Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Artculo 1
On the Use of Energy Storage Technologies for Regulation Services in Electric Power
Systems with Significant Penetration of Wind Energy
The maximum cap is 600 MW, which may be exceeded in case of multiple observed
violations of the control performance standard. The average price of 1 MW up and down
regulation capacity is $18/MW (2006). BPA uses about 175 MW of regulation capacity, and
its ancillary service rates are energy based (hourly scheduling, system control and dispatch -
0.59 mills/kWh, regulation and frequency response - 0.33 mills/kWh, and spinning operating
reserves - 7.93 mills/kWh) [5]. As a result, the annual cost of regulation in these two control
areas significantly exceeds 100 million dollars. Studies show that, with the expected
increasing penetration of wind power resources, the year 2010 regulation needs will
noticeably increase in the BPA and CAISO service areas [1-3]. Correspondingly, more
regulation capacity will be needed in these systems.
This paper reports some partial results of a project work, recently conducted by the Pacific
Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) for BPA [5]. The project proposes to mitigate
additional intermittency caused by wind generators with the help of Wide Area Energy
Management System (WAEMS) that would provide a two-way simultaneous regulation
service for the BPA and CAISO systems with the help of a large energy storage facility. The
proposed WAEMS will minimize the regulation capacity requirements in these two
neighboring areas by exchanging intermittent energy between the participating control areas
and the use of energy storage resources.
This effect is achieved through so called ACE2 sharing approach. Our estimate shows that ACE
sharing could save up to 30% of the required regulation capacity in these systems.
Additionally, because the energy storage is a fast responsive resource, it could help to save an
additional 40% of regulation requirement in California by competing with slow responsive
thermal units in the regulation market [6, 7].
The suggested WAEMS design consists of two resources: flywheel energy storage and pumped
storage (or conventional hydroelectric power) see Figure 1.
Vertical configuration, i.e. integration through the BPA and CAISO EMS systems is suggested.
BPAs and CAISO conventional regulation unit signals will be used to control the Wide Area
EMS. Dynamic schedules3 will be used to incorporate the new regulation resource into the
AGC4 systems. Control algorithms have been be designed to mimic behavior of a conventional
unit of regulation and to coordinate the control functions of participating resources. Total MW
output of fly- wheel and hydro unit should equal total MW request from both control areas.
Flywheel provides regulation down (or regulation up) service. Hydro unit provides regulation
up (or regulation down) service. Hydro unit is used to maintain the lowest (or the highest)
possible state of charge on the flywheel.
The hydro power plant output will be kept as close as practical to the most efficient operating
point. Dynamic schedules are used to distribute the flywheels and hydros outputs among
the control areas. The paper evaluates several utility-scale energy storage technology options
against acceptance criteria developed for the WAEMS project. These options are flywheels;
superconductive magnetic energy storage (SMES); pumped hydrostorage; compressed air
energy storage (CAES); super capacitors, several electrochemical battery types, and demand-
side control.
Artculo 2
Having that in mind, the main objective of this paper is to find different potential future
evolutions of the electricity generation mix in Spain, according to the four storylines
considered in the SUSPLAN project. Those futures should meet the requirements imposed by
the integration of high levels of RES generation and at the same time must be compatible with
achieving a safe operation of the system. Storyline analysis will be performed in two steps.
First, the required development of RES and conventional generation shall be computed using
a long term generation expansion model. Then, a detailed analysis of the operation of the
power system in 2020 and 2050 is carried out considering the evolution of RES and
conventional generation that has been previously computed. The medium term operation
model allows the analysis of power reserves needs, thermal and hydro generation output,
among other resources in the system. The operational analysis is essential in order to test that
the capacity resultant from the expansion model can be safely integrated to the system.
Finally, this paper is divided into three sections besides this introduction. Section II contains
the description of the four storylines, as well as the parameter/hypotheses assumed when
defining each one of them. It also describes the methodology applied to carry out the research.
Section III includes the results obtained from the analysis. Finally, Section IV presents the
conclusions.
Artculo 3
Most low-carbon electricity resources cannot flexibly adjust their output to match fluctuating
power demands. For instance, nuclear power plants best operate continuously and their
output cannot be ramped up and down quickly. Wind power and solar
energy are intermittent and their operators sometimes have no control over the schedule of
electricity output. Utility-scale electricity storage to maintain balance and prevent blackouts
remains a significant barrier to a de-carbonized power system.
There are only two large-scale (>100 MW) technologies available commercially for grid-tied
electricity storage, pumped hydro energy storage (PHES) and compressed air energy storage
(CAES). Of the two, PHES is far more widely adopted. In the United States, there are 40 PHES
stations with a total capacity of _20 GW.
Worldwide, there are hundreds of PHES stations operating with total capacity of 127 GW [1].
Only two CAES facilities, one 110MW facility in the United States and another 290MW facility
in Germany, are currently operating globally. Unlike CAES, PHES does not require burning
fossil fuels and is also generally cheaper than CAES for energy storage [2].
A PHES facility is typically equipped with reversible pumps/ generators connecting an upper
and a lower reservoir. The pumps utilize relatively cheap electricity from the grid during off-
peak hours to move water from the lower reservoir to the upper one to store energy. During
periods of high electricity demand (peak hours), water is released from the upper reservoir to
generate power at higher price.
In recent years, there has been increasing commercial interest in PHES [3]. Developers are
actively pursuing new PHES projects around the world. An additional 76 GW PHES capacity
worldwide is expected by 2014 [1]. In the United States, the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission (FERC) has granted 32 preliminary permits (as of April 5, 2010) to 25 licensees
who are interested in developing new PHES facilities [4]. The total capacity of these proposed
PHES facilities is 28.6 GW, more than the existing PHES capacity in the United States.
Nevertheless, based on historical and economic considerations, a number of these proposed
projects are unlikely to be built. A brief review of the history of PHES development in the
United States reveals the many challenges and barriers that exist today.
Artculo 4
Such a linearized model is inadequate for large variations in power output (4725% rated
load) and frequency study (478% rated value) [1]. As the hydraulic turbine exhibits highly
nonlinear characteristics that vary significantly with the unpredictable load on the unit, this
requires controller gain scheduling at different gate positions and speed error. In practice
they are designed on a linearized turbine model at rated condition, the controller is then de-
tuned for worst operating conditions. Such a design approach does not perform optimally.
Nonlinear models are required when speed and power changes are large during an islanding,
load rejection and system restoration conditions.
A nonlinear model should include the effect of water compressibility i.e. inclusion of
transmission-line-like reflections which occur in the elastic-walled pipe carrying
compressible fluid. [2]. This modeling is more important in a system with long penstock.
An interesting area for control theory and application is in the study of a penstock-turbine
model with elastic water column effect. To gain economic merits, determination of transfer
function limits and operating limits has gained an importance in recent years, specially, in
case of common penstock model. A hydraulic coupling gets introduced between the units of
the plant [3,4].
This gives an opportunity to investigate models of the hydro plant and turbine control
existing in different plant layout/configurations.
Artculo 5
The dynamic characteristics of hydraulic turbine and its governor system affect Power
system performance, during and following any disturbance, such as occurrence of a
fault, rapid change of load. An accurate modeling of power system components, such
as turbine and its governing system helps to study dynamic response. The non linear
turbine model is more suitable for studies concerning large variation in power output
and frequency. The several research articles [1-7] have presented the model
structures for different types of governors and the hydraulic effects in the penstock.
The hydraulic dynamics in the penstock are also discussed in an IEEE working group
[8] and Kundur [9]. The overall block diagram of the Hydraulic Turbine with governor
[13, 15], servomotor and synchronous machine is shown in Fig. 1.
This paper deals with a hydraulic model suitable for dynamic studies of hydro power plants.
Figure 1 shows the basic structure of a hydro turbine model.
In this context, we will treat more precisely the modeling of the prune mover, including the
water supply conduit.
In the first section, we present the model of a single turbine and its water supply conduit. The
general nonlinear model is given and a parameter estimation is proposed. Typical results are
given (they result from field tests, conducted at the Coo pumped storage plait, Belgium).
The second section is devoted to the modeling of a power plant consisting of several turbines,
supplied by a common tunnel. The model presented is able to simulate large transients such
as load rejections and their effect on the remaining groups, due to the hydraulic coupling
through the common conduit.
Comparisons between simulation and experimental results are presented.
Artculo 7
Due to the deregulated energy market, hydroelectric power plants are increasingly subjecting
to off design operation, start-up and shutdown and new control strategies.
Consequently, the operation of Francis turbine power plants leads to transients phenomena,
risk of resonance or instabilities. The understanding of these propagation phenomena is
therefore paramount. This work is a contribution to the hydro acoustic modelling of Francis
turbine power plants for the investigation of the aforementioned problematic.
The first part of the document presents the modelling of the dynamic behavior and the
transient analysis of hydroelectric power plants. Therefore, the one-dimensional model of an
elementary pipe is derived from the governing equations, i.e. momentum and continuity
equations. The use of appropriate numerical schemes leads to a discrete model of the pipe
consisting of a T-shaped equivalent electrical circuit. The accuracy in the frequency domain of
the discrete model of the pipe is determined by comparison with the analytical solution of the
governing equations.
The modelling approach is extended to hydraulic components such as valve, surge tanks,
surge shaft, air vessels, cavitation development, etc. Then, the modelling of the Francis, Pelton
and Kaplan turbines for transient analysis purposes is presented. This modelling is based on
the use of the static characteristic of the turbines. The hydraulic components models are
implemented in the EPFL software SIMSEN developed for the simulation of electrical
installations. After validation of the hydraulic models, transient phenomena in hydroelectric
power plants are investigated. It appears that standard separate studies of either the
hydraulic or of the electrical part are valid only for design purposes, while full hydroelectric
models are necessary for the optimization of turbine speed governors.
The second part of the document deals with the modelling and analysis of possible resonance
or operating instabilities in Francis turbine power plants. The review of the excitation sources
inherent to Francis turbine operations indicates that the draft tube and the rotor-stator
interaction pressure fluctuations are of the major concern. As the modelling of part load
pressure fluctuations induced by the cavitating vortex rope that develops in the draft tube at
low frequencies is well established, the focus is put on higher frequency phenomena such as
higher part load pressure fluctuations and rotor-stator interactions or full load instabilities.
(iii) The rotor-stator interactions (RSI) are studied in the case of a reduced scale pumpturbine
model. An original modelling approach of this phenomenon based on the flow distribution
between the stationnary and the rotating part is presented. The model provides the RSI
pressure fluctuation patterns in the vaneless gap and enables to predict standing waves in the
spiral case and adduction pipe.
The proposed one-dimensional modelling approach enables the simulation, analysis and
optimization of the dynamic behavior of hydroelectric power plants. The approach has proven
its capability of simulating properly both transient and periodic phenomena. Such
investigations can be undertaken at early stages of a project to assess the possible dynamic
problems and to select appropriate solutions ensuring the safest and optimal operation of the
facility.
Artculo 8
Recently, with the necessary of reliable operation of power system, the power plant
and its apparatus simulation technology has received attention in [3]-[9].
In this paper, a dynamic real-time simulator for hydraulic turbine generating unit
based on programmable computer controller (PCC) was proposed, which developed
in Research Center of Micrwomputer Control of Hohai University, China. Generally,
the hydraulic turbine generating unit has many different operating conditions such as
start-up procedure, no-load, supplying for isolated load, parallel operation, load
disturbance or load rejection, shut-down procedure, and so on. It is impossible to do
all the tests under various operating conditions in the field.
With the dynamic real-time simulator, the transients of the operating conditions
mentioned above of the hydraulic turbine regulating system could be calculated and
simulated.
Furthermore, the performance of the hydraulic turbine governor could be test and
fine-tuned whether developed in the laboratory or installed in the field. The normal
operation of the hydro power plant would not be interrupted and there would be no
risk of damage to the hydraulic turbine generating unit. The dynamic real-time
simulator also can be operated as a training system for new workers of the hydro
power plant. Some simulations and field tests have been conduct with a prototype
hydraulic turbine governor, and the results indicate that the dynamic real-time
simulator has a good performance.
Artculo 9
lawn sprinkler
Catastrophic transients
Artculo 12
The torque of a hydro electrical power plant constantly changes according to the
network
needs, generating variations of the turbines rotating speed. A regulation system acts
on the
guide vanes to keep the rotating speed constant. This manoeuvre engenders pressure
fluctuations in the hydraulic system. This scenario shows interest to model the whole
installation with the electric network, hydraulic plant and control systems to study the
stability of the power plant.
A software called SIMSEN [1] has been developed for the simulation of power
networks in transient or steady-state modes and speed drive systems including the
regulation systems.
This software includes the models of pipe, valve, surge tank and Francis turbine based
on
electric analogies. The behaviour of the whole power plant is described by a set of
differential equations that are simultaneously integrated taking into account all the
interactions between the electric, hydraulic and regulation systems.
PRESENTATION OF SIMSEN
This software is based on a modular structure, which enables the numerical
simulation in transient or steady-state modes of systems with arbitrary topologies. It
is composed of units, each representing a specific cell in the network: electrical
machine, mechanical system taking into account mechanical masses connected with
damping and springs, transformer, voltage supply, transmission line, load, static
converter, regulator. The originality of this package lies within its ability to simulate
classical three phase power networks for the generation, transmission, distribution
and networks involving semi-conductor units as well.
Each unit includes a set of differential equations based on the network element
modelling. An original algorithm has been developed in order to generate the main set
of differential equations solved by fourth order Runge-Kutta. The variable time-step
used for the integration of the governing equations allows detecting the exact
sequence of events like the on-off switching of semi-conductor or circuit-breakers
phase on-off switching.
The hydraulic elements are modelled as an assembly of RLC components and the
whole installation is modelled like an electrical network where the variables are: (1)
the piezometric head H at the node and (2) the discharge Q trough each components
respectively corresponding to voltage U and current i. Thus, the differential equations
can be generated by SIMSEN using Kirchhoffs law. The main differential set of
equations contains electric, hydraulic and regulation equations that are solved
simultaneously. An example of hydroelectric power plant, which will be created with
SIMSEN is shown in figure 1.
Artculo 15
The following three hydro plant models with different characteristics and limitations,
are discussed in this presentation: