Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Adam Bannister
Editor, IFSEC Global
CONTENTS
P9. Upgrading
Reasons to upgrade
HD analogue
Procurement
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 02
Excellence in Surveillance
INTRODUCTION
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 03
Excellence in Surveillance
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 04
Excellence in Surveillance
Other recent research revealed that surveillance systems themselves One respondent said that
are highly vulnerable to network breaches. Conducted by cloud-based their system had to operate
surveillance company Cloudview the study found that both traditional
DVR-based systems and cloud-based systems were vulnerable to the
in an environment with
cyber threat. Security flaws could allow hackers to hijack connections to no internet or even mains
the devices IP address, warned the researchers, putting people, property power
and data at risk and potentially leaving operators in breach of data
protection laws.
In the wake of recent terror attacks in Paris, Istanbul and Brussels the
threat from terrorists was perceived to pose an appreciable risk to about
a third (32%) of businesses and organisations, with the proportion in
transport and utilities naturally being rather higher at 52%.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 05
Excellence in Surveillance
We offer IDIS Mobile as a free app for iOS and android devices, which [We need] analytics
is compatible with all IDIS NVRs and IP cameras, says Brian Song,
managing director of IDIS Europe. The app supports both H.264 and
combined with motion-
H.265, so users are assured of full-HD and even 4K image quality. The detection sensors that
app packs an array of powerful features including PTZ control, calendar detect intruders combined
search, playback, bookmarking and two-way audio. Users can also with lighting and audio
receive real-time event information to mobile devices of their choice warnings that deter
via social media (Twitter), push notifications and email, to ensure they
intruders will be prominent
stay remotely informed of any incident with one simple click. Further,
our customers using IDIS Fisheye cameras are also taking advantage of in my CCTV requirements.
super smooth de-warping from their mobile devices. UK-based head of
security in the wholesale/
Arguably the most interesting result is the gulf between full-HD distribution sector
resolution in second place with 62% and the even higher, 4K
resolution, ranking bottom with only 12% of responses. Also known as
Ultra-HD, 4K surveillance cameras boast four times the resolution of full-
HD cameras and most manufacturers only really started launching a full
4K line-up in 2014. For most environments at least, full-HD models would
appear to do the job just fine. For the 77% who need to capture fine
details, usable images at long distances or both, 4K rose only marginally
to 14%.
Remote access
Full-HD resolution
Night-time lighting
Incident management/video analytics
Large storage capacity/ease of storage
Vandal-resistant/robust
Optical zoom
Plug-and-play installation
Smart PTZ controls
360 view
Central/cloud storage
Latency
4K resolution
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 06
Excellence in Surveillance
The improvements in resolutions since a 2007 Home Office report The industry needs
revealed that 80% of cameras produced images unsuitable for use in a software that can quarry a
court of law have clearly been invaluable. Beyond Ultra-HD, however, our
survey suggests that only a few unusual or high-security environments
CCTV database. We
are likely to upgrade Ultra-HD systems for resolution gains they might need to formulate granular
see as making little material difference to operational performance. quarries.
UK-based security
If high-resolution images are generally seen as very important (up to a professional in the IT/
point) then this is less the case with the frame-to-frame fluidity of those
digital sector
images, with low latency scoring only 17%.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 07
Excellence in Surveillance
Video analytics tools: ranked according to security needs Surveillance systems are
Average ranking out of 5 increasingly integrated with
Heat maps 2.8
other technologies and
Crowd density 2.91
not just security systems
People counting 3.26
Automatic Number Plate Recognition 3.74
People Tracking 4.04
Facial Recognition 4.24
Heat mapping was the most sought-after video analytics tool by those
who completed the survey, scoring an aggregate 2.8 out of 5 after
respondents ranked five options in order of importance. Particularly
applicable to retail although curiously, respondents in this sector
actually ranked heat mapping marginally lower on average than their
counterparts in other industries (2.89 versus 2.79) heat-mapping
software allows operators to quickly identify high-footfall areas, quiet
areas and bottlenecks in stores.
The second most popular feature, crowd density, was more popular
in retail (2.47 versus 2.92), as was people counting (3.11 versus 3.27).
Innovators in these fields include Agent Vi, Prism Skylabs and
Milestone Systems.
Its rather more in line with expectations that Physical Security Incident
Management (PSIM) and Video Management systems (VMS) both
integral to modern video surveillance monitoring should also rank highly.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 08
Excellence in Surveillance
UPGRADING
Reasons to upgrade
Asked to choose from a list of five scenarios, surveillance operators,
facilities managers and other respondents said a change in security
needs/priorities was most likely to prompt an upgrade of their video
surveillance system. Potentially involving a change of premises, an
increase in sensitive materials stored on site or a heightened terror
threat, this option garnered more than one in four (27%) responses.
The next most common choice with 22% was a desire to switch from
analogue to IP. The previous IDIS-sponsored report we published in
2015 revealed that 58% of organisations still had at least some analogue
cameras operational.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 09
Excellence in Surveillance
UPGRADING
Our latest survey suggests that security departments are both blessed
and cursed by a degree of autonomy/isolation from the rest of their
business. One respondent commented that upgrade decisions taken at
boardroom level are a rarity unless an incident has happened within
the organisation that required the CEO to get involved with the change.
Indeed, only 4% said that decisions made at boardroom level are most
likely trigger an upgrade, suggesting that heads of security are largely
masters of their own fiefdom. But the same, low percentage chose The rise of video-analytics
growing revenues as the most likely upgrade trigger, perhaps supporting software, which gives
the axiom that security is a grudge purchase. Businesses prefer to insights into footfall,
reinvest profits in departments say, sales or marketing that contribute bottlenecks and shopper
meaningfully to revenue generation (and its impossible to put a value on
behaviour, suggests
hypothetical losses prevented by security measures).
grudge purchase may
But such perceptions could change. Because the rise of video-analytics no longer be a fair
software (see page 8), which can give businesses insights into footfall, characterisation of modern
bottlenecks and shopper behaviour, suggests grudge purchase may no security systems
longer be a fair characterisation of modern security systems.
HD analogue
A slim majority (56%) of those who did not already have an HD analogue
solution said they would consider upgrading to one if it were cost-
effective, simple or leveraged existing coaxial cables. The other 44%
insisted that IP is the only way forward.
One installer of analogue upgrades told us: There is more than one way
to do this, but I would not advise a client to go in this direction. I can
show them a much better fit to allow IT to take care of the IT things and
security to manage all the rest.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 10
Excellence in Surveillance
UPGRADING
Technologies like
HDCVI, HDTVI and AHD
create complexity with
less support than other
technologies and [an]
absence of one standard
platform like ONVIF. We
feel that IP will soon replace
all these and be more cost-
effective. On actual site
locations, analogue is easy,
but still it will [become]
obsolete. India-based
security professional
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 11
Excellence in Surveillance
UPGRADING
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 12
Excellence in Surveillance
PLUG-AND-PLAY SYSTEMS
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 13
Excellence in Surveillance
PLUG-AND-PLAY SYSTEMS
In our previous video surveillance report (also sponsored by IDIS), Recent encounters with
published in 2015, the most common misgiving about comprehensive plug-and-play equipment
solutions was a preference for procuring the best-in-class component
in each field (62%), followed by a concern over being beholden to one
have shown that the field
supplier (29%), the cost of buying everything at once (27%) and a belief still needs to make some
that separate components work out cheaper in total (27%). advances. Currently, the
biggest issue I have with
Brian Song, managing director of IDIS Europe, believes such perceptions plug and play is that it
are fair only insofar as some plug-and-play systems are better than
seems to be almost bolted
others. Not all plug-and-play systems are equal, he says. True plug-
and-play should mean zero configuration, which is embedded into an on after the fact, and as a
entire surveillance solution that includes auto-IP, multicast DNS and a result not always great in
DNS discovery service, which in turn means plug-and-play across multi- practical applications.
site implementations. The result is less of a training burden on installers UK-based security
and a more cost-effective solution for end users in terms of ease of professional in the IT/
operation and maintenance, delivering a low total cost of ownership.
digital sector
End-to-end solutions also simplify the buying chain, so an installer
or end user is not having to buy components, software, cameras and
accessories from multiple vendors. And complete solutions, particularly
hardware and software, are designed and manufactured under one roof,
which means fewer issues with both installation and maintenance, since
technical support is provided by a single vendor.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 14
Excellence in Surveillance
PLUG-AND-PLAY SYSTEMS
Except this isnt actually true, according to IDIS, which markets a modular
system the benefit being that you buy only what you need, when you
need it, rather than an entire system, as budget permits: IDIS NVRs
also support ONVIF, so if a customer wants a staged migration path to
full-HD or even 4K across their sites, that is also something we can offer
and we have many customers doing that right now, says Brian Song,
the companys MD. IDIS is also committed to future-proofing security
investments. Built on core patented technologies, IDIS offerings all use
the same user-friendly interface, ensuring a unified user experience across
all technology platforms. What that means is that a customer could start
with a DirectIP installation at one or two of their sites or even implement
our HD-TVI range to leverage existing coax. Then in five years time, when
their business expands and they need to upgrade to, say, a server-based
system, all their existing kit is still compatible.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 15
Excellence in Surveillance
PLUG-AND-PLAY SYSTEMS
Cost is clearly a huge deterrent for many of the 59% who either dont 75% of respondents said
want a plug-and-play system or expressed only lukewarm interest. they would be more likely
Three-quarters (75%) of respondents said they would be more likely
to upgrade to an end-to-end system if it were modular, with 41% being
to upgrade to an end-
much more likely to switch. to-end system if it were
modular, with 41% being
For the other 25% of those polled, for whom a modular option would much more likely to switch
make little or no difference, investment level is perhaps not a decisive
factor at least in terms of initial outlay; they may believe, rightly or
wrongly, that modular systems are more expensive per module but
the next question sheds some light on the other reasons.
Plug-and-play perceptions
Despite the aforementioned misgivings, the responses to the next
question suggest that security professionals broadly hold a fairly positive
view of plug-and-play systems. Respondents were asked to agree or
disagree with a series of negative statements about plug-and-play
solutions and two-thirds disagreed even with the statement with which
there was the broadest agreement.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 16
Excellence in Surveillance
PLUG-AND-PLAY SYSTEMS
those polled agreed that plug-and-play security solutions are risky what
if Im locked into a model that doesnt support ongoing development? I
would have to replace the entire system at great expense.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 17
Excellence in Surveillance
PLUG-AND-PLAY SYSTEMS
IDIS says true plug-and-play what we mean is auto-IP, multicast DNS The security industry
and a DNS discovery service, which is actually perfect for multi-site lacks truly competent
implementations. The simplicity and speed of installation is good for
installers and it reduces the install costs for end users compared with
professionals with a
high levels of integration required when purchasing a separate VMS, a technical background to
variety of cameras, etc. drive manufacturers to
provide solution-based
At IFSEC 2016 we will also be launching a number of new technologies systems. The security
and features that are particularly relevant to the enterprise space,
industry lags behind the
including a 64-channel NVR with a hot-swap, SD card smart fail-over
that provides redundancy in the event of network disruption, as well as IT industry because it is
new multi-casting technology. mainly driven by service
providers with limited
Simple installation, which is a widely recognised benefit of plug and play, technical capabilities
is only possible with entry-level systems, according to 26% of security looking for financial gain
professionals. One head of security in the retail sector admitted that
they dont like plug and play as customers will try to install systems
rather than fulfilling end-
themselves, make mistakes and then blame it on the product or shop user needs. Mauritius-
that sold it to them. based security professional
in the financial sector
But Brian Song, MD of IDIS Europe, says that we never sell directly
to an end user. We work with a mixture of systems integrators and
distributors. All our integration partners (meaning anyone installing
IDIS technology) complete comprehensive training that is tailored to the
product range they are installing.
Retail is one of our core markets with Albert Heijn (worlds third
biggest supermarket chain) rolling out DirectIP across hundreds of their
stores in Benelux. Another example is Sedar (the biggest luxury fabrics
company in the Middle East), which implemented DirectIP across all their
showrooms and other facilities in the Middle East, while DirectIP is also
protecting all shops for DAMAS, (the biggest jewellery retail chain in the
Middle East).
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 18
Excellence in Surveillance
PLUG-AND-PLAY SYSTEMS
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 19
Excellence in Surveillance
CONCLUSION
Remote access is widely valued; 4K has niche appeal. Nearly two thirds
chose remote access more than any other option as one of their
five favoured camera functions (from 13) and this feature was popular
across all sectors and business sizes, as was video analytics software.
4K resolution, on the other hand, ranked lowest among the camera
features offered. Improving rapidly in recent years, image resolution
has perhaps reached a point where Ultra-HD (ranked second) is good
enough for all but the most challenging or unusual environments. Cloud
storage, meanwhile, is far from indispensable in the eyes of most security
professionals, while heat mapping is the most popular analytics feature.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 20
Excellence in Surveillance
CONCLUSION
Analogue surveillance is far from doomed. Our 2015 surveillance survey 56% of those without a HD
revealed that 58% of organisations still had at least some analogue analogue solution would
cameras operational. And though one respondent to the 2016 survey
predicted analogue would eventually become obsolete, 56% of those
still consider upgrading to
without a HD analogue solution would still consider upgrading to one if one if it were cost-effective,
it were cost-effective, simple or leveraged existing coaxial cables. simple or leveraged existing
coaxial cables
Perceptions of plug-and-play solutions are broadly positive, despite
a sizeable minority having several misgivings which are mitigated
somewhat by modular systems. Almost one in four (24%) of those
without a plug-and-play system are planning to switch to one and three in
four (75%) said they would be more likely to upgrade to a plug-and-play
solution if it were modular. Nevertheless, there are significant reservations
around integration, future-proofing, the standard of available systems,
suitability to complex installations and being beholden to a single provider
for between one in four and one in three respondents.
IDIS will showcase its flagship solution platform Direct IP, offering a
complete range of cameras, monitors, NVRs and accessories able to
leverage a revolutionary non-server, NVR-based approach to bring
unparalleled simplicity, high performance and affordability together as
never before.
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 21
Excellence in Surveillance
The Video Surveillance Report 2016: Global Security Needs and Plug-and-Play Perceptions WWW.IFSECGLOBAL.COM 22
Learn more about security and how to protect
your business at IFSEC International this June
at ExCeL London, 21-23 June 2016.
The 5 top reasons why you should be there this June:
3 Learn from experienced security professionals and develop your knowledge by attending free seminars
3 Grow your network through connecting with over 27,000 of other leading security professionals
3 Save time and pre-book meetings with your preferred suppliers using the Meetings Service
3 Learn how you can generate revenue from a new income stream at the Smart Zone and experience Home
Automation and Intelligent Buildings
3 Protect your business and property by sourcing the best perimeter security solutions from the worlds best suppliers
Register for your badge and secure your place today www.ifsec.co.uk/ifsec_global.