7.5 136 48.0 C C/X Z/4 X 36.5
BMW X5 xDrive35i $70,050 73 V Z Opt. 84 21 7.4 137 52.0 X 4/Z Z/4 V 34.5
Volvo XC90 T6 Momentum $56,805 71 V* X* Z 84 20 7.7 126 52.5 C C/X Z/Z V 35.0
Lincoln Navigator Base $68,895 69 C* X* NA 72 15 7.0 136 48.5 V X/C X/X X 61.5
Mercedes-Benz GL350
BlueTec $73,020 61 B X C 82 20 8.2 136 44.5 C Z/Z Z/Z C 47.0
Infiniti QX70** $51,635 61 V* C* Opt. 72 18 6.8 133 51.0 X C/X Z/4 X 25.5
Land Rover Range Rover
(base, 3.0L) $88,545 60 B* Z* Opt. 80 17 6.7 137 48.5 C Z/Z Z/Z C 34.5
Jeep Grand Cherokee
Limited (diesel) $49,780 60 B X Opt. 82 24 8.6 132 50.5 C X/X Z/4 X 36.5
Infiniti QX80 $63,395 58 V* X Opt. 68 15 6.9 139 48.0 V X/X X/X X 49.5
Infiniti QX60 (3.5L) $51,920 58 B V Opt. 79 19 8.3 137 47.0 C 4/Z Z/C Z 39.0
Jeep Grand Cherokee
Limited (V6) $41,375 58 B X Opt. 78 18 8.0 134 50.0 C X/X Z/4 X 36.5
Land Rover Range Rover
Sport HSE (3.0L) $74,040 57 B* Z Opt. 74 18 6.5 137 49.5 X C/X X/X V 31.5
Cadillac Escalade Premium $87,360 44 B Z Opt. 61 16 6.1 142 45.0 V C/Z Z/4 B 48.0

SURVEY
MAKE & MODEL PRICE SAFETY ROAD TEST RESULTS
RESULTS
Acceleration
Recommended

Predicted
Reliability

Owner
Satisfaction

Front Crash

Road Test Score

Overall MPG
Prevention

0-60 MPH, Sec.

60-0 MPH, Ft.

Avoidance Maneuver
Speed, MPH

Routine Handling

Ride/Noise

Driving
Position
Dry Braking

Seat Comfort
Front/Rear

Controls
OVERALL
SCORE

PICKUP TRUCKS
Ford F-150 XLT
d (3.5 V6 EcoBoost) $46,755 77 X Z Opt. 80 16 7.2 139 46.5 V 2/Z X 4/Z X
Ford F-150 XLT
d (2.7 V6 EcoBoost) $45,750 76 X Z Opt. 78 17 7.0 137 46.0 V 2/Z X 4/Z X
Toyota Tundra SR5 (5.7L V8) $38,715 69 Z X NA 63 15 6.7 153 44.5 C 2/X C X/C X
Ram 1500 Big Horn
(V6, diesel) $49,155 63 V X NA 82 20 9.5 143 47.0 V X/X C 4/Z X
Ram 1500 Big Horn (5.7L V8) $42,810 63 V X NA 81 15 7.1 141 47.0 V 4/Z C 4/Z X
Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LT
(5.3L V8) $42,070 61 B X Opt. 80 16 7.5 138 45.5 C 2/Z C C/Z X
GMC Sierra 1500 SLT
(5.3L V8) $43,200 61 B X Opt. 80 16 7.5 138 45.5 C 2/Z C C/Z X
Chevrolet Colorado LT (V6) $34,300 51 B X Opt. 69 18 7.5 132 48.5 C 2/C C 2/C Z
GMC Canyon SLE (V6) $35,835 51 B X Opt. 69 18 7.5 132 48.5 C 2/C C 2/C Z

78 WATCH, COMMENT, SHARE & MORE at ConsumerReports.org | APRIL 2016 | *Based on limited data. **Powertrain has changed since last test.
Copyright of Consumer Reports is the property of Consumers Union and its content may not
be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.