ICT for ELT (TE30603)!

Rubric for Article Review (10%)!

!
20-17 13-16 9-12 5-8 1-4 0

1) Summarizes the Provides a very Provides a clear and Provides a clear but Provides a incomplete Provides an unclear
context and content thorough and clear and concise summary of the shallow summary of the summary. Only certain Provides a somewhat and unintelligible
of the selected article concise summary of the article context and article; may be parts of the article are muddled, unclear and summary of the article!
article content. excessively brief or may covered. rambling summary of the OR!
include some article. No summary at all.
extraneous information.

2) Identifies and Thoroughly describes Describes your Describes your Describe very minimally Attempts to describe Provides an unclear,
describes your your personal reaction personal reaction to the personal reaction to the your personal reaction your personal reaction unintelligible and
personal reaction to to the article; includes article; includes a article; includes no to the article; no to the article, but lacks illogical description of
the article discussion of the simplistic discussion of discussion of the discussion of the a logical flow and personal reaction!
relevant issues within the relevant issues relevant issues within relevant issues within reaction is muddled; no OR!
the article. within the article. the article. the article. discussion of any No description of
relevant issues in the personal reaction at all.
article.

3) Grammar, Contains all correct Contains all correct info Contains mostly correct Contain largely Contains incorrect info Response is totally
mechanics, and APA information regarding regarding article title, info regarding article incorrect infer regarding regarding article title, unintelligible OR!
style for references article title, author author name, and title, author name, and the article title, author author name, and No response
and citations name, and article article source and date.! article source and date.! name, article source article source and date.!
source and date. Contains accurate and Contains frequent and date. Contains Grammatical errors
Consistently contains proper grammatical errors in grammatical numerous errors in substantially interferes
accurate and proper conventions, spelling, conventions, spelling, grammatical with understanding the
grammatical and punctuation most and punctuation; errors conventions, spelling, papers meaning.
conventions, spelling, of the time; errors do begin to interfere with and punctuation; Consistently fails to use
and punctuation. not interfere with papers meaning. substantially interferes APA for references/
Clearly and consistently papers meaning. Inconsistently uses APA with papers meaning. citation
uses proper APA Consistently uses APA formatting for citations/ Consistently fails to use
formatting for for citations/ references references APA for references/
references. citation